HERE IT IS! PART 2! I hope you enjoy the 2nd part to this ongoing theory! PART 3 will be based on 'That Night' and how Bethany ties into the main storyline for that event, and why Charlotte really hit Ali around the head! - PART 4 I'm thinking could be about what happened to Marion Cavanaugh, but let me know what you want P4 to be based around, whether it be Marion, Charlotte & Bethany in Radley or Jessica's Death, let me know!
Thank you, yeah that's true, but twins do run in the family so if Charlotte & Bethany were twins at least we know it isn't a completely improvised and random story line :)
I agree with you 100% I also think that Mary got a lot more children then just charolette and spencer then we know about maybe and I think those children are Bethany Andrew ( he's Adopted ) Aria ( her file was missing )
oh yeah we in the dollhouse Charlotte didn't actually hurt Spencer... noel(helped)and just put fake blood on Spencer making her think she killed someone but to the other girls she shocked them and stuff
Or maybe Mary had way more kids and Andrew is also one of them? That's how they're all kind of connected! I'm just trying to figure out how Hanna, Aria and Em are connected? Are they just in it cause they associated with Ali and the billions of Mary's kids or do they all have a deeper connection to Mary, Jessie and Radley? What still bothers me is the situation with Eddie Lamb and Aria. The way he seemed to know her so well and then all over a sudden he disappeared. Did Wren have anything to do with that? Wren could also be AD? Maybe his dad is Scott Montgomery and Aria used to visit her uncle while he was admitted there or at another facility? We don't know where else Eddie worked at before Radley. We know Mona was just the 1st A and had her own reasons, so she has no family connection to everyone, only a super stalker jealous psychosis which got treated at Radley. It all has to connect somehow to make some sense!
Sort of the same theory I've had only that I think the twin isn't Charlotte, but Spencer and that's why we haven't seen her face yet. If they're not identical twins then why has her face been hidden for so long? I also think that Wren may be Mary's son and therefore he was close with Bethany, cause they were siblings and that's why saw him draw the picture of the mom dad a girl and a son. I don't think he knew Spencer was also his sister until maybe later or he may still not know? Wren came to RW to figure out his origins and it led him to Radley cause his mom and dad were maybe admitted there and Bethany Young's name may just be a cover name and her real name is Hasting's cause I think she's Spencer's twin and not Charles/Charlotte's. Wren's dad had mental issues and he may have been admitted at Radley as well and that's how he was conceived? I think AD may be one of Mary's baby daddies, Ali herself or even Jessica who killed Mary and is posing as Mary right now?
the story CeCe told them about Bethany pushing Toby's mom was a lie bcs Charle was about 12y old and in some other episode toby and alison are showed at toby's house when they were teens and his mother was there
There are some theories that Maya is still alive. What if Spencer and Maya are sisters but they share the same father Eddie Lamb? Mary had an affair with Mary when she wasin Radley years before and Maya is either his illigitimate daughter or her parents divorced when she was little and she took her adoptive father's last name of St. Germain. I think that would be a nice way to tie in Troian's mix heritage too. I tend to think Bethany is a red-herring.
Hi. Amazing theories! But can you make a research about that third child. I don't think it's Bethany, I think Wilden and Charlotte are twins or just siblings. Cuz they're almost the same age. Just asking tho 😂😂 But awesome theories 👍
I know this isn't a who is A.D. theory BUT I thought A-D is a girl now that Marline tweeted that we will see the scene where the girls run into the classroom and tell Ali to run bc HE is here, I'm unsure. What do you guys think?
yeah, i agree, some part of me randomly thinks its sydney because she just randomly showed up then we never saw her again through the episode. the person in the hoodie in 7x10 was defo a female
***** Another question what do you think: Has the half burned mask the black widow once wore a meaning or not? I'm thinking maybe A.D. has a half burned face or was that Sarah? not sure about the timeline:(
+Simina The person wearing the half burnt mask is black widow, who is Sara Harvey. She was at the lodge dressed as red coat, she is the one that saved the girls when Shana took fire on it (apart from Hanna, Ali saved her only, she confirmed it herself), that's how her mask got burned i think x
What do you mean? Charles & Bethany are fraternal twins, and Spencer is their younger sibling. The video in the dollhouse vault was Charles, Jason and a Baby Spencer. The Campbell Apple Farm will come up in one of the later Parts of this theory :)
It was never confirmed, don't get me wrong it could be, but Jessica said 'Say goodnight to your sister, give her a little kiss?' and Charles kissed her and Jason only tapped her. This is what makes me believe it could possibly be Spencer :)
When Aria and Spencer visited the Obgyn who delivered the babies he was talking about a boy. Only a boy. and then said something like several years later he helped with another 1 of her children but couldn't remember the gender.(He helped with 2 of her children). So she could have had a third (Spencer) after the 1st two but wouldn't he have said she had twins or 2 babies together when he was talking about the boy from the c-section he handed to Jessica? I can't see how Bethany and Charles/Charlotte could be the same age or twins. Unless PLL is screwing with us again showing that clip...which is possible...
good point, but i think Bethany is more important than what we first thought, there is a reason why shes so significant, this theory is based off of if bethany and charlotte were the same age, but people believe bethany could also be a similar age to the liars, so in that case she could have been the 2nd baby born a few years later, but jessica could have paid dr cochran to keep his mouth shut about the twin baby (bethany) because jessica wanted it to stay quiet maybe?
That is true. She has been involved for too long not to be some major player in the plot. Even if only to tie stuff together. And it makes sense that Mary had 3 kids. Why would the doc say 2 OF her children is she only had 2. He would have said both or all...there is something there...
+Bianca Helberg exactly, thats what i thought was weird when he said '2 of her children' if there was just Spencer and Charlotte surely he would have said 'her 2 children', i mean, twins obviously run in the family from mary and jessica so its possible it could happen again :)
I know right! Well I hope you figure everything out before April 2017 because I can't wait THAT long!!!! Also, I am not sure if you have done anything like this but I would love to see a theory on Mona being A.D. I have seen 1 or 2 and to be honest...I am starting to get some idea that that could be accurate...I LOVE her but she is really shady! :) Her being so involved in everyone's lives, being in Radley, being so tech savvy, having being the original A, her ties to Charlotte and that last 2 scenes where she was fixing Caleb's coffee and letting Noel get away...mmmm
+Bianca Helberg i know right, me neither it seems like ages away! ive started watching the whole series from S1 again to try and figure out hints to Mary Drake and Spencer we wouldnt have realised before. I havent actually but that's a great idea! I'll start making it now, i have found a few points that leads to Mona being A.D but i wanna try and dig for more clues too! thanks for the idea! :)
They can't be twins.. The doctor delivered two babies.. If she had 3 children don't you think he would of pointed out they were twins.. If he delivered 2 of 3 of her babies
Lindsey Murda since when has pll been good on giving correct information? they literally told us Mona was not A -.-, but when that episode ended who was A?
HERE IT IS! PART 2! I hope you enjoy the 2nd part to this ongoing theory!
PART 3 will be based on 'That Night' and how Bethany ties into the main storyline for that event, and why Charlotte really hit Ali around the head! - PART 4 I'm thinking could be about what happened to Marion Cavanaugh, but let me know what you want P4 to be based around, whether it be Marion, Charlotte & Bethany in Radley or Jessica's Death, let me know!
where,s part 3 ???
It will be up in the next 10mins
bethanys age was confirmed. she is now 22 cause of the time jump
***** the link to the please to part 3 ,,i do like your videos
Part 3 is in the description guys :)
this theory makes me so happy 💓
Part three please I love these
will be up next week :)
Strong theory, I don't believe we're getting another twin twist tho, would've been too easy in a sense that we have mary and jessica already.
Thank you, yeah that's true, but twins do run in the family so if Charlotte & Bethany were twins at least we know it isn't a completely improvised and random story line :)
I cant wait for part three
do part 4 n 5 plz Iove ur theories..
Really nice theory!
thank you :)
I agree with you 100% I also think that Mary got a lot more children then just charolette and spencer then
we know about maybe and I think those children are
Bethany
Andrew ( he's Adopted )
Aria ( her file was missing )
oh yeah we in the dollhouse Charlotte didn't actually hurt Spencer... noel(helped)and just put fake blood on Spencer making her think she killed someone but to the other girls she shocked them and stuff
very true!
That's why there were two sets of baby clothes in the dollhouse. Charle/Charlotte and spencer
have you made a theory on why Aria's file is missing yet? I feel like they're planning a big twist on her that no one is expecting.
Or maybe Mary had way more kids and Andrew is also one of them? That's how they're all kind of connected!
I'm just trying to figure out how Hanna, Aria and Em are connected? Are they just in it cause they associated with Ali and the billions of Mary's kids or do they all have a deeper connection to Mary, Jessie and Radley?
What still bothers me is the situation with Eddie Lamb and Aria. The way he seemed to know her so well and then all over a sudden he disappeared. Did Wren have anything to do with that?
Wren could also be AD? Maybe his dad is Scott Montgomery and Aria used to visit her uncle while he was admitted there or at another facility? We don't know where else Eddie worked at before Radley.
We know Mona was just the 1st A and had her own reasons, so she has no family connection to everyone, only a super stalker jealous psychosis which got treated at Radley.
It all has to connect somehow to make some sense!
Sort of the same theory I've had only that I think the twin isn't Charlotte, but Spencer and that's why we haven't seen her face yet. If they're not identical twins then why has her face been hidden for so long?
I also think that Wren may be Mary's son and therefore he was close with Bethany, cause they were siblings and that's why saw him draw the picture of the mom dad a girl and a son. I don't think he knew Spencer was also his sister until maybe later or he may still not know?
Wren came to RW to figure out his origins and it led him to Radley cause his mom and dad were maybe admitted there and Bethany Young's name may just be a cover name and her real name is Hasting's cause I think she's Spencer's twin and not Charles/Charlotte's.
Wren's dad had mental issues and he may have been admitted at Radley as well and that's how he was conceived?
I think AD may be one of Mary's baby daddies, Ali herself or even Jessica who killed Mary and is posing as Mary right now?
have they ever actually mentioned anything about mr young working in radley?
I love it
Thank you :)
What's the name of the song in the beginning? :)
cartoon - on and on :)
the story CeCe told them about Bethany pushing Toby's mom was a lie bcs Charle was about 12y old and in some other episode toby and alison are showed at toby's house when they were teens and his mother was there
sry for bad english
There are some theories that Maya is still alive. What if Spencer and Maya are sisters but they share the same father Eddie Lamb? Mary had an affair with Mary when she wasin Radley years before and Maya is either his illigitimate daughter or her parents divorced when she was little and she took her adoptive father's last name of St. Germain. I think that would be a nice way to tie in Troian's mix heritage too. I tend to think Bethany is a red-herring.
Song ??
Cartoon - On & On (feat. Daniel Levi)
song in 1:00
Hi. Amazing theories! But can you make a research about that third child. I don't think it's Bethany, I think Wilden and
Charlotte are twins or just siblings. Cuz they're almost the same age. Just asking tho 😂😂
But awesome theories 👍
yeah sure, I will make more theories about the third child dont worry ♥
I have more clues/theories for you for Spencer and Charlotte, Woulkd you like to make one with me with it
I know this isn't a who is A.D. theory BUT I thought A-D is a girl now that Marline tweeted that we will see the scene where the girls run into the classroom and tell Ali to run bc HE is here, I'm unsure. What do you guys think?
yeah, i agree, some part of me randomly thinks its sydney because she just randomly showed up then we never saw her again through the episode. the person in the hoodie in 7x10 was defo a female
right. I saw today a pic of that scene in season 7 and I got that feeling something is up with her more that we think.
***** Another question what do you think: Has the half burned mask the black widow once wore a meaning or not? I'm thinking maybe A.D. has a half burned face or was that Sarah? not sure about the timeline:(
+Simina The person wearing the half burnt mask is black widow, who is Sara Harvey.
She was at the lodge dressed as red coat, she is the one that saved the girls when Shana took fire on it (apart from Hanna, Ali saved her only, she confirmed it herself), that's how her mask got burned i think x
+Simina so i think it does have meaning, i agree the timeline is jumbled up in some places too x
Bethany was 17. The cop said.
so maybe Charlotte didn't wanna hurt her sister
But Spencer has a twin called Alex??
i thought beth was 2 years older then the liars, toby's age
i dont think bethany is part of the fam , i thought the video was of ali jason and charles doe
if that was bethany and charles and not jason and charles, then you're saying that bethany was a trangender women too?
What do you mean? Charles & Bethany are fraternal twins, and Spencer is their younger sibling. The video in the dollhouse vault was Charles, Jason and a Baby Spencer. The Campbell Apple Farm will come up in one of the later Parts of this theory :)
+NickiiAnnaa I thought the baby in the video was Allison
It was never confirmed, don't get me wrong it could be, but Jessica said 'Say goodnight to your sister, give her a little kiss?' and Charles kissed her and Jason only tapped her. This is what makes me believe it could possibly be Spencer :)
Do u think Bethany knew about spencer?
And I love the video and part 1
+Layni Parker 826 thank you :) Possibly, it will come up in one of the next parts of this theory :)
I forgot how Mr.young looks like😢
i dont think we ever saw what he looks like
***** that's true I trued searching him up bug it just came out pictures of Bethany or Spencer 😲
oh hell yes I believe too that there are 3 kids
When Aria and Spencer visited the Obgyn who delivered the babies he was talking about a boy. Only a boy. and then said something like several years later he helped with another 1 of her children but couldn't remember the gender.(He helped with 2 of her children). So she could have had a third (Spencer) after the 1st two but wouldn't he have said she had twins or 2 babies together when he was talking about the boy from the c-section he handed to Jessica? I can't see how Bethany and Charles/Charlotte could be the same age or twins. Unless PLL is screwing with us again showing that clip...which is possible...
good point, but i think Bethany is more important than what we first thought, there is a reason why shes so significant, this theory is based off of if bethany and charlotte were the same age, but people believe bethany could also be a similar age to the liars, so in that case she could have been the 2nd baby born a few years later, but jessica could have paid dr cochran to keep his mouth shut about the twin baby (bethany) because jessica wanted it to stay quiet maybe?
That is true. She has been involved for too long not to be some major player in the plot. Even if only to tie stuff together. And it makes sense that Mary had 3 kids. Why would the doc say 2 OF her children is she only had 2. He would have said both or all...there is something there...
+Bianca Helberg exactly, thats what i thought was weird when he said '2 of her children' if there was just Spencer and Charlotte surely he would have said 'her 2 children', i mean, twins obviously run in the family from mary and jessica so its possible it could happen again :)
I know right! Well I hope you figure everything out before April 2017 because I can't wait THAT long!!!! Also, I am not sure if you have done anything like this but I would love to see a theory on Mona being A.D. I have seen 1 or 2 and to be honest...I am starting to get some idea that that could be accurate...I LOVE her but she is really shady! :) Her being so involved in everyone's lives, being in Radley, being so tech savvy, having being the original A, her ties to Charlotte and that last 2 scenes where she was fixing Caleb's coffee and letting Noel get away...mmmm
+Bianca Helberg i know right, me neither it seems like ages away! ive started watching the whole series from S1 again to try and figure out hints to Mary Drake and Spencer we wouldnt have realised before. I havent actually but that's a great idea! I'll start making it now, i have found a few points that leads to Mona being A.D but i wanna try and dig for more clues too! thanks for the idea! :)
Why would the c section scar prove anything?
Maybe it does, maybe it doesn't, thats why this is a theory :)
I forgot bethany even existed tbh
i didn't because they bring that bitch up like every episode like they knew her or something.ffs that plot has gone nowhere
I agree, but at least with this plot twist she will finally have some true meaning to the story, theres so much that hasnt been uncovered about her ♥
Bethany can't be the same age and the liars if she was born 1987 and spencer 1993
i am sorry but Bethany is crazy
They can't be twins.. The doctor delivered two babies.. If she had 3 children don't you think he would of pointed out they were twins.. If he delivered 2 of 3 of her babies
there's a theory that A.D. got to the doctor before Spencer and Aria and made the doctor lie to them about that
Lindsey Murda since when has pll been good on giving correct information? they literally told us Mona was not A -.-, but when that episode ended who was A?
Mona isn't A, she's working for A
The doctor said he delivered two OF her babies, he never said she only have two
Bethany is dead
what is the first song?