You're feedback and comments on these reviews have been so valuable in helping me create GG5! Thank you all so much :) And thanks to Hello Fresh for sponsoring today's review! Go to strms.net/hellofresh_iamsouper, use my code SOUPJAN10, and receive 10 free meals + free breakfast for life!
I remember being convinced you’d ask me to vote last because Solo is after Settled going down the call alphabetically. Then in the moment it was just far too tempting not to irresponsibly follow through with it 😅
For me this is what began the trend of "If Settled can somehow link the challenge to Morytania he wins" and this was just a constant for the rest of the season
this was the first Gielinor Games i watched and i was really on the edge of my seat every episode, it was so amazing - and huge shoutout to Ally for the support too!
I think Hooti's reaction to the vote might have been the best part. He just kind of shows up in confessional and is like, wait, was i in the wrong call? He seemed more blindsided than literally anyone else
@@IAmSouper Hey Soup, I just waned to say that I appreciate that you took the time to upload the VOD to Twitch so that the chat is preserved. I found it really fun to rewatch with chat reactions.
Man, you always drop these at the perfect time for me. Been going through some rough shit in life and these just help me escape reality for a bit and really bring me joy. Thank you Soup for all that you do
Also the easter egg that the elimination where the friends of both masterminds. Really puts the cherry on top for the snake to be out snaked. But Solomision should have a great next season now that we're in the year of the Snake.
One thing you could do to allow uneven teams again without too much of an edge is have the weak team have an extra player but use the two worse scores(assuming teams of three) or the best team has three players but uses their best two results. Thinking in context of money making but could be applicable to most things I’m sure. Money making, anything related to time, stuff like that
Gawd! I’ve forgotten how phenomenal this episode was! These two challenges are some of my top picks! The settled vote swap was absolutely legendary! And the tick perfect selection by EV? Every aspect was phenomenal. Thanks for this vid so I could relive the chaos. I really respect the behind the scenes videos. I wanted to go into video production ages ago. Seeing you create something like GG and your passion behind it? Definitely living vicariously through you. lol
Legitimately such a high quality series, it makes me think I'm watching a multi-million subscriber channel if not an actual live TV show. So good all around. The Settled bamboozle in the tribunal was a top-tier moment in GG history for sure!
I always do enjoy the music selection for GG too, I think it's an underrated component making the show great! Thanks for putting in the effort! I have many times paused an episode and added a song to my playlist lol
To quote Deadpool, we're gonna make you do this shit until you're 90! Seriously though as long as you're happy making it, we'll be just as happy to watch it
I was absolutely floored when Solo voted for Evscape! The entire episode showed me exactly why I tune in each year. I can completely understand why you would gush about this episode. Look forward to the next season.
Love all the reviews. This is one I was really looking forward to, and the next big one I'm looking forward to is the prop hunt episode. Of course I'm looking forward to all of them but I was really happy to see J1mmy make a first appearance in that specific episode because I know he was to busy at the time to take part in the season proper.
My thoughts have been said by other people on what an amazing climax this episode led to. The little easter eggs on the episode lore were also amazing! You don't need to tell me twice since i am immediately going back to rewatch this legend of an episode
This one is the best GG. Gosh I wish I watched this when it aired live. Also I dont think you put in a screen cap of the twitch chat. I gotta rewatch it now like you said at the end.
Wish I had some input to give, but tbh I just love the show so much that I wanted to comment to try to help boost this videos ability in the youtube algorithm. Keep on keepin on Soup, GG is one hell of a show that I cannot get enough of.
What an amazing end to one of the best episodes of Season 4. The Season 3 and Season 4 episodes of GieliGuessr were both so epic, it's so hard to choose which was better! Both had such an epic finish and really created major highlights for their respective seasons. The production in both episodes was so awesome as well, love the work you do! Thanks for these in-depth reviews, can't wait for the rest, and SO looking forward to Season 5!
I really wanted this to be the episode where everybody voted somebody different. Now I have to wait for next season for it to happen to see what would happen!
Perhaps there was a bit of editing magic that was at play here, but the moment Framed won against EV I could feel that Settled had this season in the bag. The tribunal had 2 very high level GG competitors, and the elimination had one of each of their allies go against each other in a shocking turn of events. So when Framed won, on top of Settled being in his 3rd (I think) tribunal thus far, it seemed impossible that Settled wouldn't make it to the finals.
Might be a good idea to have a secondary contact for players for filming? Like what happened to Westham, if the players don't mind and their contact don't mind you could get their phone number or something to get a hold of them for them to contact their partner/neighbour or friend.
Regarding prize pool did you considering just having a quick 2 min call with the remaining participants to update them and get new sound clips before each episode? Though we all love hearing Boaty's "say less" ever single week lol
How would you feel about a duo of people reacting to geilenor games, but treating it like a professional sporting event, and acting like the announcers? my high school best friend and I absolutely love the series, when it's on, even though we work opposite schedules, we made time on Sundays to talk about the episode a little and I threw that idea out to him a while ago. Personally my hope/dream with the idea is we do voice over of the episode almost like sports announcers, and then if you and others find and like the videos we get officially brought in for season 6 to provide play by play commentary (potentially with access to additional footage)
Suggstion to spice up hoarder: each player can name x amounts of items (maybe 15+?) after everyone collected theirs to get these items banned from the count. This adds more suspension, becouse the final count isn't the final count and the result can be flipped. This also forces the participants to source a few more unique items. Participants can also knock out entire shops that way, wasting the others time there adding strategy.
soup!! do you have the uncut recording of the conversation between settled picking ezscape, and then ezscape picking framed. everyone saying he one-ticked to pick framed makes me want to see just actually how fast it all went down
please get odablock in on the next season if you can. he's so terrible at anything trivia based but anything gameplay based he'll be incredible and when he has no idea what's happening he's pretty hilarious. just give him rules on language so he behaves, but i promise he'll be pure content
Haven’t watched yet but so hyped, I love GG. Me and my wife watch together. She never played RS, I played for over a decade but don’t really play anymore.
Soup, you are the God of Runescape that blesses us with this content. I am honestly shocked and super appreciative that you are already working on season 5! I hope you get a billion subs and every sponsorship in the world for this masterpiece of a series.
Why don't you do the finales on live stream? Seems like it would be a great event. You wild have to have a long wait between the semifinals and the finals but it would be fun it think.
Today I learned you let these air "live" on Twitch before uploading to RUclips! Do you have a bigger fan base there? I know you can do that on RUclips too, seems like you might have more people there?
Soup. A cool GG series concept I think for S6 would be a cast of all of the players who were knocked out 1st-2nd round of the first 5 seasons. You could call it Gileinor Games First to Fall or something catchy like that.
@ ooh. That could be like the season after or mini series after. Top 5 from the first to fall series move on to take on the top 5 from previous season or something like that. I like the champs vs chumps concept, that’s mint.
I commented this on the original episode, but I'll repeat here: I feel like it is IMPERATIVE to make sure all contestants are on the same page regarding things like the inventory/cash stack reset. Maybe it was Framed's fault for not paying attention. But in the episode, it genuinely felt like he was taken aback by the information. Like every ither contestant had correctly assumed the cash should be reset, and he just didnt make that assumption.
You're feedback and comments on these reviews have been so valuable in helping me create GG5! Thank you all so much :) And thanks to Hello Fresh for sponsoring today's review! Go to strms.net/hellofresh_iamsouper, use my code SOUPJAN10, and receive 10 free meals + free breakfast for life!
my are feedback appreciation thread
Also! Here's the twitch vod with the chat reaction to what happens during the voting - www.twitch.tv/videos/2155539126?t=00h40m24s
27:13 you never put up the twitch vod for settled voting out EV scape
I remember being convinced you’d ask me to vote last because Solo is after Settled going down the call alphabetically. Then in the moment it was just far too tempting not to irresponsibly follow through with it 😅
🐍🐍🐍
Led to probably the best moment of the series!
Commitment to the bit. You've been great in every season you've been on!
Wish we had this kind of commentary in your own review of the episodes! Hopefully next season?
please keep being you. that was your best moment on GG!
The 1-tick callout was the absolute perfect way to wrap up that entire sequence!
I would love for a fully uneditted clip of the voting+Framed callout and the cast's reactions to it. Bonus points for the tribunal call as well
Only 968k more subscribers until 1M!
For me this is what began the trend of "If Settled can somehow link the challenge to Morytania he wins" and this was just a constant for the rest of the season
this was the first Gielinor Games i watched and i was really on the edge of my seat every episode, it was so amazing - and huge shoutout to Ally for the support too!
You can really tell Soup loves his job making this stuff for us
He does a Souper job ^_^
I think Hooti's reaction to the vote might have been the best part. He just kind of shows up in confessional and is like, wait, was i in the wrong call? He seemed more blindsided than literally anyone else
The team names were definitely worth leaving in, it added a good touch of comedy
(Never change the way you say Phasmatis)
27:16 So, uh, where's the Twitch chat, Soup?
Here's a link to it! - My bad www.twitch.tv/videos/2155539126?t=00h40m24s
Is the twitch chat here with us?
@@IAmSouper Hey Soup, I just waned to say that I appreciate that you took the time to upload the VOD to Twitch so that the chat is preserved. I found it really fun to rewatch with chat reactions.
Man, you always drop these at the perfect time for me. Been going through some rough shit in life and these just help me escape reality for a bit and really bring me joy. Thank you Soup for all that you do
Absolutely the best GG episode ever imo. The editing and the confessions included for the tribunal and voting section was just perfect
Also the easter egg that the elimination where the friends of both masterminds. Really puts the cherry on top for the snake to be out snaked.
But Solomision should have a great next season now that we're in the year of the Snake.
the twist vote and the instant 1 frame callout are instant classics of the show honestly. that's some top tier reality TV(youtube)
One thing you could do to allow uneven teams again without too much of an edge is have the weak team have an extra player but use the two worse scores(assuming teams of three) or the best team has three players but uses their best two results. Thinking in context of money making but could be applicable to most things I’m sure. Money making, anything related to time, stuff like that
Gawd! I’ve forgotten how phenomenal this episode was! These two challenges are some of my top picks!
The settled vote swap was absolutely legendary! And the tick perfect selection by EV? Every aspect was phenomenal.
Thanks for this vid so I could relive the chaos.
I really respect the behind the scenes videos. I wanted to go into video production ages ago. Seeing you create something like GG and your passion behind it? Definitely living vicariously through you. lol
I LOVE this episode. It was peak entertainment
Legitimately such a high quality series, it makes me think I'm watching a multi-million subscriber channel if not an actual live TV show. So good all around. The Settled bamboozle in the tribunal was a top-tier moment in GG history for sure!
I always do enjoy the music selection for GG too, I think it's an underrated component making the show great!
Thanks for putting in the effort! I have many times paused an episode and added a song to my playlist lol
To quote Deadpool, we're gonna make you do this shit until you're 90!
Seriously though as long as you're happy making it, we'll be just as happy to watch it
When Solo said EV I was at work watching. My boss thought something happened cuz she heard me scream from the kitchen hahaha!
I was absolutely floored when Solo voted for Evscape! The entire episode showed me exactly why I tune in each year. I can completely understand why you would gush about this episode. Look forward to the next season.
This was absolutely one of my favorite episodes of the season. My jaw also dropped when Settled threw his vote to EV
Don’t apologize for being passionate about your passion project. Your enthusiasm is motivating. Keep up the good work man
Thanks for all the effort put in man!
28:20 “It probably sounds like a solomission confession” cracked me up😂
Love all the reviews. This is one I was really looking forward to, and the next big one I'm looking forward to is the prop hunt episode. Of course I'm looking forward to all of them but I was really happy to see J1mmy make a first appearance in that specific episode because I know he was to busy at the time to take part in the season proper.
My thoughts have been said by other people on what an amazing climax this episode led to. The little easter eggs on the episode lore were also amazing! You don't need to tell me twice since i am immediately going back to rewatch this legend of an episode
This was my favourite episode by far and you've convinced me to rewatch it
This one is the best GG. Gosh I wish I watched this when it aired live. Also I dont think you put in a screen cap of the twitch chat. I gotta rewatch it now like you said at the end.
Wish I had some input to give, but tbh I just love the show so much that I wanted to comment to try to help boost this videos ability in the youtube algorithm. Keep on keepin on Soup, GG is one hell of a show that I cannot get enough of.
Love these reviews!
What an amazing end to one of the best episodes of Season 4. The Season 3 and Season 4 episodes of GieliGuessr were both so epic, it's so hard to choose which was better! Both had such an epic finish and really created major highlights for their respective seasons. The production in both episodes was so awesome as well, love the work you do! Thanks for these in-depth reviews, can't wait for the rest, and SO looking forward to Season 5!
I'd love to have the raw unedited calls for moments like this in these reviews.
I really wanted this to be the episode where everybody voted somebody different.
Now I have to wait for next season for it to happen to see what would happen!
GG is really special to the community. You can really hear it in your voice how special it is to you too. Thanks for all you do ❤
13:30 almost caught you slipping and calling it the correct name
Was waiting for this episode since you announced this channel!
Perhaps there was a bit of editing magic that was at play here, but the moment Framed won against EV I could feel that Settled had this season in the bag.
The tribunal had 2 very high level GG competitors, and the elimination had one of each of their allies go against each other in a shocking turn of events. So when Framed won, on top of Settled being in his 3rd (I think) tribunal thus far, it seemed impossible that Settled wouldn't make it to the finals.
Love your content, your channel is like a sanctuary.
take a shot every time soup says something is funny or hilarious
Might be a good idea to have a secondary contact for players for filming? Like what happened to Westham, if the players don't mind and their contact don't mind you could get their phone number or something to get a hold of them for them to contact their partner/neighbour or friend.
Actually love the spaced out episodes ❤
Boaty Vs. Settled was my favorite episode, but this is a close second.
best episode of anything ever. god tier
I forgot there was a team named "Team B0aty" that just didn't have B0aty AND he was still there on another team. That shit cracks me up I stg 🤣🤣
Regarding prize pool did you considering just having a quick 2 min call with the remaining participants to update them and get new sound clips before each episode?
Though we all love hearing Boaty's "say less" ever single week lol
Correction on the surströmming, it's technically fermented, not rotten.
The tribunal in this one was one of my favorite moments of the season!
Such a touching moment ❤ 28:04
How would you feel about a duo of people reacting to geilenor games, but treating it like a professional sporting event, and acting like the announcers?
my high school best friend and I absolutely love the series, when it's on, even though we work opposite schedules, we made time on Sundays to talk about the episode a little and I threw that idea out to him a while ago. Personally my hope/dream with the idea is we do voice over of the episode almost like sports announcers, and then if you and others find and like the videos we get officially brought in for season 6 to provide play by play commentary (potentially with access to additional footage)
Absolute cinema.
The whole season was my fav, but this episode was just legendary
Suggstion to spice up hoarder: each player can name x amounts of items (maybe 15+?) after everyone collected theirs to get these items banned from the count. This adds more suspension, becouse the final count isn't the final count and the result can be flipped. This also forces the participants to source a few more unique items. Participants can also knock out entire shops that way, wasting the others time there adding strategy.
mf said "The other really thing about this location" 14:05
Soup is a real life super hero fr ❤
soup!! do you have the uncut recording of the conversation between settled picking ezscape, and then ezscape picking framed. everyone saying he one-ticked to pick framed makes me want to see just actually how fast it all went down
Please ask Settled if he is not gonna play in the next seaon to design a 1 inventory slot challenge
Snakey Mission is a fantastic beast.
please get odablock in on the next season if you can. he's so terrible at anything trivia based but anything gameplay based he'll be incredible and when he has no idea what's happening he's pretty hilarious. just give him rules on language so he behaves, but i promise he'll be pure content
Port PHATASS-mis 🗣️
Wish we could have hide and seek but with a twist next year. Maybe something like playing the audio from the soundtracks
Maybe show them the item they need to get there, but not the location? That might be too vague though.
Would anything have changed if Framed had the gp at the start for the mory one? Thinking about the knockon effects of stuff like thatbis interesting.
13:25 I was so surprised here that nobody had the infinite boat unlocked, it only costs 1m
I don't think everyone is on their main accounts as we know some people have already mentioned never playing on a maxed account before
Haven’t watched yet but so hyped, I love GG. Me and my wife watch together. She never played RS, I played for over a decade but don’t really play anymore.
You're watching the commentary before the actual episode? Talk about spoilers for the entire season lmao wtf
Please get my boy Chig in there if he's able to
I wanna see the live reaction on twitch. Where can I find it
Absolute cinema
Can we see that twitch clip with chat that you mention? Its not on your twitch channel.
Here you go! - www.twitch.tv/videos/2155539126?t=00h40m24s
Fine, I'll rewatch it for the 6th time.
these BTS episodes are so good!
and this episode was indeed fantastic
Soup, you are the God of Runescape that blesses us with this content. I am honestly shocked and super appreciative that you are already working on season 5! I hope you get a billion subs and every sponsorship in the world for this masterpiece of a series.
If they do launch private worlds in time for the next games will they be held on a private world?
invite my man scritic for the next season!
Why don't you do the finales on live stream? Seems like it would be a great event. You wild have to have a long wait between the semifinals and the finals but it would be fun it think.
Just commenting to see if soup actually reads all the comments...
Hey soup is it possible to link the respective episodes in the description? Should make it easier to watch after these.
Please get Regicidal on the show or at least involved in some way. He’s an OG and I know you guys are cool
I'm already grinding to make the donation leader board for season 5...
Soup I still don't know if your pronunciation of Phasmatys is a mistake or an intentional joke
soup, the people have spoken and they want to know. crunchy or smooth peanut butter?
Ill watch
Today I learned you let these air "live" on Twitch before uploading to RUclips! Do you have a bigger fan base there? I know you can do that on RUclips too, seems like you might have more people there?
Do you really read every comment? Loving the games!
Damn Westham sleepyhead, I wonder how often this happens?
no twitch chat?
Hmmm... something's different
27:16 Oops, looks like you forgot to put it on screen, or take this bit out of your script
Good morning
Am I blind, or did you not put the twitch reaction in the video
7:01 📸
Omg big fan :D
Soup. A cool GG series concept I think for S6 would be a cast of all of the players who were knocked out 1st-2nd round of the first 5 seasons. You could call it Gileinor Games First to Fall or something catchy like that.
cool idea but has the downside of a lot of people's favorite creators would not be in it
@ or a mini series of GG
Be really cool to pair this with a champs vs chumps concept. Don't know how you'd keep the underdog team from being eliminated right off the bat.
@ ooh. That could be like the season after or mini series after. Top 5 from the first to fall series move on to take on the top 5 from previous season or something like that. I like the champs vs chumps concept, that’s mint.
27:16 LIAR
have some algo
rizz me UP
nice
Woooooooooo
I commented this on the original episode, but I'll repeat here:
I feel like it is IMPERATIVE to make sure all contestants are on the same page regarding things like the inventory/cash stack reset.
Maybe it was Framed's fault for not paying attention. But in the episode, it genuinely felt like he was taken aback by the information. Like every ither contestant had correctly assumed the cash should be reset, and he just didnt make that assumption.