1:35 during their debuted performance days it was originally Taemin passed his own mic to Kibum to hold for him on his dance break. But as playfully he is, he pushed Kibum and both giggling
Someone mentioned that Taemin did something random at 1:53 just for the fun of it. This might be an unpopular opinion but it's possible that it was done to detract from JH's high note. He also shouted over JH at 0:56. In another performance in the same concert, he wasn't coming back into position when JH was in the centre, and JH called him back. I don't think everything was well between the members in the last few months before JH's passing. JH didn't come back into formation at the end of Lucifer and preferred to stand with Taehyon at the closing ceremony. OT4 also ignored him and took pictures without him as OT4. Let's not forget the JH was wearing Kurt Cobain's suicide letter and a cross at this concert as well. I understand that we all do silly things when we are in our 20s, but I wish JH had been treated more responsibly at a time when everyone knew he was struggling with depression. I hope we all grow to become better people, myself included. May JH rest in peace.
After reading some comment,I’ve come out with something to say.To know that this was their last perfomance as OT5 make me sad enough but to accept the fact that it is IMPOSSIBLE for them to perform together again is heartbreaking.I became a Shawol right after Jonghyun’s death news.Too bad that I become their fan this late.To see how close they are,how precious a member to the another,their charismatic perfomance,their lovely voices.It’s tough to get over it.The fact that another group which some of their member has left still can one day make a suprise comeback as a full group but not for Shinee.How I started to love Shinee especially Jonghyun after he left us,making my heart broke even more.The good thing is now Jonghyun finally found his peace.I hope he rest well up there and that he can forget about all the pain that he dont’t deserve to get.The star that shines on stage for 10 years now the star of the sky.May he rest in peace. #RIPJonghyun
I just can't believe that jonghyun's suffering was bigger than his passion for singing :( Poor baby, people should have appreciated you much more I can't cry anymore, i'll just let time do its thing and HOPEFULLY things will get better for our boys ♥ we'll never forget this loved music genius, Kim Jonghyun TT
Wait. So Jonghyun had black and blonde hair on the same day? I see a recommendation for the ending of the smtown concert and jonghyun has blonde hair in the thumbnail
he did that at the part where he would usually hand his microphone to key because of his solo. but since they didn't have hand-mics anyway he used the opportunity to do something else ^^
Someone mentioned that Taemin did something random at 1:53 just for the fun of it. This might be an unpopular opinion but it's possible that it was done to detract from JH's high note. He also shouted over JH at 0:56. In another performance in the same concert, he wasn't coming back into position when JH was in the centre, and JH called him back. I don't think everything was well between the members in the last few months before JH's passing. JH didn't come back into formation at the end of Lucifer and preferred to stand with Taehyon at the closing ceremony. OT4 also ignored him and took pictures without him as OT4. Let's not forget the JH was wearing Kurt Cobain's suicide letter and a cross at this concert as well. I understand that we all do silly things when we are in our 20s, but I wish JH had been treated more responsibly at a time when everyone knew he was struggling with depression. I hope we all grow to become better people, myself included. May JH rest in peace.
July..........I'll go back to watching old videos till 2016. I can't with anything in 2017. It's almost 2 weeks and I don't think I can say I'm fully recovered.
Do you have any other songs of video clips "Shinee lives in concert 2017"? Can you please upload more or all of them. If it's possible the other songs of this concert, please. Thank you very much in advance. For Jonghyun best memory and Thanks a lot for this vdo clip.
I just watched another video of them performing as 4 and i just cant😭😭😭 so i came back and then realized that this was their last performance together 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
He may left us early but he gave us a gift that we’ll cherish forever. If we could only take away his pain, if we could only turn back the time. You did well, Jonghyun. Thanks for all the laughter, your music, and thank you for sharing us your limited time on this earth. 😇😇😇😇
Someone mentioned that Taemin did something random at 1:53 just for the fun of it. This might be an unpopular opinion but it's possible that it was done to detract from JH's high note. He also shouted over JH at 0:56. In another performance in the same concert, he wasn't coming back into position when JH was in the centre, and JH called him back. I don't think everything was well between the members in the last few months before JH's passing. JH didn't come back into formation at the end of Lucifer and preferred to stand with Taehyon at the closing ceremony. OT4 also ignored him and took pictures without him as OT4. Let's not forget the JH was wearing Kurt Cobain's suicide letter and a cross at this concert as well. I understand that we all do silly things when we are in our 20s, but I wish JH had been treated more responsibly at a time when everyone knew he was struggling with depression. I hope we all grow to become better people, myself included. May JH rest in peace.
I'm so so so emotional and sad at the same time that i didn't know them earlier! When they were still ot5! I so loved this song that i almost watched all of their replay performances. And wt, while watching shinee vids. Jonghyun really caught my attention and my heart. His voice, his great personality, his laughs, his smile. I want to replay the time when he did that to himself. I badly want to replay the time when he's in deep pain so that there's someone who will hug him to comfort hom, say that he's so precious and many people loves him and will love him in the future. But no matter what happened, while i'm watching shinee, you're still my bias and you're always remember and will forever in our hearts! Shinee fighting!! (But huhuhu i so so love jonghyunnnnnn right now)
At 1:37 it had me dead 🤣🤣🤣🤣 the way taemin pushed Key and they were laughing so hardd….omggg😂😂🤣🤣🤣 and jonghyun also lowkey laughed at their childishness 🤣
Someone mentioned that Taemin did something random at 1:37 just for the fun of it. This might be an unpopular opinion but it's possible that it was done to detract from JH's high note. He also shouted over JH at 0:56. In another performance in the same concert, he wasn't coming back into position when JH was in the centre, and JH called him back. I don't think everything was well between the members in the last few months before JH's passing. JH didn't come back into formation at the end of Lucifer and preferred to stand with Taehyon at the closing ceremony. OT4 also ignored him and took pictures without him as OT4. Let's not forget the JH was wearing Kurt Cobain's suicide letter and a cross at this concert as well. I understand that we all do silly things when we are in our 20s, but I wish JH had been treated more responsibly at a time when everyone knew he was struggling with depression. I hope we all grow to become better people, myself included. May JH rest in peace.
Someone mentioned that Taemin did something random at 1:53 just for the fun of it. This might be an unpopular opinion but it's possible that it was done to detract from JH's high note. He also shouted over JH at 0:56. In another performance in the same concert, he wasn't coming back into position when JH was in the centre, and JH called him back. I don't think everything was well between the members in the last few months before JH's passing. JH didn't come back into formation at the end of Lucifer and preferred to stand with Taehyon at the closing ceremony. OT4 also ignored him and took pictures without him as OT4. Let's not forget the JH was wearing Kurt Cobain's suicide letter and a cross at this concert as well. I understand that we all do silly things when we are in our 20s, but I wish JH had been treated more responsibly at a time when everyone knew he was struggling with depression. I hope we all grow to become better people, myself included. May HG rest in peace.
![[4K] 170708 SMTOWN LIVE WORLD TOUR VI in SEOUL 2017 _ SHINee _ Full stage](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ABHzwbzqy1I/mqdefault.jpg)
![TXT - INTRO + 누난 너무 예뻐 (원곡 : SHINee) [2019 KBS Song Festival / 2019.12.27]](/img/1.gif)
Their last song together is their first song together 😢😢
Love u jonghyun
Was this their last song of their stage??
@@cocovcoco yup as ot5 shinee... 2017
@@lisssaa___9447 oh my heart 💜💜💜💜💜
WHOA!!!!
:(((((((
Can we replay?
1:35 during their debuted performance days it was originally Taemin passed his own mic to Kibum to hold for him on his dance break. But as playfully he is, he pushed Kibum and both giggling
Someone mentioned that Taemin did something random at 1:53 just for the fun of it. This might be an unpopular opinion but it's possible that it was done to detract from JH's high note. He also shouted over JH at 0:56. In another performance in the same concert, he wasn't coming back into position when JH was in the centre, and JH called him back. I don't think everything was well between the members in the last few months before JH's passing. JH didn't come back into formation at the end of Lucifer and preferred to stand with Taehyon at the closing ceremony. OT4 also ignored him and took pictures without him as OT4. Let's not forget the JH was wearing Kurt Cobain's suicide letter and a cross at this concert as well. I understand that we all do silly things when we are in our 20s, but I wish JH had been treated more responsibly at a time when everyone knew he was struggling with depression. I hope we all grow to become better people, myself included. May JH rest in peace.
Still my fav Kpop song ever!
Rip, Jonghyun!
After 7 days, I believe my heart will be forever broken... I miss you so much Jonghyun.
They were laughing and smiling not knowing that this would be the last stage with their brother...
Is it?
@@RadiataStories1 yes
@@RadiataStories1 no they performed again as 5 a month later
Rest well beautiful angel!❤
You'll never be forgotten!💕
You'll always be rembered!💗
You did more than well and worked hard!🌹
It hurts so much, seeing them happy together... I wanna go back in time please 😭
After reading some comment,I’ve come out with something to say.To know that this was their last perfomance as OT5 make me sad enough but to accept the fact that it is IMPOSSIBLE for them to perform together again is heartbreaking.I became a Shawol right after Jonghyun’s death news.Too bad that I become their fan this late.To see how close they are,how precious a member to the another,their charismatic perfomance,their lovely voices.It’s tough to get over it.The fact that another group which some of their member has left still can one day make a suprise comeback as a full group but not for Shinee.How I started to love Shinee especially Jonghyun after he left us,making my heart broke even more.The good thing is now Jonghyun finally found his peace.I hope he rest well up there and that he can forget about all the pain that he dont’t deserve to get.The star that shines on stage for 10 years now the star of the sky.May he rest in peace. #RIPJonghyun
Well, regret is stronger than gratitude ya know
The good thing is that SHINee is still performing; it’s not to late to be their fan. But yes, we all miss Jonghyun a lot.
I just can't believe that jonghyun's suffering was bigger than his passion for singing :(
Poor baby, people should have appreciated you much more
I can't cry anymore, i'll just let time do its thing and HOPEFULLY things will get better for our boys ♥ we'll never forget this loved music genius, Kim Jonghyun TT
GULLIBLE PERSON YOU ARE HE WAS KILLED AND THERES NO PROOF HE WROTE THAT LETTER
vintagexparadise can you shut the fuck up and stop being so disrespectful
Dear god...noo
Mark Taeyong o
SHINee last time performed Replay as 5
So sad..
Love you my SHINee
Jonghyun oppa saranghae #SHINeeIs5
9년이 지나고 이제 어린 동생이 아니어도 누난 너무 예뻐를 아직도 귀여우면서도 멋있게 부르고 있네 ㅋㅋ.. 샤이니 영원히 5조입니다. 9년전에도 그렇고 지금도 내일도 사랑합니다
Jhonghyun you are the best.
1:36 start,I can't stop crying It makes me think of their debut, I'm so moved, they all grown up. I Love SHINee I Love you Jonghyun
RIP Jonghyun :(
Key looks so handsome here.... And I miss jonghyun 😖😖😖
There is kurt cobain's letter before he suicide on jonghyun's clothes..
Husna Apriany is it really? Oh my god
holy shit you're right
Husna Apriany I didn’t get you ?? What is kurt cobains letter! Please can you say me
Oh my! That's heartbreaking :(
@@rlatha87 Kurt Cobain was an entertainer here in the US that committed suicide in 1994.
Wait. So Jonghyun had black and blonde hair on the same day? I see a recommendation for the ending of the smtown concert and jonghyun has blonde hair in the thumbnail
Now....😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Is this there last performance as ot5?
MiMoMiMo yes
Alliyah Loves kpop 😭😭😭😭
Alliyah Loves kpop really?! Omfg ,:'''''(
No
Technically yes. They performed after this as 4 but the one missing was Onew.
Love you oppa junghyun miss you Rest and peace 💋❤️four members and one angle 💔😭❤️❤️❤️
Your memories will stay with us jonghyun. You are one of the best kpop artists
Does anyone know why Taemin pushed Key and they both grinned?
Thank you for posting this! I needed it so bad. Miss them so much!
he did that at the part where he would usually hand his microphone to key because of his solo. but since they didn't have hand-mics anyway he used the opportunity to do something else ^^
Isn't it because key was about to mimic taemins solo dance, so taemin playfully pushed him to stop him
Someone mentioned that Taemin did something random at 1:53 just for the fun of it. This might be an unpopular opinion but it's possible that it was done to detract from JH's high note. He also shouted over JH at 0:56. In another performance in the same concert, he wasn't coming back into position when JH was in the centre, and JH called him back. I don't think everything was well between the members in the last few months before JH's passing. JH didn't come back into formation at the end of Lucifer and preferred to stand with Taehyon at the closing ceremony. OT4 also ignored him and took pictures without him as OT4. Let's not forget the JH was wearing Kurt Cobain's suicide letter and a cross at this concert as well. I understand that we all do silly things when we are in our 20s, but I wish JH had been treated more responsibly at a time when everyone knew he was struggling with depression. I hope we all grow to become better people, myself included. May JH rest in peace.
Love jonghyun😭😭😭😭😭❤️
One of my favorite songs. No matter how old the song gets, it will remain one of my top favorite.
I won't be able to watch anymore live performances of shinee without jonghyun.. It will hurt a lot.. Especially their debut song...
I will miss them like this
제발 돌아와주라
July..........I'll go back to watching old videos till 2016. I can't with anything in 2017. It's almost 2 weeks and I don't think I can say I'm fully recovered.
Do you have any other songs of video clips "Shinee lives in concert 2017"? Can you please upload more or all of them. If it's possible the other songs of this concert, please. Thank you very much in advance. For Jonghyun best memory and Thanks a lot for this vdo clip.
I'm want to be in this fandom back in 2015 and now i am regretting it now i hope i can be a shawols even now???
Jane CabeloVIP you're welcome anytime 💚
I love you jonghuyn ❤❤❤
I just watched another video of them performing as 4 and i just cant😭😭😭 so i came back and then realized that this was their last performance together 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
1:36 사랑해 탬범 귀여워❤️❤️
My tear drop 😭😭😭😭
He may left us early but he gave us a gift that we’ll cherish forever. If we could only take away his pain, if we could only turn back the time. You did well, Jonghyun. Thanks for all the laughter, your music, and thank you for sharing us your limited time on this earth. 😇😇😇😇
miss😭😭
Forever five
Forever SHINee
❤️
Kurt Cobain's letter before he commited suicide on Jonghyun's shirt is legit af . One of the signs we didn't . We Love you Jong ❤️ Our Angel .
Someone mentioned that Taemin did something random at 1:53 just for the fun of it. This might be an unpopular opinion but it's possible that it was done to detract from JH's high note. He also shouted over JH at 0:56. In another performance in the same concert, he wasn't coming back into position when JH was in the centre, and JH called him back. I don't think everything was well between the members in the last few months before JH's passing. JH didn't come back into formation at the end of Lucifer and preferred to stand with Taehyon at the closing ceremony. OT4 also ignored him and took pictures without him as OT4. Let's not forget the JH was wearing Kurt Cobain's suicide letter and a cross at this concert as well. I understand that we all do silly things when we are in our 20s, but I wish JH had been treated more responsibly at a time when everyone knew he was struggling with depression. I hope we all grow to become better people, myself included. May JH rest in peace.
The music makes me feel old
😍
I MISS THEM. I REALLY MISS JONGHYUN OPPA😢❤
I'm so so so emotional and sad at the same time that i didn't know them earlier! When they were still ot5! I so loved this song that i almost watched all of their replay performances. And wt, while watching shinee vids. Jonghyun really caught my attention and my heart. His voice, his great personality, his laughs, his smile. I want to replay the time when he did that to himself. I badly want to replay the time when he's in deep pain so that there's someone who will hug him to comfort hom, say that he's so precious and many people loves him and will love him in the future. But no matter what happened, while i'm watching shinee, you're still my bias and you're always remember and will forever in our hearts! Shinee fighting!! (But huhuhu i so so love jonghyunnnnnn right now)
The last performance jonghyun had at S.M. town 😭😭 gosh I miss him n his first anniversary is next month and Onew is enlisting in the 10th December
out of my way !!! solo dancing
Goodbye Angel KimJongHyun.😇😞
Fue su ultimo concierto porque porque nos dejastes porque
Shinee:
5 members
1 star
4 people
R.i.p jonghyun
20180224 4:53
the last of 5HINee. It will be 4HINee From Now On
i miss you and love you, Jonghyun. 2 months, 2 years... no difference.
No. It'll always be 5HINee.
I still can't believe it 😫
key slay!!💖
last song together and first song together.. miss you jonghyun
This hurts so badly to watch. Why did I put myself through this pain? Im stupid
if only we could replay😭😭😭💕💕💕💕💕💕💕
SHINee Jonghyun onew Taemin key Minho
At 1:37 it had me dead 🤣🤣🤣🤣 the way taemin pushed Key and they were laughing so hardd….omggg😂😂🤣🤣🤣 and jonghyun also lowkey laughed at their childishness 🤣
Someone mentioned that Taemin did something random at 1:37 just for the fun of it. This might be an unpopular opinion but it's possible that it was done to detract from JH's high note. He also shouted over JH at 0:56. In another performance in the same concert, he wasn't coming back into position when JH was in the centre, and JH called him back. I don't think everything was well between the members in the last few months before JH's passing. JH didn't come back into formation at the end of Lucifer and preferred to stand with Taehyon at the closing ceremony. OT4 also ignored him and took pictures without him as OT4. Let's not forget the JH was wearing Kurt Cobain's suicide letter and a cross at this concert as well. I understand that we all do silly things when we are in our 20s, but I wish JH had been treated more responsibly at a time when everyone knew he was struggling with depression. I hope we all grow to become better people, myself included. May JH rest in peace.
I’m still here 😔
I love them so much 🥰
is that blazer depression that jonghyun wore?
Kir aena yeesss
멋있다.
miss you
為啥泰民要推KEY呀???
I just want to turn back time and help him. Please.
Someone mentioned that Taemin did something random at 1:53 just for the fun of it. This might be an unpopular opinion but it's possible that it was done to detract from JH's high note. He also shouted over JH at 0:56. In another performance in the same concert, he wasn't coming back into position when JH was in the centre, and JH called him back. I don't think everything was well between the members in the last few months before JH's passing. JH didn't come back into formation at the end of Lucifer and preferred to stand with Taehyon at the closing ceremony. OT4 also ignored him and took pictures without him as OT4. Let's not forget the JH was wearing Kurt Cobain's suicide letter and a cross at this concert as well. I understand that we all do silly things when we are in our 20s, but I wish JH had been treated more responsibly at a time when everyone knew he was struggling with depression. I hope we all grow to become better people, myself included. May HG rest in peace.
Miss Jonghyun 😭
He is wearing cross. He is not atheist.
I hope so :(
@@Rebek116 even if he was, so what?
@@cosmicreindeer5570 what the hell are you talking about? You cult freaks need to mind your own business
why is the choreo different..?
heyya it’s not