Some singers fail sometimes. But it's important that we don't let their vocal mistakes define who they are as a singer and performer. Lots of people do that. So please in these comments don't attack other singers.
About alicia, she really had vocal damage, unfortunately, because her voice is beautiful, it is remarkable that she really suffered damage mainly between 2008,2009
She was also not very good in her recent NYE Special performance that she recorded (was on the BBC). Kept dodging high notes and the high notes she did try sounded very flat and forced and throaty. I like her music, but ended up changing the channel, because it was not enjoyable to listen to so many flat notes. Such a shame. She used to be so good.
Love the WTF vids! All singers have their moments and they’re still good. Sometimes WFT just happens and it’s good to learn of causes and fixes.💖 Please, do more Live Reactions!!😄
Of course I believe Alicia has vocal damage, but in the case of that performance, it’s just part of the song lol. It’s very intentional and purposeful. The song “Illusion of Bliss” is incredibly emotional and beautiful ❤️
The vocal shown here of Alicia Keys ‘Illusion of Bliss’ is completely intentional. It’s like that in every performance of the song and even on the album recording. It’s part of the emotional climax of the song! Sometimes we have to know the context.
Y’all need to stop lying because she does not sounds that bad on the record as she does here. I hear it and there’s a difference between vocal breaks done like Sia and vocal cracks like this. No hate to Alicia though. Love her
@@benjaminbrown682 what?? Where’s the lie??? It sounds more raw in the live but I mean.. that’s to expected of a live performance. Whether you like the sound or not is another thing. Personally, I think she sounds fine. I know that’s the sound she was going for. And obviously a sound like that isn’t going to be very controlled anyways. I wouldn’t expect her to be able to reproduce it the exact way she did it for the studio version.
Celine’s clip was bad because that performance was right after her husband died. And when she sang All By Myself, she got very emotional. That’s why her clip wasn’t very good.
Thank you, I liked the format. A minor suggestion: if you could put the name of the singer/group at the bottom of the screen it would help those of us who may not be as familiar with them all 🙂
Hi Georgina, this is unrelated to the video but I find you so adorable and entertaining to watch! I am also passionate about singing and learning to be better so your channel is a win win for me! 🤍
Possible suggestion is tell who the artist is prior to each clip. I know it's obvious to most but it took me a few seconds to determine who it actually is. Love these types of reaction videos keep them coming. Also, I honestly didn't even hear where Celine Dion messed up in her clip. I'll leave it to the professionals :)
Probably, that All By Myself live was in 2016, after her husband passed away, she wasn't good mentally and it affected her voice, but she held on to do her best
Jessica Simpson may have "pulled it off" in the sense that she successfully landed the notes in terms of hitting and sustaining the right pitch, but her placement was absolutely appalling and damaging. That wasn't intentional distortion, that was just strain from really really poor laryngeal placement.
Yeah and I think that's why she didn't use that part of her voice in the music she put out with the book last year, studio was never a problem but live I feel she's always been able to pull it off because of her pitch and sustainment. I couldn't articulate it myself but I so agree
@@ismaelm.mbaangue9147 listen to the audio version of the song. It has the exact same scream. It's like a "cry for help" since the song is about alcoholism.
Demi's first clip : She was unhealthy the entire half of the year(2014). She dodged this A5 intended note most of the days but this particular day she thought she could do it but miserably couldn't. People thought she permanently lost her voice. (Nevertheless hatsoff she never chose to lipsync) Demi's second clip: She was nervous the entire time. She wasn't singing the entire song properly. And yeah, she can't do that note live even on a good day. No idea about 2021 Demi
she was very nervous because of singing it live with her idol Christina. In other performances, she harmonized it. And now she’s even able to hit that note live ok other songs...
It's one of the things that makes me laugh the most, singers who sing out of tune, who miss a note, a riff. I sing out of tune so I don't laugh (a little anyway), I laugh and it feels good thank you Honest🤣
Not being mean to Demi in any way, but why have a big belt/note in the song when can’t sing it live. I know adrenaline or sick but it’s sometimes frustrating when you watch a live performance and a singer keeps dodging high notes because they don’t want to sing it. I understand if they are unwell or they have sang the song for years but then don’t sing it live.
Demi has very little artistic personality and think way too much of her abilities. It"s time to stop playing the Aguilera understudy and start working with what you've got.
@@HonestVocalCoach in the studio you can do so many takes off one note but not live. I really like Demi but she sometimes over pushes if she’s singing with another singer like Christina trying to maybe out do each other or be better.
I guess some singers dont think too much about singing live. They probably want to create a masterpiece in the studio despite knowing that it won’t be sung again.
Haha! That was a lot of fun! It's always good to hear a balanced objective view from you instead of biased stans view who are subjective and can't see any flaws. Cheryl, Lana and Alicia are hysterically bad in these clips.
Tongue root tension is at the root of almost all of my vocal fails. I have awful anxiety and I can't work out how to fix it 😩 starting out as a live vocalist and the nerves are not being kind to me.
Very random but I feel no one ever asks RUclipsrs this but how are you? Hope you are well. I feel with the vast stress in the world at the minute we all deserve to be asked how we are. 😊 Great video by the way. Entertaining for sure.
@@HonestVocalCoach Of course. Got to try and make the most of it too. As you said, positively isnt too easy to grasp during these situations. Well I'm glad you are okay.
I discovered your channel not long ago and i absolutely LOVE how you analyze vocals techniques! If you could react to "BTS HIGH NOTES & FALSETTOS COMPILATION" on the channel smile hoya, I am very interested in what thought you have on their techniques and their vocal range :) Lots of love, bye!
In the clip with Demi and Christina doing Fall in Line. Apparently, I read and heard that Demi was touring at the same time as well being unwell also. She was really tired and exhausted by that performance and that's why her high note was really poorly sung.
@@tanakatotoe9484 Yes she does. I'm not saying that Demi is a bad singer. I just said that she was tired in this performance and song is sung in a higher key
Singers are human beings too. Their voices can fail at inopportune moments. I've done what Rihanna did during a live theater performance once and I REALLY paid attention to NEVER do it again. And to ALWAYS have lozenges, water, tea with honey & lemon close by. And NEVER push when it's not right. 😏
Some of them didnt do good big time! 8:45 Jessica Simpson, ive been requesting for years for you to react to her live performances or videos. Hope you can see my comment now as I notice you never reply, and hopefully in the future you can start doing like singers' eras revisions. Jessica and Christina were considered the new Mariahs back in 1999 when they came out, please do!
Poor leona first video of her was ok just a bit sharp in her notes but then second song of hers tension because she has a illness which was affecting her then. Still love leona though and love most of the other singers as well.
Mishaps for singers that sing live are gonna happen. Kelly Clarkson is amazing. I’m not a big Grande fan but she can sing. If they’re having a dry day or allergies kick in, shit’s gonna happen. Nobody is perfect 100% of the time, but if they’ve proven themselves as singers, they get a pass. Or, if they have other skills, like singer/songwriters or if they’re stellar on an instrument, they get a pass. But if you don’t sing live because you can’t, someone else writes your music and you don’t play an instrument live… then I judge very critically.
Some of these weren’t really fails, they’re just not incredible. Leona’s clips for example sounded a little bit tense but I wouldn’t say they were fails
When you had that short Taylor Swift video the other day I had just seen a video that was a perfect example of what you were saying, but I couldn't remember who it was about or find it. But I finally found it. ruclips.net/video/ylQlzG_l4t4/видео.html. Lauren Daigle. If you are unfamiliar with this artist she has a song that is a masterpiece called "You Say". Though there are two covers that I like better by groups I'm sure you've never heard of, BYU Noteworthy (an all female college A Capella group) and Gentri. You said it perfect. No one can sing every song perfect every time, it's what you do when you make a mistake that matters.
I've always felt that Leona Lewis requires a lot of vocal coaching to be able to overcome her vocal weaknesses and to become a truly GREAT singer. The potential is definitely there, but I find her overall technique to be poor. She often switches between chest voice and head voice too often and rather awkwardly. She could be up there with Mariah if she worked on her voice enough.
With the Cheryl one she was Ill & I think just worn out, she absolutely can hit those low notes & I could point you to multiple performances where she does hit those notes
Yes she has but l included it bc not many people have heard of this performance before. It was flat and sharp throughout thats why l considered it as a fail for her. lts not terrible though
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
Celines “fail” is still better than everyone
I was literally just thinking this before I saw your comment . Even when she’s off she’s still better than the vast majority at their best!
@@littlemy1773 seriously😬😭
Celine doesn’t fail. That voice box is an international treasure.
Totally! Even calling it a fail isn't right 🤷🏽♂️
''she said in an interview she can't hit that note live''
''that just proves she can't hit that note''
Georgina 2021
Some singers fail sometimes. But it's important that we don't let their vocal mistakes define who they are as a singer and performer. Lots of people do that. So please in these comments don't attack other singers.
Celine doesn't fail
Agree
@@simplypaul8681 yes she does. A lot. She's human. Don't be delusional.
@@simplypaul8681 she’s voice cracked times
No one is attacking those who fail occasionally. Fact is some just suck all the time and rely on autotune like sheryl cole.
Kinda hypocritical of Cheryl side eyeing someone who missed a note 😂
Kelly’s “fails” still sound hella amazing to me! Lol
3:31 THE WAY SHE GIGGLES I CANTTTTTT
Cheryl got "lack of skill" 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂
About alicia, she really had vocal damage, unfortunately, because her voice is beautiful, it is remarkable that she really suffered damage mainly between 2008,2009
She was also not very good in her recent NYE Special performance that she recorded (was on the BBC). Kept dodging high notes and the high notes she did try sounded very flat and forced and throaty.
I like her music, but ended up changing the channel, because it was not enjoyable to listen to so many flat notes. Such a shame. She used to be so good.
Love the WTF vids! All singers have their moments and they’re still good. Sometimes WFT just happens and it’s good to learn of causes and fixes.💖 Please, do more Live Reactions!!😄
I love when you sing "this girl is on fire" what a voice Georgina
Georgina thank you so much for reacting to my video!!! :D
You're so welcome! x
Of course I believe Alicia has vocal damage, but in the case of that performance, it’s just part of the song lol. It’s very intentional and purposeful. The song “Illusion of Bliss” is incredibly emotional and beautiful ❤️
And that's why she has vocal damage lol
Celine did it and recovered like a champ. If there is to be a mishap just think to yourself. What would Celine do?
0:42 the dark shadow moving in the corner was terrifying but all’s good, just a cat
yea it was old
i’m so high rn lol i cried when i saw the little kitten coming out of the bookshelf ❤️😭
The vocal shown here of Alicia Keys ‘Illusion of Bliss’ is completely intentional. It’s like that in every performance of the song and even on the album recording. It’s part of the emotional climax of the song! Sometimes we have to know the context.
I need to agree with you however she's overpushing in other songs. I wonder why she never changed her technique
Y’all need to stop lying because she does not sounds that bad on the record as she does here. I hear it and there’s a difference between vocal breaks done like Sia and vocal cracks like this. No hate to Alicia though. Love her
@@benjaminbrown682 Sia is the Queen of Cracks
@@benjaminbrown682 what?? Where’s the lie??? It sounds more raw in the live but I mean.. that’s to expected of a live performance. Whether you like the sound or not is another thing. Personally, I think she sounds fine. I know that’s the sound she was going for. And obviously a sound like that isn’t going to be very controlled anyways. I wouldn’t expect her to be able to reproduce it the exact way she did it for the studio version.
Alicia Keys can’t sing live period
What I really like about this video is that it shows that even superstars aren't perfect so be easy on yourself.
Celine’s clip was bad because that performance was right after her husband died. And when she sang All By Myself, she got very emotional. That’s why her clip wasn’t very good.
Actually that clip was 2015. She lost her husband in 2016.
Thank you for everything you do ❤️ I love you
Thank you, I liked the format. A minor suggestion: if you could put the name of the singer/group at the bottom of the screen it would help those of us who may not be as familiar with them all 🙂
08:35 omg!!! is she dying?! XD
8:37 Omg i cant stop laughing😂😂😂🤦♂️
😂😂😂😂
I can't-😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Great gif! Great ring tone for people who call you, that you dont want to speak with :)
I'm screaming😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂
The thing that surprised me most was the fact that you have this flawless head voice right before, then the scream out of nowhere
poor Demi 🥺
Edit: and Christina
OMG RIHANNA I- I- I- omg
That clip looks like when Christina was pregnant .
Hi Georgina, this is unrelated to the video but I find you so adorable and entertaining to watch! I am also passionate about singing and learning to be better so your channel is a win win for me! 🤍
They all had me screaming 🤣😂😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣 Alicia had me rolling 8:37 my stomach hurts 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣
Possible suggestion is tell who the artist is prior to each clip. I know it's obvious to most but it took me a few seconds to determine who it actually is. Love these types of reaction videos keep them coming. Also, I honestly didn't even hear where Celine Dion messed up in her clip. I'll leave it to the professionals :)
Probably, that All By Myself live was in 2016, after her husband passed away, she wasn't good mentally and it affected her voice, but she held on to do her best
🏆I second that tip!!!
Jessica Simpson may have "pulled it off" in the sense that she successfully landed the notes in terms of hitting and sustaining the right pitch, but her placement was absolutely appalling and damaging. That wasn't intentional distortion, that was just strain from really really poor laryngeal placement.
Georgina missed Björk !!!! She does the same as Jessica AND many others, She Is unpleasent to listen too !!!!!
Yeah and I think that's why she didn't use that part of her voice in the music she put out with the book last year, studio was never a problem but live I feel she's always been able to pull it off because of her pitch and sustainment. I couldn't articulate it myself but I so agree
Yes and she was really nasal too
8:18 that’s literally just part of the song. I don’t know why people don’t know that. Literal listen to the song Illusion of Bliss
Doesn’t change the fact that it’s not good for the voice.
Alicia’s clip wasn’t a fail. That was intentional, she does that on the studio version too
And that's the reason why she has vocal damage now
Is clearly a fail and a big note strained and cracked
@@ismaelm.mbaangue9147 listen to the audio version of the song. It has the exact same scream. It's like a "cry for help" since the song is about alcoholism.
At 8:38 I couldn’t help but burst out laughing if that was me I would never surface myself to the outside world again💀😭
Demi's first clip : She was unhealthy the entire half of the year(2014). She dodged this A5 intended note most of the days but this particular day she thought she could do it but miserably couldn't. People thought she permanently lost her voice. (Nevertheless hatsoff she never chose to lipsync)
Demi's second clip: She was nervous the entire time. She wasn't singing the entire song properly. And yeah, she can't do that note live even on a good day. No idea about 2021 Demi
i was looking for this comment 🙌🙌🙌🙌 demi 2021 will deffo be able to do it !!
I'm a fan of your videos.
I'm amazed you haven't covered some of Tina's Turner's live performances as she has a very unique voice.
0:54 | This cats wants definetly attention
i really love this kind of series,u should do more
I'm howling at 8:39 it's the noise I make when I stand on a plug 😂😂😂😂
Wish you had named each in the clips , probably heard of them but didn’t recognise most !
I don’t understand why Demi didn’t harmonize that note instead of trying to hit it when she knows she can’t live.
she was very nervous because of singing it live with her idol Christina. In other performances, she harmonized it. And now she’s even able to hit that note live ok other songs...
Me neither. Guess she'd rather just chance it
It's one of the things that makes me laugh the most, singers who sing out of tune, who miss a note, a riff. I sing out of tune so I don't laugh (a little anyway), I laugh and it feels good thank you Honest🤣
2:09 demi was on tour thats why she sounds tired
Thanks for letting me know. X
The Leona one was pushy, I'm surprised you didn't notice it, never the less she's an amazing singer
Not being mean to Demi in any way, but why have a big belt/note in the song when can’t sing it live. I know adrenaline or sick but it’s sometimes frustrating when you watch a live performance and a singer keeps dodging high notes because they don’t want to sing it. I understand if they are unwell or they have sang the song for years but then don’t sing it live.
Demi has very little artistic personality and think way too much of her abilities. It"s time to stop playing the Aguilera understudy and start working with what you've got.
I would never do something in the studio I couldn't replicate live. I am not sure why she chose to that x
@@HonestVocalCoach in the studio you can do so many takes off one note but not live. I really like Demi but she sometimes over pushes if she’s singing with another singer like Christina trying to maybe out do each other or be better.
i think The obvious answer is because she thinks it sound cool and wanted to show off I guess not saying it's a good reason
I guess some singers dont think too much about singing live. They probably want to create a masterpiece in the studio despite knowing that it won’t be sung again.
Whether Alicia’s was intentional or not it sounded like she was falling off a building.
If I recall I think Kelly started singing the national anthem in the wrong key. Like to low and then she did that weird thing at the end
That’s exactly what it was
The singer of Amazing Grace is my top favorite for this week!!
Haha! That was a lot of fun! It's always good to hear a balanced objective view from you instead of biased stans view who are subjective and can't see any flaws. Cheryl, Lana and Alicia are hysterically bad in these clips.
Thank you. It’s my honest opinion, as all my videos are. Thanks for watching!!
Thank you for your time and effort making these vids, your knowledge and commentary! I love the analysis!
The Sarah Harding bum note made my dog growl :)
Tongue root tension is at the root of almost all of my vocal fails. I have awful anxiety and I can't work out how to fix it 😩 starting out as a live vocalist and the nerves are not being kind to me.
8:46 every time i see this i die laughing omg it’s sad tho jessica would sound so good if she was forcing her voice to sound more powerful
That Alicia Keys moment was very very cringy for me at 8:33 and I made the same face as u Georgina 😖😣
Very random but I feel no one ever asks RUclipsrs this but how are you? Hope you are well. I feel with the vast stress in the world at the minute we all deserve to be asked how we are. 😊 Great video by the way. Entertaining for sure.
I’m good thank you. Taking things a day at a time.
@@HonestVocalCoach Of course. Got to try and make the most of it too. As you said, positively isnt too easy to grasp during these situations. Well I'm glad you are okay.
I discovered your channel not long ago and i absolutely LOVE how you analyze vocals techniques! If you could react to "BTS HIGH NOTES & FALSETTOS COMPILATION" on the channel smile hoya, I am very interested in what thought you have on their techniques and their vocal range :) Lots of love, bye!
In the clip with Demi and Christina doing Fall in Line. Apparently, I read and heard that Demi was touring at the same time as well being unwell also. She was really tired and exhausted by that performance and that's why her high note was really poorly sung.
The song itself is very difficult as well. She has to belt the whole chorus tbh.
@@tanakatotoe9484 Yes she does. I'm not saying that Demi is a bad singer. I just said that she was tired in this performance and song is sung in a higher key
Georgina you are amazing 😂
Singers are human beings too. Their voices can fail at inopportune moments. I've done what Rihanna did during a live theater performance once and I REALLY paid attention to NEVER do it again. And to ALWAYS have lozenges, water, tea with honey & lemon close by. And NEVER push when it's not right. 😏
I love these videos
Well, singers are humans too, so we all have bad days, it just depends on you if you still have the guts to sing even you're not in condition.
Some of them didnt do good big time!
8:45 Jessica Simpson, ive been requesting for years for you to react to her live performances or videos. Hope you can see my comment now as I notice you never reply, and hopefully in the future you can start doing like singers' eras revisions. Jessica and Christina were considered the new Mariahs back in 1999 when they came out, please do!
Revisions in a cronological order I meant😅
I think "Out ouf tune" could be create by the mixed sound in the ears. Is that right ?
Love the cat ;) Had to go back because the cat stole my heart
Alicia Keyes seemed like she was trying a Wilhelm Scream. I thought Celine Dion still sounded pretty good
i LOVE this kinds of videos,
What’s the song called that Ariana grande is signing?
I Believe and You and Me - Whitney Houston
4:11 whats the song and singer name?
Keep staying positive 👍🏽👍🏽
I really think Jessica did a good job
NAH BUT YOUR CAT MADE ME ALMOST JUMP😭
Poor leona first video of her was ok just a bit sharp in her notes but then second song of hers tension because she has a illness which was affecting her then. Still love leona though and love most of the other singers as well.
Alicia Keys has an awesome voice,one of the best ever,but yeah,this was....wow 😥😂
Alicia Keys is the best 8:37
I'm in my own Band at school
Idk why Leona went with that particular Sam Smith song, when there are so many that would have fitted her voice better.
Distortion was not the issue with the Jessica Simpson clip.
So distracted by the cat lol
Mishaps for singers that sing live are gonna happen. Kelly Clarkson is amazing. I’m not a big Grande fan but she can sing. If they’re having a dry day or allergies kick in, shit’s gonna happen. Nobody is perfect 100% of the time, but if they’ve proven themselves as singers, they get a pass. Or, if they have other skills, like singer/songwriters or if they’re stellar on an instrument, they get a pass. But if you don’t sing live because you can’t, someone else writes your music and you don’t play an instrument live… then I judge very critically.
I didn’t even see ur beautiful cat at first cause he’s so black, lol! He’s a beautiful little tiger.
I think they put an Ariana old video cuz now she never fail:)))
She did actually when she perform with christina Aguilera in dangerous women live. A lot of tension so try again
Neither does Taylor :))))))))
Cause her hardest song she lip synced live
@@FellDownTheCornHole she's a singer not a vocalist. Plus shes flat half of the time
Just goes to show that singers are human, after all. (As hard as that may be for some to believe lol).
Kelly Clarkson is insane 😍
She definitely is 😍
She sounded awful, to be honest.
Can someone tell me who the last 2 singers are?
I wished the cat walked on the piano
Just what I needed after finishing work ! Great vid as always ! First comment too !
I hate to say it but I feel like Alicia Keys lost her voice. Her voice hasn't been the same in years
Some of these weren’t really fails, they’re just not incredible. Leona’s clips for example sounded a little bit tense but I wouldn’t say they were fails
Georgina missed Björk !!!! She does the same as Jessica AND many others, She Is unpleasent to listen too !!!!!
Love the kitty 💜
When you had that short Taylor Swift video the other day I had just seen a video that was a perfect example of what you were saying, but I couldn't remember who it was about or find it. But I finally found it.
ruclips.net/video/ylQlzG_l4t4/видео.html.
Lauren Daigle. If you are unfamiliar with this artist she has a song that is a masterpiece called "You Say". Though there are two covers that I like better by groups I'm sure you've never heard of, BYU Noteworthy (an all female college A Capella group) and Gentri. You said it perfect. No one can sing every song perfect every time, it's what you do when you make a mistake that matters.
I've always felt that Leona Lewis requires a lot of vocal coaching to be able to overcome her vocal weaknesses and to become a truly GREAT singer. The potential is definitely there, but I find her overall technique to be poor. She often switches between chest voice and head voice too often and rather awkwardly. She could be up there with Mariah if she worked on her voice enough.
LMAO what is Nicole singing I need to see the full one
LOVE seeing your puddy tat 🐱 at the beginning - hugs from me 💕
Everyone loves Alicia keys and I’ll admit she is talented beyond means but she is also very pitchy quite often.
Kitty 🐈⬛ cat ❤️ Hugs from Cardiff 🏴
She said that she cant hit that note live, and this vid just proves that she cant 🤠👍👉❤️
Haha, the first video I love how horrified your face looks.
I wonder why singers overpush. It’s not like it’s a practice makes perfect thing.
You keep saying 'too much tension', but what does that really mean?
Lana ❤
With the Cheryl one she was Ill & I think just worn out, she absolutely can hit those low notes & I could point you to multiple performances where she does hit those notes
Lana Del Ray 😂😂😂😂😂
... 8:37
Ooooouuuu that’s a painful one lol 😪🤣😭
Ariana has more fails- the one in this vid wasn’t even a fail
Yeah true. But she's great same for Demi.
Yes she has but l included it bc not many people have heard of this performance before. It was flat and sharp throughout thats why l considered it as a fail for her. lts not terrible though
The one with christina Aguilera when she perform dangerous women live. Ooff a lot of tension
Ariana almost has no fails. Honestly.
Ariana has no bad fails. Not like the singers in these clips. Be honest now :)