Massively underrated Genesis song. Heard it was pulled from the set list and then when it was played at the show I attended I damn near squeezed out a tear. I am so glad I went to this concert. I have seen some great concerts but this was the best.
I say God bless him. Sick as he is and has been, he's still hobbling out there and giving his all. Don't you people saying how bad he's singing realize they're saying goodbye? Saw them in Toronto last night. At the end, when they all bowed and then just the three of them bowed, I realized this is it, no more. Thus so much of the old material. That broke my heart, not Phil's voice.
Sadly I agree. I remember going to see them on the Duke tour and it was amazing also this is one of my favorite songs. I’ve heard him sing this many times but this breaks my heart to see and hear him now
Plus, pretty much every song is keyed down and as a consequence, sound funereal. But to many kidding themselves this sounds great, it's a case of the emperor's new clothes..
Massively underrated Genesis song. Heard it was pulled from the set list and then when it was played at the show I attended I damn near squeezed out a tear. I am so glad I went to this concert. I have seen some great concerts but this was the best.
Underrated by whom?
I was there and not far away from you by the looks of it. I agree about this being a highlight. What a great album Duke is.
This is really the one deep surprise for this tour, as Ripples was in ‘07.
@@ethelip5239 One of my fav Genesis songs, Duchess. I take it Ripples is not on the live set list now? That's a shame.
Duke & Trick are my favs. I don't care they just are
This one , along with "man of the corner ' is a favorite of mine
Nic is a Jewel. This music is timeless
I was in lpool tues 4 Phil voice was by no means perfect but exceeded my expectations great show xx
I f’n love this song! Mike’s bass pedals! Awesome!!!!
Best video xx
💋💛💎
I want to take my edibles and watch their light show
I say God bless him. Sick as he is and has been, he's still hobbling out there and giving his all. Don't you people saying how bad he's singing realize they're saying goodbye?
Saw them in Toronto last night. At the end, when they all bowed and then just the three of them bowed, I realized this is it, no more. Thus so much of the old material. That broke my heart, not Phil's voice.
Phil collins is very talented peter gabriell too
Phil’s voice sounds better here
Better than what??!!! It’s awful
I’ve seen genesis many times over the years but face facts it’s terrible
@@fuzzy1237 I hope to see you perform at 70 years old and keeping an audience entertained for two hours
Love Genesis. Love Phil but It kills me to listen to this. Phil sounds bad.
I’ve listened to him since the 70’s when Pete left and now to see and hear Phil like this is heartbreaking.
Sadly I agree. I remember going to see them on the Duke tour and it was amazing also this is one of my favorite songs. I’ve heard him sing this many times but this breaks my heart to see and hear him now
Hey these guys used to be Genesis...Greatest Prog band of all time
What does that mean ?
duke was a fav of mine back in the day but his voice is terrible and chester should of been tnere
Unfortunately, Phill's voice hurts the ears 😪😪😪
Sad to see....Phil really isn't up to it with his singing....shame !!!!
Should have shut up and not killed it
Phils voice is awful
Plus, pretty much every song is keyed down and as a consequence, sound funereal. But to many kidding themselves this sounds great, it's a case of the emperor's new clothes..
This is an absolute mess. Get past the emotionalism and sentimentality of it all, and just be honest. It’s bad.
The vocals are terrible 😢
Sounds like a really bad tribute pub band.