These women are amazing. Especially the mothers , who Not only build their shelter and teach their children to assist, all the while carrying an infant child on their back. I could hardly get my kids to clean their own room
Wow..I grew up in Ethiopia..and only a short distance from this tribe....and am so glad to have done so with no tourists to influence them. They will never be the same again after all the tampering and outside spectacle being created. I do so appreciate this video of the more authentic lives of the Mursi...and no foreign spectators.
I've thought about this amazing film all day and have to say this: These people remain substantially self-sufficient. They have little use for currency. Although the photographers are clearly, and wrongly, exploiting them instead pf documenting their culture, to pay them more would only undermine their values faster. Sadly, thats the fate of most of the worlds people. Thank you for raising the bar.
Came across this video which someone posted underneath a photo on Facebook. Wonderful job of telling the short story of how this tribe lives. To answer the question in the video, No, I don't think tourists should be able to just go to the area the tribe is in without prior permission. I also think that five cents is ridiculously low, they deserve much much more or better things like medical care. Thank you for making these videos.
I've been loving your work. I have been fortunate enough to visit the Mursi people and other Omo valley tribes, and I am passionate about photography. However, being there as a tourist it didn't feel right taking too many photos, I found much more value in observing and talking instead. It would even be worth insisting visitors to refrain from photography so that they can truly take in something so special that they are fortunate enough to experience. Filming and photography for educational purposes would always be welcome of course.
Ok. This is going to be an unpopular opinion... but please bear with me: My daughter and I live in Namibia. We have a similar nomadic tribe here (Himba, you've made a film about them before). In an ideal world, traditional tribes should be able to survive without modern "interference", so no photographs or money. However, times have changed. The milie flour you're talking about is very cheap but still needs to be purchased (as they're not farmers with fields), the photos create a source of income that still allows the family unit to stay together and continue their nomadic life style (I don't want to comment on the price of photos, obviously it's never fair). The only alternative would be to send people to work in the towns where traditional skills are not of value. That means they end up doing menial jobs (gardening and cleaning) for minimum wage which then is send partly home to support their families. The Himba here also do "photo shoots" in villages and towns, besides selling traditional carvings and baskets. Tourists love taking these photos, but always have to tip or pay. Thank you for your great film and informative observations.
Not unpopular with me. As it happens, we are now supporting an initiative to create a Himba owned and run tourist camp where they will build traditional huts and fit out as lodges, (although we will probably build modern showers and a cafe). I have been trying to get back there to help them design and build it but corona has made this impossible. If you know anyone in Namibia you think would support this, either come and help build or else donate then it would be great to build a local group. I would love it if such things could come out of my videos.
@@NomadArchitecture Fantastic idea. Actually, I am originally a town planner and my best friend is an architect whose also getting into alternative building methods. My (only 11 year old) daughter is obsessed with primitive skills and especially how to build Himba huts (she's the reason we watch your videos, I also like it, don't get me wrong). I also know a lot of people in the tourism industry. But my first instinct is to say stay away from large established touring companies (they are all owned by namibian germans, who blatantly sabotage all competition, they have established monopolies here). Finding smaller companies run by (non-german) tour guides (especially of Himba origin) might be the way to go...btw before this comment is misunderstood: I myself am of German origin.
In my humble opinion what you are doing is documenting differing lifestyles which may in the very near future become extinct ... I believe that to be a good thing. What the Englishmen are doing is exploitation. With that being said, the natives do not seem to mind. So, who's to say one way or the other. Thank you for the new video and I hope you are all doing well.
@@NomadArchitecture I agree with you ... but I'm not an Englishman who historically puts themselves above all other humans on the planet. If they haven't changed their ways by now, I don't think they are going to.
@@thierrybilson9634 it’s not sad to see people moving out from 5,000 year old practices as normal life, if you think that is okay there is something wrong with your thinking.
Who is living the best way, this apartment dweller wonders on the other side of the only planet with life of any kind? Winter comes for me and millions of others and necessity shapes us as it does the Ethiopians. Good will to all you who live wherever you are.
We are trying to get more of the other crafts in our latest filmings - keep an eye out for the Korowai in West Papua where my daughter has been filming lots of things.
Mascara contains mercury (and there is lead in lipstick). Thanks for this coverage - these people are truly free, living REALLY sustainable lives without the involvement of multinational corporations.
Another wonderful documentary for us to enjoy watching & learning from. These humans are so hardworking & physically fit, so unique in their history, their heritage/culture & so much more. It's truly wonderful to get a personal glimpse into their world & i personally feel honoured. They possess such gorgeous body/bone structure, almost model/statuesque like. Lovely & lithe, tall & beautifully willowy, as they all walk around working hard. They even look graceful carrying anything on their heads. In response to the asked question...... I think we Westerner's are completely curious and fascinated by such humans/tribal groups, which is understandable, however, when i see the English photographers, or any external photographers arriving & in some ways, imposing/encroaching upon their personal space, i feel somewhat disappointed & even angry. Why? Because i think of the poor & ill treatment of African's historically, specifically during colonization & slavery etc;. It's funny, but one could argue, that this sort of dominant treatment (albeit, no more colonization & slavery), @ the hands of some Westerner's still exists & is allowed to perpetuate & sometimes @ the detriment of the tribal people. At the very least, it would be better & more understandable, if a large percentage of the money made from the photos taken, was given directly to these tribal members, to both assist them financially & to empower them, but if they're not being paid enough, then personally, i see this as a form of human abuse & being taken advantage of, for the greater prosperity/empowerment of the visiting Westerner. Also, i find it utterly disrespectful & even hypocritical, that the photographers didn't want the camera pointed @ them, yet, they turned up unannounced/without formal invite it appears, disturbing the privacy & peace of these beautiful people & treating them as though they're show ponies! As though their lives aren't already hard enough! In this regard, it's just not right, or even fair. Hypothetically speaking, i imagine if the tides were turned, there'd be major pushback, rebellion & negative issues abound. But of course in reality, these quiet, respectful & humble people, would never do such things & they most probably, wouldn't be allowed to anyway. Nonetheless, as controversial to many as this may be, we must appreciate such documentaries, because you tube has certainly brought much more of this amazing world to us, hence we get the great privilege/opportunity, to learn more about humans & their respective cultures across our world.
I think what you guys are doing is good. It's important to preserve culture and tradition. You're there simply to learn. I think the photographers are exploiting them and that shouldn't be happening. Although to be fair it seems like the population has embraced them. I mean you see how they got ready for pictures.
Instead of charging 5c how about providing them with beneficial resources like solar panels, water filters, hygiene, kids supplies, livestock, tools and etc. Westerners who profit off of such things like 5c should be banned from Africa
Regarding the english photographers; Well, the it seems the question is a bit late Since the British have been doing what they want with indigenous peoples for centuries. Consciousness is always appreciated
Whatever has happened to the Kwegu tribe. I have searched for videos current videos on RUclips and nothing. My heart breaks for the beautiful Kwegu people.
Gosto muito desse tipo de vídeo mais gostaria que fosse dublado em português ou legendado em português parabéns pelo seu trabalho o vídeo ficou ótimo 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 ok
How great that its remained the same for so long 😀 my idea of what a truly advanced society should be, really. I'm highly sceptical about the wheel, really, for me, thats were it all started to go wrong. 😉
@@Hi-xu9xn compared to the current medical tyranny (no mask no job, no jab no job=no services) going on worldwide, I would rather choose this simple lifestyle than live in a cosmopolitan city in this so-called Circus 19 era. Notice there is a lot I omitted from my comment due to RUclips censorship for any speech contrary to the Circus-19 narrative!!!!!
The people don't seem to mind the camera men and tourists but I don't think 5 cents is enough since the photos will generate much more. Considering how the people live I think bolts of cloth, new tools, pots and pans etc., would be a much better deal. If the people minded the photographs it would be a different story, then I would say no photos. But as it is I think fair payment would be better and probably appreciated more than a nickle. The way it is now the people are simply being exploited.
Awesome video as always. Would it be the case that the photographer would pay the guards or may e even the government more for the photos and 5 cents is what trickles down to the people or is that what the photographer actually pays them?
So they will pay a guide who will have organised the tour. They pick a guard up on the road into the area, actually he is watching the tourists too - i.e. the government does not want them going off track for various reasons I will not go into here. But the villagers themselves get the 5c. The guide is often from a big tour company and pays the locals nothing. There is a new system slowly coming in where a village fee is paid. This is the norm in neighbouring Kenya and possibly a bit fairer.
Orang afrika yg sederhana... Tapi ternak nya begitu banyak, sapi kambing waow... Mewah banget, bikin sate gule sak walehe...
These women are amazing. Especially the mothers , who Not only build their shelter and teach their children to assist, all the while carrying an infant child on their back. I could hardly get my kids to clean their own room
I'm in Kwa Zulu. We have same huts like Ethiopian. I feel Africa ❤️❤️❤️
Wow..I grew up in Ethiopia..and only a short distance from this tribe....and am so glad to have done so with no tourists to influence them.
They will never be the same again after all the tampering and outside spectacle being created.
I do so appreciate this video of the more authentic lives of the Mursi...and no foreign spectators.
Thank you WONDRIUM for supporting this channel .
Set by example and continue your work, which is authentic. Love all your work. Thank you.
I've thought about this amazing film all day and have to say this: These people remain substantially self-sufficient. They have little use for currency. Although the photographers are clearly, and wrongly, exploiting them instead pf documenting their culture, to pay them more would only undermine their values faster. Sadly, thats the fate of most of the worlds people. Thank you for raising the bar.
A
Came across this video which someone posted underneath a photo on Facebook. Wonderful job of telling the short story of how this tribe lives. To answer the question in the video, No, I don't think tourists should be able to just go to the area the tribe is in without prior permission. I also think that five cents is ridiculously low, they deserve much much more or better things like medical care. Thank you for making these videos.
You will pleased to know that one of the younger girls in this video (filmed in 2013) has now trained as a doctor!
@@NomadArchitecture That is amazing news! They are fortunate to have her. ❤
Very beautiful video -(except the horn cutting ); and the narration ? Most beautiful , soft and in tune with the views .....
Thanks for all the past work you've created and sending all the best wishes for future productions
Been waiting months for a new video, nice to see a new one
Whole heartedly agree on this comment
Thanks, there has been a bit of a pandemic on, which has made this all difficult, but we have a lot in preparation for 2022 all being well.
Hi
@@NomadArchitecture good luck and good health!
@@anowarali2444 👋🏼
Awarness of these cultures is fascinating and should be treated as respectfully as possible.
So glad to see you're back : ) this will benefit generations to come
Thanks, Kenya, Russia and Indonesia may happen in 2022 with a bit of luck.
Hats off to the entire crew 🎩
Thank you for a wonderful video.
So this women help each other built huts make baskets and so great team work❤❤❤❤
I've been loving your work. I have been fortunate enough to visit the Mursi people and other Omo valley tribes, and I am passionate about photography. However, being there as a tourist it didn't feel right taking too many photos, I found much more value in observing and talking instead. It would even be worth insisting visitors to refrain from photography so that they can truly take in something so special that they are fortunate enough to experience. Filming and photography for educational purposes would always be welcome of course.
pipo stealing the know how while making money in the process..thats what I see
Сделайте перевод на русский
Is
filming & photography
"for education"
An exception.
Exploitation begins somewhere.
تحياتي لكم ا بالتوفيق من مصر قناه جميله جدا وهدفه نشر المعلومه عن القبائل وعاداتهم وتقاليدهم شكرا لكم احسنت النشر
Ok. This is going to be an unpopular opinion... but please bear with me: My daughter and I live in Namibia. We have a similar nomadic tribe here (Himba, you've made a film about them before). In an ideal world, traditional tribes should be able to survive without modern "interference", so no photographs or money. However, times have changed. The milie flour you're talking about is very cheap but still needs to be purchased (as they're not farmers with fields), the photos create a source of income that still allows the family unit to stay together and continue their nomadic life style (I don't want to comment on the price of photos, obviously it's never fair). The only alternative would be to send people to work in the towns where traditional skills are not of value. That means they end up doing menial jobs (gardening and cleaning) for minimum wage which then is send partly home to support their families. The Himba here also do "photo shoots" in villages and towns, besides selling traditional carvings and baskets. Tourists love taking these photos, but always have to tip or pay.
Thank you for your great film and informative observations.
Not unpopular with me. As it happens, we are now supporting an initiative to create a Himba owned and run tourist camp where they will build traditional huts and fit out as lodges, (although we will probably build modern showers and a cafe). I have been trying to get back there to help them design and build it but corona has made this impossible. If you know anyone in Namibia you think would support this, either come and help build or else donate then it would be great to build a local group. I would love it if such things could come out of my videos.
@@NomadArchitecture Fantastic idea. Actually, I am originally a town planner and my best friend is an architect whose also getting into alternative building methods. My (only 11 year old) daughter is obsessed with primitive skills and especially how to build Himba huts (she's the reason we watch your videos, I also like it, don't get me wrong). I also know a lot of people in the tourism industry. But my first instinct is to say stay away from large established touring companies (they are all owned by namibian germans, who blatantly sabotage all competition, they have established monopolies here). Finding smaller companies run by (non-german) tour guides (especially of Himba origin) might be the way to go...btw before this comment is misunderstood: I myself am of German origin.
@@moonhunter9993 m
@@moonhunter9993 ook
Great points in this comment.
In my humble opinion what you are doing is documenting differing lifestyles which may in the very near future become extinct ... I believe that to be a good thing.
What the Englishmen are doing is exploitation. With that being said, the natives do not seem to mind. So, who's to say one way or the other.
Thank you for the new video and I hope you are all doing well.
Thanks, if the Englishmen had just brought some bags of meal and sugar it would maybe have been better.
@@NomadArchitecture I agree with you ... but I'm not an Englishman who historically puts themselves above all other humans on the planet. If they haven't changed their ways by now, I don't think they are going to.
@@anitamitchell3452 Sad but true.
@@thierrybilson9634 it’s not sad to see people moving out from 5,000 year old practices as normal life, if you think that is okay there is something wrong with your thinking.
Î
I just found this channel, thanks for bringing this to us, it’s an amazing work!
I think it is interesting to see how other people live, they are happy enough , living as they have for thousands of years.
OMG 5c per pic is not ok. Thanks for treating the medical conditions, this is propbably one of the very few services this tribe needs from govenment
Excellent upload. You have an amazing channel.
Thank you for another fascinating video 💜💜💜
euthopian people are beautiful.i love their smile.. they are strong and they have good body shape
I looooove this channel!! From Nenet to Mursi. I am gaining such insight. This is phenomenal
more More MORE!! I love your work and channel. Amazing content.
Who is living the best way, this apartment dweller wonders on the other side of the only planet with life of any kind? Winter comes for me and millions of others and necessity shapes us as it does the Ethiopians. Good will to all you who live wherever you are.
Hooo proud of being a Ugandan 🇺🇬🇺🇬🇺🇬🇺🇬🇺🇬🇺🇬🇺🇬
Amazing hebat salam kenal 🇮🇩 Indonesia Balikpapan Kalimantan timur
What an incredibly inspiring video that touched my heart deeply! I want to express my gratitude for your generosity in sharing it. 🩷
I would love a video on the women's basket weaving and beadwork! This was a simply lovely documentary! Thank you!
We are trying to get more of the other crafts in our latest filmings - keep an eye out for the Korowai in West Papua where my daughter has been filming lots of things.
Very beautiful natural performance
Very good community,family,happiness.
Wow. Finally new release on this amazing channel .
Better late than never. Hopefully Chukotka in the spring!
@@NomadArchitecture 👍
Beautyful people beautyful culture please help this wonderful people save African culture lot of love from INDIA 💞💞💞💞
Great doc but once again the background music is distracting and annoying,never will I understand the over use of it docs.thanks anyway!
Quality content 👍👍
👍
How wonderful these people are. Kudos, please leave these folk alone
Great job done, you are indeed a good researcher
Mascara contains mercury (and there is lead in lipstick). Thanks for this coverage - these people are truly free, living REALLY sustainable lives without the involvement of multinational corporations.
Amazing people!
It is amazing using natural nuater to live turthe Life.
amazing video, thanks for sharing!
HERMOSO DOCUMENTAL....FANTASTICO TRABAJO...FELICIDADES😃😃😃
Another wonderful documentary for us to enjoy watching & learning from.
These humans are so hardworking & physically fit, so unique in their history, their heritage/culture & so much more.
It's truly wonderful to get a personal glimpse into their world & i personally feel honoured.
They possess such gorgeous body/bone structure, almost model/statuesque like. Lovely & lithe, tall & beautifully willowy, as they all walk around working hard.
They even look graceful carrying anything on their heads.
In response to the asked question......
I think we Westerner's are completely curious and fascinated by such humans/tribal groups, which is understandable, however, when i see the English photographers, or any external photographers arriving & in some ways, imposing/encroaching upon their personal space, i feel somewhat disappointed & even angry.
Why? Because i think of the poor & ill treatment of African's historically, specifically during colonization & slavery etc;. It's funny, but one could argue, that this sort of dominant treatment (albeit, no more colonization & slavery), @ the hands of some Westerner's still exists & is allowed to perpetuate & sometimes @ the detriment of the tribal people. At the very least, it would be better & more understandable, if a large percentage of the money made from the photos taken, was given directly to these tribal members, to both assist them financially & to empower them, but if they're not being paid enough, then personally, i see this as a form of human abuse & being taken advantage of, for the greater prosperity/empowerment of the visiting Westerner.
Also, i find it utterly disrespectful & even hypocritical, that the photographers didn't want the camera pointed @ them, yet, they turned up unannounced/without formal invite it appears, disturbing the privacy & peace of these beautiful people & treating them as though they're show ponies! As though their lives aren't already hard enough!
In this regard, it's just not right, or even fair.
Hypothetically speaking, i imagine if the tides were turned, there'd be major pushback, rebellion & negative issues abound. But of course in reality, these quiet, respectful & humble people, would never do such things & they most probably, wouldn't be allowed to anyway.
Nonetheless, as controversial to many as this may be, we must appreciate such documentaries, because you tube has certainly brought much more of this amazing world to us, hence we get the great privilege/opportunity, to learn more about humans & their respective cultures across our world.
Photographers shouldn't be allowed to use them for making a huge profit. It's not unlike how indigenous people were treated hundreds of years ago.
They continue to be treated that way today almost everywhere.
@@lucasiafelice6391
Yes.
really wild life.
I think what you guys are doing is good. It's important to preserve culture and tradition. You're there simply to learn. I think the photographers are exploiting them and that shouldn't be happening. Although to be fair it seems like the population has embraced them. I mean you see how they got ready for pictures.
I am your new subscriber 🤝💓
I am Indian 🇮🇳
Congratulations heights of good beautiful video 🥰❤️👍
Proud of my Africa
Love the videos
Very interesting. TY.
This channel is awesome.
Instead of charging 5c how about providing them with beneficial resources like solar panels, water filters, hygiene, kids supplies, livestock, tools and etc. Westerners who profit off of such things like 5c should be banned from Africa
OMG..
This peoples is strong..
Regarding the english photographers;
Well, the it seems the question is a bit late
Since the British have been doing what they want with indigenous peoples for centuries.
Consciousness is always appreciated
thank you
Judge?? Hell they are already doing the large ear hoops I'm just waiting for the lip disc to take hold here in the USA
Jamii hii inafanana Sana na kabila la wabarabaigi wanaopatikana tanzania
This is so awesome :) !
Whatever has happened to the Kwegu tribe. I have searched for videos current videos on RUclips and nothing. My heart breaks for the beautiful Kwegu people.
Que triste realidade deste povo sempre tão sofrido,vejo isso porém meu coração dói,
The guy with the AK-47 at 5:12
Great Job
Pena que nao tem traduçao em portugues gosto destes videos culturas diferentes
Muito importante conhecer os costumes e suas tradiçoes.
s
Thank you for sharing
Wonferful work. Good
In my tribe, Mursik is a specially prepared sour milk. We hold it dearly
Gosto muito desse tipo de vídeo mais gostaria que fosse dublado em português ou legendado em português parabéns pelo seu trabalho o vídeo ficou ótimo 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 ok
Beatiful. Super video...
Thank you.
Support to you 🙏
Excelente.
Thank you 💕
🌍⭐BEAUTIFUL⭐🌍
❤❤😮
I'm trying to figure out what they playing with in they hand
Great people!!!!
Thnk you🤗
So many questions. How puzzling life has remained the same for so long.
How great that its remained the same for so long 😀 my idea of what a truly advanced society should be, really. I'm highly sceptical about the wheel, really, for me, thats were it all started to go wrong. 😉
Good afternoon
Que loucura elas fazem na boca😮
someone needs to teach this tribe to start charging way more than 5 cents. shame on those photographers for exploiting their innocence.
What use would cash money be?
@@leadbelly1495 they use it to purchase clothes and tools Ive heard.
@@Royak These tribes should have been gone from living this type of life style hundreds of years ago
@@Hi-xu9xn are you saying they are uncivilised?
I do wonder why they chose to live this way, if there is an option of living the urban city life.
@@Hi-xu9xn compared to the current medical tyranny (no mask no job, no jab no job=no services) going on worldwide, I would rather choose this simple lifestyle than live in a cosmopolitan city in this so-called Circus 19 era. Notice there is a lot I omitted from my comment due to RUclips censorship for any speech contrary to the Circus-19 narrative!!!!!
Al final son felices nadie los molesta ni ellos molestan bendiciones
God bless you
Love this ❤️
Very amazing 😊
So sad we go there to disturb them, we should be ashamed of that behaviour.
Kanalınız çok güzel 🤗
Prelijepi ljudi
Leave them to live their own life’s .
طمس.عين.كل.ليم.عفاف.نوياهم.وطبعهم.والا.هم.كل.الجمال.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
No body should allowed to intrude in their lives except to resolve food , water crisis and medical help.
Means wow how they can live in such arid area
I think they should be left alone, but on the other I love to learn about their culture
Come and learn
I am curious to know where the iodine in their diet comes from. Very interesting diet. Lots of vitamin A in blood and milk.
The people don't seem to mind the camera men and tourists but I don't think 5 cents is enough since the photos will generate much more. Considering how the people live I think bolts of cloth, new tools, pots and pans etc., would be a much better deal. If the people minded the photographs it would be a different story, then I would say no photos. But as it is I think fair payment would be better and probably appreciated more than a nickle. The way it is now the people are simply being exploited.
Awesome video as always. Would it be the case that the photographer would pay the guards or may e even the government more for the photos and 5 cents is what trickles down to the people or is that what the photographer actually pays them?
So they will pay a guide who will have organised the tour. They pick a guard up on the road into the area, actually he is watching the tourists too - i.e. the government does not want them going off track for various reasons I will not go into here. But the villagers themselves get the 5c. The guide is often from a big tour company and pays the locals nothing. There is a new system slowly coming in where a village fee is paid. This is the norm in neighbouring Kenya and possibly a bit fairer.
@@NomadArchitecture wow thanks for such a detailed response. Keep up all the good work. I always look forward to seeing your content.
TANKS wonderful 😘
Welcome 😊