World should have given Jews a ‘piece of Germany’
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 сен 2024
- “Jews are not Israelis in exile”
Allan Brownfeld, editor of the American Council for Judaism magazine, tells TRT World that Zionist propaganda has created a confusion between “religion” and “nationality” among American Jews, and if the world wanted to make up for the Holocaust, the world should have given Jews a piece of Germany.
Subscribe:
trt.world/subsc...
Livestream: trt.world/ytlive
Facebook: trt.world/facebook
Twitter: trt.world/twitter
Instagram: trt.world/insta...
Visit our website: trt.world
The victims turned into murderers.
The survivors turned into occupiers.
The targetted turned to oppressors.
the palestinians stayed racists
the palestinians stayed genocidal
the palestinians stayed violent
They will have to evolve !
The vast majority who went to Palestine were the zionist Jews who accepted the offer made to them by hit. Ler. As Zizek said, the zionist Jews went to Palestine and the non zionists Jews went to the concentration camps.
Yours is a common misconception.
As Zizek said, the zionist Js went to Palestine and the non zionist Js went to the con. Cent. ration camps
Crazy but true.
Britain is wholly responsible for everything that happened in the land of Palestine since 1917. Who granted the permission to Britain to donate Palestine to a group of people from Eastern Europe nationals?
yes, correct
Its not the Brittisch my guy. Lord Rothschild is one of the infiltrators, hiding in our European land. In Europe, they rule. The country doesnt matter, because they are internationalists. The ones with no homeland, thats why they had to steal one
Simply...it didnt. That was UN Resolution 181 ( 1947 ). Did your country vote yes ? Britain didnt.
@@stevendale7301 what the heck do you mean by Arab version? Look around, even hyenas are condemning you for killing children, let alone human beings. You're full hate and vengeance of Arabs. You should, because they are real Semites and you're not.Take a moment of your useless time and read the Balfour Declaration. That was the initiator wasn't it?
@@stevendale7301What was the thought process behind the decision?
The British caused this mess! Likewise throughout the world too!
yes, correct.
One stage they wandering parasites wanted part of australia! ISRALIA??
British started it and American government is supporting its continuing of occupation of Palestine 🇵🇸
For most of the problems of the modern middle east, you can draw a straight line to the British Empire.
@@mairajk4873Wrong.
They will call him antisemitic or self hating .
who "they" ?
@@GracePew-ek3rmZionists. Duh.
They will love him
He is bloody spot on; once in awhile a real sincere Jew emerges from the pool of roaches Zionists. And he is absolutely correct; it’s the Germans who have to pay the prices for the Holocaust atrocities done onto the Jews; Palestinians have nothing to do with Holocaust and yet they suffer the consequences Germans evil actions.
It does assume that Jews are just a religious minority of the world, while disregarding their ancestry and place of origin.
The Balfour Declaration was British so the British should pay for this mess.
Liverpool and Manchester should be handed over to Palestinians should they wish to emigrate
Stop trying to blame anyone but Jewish Zionists for what Jewish Zionists have done. The British did not commit the Nakba. Germans did not commit the Nakba. Jewish European Zionists committed the Nakba.
Exactly. The Brits promised the land to the zionist in 1917, before the League of Nations was even created to allow them the mandate.
they were british jews who organized it
But the British are now under Washington’s boot. What a mistake the West made when they appointed the US world cop. Totally corrupt cop.
And the injustice of it all is that Palestinians are paying the terrible price for a crime they did not commit-with their lives, dignity, possessions, freedom, and sovereignty.
Nonsense! Grow up!
What Palestine are talking about? Palestine NEVER EXISTED EVER It was a Roman invention a name given by Emperor Hadrian to the land of Israel to erase its identity in the year 135 to punishtheJews for their rebellions against Rome THAT S ALL there were never a Palestinian people ever The Jews didn't want a piece of any one s land they wanted their own for God's sake and that land is Israel is their ANCESTRAL LAND whether you like it or no All of you are in a rage because they are MUSLIMS thats the trouble here They are notArabs and Muslims that is why you all wanted Israel s annihilation but God protect them because they are not going anywhere they are to stay be realistic
@@stevendale7301 what nonsense ? you cannot counter it with a rational argument so are trying to shout it down. It is you who needs to grow up
Nope. The only things "Palestinians" are paying a price for are their own greed and stupidity.
Just what price did the Arabs pay for Israel's existence? They didn't have to resist the creation of the state. Whatever they've suffered for their choice to battle Israel is on them, not us.
Evil is evil it doesn't matter what ideology you name it .
And we ALL saw what evil looks like on october the 7th...
@@GracePew-ek3rmYou mean we've all heard and seen the evil since 1948
@@GracePew-ek3rm
God allowed Oct7 to happen for illegal occupation.
@@user1qaz2wsx3edcAnd God allowed what's happening now in Gaza for Oct. 7 massacre. Everything happens for a reason.
@@Johnwick-hl7cvhasbara again
1. Haifa Massacre 1937
2. Jerusalem Massacre 1937
3. Balad al-Sheikh Massacre 1939
4. Haifa Massacre 1939
5. Haifa Massacre 1947
6. Abbasiya Massacre 1947
7. Al-Khisas Massacre 1947
8. Bab al-Amud Massacre 1947
9. Jerusalem Massacre 1947
10. Sheikh Bureik Massacre 1947
11. Jaffa Massacre 1948
12. Deir Yassin Massacre 1948
13. Tantura Massacre 1948
14. Khan Yunis Massacre 1956
15. Jerusalem Massacre 1967
16. Bahro Al Baquar 1972
17. Sabra and Shatila Massacre 1982
18. Al Aqsa Mosque Massacre 1990
19. lbrahimi Mosque Massacre 1994
20. Jenin Refugee Camp April 2002
21. Gaza Massacre 2008-09
22. Gaza Massacre 2012
23. Gaza Massacre 2014
24. Gaza Massacre 2018-19
25. Gaza Massacre 2021
26. Gaza Massacre 2023
ongoing , They can NOT AND WILL NOT rewrite history ,IT DID NOT start on OCT 7TH.
war will be FOREVER you deserved to copy and paste as above, it's time for you to go to Uranus and shut the f up...
Before 48 it was part of a conflict between arabs to a jewish teror groups.
The very first act of violence and sexual violence was the Hebron massacre made by an arab mob.
True, it started by the arabs with the jerusalem riots in 1920 and then with the arab revolt btw 1936-1939 😂
First learn to coexist with other humans then lecture. Israel will continue to exist irrespective of what you feel .
'coexist' with land thieves,lol.. onus on who..
the occupiers have overstayed their time in Palestine. they need to get out and take their rubble with them. Shalom.
Yes, it's about time the "Palestinian" occupiers of Jewish land left it.
@@jeffreywilheim5970 lol hasbara, nobody respects this nonsense
@@jeffreywilheim5970 found the Zionist
@@jeffreywilheim5970 land thieves, liars and murderers. That' s what the world thinks of you.
@@jeffreywilheim5970. If Muslims aloud Jews to come and live in Palestine 🇵🇸. Now the Muslims will make sure that will do the right thing and tell them that they are no longer welcome in Palestine 🇵🇸
109 countries….but never do they tell you why
Please tell me why instead of just repeating stupid antisemitic rhetoric. Do you even know what the countries are?
@@Aksjejwjq "Pwease say something I can report to youtube 🤥"
@@Wicker_ By saying something, do you just mean being completely antisemitic? I don’t see why RUclips would take it down if you had an actually valid point to make.
@@Aksjejwjq Whether something is truthful or not has literally no relevance to whether you're persecuted or deplatformed by the powers that be.
Similar to how a fact being anti-semitic or not has no bearing whatsoever on whether or not it's factual.
@@Wicker_ Okay, then please give me a legitimate fact. I’m honestly half expecting you to use the Protocols of the Elders of Zion or blood libel as fact. Or, maybe you’ll cite something outdated like the Khazar conversion theory. I’d be shocked if you can actually provide a genuine fact that backs up antisemitism.
Mileikowsky: I'mma pretend i never heard that.
Nah, he'll said this guys is antisemitic
@@akhsanarrazi7825He'll say this guy is kkkkkkkkkhamas
Mileikowsky who grew up in Philadelphia? LoL He's the biggest fraud of all and a serial killer
The Jews should have been given all of Germany.
No, its Melilkoksky
FREE PALESTINE!!
Free 🇵🇸 from pissraevil
Freedom to 🇵🇸
what does that mean?
Free to go back to Muslim country.
@@davidk2471It means :
Destroy Israel.
Kill the Jews.
Replace a peaceful democratic state with a genocidal terrorist state.
Frankly it sounds like a bad idea to me.
If anyone has any sympathy for the Jews, give them your land, but the Palestinian people will never give them even an inch of Palestinian land.....
It was never "Palestinian" land as there was no such thing as a "Palestinian" until Arafat invented the "Palestinians" in the 1960s. And whether you like it or not, dear heart, Israel is going nowhere.
@@jeffreywilheim5970 i don't know where you got that information from but it wasn't created in 1960s
@@jeffreywilheim5970what a joke hasbara
@@ahmedelasri2509 Yes, it was. There was never an entity called the "Palestinian people" before the 1960s. They considered themselves Arabs, which as far as I'm concerned, they still are.
Even if that land had no name. We don’t care.
There are people living on it and that is there land.
They welcomed Europeans on it and shared their homes and bread with them.
Then the European Jews stole their homes and kicked them out and kelled the Palestinians- the ones already living on the land- whatever you wish to call them.
They wanted a land of people who couldn't fight back
@@yahayamuhammad4119 The British wanted an ULSTER in the ME.
Britain broke its own law in taking someone else's land and giving it to European immigrants - - Dr Ralph Wilde
Israel is the land of the Jews.
It is not "Palestine ".
And it doesn't belong to the "Palestinians ".
Palestine and Palestinians are made up.
Palestinians true identity is Arabs.
Hence their land is Arabia not Israel.
Israel was founded on legally owned land.
Nothing was taken from anyone else.
As Germany is advocating for them,why don't they give their land? All of these chaos are created intentionally
Well by that logic Turkey should be given back to armenians and greeks and assyrians and they should be expelled to central asia and all muslims from other countries should be sent back to arabian peninsula.
Remove Islam from Malaysia and Indonesia , restore the native culture that was destroyed by hordes of Islamists.
Then Lecture about sending jews back to europe
Because it belongs to US-Israel already. Kind regards from Germany.
Because, since denazification, Germans have a thing called "common decency" and respect the right of Jews to their own homeland. Someday you will have common decency too.
@@jeffreywilheim5970 I believe common decency is always there in every society but when u got dictatorship that push propaganda down people's throats, and promotes hate. It radicalises almost entire sections of society and normalises something that would normally be a taboo.
You can see something like this in Islamist Ideology where rabid hate towards jews is so rampant that even kids in arab countries repeat antisemitic tropes even though they don't know the history behind them. But because the hate in their society have radicalise even their young & innocent minds
yes, correct
Well said sir the truth!!
LoL! Palestinians should return to where they came from.
Not one worrd of truth there
yes, correct
@@marinats5873 If not, then please try to refute it ? No ? I am waiting.....
Palestinians want the whole world to help them fight Israelis.
Well, Arabs did, but it failed, and only helped Israel be more cautious.
My cat says:
🏃♀️...Berlin left the chat...🏃♀️
Berlin/Germany: ((Nervous laughing)) “We’re in danger.”
Actually they should have given them peace of Britain because the British are responsible for this
Actually you are wrong.
This opinion is based on lies as usual.
The truth is that Israel is the land that God has given to his people.
Not for a limited period of time but for eternity.
There have always been a Jewish presence in Israel for the last 3000 years plus.
But there have never been a country called "Palestine " or a people called "Palestinians " in the history of the world.
Israel was founded in 1948 in Jewish owned land.
Nothing was taken from anybody else.
Nothing was given to them by "the world ".
But the Arabs wanted to take what the Jews had.
They have started all of the wars that Israel have been involved in
1956, 1967, 1973, 2023 and more.
The "Palestinian" people was only invented in the 1960s to fight the Jews.
And there is actually a direct connection between the so called "Palestinians " and the Holocaust through a man named Haj Amin al-Husseini.
Oh! so well articulated, so simple, so clear. Thanks TRT for uploading. thanks Mr. Brownfeld!
Well articulated, so simple, so clear and so wrong.
Germany should not make Palestinians suffer for the crime's it committed
nothing to do with that
Europeans supported it because it helped them get rid of their Jewish population.
Palestinians had nothing to do with the Holocaust.
@@shafiqshafiq6737 Sad that it's only a mask for their true intentions - oil and gas or something?
this is kind of a bad argument though, nobody let the Romani run around stealing land and murdering people. We are conditioned by propaganda that everything is about Jews.
Germany has nothing useful to say. Palestinians are paying for Germany's crimes. Don't recall reading anywhere that the holocaust was caused by Palestinians. So if you don't support Palestinians, if only as an act of atonement, shut up.
I hope they will understand!
Understand yes, agree absolutely not.
The momentum of fate will make things clear to all
If you understand you will realize how wrong this idea is.
Freedom and justice for Palestinians 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
yes, absolutely
@@mairajkhan2033if land is so sacred why does Germany now have to give up her land?
So, what's the deal with the pact between zionists and nazis in the Haavara Agreement?
Are you trying to say that nazis and Jews were friends ? you heard about the 6.000.000 deaths of the Shoah ?
Have you herad of the many collaboration between nazis and arab leaders after WWII ?
What is the Havara agreement say.??
So, what's the deal with the collaboration between arab leaders and nazis after WWII ?
Their common hate of Jews was the ideological link between those monsters !
@@mushtaqobaray7529The Nazis helped 60,000 German Jews emigrate to Palestine.
@@mushtaqobaray7529 it was a deal between the Zionists and Hitler to allow Jewish people to leave Germany and go to Palestine. The Jewish had to sell all their possessions before leaving, percentage went to the Zionists and upon arrival in Palestine they had to buy German goods.
One of the few sane mind in this world full of insanity
lol
As a Zionists I couldn't agree more! 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Israel is the national homeland of the Jewish people.
There was never a country called "Palestine ".
I don't understand how so many people wants to support a fake country run by terrorists.
Exactly! The perpetrators should have been held accountable and compensated for their wrongdoings.
And the Jews had a right to the return of their stolen property, the land of Israel.
OK, so Israeli Jews are going to receive compensation from the acts of terrorism and attempt to steal their land the Arabs have engaged in for 100 years? Cool!
Who are the perpetrators? If you think Germany, then you didn't learn what happens when you punish people for extended periods with things like the war debt in the Treaty of Versailles. Most of the world learned not to do that after making that mistake in WWI. That is except for one group that neighbors Gaza.
@@user-kf3rm3gd5j Israel's not the perpetrator here, dear heart, and Israel isn't going anywhere.
@@user-kf3rm3gd5j Yeah...I've never bought this argument re Germany after World War I. German historians themselves have blamed Germany for the war. And no matter how humiliated Germany was after World War I, Hitler and Nazism were a choice, not an inevitable outcome. The Germans could have realized that imperialism was getting them nowhere.
Disappointingly, taking on the behavior of their own historical oppressors ! 😮
@@silkycaterwaul3897 lol, they're the same people!
Zio and Nzi
There is no resemblance.
However "Palestine " under Hamas rule is very similar to Nazis Germany only worse.
Or perhaps they were simply projecting the entire time. Are you guys not starting to wonder if maybe the Germans weren't just making up all of their complaints?
@@oscarjosefsson9300 yes, this time "no swimming pools, orchestras, soccer teams, or theatres"
Agree with the uncle 100%, Jewish people never felt they had the need to have their own state, they were born in many different countries and they were always citizens of those countries.
Don't true citizens of a county prioritize that country first and second as something else? Not the other way around. While Christians say the are first Christians, do you see them supporting Christians in other countries before their own nation? What about Arabs? What about Jews?
I have always said exactly what this Jewish man said. I agree completely.
Amazing- is that all you ever said? Or did you w]ever say anything else?
Well actually most of the jews in europe were living in modern day Poland so if you wanna send back to their native land then that would be a more correct choice
When the author Giles McDonogh did the research for After the Reich when the evil Morgenthau plan was put into action to slaughter German civilians he discovered in the official records that 2 in 3 jews had left most European nations before the war started, most of them went to the Uk or America.
The point is that Germany committed the Shoa and should therefore have been the ones losing a large chunk of land for the creation of a Jewish state. They and not the Poles had something done that they needed to make up for as much as possible. (Which would have needed to be more than giving up land.)
@@camelopardalis84 Well they did lose a lot of land to the poles and soviets even the ones that had germans living before the war even began. And since we are talking about Shoah, lets talk about Armenian Genocide that Turkey has still not apologised for. Not to mention how turkey itself is built after multiple ethnic cleansing of Greeks and Armenians and Assyrians and then resettling them with turks , to the point that not a single world heritage site in modern turkey that predates ottomans was built by the turks. Maybe their country should be carved out to give land to greeks and armenians .
Typical west and infidel haters like TRT love to put a spin on things , the thing is Israel ain't going anywhere. You can try to expel the jews and see how it works out .
Prussia should have been given to the Jews. Although Prussia was probably the least jewish region in Germany back then
@@tst2363 Even more reason. These white supremacists are giving eastern european jews land that doesn't belong to them. They should know what they feels like.
But in Germany there is no oil (in the sea) nor beautiful seaside such as Palestine and Lebanon have nor a sunny climate.
And it's also not our homeland, to which we have a connection of 3000 years and to which we have a right.
Which suits the european's fair skin far better, frankly, as skin cancer rates demonstrate
@@jeffreywilheim5970 No you don't have the right, it's arab land in the middle east which is the land of the Arabs.
Ah so that's what they want huh.
It's not about Religion and "promised land" then.
@@jeffreywilheim5970 this land is the holy land for all monotheistic religions. Yes you have the right to be there, however does it give you the permission to commit what has been committed for the last 7 decades? No. Don't you know what "peace" and "respect others" mean? It means that when you go to a land where there are people already living there for thousands years, you respect them, and do everything to create peace to live all together in harmony. Go back to basics human beings before talking about "we have the right to be there".
Our blood is boiling and we swear to help them but..... 😢😢❤❤❤I can't why?? 😢Ya Allah only you can help no country has courage to help 😢😢😢
So well said and Truthful.👍
Kind man with good values understood Torah. Understood and felt the pain of human beings sufferings in Gaza. True Jews must be like this.
They can have a piece of Florida. If they want to avoid being assimilated.
We can also have all of Israel, as it's our country.
yes, correct
@@jeffreywilheim5970 Isn'treal will never know peace until the day it dissolves
They can all take their primary passports back to where they are originally from and be glad they're not implicated in the criminal charges against the Israeli government due to are there aiding and abetting if not actually participating in these crimes. And if they want to live in a Jewish only sovereign state that they can travel to the one that exists in Russia right now that is full of Jews that aren't participating in genocide and ethnic cleansing and are living according to the rules of their religion. Everyone is so eager to say Israel is the only place set aside for Jews alone and it's just not true.
@@decolonizeEverywhere Yeah, see, Israel's been issuing passports of its own 1949. We decolonized our homeland and won't apologize for doing so just because some academic somewhere wants to pretend we're "settler colonialists" for returning to our own country. Wherever they were born, Israeli citizens are Israelis. We don't really give a crap whether you think we're authentic or have the right skin color to live in our own country. And we're not going anywhere no matter how much you scream and no matter how many lies you tell about war crimes and a genocide that aren't happening. So take your antisemitism and shove it.
Basically they got so butthurt after the holocaust they demanded an already settled land back for compensation. They could have formed such a place in europe where it is safe and not illegal.
They continue to claim God promised them this land when in the reality it was the british who actually promised them the land.
The Zionists were secular, they never claimed so.
And Germany owes Jews reparations and land not Palestine.
they probatly thought that they were god?
That could be true from an athiest's point of view since the British were the power especially after winning World War 1 thus ruling the entire world
In reality God promised them the land and not Brittain.
If you believe that Brittain gave "Palestine " to the Jews then you don't know the history.
because it never about Jewish or Palestinian. it's US and Israel thing. it's the canal that they're after.. whoever owned the canal they rule the world.
Thanks for uploading this
There’s an insightful man telling it as it is and should have always been!
Right sir 😊
Amazing that this man does not truly know Jewish history. And he is the editor of the American Council of Judaism? Unbelievable.
It was supposed German chancellor gave place for Jew not the Palestinian people.
sources? last time i researched it was britain with the British mandate of Palestine. For readers, please don't take information from liberal muslims.
Give Constantinople back to the Greeks.
Spot on.
yes, absolutely correct
Actually the Palestinians were fighting for Britain in World War Two, so although they might not have liberated the camps they were an allied nation.
When Britain entered World War Two all the countries in the British empire entered World War Two, this includes Palestine.
They must have pieces of Germany, Britain and 35% of the US. Specifically the states that is landlocked.
It's about money and oil, greed and paranoia with one lie after another.
Yes this is so true Judaism is a religion not a nationality .
Thank you for clarifying that my identity is fake. I'll let my family know
It's only a few thousand years old. Most of human history took place before Judaism was invented. Christianity was invented. It's just a vessel for stealing land and colonization. Everyone who isn't indoctrinated can see that. So ridiculous to say "God told me that I'm allowed to steal your land." Liar.
@@davidk2471 "Judaism" is literally and unambiguously a religion, not a nationality
@@chompythebeastHistorically it is an ethnoreligious group, German Jews as "German" as they are nationaity wise, saw themselves as a clear distinct group and Germans that aren't jews saw them as such as well, hence their desire for Israel to exist hence their siding with Britain hence German non jew reaction hence aftermath with a ww2 ally victory the creation of the state of Israel, such things are so simple yet you people speak as if like you invented the wheel when you literally know nothing...
The promise for a land for the jews had nothing to do with reparations, jews were showing up in what is called Israel today from mid to early 1800s, way before "Germany" even exist, grow up...
Absolutely. And there are many who claim to be athiest Jews. How can you be a non believer and a jew at the same time. Really ridiculous.
Wow, talk about epic cluelessness. Jews have been considered a nationality from 1300 BC up to 2000AD.
American Jews never believed that they were in exile? Take a look at the prayers Jews recite 3 times a day, including Shaabat. "Let our eyes witness the return to Zion".
You can't get away with telling lies.
Israel should have been in Germany or USA not in Palestine.
yes, absolutely correct
Exactly. Germany committed the crime, they should have given up their land.
Nobody believes your clown ' narrative'
you get the hell out of here
@ChaseSanchez-ym6eb "Indoeuropeans should return to Yamna" Basque Person probably
Germany lost 20 million people and half it's land mass you idiot.
No one should have given up their land
Give them west germany and florida.
yes, correct
yes, absolutely
No, let them take their primary passports back to where they're originally from and be lucky they're not implicated in the criminal charges against their government which they have been assisting if not participating in the crimes of
And why exactly would you want to reward people who are committing genocide and ethnic cleansing with a nation of Their on? Did we get the Nazis a nation of their own when they were kind enough to stop committing genocide and ethnic cleansing against them after World War ii? No we took them to the Nuremberg trials and tried them for their crimes and put them in prison as much as we could. And we're not going to give these Nazi zionists a country of their own because they're finally forced to stop committing their crimes. Justice doesn't work that way.
Thanks but no thanks.
God already gave us land.
yes, absolutely correct
Just like the majority of the problems we're facing today, the British are to blame.
Right, they should have never created Pakistan for Muslims to have their own State...
Exactly 💯💯💯
I fully agree. Since they experienced the horrors of germany they should go there and have their own land there.
@JoeM-yv2br nah its now better than ever, now that the new german passport application needs you to say something about the zionazi state.
Here's an interesting perspective.
There were around 2.18 million Palestinians were registered as refugees in 2016 according to Minority Rights Group. This population was either born in Jordan or moved there between 1947 and 1967. Now, lets say that Israel keeps going and still exists in 200 years. Should the decedents of those Palestinians still be able to claim the right to go back to the places their ancestors come from? Basically, how long should they be able to make that claim?
And lets say the United States dissolves this year and Britain get a UN mandate to oversee the area, should the British give the native Americans nations the right to reclaim their old territories and start their own nations? Regardless of the people who live there currently? Or should they buy those people out? Like do North and South Dakota become Sioux land again? Do the Sioux that live in different states or different countries get to move back to the Dakota's to participate in this land? Is there going to need to be a two state solution for the Native Americans and otherwise national Americans?
So, what kind of logic do you base these decisions on/off of?
Now, I'm sure most of you understand the implications of different answers that can be given here (if you don't understand, just ask and I will spell it out for you).
But please don't misunderstand, I don't think there are easy answers either way currently. But I also think the easy answers that most people are giving here (along the lines of "the Jews should just leave") are very helpful in both the short and long term.
It all began with the "Balfour Declaration" in 1917...
The Saudis suggested giving a chunk of Germany, AT THAT TIME.
BUT, in the 1940's neither Jew nor Arab was given "FULL STATUS" BY THE WEST.
Im a Israeli jew and my family has been here for at least 9 generations and many of my friends families have been way before this become a jewish state
...and we were living in peace before the creation of the state of Israel .
Your relatives were "palestinians j3ws" they you all became "israelis" after 48.
That is very true…
Sadly we can argue until the end of time were did it go wrong exactly and by who’s interest but the reality is we are both here to stay.
Just seems as long as there will be muslim terror that agenda of 2 states get further away.
Peace advocates got burnt alive on film by hamas.
Thats not progress.
By the way I’m living in peace with many Arab neighbours around my house. Some of the best people i know.
@@user-dj1hu4hk1q Your family should be allowed to stay. European settlers from the late 19th century onward, however, will be subject to greater scrutiny as to whose house and whose land they squat
That was under the "Laissez faire" Ottoman Rule. I don't think it will be that way should HAMAS ever conquer Israel.
Us, Vietnamese, have been through everything: being colonized for thousands of years by powerful countries, exploited to the core, killed in horrendous ways,... and still we have to pay money to normalized our affairs with those countries. During the 1940s, when we were being oppressed by the French and the Japanese at the same time, no one said anything... but we still fought for our freedom and maintain peace with the countries. Meanwhile, a developed country like Israel, which used to oppressed by the Nazis and was helped by the world is now being a tyrant? Killing, bombarding thousands of civilians and children? This world is messed up.
The Palestinians were offered a choice by history, and they blew it. It's that simple. The Japanese were smart enough to seize the day. The Palestinians floundered on extremely narrow self-interest and immediacy.
Why would any country give you land? It is not anybody's responsibility. Build your own!
the most logical thing about israel-palestine conflict and about holocaust I have ever heard.
For 2000 years, the last line of Passover is always, Next year in Jerusalem. Jews have lived there 3;500 years. Israel is covered with ancient cities, the archeology is Jewish. .We are called Jews because we are indigenous to Judaea. The Jewish star’s 2 triangles stand for the relationship between G-d, Torah, and Israel.
A country of psychopaths, thieves and racists called israel. Your illegal country is founded on violence and blood. The world has woken up.
Indeed. German should give a piece of its land if they want to redeem themselves. Or America if they love zoinist so much. Why punish Palestine for German's sin?.
Germany belongs to the US and Israel already.
Actually while there were pogroms in czarist Russia and of course the nazi mass murder the safest place for the Ashkenazi would and has been America.A single lynching in 1915 if a Jewish northern businessman for the rape and murder of a 13 year old girl .Irish Catholics and especially Italians let alone Huspanics Asians and blacks faced far worse by the racist Anglo Saxons.And now what Arabs and Muslims are forced to suffer because of the endless bigotry of the anglo zionist MSM.give them Florida Save the taxpayers some money to help the homeless and health care!
Religion and nationality shouldn’t determine where you can or cannot live.
God I'm so sick of hearing about these people
After the horrors they experienced, they must have wanted to get the hell out of Germany.
Sahi baat hai
Big shame on Israel claming land of Palestinian 😢😢😢
Who are the "Palestinians"? Who? Where did they come from genius? Where was this country Palestine? Who was the ancient king or President of Palestine? The land known as Judea had been conquered over and over again, by Romans, Ottomans, the British, etc. A country known as Palestine never existed. The UN gave this land back to its rightful owners. It would be a Jewish State. The fact is the Muslim world would not stand for it. All the rest is BS. This is not about land or some made up people called Palestinians. Hamas could not give a crap about them. They hide behind women and children for PR purposes.
They're coming for Spain next....as it used to be mostly Islamic. Then greater Europe.
If you repeat the lies that you have been told, often enough, you will believe that they are true.
@@gwarlow the Palestinians had nothing to do with the Holocaust.....This is true. They had nothing to do with anything. They didn't exist until the 1960. They are just a gang of Arabs self- identifying as "Palestinians" and telling the world that they are perpetual victims of Western colonialism and Jews in particular. They simply serve a purpose for the Imans that really run the Islamic world and want to take it over the entire globe.
Well said. ❤
I think its BS for a people to say "hey our ancestors used to live here so we have an eternal right to this land". People move around, sometimes by choice and sometimes by force. It's happened to all regions throughout history in times of never ending war and conquest. They weren't the first people and they weren't the last.
Im sad man Calling chill Jews exiles
If the truth is not in you then you will swallow the lies of the world.
I had never thought about that. I think you're right. If the problem was to give a land to the Jews, the logic was to take it from those who wanted to eliminate them and lost. Thank you, I learned another lesson.
Germany belongs to US-Israel already. never visited Germany? Zionism isn't interested in Europe, they want the Holy Land.
That would have been a wise decision. It's better than displacing both European Jews and Palestinians.
Absolutely. Families of the German and other European jews whose homes and property was stolen should be compensated and able to return to their homes or similar. This was the greatest injustice done to the jewish survivors after the war. Europe still suffers from their parting. Btw in the post war negotiations, Abdulaziz told the Allies that this was the best solution instead of creating a new state on arab land.
"Palestinians had nothing to do with the holocaust"....... Amin al-Husseini
Actually they did.
@@jeffreywilheim5970 Haavara Agreement.
@chompythebeast You honestly think that was legitimate or in any way benefited zionists? Clownf
No they shouldn't have because neither Germany nor Palestine were yours!
Well said!
@@CKyIe danke
As far as the thumbnail, they shouldn't give any part of Germany to them at all because "it" never even happened.
I've been saying this since I was a kid. You have to ask, why isn't there any evidence of a single Jew from the time period, demanding territory from Germany?
That makes a lot of sense when you think about it. European Jews should get land allocated in Europe for them as Holocaust reparations instead of given Palestinians home and land to them after uprooting them throughout the decades.
AND TURKEY OUGHT TO GIVE BACK ALL ARMENIAN TERRITORIES TO ARMENIA, ASSYRIAN ONES TO ASSYRIANS AND GREEK ONES TO GREECE!
The Palestinians are the descendants of the Greeks, Turks, and Assyrians who came to conquer Israel in history. The Greeks were Philistine which translates to Palestine.
We are seeing the same images of starving people in ga za and it's being done by their descendants.
@@Naomi-de2ps i really, really don't think "israelis" are the descendants of holocaust victims. I think they're more of converted german jews or something. Haavara agreement...look it up.
We were kind enough to give them an autonomous region in Russia and they're just something else.
If American Jews never believed they were in exile, why did they Long to return to the holy Land name their towns and neighborhoods names like Bethlehem, Hebron, Bethel and last but not least Palestine‽
Couldn't given them eastern Germany which is now poland
The Jews didn't want it, or any other place. It was always"Next year, in Jerusalem!". Always. And they were , and are entitled to it.
So many of you are missing the point. Even if they were offered a piece of land in Europe, they wouldn't care. They want Palestine, they want historic Judea, they want "The Promised Land".
The Palestinians had a leader called the Mufti who was a Nazi sympathizer and even met with Hitler to discuss the final solution. So in fact they did have a hand in the holocaust and actually were supporting it
It's not too late to give them a piece of Germany. The state now requires would be citizens to recognise their right to exist....so give them Bavaria.
Ottoman genociders should be brought to justice. Turkey should give reparations to all victims.
Yasser Arafat in 1964 said only Arabs could call themselves Palestinian. When I was a kid in the 50s, Palestinian meant Jewish.
That is true and it is recorded on film in Australia in the 1920s a visiting group of Jewish footballers were called Palestinians
Correction: some of them are descendants of the victims, and others weren't even victims.
Most of the jews in Israel actually came from the middle east Turkey Iraq Syria? What about them
If you include the Palestinians because of their Semitic heritage, then yes. Otherwise, not at all. Jews have been a minority in the region of Palestine for the longest time, and only started moving there starting in the 1920's through the machinations of the Zionists.
The argument of the Pro-Palestine movement is that these Jews originally came from their ancestral homeland of Eastern Germany.
Took the words right out of my mouth- agreed wise man!