I run a small ecommerce store in USA from India . I slept on the idea of moving my business to Dubai. I could have access to much better payment processors, credit, and ofcourse no tax. I am gonna move my business to Dubai after USA holiday season is over. Running international business from India makes it almost impossible for small ecom entrepreneurs to compete with Chinese or any first world counterparts. Taxes are one thing but it's ok. access to credit, availability of various resources is killer
First of all, taking about fairness, you are not doing fair with American by earning in USD and spending in INR. Because of difference in currency you are benefiting. This is CHEATING. Run your business in India! It will do well. If not, change something. Chinese export a ton of things. You can also try that. But don't come out and complain to others that its so tough to run a business from India in USA. Its already a miracle that it can be done!
Law is skewed towards the advantages of super rich. The Indian earning class is destined to pay taxes of 60% of their earnings.( IT plus, various taxes on your purchase means you end up paying more than 60% of your earnings as taxes).
Not just the law, it's the nature of the society and that's how the economy works. Buy a small packet of maggy, it'll cost More per unit vs a big packet. Buy it in a mall in south Bombay, the big packet will have some discount, now imagin some nobody buying the small packet in a poor village in india. Same with money, you've less money you get less interest. Everything is like that.
I am about to pay 40 lac rupees in taxes this year and that is just outrageous that I have to pay that much on just 1.3 cr income. that's literally 37% taxes I have to pay. I am gonna use Dubai to reduce my taxes.
The really rich never pay taxes in capitalist countries. They get loans, loan waivers and reduction in corporate taxes. Thats how India has become capitalists and abandoned socialism after Rajiv got assasinated
@@chirkuttrader2898 What about transactions tax, whether you have profit or not? How many thousands of crores government earns through that to waive off loans?
Yes i am in india and i just pay 50% of my portforlio earnings, market crashes. yet it has not bottomed, It has no business at this level in the first place, pumped up by the Fed and central banks around the world. You can still be 100% invested at this level. Good luck! I prefer to sell the bounce and keep 50% cash. I will not get back into the market more than 50% if S&P is not 30% lower from here. I trade and make quick profits. With this inflation and my expectation on the economy, I am ok with 70% cash. I don’t short the market. Just keep selling the bounce!
I am sitting on cash. I sold my stocks but the best part about this sell-off i have been mostly right, the worst part about it is that i don’t short anymore so I’m not making so much money but at least i will get to buy twice the stock with the same USD amount.
@@monicamoore4329 It's been a terrific experience, I actually made my first ever 6figure profit of about 28 BTC in 5 months and I'm getting more active and knowledgeable in the market.
I outlined a decent sum and I generally stay contributed, with the assistance of a counselor "Lisa Michelle Pacillas" she assisted me with accomplishing this level, basically look her name up on the web
If your income is less than in a FY is 2.5 lakhs or even less than 10 lakhs you're not forced to pay taxes... Book an appointment with any good or average consultant. They will guide you...
@@the.candlelight_2094 thats if his total income under heads is below 2.5 lakhs Under section 112A u can get threshold limit 1 lakhs capital gain profit
As per section 4 of Income tax act, 1961.. tax is levied onincome of a person of indian origin and as per case law it has been decided that any income which is generated in india.. like fno from Indian stock companies (even nifty and bank nifty is composed of Indian stocks only), then tax is required to be paid by the person.. and residency won't matter here because generation of income is from Indian companies only. Thanks 🙏
DTAA and STCG The DTAA between India and the UAE is designed to prevent double taxation and ensure that the same income is not taxed twice in both countries. STCG on Indian Securities: Capital gains from the sale of shares, mutual funds, or other securities in India are typically taxed in India where the income is sourced. The DTAA usually does not provide a specific exemption for STCG derived from transactions in Indian securities. Taxation in India: Even if you have a TRC, STCG from equity trading in India is taxed at a flat rate of 15% under Section 111A of the Indian Income Tax Act if the securities transaction tax (STT) is paid.
citing the first example of one family member being NRI and trading. If a person is employed in Dubai and is therefore NRI, trades in indian derivatives, will he have to pay tax as in first example.
As per income tax Act, any income which is deemed to accrue or arise in India will be taxable in India, irrespective of the fact whether it is earned by resident or non resident. Income from trading in Indian markets will be taxable as per above rule. DTAA comes into force when a person is resident of both the countries. In that case also, Income tax department applies force of attraction (FOA) Rule which acts as a tie breaker to decide which country's resident a person actually is. After the tie breaker, it is decided, how both the countries will share the taxes, if any Not paying tax in india on Trading income through Dubai/Singapore route is not that easy as it sounds.
@@manojlds I heard it right the first time. But did you hear anything about the reason at 6:00 in the entire video ? If not, then the purpose of writing 2 paras is very clear I suppose.
@@periwalvaibhav is correct. Moreover, NRIs cannot operate in Derivates or future & options etc. DTAA simply mean they will not pay double tax on the same income.
1) How can NRi ( still Indian citizen) trade in F& O 2) Consider all teh cost of travels and staying in UAE the savings from Indian F&O Trading tax has to be HUGE! so break even is very high!
FPI AND FII are both different, to be precise FPI- retail foreign investors who invest on shares of businesses FII - institutional foreign investors who invest in businesses
Getting money through trading is after great losses for years. Later after earning paying income tax and Gst from the earned white money is too tough. Whatever may be the type of trading or investing or capital gain, maximum affordable decent tax should be more than 10%.
Any derivative trading via NRO account is taxable in India even for UAE NRIs. In fact there is direct TDS of around 30 percent which need to be settled via IT return filing. Request to take expert opinions before making any such move or video on subject to avoid confusions for blind followers
If you compare the cost of living in Dubai vs India, I think India is far cheaper. Also the fact that you miss out on living near your loved ones vs living alone in a foreign land. So its not that simple.
Also if u r frequent flyer need to pay huge expense on airticket, which may equal to tax. Only profitable for big taxable people whose tax in very higher side when compare to air tickets
Sir Dubai maybe tax free but please tell that Dubai expense of living is much higher than India, for eg. Internet costs 1000 rs per month here in India and in Dubai it’s 12000 for the same package…
Thank you for making this video, informative and useful for all NRI and NRE. There will be many who will troll but don't mind ,as many doens't know how much money NRI and NRE bring back as value addition to Indian Economy.
Wrong information. Double taxation treaty means that the tax paid in India will not be double taxed in country where you are tax resident. That means I produce certificate that I have paid tax in India to Dubai and donot get taxed in Dubai. Since no tax in Dubai, it doesnot matter. Any income in India is to be taxed in India. This is the basic rule.
I think a critical point you missed is that in order to be registered as an FPI with SEBI, the fund must have at least USD 30 million in assets under management (AUM). Please correct me if i am wrong.
You’re missing the point, your not listing an investment fund or ETF. If you have USD 300 you can register yourself as an individual as foreign portfolio investor.
You are mistaken, even if you are a NRI living in uae or Saudi Arabia, any income earned in India is subject to tax and of course if you have yearly earnings inside India lower than 1 lac you don’t have to file tax usually (except if your trading turnover is above a certain limit). For NRIs in Middle East, the income earned in Middle East isn’t taxable but their Indian income is still subject to tax.
he said you need to Open An Nri Account for the Broker of India to Trade in india so Officially we are considering as nri Is trading and He has Uae Trc Certificate so He submitted His Certificate to ITD for Filling The Tax Bcz the Dtt Has Been Signed from indian government with Uae Government So We Will Pay Taxes in Uae That Is Living Cost or Vat Only 👍
after reading many comments, I understand that people didnt get you. he is saying become a FPI and then trade in FnO thats tax free in india for FPIs. but for NRIs any income accrued in India , its taxable in india. I was an NRI for few years and I was in Dubai only so,, i am pretty sure about it.
If SEBI is really worried for Small investors than stop Sebi fees to Small investors and requested all members to oppose Sebi Consultation paper proposal on SEBI portal
A lot of development that is happening in our country is because of taxes been paid by honest citizens. However the percentage of people paying taxes is still very low. Our government is doing a lot to encourage people to pay taxes which helps in building defense, infrastructure, healthcare and education. Middleclass people do not mind paying taxes nor do the large corporate houses that has made India its primary location. Yes, there are some UHNI's & HNI's with short term interest who think otherwise. It is believed that only 10% of traders make money and which is BIG MONEY and we should encourage them to contribute to nation building. Mr. Sunder, you have a big following in this segments mostly youngsters and budding traders who appreciate your accomplishments and daily views. I have seen many successful people who have built some competencies often tend loose a lot when they get into areas which is not very clear. I think we should promote India and not Dubai even for a fee.
The really rich never pay taxes in capitalist countries. They get loans, loan waivers and reduction in corporate taxes. Thats how India has become capitalists and abandoned socialism after Rajiv got assasinated
It's a myth tht few people pay taxes. There is GST tax and other taxes on products. This is also tax 18%. We pay tax (income & GST) to build road. Then more tax to keep the road clean & then toll tax for maintenance of the road. We keep on paying taxes and in the end we don't even proper road. There should be a limit to tax. Many farmers earn in millions and they are exempted from tax. Businesses man avoid tax with the help of CA. Only middle class suffers.
Better shift to Canada or Germany i would say.I would be taking permanent residency in Canada soon and leave the Indian passport .Much better return and benefits of taxes being paid in Canada or UK.Hope you do well.
As a matured and reputed trader, he should encourage people to pay tax on profits. Never educate people as how to avoid taxes. You don't want to pay taxes but expect govt to announce new schemes. And increase in GDP every quarter. 😊
Are you kidding me ?. it is very necessary to educate people to avoid taxes, 80% of Indian population is middle class & provide a hell load of tax. But what happens with that tax , new parliament construction ?, ram mandir construction ?. What about opportunities, quality of life ?. Govt. already knows that these are the ways to evade taxation but still they help their HNI friends to do so. Because some of them provide a huge amount to party funds.
@@SPARSHKUMAR-f4hIdiot andhnamazi we have paid for ram mandir not government correct your fact don't point out on our temples we have contributed for it .Tax is going in pocket of all political parties leaders and mlas .
@@kamranwasifify Yes, They are saying Europe is getting expensive. Pension is not sufficient for aged. Property is not affordable. Too much Alchohol and Drugs. Illegal immigration. Rents are expensive. If they get the same money what they are earning, they can easily live in Asian countries. Thailand and many countries is promoting them. Young Digital Nomads are more interested in Asian countries including India. India is not issuing a long term solution for them.
@@helium740🤣🤣🤣 Where did you got this information from?? Literally every European countries have way better living standards and safety than India. It's true that some Europeans go to south east Asian countries but nobody is coming to India.
Dear sir, being a genius, you should suggest tax structure to government, that will keep Indian money in India. Indian sons, the soldiers, sacrifice their life for India. Can't we do this much for India? Modiji is working tirelessly for 1.4 billion people. Can't we do just 1% of that effort? Jai Hind!
Dear Sir , Please suggest where to get informations like fed meeting calendar , US job data , Auto sales data ? Companies quarterly annual results calendar ?? where to get all those datas ? Any particular website or list of websites ???
I am about to pay 40 lac rupees in taxes this year and that is just outrageous that I have to pay that much on just 1.3 cr income. that's literally 37% taxes I have to pay. I am gonna use Dubai to reduce my taxes.
I would never ever evade tax. As a patriotic citizen of this great country called India I feel it's my primary duty and responsibility to pay tax and adhere to the law of this land. I would happily pay my taxes and contribute to the growth and development of our economy and people, share a large chunk of my fortunes to people who are in need... Involve in philanthropic activities and causes I believe in ... After all all that I have I now is given to over to me by this country.. Would love to identify myself as a law abiding citizen of this country... A 360 degree growth includes our value system too... My respect for you grew manifolds when you said you will offer consulting and services only if its legal.. great sir...
@@sayedallabakash756 true brother jo loag tax nahi bharte wo kya jane ki aapka 50% earning le le jyadatar toh loag toh tax bharte nahi mai toh trader hun soch raha hun uae settled ho jaun
I’m a CA student. As per IT Act if a Non Resident making any income from India as TRADING relevant here, it is deemed to accrue or arise in india so even though he is NRI he still layable to pay tax on that trading income.
If one person in family is NRI (in Dubai), how can entire family's income be transfered to his ac and let him invest as tax free income? This is illegal. It's treated as business trx.
I think people forget the cost of living in Dubai. Setting up is easy, maintaining and complying with all requirements will cost a bit. If you're an HNWI, it shouldn't be a problem, you'll have a good lifestyle in Dubai. But if you're planning to incorporate there for the purpose of trading, be ready for the introduction of corporate tax in Dubai next year. Not as much as India at 25-30%, maybe around 9% or 10% - still better. But is it really worth it?
1. How much net worth or cashflow makes them HNWI? 2. If you pay yourself entire profit of company as director salary, your company technically pays 0 tax.
goto freezone and register your company make money dont pay corporate tax because your company is not mainland company and not doing any buisness with uae people so you dont pay.
Lol u living in 2018, dubai has introduced it at 9percent flat if you make business profits above 350k dhs per aanum...and besides dubai is more business friendly, and the ease of doing one is much more easier with no hassles.
As a banker I do not agree that small people are harassed and big people not after taking loan from bank. This is totally wrong. Small people r only beneficiary of loan waiver schemes ,not the big. When big people fail to pay there are very steps fr recovery , bank going to court , NCLT , SARFESI rules are used. 2-3 persons may hv run out of the country but then all their assets are attached.
Thanks for this video. Can you please update this video as of today? Are there any complications? Also please mention with some examples with a profit of 1cr profits from US stocks through indian apps.
Title should have been "Bharath Mata ki......Bye!!" This is a story about a man living in a joint family. He along other earning members of the family, is expected to contribute to his family. Our man finds that giving money to the family is not worth it, so lets himself move to his neighbour's house, who allows this man to stay in his place without any contributions. After that, our man's rest of the family members lived happily ever after!. Q1, We are paying taxes from our profits only, right? Q2, Also what about the other expenditure Q3, Travelling to Dubai back to India, and other expenditures incurred in this process, all combined, does it really offset the tax? Q4, After all this , if you make losses in the stock market, then ? Q5, There must be some benefit for UAE, what is the hidden agenda? Please love thy country!
Sir, you mentioned you'd not spent more than Rs. 700 on the shirt as you dont prefer branded items. Then why did you spend crores of Rs. On Rolls Royce, even Corolla could serve the purpose. Please clarify. It will help me understand your mindset.
SIR,you are a gentleman ,why you have think of evading taxes.Not required,infact you donate 25% of your profit to Tamilanadu Govt.When we get good money in derivative market,what is the problem in paying IT. good video.
But it is a wrong to say that low class doesnt pay tax. Even when you buy even simple vegetables-you pay for the transport charges-petrol-govt tax. When you buy a simple soap-sales tax-you pay
Same i here, i will praise mrs heather over and over again because she has great skills, i started with $2000 and after 2week i received a returns of $6,000 then i continue with her ever since she has been delivering
So basically govt is facilitating HNIs to shift from India and don't pay taxes, and SQUEEZE all the lower, middle and upper middle class! Not fair at all! Thanks Anna for opening our eyes! 🙏
No it's not like that, pls understand super rich still don't want to stay in tax heaven (carbean islands or gulf countries like dubai etc) as their school ,colleges, Childern education, democratic rights, freedom, economic etc of those countries still under not at par with Europe/developed countries and they don't want to stay in those countries with their families. India is doing no wrong, taxation laws of any country depends upon economic condition of that country and as per mutually signed treaties of that country with other countries
There is no such thing as a good tax, govt policies do punish everyone, its only the rich who have the means to circumvent this, indians are losing out due to this
those who are thinking to move dubai 1bed room 4x8ft will cost you 20-30k thats 2.5-3.5L per year + food, travel and other expenses thats 4-6L per year😂 move only if you are earning 1cr+
I earn money to spend with family and friends, what I do with lot of money without them, instead of paying flight charges and other expenses i am ready to pay taxes to India 🇮🇳
Things which he didn't mention about , currency exchange risk , u need administrator for FPI which is very costly , you need indian custodian , you need to incorporate FPI in foreign countries like Mauritius, singapore where they have tax treaty with government of India , need three directors , Combined holding of NRI cant be more than 49% of AUM of FPI so u need to bring 51% of investment from foreigner, total running expense of a FPI is around 50K USD not including office and salary expense. yearly ,
I think I'm blessed because if not I wouldn't have met someone as spectacular as expect penny Pennington, I think she is the best broker I have ever seen
Intention prevails over legality. Even though each of the activities seems to be legal, if anybody proves that your intention is to avoid taxes, you will be caught.
SIR THANKS A LOT FOR YOUR MOTIVATION WILL YOU PLEASE UPDATE ABOUT HCC I AM HOLDING SHARES IN HCC I WAS THINKING TO EXIT BUT AFTER UR INFORMATION I WANT TO HOLD THANKS A LOT AGAIN
If a person buys property in Dubai and he gets residential visa for 12 years afterwards he can stay in India and does he can trade forex market from India
suddenly youtube decides to recommend this video now after 1year 👀
RUclips also knows what nirmala tai did recently and wants you not to suffer :D
true
Yeah same thing even I’m wondering 😂
i got this after 2 year
Who is here after the budget 😂😂
😂😂
😂😂😂
❤
🎉
😂
😅😅😅😅😅
Super Secret Strategy revealed by Mr. PRS.
There is a beautiful quote.
" it doesn't matter how you earn it's how much u save"
You sounded very honesty and realiable
while being dishonest to the country that gave you so much.
@@Yakridu_Anna the country gave but now it's being ruled by evil politicians
@@Yakridu_Anna😂😂
Finance Minister too is listening to you Mr. Sundar! She will plug all this in her next budget.
😂😂😂
When everybody know the loopholes, it's not going to remain same anymore 😎😎
I run a small ecommerce store in USA from India . I slept on the idea of moving my business to Dubai. I could have access to much better payment processors, credit, and ofcourse no tax. I am gonna move my business to Dubai after USA holiday season is over. Running international business from India makes it almost impossible for small ecom entrepreneurs to compete with Chinese or any first world counterparts. Taxes are one thing but it's ok. access to credit, availability of various resources is killer
First of all, taking about fairness, you are not doing fair with American by earning in USD and spending in INR. Because of difference in currency you are benefiting. This is CHEATING.
Run your business in India! It will do well. If not, change something. Chinese export a ton of things. You can also try that. But don't come out and complain to others that its so tough to run a business from India in USA. Its already a miracle that it can be done!
what do u mean by access to credit ?
(noob here)
Hi how is it going I am thinking of the same. Moving my software business to Dubai. Any recommendations
Law is skewed towards the advantages of super rich. The Indian earning class is destined to pay taxes of 60% of their earnings.( IT plus, various taxes on your purchase means you end up paying more than 60% of your earnings as taxes).
Better to shift to Business Class, even a small step today will lead to larger growth in future.
A car real price is half of it.
Not just the law, it's the nature of the society and that's how the economy works. Buy a small packet of maggy, it'll cost More per unit vs a big packet. Buy it in a mall in south Bombay, the big packet will have some discount, now imagin some nobody buying the small packet in a poor village in india.
Same with money, you've less money you get less interest. Everything is like that.
Yes true
I am about to pay 40 lac rupees in taxes this year and that is just outrageous that I have to pay that much on just 1.3 cr income. that's literally 37% taxes I have to pay. I am gonna use Dubai to reduce my taxes.
YOU LEARNED THESE THINGS DURING YOUR RECENT VIST TO DUBAI. THERE ARE MANY INVESTORS. I WAS THERE FOR 20 YRS IN DUBAI
What do u want to say after living in dubai for 20 yrs
if indian government reduces taxes to 10 - 15 % then every citizen will be happy to pay taxes
The really rich never pay taxes in capitalist countries. They get loans, loan waivers and reduction in corporate taxes. Thats how India has become capitalists and abandoned socialism after Rajiv got assasinated
Definitely that will be golden period of India. Because so many people will give their taxes, not only traders but also small busines men
Capital gain is taxed at 10, 15 & 20 percent where Derivatives trading taxed at normal slab rate as it 8s business income
@@chirkuttrader2898 What about transactions tax, whether you have profit or not? How many thousands of crores government earns through that to waive off loans?
5 % at max.
Yes i am in india and i just pay 50% of my portforlio earnings, market crashes. yet it has not bottomed, It has no business at this level in the first place, pumped up by the Fed and central banks around the world. You can still be 100% invested at this level. Good luck! I prefer to sell the bounce and keep 50% cash. I will not get back into the market more than 50% if S&P is not 30% lower from here. I trade and make quick profits. With this inflation and my expectation on the economy, I am ok with 70% cash. I don’t short the market. Just keep selling the bounce!
describe an unknown factor that hasn't made the RUclips headlines widely yet
I am sitting on cash. I sold my stocks but the best part about this sell-off i have been mostly right, the worst part about it is that i don’t short anymore so I’m not making so much money but at least i will get to buy twice the stock with the same USD amount.
@@monicamoore4329 It's been a terrific experience, I actually made my first ever 6figure profit of about 28 BTC in 5 months and I'm getting more active and knowledgeable in the market.
how did you achieve that?
I outlined a decent sum and I generally stay contributed, with the assistance of a counselor "Lisa Michelle Pacillas" she assisted me with accomplishing this level, basically look her name up on the web
After all stt and other charges, Govt should consider reducing taxes on stock market earnings, atleast for small profits upto 2 lacs for a year
If your income is less than in a FY is 2.5 lakhs or even less than 10 lakhs you're not forced to pay taxes... Book an appointment with any good or average consultant. They will guide you...
@@the.candlelight_2094 thats if his total income under heads is below 2.5 lakhs
Under section 112A u can get threshold limit 1 lakhs capital gain profit
It's not applicable on trading income
I think there is an basic exemption of 2.5 lac rs 🤔
You are Indian at heart, stay happily in Chennai and give up all this jugglery Mr Sundar, enjoy the remainder of your life.
That is why He prefers to stay out.
As per section 4 of Income tax act, 1961.. tax is levied onincome of a person of indian origin and as per case law it has been decided that any income which is generated in india.. like fno from Indian stock companies (even nifty and bank nifty is composed of Indian stocks only), then tax is required to be paid by the person.. and residency won't matter here because generation of income is from Indian companies only. Thanks 🙏
Not true.
DTAA and STCG
The DTAA between India and the UAE is designed to prevent double taxation and ensure that the same income is not taxed twice in both countries.
STCG on Indian Securities: Capital gains from the sale of shares, mutual funds, or other securities in India are typically taxed in India where the income is sourced. The DTAA usually does not provide a specific exemption for STCG derived from transactions in Indian securities.
Taxation in India: Even if you have a TRC, STCG from equity trading in India is taxed at a flat rate of 15% under Section 111A of the Indian Income Tax Act if the securities transaction tax (STT) is paid.
Feels like this video is specifically for peeps above 5cr netwrth
more ser
Very simple and wise man
citing the first example of one family member being NRI and trading. If a person is employed in Dubai and is therefore NRI, trades in indian derivatives, will he have to pay tax as in first example.
This video had solved my biggest problem...thanks and lots of love sundar sir😊🎉
As per income tax Act, any income which is deemed to accrue or arise in India will be taxable in India, irrespective of the fact whether it is earned by resident or non resident. Income from trading in Indian markets will be taxable as per above rule.
DTAA comes into force when a person is resident of both the countries. In that case also, Income tax department applies force of attraction (FOA) Rule which acts as a tie breaker to decide which country's resident a person actually is. After the tie breaker, it is decided, how both the countries will share the taxes, if any
Not paying tax in india on Trading income through Dubai/Singapore route is not that easy as it sounds.
Did you watch the video? He addresses that at 6:00
@@manojlds I heard it right the first time. But did you hear anything about the reason at 6:00 in the entire video ? If not, then the purpose of writing 2 paras is very clear I suppose.
@@periwalvaibhav is correct. Moreover, NRIs cannot operate in Derivates or future & options etc. DTAA simply mean they will not pay double tax on the same income.
Not really, he s talking about fii or fpi, the taxation for them is different, as of now like he said isn't taxed, to attract investments.
@@anupbatra9368 lol you sure about that... have nri friends doing futures and options...
Business secrets revealed so kindly and bluntly
Thankyou sir. This is super idea.
1) How can NRi ( still Indian citizen) trade in F& O 2) Consider all teh cost of travels and staying in UAE the savings from Indian F&O Trading tax has to be HUGE! so break even is very high!
FPI AND FII are both different,
to be precise
FPI- retail foreign investors who invest on shares of businesses
FII - institutional foreign investors who invest in businesses
Getting money through trading is after great losses for years. Later after earning paying income tax and Gst from the earned white money is too tough. Whatever may be the type of trading or investing or capital gain, maximum affordable decent tax should be more than 10%.
As always after the recent budget this was really helpful
Any derivative trading via NRO account is taxable in India even for UAE NRIs. In fact there is direct TDS of around 30 percent which need to be settled via IT return filing. Request to take expert opinions before making any such move or video on subject to avoid confusions for blind followers
He is talking as FPI not NRI. Please listen carefully before commenting
@@CosmosChill7649 FPI?
Dubai is not a country, city of UAE
Amit... Tax differs if we trade from savings account or current account? Please tell ..By how much difference?
He didn't say anything contrary to this
I liked this video under 2min i didnt get much information in the 2min but the way he put the facts i simply liked it.
If you compare the cost of living in Dubai vs India, I think India is far cheaper. Also the fact that you miss out on living near your loved ones vs living alone in a foreign land. So its not that simple.
Also if u r frequent flyer need to pay huge expense on airticket, which may equal to tax. Only profitable for big taxable people whose tax in very higher side when compare to air tickets
Tax is huge here
Yes exactly, I too same feeling. We will spend other way like air ticket, oversea accommodation etc...
@@nigiyu air fare ranges 7600-22000Rs. Tax is more than that
cost of living is not that expensive in dubai
Thanks a lot . Please make one video in forex legal trading from India or legal ways not to pay tax
Sir Dubai maybe tax free but please tell that Dubai expense of living is much higher than India, for eg. Internet costs 1000 rs per month here in India and in Dubai it’s 12000 for the same package…
I live in middle of filth and pay 28%tax plus 12% gst for all products, and thrn pay 10-30%tax on any gain on investments.
Thank you for making this video, informative and useful for all NRI and NRE.
There will be many who will troll but don't mind ,as many doens't know how much money NRI and NRE bring back as value addition to Indian Economy.
Dubai is not cheap, it may be viewed as relatively cost effective compared to Singapore.
Bahrain is cheaper than Dubai
Thank you for the information... No one sharing this kind of information.. Thank you again sir 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Wrong information. Double taxation treaty means that the tax paid in India will not be double taxed in country where you are tax resident. That means I produce certificate that I have paid tax in India to Dubai and donot get taxed in Dubai. Since no tax in Dubai, it doesnot matter. Any income in India is to be taxed in India. This is the basic rule.
6:15 Reason why Chartered Accountant sy like that is because of the Concept of DEEMED RESIDENCY.
love you sir , Im 23 and I am an NRI, you have indeed made me a better investor. take care
I think a critical point you missed is that in order to be registered as an FPI with SEBI, the fund must have at least USD 30 million in assets under management (AUM). Please correct me if i am wrong.
You’re missing the point, your not listing an investment fund or ETF. If you have USD 300 you can register yourself as an individual as foreign portfolio investor.
Yes your right
just querious, have do done it? @@scott701230
Taxation in india is totally messed up. Govt throwing blind eye on it.
You are mistaken, even if you are a NRI living in uae or Saudi Arabia, any income earned in India is subject to tax and of course if you have yearly earnings inside India lower than 1 lac you don’t have to file tax usually (except if your trading turnover is above a certain limit). For NRIs in Middle East, the income earned in Middle East isn’t taxable but their Indian income is still subject to tax.
You are correct
And if you watched the video hes referreing to being an fpi or fii, Indian govt has no taxes for them.
Hes not talking about nri
he said you need to Open An Nri Account for the Broker of India to Trade in india so Officially we are considering as nri Is trading and He has Uae Trc Certificate so He submitted His Certificate to ITD for Filling The Tax Bcz the Dtt Has Been Signed from indian government with Uae Government So We Will Pay Taxes in Uae That Is Living Cost or Vat Only 👍
after reading many comments, I understand that people didnt get you. he is saying become a FPI and then trade in FnO thats tax free in india for FPIs. but for NRIs any income accrued in India , its taxable in india. I was an NRI for few years and I was in Dubai only so,, i am pretty sure about it.
watching this video with 1 lakh capital
😂😂
2 lakh😅
So are we 😂
More than enough.
Never underestimate the power of 1 lakh capital ; ]
20k🌚
Derivatives income is business income so you can use yours expenses as business expenses
Thank for this information, i was searching for it 🙏🙏🙏
If SEBI is really worried for Small investors than stop Sebi fees to Small investors and requested all members to oppose Sebi Consultation paper proposal on SEBI portal
A lot of development that is happening in our country is because of taxes been paid by honest citizens. However the percentage of people paying taxes is still very low. Our government is doing a lot to encourage people to pay taxes which helps in building defense, infrastructure, healthcare and education. Middleclass people do not mind paying taxes nor do the large corporate houses that has made India its primary location. Yes, there are some UHNI's & HNI's with short term interest who think otherwise. It is believed that only 10% of traders make money and which is BIG MONEY and we should encourage them to contribute to nation building. Mr. Sunder, you have a big following in this segments mostly youngsters and budding traders who appreciate your accomplishments and daily views. I have seen many successful people who have built some competencies often tend loose a lot when they get into areas which is not very clear. I think we should promote India and not Dubai even for a fee.
The really rich never pay taxes in capitalist countries. They get loans, loan waivers and reduction in corporate taxes. Thats how India has become capitalists and abandoned socialism after Rajiv got assasinated
It's a myth tht few people pay taxes. There is GST tax and other taxes on products. This is also tax 18%.
We pay tax (income & GST) to build road. Then more tax to keep the road clean & then toll tax for maintenance of the road. We keep on paying taxes and in the end we don't even proper road. There should be a limit to tax.
Many farmers earn in millions and they are exempted from tax. Businesses man avoid tax with the help of CA. Only middle class suffers.
Thank you for detailed knowledge about Dubai based trading
thank you sir for this, no point paying taxes to this nation. it acts to our own detriment, better to look out for ourself and that's it.
Then leave the country & spare us from your ridiculous thoughts....
I think you are talking about your Al Kherala, not India.
Better shift to Canada or Germany i would say.I would be taking permanent residency in Canada soon and leave the Indian passport .Much better return and benefits of taxes being paid in Canada or UK.Hope you do well.
@@jamesvaidyan81 nope Entire India
@@mortalgod_1210 weird that atleast 13 people seem on board with my thoughts
Bahrain Dinar is also pegged against US dollar
As a matured and reputed trader, he should encourage people to pay tax on profits.
Never educate people as how to avoid taxes.
You don't want to pay taxes but expect govt to announce new schemes. And increase in GDP every quarter. 😊
tax is basically theft.peope are making money and stupid govt wants all the money.govt salary,judges,police,ias all paid by hardworking taxpayers.
Modi is f**king people by increasing tax so what’s wrong in f**king midi by avoiding tax
Are you kidding me ?. it is very necessary to educate people to avoid taxes, 80% of Indian population is middle class & provide a hell load of tax. But what happens with that tax , new parliament construction ?, ram mandir construction ?.
What about opportunities, quality of life ?. Govt. already knows that these are the ways to evade taxation but still they help their HNI friends to do so. Because some of them provide a huge amount to party funds.
@@SPARSHKUMAR-f4hIdiot andhnamazi we have paid for ram mandir not government correct your fact don't point out on our temples we have contributed for it .Tax is going in pocket of all political parties leaders and mlas .
@@SPARSHKUMAR-f4h You ignorant fools, Ram mandir was NOT built with Tax money.
Sir you are a fun person.
I really enjoyed your video 😄
If we make money by trading, we don’t mind paying taxes 😅
I mean it goes upto 42 % right, that's too much tax right
@@yashpandirkar4814 make a business account
@@091-b8j then it's less tax ?
@@gopiadmink8055 yes I agree
Start a startup with trading profit. Can claim exemption. Just saying.
Is that TEEKA on "Wall Street Bull"'s head on the table?
I know many white middle class Europeans who want to stay in India permanently and get Indian Citizenship.
What a world
did you ask them why?
@@kamranwasifify Yes, They are saying Europe is getting expensive.
Pension is not sufficient for aged.
Property is not affordable.
Too much Alchohol and Drugs.
Illegal immigration.
Rents are expensive.
If they get the same money what they are earning, they can easily live in Asian countries.
Thailand and many countries is promoting them.
Young Digital Nomads are more interested in Asian countries including India.
India is not issuing a long term solution for them.
Saw a post from famous Finance RUclipsr Akshat Srivastava regarding the same issue which I posted couple of days back
😂😂 nobody wants to live in India
You are delusional.
@@helium740🤣🤣🤣
Where did you got this information from??
Literally every European countries have way better living standards and safety than India.
It's true that some Europeans go to south east Asian countries but nobody is coming to India.
Dear sir, being a genius, you should suggest tax structure to government, that will keep Indian money in India.
Indian sons, the soldiers, sacrifice their life for India. Can't we do this much for India?
Modiji is working tirelessly for 1.4 billion people. Can't we do just 1% of that effort?
Jai Hind!
Dear Sir , Please suggest where to get informations like fed meeting calendar , US job data , Auto sales data ? Companies quarterly annual results calendar ?? where to get all those datas ? Any particular website or list of websites ???
Forexfactory
I am about to pay 40 lac rupees in taxes this year and that is just outrageous that I have to pay that much on just 1.3 cr income. that's literally 37% taxes I have to pay. I am gonna use Dubai to reduce my taxes.
Really
bruv what'dya do for living?
@@hackrogaming5913zhut bol raha h
Sir, admire your work, wish to learn more from you
I would never ever evade tax. As a patriotic citizen of this great country called India I feel it's my primary duty and responsibility to pay tax and adhere to the law of this land. I would happily pay my taxes and contribute to the growth and development of our economy and people, share a large chunk of my fortunes to people who are in need... Involve in philanthropic activities and causes I believe in ...
After all all that I have I now is given to over to me by this country..
Would love to identify myself as a law abiding citizen of this country...
A 360 degree growth includes our value system too...
My respect for you grew manifolds when you said you will offer consulting and services only if its legal.. great sir...
40% to 50% tax is very huge bro
I earn 10cr but my final earnings is just 5cr. That is heart braking my brother.
@@sayedallabakash756 true brother jo loag tax nahi bharte wo kya jane ki aapka 50% earning le le jyadatar toh loag toh tax bharte nahi mai toh trader hun soch raha hun uae settled ho jaun
@@godisfake6865that too for a developing country where 98% citizens doesn't pay income tax
Thank you Mr. PRS.
Dear sundar sir Golden visa is given for a investment of 2 million on property or land but not given when you take with a loan.
50% bank loan is permitted
Famous shops here in my place don’t accept UPI , they receive only cash , very less tax they pay 😂
Sundar sir revealing all the information of FIIS...and HNIS
I think F&O is not allowed for NRIs, I also have NRO account but Zerodha doesn’t allow me to enable F&O segments.
I’m a CA student. As per IT Act if a Non Resident making any income from India as TRADING relevant here, it is deemed to accrue or arise in india so even though he is NRI he still layable to pay tax on that trading income.
but how will he pay tax if he is selling you from different country. The only party paying tax will be importer as import tax.
What about stay period?
Yes, exactly right. Being an NRI doesn't help you avoid Indian trading taxes or Indian capital gains on Indian traded stocks/options/futures.
@@SA-lz1vx stay doesnt matter it’s income arised in india so he is payable to pay tax.
I suspect he means that though it's taxable , we will get relief based on the double taxation tresty
If one person in family is NRI (in Dubai), how can entire family's income be transfered to his ac and let him invest as tax free income? This is illegal. It's treated as business trx.
I think people forget the cost of living in Dubai. Setting up is easy, maintaining and complying with all requirements will cost a bit. If you're an HNWI, it shouldn't be a problem, you'll have a good lifestyle in Dubai. But if you're planning to incorporate there for the purpose of trading, be ready for the introduction of corporate tax in Dubai next year. Not as much as India at 25-30%, maybe around 9% or 10% - still better. But is it really worth it?
1. How much net worth or cashflow makes them HNWI?
2. If you pay yourself entire profit of company as director salary, your company technically pays 0 tax.
goto freezone and register your company make money dont pay corporate tax because your company is not mainland company and not doing any buisness with uae people so you dont pay.
How do you bring that money to india ?
@@drpradeepbhandari854 by transfer, to nre or nro account...it's simple
Lol u living in 2018, dubai has introduced it at 9percent flat if you make business profits above 350k dhs per aanum...and besides dubai is more business friendly, and the ease of doing one is much more easier with no hassles.
Interesting.....
Thank you for sharing.....
When i was NRI in Europe icici Bank blocked my demat account saying. NRI can't trade..... Your statement is contradictory. Please answer
U have to change it to nro account and broker
Hi sir.. what about ur benz?? who is driving it now??
As a banker I do not agree that small people are harassed and big people not after taking loan from bank. This is totally wrong. Small people r only beneficiary of loan waiver schemes ,not the big. When big people fail to pay there are very steps fr recovery , bank going to court , NCLT , SARFESI rules are used. 2-3 persons may hv run out of the country but then all their assets are attached.
can u make a video abt 0 tax and free tax??
Thanks for this video. Can you please update this video as of today? Are there any complications? Also please mention with some examples with a profit of 1cr profits from US stocks through indian apps.
Title should have been "Bharath Mata ki......Bye!!"
This is a story about a man living in a joint family. He along other earning members of the family, is expected to contribute to his family. Our man finds that giving money to the family is not worth it, so lets himself move to his neighbour's house, who allows this man to stay in his place without any contributions.
After that, our man's rest of the family members lived happily ever after!.
Q1, We are paying taxes from our profits only, right?
Q2, Also what about the other expenditure
Q3, Travelling to Dubai back to India, and other expenditures incurred in this process, all combined, does it really offset the tax?
Q4, After all this , if you make losses in the stock market, then ?
Q5, There must be some benefit for UAE, what is the hidden agenda?
Please love thy country!
I wonder why one would let emotional attachment to motherland hijack and kill all other virtues to live less financially prosperous than otherwise.
@@portraitofmadhu when one has emotional attachment to money, attachment to motherland cannot be too bad
@@pkbul10 😂that's what they want you to subscribe to. Anyhow, good for you, bro ❤️🤝🏻
@@portraitofmadhu dear, Who are "they" ? Next some one would offer you a tax waiver, if you converted to their releigion, Would you take that too. ?
@@pkbul10 bro, there is life beyond nationalism and religious. My heart goes out to you.
Sir please, Dubai is not a country… It’s one of the emirate of UNITED ARAB EMIRATES.
Hello Sir,
I have one question i am working in IT I am an employee of MNCs in India. can I move to Dubai and save tax
Yes, you can apply for digital nomad and it is valid for 1 year.
Sir, you mentioned you'd not spent more than Rs. 700 on the shirt as you dont prefer branded items. Then why did you spend crores of Rs. On Rolls Royce, even Corolla could serve the purpose. Please clarify. It will help me understand your mindset.
SIR,you are a gentleman ,why you have think of evading taxes.Not required,infact you donate 25% of your profit to Tamilanadu Govt.When we get good money in derivative market,what is the problem in paying IT.
good video.
He explains all the illegal issues.
But it is a wrong to say that low class doesnt pay tax. Even when you buy even simple vegetables-you pay for the transport charges-petrol-govt tax. When you buy a simple soap-sales tax-you pay
He is talking about income tax.
Every thing is taxed and everyone pays taxes but not everyone pays income tax. Atleast 50 percent of the tax income comes from indirect tax.
how i can trade in option and future in foregion market because our sebi is not giving margin .hence i want to move
Become an NRI
Making money is an action. Keeping money is behavior. Growing money is knowledge. Secure your future through investing!
I invest with her too, i make about a 15,000USD every month.
Same here, a Transformations of £4000 to a £15,400 in just 2 weeks, She's the really best
@MaryLinda
Oh please guys, is there any way I can reach out to Mrs Heather Doreen , this sounds so helpful and I would love to be guided well
Same i here, i will praise mrs heather over and over again because she has great skills, i started with $2000 and after 2week i received a returns of $6,000 then i continue with her ever since she has been delivering
point to be noted your honor..(11.06)..this is what Adani company doing ...its not legal.
So basically govt is facilitating HNIs to shift from India and don't pay taxes, and SQUEEZE all the lower, middle and upper middle class! Not fair at all! Thanks Anna for opening our eyes! 🙏
No it's not like that, pls understand super rich still don't want to stay in tax heaven (carbean islands or gulf countries like dubai etc) as their school ,colleges, Childern education, democratic rights, freedom, economic etc of those countries still under not at par with Europe/developed countries and they don't want to stay in those countries with their families.
India is doing no wrong, taxation laws of any country depends upon economic condition of that country and as per mutually signed treaties of that country with other countries
Indian government itself helping foreigners ( and brahmin bania parsi corporates ) to screw the country
There is no such thing as a good tax, govt policies do punish everyone, its only the rich who have the means to circumvent this, indians are losing out due to this
@@strongpp240 and its the other way round, the economic condtion of the country depends on the policies of the country, especially taxes.
those who are thinking to move dubai
1bed room 4x8ft will cost you 20-30k thats 2.5-3.5L per year + food, travel and other expenses thats 4-6L per year😂
move only if you are earning 1cr+
Sir please show correct Map of INDIA on Thumbnail
That's actually correct map . POK not in our control
@@sagarkoyya but it will start controvercy
Updating.
@@krunalraghavani4500 got it
Don't know the obsession of Indians with map
super sir, you are great. thank you for your videos and information, god bless you
I earn money to spend with family and friends, what I do with lot of money without them, instead of paying flight charges and other expenses i am ready to pay taxes to India 🇮🇳
But how can a non resident who has made income in India avoid paying tax to Indian govt. Taxation rate is applicable even to non resident
Things which he didn't mention about , currency exchange risk , u need administrator for FPI which is very costly , you need indian custodian , you need to incorporate FPI in foreign countries like Mauritius, singapore where they have tax treaty with government of India , need three directors , Combined holding of NRI cant be more than 49% of AUM of FPI so u need to bring 51% of investment from foreigner, total running expense of a FPI is around 50K USD not including office and salary expense. yearly ,
very good information sir thank you
I'm done sitting tight for the award advance since i acquire $23,000 every 12 days of my investment.
How I would really appreciate if you show me how to go about it. Please can you list the platforms?
I heard a lot of investing with Mrs Penny Pennington and how good she is, please how safe are the profit?
Same here I earn $13,000 a week. God bless Mrs Penny Pennington, she has been a blessing to my family.
I started with just 4,000 dollars now am earning upto 17,000 dollars weekly
I think I'm blessed because if not I wouldn't have met someone as spectacular as expect penny Pennington, I think she is the best broker I have ever seen
Intention prevails over legality. Even though each of the activities seems to be legal, if anybody proves that your intention is to avoid taxes, you will be caught.
SIR THANKS A LOT FOR YOUR MOTIVATION WILL YOU PLEASE UPDATE ABOUT HCC I AM HOLDING SHARES IN HCC I WAS THINKING TO EXIT BUT AFTER UR INFORMATION I WANT TO HOLD THANKS A LOT AGAIN
Saudi Riyal is also pegged to US dollars.
The video I searched for months is now here 🔥🔥🔥🔥 thanks sir
probably the author is wrong. He must verify about the FPI derivate income not taxable
If a person buys property in Dubai and he gets residential visa for 12 years afterwards he can stay in India and does he can trade forex market from India
No
Dubai is one of 7 states of the country, United Arab Emirates (UAE). Please always refer UAE as the country. We do not refer Chennai as a country..
What happens if dubai govt decides to tax ? Or what happens if Indian govt exempts double taxation to dubai or Singapore ?
Adanis younger brother is dubai resident!! Part Owner of ALL Adani companies!