Great Video, but a couple of reforms that you suggested seem like catch 22 For example, You talked about "Assured tenure" for an IPS officer or IAS officer so that he feels secured in the job and take decisions without fear. BUT If most of the IAS officers are corrupt and an honest IAS officer is an exception rather than a rule then "assured tenure" will only enable them to do more corruption. Same applies for the other point, if the government tries to transfer him and he again takes an equivalent powerful position then again the entire exercise is rendered futile. My assumption here is that determination of whether an officer is corrupt/honest, is determined by his goodwill/perception that he has created and not based on whether he is convicted under the law or not, it will take a long time for the government to get rid of a corrupt officer with due process of law therefore if they can transfer him to a less powerful position then at least they are minimising the damage. In other words, it is a potential safeguard/check & balance.
Valid points. I guess it's the final the point in Sir's solution which ultimately holds out i.e. we need to reform our political values and talk about the right issues, the rest would come automatically.
You know how tough is to get into the service. And how skilled and talented they are which have only here in India . In India civil service not the last option for anyone it's their ambition of life so get corrupt people straight up is highly unlikely
Same applies to bullying in Indian schools . Nowadays situation in better with CCTVS and student standing up for themselves immediately. But 10 yrs back then there was no such thing. Kids problems were small problems. Vulnerability is biggest misfortune.
Mr Rajan Singh ,today I came across your channel and I am really getting inspired by your talks on many of your videos and also feeling proud that people like you were in police force and have great intentions to change or improve the old laws and contribute to the better and improved India ! Law and order is the most important thing for any nation to grow with pride in every citizen of the nation and everything else depend on unbiased and effective execution of law & order! Thank you so much for spreading awareness and sharing your experience and suggestions ! Awaiting to see video on your thoughts on Maharashtra CP Param Bir Singth and HM allegations case ,do you think it could be true or it’s just a politics in your opinion!
Nice explanation ! It is so heartening to know that Brilliant persons like you have not succumbed to the overseas lucre & served our nation. Kudos ! & May your kind increase.
Sir this video help me to get better understanding on actual working culture in govt jobs and hope that one day police institutions will also become independent like judiciary
Can you make a video about digital freedom and how much access does the police have over our data? and is it against the law to use personal information for investigation?
Better to introduce Artificial Intelligence cops. Having said that it’s not an easy task. Awareness has to be generated in the society. Easy reforms are to be made which should enable police to work peacefully with out or minimized political interface. I nice video, as always I enjoy watching your videos.
Prakash Singh Judgement guidelines still not implemented Civil Services Board are in paper Sir till political will for reforms is not there, it's a difficult task...... And seeing the nature of politics it's seems a virtual reality
PROTECTS INDEPENDENCE OF EXECUTIVE GUARANTEED BY CONSTITUTION OF INDIA TO ALL EXECUTIVE BY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED PROVISIONS FORMALLY AND PROPERLY. AS A RESULT NO POLITICAL PERSON SHALL DARE TO INTERFERE IN INDEPENDENCE OF EXECUTIVE OF ANY EXECUTIVE OFFICER IN EXECUTION OF DUTIES OF HIS OFFICE.
Comparison with a hospital in clarifying administrative dispensation is a flawed idea. A police officer is mandated to comply with only lawful order. Here , issue is not of discretion rather legality. A junior Doctor may be advised on medication method and dose administration . No code or thump rule exists.
![Diggy Graves - Red Vineyard [Official Lyric Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8Ro085T0mnQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I post new videos regularly on my other channel - ruclips.net/user/habitstrong
Great Video, but a couple of reforms that you suggested seem like catch 22
For example, You talked about "Assured tenure" for an IPS officer or IAS officer so that he feels secured in the job and take decisions without fear.
BUT If most of the IAS officers are corrupt and an honest IAS officer is an exception rather than a rule
then "assured tenure" will only enable them to do more corruption. Same applies for the other point, if the government tries to transfer him and he again takes an equivalent powerful position then again the entire exercise is rendered futile.
My assumption here is that determination of whether an officer is corrupt/honest, is determined by his goodwill/perception that he has created and not based on whether he is convicted under the law or not, it will take a long time for the government to get rid of a corrupt officer with due process of law therefore if they can transfer him to a less powerful position then at least they are minimising the damage. In other words, it is a potential safeguard/check & balance.
Valid points.
I guess it's the final the point in Sir's solution which ultimately holds out i.e. we need to reform our political values and talk about the right issues, the rest would come automatically.
You know how tough is to get into the service. And how skilled and talented they are which have only here in India .
In India civil service not the last option for anyone it's their ambition of life so get corrupt people straight up is highly unlikely
Same applies to bullying in Indian schools . Nowadays situation in better with CCTVS and student standing up for themselves immediately. But 10 yrs back then there was no such thing. Kids problems were small problems. Vulnerability is biggest misfortune.
7 dislike from Home Ministers Family members
Sir lots of respect for you, why you decided to leave the service, present society needs honest police officer like you sir
Mr Rajan Singh ,today I came across your channel and I am really getting inspired by your talks on many of your videos and also feeling proud that people like you were in police force and have great intentions to change or improve the old laws and contribute to the better and improved India ! Law and order is the most important thing for any nation to grow with pride in every citizen of the nation and everything else depend on unbiased and effective execution of law & order! Thank you so much for spreading awareness and sharing your experience and suggestions !
Awaiting to see video on your thoughts on Maharashtra CP Param Bir Singth and HM allegations case ,do you think it could be true or it’s just a politics in your opinion!
This is such an amazing channel. Like really.
Thank you so much Sir.
Your suggestions to reform our police system is indeed a good start point
Sir , i really found u to be a good human being . I feel motivated towards humanity after listening to uh sir .
Sir, you are really true honest person and India's true " Bharat Ratna"
Nice explanation ! It is so heartening to know that Brilliant persons like you have not succumbed to the overseas lucre & served our nation. Kudos ! & May your kind increase.
Ur doing a commendable job...your views are enlightening the general public
Sir you are really an amazing person.
Talented and down to earth.
Sir this video help me to get better understanding on actual working culture in govt jobs and hope that one day police institutions will also become independent like judiciary
Sir you are real ex ips officer .
Great work, Great video sir. Please keep posting more such videos :)
Sir your videos are very real ,
Informative , practical and helpful
Thank you sir
Pleasure listening to you.
For the firstt time these things came in public
These issues will be resolved soon
Bahut ki achha hae sir ji
Can you make a video about digital freedom and how much access does the police have over our data?
and is it against the law to use personal information for investigation?
Sir tell us about bribery system in department
Excellent begining.
Very imp issue and great explanation.
Thanking you sir for the informative vedio..
Country needs u in politics
Excellent insider affair about police work sir !! Great
Same things are happening in DRDO very frequently
Better to introduce Artificial Intelligence cops. Having said that it’s not an easy task. Awareness has to be generated in the society.
Easy reforms are to be made which should enable police to work peacefully with out or minimized political interface.
I nice video, as always I enjoy watching your videos.
Neta log hi bhrast hay ...wo log policy maker wo log thodi karega😂
Good sir
Make video about IFS foreign role, power, salary.
ruclips.net/video/tKV5rxzLAME/видео.html
He is also on Quora
Awesome
Prakash Singh Judgement guidelines still not implemented
Civil Services Board are in paper
Sir till political will for reforms is not there, it's a difficult task...... And seeing the nature of politics it's seems a virtual reality
PROTECTS INDEPENDENCE OF EXECUTIVE GUARANTEED BY CONSTITUTION OF INDIA TO ALL EXECUTIVE BY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED PROVISIONS FORMALLY AND PROPERLY. AS A RESULT NO POLITICAL PERSON SHALL DARE TO INTERFERE IN INDEPENDENCE OF EXECUTIVE OF ANY EXECUTIVE OFFICER IN EXECUTION OF DUTIES OF HIS OFFICE.
Nice video
Comparison with a hospital in clarifying administrative dispensation is a flawed idea. A police officer is mandated to comply with only lawful order. Here , issue is not of discretion rather legality. A junior Doctor may be advised on medication method and dose administration . No code or thump rule exists.
🎉😮
Sar, police paise lekar jhutha mukadma registered karti hai is per ek video banaaiye dhanyvad ... my name is Jawahar phone number 8451 097 261