They were way ahead of time. No hate to anyone but couldn't help saying it Shinee faced something so huge and even after that they came back very strongly The kpop industry scenario might have changed or the criteria of everything might have changed but im proud of them for always trying to come back and always staying away from trashy race I respect them so much for being the same legendary shinee And yes i feel bad that they don't get the recognition and success they deserve but no matter what I will always be a shawol and I will always wish for their happiness and success
Agreed…there is no k-pop group like them…idk if F(X) is still active but if not, they are (i think) the only group that came back strong and still working hard all the way from the early 2000’s…
as how much Jjong part in here, when they perform this song in future,his voices will always be there as the background and adlib full of his voices. and that is 5HINee.
Im rewatching this for the first time in a while and my heart feels a little sore bc im missing Jjong a little more than usual but I cant wait for the day I finally get to see the boys💙💙💙💙💙
I dunno why I’m torturing myself by watching this again. The amount of strength it must have taken to come back from the loss of their best friend. To perform again as four instead of five. I’m not sure I would have been able to do such a thing. I still miss Jonghyun. I’m sure they do too. He’s still with them though. They will always be 5HINee.
That feeling... Then they were lively and full of happiness while perfoming replay esp its their debut song..but after jjongs gone it was never been the same...😢😢 Though they were smiling the pain is shadowing in their eyes..which makes it more painful for us shawols..
watched this on oct 2020, and still cryingggg. everyone in shinee has their own unique voices which we can recognize the moment we listen to their song. they will forever be legendary
This song reminds me when the song sang with Jonghyun. His voice I miss the songs are no longer the same since he died 😭😭😭😭. SHINee =4 people and 1 angel ❤️🌹🥀
I can not begin to imagine how difficult this concert was for them. What a special moment from the fans. You can see how much strength, purpose, and gratitude it gave to SHINee. I am a VIP who also adores SHINee. The bond between SHINee and Shawols is something that is unrivaled in kpop and truly beautiful to get to witness over the years.
It's because you know what happended and how sad it is but the shawol fandom is litterally so strong and SHINee themselves are very strong to deal with such a tragic loss at that age is something that isnt normal and because as I can see your an army and it would be the same if one of there members passed away. It would leave a hole that is still being felt till this day in shawols hearts all over the world. Espically with SHINee singing there debut song it means so much espically because there is a main voice in this song missing, SHINee debut as 5 and everyone thought that they where going to finish as 5. But sadly the truth is there still 5 members but not here physically and it makes me so sad. 5HINee forever 😭😭 by the way thanks for crying with us its heart warming seeing so many other fandoms still coming to pay respects to SHINee.
You can tell how they are trying to keep it together at the beginning and those puppy eyes of Minho when he saw "forever shinee" ... Our beautiful, talented and sweet boys.. I'm so proud I can't even describe it .. they deserve the world
This hurts sooo much 💔 Everytime I hear replay it gives me Goosebumps. These boys are so brave and humble. The look on their faces says it all when they saw Forever Shinee. Jonghyun I can hear you singing from the heavens... never forgotten xxxx
I don’t know why I keep coming back to these performances. I don’t know why after 3 years, I cry and mourn his death all over again. I can’t stand seeing only 4 of them, because I feel this empty space. I can’t believe how strong they are, standing there on a stage, performing, when it’s clear they all wanna cry. Every time I think I’m over it, I fall in this deep hole, over and over again. The pain never went away and it will never will. Soon, it will be the 3rd year after his death. I still wish to this day that it is all a stupid lie. I can’t live without him. I can’t now and never will. I truly hope he’s okay up there, finally resting and living the life he wanted and deserved. Rest well, Jonghyun
it’s 2021 and i still listen to their debut song, it just holds so much memories and is really the go-to song whenever u are feeling stressed or just wanna relive old times. i remember this was the first kpop song that i really liked, although not the first song from shinee that i listened to but for some reason this is it, this is the one that brings me the waves of emotions, like as if i’m seeing the young boys debut again. every time i listen to this song it’s as if i time travelled back to the first time listening and watching their debut mv. those carefree times i had while listening to this song. i’d literally watch the whole mv again and again just to focus on each and every member, and till now i still do it. really wish we could all go back to the old days, i really want to experience it all over again
This are the reason why I became a Shawols. They're talented, have a strong vocal line and their ocean are so beautiful. Replay are one of the best kpop debut song.
I was never so interested in Shinee, yet I liked their songs and perfomance and now seeing this after all this time I doubt they will ever dance and sing this song as lively as they used to, this song will always be remembered by all of us as treasure of them five.
i grow up with them. i grow up with this song. i love them. and all the memories, the person, I've got back then. this song means everything to me. i miss you shine, I miss you jjong-oppa. i miss my life back then.
No matter how many k pop artists I have known and loved No matter how many new artists I come to know and love Shinee has always been on top And not coz they were the first kpop artist I ever heard. They are actually the most talented, consistent and unique artists not only in the kpop industry but in the whole world No matter what at the end of the day..I always find my way back to them... They are the ones I listen to when I'm cooking, walking, sleeping... They hit different It's just Shinee makes me feel different They shinee in their own way and touch our lives forever It's never about the charts etc with shinee (though they rule their too) It's never about views etc. It's never about brining anyone down They are on their own league Whether it's REPLAY or DON'T CALL ME I can listen to them all day all night on repeat mode That's the power they hold That's what legends are all about And yeah SHINEE'S BACK And I will always be here forever to support them
Shinee is so resilient, incredibly talented, hardworking, and tough. They’re the absolute best at everything they do - losing the main vocalist 2 months prior to the concert did not dampen their performance (and mind you their performances are incredibly complex and difficult to execute) by any measure. SHINee is gonna go down in the history books as absolute legends.
Después de casi cuatro años todavía no tengo el coraje de ver muchas presentaciones, hoy es mi primera vez escuchando replay desde el 2017, mi corazón se siente melancólico, feliz y orgulloso al mismo tiempo. Trabajaste duro.
TW:// dec 18. This is my first time watching this performance since people started posting about it bc of how painful I knew it was going to be. It’s been almost 3 years since & I’ve found ways to cope ❤️ I felt a little stronger today and thought I was ready to watch them sing their debut song w/o him. I still cried, even harder when I saw what the shawols did in the crowd, but I’m so thankful to see how strong they were up there. Lord knows how hard that must have been, but they pushed through for Jjong and SHINee world. I’ve been a fan since 2009 so this song will always have a special place in my heart. 💎 5HINee Forever 💎
I usually never watch this performance older SHINee songs I have to have all 5 of them but this is still so beautiful and heartbreaking I loved SHINee since 2011 and still am here i love u SHINee 💎❤
Los amoooo bbs por ser tan fuertes y seguir adelante a pesar de todo 🥺 jjong te amo bb espero que de donde estés le des fuerzas a los bbs que deben extrañarte tanto así como todas las shawol del mundo 🌎 🇨🇱
Hace 2 días salió el cover de TXT de Replay de SHINee, no saben como lloré, y hoy junte el valor para venir a ver el vídeo... mentiría si les digo que no estoy llorando, aún duele la perdida de Jonghyun... las Shawol son muy fuertes, nunca dejen morir si recuerdo❤
@@dreaMinwitu no no es raro a mi me paso igual cuando supe la existencia de shinee, espero que cuando salgan del ejército nuevamente se junten. Vale la.pena escucharlos cantan bellísimo los 5.
Jenica Felix it’s a thing that might slip our minds at times, especially as the time flies... but there will be times where it slows and all you remember is the past. Beautiful times, times you wish never happened, and sadness. Thinking back on Jjong-ah and shinee, it was beautiful, still is. When you can still hear their voice, their smile flashes back as well, and you remember in that moment how much love and pain is in life. I hope you’re smiling, we miss you.
Shinee é incrível❤Sempre brilhante mesmo passando por tanta dor com a ausência do Jonghyun😞eles foram muito fortes e por isso merecem nossos respeito e carinho❤❤❤❤❤
Still cry years later watching this. I don't know how they made it through! Replay is the Best Debuet Song to this day. They preformed it like they always do like Jonghyun was there standing beside them.
![[C.C] Key and Taeyeon think of the beautiful memory with Jonghyun #SHINEE #KEY](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Vad27IQEVYo/mqdefault.jpg)
![DDG & G Herbo - Nosey [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/I9Ra0Zc2NlQ/mqdefault.jpg)
2020? Still Crying 😭 🙏 💐
Yes, I do. I love them so much and I still miss Jonghyun ❤
yup
I very miss jonghyun😭
I very miss jonghyun😢
Same
The first time I did not catch fans doing the Forever 5hinee sign. I was like why did they stop singing and start crying at 2:59 ? Now I'm crying
Shinee forever💎💎💎💎💎
Kangen konser SHINee
😭😭😭😭😭I'm crying now, seeing them again... Its 2019 right but I don't know why I'm seeing this video again... Always remember you guys...
Oh god this is too emotional to watch, this will forever be the best debut song in the world, I’m sorry but no group can compare to SHINee.
:(
They were way ahead of time.
No hate to anyone but couldn't help saying it
Shinee faced something so huge and even after that they came back very strongly
The kpop industry scenario might have changed or the criteria of everything might have changed but im proud of them for always trying to come back and always staying away from trashy race
I respect them so much for being the same legendary shinee
And yes i feel bad that they don't get the recognition and success they deserve but no matter what I will always be a shawol and I will always wish for their happiness and success
🙌💗💯🙌💗💯
True legends 👌❤️🇬🇧
Agreed…there is no k-pop group like them…idk if F(X) is still active but if not, they are (i think) the only group that came back strong and still working hard all the way from the early 2000’s…
their precious reactions when they saw shawols project FOREVER 5HINee 😭
as how much Jjong part in here, when they perform this song in future,his voices will always be there as the background and adlib full of his voices. and that is 5HINee.
Nerelisin?
Im rewatching this for the first time in a while and my heart feels a little sore bc im missing Jjong a little more than usual but I cant wait for the day I finally get to see the boys💙💙💙💙💙
omg Minho's face when he realized what was happening 🥺
Me: Don’t cry don’t cry don’t cry-
*the video starts playing*
Me: starts crying
Meeee
I dunno why I’m torturing myself by watching this again. The amount of strength it must have taken to come back from the loss of their best friend. To perform again as four instead of five. I’m not sure I would have been able to do such a thing. I still miss Jonghyun. I’m sure they do too. He’s still with them though. They will always be 5HINee.
Their faces when they read "Forever 5hinee" are having me tear up
2019?? Still crying
Yes😭❤
Crying now😭😭😭😭😭😭
I am not crying anymore, I am happy bcz he was here
@@dunya-828 ❤❤❤..he will be forver here with us and in our hearts uwu❤
Yes 😭
I still consider this fan project to be one of the most touching in music history.
That feeling...
Then they were lively and full of happiness while perfoming replay esp its their debut song..but after jjongs gone it was never been the same...😢😢
Though they were smiling the pain is shadowing in their eyes..which makes it more painful for us shawols..
watched this on oct 2020, and still cryingggg. everyone in shinee has their own unique voices which we can recognize the moment we listen to their song. they will forever be legendary
Mee
Replay... Always full of memories , full of feelings...
Jjong-ah , we miss you :(
Our five boys, you have worked hard...
It’s almost 3 years already yet still crying every time Im missing jonghyun’s smile and singing voice 😢😢😢
It’s gonna be 3 years
This song reminds me when the song sang with Jonghyun. His voice I miss the songs are no longer the same since he died 😭😭😭😭.
SHINee =4 people and 1 angel ❤️🌹🥀
I can not begin to imagine how difficult this concert was for them. What a special moment from the fans. You can see how much strength, purpose, and gratitude it gave to SHINee. I am a VIP who also adores SHINee. The bond between SHINee and Shawols is something that is unrivaled in kpop and truly beautiful to get to witness over the years.
OMGGGG this is so touching
... I'm crying 😭😭
Their vocals are no Joke...
I don't know them,
I don't know jonghyun
I don't listen to their songs
I never heard about them
I never took interest in them
Yet I'm crying?
It's so sad, beautiful and emotional at the same time 😢❤️
It's because you know what happended and how sad it is but the shawol fandom is litterally so strong and SHINee themselves are very strong to deal with such a tragic loss at that age is something that isnt normal and because as I can see your an army and it would be the same if one of there members passed away. It would leave a hole that is still being felt till this day in shawols hearts all over the world. Espically with SHINee singing there debut song it means so much espically because there is a main voice in this song missing, SHINee debut as 5 and everyone thought that they where going to finish as 5. But sadly the truth is there still 5 members but not here physically and it makes me so sad. 5HINee forever 😭😭 by the way thanks for crying with us its heart warming seeing so many other fandoms still coming to pay respects to SHINee.
@@juliettetaisne exactly
Kerron Walker crap, don’t cry don’t cry don’t cry don’t cry don’t cry. It takes so much strength, to have an essential person in your life be gone.
Same feelings!
不知不覺就這樣過了七個月
仍然好想他
一直走花路吧哥哥們🌸
5hinee💙
You can tell how they are trying to keep it together at the beginning and those puppy eyes of Minho when he saw "forever shinee" ...
Our beautiful, talented and sweet boys.. I'm so proud I can't even describe it .. they deserve the world
This video is still so hard for me to watch. I cry every time. I love you guys. You did well JongHyun
聽著聽著 二哥好像也在歌詞裡
因為密不可分所以顯得更加感動
又更加的喜歡這首歌
謝謝你的作品 辛苦了喔💗
ジョンよりも4個も年が離れてたのに気づいたらもう同年になったよ… お別れしてからこんなに時間が経つと思うとなんだか不思議な気持ちになる。この日のライブも行ってたけど何度ジョンの名前を叫んでもステージには姿が無くて でもあの瞬間は心の底からジョンを思って名前を叫べる場所だった。
何年経ってもずっとシャヲルだしまたジョンの姿を探しにくるね。
Japanese so lucky that Shinee make Japanese version. I wish they will make English version or even Indonesian version hehehehe
the look in their eyes when they saw 'FOREVER 5HINee' 🥺😭
This hurts sooo much 💔 Everytime I hear replay it gives me Goosebumps. These boys are so brave and humble. The look on their faces says it all when they saw Forever Shinee. Jonghyun I can hear you singing from the heavens... never forgotten xxxx
I don’t know why I keep coming back to these performances. I don’t know why after 3 years, I cry and mourn his death all over again. I can’t stand seeing only 4 of them, because I feel this empty space. I can’t believe how strong they are, standing there on a stage, performing, when it’s clear they all wanna cry.
Every time I think I’m over it, I fall in this deep hole, over and over again. The pain never went away and it will never will. Soon, it will be the 3rd year after his death. I still wish to this day that it is all a stupid lie. I can’t live without him. I can’t now and never will. I truly hope he’s okay up there, finally resting and living the life he wanted and deserved.
Rest well, Jonghyun
Not you make me bawling here 😭
✨🙏💎
5hinee... Forever ❤❤ No one Idol can replace the SHINEE ... shine be forever.. Love from India 😊
Shinning Shinee ❤❤❤......
Me too from India..♥5hinee forever♥
SHINee from Malaysia
@@kasturikregek shawol from India
Me too frm india😍
🤗
This got to be their most painful performance of replay
Jonghyun is not here but I can still hear his voice.
謝謝你，又讓我看到思念的輪廓，中文字幕真的最美！很感動，很想念，很閃耀！
2:58 their reactions.. Beautiful..
Why were they standing simply during that time
All of them was out of mind during that time
it’s 2021 and i still listen to their debut song, it just holds so much memories and is really the go-to song whenever u are feeling stressed or just wanna relive old times. i remember this was the first kpop song that i really liked, although not the first song from shinee that i listened to but for some reason this is it, this is the one that brings me the waves of emotions, like as if i’m seeing the young boys debut again. every time i listen to this song it’s as if i time travelled back to the first time listening and watching their debut mv. those carefree times i had while listening to this song. i’d literally watch the whole mv again and again just to focus on each and every member, and till now i still do it. really wish we could all go back to the old days, i really want to experience it all over again
When I miss SHINee I watch replay!! Can’t wait for their comeback
They need to calm down.
It's been so hard for them.
Not now.
Soon♡
2021 SHINee is back!!!!
And they're back again in 2023
Every time i watch this I can feel the magical vibes even from my computer screen ❤ 5HINee FOREVER ❤
Bruh it’s 2022 but still watching this. It’s still the best song that let you feel the nostalgic and at the same time, the melancholic feeling :(((
watching this in 2020, and I'm still sobbing.
me, an idiot: i can totally handle watching this without crying it's been two years
me, now sobbing: dammit
I'm not a Shawol .
I discovered this song only today.
I'm still in tears.
It's almost 3years the world lost it's brightest star yet it still hurts like yesterday Jjong we missed you. 5hinee forever.
2021 and Still Crying? 😭 5HINee Forever!
I can't stop crying.
SHINee SHINee SHINee SHINee...
ReplayがやっぱりSHINeeの代表の曲だよ...
大好き！！
好想好想金鐘鉉…知道他一直都在我們身邊的😢😢😢好喜歡這首😭看到FOREVER SHINee應援好棒好美💎SHINee S.W.要一起走到永遠👫🖤🖤🖤
Their reactions when they saw the sign are juat precious ❤️💎
This are the reason why I became a Shawols. They're talented, have a strong vocal line and their ocean are so beautiful. Replay are one of the best kpop debut song.
2020 and still crying! My heart still breaks everytime! But I just remember SHINee is 5 members; 4 humans & 1 angel👼 rip Jonghyun 😭
SHINee... 2019???..😭😭😭 good luck my boys ❤️❤️
Who watch October 2020 and still crying?! I Miss them 😭 Hope they will comeback soon:"
5️⃣HINee 💎forever
I was never so interested in Shinee, yet I liked their songs and perfomance and now seeing this after all this time I doubt they will ever dance and sing this song as lively as they used to, this song will always be remembered by all of us as treasure of them five.
i grow up with them. i grow up with this song. i love them. and all the memories, the person, I've got back then. this song means everything to me. i miss you shine, I miss you jjong-oppa. i miss my life back then.
I love u 5hinee.
2:49-2:53, 3:28-3:31 Taemin 👏🏼
3:05-3:08 Onew👏🏼
Este video me hizo llorar, extraño a Jonghyun, su voz era única :(
Forever Shinee!! 💎💙
It's 2020 and I'm still not over this.
No matter how many k pop artists I have known and loved
No matter how many new artists I come to know and love
Shinee has always been on top
And not coz they were the first kpop artist I ever heard.
They are actually the most talented, consistent and unique artists not only in the kpop industry but in the whole world
No matter what at the end of the day..I always find my way back to them...
They are the ones I listen to when I'm cooking, walking, sleeping...
They hit different
It's just Shinee makes me feel different
They shinee in their own way and touch our lives forever
It's never about the charts etc with shinee (though they rule their too)
It's never about views etc.
It's never about brining anyone down
They are on their own league
Whether it's REPLAY or DON'T CALL ME
I can listen to them all day all night on repeat mode
That's the power they hold
That's what legends are all about
And yeah SHINEE'S BACK
And I will always be here forever to support them
Forever 5SHINEE💙💙💙💙💙
💎SHINee💎SHINee 💎SHINee💎
I LOVE SHINEE SO MUCH 💎💎💎💎💎
永遠に好きな曲🫶🫶
Shinee is so resilient, incredibly talented, hardworking, and tough. They’re the absolute best at everything they do - losing the main vocalist 2 months prior to the concert did not dampen their performance (and mind you their performances are incredibly complex and difficult to execute) by any measure. SHINee is gonna go down in the history books as absolute legends.
I'm finally watching this and I can't stop sobbing.
Lee Jinki💎
Kim Jonghyun💎
Kim Kibum💎
Choi Minho💎
Lee Taemin💎
Always with SHINee❤️
「25.4.2021」
Después de casi cuatro años todavía no tengo el coraje de ver muchas presentaciones, hoy es mi primera vez escuchando replay desde el 2017, mi corazón se siente melancólico, feliz y orgulloso al mismo tiempo.
Trabajaste duro.
TW:// dec 18. This is my first time watching this performance since people started posting about it bc of how painful I knew it was going to be. It’s been almost 3 years since & I’ve found ways to cope ❤️ I felt a little stronger today and thought I was ready to watch them sing their debut song w/o him. I still cried, even harder when I saw what the shawols did in the crowd, but I’m so thankful to see how strong they were up there. Lord knows how hard that must have been, but they pushed through for Jjong and SHINee world. I’ve been a fan since 2009 so this song will always have a special place in my heart.
💎 5HINee Forever 💎
Aren't they the most iconic? No matter what era what age. They fit perfectly well in every way.
my respect for this group and fandom is endless
still too hard to watch this, they are not the same
Agreed
I usually never watch this performance older SHINee songs I have to have all 5 of them but this is still so beautiful and heartbreaking I loved SHINee since 2011 and still am here i love u SHINee 💎❤
Los amoooo bbs por ser tan fuertes y seguir adelante a pesar de todo 🥺 jjong te amo bb espero que de donde estés le des fuerzas a los bbs que deben extrañarte tanto así como todas las shawol del mundo 🌎 🇨🇱
LEE JINKI
KIM JONGHYUN
KIM KIBUM
CHOI MINHO
LEE TAEMIN
5HINee
💎💎💎💎💎
Hace 2 días salió el cover de TXT de Replay de SHINee, no saben como lloré, y hoy junte el valor para venir a ver el vídeo... mentiría si les digo que no estoy llorando, aún duele la perdida de Jonghyun... las Shawol son muy fuertes, nunca dejen morir si recuerdo❤
La presentación de TXT con Replay es la razón por la que estoy buscando tanto sobre esta banda 💜
Es raro querer llorar con esto si no soy fan?
@@dreaMinwitu no no es raro a mi me paso igual cuando supe la existencia de shinee, espero que cuando salgan del ejército nuevamente se junten. Vale la.pena escucharlos cantan bellísimo los 5.
感覺又想起那一場從頭到尾手上都抓著衛生紙的演唱會。
跟鐘鉉啊 真的很想你。
"FOREVER 5HINee"
💎💎💎💎💎
This is too painful to watch :(
FIGHTING GUYS !!! ❤❤❤❤❤ ALL THE BEST !!! LIFE MUST GO ON ❤❤❤❤❤
Did I tell this before?? SHINee world are the best ❤❤ specially J-Shawols they support our boys so much 💕
Remember to be strong Shawols. SHINee always will be 5.
Me gusta mucho ver la reacción de minho y taemin, lloro al verlos ,SHINee te quiero
Forever 5HINee ❤️
SHINee 💕
Shinee❤️
I miss you so much, Jjong 🩵💎🪽
Jenica Felix it’s a thing that might slip our minds at times, especially as the time flies... but there will be times where it slows and all you remember is the past. Beautiful times, times you wish never happened, and sadness. Thinking back on Jjong-ah and shinee, it was beautiful, still is. When you can still hear their voice, their smile flashes back as well, and you remember in that moment how much love and pain is in life. I hope you’re smiling, we miss you.
2021, I think no matter how many years pass by, I'll always cry with this video.
2:50 そこテミンなんだ😭
ておもって泣いちゃった
ジョンヒョン がいなきゃ、😢
I am crying again...T_T
Shinee é incrível❤Sempre brilhante mesmo passando por tanta dor com a ausência do Jonghyun😞eles foram muito fortes e por isso merecem nossos respeito e carinho❤❤❤❤❤
💞💞💞💞💔🇵🇱🫰🫠Dziękuję za piękny komentarz. Pozdrawiam z Polski.
My bravest boys!! Love u sm. Shinee is always 5 :’)
Shinee forever
any one here remember this in 23❤❤
Очень хорошая песня за душу берет так хочется за плакать но группа ШАЙНИ молодцы любимые наши группы и группа ВТS мы у Вас гостях Южная КОРЕЯ
Still cry years later watching this. I don't know how they made it through! Replay is the Best Debuet Song to this day. They preformed it like they always do like Jonghyun was there standing beside them.
Man I didn’t even know this group. Watching the one with JongHyun and now this one... so sad 😰
Banyak sekali yg sudah anak2 muda ini lalui.. dan mereka masih berdiri sampai sekarang... Sangat bangga tumbuh bersama SHINee
Did anyone else see the mini panic attack each of them had at the beginning?🥺
Thank you SHINee, Our precious JHyung is watching from above.🥺💎❤️
Once a shawol always a shawol💗 yes FOREVER 5HINEE💎💎jonghyun oppa you did so well. ILOVEYOU and I miss u so much💋💋 till we meet again💍💍🌹🌹❤❤
Love you so much