I'm agnostic, but I come from a christian family. I feel like this song is directed towards people like some of my relatives - who go to church and read the bible, but aren't especially kind people. They'll recite bible verses from memory, but ask them to spare some empathy for others and they tap out.
i'm the type of person they'd recite the bible to and i'd recite another verse that contradicts theirs. Then say it's people like them and the verses within their preconceived notion of what the bible is to them, that i lost faith in their God. Granted they only play a part in the millions of things that actually did. Buut if god has no faith in me , i'm fine with that as well, deserved even i say. I tend to place my faith in death. Death is the end and that's all...or i hope that's all. An eternity with all the world and those that come after is honestly my own personal hell, mostly i can't deal with other people for more than a few hours let alone an eternity.
A long, long time ago I heard someone say: "Standing in a church makes you no more a Christian, than standing in a garage makes you a car." Now, this doesn't mean that going to church is a complete waste of time. What it is saying is that you can go thru the motions of being a devout follower, but you cannot hide what is truly in your heart from God. Bo is pretty much confirming that you can't bullshit your way in either. 😂
@@Zarryon12 This is basically my pov as well, but I go a bit further even: Eternity with the god of the bi(b)le sounds like Hell to me. And I don't think he'd like eternity together with me, either. Some Christians have told me that, when we're let into Heaven, we become our best versions of ourselves that we can be, with all of our flaws removed. To that I've answered that what's regarded as "flaws" is _highly_ subjective: I'm a very argumentative contrarian, and I even feel that my contrarianism is one of my best personality traits. If I was let into Heaven, I'd never shut up about how absolutely fucked up the existence of Hell is and how badly someone who not only creates Hell but even puts beings into it needs to be overthrown and, if not outright destroyed, then at least thrown down into Hell himself... Yes, the god of the bi(b)le deserves Hell as far as I'm concerned. In fact, he deserves it more than literally any human that's ever existed. So yeah, no, having to spend eternity in Heaven in that monster's company would most definitely be Hell to me.
“Maybe God does not believe in you” has always, to me, meant that God doesn’t have confidence in us. For instance, imagine your spouse goes to race in a big marathon. You say “I believe in you!” That translates to “I have confidence in your ability. I believe that you can do it.” From this, I think Bo is trying to say that God no longer has confidence in us getting into heaven because of the awful things we do as people
Let's be honest, if God were real he bounced long ago. He probably looks at us in horror and ran the fuck away to give it another try on a different planet he created to see if he could make a human like race like us but without all the terrible flaws.
Yes, specifically it's often the people who are the most vocal about spreading the word of their god who deviate furthest from the course they tell other people to follow. Jesus would be appalled to see our modern civilization, where our technology exceeds any of the wildest expectations someone who lived only a few decades ago could imagine. And yet, human suffering still happens on an unimaginable scale.
“Live a good life. If there are gods and they are just, then they will not care how devout you have been, but will welcome you based on the virtues you have lived by. If there are gods, but unjust, then you should not want to worship them. If there are no gods, then you will be gone, but will have lived a noble life that will live on in the memories of your loved ones.” ― Marcus Aurelius This is a quote that I try to live by and I think it's about the same thing that Bo is trying to get across in this song in my opinion
Same I live and will die by this id rather live a good and onle life by my own will and The good In my heart then try to live a "just" life out of fear from a god and worship said god because they command it if that god was just then they wouldn't care about my faith only the actions deeds ive done
Did you know, the Mormon (actually LDS, but thats semantics) church, their faith believes that you get into heaven on virtue, not faith. You can go your whole life, never even HEARING of god, and he will welcome you with open arms. Personally im not mormon, but my grandmother is, and shes taught me a ton about it, and honestly, they have a good idea.
I live under the belief all people are selfish and act according to their selfish wants. I endulge in my selfish wants, but they often correlate with helping others and doing favors, because what I enjoy most is often solving another persons problem. I don't believe a god can exist, but if they do then surely they don't care if I believe in them. The only god who would condemn someone for not believing in it would be an ultra narcissistic god.
@@JeppeBeier That is a very nihilistic way of looking at things...a way I don't necessarily disagree with, if I'm being honest. I want there to be a deeper meaning but I think, in reality, we all do things that we want and there's no greater scheme to things; or so I think on my darker days. That way of thinking takes a toll on a person, my friend
"Maybe life on earth could be heaven, doesn't just the thought of it make it worth a try." - That line always resonated with me. The irony of spending our entire time on earth focused on getting to the next 'better" life, when this one could be heaven as well if we merely open our minds and our hearts and try.
As an atheist, I love this line. There’s so much suffering and pain, but if everyone realized that there was no afterlife, that your body rots and your soul, your consciousness is obliterated when you die, that no one is right, and there’s no being you should idolize metaphorically or literally, regardless of authority, then so much could be fixed. You can’t do everything, that’s why there are other people. Doing something different doesn’t make you better, and decisions should only be made by those with experience, not those with power. The knowledge that evil people won’t be punished for their bad acts, and there’s no paradise beyond our feeble earth should encourage empowerment, activism, preservation, and a more philosophically sound discourse. Science and Philosophy is necessary, but completely separate. We like being in a group, it makes us comfortable. No more. We should be able to share thoughts as a group (including peaceful protests), but unless manpower is absolutely necessary, actions themselves should be individual and with you full accountability. People should also not be shunned because they asked for help, but should likewise not be defended just because their life is hard or their people had horrible things done to them. Judgement should only consist of action and motive, not based on looks. This is part of the reason I find celebrity crushes, idolizing famous people in other ways than just their accomplishments, and electing leaders based on looks or an interesting perspective pretty stupid. These can be factors of great people, but they can also mask incredible stupidity, cunning, and/or evil. The devil is in the details, after all.
@@vizardonator8571Thats a optimistic way of looking at things. I mean I dont even think he has the same view of this as seen in his "all eyez on me" song
The immediate shift in the mood of the crowd as he says "none of you are going to heaven" is my favourite part of this song. Just absolute pin drop silence
As someone who grew up in church, so many people only gain their sense of right or wrong from what their pastor tells them or what they think the bible says (which it often doesn't or has been changed to say). The "you shouldn't abstain..." lines really hit hard. Even if you believe in Christianity you have to think for yourself and find the humanity and love in everyone. Being good is not reserved for people of one faith, goodness and the ability to be good lies in everyone, even if they haven't read the bible
I’m a theist, and when I see theists only abstain from things they think is bad because the Bible says they are bad is just dumb. Bru God doesn’t necessarily tell you not to piss on another person, but you still shouldn’t; That should be common knowledge!
This. God gave us free will and a big bright universe to investigate *for a reason.* The only people in history that have ever wanted us to shut off our free will have been tyrants. A lot of the best prophets in history have been the "choose of your own volition to follow me" types.
The very first line of actual singing is, "The books you think I wrote are way too thick." This implies that god didn't write any holy book, so none of them are correct. The other spot of note is the love has gotta come from you bit. You interpreted the meaning as love others first, but I saw it as you have to learn to love yourself. The previous bit about wanting god's love is saying that the person being spoken to wants to be loved. As someone who suffers from depression and anxiety, self love is the hardest to come by. Just my two cents.
Personally, the reason I personally took it to mean loving others is because of the amount of external hatred amongst humanity he mentions in the song (e.g. the “bickering” between religions, r*pe, the presence of gay folks not “going well,” we have trouble figuring out we shouldn’t be a dick, the shaming of natural bodily activity, etc.)
Actually, God spoke through the prophets and writers who wrote the Bible, which He can most certainly do since he created the universe. So although God didn't write the book Himself, he sort of did.
@@keelanelder2946 Since the song is being broad here and trying to cover all religions, it used a generalized way of speaking. That and if I dictate a book to you while you write it down, which of us is the author? In the same way you could consider your god to be the author of your holy book.
I interpret it as the only love that exists is that which we put into the universe. Love unfortunately is way too broad a concept in English, ancient Greek had like 16 words for it. But God is Love is generally the milquetoast takeaway. Love others even when it makes no sense, love thy enemy, love thy friend even when they fail. None of those necessitate abandoning self preservation but engaging in that as a “prayer” as a purposeful mental exercise, to understand those who have harmed you I tend to find helps me accept my own failures and shortcomings too. Just deciding to love yourself in a vacuum for some is about as helpful as “try being happier”, with drugs as help and anything that resets your mental framework purposefully deciding to try and understand how to love others can allow that mindset to recursively apply to a self image. Obviously not the only step but if he’s referencing the Bible that’s Jesus’ take but stated more bluntly that don’t wait for divine intervention, it’s on you. I certainly struggle with all aspects of that, tho I suppose I don’t crave the approval of extradimensional observers, but I do believe engaging the world that way can be productive regardless- assuming you are able to engage the world at all.
"maybe God doesn't believe in you" could also be referring to a world view similar to Deism. Many of our founding fathers were Deists and believed God created the universe but isn't actively managing or even watching us. Like an ant farm sitting forgotten in the corner.
His mom is a hospice nurse and very religious , he’s an atheist , he regrets some of the atheist songs he did because he felt they were pretentious and presumptuous . So this song is his most nicest to religion . You listen to rant from his first special that rap goes hard against Christianity . He has a small song about Catholic hell . “ Hitler was there and so were all the Jews so it got a little awkward “
I found everything you said incredibly true. It struck a certain chord with me, too, cause when I listened to the song for the first time, the very first "You're not going to heaven" irritated me, like incredibly. And it also confused me that it had this much power over me since I'm not even that Christian anymore although I have been raised in a very Christian way. Maybe that's why I almost took offense to Bo's sentence, despite not really thinking about heaven and hell in my everyday life. Only when the song progressed, the sentence "You're not going to heaven" felt more and more bitter and sad and I started to really feel bad for what humanity has effectively done to itself and others. I also felt bad for becoming irritated, as I realised my irritation was unjustified and blind. I now hold this song extremely close to my heart, because of its inherent meaning and because it made me reflect on myself, too. Really glad your reaction was so open-minded and smart. The best one out there in my eyes.
Remember that the Bible says that "whosoever BELIEVETH in Him shall not perish but have everlasting life" so as long as you acknowledge the presence of the Lord, you will enter His kingdom where you'll find God waiting open arms for you. He loves you more than you could ever know, and it's the very least any of us can do to love Him back.
@@keelanelder2946 I'm sorry if this is a stupid question, but isn't that a pretty bad way to handle things? Like, if a mass murderer believes in god, does that mean they're going to heaven? On the other hand, if someone only does good things, but doesn't believe in god, does that mean they have to go to hell? Because that sounds like a very arrogant way to handle things: if people are part of the "fan club" of god, they get to go to heaven, all of them, otherwise, they don't. Everyone can be wrong, we're only human, and if someone is convinced that another religion is the correct one (or, like me, doesn't know which one to believe in over the others or maybe even none at all), but they are a good person, why would a being as good and powerful as God deny them a good afterlife just due to that?
@@lilia3944 if you went to heaven and God told you he would be “fair” and judge you according to your standards of what you think “good” is do ynot u think you would live up to those standards? The answer is no. If you ever said it was wrong to lie, mistreat people, be unloving, lust, have horrible thoughts or more do you think you would have a perfect record? Never breaking any rules of your own morality? Really no one is good but God loves us all and if you were a murderer than you wouldn’t want to have to face eternal punishment either. We have all done wrong things wether it be thinking wrong thoughts or having wrong desires or mistreating someone or mistreating God. God is forgiving and I don’t see anything wrong with forgiveness really because it is beautiful and all of us need it. Also please don’t be confused by the term “believing in God” that doesn’t imply just believing he exists but also believing in what he does, says, stands for, and his love for you and the reality of what he wants to do in your life. So it’s more than just believing in the concept of God or believing that he exists. It is more than that.
@@Calebthecreator Yeah okay, there's my issue - I don't believe in everything the Christian God stands for, at least according to the Bible. I don't think attempting to kill your son (even if God stopped that before he died), no matter who tells you to, should be rewarded. I don't think a god would be in the right to kill, be it through floods or destroying cities, because of negative characteristics of beings he created - punishing others for your own mistakes is never the right thing to do. I haven't read all of the Bible, and it does contain good moral values too - but there's too many passages where God condones or even rewards violence or blind obedience for me to say I agree with the values of the Bible in general. At least in Greek mythology, people agreed that their gods were, at least most of the time, self-centered assholes.
I love how open you are to Bo's perspective even though you are a Christian :) Because Bo's point was never to bash any religion at all, but simply make you think about things from a new perspective. Just like you said !
I really appreciate the layout of your videos; straight into the music and then only pausing to interject with well thought out analysis. No waffling, no shilling, no nonsense. Looking forward to more!
Bo Burnham has tons of songs that are worthy of being dissected next. All of the commenters saying to look at "Rant" are correct and it's a great song but I also wanna suggest looking at this song called "Right Brain Left Brain" or "Nerds" both of which are in his special What.
Immense props for not just giggling and doing lazy surface-level reactions. Really appreciate that you actually take the time and effort to think about what you're seeing and hearing. The attempt at analysis- not just reaction, is what'll help your channel rise above others doing the same type of content. Never stop doing it that way.
I interpreted the "If you want love, the love has got to come from you" to be more about how devoutly religious people will work so hard to force themselves into a perfect box that their religion says, and they make so many sacrifices in their lives in a desperate attempt to please their God and earn its love- when maybe a much more meaningful love for this life is to learn to accept and love yourself
Oh, dang, I’m actually here I just love how Bo always has something to say. In Pandering it really gives you a view of stage country music while still being funny, and Lower Your Expectations is also excellent and a bit of a commentary on today’s society with love and dating. Very good video today!
I really appreciate your perspective on this song- especially what you said about the importance of considering the lyrics even if you don't agree with what he's saying. I look forward to seeing your reactions to the others! I also recommend "Repeat Stuff"- it still touches on something interesting/important, but its a touch less intense compared to some of what he's covered imo
I'm so glad I found you while on my Bo-reactions hunt! It's rare to see people actually understand the meaning behind every lyric on first listen. 90% of reactions I saw only paused to say something dumb, so their vid would qualify as a "reaction", but you use the pauses to discuss and analyze, so refreshing! For other songs I would recommend some stuff from his "what." special: specifically "Left Brain, Right Brain", "Sad", "Repeat Stuff" (
I am so glad you took the time to interpret the lyrics from your own perspective. I feel like other reactors just say 'wow thats deep' and move on, but they don't input why. Great reaction.
I've always thought "if you want love then the love has got to come from you" means to love yourself before you love others, but your take on it is really interesting and makes perfect sense. I'm not religious at all so it's really cool to see your take on this song!
Idk I’m constantly watching reactions to Bo, but you’re the best at it lol. Even when I’ve seen all of his work multiple times, your insight still gives off another perspective that I haven’t thought of, or point out things I previously looked over. Kudos man!
Love this song. Starts off funny and goofy, and then suddenly turns into a serious song. "Maybe God does not believe in you" hits me hard.And im not religious. Just look at the way he looks at the audience when he sings that
As a Christian, I really appreciated your reaction to this song. And I love how Bo is able to write songs like this and yet still have respect for people of faith. I've heard him say in several interviews things like, "I don't really believe in God, but there are a lot of really smart people who do." Or "I don't know if God exists, but my mom loves Jesus, and she's great." Like you, even if I don't necessarily agree with the theology of this song, I really appreciate the questions it is asking, and that I think we all need to wrestle with at some point.
I love watching you react to stuff because you seem to genuinely reflect about what you're listening to which not many react channels do, it is super interesting to hear you're opinion. I would love to see you react to We Think We Know You which is the finale of his special what.
I've always believed that the point Bo makes is that humanity is a huge mess. Even the most religiously "righteous" don't follow the book they put all their faith in. The people who *know* they're going to heaven still walk around full of hate and condemnation for all sorts of people who are different from them. Their Bible says to "love thy neighbor", there are no exceptions here. Not "love thy-" straight, or white, or christian neighbors.
That’s the thing though, people(mainly non Christians) think that “love thy neighbor” means something that it doesn’t.. I love everyone, and you can love people without supporting everything about them like sin.. if I love someone I would want someone to go to heaven not hell, so I won’t sugar coat what it takes to get to heaven. The world is way to soft these days and everyone wants everyone else to conform to what they want or believe.
@@mellowmorningsasmr3770 The bible may say to bear witness, but you can do so without being a shitty person , and that's my experience with Christians, even having been raised in the church. The religion teaches "Love thy neighbor"; there is no but, or except, or only if. The religion also says "judge not, lest ye be judged" and "let those among you without sin first cast a stone". Nowhere in the bible does it say that it is the duty of the followers of christ to condemn sinners or non-believers, but man do a lot of Christians just *love* to do that. You don't have to agree or support things you don't agree with; You just have to mind your own business and keep your mouth shut. It is perfectly fine to have an opinion and also keep it to yourself.
@@mellowmorningsasmr3770 You're exactly the kind of person whose faith is a lie. You believe in God because you think it will get you something and it makes you better than others. You love no one and nothing. It's plain in every word you typed.
I believe in God though I don’t go to church every Sunday as everyone in my toxic biological father’s family does; I don’t pray every single night before I go to bed as they do either only every now and then I do when I feel the need to when I feel lost or very hopeless, feeling like I should give up living all together but I pray because deep down I don’t want that and I need God’s help to keep me from giving up. To keep me hopeful in my rock bottom moment in life. It helps. I seen/heard my toxic family members talk nasty things about me, my mom and everyone else who they don’t agree with or like but they believe SO much of God and that they are in the right and that I will go to hell just because I cut them off of my life including my father…especially now that I changed my name and their last name out of my identity. I don’t believe I’m a good person, I don’t believe I’m a bad person either however I believe that I am just a young woman, a human being who makes bad and good choices but I’m trying to learn and grow from them because I want to make the best out of my life as much as possible because I only have one life and I don’t want to be depressed, anxious and feeling so hopeless forever…I want to be happy and be stronger than I was before. We should help one another not bring each other down based on our differences and opinions, we should be caring and loving and do the best we can do to help the helpless and the hopeless people we encounter. The world isn’t all black and white, neither isn’t the world all who’s the good guy and who’s the bad guy because life is too complex, too messy and mangled and only seen as one sided because we don’t see nor think that way. If we all did good for the soul purpose because you care, because that voice Within you gave you the feeling/the thought to help that person who needs it…because you care, and something is telling that you need to share them something that is yours either buy a homeless person food for them to eat, spare money or when you see someone who’s having a mental breakdown in public who’s crying try to talk to them help them to have someone to talk to and take them outside or somewhere else get a coffee or anything and just talk or just listen. Try to put yourself in the hopeless/helpless shoes and wonder what you would’ve wanted and needed and be exactly that person and help said stranger who’s suffering. We will not see how much of an impact we do by doing one such simple selfless action to help can do for that person…that person will remember that and help another person in need or tell another their encounter with you in memory just for you being you and doing what you felt was right in that moment. You did a good thing and you feel good that you helped their life to be a little less darker and hopeless, life is still worth living. That’s what I feel what God wants us to be and do but how should I know right? I’m just doing because I feel like it’s right and because I can’t ignore that feeling when I can have the choice to do something to help. Just try, everyone has nothing to lose by just doing something to help, being kind isn’t going to cost you anything.
What a thoughtful and insightful reaction man. I’ve listened to this song dozens of times over the years and you brought up things I’d never thought of! Thank you 😊
i know this song is titled “from god’s perspective” and that he’s pretending to be literally God, but when he says “i’m not gonna give you love just because you want me to, if you want it then it has to come from you”, something about that feels deeper to me than just bo acting out a character. that felt like bo was really talking as himself for a second there. and it would make sense. you’ve seen him perform “art is dead” where he’s tells the audience “i’m just a kid, i’m just an artist. i’m not your god, please don’t worship and revere me.” i get those same vibes with this performance. like yes, the point of this song is to speak as though he’s literally God, but in a deeper, more subtle way, it’s like he’s kinda playing into/satirizing the way the general public completely worships their celebrity idols. or maybe i’m reading way too much into it. that was the gut feeling that i got, though.
when i was a child i do have that mind set to think to much because if i stop i would get dizzy and blackout but one of those thoughts that when i pray "does god believe in me" or "from all the people of the world, is he able to hear me" so from that forward i always have an open mind like having an opinion of myself than others
Great reaction! I love how you take the time to really think about his lyrics. You even made a few comments that I hadn't thought about or realized so thank you for that! Bo Burnham is probably my all time favorite comedian, love how he blends comedy and serious topics together. Keep up the good work! :)
This whole song just reminds me of a famous quote from Marcus Aurelius. It's along the lines of a just god wont care how devout you are, they will care if you are a good person. If a god wanted you to you be devout over good then they aren't a god you should worship in the first place and whether there is a god or not you will still have lived a good life.
genuinely, youre one of the best reaction channels ive ever watched. most reaction channels are fine and fun, but i love how you break down the music so smartly, you explain things incredibly well, i didnt grow up exposed to a lot of religion, my grandmother is a catholic and ive always been very close to her but shes never once tried to make me religious , and ive spent a long time not quite understanding the line "my loves the type of thing you have to earn, and when you earn it you wont need it" i felt like i got it but i couldnt put it into words, and you did exactly that. and i really CAN tell you went to school for music, im genuinely shocked youre just a normal reaction channel and not a professional music theorist. musical philosopher guy. i feel like youd make a fantastic teacher i think. ive never subscribed to a reaction channel but today i will be :D
I think the point of "my love is the type of thing you have to earn and when you earn it you won't need it" is essentially saying that in order to earn God's love you must be a pure loving being who makes it their mission to make life on earth heavenly, thus neglecting the nessecity for a heavenly afterlife.
I'd love to hear your reaction/analysis for some of the songs from Inside. They're not on Bo's channel, but I'm pretty sure you can still find them on youtube. That funny feeling is a really good one.
I really love the way you take this, while I might not be a Christian anymore. (Grew up and was raised as one, a very strict household on the matter) this is what I wished religion was like and still do. If religion is real and what they believe in I wish they did have that look on life. You don’t impress god or deities. You earn it by being a good person. Thanks for reacting to this. While my family has accepted that I’m no longer religious, I’m glad that they have learned to have this out look instead of what was originally there when I was a kid.
I thought the line “maybe god doesn’t believe you” as we don’t know if god is real or not but nobody has thought of that maybe god doesn’t think we’re real or not
I was also raise christian/baptist (although at the current moment I'm very much not) and I do actually like your way of going about reacting to this from both potential sides of religious bias. I also have some thoughts on lines; I think that within the line "I loves the type of thing that you have to earn, and when you earn it you don't need it" it is referring back to the previous lines where he says "maybe life on earth could be heaven". I take it as him talking about all the hateful and awful things people do in "the name of God" in order to gain what they believe to be God's love when in reality after all of that time you spent trying to earn it you ended up dead and wrong anyway. Life could be heaven where everyone gets along in harmony but instead, people spend their lives being harmful to each other trying to prove themselves right in the name of their gods and waste the one life they did have being hateful. - So in the end life could be heaven, but because you spent your entire life being hateful, not only did you waste your only life, but when you die and get to whatever god you were preaching for, you probably won't gain entry to heaven anyway because of how you wasted your life.
I’ve always though the earned love line is a reference to the “need” of some humans to trust and believe in a greater power’s love for them to fill a hole and give them a purpose beyond just living. But, based on the teachings believed, the love you “need” has to be earned through being a decent person and sharing your love with others. And that act, if truly being performed, is enough to fill that hole on its own. So the moment you’ve “earned” the love, you no longer “need” it.
Always happy to see another Bo reaction from you! You really are great at analyzing his songs, and you always communicate your thoughts on them so damn eloquently. I may have said this before, but your channel is like a breath of fresh air when it comes to reaction videos. Keep it up, man! (Also, as far as Bo videos go, I'd love to see you react to "Are You Happy?" from the end of the Make Happy special!)
Also please do Left Brain Right Brain next! I think it's one of his best stage performances in terms of character performance and is another one that starts out lighthearted or weird and gets more serious
To me Bo has done a trilogy throughout his last 3 specials that deserve to be watched back to back to back in one sitting. You Think You Know Me - What Kanye Rant - Make Happy All Eyes On Me - Inside
One song that kind of get over looked from these reactions and history of Bo is the song right after “can’t handle this” is “are you happy” which takes place in the same room as inside 5 years earlier and sort of transitions to the Special as we sort of takes his break.
I always thought of "you have to earn it, when you earn it you won't need it" being linked to "the love has got to come from you" because of humanity gets it shit together and surrounds itself with love for one another we won't be desperately seeking that approval from this magical third party that may or may not be real.
I think your breakdown of the song was quite good and well considered. I have liked this song since I first caught it on Netflix because it has so many paths for deeper thought and contemplation. If god were a real thing, an omnipotent all knowing creator of everything, I'd have to assume it would have an outlook on the universe far closer to Bo's than most religious books interpretations. That's to say nothing of his lines about heaven though, I feel in those he was playing into the god hypothetical. Even assuming a generic god being existed that created everything, there's still several more assumptions that would have to be made for a heaven that God is hosting to be a thing, let alone souls existing, where heaven could exist, how souls could travel there, etcetera. I feel like I'm getting preachy, I'll stop hopefully before I become a nuisance, but thank you for the earnest take on the video.
The love part (or at least the way that it makes sense to me, maybe that's not what he meant) is like this- we human beings have a need for love, acceptance, safety, and so on. We have a need to feel loved (i guess love is a general word and you can specify by saying accepted, encouraged, supported and so on, and so forth). So... If you depend on anything but yourself for love, you may or may not get it, but "the god" in this song is saying that love is gotta come from you, meaning... If you look for validation (love) externally, you may or may not find it, but you'll also be dependant on it, and it can be the void inside of you that's never satisfied. However... if you learn to appreciate yourself, accept yourself, support yourself, encourage yourself and so on, that's the most stable, reliable, and probably "best" way to be.
I'm quite new to your channel and really love your reactions! You are very smart and you think about and understand (from my point of view) the content very good. Enjoyed your reaction! Especially here, where one could think you are commenting biased, you are completely open to different interpretations and acknowledge them. Makes me excited for the next reaction.🙂 Greetings from 🇩🇪
The part "God thinks that this is a bad game of sim....so he doesn't believe in you" (paraphrasing) kinda happened in the Bible, he wiped the world population to restart the game in the flood.
I think the point of the song is to acknowledge that we as people are overconfident. We believe we understand the nature of the world, claiming to fully understand things that are far beyond our own comprehension.
I like this song because the takeaway isn't "God is fake and you're dumb if you believe in him". Instead, it's calling out the entitlement and self-righteousness that certain religious people tend to carry. I feel like a lot of atheists and people who are mad at religion as a whole are more mad at the people who believe in God than they are at God himself, but they take it out on God because it's easier. Bo takes a really interesting and intelligent perspective and although I don't neccesarily agree with all of what he says, I still think that a lot of the criticisms of the Church do ring very true.
I mean if God knows everything, he'd already know the things you do while sleeping. Besides, that's Santa that "sees you when you're sleeping, knows when you're awake. He knows if you've been bad or good, so be good"
I’m sure someone else has said this but the “what if god does not believe in you” part is close to the story of Noah where god was disappointed in his creations and decided to wipe them all out except for the one decent dude on the planet.
Idk why but this video made me very happy because as somebody who grew up in a very strict Catholic household my mom hated this dong because she took it as a disrespect to religion but I always found his words meaningful. Thankyou
Man, I love your takes. It's like watching my brain processing the info the first time I heard it. He's a Boston Catholic boy who questioned the system the Church forced down his throat, but he didn't lose the message of religion and is critical of those who are missing the point, which sadly is damn near everyone who prays to someone. Me vs. You, yet all their Gods say treat people with kindness and respect. Hmmm...
I really like your reactions to Bo Burnham's songs! You have such a good understanding of lyrics and you also show a lot of respect to him and his songs. You were the first RUclipsr I watched who reacted to his songs, and I watched a lot of reactions after but yours are still my favorite. And about "my love's a type of thing you need to earn and when you earn it you won't need it" line. I always thought about it in a way that people struggle so much throughout life to earn God's love and miss so many opportunities for what? To live this boring type of life in heaven for the rest of the eternity? Like isn't life on Earth is given to you for living it happily and trying all different interesting things before you'll die? But anyway your take is also very interesting and very much possible.
Love this song. As an agnostic, I’ve always found the rituals that various religions practice rather odd. Like, you do you, but IF a God exists, do you think they would care about all these small acts of worship? If God is truly good, then they’d not care for the worship or being honoured, all they would care about is how you treat others & the world around you. I think it would take a pretty vain and selfish God to want all of that worship and set all these weird arbitrary boundaries that you mustn’t cross.
I totally agree with the earning of the love and not needing it like if you're good enough to earn God's love then life will return the favor you don't need God's love at that point
I'm agnostic, but I come from a christian family. I feel like this song is directed towards people like some of my relatives - who go to church and read the bible, but aren't especially kind people. They'll recite bible verses from memory, but ask them to spare some empathy for others and they tap out.
i'm the type of person they'd recite the bible to and i'd recite another verse that contradicts theirs. Then say it's people like them and the verses within their preconceived notion of what the bible is to them, that i lost faith in their God. Granted they only play a part in the millions of things that actually did. Buut if god has no faith in me , i'm fine with that as well, deserved even i say. I tend to place my faith in death. Death is the end and that's all...or i hope that's all. An eternity with all the world and those that come after is honestly my own personal hell, mostly i can't deal with other people for more than a few hours let alone an eternity.
I relate to this so much; I've known so many, many people like that.
A long, long time ago I heard someone say: "Standing in a church makes you no more a Christian, than standing in a garage makes you a car." Now, this doesn't mean that going to church is a complete waste of time. What it is saying is that you can go thru the motions of being a devout follower, but you cannot hide what is truly in your heart from God. Bo is pretty much confirming that you can't bullshit your way in either. 😂
Ditto. I'm constantly telling my family that, "your god is an egotistical asshole".
@@Zarryon12 This is basically my pov as well, but I go a bit further even: Eternity with the god of the bi(b)le sounds like Hell to me. And I don't think he'd like eternity together with me, either. Some Christians have told me that, when we're let into Heaven, we become our best versions of ourselves that we can be, with all of our flaws removed. To that I've answered that what's regarded as "flaws" is _highly_ subjective: I'm a very argumentative contrarian, and I even feel that my contrarianism is one of my best personality traits. If I was let into Heaven, I'd never shut up about how absolutely fucked up the existence of Hell is and how badly someone who not only creates Hell but even puts beings into it needs to be overthrown and, if not outright destroyed, then at least thrown down into Hell himself... Yes, the god of the bi(b)le deserves Hell as far as I'm concerned. In fact, he deserves it more than literally any human that's ever existed. So yeah, no, having to spend eternity in Heaven in that monster's company would most definitely be Hell to me.
“Maybe God does not believe in you” has always, to me, meant that God doesn’t have confidence in us. For instance, imagine your spouse goes to race in a big marathon. You say “I believe in you!” That translates to “I have confidence in your ability. I believe that you can do it.” From this, I think Bo is trying to say that God no longer has confidence in us getting into heaven because of the awful things we do as people
That makes a lot of sense, I like that interpretation
Let's be honest, if God were real he bounced long ago. He probably looks at us in horror and ran the fuck away to give it another try on a different planet he created to see if he could make a human like race like us but without all the terrible flaws.
Yes, specifically it's often the people who are the most vocal about spreading the word of their god who deviate furthest from the course they tell other people to follow.
Jesus would be appalled to see our modern civilization, where our technology exceeds any of the wildest expectations someone who lived only a few decades ago could imagine. And yet, human suffering still happens on an unimaginable scale.
@@ProperlyGaming plot of supernatural right there 😂😂
@@johnnyparsnips7641 why does this sound like a plot for an anime to me ??? Would be awesome 😆
"I was raised very well, like a field of corn. I was also raised very Christian, like the children of the corn" - bo
“Live a good life. If there are gods and they are just, then they will not care how devout you have been, but will welcome you based on the virtues you have lived by. If there are gods, but unjust, then you should not want to worship them. If there are no gods, then you will be gone, but will have lived a noble life that will live on in the memories of your loved ones.”
― Marcus Aurelius
This is a quote that I try to live by and I think it's about the same thing that Bo is trying to get across in this song in my opinion
it's like the anti-Pascal's wager.
Same I live and will die by this id rather live a good and onle life by my own will and The good In my heart then try to live a "just" life out of fear from a god and worship said god because they command it if that god was just then they wouldn't care about my faith only the actions deeds ive done
Did you know, the Mormon (actually LDS, but thats semantics) church, their faith believes that you get into heaven on virtue, not faith. You can go your whole life, never even HEARING of god, and he will welcome you with open arms.
Personally im not mormon, but my grandmother is, and shes taught me a ton about it, and honestly, they have a good idea.
I live under the belief all people are selfish and act according to their selfish wants. I endulge in my selfish wants, but they often correlate with helping others and doing favors, because what I enjoy most is often solving another persons problem.
I don't believe a god can exist, but if they do then surely they don't care if I believe in them. The only god who would condemn someone for not believing in it would be an ultra narcissistic god.
@@JeppeBeier That is a very nihilistic way of looking at things...a way I don't necessarily disagree with, if I'm being honest. I want there to be a deeper meaning but I think, in reality, we all do things that we want and there's no greater scheme to things; or so I think on my darker days. That way of thinking takes a toll on a person, my friend
"Maybe life on earth could be heaven, doesn't just the thought of it make it worth a try." - That line always resonated with me. The irony of spending our entire time on earth focused on getting to the next 'better" life, when this one could be heaven as well if we merely open our minds and our hearts and try.
As an atheist, I love this line. There’s so much suffering and pain, but if everyone realized that there was no afterlife, that your body rots and your soul, your consciousness is obliterated when you die, that no one is right, and there’s no being you should idolize metaphorically or literally, regardless of authority, then so much could be fixed. You can’t do everything, that’s why there are other people. Doing something different doesn’t make you better, and decisions should only be made by those with experience, not those with power. The knowledge that evil people won’t be punished for their bad acts, and there’s no paradise beyond our feeble earth should encourage empowerment, activism, preservation, and a more philosophically sound discourse. Science and Philosophy is necessary, but completely separate. We like being in a group, it makes us comfortable. No more. We should be able to share thoughts as a group (including peaceful protests), but unless manpower is absolutely necessary, actions themselves should be individual and with you full accountability. People should also not be shunned because they asked for help, but should likewise not be defended just because their life is hard or their people had horrible things done to them. Judgement should only consist of action and motive, not based on looks. This is part of the reason I find celebrity crushes, idolizing famous people in other ways than just their accomplishments, and electing leaders based on looks or an interesting perspective pretty stupid. These can be factors of great people, but they can also mask incredible stupidity, cunning, and/or evil. The devil is in the details, after all.
@@vizardonator8571Thats a optimistic way of looking at things. I mean I dont even think he has the same view of this as seen in his "all eyez on me" song
The immediate shift in the mood of the crowd as he says "none of you are going to heaven" is my favourite part of this song. Just absolute pin drop silence
Concerning the upcoming reactions, "left brain right brain" and "We think we know you" are two incredible choices that I'll definitely watch
As someone who grew up in church, so many people only gain their sense of right or wrong from what their pastor tells them or what they think the bible says (which it often doesn't or has been changed to say). The "you shouldn't abstain..." lines really hit hard. Even if you believe in Christianity you have to think for yourself and find the humanity and love in everyone. Being good is not reserved for people of one faith, goodness and the ability to be good lies in everyone, even if they haven't read the bible
I’m a theist, and when I see theists only abstain from things they think is bad because the Bible says they are bad is just dumb. Bru God doesn’t necessarily tell you not to piss on another person, but you still shouldn’t; That should be common knowledge!
This. God gave us free will and a big bright universe to investigate *for a reason.* The only people in history that have ever wanted us to shut off our free will have been tyrants. A lot of the best prophets in history have been the "choose of your own volition to follow me" types.
The very first line of actual singing is, "The books you think I wrote are way too thick." This implies that god didn't write any holy book, so none of them are correct. The other spot of note is the love has gotta come from you bit. You interpreted the meaning as love others first, but I saw it as you have to learn to love yourself. The previous bit about wanting god's love is saying that the person being spoken to wants to be loved. As someone who suffers from depression and anxiety, self love is the hardest to come by. Just my two cents.
That is a really great point, I forgot he mentioned that right in the beginning.
Personally, the reason I personally took it to mean loving others is because of the amount of external hatred amongst humanity he mentions in the song (e.g. the “bickering” between religions, r*pe, the presence of gay folks not “going well,” we have trouble figuring out we shouldn’t be a dick, the shaming of natural bodily activity, etc.)
Actually, God spoke through the prophets and writers who wrote the Bible, which He can most certainly do since he created the universe. So although God didn't write the book Himself, he sort of did.
@@keelanelder2946 Since the song is being broad here and trying to cover all religions, it used a generalized way of speaking. That and if I dictate a book to you while you write it down, which of us is the author? In the same way you could consider your god to be the author of your holy book.
I interpret it as the only love that exists is that which we put into the universe. Love unfortunately is way too broad a concept in English, ancient Greek had like 16 words for it. But God is Love is generally the milquetoast takeaway.
Love others even when it makes no sense, love thy enemy, love thy friend even when they fail. None of those necessitate abandoning self preservation but engaging in that as a “prayer” as a purposeful mental exercise, to understand those who have harmed you I tend to find helps me accept my own failures and shortcomings too. Just deciding to love yourself in a vacuum for some is about as helpful as “try being happier”, with drugs as help and anything that resets your mental framework purposefully deciding to try and understand how to love others can allow that mindset to recursively apply to a self image.
Obviously not the only step but if he’s referencing the Bible that’s Jesus’ take but stated more bluntly that don’t wait for divine intervention, it’s on you. I certainly struggle with all aspects of that, tho I suppose I don’t crave the approval of extradimensional observers, but I do believe engaging the world that way can be productive regardless- assuming you are able to engage the world at all.
"maybe God doesn't believe in you" could also be referring to a world view similar to Deism. Many of our founding fathers were Deists and believed God created the universe but isn't actively managing or even watching us. Like an ant farm sitting forgotten in the corner.
His mom is a hospice nurse and very religious , he’s an atheist , he regrets some of the atheist songs he did because he felt they were pretentious and presumptuous . So this song is his most nicest to religion . You listen to rant from his first special that rap goes hard against Christianity . He has a small song about Catholic hell . “ Hitler was there and so were all the Jews so it got a little awkward “
Definitely listen to "rant" not to be confused with the Kanye rant. Its a rap about his religious upbringing
Yes please! Not enough people have reacted to that one!
Yes!!!
yes it's so good
I found everything you said incredibly true. It struck a certain chord with me, too, cause when I listened to the song for the first time, the very first "You're not going to heaven" irritated me, like incredibly. And it also confused me that it had this much power over me since I'm not even that Christian anymore although I have been raised in a very Christian way. Maybe that's why I almost took offense to Bo's sentence, despite not really thinking about heaven and hell in my everyday life. Only when the song progressed, the sentence "You're not going to heaven" felt more and more bitter and sad and I started to really feel bad for what humanity has effectively done to itself and others. I also felt bad for becoming irritated, as I realised my irritation was unjustified and blind. I now hold this song extremely close to my heart, because of its inherent meaning and because it made me reflect on myself, too.
Really glad your reaction was so open-minded and smart. The best one out there in my eyes.
Remember that the Bible says that "whosoever BELIEVETH in Him shall not perish but have everlasting life" so as long as you acknowledge the presence of the Lord, you will enter His kingdom where you'll find God waiting open arms for you. He loves you more than you could ever know, and it's the very least any of us can do to love Him back.
@@keelanelder2946 I'm sorry if this is a stupid question, but isn't that a pretty bad way to handle things? Like, if a mass murderer believes in god, does that mean they're going to heaven? On the other hand, if someone only does good things, but doesn't believe in god, does that mean they have to go to hell?
Because that sounds like a very arrogant way to handle things: if people are part of the "fan club" of god, they get to go to heaven, all of them, otherwise, they don't. Everyone can be wrong, we're only human, and if someone is convinced that another religion is the correct one (or, like me, doesn't know which one to believe in over the others or maybe even none at all), but they are a good person, why would a being as good and powerful as God deny them a good afterlife just due to that?
@@lilia3944 if you went to heaven and God told you he would be “fair” and judge you according to your standards of what you think “good” is do ynot u think you would live up to those standards? The answer is no. If you ever said it was wrong to lie, mistreat people, be unloving, lust, have horrible thoughts or more do you think you would have a perfect record? Never breaking any rules of your own morality? Really no one is good but God loves us all and if you were a murderer than you wouldn’t want to have to face eternal punishment either. We have all done wrong things wether it be thinking wrong thoughts or having wrong desires or mistreating someone or mistreating God. God is forgiving and I don’t see anything wrong with forgiveness really because it is beautiful and all of us need it. Also please don’t be confused by the term “believing in God” that doesn’t imply just believing he exists but also believing in what he does, says, stands for, and his love for you and the reality of what he wants to do in your life. So it’s more than just believing in the concept of God or believing that he exists. It is more than that.
@@Calebthecreator Yeah okay, there's my issue - I don't believe in everything the Christian God stands for, at least according to the Bible.
I don't think attempting to kill your son (even if God stopped that before he died), no matter who tells you to, should be rewarded. I don't think a god would be in the right to kill, be it through floods or destroying cities, because of negative characteristics of beings he created - punishing others for your own mistakes is never the right thing to do. I haven't read all of the Bible, and it does contain good moral values too - but there's too many passages where God condones or even rewards violence or blind obedience for me to say I agree with the values of the Bible in general. At least in Greek mythology, people agreed that their gods were, at least most of the time, self-centered assholes.
@@lilia3944 100% agree.
I love how open you are to Bo's perspective even though you are a Christian :) Because Bo's point was never to bash any religion at all, but simply make you think about things from a new perspective. Just like you said !
Maybe try reacting to "we think we know you", its the finale of his show What. Would love to see you break it down and to see what you think of it^^
Hey, an underrated song is “lower your expectations” it’s really good, thank you
That’s a great one
Underrated? Oh this is interesting, I’d consider it one of Bo’s most known/popular songs,, at least for the general public
I really appreciate the layout of your videos; straight into the music and then only pausing to interject with well thought out analysis. No waffling, no shilling, no nonsense. Looking forward to more!
"That's such good musician stuff" - my new favorite quote xD Seriously, really like your reactions. More please :D
Bo Burnham has tons of songs that are worthy of being dissected next. All of the commenters saying to look at "Rant" are correct and it's a great song but I also wanna suggest looking at this song called "Right Brain Left Brain" or "Nerds" both of which are in his special What.
Immense props for not just giggling and doing lazy surface-level reactions. Really appreciate that you actually take the time and effort to think about what you're seeing and hearing. The attempt at analysis- not just reaction, is what'll help your channel rise above others doing the same type of content. Never stop doing it that way.
I interpreted the "If you want love, the love has got to come from you" to be more about how devoutly religious people will work so hard to force themselves into a perfect box that their religion says, and they make so many sacrifices in their lives in a desperate attempt to please their God and earn its love- when maybe a much more meaningful love for this life is to learn to accept and love yourself
Oh, dang, I’m actually here
I just love how Bo always has something to say. In Pandering it really gives you a view of stage country music while still being funny, and Lower Your Expectations is also excellent and a bit of a commentary on today’s society with love and dating.
Very good video today!
bo was actually raised in a catholic household and his song “rant” talks about how he feels about the religion. it’s an awesome song !
I really appreciate your perspective on this song- especially what you said about the importance of considering the lyrics even if you don't agree with what he's saying. I look forward to seeing your reactions to the others! I also recommend "Repeat Stuff"- it still touches on something interesting/important, but its a touch less intense compared to some of what he's covered imo
That "maybe god does not believe in you " line got to me too! I had never thought of it that way
I'm so glad I found you while on my Bo-reactions hunt! It's rare to see people actually understand the meaning behind every lyric on first listen. 90% of reactions I saw only paused to say something dumb, so their vid would qualify as a "reaction", but you use the pauses to discuss and analyze, so refreshing!
For other songs I would recommend some stuff from his "what." special: specifically "Left Brain, Right Brain", "Sad", "Repeat Stuff" (
Glad you enjoyed it :)
And thank you for the recommendations
What I love is how respectful you are in giving your opinion. I mean I love Bo so much and think his song writing is amazing!
I am so glad you took the time to interpret the lyrics from your own perspective. I feel like other reactors just say 'wow thats deep' and move on, but they don't input why. Great reaction.
I've always thought "if you want love then the love has got to come from you" means to love yourself before you love others, but your take on it is really interesting and makes perfect sense.
I'm not religious at all so it's really cool to see your take on this song!
Idk I’m constantly watching reactions to Bo, but you’re the best at it lol. Even when I’ve seen all of his work multiple times, your insight still gives off another perspective that I haven’t thought of, or point out things I previously looked over. Kudos man!
Love this song. Starts off funny and goofy, and then suddenly turns into a serious song. "Maybe God does not believe in you" hits me hard.And im not religious. Just look at the way he looks at the audience when he sings that
this guy is so enjoyable to watch. Binged like 6 of his videos. Keep it up dude!
Another great reaction. Really like to hear different interpretations of Bo’s lyrics.
he's quite literally a genius. the things that he can think of, it's insane.
As a Christian, I really appreciated your reaction to this song. And I love how Bo is able to write songs like this and yet still have respect for people of faith. I've heard him say in several interviews things like, "I don't really believe in God, but there are a lot of really smart people who do." Or "I don't know if God exists, but my mom loves Jesus, and she's great." Like you, even if I don't necessarily agree with the theology of this song, I really appreciate the questions it is asking, and that I think we all need to wrestle with at some point.
Awesome reaction and fantastic insights, we’ll done my guy
That whole crowd is quiet enough then the gasp/sigh of understanding when he says "love has got to come from you" its light but its there
maybe watch “rant “ by bo burnham. that’s also about religion
Been waiting for your reaction to this one!! :D
"He hasn't explicitly said that the bible isn't real"
At the beginning of the song he said
"The books you think I wrote are way too thick"
Implaying he didn’t write the book
@@frozengamer1178 or at least not all of it
I love watching you react to stuff because you seem to genuinely reflect about what you're listening to which not many react channels do, it is super interesting to hear you're opinion. I would love to see you react to We Think We Know You which is the finale of his special what.
This song just makes me feel good inside.
I've always believed that the point Bo makes is that humanity is a huge mess. Even the most religiously "righteous" don't follow the book they put all their faith in.
The people who *know* they're going to heaven still walk around full of hate and condemnation for all sorts of people who are different from them. Their Bible says to "love thy neighbor", there are no exceptions here. Not "love thy-" straight, or white, or christian neighbors.
That’s the thing though, people(mainly non Christians) think that “love thy neighbor” means something that it doesn’t..
I love everyone, and you can love people without supporting everything about them like sin..
if I love someone I would want someone to go to heaven not hell, so I won’t sugar coat what it takes to get to heaven.
The world is way to soft these days and everyone wants everyone else to conform to what they want or believe.
@@mellowmorningsasmr3770 The bible may say to bear witness, but you can do so without being a shitty person , and that's my experience with Christians, even having been raised in the church.
The religion teaches "Love thy neighbor"; there is no but, or except, or only if. The religion also says "judge not, lest ye be judged" and "let those among you without sin first cast a stone".
Nowhere in the bible does it say that it is the duty of the followers of christ to condemn sinners or non-believers, but man do a lot of Christians just *love* to do that.
You don't have to agree or support things you don't agree with; You just have to mind your own business and keep your mouth shut. It is perfectly fine to have an opinion and also keep it to yourself.
@@mellowmorningsasmr3770 You're exactly the kind of person whose faith is a lie. You believe in God because you think it will get you something and it makes you better than others. You love no one and nothing. It's plain in every word you typed.
I believe in God though I don’t go to church every Sunday as everyone in my toxic biological father’s family does; I don’t pray every single night before I go to bed as they do either only every now and then I do when I feel the need to when I feel lost or very hopeless, feeling like I should give up living all together but I pray because deep down I don’t want that and I need God’s help to keep me from giving up. To keep me hopeful in my rock bottom moment in life. It helps.
I seen/heard my toxic family members talk nasty things about me, my mom and everyone else who they don’t agree with or like but they believe SO much of God and that they are in the right and that I will go to hell just because I cut them off of my life including my father…especially now that I changed my name and their last name out of my identity.
I don’t believe I’m a good person, I don’t believe I’m a bad person either however I believe that I am just a young woman, a human being who makes bad and good choices but I’m trying to learn and grow from them because I want to make the best out of my life as much as possible because I only have one life and I don’t want to be depressed, anxious and feeling so hopeless forever…I want to be happy and be stronger than I was before.
We should help one another not bring each other down based on our differences and opinions, we should be caring and loving and do the best we can do to help the helpless and the hopeless people we encounter.
The world isn’t all black and white, neither isn’t the world all who’s the good guy and who’s the bad guy because life is too complex, too messy and mangled and only seen as one sided because we don’t see nor think that way.
If we all did good for the soul purpose because you care, because that voice Within you gave you the feeling/the thought to help that person who needs it…because you care, and something is telling that you need to share them something that is yours either buy a homeless person food for them to eat, spare money or when you see someone who’s having a mental breakdown in public who’s crying try to talk to them help them to have someone to talk to and take them outside or somewhere else get a coffee or anything and just talk or just listen. Try to put yourself in the hopeless/helpless shoes and wonder what you would’ve wanted and needed and be exactly that person and help said stranger who’s suffering.
We will not see how much of an impact we do by doing one such simple selfless action to help can do for that person…that person will remember that and help another person in need or tell another their encounter with you in memory just for you being you and doing what you felt was right in that moment.
You did a good thing and you feel good that you helped their life to be a little less darker and hopeless, life is still worth living.
That’s what I feel what God wants us to be and do but how should I know right? I’m just doing because I feel like it’s right and because I can’t ignore that feeling when I can have the choice to do something to help.
Just try, everyone has nothing to lose by just doing something to help, being kind isn’t going to cost you anything.
I love this reaction. It’s the first really analytical and deep look into it I have seen on YT.
What a thoughtful and insightful reaction man. I’ve listened to this song dozens of times over the years and you brought up things I’d never thought of! Thank you 😊
I love your reactions to Bo's work because you take the time to reflect on the deeper lyrics. It's nice to hear your interpretations :)
i know this song is titled “from god’s perspective” and that he’s pretending to be literally God, but when he says “i’m not gonna give you love just because you want me to, if you want it then it has to come from you”, something about that feels deeper to me than just bo acting out a character. that felt like bo was really talking as himself for a second there. and it would make sense. you’ve seen him perform “art is dead” where he’s tells the audience “i’m just a kid, i’m just an artist. i’m not your god, please don’t worship and revere me.” i get those same vibes with this performance. like yes, the point of this song is to speak as though he’s literally God, but in a deeper, more subtle way, it’s like he’s kinda playing into/satirizing the way the general public completely worships their celebrity idols. or maybe i’m reading way too much into it. that was the gut feeling that i got, though.
when i was a child i do have that mind set to think to much because if i stop i would get dizzy and blackout but one of those thoughts that when i pray "does god believe in me" or "from all the people of the world, is he able to hear me" so from that forward i always have an open mind like having an opinion of myself than others
„I’m not gonna give you love just cause i know that you want me to, if you want love then the love has gonna come from you.“ chills …
Great reaction! I love how you take the time to really think about his lyrics. You even made a few comments that I hadn't thought about or realized so thank you for that! Bo Burnham is probably my all time favorite comedian, love how he blends comedy and serious topics together. Keep up the good work! :)
This whole song just reminds me of a famous quote from Marcus Aurelius. It's along the lines of a just god wont care how devout you are, they will care if you are a good person. If a god wanted you to you be devout over good then they aren't a god you should worship in the first place and whether there is a god or not you will still have lived a good life.
There aren’t many reaction channels I like, but I do enjoy the way you break everything down to analyse 🖤
genuinely, youre one of the best reaction channels ive ever watched. most reaction channels are fine and fun, but i love how you break down the music so smartly, you explain things incredibly well, i didnt grow up exposed to a lot of religion, my grandmother is a catholic and ive always been very close to her but shes never once tried to make me religious , and ive spent a long time not quite understanding the line "my loves the type of thing you have to earn, and when you earn it you wont need it" i felt like i got it but i couldnt put it into words, and you did exactly that. and i really CAN tell you went to school for music, im genuinely shocked youre just a normal reaction channel and not a professional music theorist. musical philosopher guy. i feel like youd make a fantastic teacher i think. ive never subscribed to a reaction channel but today i will be :D
I think the point of "my love is the type of thing you have to earn and when you earn it you won't need it" is essentially saying that in order to earn God's love you must be a pure loving being who makes it their mission to make life on earth heavenly, thus neglecting the nessecity for a heavenly afterlife.
7.5 billion people. 7.5 billion grains of sand are all different but you can't tell them apart unless you're face down in the sand.
I'd love to hear your reaction/analysis for some of the songs from Inside. They're not on Bo's channel, but I'm pretty sure you can still find them on youtube. That funny feeling is a really good one.
I really love the way you take this, while I might not be a Christian anymore. (Grew up and was raised as one, a very strict household on the matter) this is what I wished religion was like and still do. If religion is real and what they believe in I wish they did have that look on life. You don’t impress god or deities. You earn it by being a good person.
Thanks for reacting to this. While my family has accepted that I’m no longer religious, I’m glad that they have learned to have this out look instead of what was originally there when I was a kid.
Bo is saying, maybe His experiment didn't work out. we failed
I thought the line “maybe god doesn’t believe you” as we don’t know if god is real or not but nobody has thought of that maybe god doesn’t think we’re real or not
man I can't lie, I love your reactions. I love hearing your interpretations. Hope you are doing good
I appreciate that
I am doing very well.
I hope the same for you
It's always interesting to see everyone's views to the lyrics. Love this song
I was also raise christian/baptist (although at the current moment I'm very much not) and I do actually like your way of going about reacting to this from both potential sides of religious bias. I also have some thoughts on lines;
I think that within the line "I loves the type of thing that you have to earn, and when you earn it you don't need it" it is referring back to the previous lines where he says "maybe life on earth could be heaven". I take it as him talking about all the hateful and awful things people do in "the name of God" in order to gain what they believe to be God's love when in reality after all of that time you spent trying to earn it you ended up dead and wrong anyway. Life could be heaven where everyone gets along in harmony but instead, people spend their lives being harmful to each other trying to prove themselves right in the name of their gods and waste the one life they did have being hateful.
-
So in the end life could be heaven, but because you spent your entire life being hateful, not only did you waste your only life, but when you die and get to whatever god you were preaching for, you probably won't gain entry to heaven anyway because of how you wasted your life.
You paused the video when the chills were chilling 😭😭😭😭 however great analysis! SUBSCRIBED!
I’ve always though the earned love line is a reference to the “need” of some humans to trust and believe in a greater power’s love for them to fill a hole and give them a purpose beyond just living. But, based on the teachings believed, the love you “need” has to be earned through being a decent person and sharing your love with others. And that act, if truly being performed, is enough to fill that hole on its own. So the moment you’ve “earned” the love, you no longer “need” it.
5:38 as someone who doesn't eat pork,this line killed me 😂
Religious or health-related reasons? Just curios.
I saw written somewhere the songs "Stairway to Heaven" & "Highway to Hell" say a lot about the expected traffic numbers
Always happy to see another Bo reaction from you! You really are great at analyzing his songs, and you always communicate your thoughts on them so damn eloquently.
I may have said this before, but your channel is like a breath of fresh air when it comes to reaction videos. Keep it up, man!
(Also, as far as Bo videos go, I'd love to see you react to "Are You Happy?" from the end of the Make Happy special!)
Thank you so much for the kind words :)
I'll definitely be doing that one at some point!
Also please do Left Brain Right Brain next! I think it's one of his best stage performances in terms of character performance and is another one that starts out lighthearted or weird and gets more serious
To me Bo has done a trilogy throughout his last 3 specials that deserve to be watched back to back to back in one sitting.
You Think You Know Me - What
Kanye Rant - Make Happy
All Eyes On Me - Inside
The word you were looking for at the end is "haunting". It stays with you. Changes how you think.
One song that kind of get over looked from these reactions and history of Bo is the song right after “can’t handle this” is “are you happy” which takes place in the same room as inside 5 years earlier and sort of transitions to the Special as we sort of takes his break.
I plan to react to that one as well
I always thought of "you have to earn it, when you earn it you won't need it" being linked to "the love has got to come from you" because of humanity gets it shit together and surrounds itself with love for one another we won't be desperately seeking that approval from this magical third party that may or may not be real.
I think your breakdown of the song was quite good and well considered. I have liked this song since I first caught it on Netflix because it has so many paths for deeper thought and contemplation. If god were a real thing, an omnipotent all knowing creator of everything, I'd have to assume it would have an outlook on the universe far closer to Bo's than most religious books interpretations. That's to say nothing of his lines about heaven though, I feel in those he was playing into the god hypothetical. Even assuming a generic god being existed that created everything, there's still several more assumptions that would have to be made for a heaven that God is hosting to be a thing, let alone souls existing, where heaven could exist, how souls could travel there, etcetera. I feel like I'm getting preachy, I'll stop hopefully before I become a nuisance, but thank you for the earnest take on the video.
The love part (or at least the way that it makes sense to me, maybe that's not what he meant) is like this- we human beings have a need for love, acceptance, safety, and so on. We have a need to feel loved (i guess love is a general word and you can specify by saying accepted, encouraged, supported and so on, and so forth). So... If you depend on anything but yourself for love, you may or may not get it, but "the god" in this song is saying that love is gotta come from you, meaning... If you look for validation (love) externally, you may or may not find it, but you'll also be dependant on it, and it can be the void inside of you that's never satisfied. However... if you learn to appreciate yourself, accept yourself, support yourself, encourage yourself and so on, that's the most stable, reliable, and probably "best" way to be.
Bo gets deep. He's like a mental ninja you hear it and then when you really listen there are little bombs of knowledge
I swear Bo's entire purpose is to give everyone an existential crisis
THIS
Cool perspectives man, keep doing you 👊🏼
I'm quite new to your channel and really love your reactions! You are very smart and you think about and understand (from my point of view) the content very good. Enjoyed your reaction!
Especially here, where one could think you are commenting biased, you are completely open to different interpretations and acknowledge them.
Makes me excited for the next reaction.🙂
Greetings from 🇩🇪
your bo burnham reactions are one of the best
"The fact there is a Stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell tells us a lot about predicted traffic"
The part "God thinks that this is a bad game of sim....so he doesn't believe in you" (paraphrasing) kinda happened in the Bible, he wiped the world population to restart the game in the flood.
Bo burnham has such a talent for music
I think the point of the song is to acknowledge that we as people are overconfident. We believe we understand the nature of the world, claiming to fully understand things that are far beyond our own comprehension.
"You argue and you bicker and you fight..." is my favorite part of it :)
I like this song because the takeaway isn't "God is fake and you're dumb if you believe in him". Instead, it's calling out the entitlement and self-righteousness that certain religious people tend to carry. I feel like a lot of atheists and people who are mad at religion as a whole are more mad at the people who believe in God than they are at God himself, but they take it out on God because it's easier. Bo takes a really interesting and intelligent perspective and although I don't neccesarily agree with all of what he says, I still think that a lot of the criticisms of the Church do ring very true.
noahs flood be the equivalent of making sims jump into the pool and deleting the ladder
I mean if God knows everything, he'd already know the things you do while sleeping. Besides, that's Santa that "sees you when you're sleeping, knows when you're awake. He knows if you've been bad or good, so be good"
I always took ‘You have to love yourself’ as in: Why do you always depend on me for love and support? Love yourself, you don’t need me.
Whooo. More Bo. It doesn’t really matter which song. They all have something interesting in them.^^
Such good musician stuff. Agreed. Also, you're very technical in your...words.
I love the way he sings “you pray so badly for heaven, maybe life on earth could be heaven”
I’m sure someone else has said this but the “what if god does not believe in you” part is close to the story of Noah where god was disappointed in his creations and decided to wipe them all out except for the one decent dude on the planet.
Idk why but this video made me very happy because as somebody who grew up in a very strict Catholic household my mom hated this dong because she took it as a disrespect to religion but I always found his words meaningful. Thankyou
Man, I love your takes. It's like watching my brain processing the info the first time I heard it. He's a Boston Catholic boy who questioned the system the Church forced down his throat, but he didn't lose the message of religion and is critical of those who are missing the point, which sadly is damn near everyone who prays to someone. Me vs. You, yet all their Gods say treat people with kindness and respect. Hmmm...
I really like your reactions to Bo Burnham's songs! You have such a good understanding of lyrics and you also show a lot of respect to him and his songs. You were the first RUclipsr I watched who reacted to his songs, and I watched a lot of reactions after but yours are still my favorite.
And about "my love's a type of thing you need to earn and when you earn it you won't need it" line. I always thought about it in a way that people struggle so much throughout life to earn God's love and miss so many opportunities for what? To live this boring type of life in heaven for the rest of the eternity? Like isn't life on Earth is given to you for living it happily and trying all different interesting things before you'll die? But anyway your take is also very interesting and very much possible.
Thank you :) I am glad to hear it!
I like that interpretation as well
His voice is so smooth in this song
this song always reminds me of another song by Aurelio Voltaire called God Thinks. I like the message of both of them
Well the very first part says "The books you THINK I WROTE are way too thick."
Which implies that he didn't write The Bible at all.
Love this song. As an agnostic, I’ve always found the rituals that various religions practice rather odd. Like, you do you, but IF a God exists, do you think they would care about all these small acts of worship? If God is truly good, then they’d not care for the worship or being honoured, all they would care about is how you treat others & the world around you. I think it would take a pretty vain and selfish God to want all of that worship and set all these weird arbitrary boundaries that you mustn’t cross.
I totally agree with the earning of the love and not needing it like if you're good enough to earn God's love then life will return the favor you don't need God's love at that point