Would love to hear your reaction to Dan Bull's Hellblade song, ruclips.net/video/lyvXuCRJbDI/видео.html because the whispers used in the background are downright eerie. Not to mention the hook is really great. My younger cousins missed the BTS train, they're all about Lord Huron instead for some reason.
One of my favourite of the more well known songs of BTS! The musical production is just too much genius! The whole MV is fire as well!!! Props to everyone involved - BTS, the music producers, choreographers, backup dancers, support staff!!!!
Check out BTS "on" Commentary Film: Dialogue, a little behind the scenes for the music production. They had a choir and a college band record most of the stuff. Video was filmed on top of the LA Dam
Wow it's so fascinating to me how I literally hear many things only after you point them out I think people that do your job can enjoy music in totally different way and that makes me want to learn more, so thank you for these reactions!
I was thinking the same thing! I would NEVER have caught any of the things he points out. Then when he does I have to go back and listen, and it's like - wow, that was there.
I used to go to a music school for some singing lessons when I was younger, and all the teachers in that school are phenomenal. When you see them interacting with each other, talking about music, it's just something else. Most of them know how to play 3 or more instruments (at least at a basic level), and they also know about music theory and production. When they jam together or talk about a song they are composing or arranging they don't even talk sometimes. They just make an imperceptible sound (at least to me) or add something else to the production and the other ones go like "uh, that's right" or "woah okay" or just a small chuckle 😂 They literally communicate through music and it's just so amazing to watch.
@@danas388 that's why an elaborate piece of music or listening to professionals talking about music never stops to amaze me in the best way possible. It's like when you know a language good enough to be able to recognize different accents or to be able to make jokes and play on words in that language.
After every Joey NATO reaction, I reach for my headphones immediately to listen to the things he described. Like, I didn’t even pick up on the choir (though as suggested by some of you, I’ve seen the commentary). Joey’s commentaries always make me appreciate how skilled music producers have to be to elevate a song. Thanks!
I honestly want to like this comment so bad cause you're the first one i see to say that after watching this, but the holy number has reached the like button before i did so 😂
THIS IS THE LEAD SINGLE SKSJSKSJ they will just be dropping another mv for it in a week that's it 👏 EDIT : THE NEW MV IS OUT NOW AND IT'S SO GOOOOOD. PLEASE STREAM IT 💜
@@High_Exotic check bighit's twitter.... The whole album is already out. The lead single is ON and it has two mvs, one of them is the kinetic manifesto film that's already out, and the other one will be out on Feb 28 :))
BTS can, and will, sing this without autotune. They don't need a machine to fix their vocals. If they used it here it's for effect. (They did the same in black swan, and then did it live without it)
Just watched them perform live in Korea and I already knew they would sound great love but omg did they sound amazing! Literally they sounded amazing live while dancing 😍
Yoongi has a natural swag to him. Doesn't even have to try. He just doesn't give a UGH! No matter if he is on camera, on stage or when he deals with annoying reporters asking inappropriate qustions at press conferences... And his cypher verses are one of the reasons he became my bias. Whenever I need a boost of confidence I count on him to lend me some. 😊
Yeah its true Different tones That why this Comeback of BTS is different. I love their voice. The rapline is so savage Especially Jhope Suga rap and Rm rap is so damn gooddd Jk high notes Jimin High Note V OMG deep voice And then Jin voice 😭😭 Actually im dead😭
The reason why the autotune was prominent in most of the tracks in this album "Map of the Soul: 7" is because the overall topic is about overcoming your own "SHADOW" and autotune represents the shadow. Also in Suga's Interlude: Shadow, you can hear the ending was soooo autotune (tho still sounded amazing) is because his shadow was overtaking)
@@ashishsh2859 well lol I've been an ARMY for 2 years now and I've never seen tracks from them esp the recent albums that doesn't have underlying meaning to it. They are intricate in sounds and beats/melodies. Yeah it sound cool on the surface but it's more than that
Brain Stained ive been studying music production and I’ve been an amry for more than 5+ years , and yes I know that BTS love to have hidden meanings in their songs and music videos, especially back in the I need u to fire era when all the fan theories were going crazy. But sometimes some production details are there just to make the song sound better not everything is meant to have a meaning like auto tuned rap is just for the cool effect, hence why they didn’t use as blatantly on the singing sections , if auto tune was meant to have a hidden meaning in this song it would make sense to use to more blatantly on everyone’s voice to make it look like “they all have shadows “ or something. And plus auto tune has been prominent in rap sections in the last couple of albums not just this.
@@ashishsh2859 well I get you but since yoongi was the intro, he has prominent autotune (tho I know he loves to use this esp recently) nad as some analyzed the interlude:shadow it isn't far from what I've said lol. when his shadow talked back to him in the latter part the autotune was immense, making it seems like it was representing the shadow's characteristic.
Brain Stained well looking back to “interlude:shadow” I get what you mean but I think instead of auto tune to representing the shadow they actually used “distortion and saturation” which is definitely more prominent than the Auto tune and is widely used around the emo hip hop/ pop scene ( the weekend,xxxtentacion) to create a very dark , uncomfortable vocal effect. Your idea definitely makes sense when listening to “interlude : shadow” . But I just don’t think they were aiming for that here since they processed the vocals just like every other rap vocals are produced : compression , de-essing , auto tune - reverb , delay and dynamic Eq.
I think any sane producer would know you can't electronically produce those kind of snares and tubas and trumpets. Yes, Nato is smart. But so is any other producer. Just my humble non-professional opinion :-)
Yess please check out their ON Documentary Film: Dialogue, they did have an actual choir sing along w/ an actual marching band from UCLA. You can see more in depth how they created and produced ON and their whole album :)
@@lunaniteshade9952 nope, you're wrong! the marching band on the actual song IS from UCLA. the marching band in the VIDEO are the Blue Devils. they're two different bands.
@@totally5694 You're right too but I'm guessing this person was talking about the studio marching band so he/she is right as is what's this documentary covers
Yo I just got a revelation. RM says, "Look at me feet, look down", but you notice that you can't really see his feet. While you can see your body shadow, you can't see your feet shadow. This is where your body and its shadow join, hence he says, "My shadow resembles me."
This IS the LEAD SINGLE🤣 Yes they had a marching band called UCLA MARCHING BAND and A GOSPEL group do this!!! They just released a behind commentary on the song and they showed the behind production it was amazing!
ashvegas2448 that’s what I thought originally too! But all of my friends in marching band said that wasn’t the case so I’m a bit confused haha. The Solid Gold Sound of the UCLA Bruin Marching Band is UCLA’s marching band name.
Watching his video reactions on BTS music makes me notice a lot of layers in their songs that I’ve never noticed before. He made me realize and appreciate every details in BTS music even the smallest one. In result, Im loving BTS more and become prouder to these 7 incredible and talented man.
Watch the carpool karaoke they did, Jungkook did that high note and it sounds amazing. I genuinely thought it was a falsetto when I first heard the song, but nope
"Sounds like a marching band during a football game" yeah, cause there was a marching band involved. "this has some gospel vibes" yeah, cause there was a gospel choir involved.
Okay! Prepare for a long comment! Firstly, the marching band BTS collaborated with is actually a really famous drum corps called The Blue Devils. I highly highly recommend searching them up on RUclips, they're amazing. Secondly, apparently the gospel group they worked with worked for MONTHS perfecting their contributions to the album. Thirdly, a little cultural tid bit. "Fighting" or "Hwaiting" are Korean phrases that kind of mean "Let's do this! We got this, we can do it!" It's not just a BTS thing. Only wanted to point it out! Fourthly, Nato this is seriously BTS's best album in my opinion. You gotta do a listening party or something. You wanna hear church music? Taehyung's solo reminds me of like Christian rock bands. Their music choices and genres are so so so smart this time around I think you would really enjoy the album as a whole! Thank you again for an awesome video! Only you could drag out a 5 minute performance video to nearly 20 minutes 😂
@@JoobieLoobieSoobieAh, that makes sense. I was looking at the lyric book in the album and saw all the conductors and such were from UCLA. Thank you for the correction!
And the documentary shows the same gospel singers doing the backing for Friend (and I think Inner Child, too)...and one of them did the ad libs at the end of Ego (wasn't Adore like many of us thought) They've been working HARD with BTS for quite some time it would seem. Props!
Courtney no prob! This got me so excited for the shows. I have a very good feeling that we are gonna get marching bands on stage - probably locals for each city. If Clark Atlanta or Morehouse shows up in Atlanta it’s all over.
i think you hit the nail on the head about autotune - everyone just likes to assume that producers use autotune to mask their voices but it just adds a nice affect to the song
lmao I actually did skip enough of the intro to hear you say "If you skipped _that_ part of the intro..." and then I went back. Got me. But how would I have known, Nato?! Your intro length varies. xD Gotta love you.
One of the many things I respect BTS for is that when auto tune is being used it’s only for effect, maybe a little few tweaks in their voices but what you hear is all them. BTS live sounds just like the studio version.
"Fighting" do not only armys say it's actually something alot of people in korea say to like cheer something like "you got this" or something similiar. Correct me if i'm wrong please :)
you always notice so many details, that's why i love watching your reactions. i already love this song to death but it's really cool to get even more insight and stuff to appreciate. thanks!
When I already love a song , I come to your page to watch your reaction. You break down songs & help me here the song in a way I didn't hear before. Ot make me appreciate the song more
This is why I love your reactions. You bring out stuff that I otherwise wouldn't have noticed listening to the song. Idk how many times I heard the song prior to watching this and never paid attention to some of the background sounds or the choir in certain parts.
Yes, they have a whole marching band and choir for this and some of the songs in the new album. It is in their previous commentary film they released featuring the creative process and working with them. 😊
Yoongi’s rap parts always give me a heart attack for some reason...JEEZE! All the times I had a heart attack from Yoongi: *‘Save me’* *‘Dope’* *‘Cypher 4’* *‘BST’* *‘Paradise’* *‘Fake love’* *‘DNA’* *‘Go go’* *‘Tear’* *’Airplane pt 2’* *’Boy With luv’* *’Home’* *’Black swan’* *’ON’* And he will probably give me more heart attacks...
Joey, don't be mad please, but I absolutely love that most of the time your headphones are on backwards. Its adorable. Also, I've been browsing your original songs and oof! That shit is FIRE 🔥 Someday my bars will be heard too. Until then, I'm turning these L's into Life experience. 🔥💜💜 ARMY is happy to have someone like you who appreciates the music and production of the songs. The lyrics and visuals are insane everytime with BTS, but you point put what we cant catch in the background. Thank you.
I love your detailed explanations about what is happening musicwise ! And I also love the fact that you are pausing the video to explain things. This way I'm learning about and hearing so many new details. As soon as you explain a music detail I can hear it as well, even though I couldn't hear it before. And I love your positive energy!! Saying yourself that you are amazing shows your healthy selfconfidence :-)
Your analyses of these MVs always make me see music in another light. I absolutely loved the song. They came out with a sort of documentary about the making of the song. You were spot on about them using a live marching band. Like Black Swan, they layered other members vocals in some parts in a much more obvious way, but it also keeps the autotune from completely making the vocal foreign and instead just adds effect onto it. I CANNOT wait to see this performed live.
BTS used the UCLA Marching Band and the saying on V's cheek is The Shadow Like Me. This is my first time watching your comments. Really enjoyed the it. Such a fantastic video/music/choreo and the overall talent that BTS has shown is beyond amazing.
You have such a good ear. Picking up all those sounds. I enjoyed your vid. Thanks!!! Yup they got marching band indeed. They have uploaded the documentary of this from the musicians behind it. Incorporating usa's culture into their song, marching band. Who would have thought of bts using marching band? It works tho. They used gayageum in black swan and it works too. They can do anything!
Always love these break-down videos Nato does. It seriously makes me love the songs I love even more - especially when he picks up on small, minute details that I didn't notice at first.
Seriously your review is so on point and I get so much life from it. Thank you for giving BTS a great review :) HAHA and you're really funny too lol. I feel like you have so much gift in producing and understanding music. I hope great things happen to you!
Every time I watch a different artist review ON, I discover something else about the song/dance that really shines it in a new perspective and allows me to further admire this work of art
this comeback of BTS just sound so Fresh.. they really try to explore something new without leave they trademark thou.. it's always good decision that I watched your video, it's give me another knowledge from producer/musician point of view. I appreciate so much for your positive reaction 💜💜
Just a couple of days ago, Suga talked about Interlude: Shadow and some of the things he did to make it sound the way it does and his answer was basically a short version of things you said in your reaction. It was dope to have that little previous knowledge because of your video.
11:50 I'm not Korean but from what I understand is that "fighting" is usually used for when cheering someone on, like "fighting spirit" cheer or something I think? ^^ Nice reaction, always great commentary from you Joey!
special-cereal yup, it’s used a lot in k-dramas too, there is theories it’s from American soldiers placed in Korea (can’t remember all, just remember reading something a few years ago on google)
GLC Nornes Yes, you’re right- lots of more modern influences on the culture are traced back to the 50s during the Korean War when there was a very large American presence helping the south. “Fighting”/파이팅/화이팅 just is a way to say “good luck”/“break a leg”/“do well” in a more simple and streamlined, modern way. Tons of konglish comes from this time period, some is even really outdated! This is also why Spam is so popular in Korea, because it was a cheap food to Americans that was very abundant in war times since it’s also non perishable, so it was given to Koreans from American soldiers in times of need then, so now it’s become kind of a comfort food in Korea :) very commonly used in 부대찌개/“army base stew” which also dates back to war times since it uses very cheap items that were readily available all made into a stew. Super yummy if you ever get a chance to try it! All of this is a big reason why I hope the US doesn’t ruin their relationship with Korea, because there is such rich history of citizens helping each other during dire times, and I think “fighting!” Is a really cool example of that :)
I STAN THE GREATEST it’s Paiting/Hwaiting OR fighting... according to the language pages i just went to double check on, but for a user-friendly site, here’s a wiki quote: *“Paiting! (Korean: 파이팅, pronounced [pʰaitʰiŋ]) or Hwaiting! (Korean: 화이팅, pronounced [ɸwaitʰiŋ]) is a Korean word of support or encouragement. It is frequently used in sports or whenever a challenge such as a difficult test or unpleasant assignment is met.[1] It derives from a Konglish borrowing of the English word "Fighting!"[1][2][3]”*
I’ve seen a lot of producers react to these kids of things but i like watching you specifically. You explain everything in a way where me, someone who doesn’t really have a lot of knowledge in music production, can understand and you point out sounds that I didn’t even hear before. I’m amazed.
Joey! I REALLY appreciate your production analysis!! It helps me understand the music in a different way! I learn a lot from you! tysm! 😁💜 You're very skilled and talented! You're really smart, Joey! Own it!! You know how to produce music well!!!
It's nice seeing someone point out all the musical aspects of ON, because most reactors pay attention to almost exclusively the visuals like dancing and the camera angels, or when a high note comes on, so I gotta say thank you for, not only for teaching me (and I think other Armys, too) more about the music we are passionate about, but also for genuinely listening to the messages somewhat hidden in the instrumentals!
The whole album is a freaking masterpiece, make sure to listen to it ❤️👌🏻😭 Especially to LOUDER THAN BOMBS ; WE ARE BULLETPROOF: THE ETERNAL ; FRIENDS ; FILTER.... ETC. 🎶❤️🎶❤️🎶
배경에 깔리는 오르간과 가스펠 코러스, 실제로 연주하는 마칭밴드 사운드, 보컬춉, 제이홉 랩파트의 세세한 보컬들... 그냥 들었을 땐 전혀 신경쓰지 않고 들었는데 이 영상 보고 나서 다시 on을 들으면 신기하게도 다 들려오네요! 저번 섀도우 리액션때도 리버브 얘기 많이 해주셨는데, 이번에 컴백보라에서 슈가가 리버브 얘기하는거 보고 오오👀뭔가 알고 있는게 나와서 신기했어요 ㅋㅋㅋ 방탄 리액션은 요새 그냥 소리만 지르고 놀란 척만 하는 유튜버들이 많아서 요샌 거의 안보고 있었는데, 조이 나토꺼만 보게 되네요
Hey Joey, I love this reaction/producer breakdown channel cuz like you really catch every single beat and sound that is used in the music. It's so cool that you hear all these sounds while I'm listen to these songs not really knowing how good it is. Just wanna thank you for great content. 👍💜💜💜
god i love u nato XD your sarcasm knows no bounds lol but for real, i love hearing your musical opinions on their songs cus it brings a whole 'nother layer of meaning and appreciation to BTS's music :3
The reason I watch singers,producers,and other professionals reacting because they see something and hear something I couldn't see or hear while watching the video. It makes me learn more. I didn't even know there were background voices until now. And I won't unhear it anymore.
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
*Joey Nato - Black Swan Remix: **ruclips.net/video/08s0PTR2hCo/видео.html*
OMG i love your reaction😂
Bro, do the UGH! next
This reaction made my day!
Would love to hear your reaction to Dan Bull's Hellblade song, ruclips.net/video/lyvXuCRJbDI/видео.html because the whispers used in the background are downright eerie. Not to mention the hook is really great. My younger cousins missed the BTS train, they're all about Lord Huron instead for some reason.
In V face tattoo written that "the shadow like me"...
"How can I look at your feet if you zoom in ?!?!"
I died
"Look at my hand" *Joey zooms in*
I died
I choked cause of my own laughter 😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
RUclips money is getting into his stupid head. Lol. Fake kpop reactors annoying as fuk.
@@JujuCapital relax he's just messing around
@@JujuCapital why u watching then?
Probably in the studio...
Joon: So what are we thinking genre wise? Between trap, gospel, R&B, hip hop, and band.
Yoongi: *Yes*
Yes.
Y E S
One of my favourite of the more well known songs of BTS! The musical production is just too much genius! The whole MV is fire as well!!! Props to everyone involved - BTS, the music producers, choreographers, backup dancers, support staff!!!!
BTS GENRE
Check out BTS "on" Commentary Film: Dialogue, a little behind the scenes for the music production. They had a choir and a college band record most of the stuff. Video was filmed on top of the LA Dam
you beat me to saying this but yes he needs to watch this!
Yes I had to make sure someone commented that he has to check out Dialogue. Hope he does 🙏🏾
Where can I watch it????
@@sumpiikalung1552 bangtan channel
i was screaming thisss!!!
joey: *stops at yoongi*
joey: they have so much swag
lmao there couldn't be a more perfect timing
“Don’t worry, love
None of this is a coincidence”
Joey: HOW DO I KNOW THESE THINGS???
Me: Sir you're a producer
Lol same thoughts
Lmao 😆😆
Exactly what I was thinking XD
HE'S A PRODCER NOT B TO THE FUCKING ST ........BTS R ALWAYS UNIQUE!!!!!! NO ONE KKNOWS WHATS NEXT
Haha
"I'm getting going to church vibes, are we taking them to church?"
No. BTS is taking EVERYONE to church.
Breaaire7 bts is the religion itself
@@heyitsmariabanana
wtf
Good one!
@@PeyloBeauty it's not a literal statement, it's a joke.
@@PeyloBeauty wtf
Wow it's so fascinating to me how I literally hear many things only after you point them out
I think people that do your job can enjoy music in totally different way and that makes me want to learn more, so thank you for these reactions!
I was thinking the same thing! I would NEVER have caught any of the things he points out. Then when he does I have to go back and listen, and it's like - wow, that was there.
I used to go to a music school for some singing lessons when I was younger, and all the teachers in that school are phenomenal. When you see them interacting with each other, talking about music, it's just something else. Most of them know how to play 3 or more instruments (at least at a basic level), and they also know about music theory and production. When they jam together or talk about a song they are composing or arranging they don't even talk sometimes. They just make an imperceptible sound (at least to me) or add something else to the production and the other ones go like "uh, that's right" or "woah okay" or just a small chuckle 😂
They literally communicate through music and it's just so amazing to watch.
@@kwm1013 exactly! Sometimes he's like "ooh wow that's a crazy cord progression right there" and I'm like what- haha I can't hear anything
@@ablindinglightthatnolonger8379 that's amazing! Yeah it's a whole language and unless you have studied you can't really get it
@@danas388 that's why an elaborate piece of music or listening to professionals talking about music never stops to amaze me in the best way possible. It's like when you know a language good enough to be able to recognize different accents or to be able to make jokes and play on words in that language.
After every Joey NATO reaction, I reach for my headphones immediately to listen to the things he described. Like, I didn’t even pick up on the choir (though as suggested by some of you, I’ve seen the commentary). Joey’s commentaries always make me appreciate how skilled music producers have to be to elevate a song. Thanks!
Elle Caledonia omg sameeee
ikr i didn’t even notice the choir and organ it’s really cool
samee
“Sorry for the smoke detector going off in the background, I live next to wiz Khalifa” 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I honestly want to like this comment so bad cause you're the first one i see to say that after watching this, but the holy number has reached the like button before i did so 😂
Catzilla 123 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 hahahahahasksksk the holy number 😭 69 BABYYYYYY
Velly Bear i know 😂😂😂
Omg, I laughed so hard
Jin: "Find me and I'm gonna live with ya"
Sasaeng fans: "AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA"
Haaa, thats scares bro u.u
That's not funny. I don't like what this suggests
THIS IS THE LEAD SINGLE SKSJSKSJ they will just be dropping another mv for it in a week that's it 👏
EDIT : THE NEW MV IS OUT NOW AND IT'S SO GOOOOOD. PLEASE STREAM IT 💜
had to browse through to check if anyone mentioned this lol.
Good. I was looking for someone saying this.
Where did u get that information?
@@High_Exotic check bighit's twitter.... The whole album is already out.
The lead single is ON and it has two mvs, one of them is the kinetic manifesto film that's already out, and the other one will be out on Feb 28 :))
So sksksk is when you are annoyed he made a mistake relax
You're the only producer I watch in BTS reaction. Each and every time you catch every beat and instrumental things so well. Genius man. Appreciated
Joey's house might be burning down, but he's got to know what's on V's face.
Lol
Lol
Lol
Lol
Lol
BTS can, and will, sing this without autotune. They don't need a machine to fix their vocals. If they used it here it's for effect. (They did the same in black swan, and then did it live without it)
Lady Sugarquill exactly and it sound even better you know your stuffs
yeah they didnt use autotune to fix their vocals
Just watched them perform live in Korea and I already knew they would sound great love but omg did they sound amazing! Literally they sounded amazing live while dancing 😍
@master ???
@master try and check their acoustic version that the sung themself
Taehyung's face says " the shadow like me" if you wanted to know Joey😃
Joey Ego : I don't break down videos
Joey ON : what does his face say I NEED TO SEE WHAT IT SAYS
This is hype as always!
YEAH, in their documentary they talk about that "gospel vibes". Was a live band and a choir from New Orleans!!!
Was UCLA Marching Band...
@@BugsOvrBTS It was like 3 different bands and UCLA was one of them
Shawna B the choir was from nola
I knew there was some soul in the production
@@wife0fsunwoo Hella talent!!! Thank you!
Yoongi has a natural swag to him. Doesn't even have to try. He just doesn't give a UGH! No matter if he is on camera, on stage or when he deals with annoying reporters asking inappropriate qustions at press conferences... And his cypher verses are one of the reasons he became my bias. Whenever I need a boost of confidence I count on him to lend me some. 😊
Aah I see what u did there 😏
Ugh
Yeah its true
Different tones
That why this Comeback of BTS is different.
I love their voice.
The rapline is so savage Especially Jhope
Suga rap and Rm rap is so damn gooddd
Jk high notes
Jimin High Note
V OMG deep voice
And then Jin voice 😭😭
Actually im dead😭
Same bro 😭😭
The reason why the autotune was prominent in most of the tracks in this album "Map of the Soul: 7" is because the overall topic is about overcoming your own "SHADOW" and autotune represents the shadow. Also in Suga's Interlude: Shadow, you can hear the ending was soooo autotune (tho still sounded amazing) is because his shadow was overtaking)
Brain Stained pretty sure it was there just to get the cooler sounding vocals for mainly the rap. But if that’s what you think , sure 🤷♂️
@@ashishsh2859 well lol I've been an ARMY for 2 years now and I've never seen tracks from them esp the recent albums that doesn't have underlying meaning to it. They are intricate in sounds and beats/melodies. Yeah it sound cool on the surface but it's more than that
Brain Stained ive been studying music production and I’ve been an amry for more than 5+ years , and yes I know that BTS love to have hidden meanings in their songs and music videos, especially back in the I need u to fire era when all the fan theories were going crazy. But sometimes some production details are there just to make the song sound better not everything is meant to have a meaning like auto tuned rap is just for the cool effect, hence why they didn’t use as blatantly on the singing sections , if auto tune was meant to have a hidden meaning in this song it would make sense to use to more blatantly on everyone’s voice to make it look like “they all have shadows “ or something. And plus auto tune has been prominent in rap sections in the last couple of albums not just this.
@@ashishsh2859 well I get you but since yoongi was the intro, he has prominent autotune (tho I know he loves to use this esp recently) nad as some analyzed the interlude:shadow it isn't far from what I've said lol. when his shadow talked back to him in the latter part the autotune was immense, making it seems like it was representing the shadow's characteristic.
Brain Stained well looking back to “interlude:shadow” I get what you mean but I think instead of auto tune to representing the shadow they actually used “distortion and saturation” which is definitely more prominent than the Auto tune and is widely used around the emo hip hop/ pop scene ( the weekend,xxxtentacion) to create a very dark , uncomfortable vocal effect. Your idea definitely makes sense when listening to “interlude : shadow” . But I just don’t think they were aiming for that here since they processed the vocals just like every other rap vocals are produced : compression , de-essing , auto tune - reverb , delay and dynamic Eq.
13:55
Dude, he really is so smart.
There's a behind the scenes video about the Marching band and the Choir.
I think any sane producer would know you can't electronically produce those kind of snares and tubas and trumpets. Yes, Nato is smart. But so is any other producer. Just my humble non-professional opinion :-)
Joey: “LoOk AT mY HaND”
I choked 🤣🤣😭
Yess please check out their ON Documentary Film: Dialogue, they did have an actual choir sing along w/ an actual marching band from UCLA. You can see more in depth how they created and produced ON and their whole album :)
@@lunaniteshade9952 nope, you're wrong! the marching band on the actual song IS from UCLA. the marching band in the VIDEO are the Blue Devils. they're two different bands.
@@totally5694 they are correct though Nato didn't say the band in the video he said I guarantee you they had a marching band record this in the studio
@@totally5694 You're right too but I'm guessing this person was talking about the studio marching band so he/she is right as is what's this documentary covers
@@Iamone1111 I was replying to someone else, but they have deleted their comment now because they were wrong lmao
@@arlecchino7936 I was replying to someone else, but they deleted their comment 💀
Yo I just got a revelation. RM says, "Look at me feet, look down", but you notice that you can't really see his feet. While you can see your body shadow, you can't see your feet shadow. This is where your body and its shadow join, hence he says, "My shadow resembles me."
This IS the LEAD SINGLE🤣 Yes they had a marching band called UCLA MARCHING BAND and A GOSPEL group do this!!! They just released a behind commentary on the song and they showed the behind production it was amazing!
Luna Niteshade in the dialogue video, it shows UCLA marching band members doing the recording! On Spotify it says UCLA as well. Perhaps it is both?
@@sorasoda2717 The UCLA Marching Band is the Blue Devils actually....
ashvegas2448 that’s what I thought originally too! But all of my friends in marching band said that wasn’t the case so I’m a bit confused haha. The Solid Gold Sound of the UCLA Bruin Marching Band is UCLA’s marching band name.
@@sorasoda2717 yeah, I actually had to look that up... It's not that well known of a name for them...
Yes saw the vid appreciate it more to me at least.
Watching his video reactions on BTS music makes me notice a lot of layers in their songs that I’ve never noticed before. He made me realize and appreciate every details in BTS music even the smallest one. In result, Im loving BTS more and become prouder to these 7 incredible and talented man.
When you watch Joey to see the things he heard in the music that you didn't hear.
Urei Miura “SEE the things he heard ” 😅 I totally get you, and had to re-read to realise you said see and not hear 😄💜
hahah exactly why i like seeing other musicians reactions
true
absolutely right
Watch the carpool karaoke they did, Jungkook did that high note and it sounds amazing. I genuinely thought it was a falsetto when I first heard the song, but nope
The words on Taehyung's cheek says "the shadow like me"
'This shadow like me' V's face tatto
6:32 dude... you say they missed the shoutout on the "hey nanana" and you miss that it is the last word from rm right before the "hey nanana"
XD
"Sounds like a marching band during a football game" yeah, cause there was a marching band involved.
"this has some gospel vibes" yeah, cause there was a gospel choir involved.
Okay! Prepare for a long comment!
Firstly, the marching band BTS collaborated with is actually a really famous drum corps called The Blue Devils. I highly highly recommend searching them up on RUclips, they're amazing.
Secondly, apparently the gospel group they worked with worked for MONTHS perfecting their contributions to the album.
Thirdly, a little cultural tid bit. "Fighting" or "Hwaiting" are Korean phrases that kind of mean "Let's do this! We got this, we can do it!" It's not just a BTS thing. Only wanted to point it out!
Fourthly, Nato this is seriously BTS's best album in my opinion. You gotta do a listening party or something. You wanna hear church music? Taehyung's solo reminds me of like Christian rock bands. Their music choices and genres are so so so smart this time around I think you would really enjoy the album as a whole!
Thank you again for an awesome video! Only you could drag out a 5 minute performance video to nearly 20 minutes 😂
Blue Devils were in the video, but UCLA marching band did the actual recording of the song.
@@JoobieLoobieSoobieAh, that makes sense. I was looking at the lyric book in the album and saw all the conductors and such were from UCLA. Thank you for the correction!
And the documentary shows the same gospel singers doing the backing for Friend (and I think Inner Child, too)...and one of them did the ad libs at the end of Ego (wasn't Adore like many of us thought) They've been working HARD with BTS for quite some time it would seem. Props!
Courtney no prob! This got me so excited for the shows. I have a very good feeling that we are gonna get marching bands on stage - probably locals for each city. If Clark Atlanta or Morehouse shows up in Atlanta it’s all over.
@@JoobieLoobieSoobie I hope so! I live in the Chicago area so fingers crossed they need a sousaphone player 😂
i think you hit the nail on the head about autotune - everyone just likes to assume that producers use autotune to mask their voices but it just adds a nice affect to the song
lmao I actually did skip enough of the intro to hear you say "If you skipped _that_ part of the intro..." and then I went back. Got me. But how would I have known, Nato?! Your intro length varies. xD Gotta love you.
One of the many things I respect BTS for is that when auto tune is being used it’s only for effect, maybe a little few tweaks in their voices but what you hear is all them. BTS live sounds just like the studio version.
"Fighting" do not only armys say it's actually something alot of people in korea say to like cheer something like "you got this" or something similiar. Correct me if i'm wrong please :)
It's 화이팅 which is like a cheer or 'good luck' or 'you got this'
@@_kill_bill_ yes, that was what i meant to say but i couldn't really explain it right cause i'm dumb, thank you very much :)
Omg it's min yoongiiii
@@katinaborchert2206 how you doing
you always notice so many details, that's why i love watching your reactions. i already love this song to death but it's really cool to get even more insight and stuff to appreciate. thanks!
Omg i was waiting for this. Youre reactions are the best
When I already love a song , I come to your page to watch your reaction. You break down songs & help me here the song in a way I didn't hear before. Ot make me appreciate the song more
This reaction proves how good you are! You were able to identify things so easily and picked up on things I didn’t hear before!
6:33 "They messed up my shout out on this one" LMAO
Me: excitingly waiting for Joey to react to Jimin's intro
Jimin: I can't understand--
Joey: STOP!!
Me: 😳
"I live next to wiz khalifa" that killed me
😂🤣😂🤣😂 dude same
I love you Joey Nato! I've been waiting for your reaction to this song for days and it's dope as expected! Thanks! 💜
15:43
That timing on the pause LOL
This is why I love your reactions. You bring out stuff that I otherwise wouldn't have noticed listening to the song. Idk how many times I heard the song prior to watching this and never paid attention to some of the background sounds or the choir in certain parts.
Yes, they have a whole marching band and choir for this and some of the songs in the new album. It is in their previous commentary film they released featuring the creative process and working with them. 😊
gospel choir!
@@thepriceofsalt9003 yes a gospel choir 😊
Yoongi’s rap parts always give me a heart attack for some reason...JEEZE!
All the times I had a heart attack from Yoongi:
*‘Save me’*
*‘Dope’*
*‘Cypher 4’*
*‘BST’*
*‘Paradise’*
*‘Fake love’*
*‘DNA’*
*‘Go go’*
*‘Tear’*
*’Airplane pt 2’*
*’Boy With luv’*
*’Home’*
*’Black swan’*
*’ON’*
And he will probably give me more heart attacks...
And now you have Daechwita
MinealVab veb and now I am planning my funeral
Joey, don't be mad please, but I absolutely love that most of the time your headphones are on backwards. Its adorable. Also, I've been browsing your original songs and oof! That shit is FIRE 🔥 Someday my bars will be heard too. Until then, I'm turning these L's into Life experience. 🔥💜💜 ARMY is happy to have someone like you who appreciates the music and production of the songs. The lyrics and visuals are insane everytime with BTS, but you point put what we cant catch in the background. Thank you.
I love your detailed explanations about what is happening musicwise ! And I also love the fact that you are pausing the video to explain things. This way I'm learning about and hearing so many new details. As soon as you explain a music detail I can hear it as well, even though I couldn't hear it before. And I love your positive energy!! Saying yourself that you are amazing shows your healthy selfconfidence :-)
under V's eye is written "THE SHADOW LIKE ME" ;)
I really hope that's not a real tattoo because he's not a shadow 😭
@@katiekoo-koohead2551 its not real lol...
Your analyses of these MVs always make me see music in another light. I absolutely loved the song. They came out with a sort of documentary about the making of the song. You were spot on about them using a live marching band. Like Black Swan, they layered other members vocals in some parts in a much more obvious way, but it also keeps the autotune from completely making the vocal foreign and instead just adds effect onto it. I CANNOT wait to see this performed live.
Yesss. They had an actual band help them produce this. All the choirs and everything.
BTS used the UCLA Marching Band and the saying on V's cheek is The Shadow Like Me. This is my first time watching your comments. Really enjoyed the it. Such a fantastic video/music/choreo and the overall talent that BTS has shown is beyond amazing.
You have such a good ear. Picking up all those sounds. I enjoyed your vid. Thanks!!! Yup they got marching band indeed. They have uploaded the documentary of this from the musicians behind it. Incorporating usa's culture into their song, marching band. Who would have thought of bts using marching band? It works tho. They used gayageum in black swan and it works too. They can do anything!
Always love these break-down videos Nato does. It seriously makes me love the songs I love even more - especially when he picks up on small, minute details that I didn't notice at first.
Seriously your review is so on point and I get so much life from it. Thank you for giving BTS a great review :) HAHA and you're really funny too lol. I feel like you have so much gift in producing and understanding music. I hope great things happen to you!
Every time I watch a different artist review ON, I discover something else about the song/dance that really shines it in a new perspective and allows me to further admire this work of art
PLEASE REACT TO BTS- UGH
yeees
Yes
Yes! I've been waiting for Nato to react to Ugh!
Its got so many layers, please listen to that one!!!
Up
Jimin: I can't underst-
Joey: *STAPH!*
😂😂😂
15:40 that pause timing though lmao
IKR! I was like 😱😱😱😱😱😱 what is this sorcery!?
He paused it at the perfect time😂😂😂😂
I love that you go into details with their MV well appreciated.👍
This is the Lead single . This is the first MV for it
Literally keep me coming back with the intro! Love it!
"sorry for the smoke detector going off in the background.. i live next to wiz khalifa" HAHAHAHAHAAHAHA I'm dead
this comeback of BTS just sound so Fresh.. they really try to explore something new without leave they trademark thou..
it's always good decision that I watched your video, it's give me another knowledge from producer/musician point of view.
I appreciate so much for your positive reaction 💜💜
15:40 he really did accidentally stop at the right time 👌🏻
That’s what I said!
I've been waiting for your reaction! Thank you for another good reaction, in which i ,as always, learned something from you!
In conclusion:
BTS HAS EVERYTHING
Just a couple of days ago, Suga talked about Interlude: Shadow and some of the things he did to make it sound the way it does and his answer was basically a short version of things you said in your reaction. It was dope to have that little previous knowledge because of your video.
11:50 I'm not Korean but from what I understand is that "fighting" is usually used for when cheering someone on, like "fighting spirit" cheer or something I think? ^^
Nice reaction, always great commentary from you Joey!
special-cereal yup, it’s used a lot in k-dramas too, there is theories it’s from American soldiers placed in Korea (can’t remember all, just remember reading something a few years ago on google)
GLC Nornes Yes, you’re right- lots of more modern influences on the culture are traced back to the 50s during the Korean War when there was a very large American presence helping the south. “Fighting”/파이팅/화이팅 just is a way to say “good luck”/“break a leg”/“do well” in a more simple and streamlined, modern way. Tons of konglish comes from this time period, some is even really outdated! This is also why Spam is so popular in Korea, because it was a cheap food to Americans that was very abundant in war times since it’s also non perishable, so it was given to Koreans from American soldiers in times of need then, so now it’s become kind of a comfort food in Korea :) very commonly used in 부대찌개/“army base stew” which also dates back to war times since it uses very cheap items that were readily available all made into a stew. Super yummy if you ever get a chance to try it!
All of this is a big reason why I hope the US doesn’t ruin their relationship with Korea, because there is such rich history of citizens helping each other during dire times, and I think “fighting!” Is a really cool example of that :)
Koreans says "HWAITING".
I STAN THE GREATEST it’s Paiting/Hwaiting OR fighting... according to the language pages i just went to double check on, but for a user-friendly site, here’s a wiki quote: *“Paiting! (Korean: 파이팅, pronounced [pʰaitʰiŋ]) or Hwaiting! (Korean: 화이팅, pronounced [ɸwaitʰiŋ]) is a Korean word of support or encouragement. It is frequently used in sports or whenever a challenge such as a difficult test or unpleasant assignment is met.[1] It derives from a Konglish borrowing of the English word "Fighting!"[1][2][3]”*
배핸아 thank you for your comment with explanation, was lovely to read.
I’ve seen a lot of producers react to these kids of things but i like watching you specifically. You explain everything in a way where me, someone who doesn’t really have a lot of knowledge in music production, can understand and you point out sounds that I didn’t even hear before. I’m amazed.
The way I skipped the part and when I played the video he was out there calling me out shgsgsgsgs
😂😂😂😂😂 because the intro wasn't that long bro
When Joey said "Look at my hand" I literally choked on my spit from trying not to laugh.
Joey! I REALLY appreciate your production analysis!! It helps me understand the music in a different way! I learn a lot from you! tysm! 😁💜
You're very skilled and talented! You're really smart, Joey! Own it!! You know how to produce music well!!!
It's nice seeing someone point out all the musical aspects of ON, because most reactors pay attention to almost exclusively the visuals like dancing and the camera angels, or when a high note comes on, so I gotta say thank you for, not only for teaching me (and I think other Armys, too) more about the music we are passionate about, but also for genuinely listening to the messages somewhat hidden in the instrumentals!
That “look at my feet down” pissed me off too 😂
Joey: I'm getting church vibes
Me: you're gonna have to go to church after this
It says “The shadow like me” 😆
For some reason every time I watch Joey's reactions I can hear way more detailed the songs than I did before
This is actually their lead single.
Him: "How do I know there's gonna be some crazy drop?"
Me: "Ahhh you're a music producer? Lol."
The whole album is a freaking masterpiece, make sure to listen to it ❤️👌🏻😭
Especially to LOUDER THAN BOMBS ; WE ARE BULLETPROOF: THE ETERNAL ; FRIENDS ; FILTER.... ETC. 🎶❤️🎶❤️🎶
Idk why but this is just my fav video of nato. I think his personality is really shining through and I love it:)
The production on their albums is always so glorious
You have no idea how much I was waiting for your reaction!!!
이분 리액션 한글자막 했으면 좋겠어요.
금코끼리 완젼공감해여!!!
Someone help this person get Korean subtitles.
As soon as the MV dropped, I knew I couldn't wait for your reaction 👏👏
배경에 깔리는 오르간과 가스펠 코러스, 실제로 연주하는 마칭밴드 사운드, 보컬춉, 제이홉 랩파트의 세세한 보컬들... 그냥 들었을 땐 전혀 신경쓰지 않고 들었는데 이 영상 보고 나서 다시 on을 들으면 신기하게도 다 들려오네요! 저번 섀도우 리액션때도 리버브 얘기 많이 해주셨는데, 이번에 컴백보라에서 슈가가 리버브 얘기하는거 보고 오오👀뭔가 알고 있는게 나와서 신기했어요 ㅋㅋㅋ 방탄 리액션은 요새 그냥 소리만 지르고 놀란 척만 하는 유튜버들이 많아서 요샌 거의 안보고 있었는데, 조이 나토꺼만 보게 되네요
Hey Joey, I love this reaction/producer breakdown channel cuz like you really catch every single beat and sound that is used in the music. It's so cool that you hear all these sounds while I'm listen to these songs not really knowing how good it is. Just wanna thank you for great content. 👍💜💜💜
10:21 yoongi's hair 😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
LMAOOOOOO SLSKWOAJAU
we weren’t lying when we said bts’s hair dances with them 🤣🤣🤣
god i love u nato XD
your sarcasm knows no bounds lol
but for real, i love hearing your musical opinions on their songs cus it brings a whole 'nother layer of meaning and appreciation to BTS's music :3
The temperary face tattoo Taehyung has in ON says "The shadow likes me"🙂 timestamp: 3.10
The reason I watch singers,producers,and other professionals reacting because they see something and hear something I couldn't see or hear while watching the video. It makes me learn more. I didn't even know there were background voices until now. And I won't unhear it anymore.
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 2:55 오빠 예전에는 이런거 굳이 보지 않았자나 ㅋㅋㅋ 오로지 프로듀싱만 이야기 했었다고... V의 타투 문구를 궁금해 하는 당신의 모습. 쏘 굿~~~~~ ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 당신은 아미가 되어 있었구나.. 💜💜
ㅋㅋ
언젠간 일어날 일이 었습니다. 방탄은 한번도 안본 사람은 있어도 한번만 본사람은 거의 없읍니다. 특히 음악이나 댄스 전공자나 관심있는 분들은.
Genevieve Valois 그렇긴 한데요 ㅋㅋ 나토의 처음 리액션 하던때가 생각 나서요... ㅋㅋ 엄청 진지 했다고요. 심지어 쩔어를 리액션 할때도요 ㅋㅋ 🤗
@@worm6124 세상에 행복한 사람이 하나 더 는거죠. 요즘 같은 난세에 건강 조심하세요.
your reaction is the best so far EVER! youre funny so much and that make me really enjoy your clips omgggg thank you a lot!
Joey Nato: Stops everytime there’s a new sound to the song and takes 2 min to explain everything
Love you and your reaction!