4:15 is so beautiful it hurts.. Jesus christ it feels so reminiscent... A month ago I found this movement beautiful. I had no idea my relationship was over... now it sounds tragic. God I love this music.
Since I discovered this performance last night I cannot stop listening to it .....on repeat. So hauntingly beautiful....the cello at first than the violin....wow so beautiful.... And than later when the viola plays the theme and the violin plays the sixteenths....how can something be so perfect, so moving.....
Je pense vraiment que cette prestation est la plus accomplie Il est indéniable de reconnaître que l ultime a été atteint. Cette version est de loin la meilleure.
I absolutely admire Carter Brey's intro.... especially the part when he started to use all G string (a smart choice, compared to others) and as a result, the color of sound is perfect and he can also make those heavenly slides between the notes!
Agreed, he can pull it off beautifully, but i won't want to see nor hear anything less beautifully executed just for bragging rights to stay on the G string.
Gary... the cello itself will dictate what register the player can play and make the best result. Some cellos play perfectly well on the G string in that run, others do not. So it's not only a matter of personal choice, it's what your particular instrument can do. My point is, it was a "smart choice" for his cello and him, but that doesn't mean he's made a "smarter" choice than another cellist for her or his own cello. I could sit right next to Carter (and I have) and he could play that line. Then we could switch cellos and he could attempt to play that line on my cello and it be a failure... or rather, not the "smart choice," on that particular cello. It works the other way, too, though. Meaning, I could play the same run on the G string on MY cello, then try to play it on his and it not come out as well. We each know our instruments intimately, and what they're capable of. Funny thing is, Carter probably was joking around in starting to practice that melody and seeing how many notes could he get away with playing on the G string, lol. Obviously he more than got away with playing the entire line in that register and beautifully, lucky for us ;-). And by the way, he, and that cello, would have sounded just as beautiful had he chosen not to play it all on the G string.
@@morphflow It was an instrument made for me in 2010 by James McKean. I've no idea who the anonymous saputello is who made the previous comment, but it's completely wrong as well as remarkably prolix.
@@cbrey Hey man, wasn’t being a wiseass (nessun senso dell’ umorismo). I still love your playing, but I guess you missed all the compliments I gave you in alllll those words 😂.
Gifted musicians, an achingly lovely piece of music, a rapt audience-how can anyone post a "thumbs down" message? Fortunately, I never read the negative comments...
ah well , yes indeed one can do thumbs down for such a version. There are plus and minuses/ups and downs with all performances. Some glaring aspects for sure...
This piece speaks to me. I also know Schumann wrote this piece with his wife Clara on the mind...the progressions. This movement expresses love to me. Reminds me of a person I use to love dearly...well still do haha. Goodness...Schumann just brings out emotion even in YT comments. One of my fav composers☺❤
What a lovely performance! I believe I saw Beth Guterman Chu play an unaccompanied Hindemith viola sonata years ago and was quite impressed - even more so with her chamber music skills now.
This piece made me feel so emotionally frustrated 😭I want to be the instrumentalist too but can't do🥺 Oh Schumann, how you beautifully made this for us to enjoy👍👏🙏🏾
Absolutely beautiful. Other versions I've heard have been unbalanced by too heavy a hand at the piano. Joyce Yang shows incredible nuance and restraint.
Bravi tutti 👏👏👏 This performance was outstanding. Everyone in the team made this piece a magical experience for the listener to hear - something tender and beautiful to behold.
Outstanding. This is a highly nuanced piece. The recording mixing work appears a tad less in-balance (especially for the piano) than an experienced ear might prefer, yet I thoroughly enjoyed this performance. And that lovely Presbyterian church is among my favorites. Thank you.
All four play beautifully. Carter tuned his bottom string down to B-flat before the movement started. I could tell by the way he fingered certain passages involving the bottom string. The effect of that deep pedal B-flat is extremely important and must never be omitted.
i did enjoy the video alot! in fact I'm looking for a good cello teacher. I've been searching for a few months and i might consider auditionig for curtis
![R.Schumann-Piano Quartet in E flat 3rd mvt [슈만 피아노사중주 3악장] | Muzén Quartet Series](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YXC9IYeVbGg/mqdefault.jpg)
This is one of the default Samsung alarms lmao. Guess I gotta thank them for introducing me to this beautiful piece.
Same here. I have bought Samsung phone and I fell in love with this beautiful peice.
S21 ultra brought me here
Same
S23 brought me here 😂. Gorgeous piece of music
Is everyone here from Samsungs default ringtones? Cause I know I am😂
I feel loneliness and warmth, sorrow and joy of life, and nostalgia and hope. I can’t stop the tears falling down.
슈만 피아노 4중주 op. 47 III 여러 영상 중 이 연주가 가장 마음에 듭니다.
처음듣고 난 뒤에 너무 아름다워서 듣고 충격받았었는데 진짜 이보다 잘표현한 3악장은 없는거 같아요... 너무 아름답고 슬퍼서 눈물납니다 다른악장도 듣고싶어요
Une perle !
Merci ❤
When the Viola takes on the melody, it's utterly sublime.
It really should be in mid-position in a trio - alto connects the parts with supporting textures, after all.
you know the chamber music !!!!
Carter Brey is such an amazing cellist-
4:15 is so beautiful it hurts.. Jesus christ it feels so reminiscent...
A month ago I found this movement beautiful. I had no idea my relationship was over... now it sounds tragic. God I love this music.
my favorite part~♡
I just discovered this today and listened to 4 different videos, one after the other; How did I miss this for so many years? Utterly beautiful
How did Schumann get the musical inspiration for this piece? It is so addictive to the heart.
Think Clara Schumann
마지막 첼로 솔로, 심금을 울리네요.
슈만이 어떤 행복한 삶을 살았는지, 과거의 슬픔과 고난 그리고 당시 현재의 행복이 미묘하게 오버랩되면서 서글프면서 낭만적인 콰르텟을 만들어낸 것 같네요.
잘 들었습니다. 좋은 연주 감사합니다.
정신병이 발동했죠
@@최줄리아나니 엠위처럼?
너무 아름답네요♡
너무 좋아서 계속 반복해서 듣게 됩니다~❤
매번들어도 너무 좋아여 이곡은 ㅠㅠ
아름다운곡 오늘도 여러번 듣네요
I can't stop listening to this. It's so beautiful 🥹
Since I discovered this performance last night I cannot stop listening to it .....on repeat.
So hauntingly beautiful....the cello at first than the violin....wow so beautiful....
And than later when the viola plays the theme and the violin plays the sixteenths....how can something be so perfect, so moving.....
Indeed. It is so powerful... trying to describe it in words feel so unjust. How everyone on the planet isn't deeply moved by it is beyond me.
++++++...
Me too; I listened and relistened; it is very moving, and beckons deep within my soul
Superb performance! Robert Schumann, a great and still underrated composer
Underrated, is that so ?
Je pense vraiment que cette prestation est la plus accomplie
Il est indéniable de reconnaître que l ultime a été atteint.
Cette version est de loin la meilleure.
kbs클레식라디오 방송에서 듣고 찾아 들어왔네요
모든 내면의 감정들을 일깨우는 연주곡입니다
내가 들어본것중 단연 최고입니다. 영감을 불러 일으키는 연주. 다른 악장도 듣고싶네요. 첼로 피아노가 특히 너무너무너무나 훌륭합니다~
너무 감동적인 연주입니다❤
너무 아름다워요♡
Bravo. Among the most beautiful Andante movements in chamber music.
何回聴いても色褪せない良い曲だなぁ
almost like heaven,,,,
Schumann’s soul was in torment, closer to hell than heaven when he wrote this I think
I absolutely admire Carter Brey's intro.... especially the part when he started to use all G string (a smart choice, compared to others) and as a result, the color of sound is perfect and he can also make those heavenly slides between the notes!
Agreed, he can pull it off beautifully, but i won't want to see nor hear anything less beautifully executed just for bragging rights to stay on the G string.
Gary... the cello itself will dictate what register the player can play and make the best result. Some cellos play perfectly well on the G string in that run, others do not. So it's not only a matter of personal choice, it's what your particular instrument can do. My point is, it was a "smart choice" for his cello and him, but that doesn't mean he's made a "smarter" choice than another cellist for her or his own cello. I could sit right next to Carter (and I have) and he could play that line. Then we could switch cellos and he could attempt to play that line on my cello and it be a failure... or rather, not the "smart choice," on that particular cello. It works the other way, too, though. Meaning, I could play the same run on the G string on MY cello, then try to play it on his and it not come out as well. We each know our instruments intimately, and what they're capable of. Funny thing is, Carter probably was joking around in starting to practice that melody and seeing how many notes could he get away with playing on the G string, lol. Obviously he more than got away with playing the entire line in that register and beautifully, lucky for us ;-). And by the way, he, and that cello, would have sounded just as beautiful had he chosen not to play it all on the G string.
@@BetterMe981 Would you happen to know what his cello is?
@@morphflow It was an instrument made for me in 2010 by James McKean. I've no idea who the anonymous saputello is who made the previous comment, but it's completely wrong as well as remarkably prolix.
@@cbrey Hey man, wasn’t being a wiseass (nessun senso dell’ umorismo). I still love your playing, but I guess you missed all the compliments I gave you in alllll those words 😂.
Schumann is my favourite composer ,the Best for me
I love the bright sound of the piano above and in contrast to the strings!!! Great group performance!!! 👏👏👏👏👏
Gifted musicians, an achingly lovely piece of music, a rapt audience-how can anyone post a "thumbs down" message? Fortunately, I never read the negative comments...
ah well , yes indeed one can do thumbs down for such a version. There are plus and minuses/ups and downs with all performances. Some glaring aspects for sure...
Bravissimi! È per me uno dei movimenti lenti più belli mai concepiti da mente umana. Grazie.
What a beautiful piece... And the performance is really moving
This piece speaks to me. I also know Schumann wrote this piece with his wife Clara on the mind...the progressions. This movement expresses love to me. Reminds me of a person I use to love dearly...well still do haha. Goodness...Schumann just brings out emotion even in YT comments. One of my fav composers☺❤
Di fronte ad una melodia del genere non ci sono parole che possano descriverne appieno la bellezza per cui meglio lasciar parlare soltanto la musica.
들을때 마다 행복하고 아름다운 음악입니다.
이 곡을 알고 나서 여기서 몇번째 듣는지 셀수도 없네요 못해도 몇백번은 되는거 같아요..
첼로랑 바이올린소리가 흐느껴우는것같네요
Violist crushin’ it… super cute, too. You all sound amazing.
Sublime - I am crying
What a lovely performance! I believe I saw Beth Guterman Chu play an unaccompanied Hindemith viola sonata years ago and was quite impressed - even more so with her chamber music skills now.
This piece made me feel so emotionally frustrated 😭I want to be the instrumentalist too but can't do🥺 Oh Schumann, how you beautifully made this for us to enjoy👍👏🙏🏾
너무 좋아용 :)
좋아요~
What a beautiful song to wake up im the morning
너무나 아름다운 연주 잘 들었습니다. 감사합니다.
Absolutely beautiful. Other versions I've heard have been unbalanced by too heavy a hand at the piano.
Joyce Yang shows incredible nuance and restraint.
If you like the sound, credit the sound engineer. Look at all those mic placements. The engineer obviously did quite a job to blend everything in.
This opening makes me swoon every time 😍❤️
Bravi tutti 👏👏👏 This performance was outstanding. Everyone in the team made this piece a magical experience for the listener to hear - something tender and beautiful to behold.
I just love this rendition... So alive and yet true to the core!
Thanks so much! It was a beautiful performance.
내 핸드폰벨소리 너무슬프고
애잔해ㅠ
best of best! 💕
So dulcet !! This piece is my favorite version , i love it .
실내악 공연 보러 갔다가 앵콜때 연주 해주셔서 처음 들었는데 너무 좋아서 눈 감고 감상 했었던..
알람해놨다가 곡이 너무 좋아서 왔는데 좋네 ㅋㅋㅋㅠ 왤케 좋냐ㅜㅜ....
음악으로 대화를 한다는게 이런거구나...
Essa música toca a alma.
So moving and beautiful
A beautiful lesson in cantabile playing!
Beautiful performance!❤
And the music of Schumann is so moving!
This is sheer sublime
Really fantastic!! 👏👏👏👏❤️❤️❤️
What a beautiful piece...!
또모 영상 보고 오신분..?
저요....
저도... 이런 곡을 왜 이제야 알았는지.
여기 한명 추가요! 감동
저욬ㅋ
눈물이 또르륵...ㅠㅠ
최고👍👍
Carter Brey and Amy Schwartz sound fabulous. And I've never heard of her till now.
This is beautiful!!
Jejsdj
Shdjjxjd
Shhdjxj
Jwjjdjdj
Beautiful piece, it moved me. I loved the intro, what a composition!!!!!
Outstanding. This is a highly nuanced piece. The recording mixing work appears a tad less in-balance (especially for the piano) than an experienced ear might prefer, yet I thoroughly enjoyed this performance. And that lovely Presbyterian church is among my favorites. Thank you.
Cello So attractive ❤
Bridgehampton, New York
Bellissimo. Bravi!
ce deuxième mouvement du quatuor op47 est divin !! Je l'aime de toutes les fibres de mon être
the beauty of classical music is that its not tainted with the trash of human errors in form of words which color the songs original feelings
It's my favorite performance
Wow now thats a re cellist! ♡
René Pariente: Quelle magnifique mélodie.
형용할 수 단어를 못 찾겠어요.. 아름답고 고귀한 음악
All four play beautifully.
Carter tuned his bottom string down to B-flat before the movement started. I could tell by the way he fingered certain passages involving the bottom string. The effect of that deep pedal B-flat is extremely important and must never be omitted.
Wonderful music.
20---------24. Mexico. 🇲🇽🎶🎶🎶💐
I've heard this piece played by world's top players and they fail to convince me of the composition's beauty as much as these community players.
amazing.. best play ever
Soooo beautiful!
Gran faro de la música Schumann, eterno!!!!
Esa viola que me despierta😂😂😂ya sabe que tiene toda mi atencion .😂😂😂
💕💕💕💕💕💕
Heavenly
ㄹㅇ
어두움과 아름다움이 찟게까려있어요?
I can hear the quarter notes and if only the violin could get out of the way when the line is on the viola.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
0:11
이렇게 좋은 곡을 왜 이제 알았지
This is underrated.
Écoute bien, au fond de toi, c'est indescriptible d'être
Absolutelybeautiful ♥️
Love the cello part melody at the beginning
The sound of the viola crying ....
어우......ㅜㅜ
128,186
is the cellist teaching at curtis institute of music in pennsylvania?
Yes - Carter Brey is on the faculty at Curtis. Hope you enjoyed the video!
i did enjoy the video alot!
in fact I'm looking for a good cello teacher. I've been searching for a few months and i might consider auditionig for curtis
👍
My samsung galaxy s23's ringtone🩶
Same
My Samsung Galaxy A23 Ringtone.
А55