@@edwardanthony7283 - Robin was definitely the SOUL and HEART. Barry being oldest was the leader. Robin was considered "the best white soul singer of his time" by peers and critics. Simply a fact. His voice, as Mo said, was "The voice that grabbed your heart" and Barry said his was the best voice in the group. Recently in an interview, the interviewer said "Robin was the best recorded pop voice in history". Barry's response was "You'll get no argument from me". Their words, not mine. Go argue with Barry, LOL. NOBODY was "the best" although I also prefer Robin's voice. Don't forget Robin co-composed most of their songs once he became 15 years old and after.
Oh gorgeous, talented Robin. What a unique and beautiful voice. I love this sad but beautiful song. Most of all I Love sweet Robin and miss him terribly.
the best band in history, THE GIBB BROTHERS.... I have almostvall of their 700 plus songs,and this super underrated gem is one of the best ones. what a voice had ROBIN,,,,R.I.P.
This is the first ever Bee Gees song I heard in the radio when I was very young. Listen to it now brings back all the memories of 60s. Robin's got the most magnetic voice among all the singers in the world. Still is.
Just when I think I wont find another beautiful song by the BeeGees I find another. It seems never ending. So many songs that are new to me. Love them all.
Linda vidoebuff Yes, I know just how you feel!....Every time when I think I've finally at least narrowed it down to the top 5 amazing favorites...then I bump into some little 'beauty' like this one here!....and they all look so friggin young, sweet, and absolutely gorgeous to me here!....and they can sing like angels to boot!Lol.
They were very young and sweet and beautiful. I love the sideburns also. Its hard to believe that they were around so long ago in the sixties. Love them.
A beautiful voice (Robin Gibb) in this song, I haven't heard this song for a long time, now I can hearing it and will be repeating for many times !!! Nice Song and nice voice.
What a wonderful song! ROBIN's voice is the best of it. I'm impressed by the accuracy of their musical notes. An emotional song. BARRY harmonies are perfect with ROBIN. I love music BEE GEES. BEE GEES Love. Thanks for sharing WebTwinkle love. BEE GEES MY LIFE. - ............................................... Qué canción maravillosa! La voz de ROBIN, es lo mejor de ella. Me impresiona la precisión en sus notas musicales. Una canción emocional. Las armonías de BARRY con ROBIN son perfectas. Amo la música de BEE GEES. Amo a BEE GEES. Gracias WebTwinkle por compartir con amor. BEE GEES MI VIDA.-
+ BeeGeesMiAmor. "BARRY harmonies are perfect with ROBIN." You're spot on! Unfortunately it ended up wit ROBIN harmonising for Barry, and that ruined their music big TIME!
Love this song so much. Robin has such a unique voice and Barry has the most perfect vibrato in this genius piece that they all wrote together. Love all of them for their voices, personalities and their ability to write such an assortment of songs. I never tire of their songs and I've been listening to them for years! May God Bless Barry! RIP Andy, Mo and Robin. I'm sure you are singing with the angels!
+ lillangbg + Barry later began singing falsetto, not with vibrato. The vibrato was Robin. -------------------- Barry comenzó a cantar mas tarde con ¨falsete", no con vibrato. El vibrato fué de Robin.
+lillangbg. Barry has never sang with vibrato, he had tremolo. Robin is the only Gibb brother that had vibrato, which affects his pitch. It was very fast. Their engineer said this years ago, including the brothers. Barry, Andy, and Mo could quite often sound alike, but their was no mistaken Robin's voice from anyone in pop history. Robin also had a much higher vocal than any of them, not to mention he could sing in falsetto.
Then you might tell Barry that he didn´t/don´t have vibrato. In several invervieuws he talks about it. Comparing his vibrato to Robin;s. He calls his vibrato much slower but still a vibrato.
I also grown up in HK, that song impressed me so so much, we really watched it on TVB a lot. But I still love this song very much. Bring me a lot of memory of that time.
The first time I saw this clip was in 1969-70 and it was the first Bee Gees' song I heard. Apart from Massachusetts, The Singer Sang His Song was and still my favorite BG song.
estos eran mis Bee Gees favoritos de los sesenta y setenta !!! donde Robin figuraba cómo el primer vocalista , el siempre fue mi favorito !!!!grande Robin Gibb!!!!grande Beegees!!!💔💔❤
Loved the Bee Gees when I was young listening to the top 40 station on the little transistor radio. Great memories. Sad to see so many people leaving us.
The best voice of the Bee Gee,s l don, t think he really knew how brilliant his voice was ,so rare and exquisite ,just unique ,l love listening to all he sings ,Beautiful Amazing .singing with the angels darling RIP you lovely man .love to you Paula xxx .
Yes. He was 6 when he first went on a stage, so he had 12 years experience,. Plus, when people start that young, it is as if each year at that point is like 1 1/4 years later on.
@@rhondaclark4173 t 2020 marked 60 years since their first appearance on Australian TV Have you seen a video clip where Robin sings "out of time" by the Stones, he would have been maybe 16. I think it might have been short time before they left for England, check out Barry's pants and the way Maurice is dressed. So hip. For that time.
@@juanita6479 Oh so sorry, hopeless at those things. Try searching on You tube for -out of time bee gees Australia- ,hopefully it will come up for you. It was never shown on TV, but they kept it in the archives.
Robin would have been 16/17, I reckon it was not long before they moved back to England, looking at what Barry and Maurice are wearing, Robin is still in his suit, absolute stunning performance, can't believe it never got on tv
@@juanita6479 I totally agree, my brother was into the Stones, Janice Joplin, Jimi Hendrixand so on and I just loved the Bee Gees from the first time I heard them, when I came across the song it just took me straight back to that time, also such an unexpected style from Robin. Now that I have time on my hand, I have seen a lot of videos of interviews and performances of them, so addictive. Apparently I am not the only one. If only I could have seen all three brothers in concert, but was able to see Barry about 6/7 years when he had concerts in Brisbane. It is nice to know they still have so many fans, their music doesn't age, my kids and partners like them too.
Wow Robin . Was für eine einmalige Stimme. Ich bin mit den BEE GEES aufgewachsen. Aber Robin war meine grosse Liebe. Ist er heute noch. Ich vermisse ihn . R I P ROBIN 🤣🙋♀️💘
That was part of why Robin left the band. Barry's songs got the A-side and Robin got the B-side. Barry finally manned up and expressed is regret only after Robin and Mo were gone.
@@jduff59 The same with "Spicks and Specks" (Barry) and "I Am The World" (Robin). If you want to know what a great song IATW is, just listen to the "New Version" released by Robin four years before he died.
Which beautiful song ... They were at the beginning of his career ... So young and able to write a song like this ... The lyrics seem simple but profound thought contained therein ... Thank you!
Underrated understated and God forsaken when they thought he was back ground singer to a band that just made it..they were foolish for the taking. Millions of albums later he is a bad boy ground shaker
@@nobodyspecial6267 yes I agree, he should have been given the opportunity to be in the forefront when they started out his voice just got better and stronger and was so underrated. He was truly a beautiful talented performer!!💖💖
They all three worked as a team, they were a unit and all 3 had their own angelic voices, including Maurice, it kills me why people have to say who was the better Bee Gee !
I think it's fine that people have their favorite. It's what appeals to each persons individual taste! I looove Robins voice, the best by far for me. But I Adore Barry's natural baritone voice as well. I really enjoy when Barry and Robin would trade-off on the lyrics! The Best! And Mo was the perfect harmonizing voice!!😉
Absolutely, we all have an opinion, but that doesn't make it true. Stop slamming one of them, usually Barry, to build up the one you favor,usually Robin. Robin and Maurice were just as good as and just as important as Barry. They were equals, and they all three made up the Bee Gees.
@@brcfan9 Maybe you should read my comment again! I wasn't slamming any of the brothers, as they are my favorite musical group. I have everything they ever did from the Australian recordings & even their unreleased material. Every LP from “67” to “2001” So stop your whining!
Going back to the Sound of the Nations with the Bee-Gees....The Singer Sang His Song....Well if this ain't a "masterpiece" by Robin & his Brothers..... then I don't know it anymore by myself....If we must compare this video to "nowadays music performances".... the choice is "easily-made" otherwise there wouldn't be more than 100.000 vieuwers.... and to those who don't like it.....no hard feelings to you....but I wonder if you've got "brains"?
In March, 1968, several of the Drake programmed stations played this as an A side, instead of Jumbo, but it didn't fare too well. Great tune. Highly underrated.
So, so beautiful! Oh, Robin....what a talent. 😢
Brilliant Robin Gibb! Just beyond BRILLIANT!!! 💕💕💕
THE voice … Robin Gibb … ❤❤
I can't believe I never knew this song existed! Robin was definitely the best bee gee. His voice always touched me.
Barry was the best & was the heart, soul & brains behind the artwork.
Sad he barely made it past 60.
@@edwardanthony7283 - Robin was definitely the SOUL and HEART. Barry being oldest was the leader. Robin was considered "the best white soul singer of his time" by peers and critics. Simply a fact. His voice, as Mo said, was "The voice that grabbed your heart" and Barry said his was the best voice in the group. Recently in an interview, the interviewer said "Robin was the best recorded pop voice in history". Barry's response was "You'll get no argument from me". Their words, not mine. Go argue with Barry, LOL. NOBODY was "the best" although I also prefer Robin's voice. Don't forget Robin co-composed most of their songs once he became 15 years old and after.
Me too, i love This song
I still love robins voice up to this day
Never heard this as song. And I thought I had heard everything the bee Gees had done. As usual Robin made it beautiful and remembered.
The reason you haven't heard this song before it's because the stupid record company Atco put it on the B side of a non hit called jumbo
Beautiful Robin and his wonderful voice.
Yes Robin with the crying voice every song is a hit Go Bee Gees forever
Bee Gees had too many beautiful songs. This song sung by Robin is one of them. 😍
Diese Stimme geht direkt in die Seele.
Beautiful Robin, and his beautiful voice !!
The only band that could truly write for every genre, pure genius!
Oh gorgeous, talented Robin. What a unique and beautiful voice. I love this sad but beautiful song. Most of all I Love sweet Robin and miss him terribly.
For eternity the most beautiful voice, Robin ❤️❤️❤️
the best band in history, THE GIBB BROTHERS.... I have almostvall of their 700 plus songs,and this super underrated gem is one of the best ones. what a voice had ROBIN,,,,R.I.P.
He seems to sing so effortless but puts so much heart and soul into his singing!
This is the first ever Bee Gees song I heard in the radio when I was very young. Listen to it now brings back all the memories of 60s. Robin's got the most magnetic voice among all the singers in the world. Still is.
Yes, agree
Very much agree with you! It's so beautiful, unique and extraordinary.
Ll
tengo la misma opinión !!! la voz dulce de Robin NO se compara con ninguna es única !!!!
I feel the same 😉
Underbar sång skriven av Barry och Robin. Lyssnar varje dag älskar denna låt. 🥰
I feel the same 😉
Absolutely gorgeous! Wow! So happy that i can listen to this here on RUclips! There is no one like Robin Gibb!
Hearing Robins voice makes me want to cry. I love and miss so much. There will never be another that even comes close. RIP my sweet Robin
I love Robin and his phenomenal voice. He was the best singer of the 3 in my opinion. I'am so thankful for his music and his videos.
The music wrote Mo
Yes agree
Robin only sang in a quivering vibrato, which is by far the best in the group.
Just when I think I wont find another beautiful song by the BeeGees I find another. It seems never ending. So many songs that are new to me. Love them all.
+Linda vidoebuff Its a fabulous journey isn't it? So many of us fans have had the same wonderful experience after discovering YT.
+allymayful It surely is a journey of discovery. I've never,ever heard this one before!!
Linda vidoebuff Yes, I know just how you feel!....Every time when I think I've finally at least narrowed it down to the top 5 amazing favorites...then I bump into some little 'beauty' like this one here!....and they all look so friggin young, sweet, and absolutely gorgeous to me here!....and they can sing like angels to boot!Lol.
They were very young and sweet and beautiful. I love the sideburns also. Its hard to believe that they were around so long ago in the sixties. Love them.
Linda vidoebuff So bloody true!!!
If only I could go back to these happier days and understand them more!
Robin, R.I.P. We love your unique voice and singing skill forever and ever !!!!
I just love this song.. and Robins voice and facial expressions are Sooo beautiful!!
Beautiful! Miss you, Robin, your vibrato was angelic.
robins voice, so perfect. I miss him and continue to listen to his music and will forever R.I.P
The angelic gifted voice from God! Rip Robin u are truly missed!
Love Robin 4 ever .... what a loss and what a treasure
A beautiful voice (Robin Gibb) in this song, I haven't heard this song for a long time, now I can hearing it and will be repeating for many times !!! Nice Song and nice voice.
Robin has the best eyes and voice. Mo said this was his favorite song.
Because it describes the life of stage performers.
I agree you
Maurice had gorgeous eyes 👀
Robin voice Best all of Time.Beeges the Best. My favorite Robin.
I love Robin...I think he was the one that felt.
Beautiful song.. and briliant singer!!
Ganz toll😆
LOVE THIS VIDEO IT SHOWS LOVE HAS NO COLOR YAAAAAY BEE GEES 😊
What a wonderful song!
ROBIN's voice is the best of it.
I'm impressed by the accuracy of their musical notes.
An emotional song.
BARRY harmonies are perfect with ROBIN.
I love music BEE GEES.
BEE GEES Love.
Thanks for sharing WebTwinkle love.
BEE GEES MY LIFE. -
...............................................
Qué canción maravillosa!
La voz de ROBIN, es lo mejor de ella.
Me impresiona la precisión en sus notas musicales.
Una canción emocional.
Las armonías de BARRY con ROBIN son perfectas.
Amo la música de BEE GEES.
Amo a BEE GEES.
Gracias WebTwinkle por compartir con amor.
BEE GEES MI VIDA.-
+ BeeGeesMiAmor. "BARRY harmonies are perfect with ROBIN." You're spot on! Unfortunately it ended up wit ROBIN harmonising for Barry, and that ruined their music big TIME!
Nice
A Legend will never be another...
This song is very beautiful ,and so is Robin.His beautiful brown eyes ,and his voice.No one come close too him.I love him♥️
Agreed
❤he’s hopefully 🤞 taken by me,myself and my shadow…😊😊😊
Love this song so much. Robin has such a unique voice and Barry has the most perfect vibrato in this genius piece that they all wrote together. Love all of them for their voices, personalities and their ability to write such an assortment of songs. I never tire of their songs and I've been listening to them for years! May God Bless Barry! RIP Andy, Mo and Robin. I'm sure you are singing with the angels!
Barry doesn't have vibrato, that's Robin.
Barry started to sing with more vibrato later, but hes is much slower. Robin had a very quick vibrato, that´s how you can tell them apart.
+ lillangbg + Barry later began singing falsetto, not with vibrato. The vibrato was Robin. -------------------- Barry comenzó a cantar mas tarde con ¨falsete", no con vibrato. El vibrato fué de Robin.
+lillangbg. Barry has never sang with vibrato, he had tremolo. Robin is the only Gibb brother that had vibrato, which affects his pitch. It was very fast. Their engineer said this years ago, including the brothers. Barry, Andy, and Mo could quite often sound alike, but their was no mistaken Robin's voice from anyone in pop history. Robin also had a much higher vocal than any of them, not to mention he could sing in falsetto.
Then you might tell Barry that he didn´t/don´t have vibrato. In several invervieuws he talks about it. Comparing his vibrato to Robin;s. He calls his vibrato much slower but still a vibrato.
I love this sexy guy! I love his wonderful voice. I also love his beautiful lips. Gorgeous. There will never be another like Robin Gibb. ❤️🌹❤️
@GoPro2000 That's a matter of taste, but Robin was consistently good looking for 20 years at least. There was something about him...
and those beautiful expressive hands
Desde sempre Robin encanta quando canta!!! Amo Bee Gees... louca por Robin ❤❤❤
I also grown up in HK, that song impressed me so so much, we really watched it on TVB a lot. But I still love this song very much. Bring me a lot of memory of that time.
mi favorito Robin Gibb nadie cómo tu grandioso Robin !!! gracias lindo vídeo 👏👏👏👏
The first time I saw this clip was in 1969-70 and it was the first Bee Gees' song I heard. Apart from Massachusetts, The Singer Sang His Song was and still my favorite BG song.
estos eran mis Bee Gees favoritos de los sesenta y setenta !!! donde Robin figuraba cómo el primer vocalista , el siempre fue mi favorito !!!!grande Robin Gibb!!!!grande Beegees!!!💔💔❤
what else can i say?one of the most beautiful songs that has ever been written.
Robin's voice kept getting bigger. never have I heard any voice that even comes close to Robin's
Dorothy Kirton Try listening to 'Monday's Rain.'...Robin is only 16 years old there..and his big, beautiful voice is not to be believed!!!
You are right. No one has ever heard a voice like that again..
Dear Robin has so much music in his soul, and it poured out
freely. That's why we love him so much
yesterday I lost someone iI´d loved very much- all my life the music from Robin and the Bee Gees bring comfort to my suffer
Eu adoro essa musica...Adoro Robin, como solista e claro, amo demais os Bee Gees!
My favorite Bee Gees song. So many to choose from.
Loved the Bee Gees when I was young listening to the top 40 station on the little transistor radio. Great memories. Sad to see so many people leaving us.
The best voice of the Bee Gee,s l don, t think he really knew how brilliant his voice was ,so rare and exquisite ,just unique ,l love listening to all he sings ,Beautiful Amazing .singing with the angels darling RIP you lovely man .love to you Paula xxx .
Very good song, Robin has a unique voice, lives on forever.....
Robin ...era a voz mais linda da banda.
Robin was one gorgeous man!
Love that song so much !!!!!!
Robin was 18 when this song was released and it sounds like he has 20+ years of experience in music
Yes. He was 6 when he first went on a stage, so he had 12 years experience,. Plus, when people start that young, it is as if each year at that point is like 1 1/4 years later on.
@@rhondaclark4173 t
2020 marked 60 years since their first appearance on Australian TV
Have you seen a video clip where Robin sings "out of time" by the Stones, he would have been maybe 16. I think it might have been short time before they left for England, check out Barry's pants and the way Maurice is dressed. So hip. For that time.
@@juanita6479 Oh so sorry, hopeless at those things. Try searching on You tube for -out of time bee gees Australia- ,hopefully it will come up for you. It was never shown on TV, but they kept it in the archives.
Robin would have been 16/17, I reckon it was not long before they moved back to England, looking at what Barry and Maurice are wearing, Robin is still in his suit, absolute stunning performance, can't believe it never got on tv
@@juanita6479 I totally agree, my brother was into the Stones, Janice Joplin, Jimi Hendrixand so on and I just loved the Bee Gees from the first time I heard them, when I came across the song it just took me straight back to that time, also such an unexpected style from Robin. Now that I have time on my hand, I have seen a lot of videos of interviews and performances of them, so addictive. Apparently I am not the only one. If only I could have seen all three brothers in concert, but was able to see Barry about 6/7 years when he had concerts in Brisbane. It is nice to know they still have so many fans, their music doesn't age, my kids and partners like them too.
Its truly sad that there won't be any more creative music from Robin Gibb.
This song is just too beautiful !!!
Handsome Robin.😻
Forever bee gees and Robin voce unica
Oh Robin, what a great voice
Que voz mais linda!Robin Gibb Maravilhoso!
The only one voice on earth. Robin
One of his best performance
Angelic voice
I regret they didn't do an unplugged
Live album I bet it could be a platinum one
I never heard this song until today, just fabulous!
the beegees always sings at its best.thats the reason why thier songs never fades.
So very special.
What a beautiful song and so beautifully sung.
Robin wonderfull .the aaron neville from across the pond.!!!!!!!!!!!!
Robin is my favorite....I love Aaron Neville too.
When I listen to Robin singing Oh Darling, it reminds me of Aaron Neville singing Tell It Like It Is.
Wow Robin . Was für eine einmalige Stimme. Ich bin mit den BEE GEES aufgewachsen. Aber Robin war meine grosse Liebe. Ist er heute noch. Ich vermisse ihn . R I P ROBIN
🤣🙋♀️💘
Robin voice best
I missed him
RIP . Love all brother
Singer 👩🎤
Perfect !!!!
The greatest forever and always and ever !
Oh God ..robin's voice
Needs more footage of Robin.
? He was the lead vocals ♥️
Me, I'd be happy if it contained even more footage of Patti Arnold in her prime (dunno who that guy is running around with her)
@@Grithron2 So THAT'S the girl's name! Thank you.
@@Grithron2 she's pretty and all, but she's no Robin! ;)
Que voz única deste Robin. Perfeito. O faltou de beleza superabundou em talento.
One of my favourite song of them....
Incredible! I've just learned that this WAS the original promotional video for this song! What got into them?! 😆
The best song of Bee Gees for me!
Comic interludes apart, it's awesome to see Robin perform live in the spring of his life!
Oh yeah!!! What about Lamplight???? Absolute class!!!!!!! love that song,know what i mean?
ruclips.net/video/kgLpMFklwHs/видео.html
Totally agree!
I love this song
blijft zelfs na jaren one of my favorites all time
This song blows away Jumbo.
Lamplight was a very good song !!!!! Margy Gipe
I think this song is more better than Jumbo.And it is one of the best song of the Bee Gees.
That was part of why Robin left the band. Barry's songs got the A-side and Robin got the B-side. Barry finally manned up and expressed is regret only after Robin and Mo were gone.
@@jduff59 The same with "Spicks and Specks" (Barry) and "I Am The World" (Robin). If you want to know what a great song IATW is, just listen to the "New Version" released by Robin four years before he died.
@@SuperNevile You are so right. "I Am The World" revised by Robin, will blow you clean Away!!😎
Which beautiful song ... They were at the beginning of his career ... So young and able to write a song like this ... The lyrics seem simple but profound thought contained therein ... Thank you!
Bring back so many memories of the days of innocence !
ooh boy he's an angel and he really is even after he is gone now
Robin also has the most kissable lips I have ever seen. Gorgeous just plain gorgeous! His voice is very beautiful. Love and miss you, Robin! ❤️🌹❤️
Underrated understated and God forsaken when they thought he was back ground singer to a band that just made it..they were foolish for the taking. Millions of albums later he is a bad boy ground shaker
Beleza.conta a interior não a exterior, um abraço, amo eles também
@@nobodyspecial6267 yes I agree, he should have been given the opportunity to be in the forefront when they started out his voice just got better and stronger and was so underrated. He was truly a beautiful talented performer!!💖💖
Yo tenia 18 años Cúado escuchaba estas rolas hoy tengo 70 y cuando las escucho me ciento y me regreso esa edad,
This was the second place in the list of
my most fave songs as a teenager n’ the best fave of Bee Gees for a long time.
They all three worked as a team, they were a unit and all 3 had their own angelic voices, including Maurice, it kills me why people have to say who was the better Bee Gee !
💙
I think it's fine that people have their favorite. It's what appeals to each persons individual taste! I looove Robins voice, the best by far for me. But I Adore Barry's natural baritone voice as well. I really enjoy when Barry and Robin would trade-off on the lyrics! The Best! And Mo was the perfect harmonizing voice!!😉
Absolutely, we all have an opinion, but that doesn't make it true. Stop slamming one of them, usually Barry, to build up the one you favor,usually Robin. Robin and Maurice were just as good as and just as important as Barry. They were equals, and they all three made up the Bee Gees.
@@brcfan9 Who's slamming who? I refuse to say who's the best Bee Gee!
@@brcfan9 Maybe you should read my comment again! I wasn't slamming any of the brothers, as they are my favorite musical group. I have everything they ever did from the Australian recordings & even their unreleased material. Every LP from “67” to “2001” So stop your whining!
very good.
love Bee Gees💙💙👌👌
lagu ini enak bngt unt saya, mengingatkan wkt jaman kuliah dulu...
pay attention to robin's face.he was so cute.
Cuando hay talento lo q se produce es EXTRAORDINARIO.
Dit blijft een heerlijk nummer >I love this song.
Going back to the Sound of the Nations with the Bee-Gees....The Singer Sang His Song....Well if this ain't a "masterpiece" by Robin & his Brothers..... then I don't know it anymore by myself....If we must compare this video to "nowadays music performances"....
the choice is "easily-made" otherwise there wouldn't be more than 100.000 vieuwers....
and to those who don't like it.....no hard feelings to you....but I wonder if you've got "brains"?
UNA HERMOSÍSIMA CANCIÓN! TÍPICA DE ESTOS GENIOS!...
In March, 1968, several of the Drake programmed stations played this as an A side, instead of Jumbo, but it didn't fare too well. Great tune. Highly underrated.
Fred. Many of Robin's songs take a few listens to grow on you. They have a classic melodic structure.