How Israel came into being ‘at the expense of Palestinians’ | Roy Casagranda | UNAPOLOGETIC
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 дек 2024
- “There is a place called Deir Yassin where they conduct a massacre and the hope was to cause panic in the Palestinian population to cause them to run away.”
Professor Roy Casagranda unpacks how antisemitism in Europe and the Zionist movement paved the way to Israel’s genesis and the Nakba.
See the full episode where Prof Roy Casagranda explains the 100-year history of the US and UK meddling in the Middle East here: • 100-year history of US...
Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH
Subscribe to MEE Telegram channel to stay up to date: t.me/MiddleEas...
Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye
Thank you for sharing the truth. I wish I could like this video a thousand times.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
It’s Israel today and there is nothing you can do about it.
@@echoe4806 it's what?* idk even YT don't allow me writing LUL how ironic*
@@echoe4806 The world has woken up to the crimes and lies of Israel, and to the arrogance displayed by pathetic persons like you. Israel will not last.
@echoee4806 nothing built on a weak foundation stays around for long. The foundation is definitely crumbling
@ Agree.After 1400 years of Arab colonialism it did happen and the Jews came home.Usually big empires are crumbling not small tiny countries…..
And the rest is genocide
There is no ge-nocide.
@@HamzaGrygoriREALLY 🤬🤬🤬🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴
The arabs have been calling for genocide of jews for decades
@@HamzaGrygori😂😂😂
@@HamzaGrygori aww a brand new bot has joined us
Brilliantly explain. The world must open the eyes
Explained
The Balfour Declaration had a massive effect on the end of WW1, the biggest single thing.
The Germans on the western front went home believing they were defeated at home by the strikes & the Zionist influenced politicians.
Herr Hitler & his followers called it the stab in the back.
The seeds of the Balfour Declaration ended WW1.
It started WW2 & will most probably start WW3.
Actually absolute nonsense by a nonentity that does not even warrant a Wikipedia entry
Polish man named Milikowsky changed his name to 'Benjamin Netanyahu' for look like jewish.
An Egyptian born in Cair0 on August 1929 by the name of - Mohammed Abdel Rahman Abdel Raouf Arafat al-Qudwa al-Husseini.
Before he migrated to the H0ly-Land, he chg his name to Yasser Arafat and later he claimed he was the indigenous people of the H0LY L@nd😂
he is jewish, and has semitic feature, looks a bit like bashar al-assad.
also, the only reason they had those European names was because they had lived in Europe for 2000 years after the romans had kicked their ancestors out of the Middle East to Europe during the Jewish-Roman wars and Bar-Kokba revolt.
I suppose you don't know that during the Jewish holocaust half of those killed were living in exile in Poland. Did that mean that Hitler killed them for being poolocks ?
@@PodcastCentral333if im from south India and my ancestors 2000ya were in iran,can I claim my land in persia back??😅😅
Any kind of religious you believes, whatever cultural norms you have, or what type of ideas u have all of it doesn't stop you to Saying "Israeli committed a genocide in qaza".
100%
That’s a hard argument to make when Gaza provoked Israel since 2007 and even harder when the Palestinian population has not stagnated or decreased.
Yawn
@arcane4848 really? Oh look there's 2 million of them, so killing 40+k isn't really murder? Person A killed my family, so I can go on a killing spree and kill everyone? What law school did you go to?
But it didn't. The population is now larger than it was a year ago
Thank you!
And now at the expense of the world......
He is on point here, 100% on point factually
Actually it's total deliciously fact free boule sheeet
10:38 my fathers family were part of this mass fleeing and my grandmother still had the front door key to this day
😢❤
The question
Why didnt the western colonial powers not stop this as it was in violation of the UN charter
The UN should have saved all these years of the fascist occupation of Palestine from ever being the cruel ongoing genocide its been
US UK France and Germany
You all have the guilt and blood on your hands for this
The UN at the time was controlled by Europe and countries of the Anglo-American diaspora. They didn't want to have to accept any of the Jewish displaced persons languishing in Europe and were indifferent to the ethnic cleansing of the Arabs, so Israel was accepted as a "peace-loving" member of the UN in 1949.
@@bobnto the mindset or propaganda over collective guilt for the holocaust of the west was a powerful political tool for israel and its actions in Palestine
@@donnrutherford7059The land was called Judeea anyway so they went back home.
@@echoe4806 😂
@@echoe4806😂
Yep.
And how conveniently the West ignore this!
Brilliant solution from the professor! 😂 Bravo, Sir 👏 Free Palestine 🇵🇸
It is an extremely lucid and concise account of the actual history. I commend you, sir!.
"The Jewish people are theonly people I know of who in thesame language, worship the samefaith, on the same land, in the samecountry, as they did 3000 years ago.That is a true indigenous people."
Then they steal their land culture and food and try to deny their existence
Roy is a true historian
As an aside, the Austrians speak a form of German, but they're primarily the descendants of Celtic tribes, not Germanic ones.
Fun fact almost all the EU infiltrator ministers changed their names to sound more Jewish
Benzion Netanyahu instead Bensyjon Milejkowski,
Shimon Peres instead Szymon Perski,
David Ben Gurion instead Dawid Gryń,
Golda Meir instead Golda Mabowicz,
Yitzhak Ben-Zvi instead Izaak Szymszelewicz,
Zalman Shazar instead Szneur Zalman Rubaszow,
Ben-Zion Dinur instead Ben-Zion Dinaburg,
Moshe Sneh instead Moshe Kleinbaum,
David Raziel instead Dawid Rosenson,
Yitzhak Shamir instead Icchak Jaziernicki,
Eliyahu Ben-Elissar instead Eli Gottlieb,
Aharon Amir instead Aharon Lipec,
Israel Eldad instead Izrael Scheib,
Shlomo Ben-Yosef instead Szalom Tabacznik
the only reason they had those European names was because they had lived in Europe for 2000 years after the romans had kicked their ancestors out of the Middle East to Europe during the Jewish-Roman wars and Bar-Kokba revolt.
@@EM.K024 An Egyptian change his name
From
Mohammed Abdel Rahman Abdel Raouf Arafat al-Qudwa al-Husseini.
To
Yasser Arafat
They were descendants of Khåzar Ukrainian converts from 6th century 😂 plain and simple, then they were kicked out all over EU 109 times for their corruption.
And so? What is wrong with that??
@@EM.K024 The Khazar myth has ben debunked many times.
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎If God exiles a people from a land
▪︎For their Transgressions,Wickedness
▪︎To reestablish State with Messiah
▪︎If reestablish State without Messiah
▪︎Righteous or Wicked?
Very well said and explained
Before the jews came from Mesopotamia land of Canaan was part of Egypt
We claim western Arabia, Palestine, Levant and southern Turkey in the name of Amun Ra, the ever present.
To deny us is antikemetic
As a 1/4 Buddhist 1/4 Christian, 1/4 Muslim and the other 1/4 from my mum´s dad´s side are Hindu,, in theory I get a free house in most of the world.. God told me i can have a Valley in Tibet, a Farm in Congo, an island in Indonesia and a Tea plantation in Kerala.. I´ve decided to raise my kids Jewish so they can get a water front condo on Gaza beach. God said it !! Not my fault.. Go n argue with God about it, n leave me out of it !! Iff you don´t like the plan that´s just because you don´t like GOD.. god hater!!
Exactly the Zionist logic.
It would've been witty if it wasn't true. 😓
Faith is not inherited race is
You are not Muslim at all if you are even 0.00001 percent of the other
Don’t confuse your self
Religion cannot be inherited
Yes when are born , regardless of to which family, we all are born in Islam
Then as we come of age we decide what our religion is according to our conditioning or our thinking and contemplating
And to search and research and think and study and compare then decide is right way
@@behuman3801 😊Exactly..
I know, logic of a godless thief 😂 and now murderer, rapist, all in the name of a myth.
As an Arab Mizrahi Jew from Babylonian Origins, I doubt the so called kingdom of Israel in Christian Bible.
ZIONAZIS/Romans probably twisted the bible to benefit themselves
As a Texan Ottoman born in Constantinople, I never doubted One True God. Join Muslims against prpht kllers, Muslim means believer of One True God.
Be careful Roy, You will no doubt be labelled an anti-semite 😂😂😂
Be proud to be an antisemite if that term relates to Zionists and their sick fascist agenda.
you guys really are poor people. you should be sad that these are the best guys you have. yes, he may seem funny to you, but this is the exact reason why you are just marxists and muslims vandalizing through streets and a couple arab states making use of their UN majority.
no one takes you seriously because you make clowns of yourselves the whole time. this is why you have achieved nothing.
jokes and lies wont help you. you need genuine honesty and good faith attempts at solving the issue of jihadists, otherwise Israel will always control the West Bank and Gaza.
I made a video on this topic, there are astonishing similarities between Pharaoh and modern day J3wz - and the Israelites and today's Palestinians. The story told in Quran will give you goose bumps. It's shocking how Israh3|| is behaving/acting exactly the same as Pharaoh did. I have tried to provide all the verses from the Quran. That's the first ever video on my channel.
do you have a link i cant find it
@@Flashh2124 It's on my channel. The very first video. RUclips won't allow links in comments section.
Which Pharoah ? If it's in the quaran then a story is what it is, a product of a pedophile war lords imagination.
You are lying
@@alizakessler I am not
So slick
Slimey, really.
Mad boy
Brian less UN
Who splits land in that way
All pieces here and there
So why couldn’t Arabs , Christians and Jews live together in that land called Palestine ?
There were some Zionists in Palestine who thought that could happen but they were outvoted by those with the colonist mentality. Essentially, the colonists were racist. They were not even kind to the 'Arab' Jews.
They were living peacefully together until the Zionists came after WWII.
They were. The trouble started when the Euro jews arrived
LUL they lived there 400year in peace until fake so called jews-zio come at pales to make chaos...
What a question, didn't they live that way b4 Zionists came and destroy everything? The Internet has all you just asked
It'd be like me, making accusations of anti-Sicilianism, while ruling over a good portion of the Northeast that my maternal great grandfather and paternal great granduncle, aka the ruthless King of the Night, ruled over during the 1920s
Zahir Muhsein was a Palestinian leader of the pro-Syria As-Sa'iqa Ba'athist faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization between 1971 and 1979.
In an interview with Trouw Magazine, 31. March 1977 he stated....."The Palestinian people do not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons. The establishment of a Palestinian state is a new tool to continue the fight against Israel and for Arab unity.
Yes, European Nationalism is what gave birth to the idea of a Jewish state. The old world did not think in terms of strict boundaries and ethno states. The idea of a Palestinian state became necessary as the natives were being pushed off their lands and killed.
He just talked about the only "democracy" in the Middle East 😂
Is there any other demogracy in the Middle East?
@echoe4806 There's none. There has never been one. Not even in the Western world, what there is, is a kleptocracy.
@@InformedGlobe Still better then the desert stuff.
@echoe4806 Right, just like jews don't want war, just genocide.
Apartheid and democracy is an oxymoron, so the idea that Israel is a democracy is patently ridiculous and untrue. A Brooklyn Jew can come and go, but an indigenous Palestinian has no right of return.
Easy target have no power in the world to depend itself during that time , with the help of the American and the British
I would have loved to hear about the archeology of the land and its relevance to the whole issue.
"We [Palestinians] were never an independent state in history, we were part of an Arab state and an Islamic state.” -- Palestinian Hamas Foreign Minister Mahmoud Zahhar (quoted in The Economist, February 2, 2008)
So how can you explain that Golda Meir herself had a Palestinian passport ?
@@rosek5927 h’mm that name sounds Yiddish, she must be Central European
If you studied the history of this area even just a little bit you will know this guy is spot on. If the Jews decided that they should have the same amount of land as their population compared to the Palestinians, Israel might have worked. Even that wouldnt have kept conflicts to zero, because far right extremists on both sides have always been the problem.
I’ve never heard any of these historians mention where the phrase , “ a pound of flesh “ originated from .
And senator in america said palestine doesn't exist only israel? Or did he mean AIPAC exist?😂😂
Hi Roy, would you be open to debating Gaad Saad?
He doesn’t have time to spare with certain people.
Iran will even the Score before long.
❤❤❤❤
Dreyfuss wasn’t german, when he was borne, Alsace pertained to France. 🇫🇷
BTW, It is still French…
Ah but Alsace was not historically a part of France but a part of the Holy Roman Empire, well most of it.
The partition resolution, UNGA 181, did not propose states that were exclusively Jewish and Arab, simply that Jews and Arabs would represent the majority in their respective states - Jew and Arab would retain equality of rights in both. Of course this was a fantasy and the UN would have known it: Arabs outnumbered Jews 2 to 1 in the Mandate and represented the majority in every sub-district but one. Jews were barely a majority within the boundaries of the state the UN had proposed and were a decided minority in the larger area the Zionists coveted - the Arabs had to go. So when the ethnic cleansing did occur, the UN just shrugged and set up UNRWA.
Typical Middle East eye comment section never fails to entertain. 🍿
The 1911 Encyclopedia Britannica defined Palestine as, “a geographical name of rather loose application.” If the Palestinians were an ancient indigenous group, then why did the 1911 Encyclopedia Britannica just forget to mention them in the entry on Palestine?
113 years ago? Yeah, that's when all historical and anthropological studies stopped evolving. May want to update your reserch material. A lot has happened since 1911 bub!
Maybe it’s because it is called Britannica? 🇬🇧
Are you serious ? Britain ? Have you listened to what was explained here ?
Could be some source bias... I wonder if Lawd Balfour knew the publisher! 😂
Who was the first prime minister, king or president Palestine 🤔
Who was the first prime minister of all countries before they actually became one? Be asking du mb question, like people on their lands don't exist before they become a country
@idayattijani5341 thanks for answering my question that there has never been a state called Palestine. So if that's the case, why are you not demonstrating for Kurdistan and all the other people that want a state but have never been one
what what a remarkable person. I thought he was Arab by the way he exposed western narratives on history. I am surprise she is Austrian
the professor is including the whole Arava as that land devoted to the Jewish state,
; it's all desert and uninhabitable;;
Thank you for showing us true history.
2'46" the Uganda lie
7'28 False equivalence.
The Dreyfus affair wasn’t ’interpreted as an attack on a Jewish person’, it was a moment of public antisemitic hysteria. Yes there were concerns about his loyalty towards France as a German Jew but he wouldn’t have been seen as an ethnic German but as an ethnic Jew. The reason why this was a catalyst for Zionism was because Dreyfus was highly assimilated and the kind of antisemitism seen in 1890s France showed that assimilation didn’t reduce antisemitism but create a new kind targeted against ‘hidden Jews’. You make it seem like Jews were just neurotic in their response to the Dreyfus affair
A Jew is not part of ethnic group nor is a muslim.
what crap. they did not welcome them.
Lol Abu Adam where were these guys for the past year from the real Muslim cause which is Palestine the holy land? Where are they from Gaza all the soldiers they have all the artillery they have in the name of Islam where are they? All of a sudden they just came out to slaughter Syrian people again come on talk to me and forget about this.Shia and Sunni stuff. Use your common sense. Use your conscience. Where are these? So-called Islamic rebels from Palestine where the real enemy is slaughtering people in Gaza that is the real enemy I’m just throwing it out there. It really doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure what’s going on, it’s the great Israeland the way you are talking. You are talking in support of that because these so-called Islamic fighters in Syria are western made, and Israeli made.
"Genesis" is a hint as to Israel's origins for the dummies who think Zionism is a modern European concept. Zionism is the heart of Judaism. Read "the book" if you don't understand this.
ISRAEL BALKIND THEODORE HERZLE BACKED BY LORD BALFOUR
Quite a poor summary containing a number of errors. Best to listen to Ilan Pappe or Avi Shlaim about this period.
Yes, this was on the glib side, casually talking about welcoming the Jews, which is somewhat simplistic and casual reference to the first big massacre of Palestinians. Ilan Pappe would do a better job and wouldn't try and summarise such a long period from the beginnings of zionism to the partition of Palestine in 11 minutes.
"271k
The idea of creating Israel in Europe is silly. Of course it has to go in ottoman territory. Sounds like the Palestinians had their chance, kept saying no and now they're left with nothing. Tough.
Modern state of Israel you mean!
There is only one Israel, the Modern one, the Old one was a Kingdom not the same thing, not even the same people.
Mispelled Israhell where Satanyahu dwells.
Poilievre: "The Jewish people are the
only people I know of who in the
same language, worship the same
faith, on the same land, in the same
country, as they did 3000 years ago.
That is a true indigenous people."
Una persona no se debe considerar judia por adoptar el judaismo como religion seria practicante de jufaismo
With a little bit of truth and a lot of lies you can easily make an alternative history. This "professor" is full of sh1t😂
The name Jew it self is ancient 😂😂😂
The religion is ancient, religion judaism in its earlier forms, but modern religion does not determine where you belong but being a native of your nation. The only jews that are natives to palestine are palestinians arabs jews, who were already living there among rest of palestinias, before zionism radical nationalist ideology arrived there. The rest are inmigrants and refugees who happened to practice modern judaism. I can tomorrow turned into Judaism, why it will give me any right to claim palestine. By that thinking any Christian in the world can claim palestine because the historical and religious connection, but such right does not exist. Not only absurd and delusional but a lie to just justify plain modern illegall. colonialism nothing else.
@LukesGwaza...Nah, the letter "J" did`nt excist until the 15th century AD..look it up!
"Zionism and Judaism are Diametrically Opposed "
Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro.
Who Cares.???
My appeal to every Muslim, my brother or sister, the owner of the channel, I know that it is not my right to comment on your channel, but God is my witness that our circumstances are harsh and forced me to do this. Please forgive me. My brother, there is still a brotherhood of faith. I asked you for a bag of flour. My brother, we women cannot go out among men. There is still a woman with you. My brother, God has honored you. You are men. We are women. We cannot go out or work like you. My brother, where is the brotherhood of faith in your hearts? We are women. There is no brotherhood, no mercy, no compassion, no humanity. And give good tidings to the patient. It is the greatest hope while waiting for what we want. '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' How many times I called and talked and tried hard, but no one responded. Oh man, we are with you. My mother ordered us food from the restaurant. More and today. My mother left. Crying. She said, Why are you crying, my mother? She said, My daughter, I ask. God, that I may be honored by death. She said, Why, my mother. She cursed us. She said, "My daughter, today the restaurant owner insulted me. I said, 'Why?' I said, 'How can I be better than people?' I ask God, my daughter. May God gather me. With death alone, a gathering that is better than this humiliation and this humiliation. It is true. I am saying this. It diminishes my value and respect. But, man. I swear to God that I did not say this. I kiss your boots. I am so hungry that my conscience no longer allows me to let you go and ask us for food. I kiss your boots, man, and I ask you by God Almighty and in the Book of God, man, I kiss your boots, man. He has caused us harm, my brother, so that we can buy a kilo of flour and pay the rent. My brother, have mercy on us. He who is in the show will have mercy on you, He who is in the sky. My brother, this is my WhatsApp number: *00967717126434* . Whoever can help us, message me on WhatsApp. We will send him the full name. He will transfer us as much as he can. May Allah reward you. Allah knows that my family and I, our house rent is 15 thousand Yemeni riyals per month, and now we owe 45 thousand for 3 months. The owner of the house is one of those people who do not have mercy. By Allah, my brother, he comes every day and humiliates us and talks about us and wants to throw us out of the house and into the street because we were unable to pay him the rent. We will have until the end of the week, and if we pay him, he will swear by Allah that he will throw us out into the street without mercy. See my situation for yourselves. I ask you by Allah, the Living, the Eternal, to help me. By Allah, the Almighty, even at night we cannot sleep from fear. We do not have mattresses or blankets to warm ourselves from the cold. Everything is flooded from the rain, and we have no one but Allah and then you. My brothers, I kiss your boots, don’t turn me away empty-handed. Help us with whatever you can. Is it acceptable to you that we live in this place? We are girls and we have no one. Our father died in a car accident. Consider us your daughters and your honor, and help me with whatever you can. May God reward you with good =>[[}>] ^][/*&;;&;&&;•̥·-`.`.`.`.`.•.,¸-•.,¸°꒰·̮ •̥·°`.`.`… nn…...............l ...... ……… .j… ,,,……… ..i. .......l,.. ,..............jl. .. ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,i,,,,,____
Sister You can open your own channel so you can earn money ❤
It will take time but you should try,
If I be honest with you then I'll say that no one is going to trust on you because there are a lot scammer online please don't take me wrong
@@Singh....406 I suspect these dumb requests are put out by Hasbara bots...
@@Singh....406 THIS IS A SCAMMER MOST LIKELY ANOTHER ISREALI SCAM
Two peoples have a claim to the land of Palestine.
Ernest Bevin (then UK Foreign Minister) summed it up best in 1947 when UK passed the Palestine mandate to the UN. "This problem is incapable of resolution. The first and overwhelming priority of the Jews is to have a Jewish state. The first and overwhelming priority of the Arabs (as the Palestinians were then known) is that the Jews should not have a Jewish state".
The trouble is that the Palestinians are resolutely opposed to sharing the land of historic Palestine with the Jews on any basis.
And, the tragedy for them is that the Palestinians could have had 80% of Mandate Palestine (1937 Peel Commission) and then 50% (1947 UN Partition … and their 50% excluded the Negev desert). More recently, they were offered self-determination on successive occasions by Rabin, Barak and Olmert … and turned it down on every occasion!
Now, they'll be lucky to get 20% of the land.
What spectacularly misguided leadership ... to choose so-called "resistance" (but, in truth, just violence and terrorism) every time, instead of any one of multiple pragmatic solutions that would have given them a state to build on.
The Palestinians go on and on about the Nakba as though they were the only people in history to suffer an injustice.
At the same time as the Nakba, more than 600,000 Jews were forced to flee the Arab countries of the Middle East.
Since then ...
NO dedicated UN refugee agency for Jewish refugees;
NOT 1 Jewish refugee camp;
NOT $1 of UN aid to the Jewish refugees; and
NOT 1 claim by Jewish refugees for right of return to their countries of origin.
Instead of wallowing in self-pity and victimhood, they got on with their lives. If the Palestinians had only done the same, what a wonderful and thriving state they could have had by now. Instead, they took the easy way out ... clinging to their refugee status for 76 years, and going with a begging bowl to seek charity for their survival ... UNWRA since 1947(!), and billions and billions of $ of foreign aid from all the Western countries they so despise. Have they no pride.
So, while the sorrow for their plight runs deep, there’s not much respect to go with the sorrow.
No, one group of people has a claim to Palestine - the indigenous population. German, Russian, Polish, Hungarian Jews etc are not indigenous to Palestine.
This guy keeps referring to an event that never happened in Europe that you cannot refer to never having happened on RUclips.
"Never forget this one point: There is no such thing as a Palestinian people, there is no Palestinian entity, there is only Syria. You are an integral part of the Syrian people, Palestine is an integral part of Syria." Syrian President Hafez al-Assad [Addressing the Chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization Yasser Arafat during a meeting with leaders of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) in 1976]
No, Israel was not born at the expense of anyone..!
Jews were put in a desert because nobody wanted them.
He made a mistake by using the term Palestinians in 1948.The term was first used by Yasser Arafat in 1964 to differentiate from Arab Jews in Israel that got citizenship.
Just one of the propaganda lies leading to the lie that is Israel. The word
Palestine goes back to Roman times & owes it’s origins to a far old similar Egyptian word
@ Do you know any Palestinian kings? What language were they speaking????
How come that during Roman Empire censuses the Jews were the majority?
How come Palestine was never mentioned in the Torah,Bible or Quran?????
You sound du mb how come China,America, Argentina, Nigeria were not mentioned in the bible quran and toarh dumm y
@@echoe4806 You do know that contemporary Palestinians are the modern group most closely descendent from the Hebrews of antiquity. As the secular Jews the Romans never exiled mostly over time assimilated into Greek & Syriac christians of the Eastern Roman / Byzantine Empire, then during the caliphate they mostly assimilated into the Arab culture of the elite. the caliphate was huge, being spread from Spain to Western China, outside of the Arab Peninsula, so Peninsula Arabs only ever formed a tiny elite outside of the Peninsula. This is why modern Egyptians have basically the same DNA as ancient Egyptians, the Lebanese have the same DNA as the Phoenician Sailors of the Punic age & the Palestinian DNA matches that on the Hebrews of antiquity, unlike European Jews that have essentially no maternal Hebrew DNA.
@ Palestinians are just Arabs like the 2 million Arab Jews citizens of Israel or Jordanians,Egyptians etc…
"Such a creature as Palestine does not exist at all." (Ahmad Shukan , Saudi Ambassador to the UN, 1956)
You misspelled liar 🤥
"Such a monster as Shitrael does not exist at all" (Uvuweuwevuvuvuweb- Rohirim Ambassador, 3500 BCE) 😂😅 🤮🤮
This is a very soft and diluted version of what happened. There were no 'maybes' about what they wanted and where it was, this version is so weak and off the mark.
"There is no such thing as Palestine in history, absolutely not." -- Arab Princeton Professor, Philip Hitti, before the Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry in Jerusalem in 1946.
Great there was no America in history either until 248 years ago. Same logic
@@reaazali6347 Not the same logic! Try again.
Israel is a "Pariah State "
UN Rapporteur, Francesca Albanese...
The 3rd Oldest Christian Church in the World is Located in Gaza Palestine.
St Pophyrious Orthodox Church, Dating back to 425 C E.
Prior to the Creation of Israel, Jews, Muslims, Christians lived together peacefully.
@KingForever-zu5jl
Clumsey effort,there is a place called Israhell where Satanyahu dwells.
The Kingdom of Israel existed 1000 years before the Romans invented Syria Palestina and 3000 years before the British invented Palestine.
The kingdom of israel was a medieval kingdom. Its not the same as the apartheid state it is today
@@blackflag6976 When you people think you own the words Genocide and Apartheid. Terrorists don't get rights !
Imagine thinking the kingdom of Israel from thousands of year ago along with its people is the same as today.
That’s equivalent to a group of people creating a new group and calling themselves Canaanite’s and saying “we were there before Israel, it’s our land”… grow a brain.
@blackflag6976 The medieval period started 1500 years after the kingdom of Israel was created. It was also in Europe.
lol why start from kingdom of israel? let's start from the Canaan.
The Arab colony extends from Iraq to Tunisia. Surely they could spare some room for the indigenous Jews?
The ones from Europe are neither indigenous nor owned the land nor had a relative that lived in Palestine nor had connections with the middle east. The only indigenous ones were the Palestinian jew who spoke Arabic and identified as Arabs and owned the land they lived on. Read a book.
The word "Arab" refers to people with different ethnic backgrounds that adopted Arabic as their first languages. This is why Lebanese, Egyptians, Saudis, etc are genetically different from each other. and this is why Arabs have massively different looks, skin color and facial features. What do called 'Arabs' nowadays are nothing but a continuation of their 'non-Arab' ancestors. They are natives to a great extent to the land and especially the Palestinians. DNA does not lie.
@@Esoterica-Arabicexactly. 2017 and 2020 DNA tests confirm that Palestnians are the original people of that land.
Exactly. DNA tests conclude that Palestinians are the Levantines the original people of that land.
@@Esoterica-Arabic ..."every Palestinian, in Gaza and throughout Palestine, can prove his Arab roots - whether from Saudi Arabia, from Yemen, or anywhere. We have blood ties. Personally, half my family is Egyptian. We are all like that. More than 30 families in the Gaza Strip are called Al-Masri ["Egyptian"]. Brothers, half of the Palestinians are Egyptians and the other half are Saudis. Who are the Palestinians? We have many families called Al-Masri, whose roots are Egyptian. Egyptian! They may be from Alexandria, from Cairo, from Dumietta, from the North, from Aswan, from Upper Egypt. We are Egyptians."
Hamas Minister of the Interior and of National Security Fathi Hammad, aired by Al-Hekma TV on March 23, 2012.
The so called Palestinians are not even from the region known as Palestine!!!!!!
www.memri.org/tv/hamas-minister-interior-and-national-security-fathi-hammad-slams-egypt-over-fuel-shortage-gaza
Wow, some small manipulations with facts, dates and names makes huge difference in entire story. You do really good job with it. Who subsidize that really good almost truly story?
What are the small manipulations?
For example,
1. “at the end of 19 century Palestinians…”. Not only arabs were” Palestinians” at that time. Arabs starter to call them self like this about 1965. Before that every body who lived there was “Palestinian”. First Israeli prime minister had Palestinian passport.
2. “Rename Austrian city to Jerusalem” It is a main point, Jerusalem is 5000 years old and always was in every Jew heart.
3. “Arabs let Jews in their houses”. Rich Jews were buying lands and hired “ seasonal workers” -local Arabs. NP. Later Jew from Russian Empire started to arrive and rich Jews, started to hire them instead. Is it unfair for local Arabs? Yes. Is it a crime? No.
4. “After declaring Israel- it won the war with 5 countries” It sounds at least interesting. Israel attacked 5 Arab neighbours??? With population more than 10 times greater??? Really??? Israel won, but it was so close to be destroyed.
A lot of small things in that story. I can continue with almost every aspect of this story. It is a very good made up speech
Hahaha
The language is hybrid not Hebrew
The man is massively manipulating..
oh please shut up
Lies
So much BS in his narrative
How is it at the expense of the Palestinians if Palestine never existed?
Here comes and idiot.
Obtuse much eh
@reaazali6347 talk to me with facts
I think you might be getting hung up on semantics. Look at it ontologically.
People, who you don't have to call Palestinian if you don't want to, are being slaughtered. Have been... continue to be, worse than ever, in that region. Most of them women and children.
So let's not call them Palestinian. Okay. Is that your argument for supporting what's going on?
What with all the background history of Israel and their balical connection to the land of Israel ? What with the jews who came from the Arab world ? you tells only what you want and not the real relevant parts..
@@WhiteBlue-g2h
Just G00GLE - first king of Israel
It's not their land simple no point going into religious books.
@ 🤣the fact the land in west bank was called Judea and Samaria, ancient city of Izzrael.
If Arabs/Palestinians lost their land rights when ancient Israelites came in and conquered them, then so did Israelites lose their right when they were conquered---multiple times, by Assyria, Babylon, Rome...
@
Their land were given back to them by United Nation in 1947.
Izzrael just received it.
Thank you for UN Resolution 181 Two States partitioning!🤗
Palestinians rejected a state for themselves in 1947 and have done so since. Stop peddling lies.
Reject a state on their lands stolen and divided, can you give me your house and stay in the store room?
Oh, you are not aware that Arabs and Islam conquered, occupied, and colonized the Holy Lands from the 7th to the 19th century. That makes it 12 centuries of occupation and oppression of the indigenous people of the area. The place was originally called Judea and Samaria. The West Bank is a recent invention, as is Palestine.
^ Oh you’re not aware of the land of Canaanite’s which was stolen by the Israelites who colonized and forced them out? 12 centuries of occupation by Arabs? Lmao…. Read a history book.
wow,,...what a load of shit...
An offended Zionist
No guy, I have two degrees in History, this was a great synopsis. The Zionists stole that land. Colonial project of the west 100%
The facts never hurt unless they have to. Grow up.
Does the truth hurt you Zionist?
Truth Hurts...
The Nakba? Coined by Syrian professor Constantine Zureiq in his book Ma'na al Nakba. According to professor Zureiq, the meaning of the Nakba, 'the catastrophe', was the failure of seven arab armies to eradicate the Jewish state in 1948. The failure to commit the genocide they set out to commit. Of course these people try to change and twist the meaning of Nakba in order to make it more palatable, a lamentation of victimhood, which it is not. For the same reasons they try to narrow the meaning of Jihad, or Intifada, so it's not quite as hateful or violent.
What a shallow ridiculous speech.
Thats his narrative…. It doesn’t make it true… you can see the jew hate in him
B.S.
Always the victim. Seen any videos out of Gaza, recently? How nice that you're not forced to live there.
@@sculpy2758 what about what hamas has done… is that ok?! Hamas was voted into power… meaning that most majority want hamas and have the same ideology… to kill the jews!!!
@@roysonne learn history… not just a narrative!!
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
"There is no such thing as Palestine in history, absolutely not." -- Arab Princeton Professor, Philip Hitti, before the Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry in Jerusalem in 1946.
In 1937, Secretary of the Arab Higher Committee to the British Peel Commission, Awni Abd al-Hadi stated: “There is no such country as Palestine. ‘Palestine’ is a term the Zionists invented.”
"We [Palestinians] were never an independent state in history, we were part of an Arab state and an Islamic state.” -- Palestinian Hamas Foreign Minister Mahmoud Zahhar (quoted in The Economist, February 2, 2008)
"Never forget this one point: There is no such thing as a Palestinian people, there is no Palestinian entity, there is only Syria. You are an integral part of the Syrian people, Palestine is an integral part of Syria." Syrian President Hafez al-Assad [Addressing the Chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organization Yasser Arafat during a meeting with leaders of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) in 1976]
Zahir Muhsein was a Palestinian leader of the pro-Syria As-Sa'iqa Ba'athist faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization between 1971 and 1979.
In an interview with Trouw Magazine, 31. March 1977 he stated....."The Palestinian people do not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons. The establishment of a Palestinian state is a new tool to continue the fight against Israel and for Arab unity.
'There has never been a land known as Palestine governed by Palestinians. Palestinians are Arabs indistinguishable from Jordanians (another recent invention), Syrians, Iraqis etc. Keep in mind that the Arabs control 99.9 per cent of the Middle East lands. Israel represents one tenth of one per cent. But that is too much for the Arabs. They want it all. And that is ultimately what the fighting in Israel is about today...no matter how many land concessions the Israelis make, it will never be enough''. (Arab writer and historian Joseph Farah in his book Myths of the Middle East October 2000.)
"Such a creature as Palestine does not exist at all." (Ahmad Shukan , Saudi Ambassador to the UN, 1956)
@KingForever...
The 3rd Oldest Christian Church in the World is Located in Gaza Palestine.
St Pophyrious Orthodox Church, Dating back to 425 C E..
Revelation 2;9...
The Jews that say they are Jews and are not.