It makes sense now when Melissa & Peter would constantly say they were trying to protect Spencer. They never would say from who or what but would tell her to stay away from Ali's family. Makes so much sense now
So I hope you enjoy this theory! I put a lot of effort into it, i've been compiling the evidence to back it up for a couple of weeks now! I will have a part 2 coming soon! Give this a thumbs up if you want to see a Drake Family video next - including one other character almost everyone has forgotten about ;)
And for all those asking where I got the birthdays from, I used PLL Wikia, and for the dates they were conceived, I worked it out by going 9 months prior to the birth date :)
+justanotherpersonxo it could be :) perhaps one of them is intertwined in this and is also a drake, a main clue is back when mary showed the scar on her stomach from Charlotte 😉
+NickiiAnnaa So cool! i am super excited to see how you'll connect everything. just binge watched your videos. And even though some of them didn't turned out to be right it all made a lot of sense and it could be an alternative way for the writers to go. You have a great eye for detail! keep making these videos!
+justanotherpersonxo Aw thank you so much! I just love connecting everything together! I'm really excited to see what the writers do with the A.D story, thank you for your support, much love xox
now that Alison and Emily are going to basically be married with a baby emision(emily's eggs), Spencer is Alison's cousin. Now they just need to connect Aria and Hanna to the family tree.
+Nadia Holstege it seems to me that's where the writers are going with this though. Why have the storyline of Emily donating eggs, for them to be stolen by A.D.? Emily recieved messages from A about "you better talk before our baby does" or something like that. Then, Alison's admitted to a hospital where she's drugged and who knows what else, then she becomes pregnant even though to hear Alison say it "i thought we were careful"
everything is correct except i think Spencer has a twin. A.D. another drake. here's my reasons, Hanna's dream scene, & twins run in the family. also When Mary drake visited Spencer she looks at a picture of Spencer and Melissa and says "almost like twins" Spencer says "we got that a lot when we were younger" umm.. Melissa is 7 years older than Spencer. Have you ever looked at a 5 and a 12 yr old and say you two look like twins? No! i think Spencer was having memories of an actual twin? plus, why would Mary say that when she knows she's her mother. idk
There's a 7 year gap between me and my sister and people have always commented on how we looked so similar we could be twins altho usually a comment about he age gap was mentioned as well, but people could have just been commenting on the similarity of Spencer and Melissa as sisters. However I find it weird that they would make a point of saying just how similar Melissa and Spencer look when at the very most they're half sisters as far as we're aware. It doesn't seem like something they'd say just so we'd think Peter is still Spencer's biological dad it seems like a more pointed clue. Don't think I'll last til April I want more episodes now 😫lol
BUT, I think it was Wren behind spencer in the doll house. The person was taller than Spencer it looked like. But then I also wonder why would he have been in there? And yes Charles and Jason in the video, but I think the little girl was Alison not Spence
I don't think Charlotte/Cece/Charles lied. I think Spencer's real dad or Wren or Melissa (maybe not) or Detective Wilden is A.D. It could be Wilden cuz A.D. Stands for After Death. Wilden was also on the Halloween episode, on the train
The only thing I'm having trouble understanding is the family home video Spencer discovered in Charles' vault. You said that the baby is Spencer but isn't in Alison? Jessica didn't give birth to Spencer, she have birth to Jason and Alison and adopted Charles/CeCe/Charlotte. I just don't understand how it can be Spencer when Spencer was born in Radley and Jessica didn't want anything to do with her or the Hastings Family.
CDancer Ade I'm still not convinced that was necessarily Jessica in that hime video. the hair was pretty dark- like Mary's. It could've been Mary, Jason, Charles and Spencer. I'll be surprised if they ever give us a definite answer though..
There are probably 100+ unanswered questions with so many plot holes that I doubt we will get all of them answered before the series end! I hope they will have a Q&A or some sort of an episode dedicated to all the questions and how 'A' came to be! It would be really cool if we had an episode from A's perspective
Exactly! And I agree. It's ridiculous that we've had so many questions answered via twitter or interviews than the actually show but at this point I'd take whatever I can get. An episode from A's perspective would be amazing!
Right? For example, they never confirmed that Wilden killed Garrett on the show and technically , I dovn't think they ever solved his murder on the show. Also, they never confirmed what really happened to Ian after Alison pushed him off the bell tower. I mean we know he committed suicide, but we don't really know it it was at hands of 'A' or his own doing. A lot of people still think Maya is alive because Nate/Lyndon never explicitly stated on the show "I killed Maya..."! All the questions should be addressed THROUGH THE SHOW and not through Twitter; it just makes everything confusing 😳 Also, I don't understand how Jenna and Charlotte/CeCe could be friends when they hated each other in Season 4?! Wasn't CeCe the one who pushed Jenna in the lake at Emily's Birthday party and wasn't Jenna also afraid of her?! It doesn't make sense
Its so frustrating. I was upset about Jenna and Cece as well. Doesn't add up. Unless Jenna was just pretending to be afraid of Cece to cover for her.. But that doesn't make a lot of sense either. As far as Wilden, I guess we're supposed assume that he killed Garrett because he was going to expose him for being a crooked cop but clarification would be nice..
floraldream xo yes they are. they share the some mother (Mary). and possibly the same father. I do believe like this theory says that Spencer is Peter's, just because of all he's done for her. but I'm not convinced he fathered Charlotte. her dad could be literally anyone lol.
My theory is that Peter went to Radley to meet up with Jessica (who was on the board at the time), but Mary got hold of Jessica's clothes and pretended to be Jessica...I mean think about it, Radley was never really fully contained, Mona managed to sneak in and out without the bat of an eyelid so I'm sure Mary could have slept with Peter in a closet or something and got away with it. Dr Cochran found out, and that was why Mary was 'naughty again' cause she did it before with Mr Young, hence why she gave birth to Charlotte, and then Spencer.
This would explain why Jessica always had it in for Spencer. She couldn't stand Spencer because she was Marry's daughter. BTW if its true about Ezra knowing the truth then Spencer and Aria is going to hate him
yeah...i think he knows from his research, thats why he was so adament veronica and peter needed to be prepared for the secrets to come out..besides it wouldnt be the first time ezra has lied x
ben davis Well considering the fact that "Cece" (Charles/Charlotte) chose "Drake" as her fake last name, she must've known somehow that Mary Drake was her birth mother. She's quite clever to not figure it out. Jessica, however, raised Cece as her own and considers her as her mom.
so wait peter and mary slept? and they have spencer. peter and jessica had an affair? and they had jason. so wait? spencer and jason are like half siblings or step-siblings? cuz they have the same dad? but if mary is alison and jason aunt and mary is spencer real mom? what now jason and spencer are cousin instead of half siblings? i mean we know now that alison and spencer are cousin. what about jason?? someone explain to me!!
Actually it's still spencer hasting because kids get there fathers last names and Peter Hastings is still her father plus Hastings goes better with spencer
![YoungBoy Never Broke Again - Sneaking [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1ILUps2zDFU/mqdefault.jpg)
that was quick! Love that Spencer is becoming central to the main plot :)
Me too! I always wanted one of the liars to be more deeply intertwined in the messed up family tree lol :)
Yes, and Spencer just makes sense. It fits perfectly.
+NickiiAnnaa what app did you use for this video
i use movie maker for all my vids :)
It makes sense now when Melissa & Peter would constantly say they were trying to protect Spencer. They never would say from who or what but would tell her to stay away from Ali's family. Makes so much sense now
This is great. Good job. We can see how u have put time and effort into this.
So I hope you enjoy this theory! I put a lot of effort into it, i've been compiling the evidence to back it up for a couple of weeks now! I will have a part 2 coming soon!
Give this a thumbs up if you want to see a Drake Family video next - including one other character almost everyone has forgotten about ;)
And for all those asking where I got the birthdays from, I used PLL Wikia, and for the dates they were conceived, I worked it out by going 9 months prior to the birth date :)
+NickiiAnnaa
👍👍loved it!!Please do the video!
Is the character everyone has forgotten g about is Bethany young or Wren?
+justanotherpersonxo it could be :) perhaps one of them is intertwined in this and is also a drake, a main clue is back when mary showed the scar on her stomach from Charlotte 😉
+NickiiAnnaa So cool! i am super excited to see how you'll connect everything. just binge watched your videos. And even though some of them didn't turned out to be right it all made a lot of sense and it could be an alternative way for the writers to go. You have a great eye for detail! keep making these videos!
+justanotherpersonxo Aw thank you so much! I just love connecting everything together! I'm really excited to see what the writers do with the A.D story, thank you for your support, much love xox
Please put part 2 on this is really interesting
now that Alison and Emily are going to basically be married with a baby emision(emily's eggs), Spencer is Alison's cousin. Now they just need to connect Aria and Hanna to the family tree.
There was nothing confirmed about Emily's eggs?
+Nadia Holstege the eggs are just a theory.
+Boo Billis the Realest Okay :)
+Nadia Holstege it seems to me that's where the writers are going with this though. Why have the storyline of Emily donating eggs, for them to be stolen by A.D.? Emily recieved messages from A about "you better talk before our baby does" or something like that. Then, Alison's admitted to a hospital where she's drugged and who knows what else, then she becomes pregnant even though to hear Alison say it "i thought we were careful"
+Boo Billis the Realest The hospital thing makes sense, but unfortunately we have to wait until April :(
Pleasee! part 2, it's a very good theory! Nice job
sounds totally plausible, im with you on most points here! Look forward to part 2!
thank you 💖
Perfect this better be Marlene's story too 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
my cousin love the show and he liked your theory... he is looking for part 2
everything is correct except i think Spencer has a twin. A.D. another drake. here's my reasons, Hanna's dream scene, & twins run in the family. also When Mary drake visited Spencer she looks at a picture of Spencer and Melissa and says "almost like twins" Spencer says "we got that a lot when we were younger"
umm.. Melissa is 7 years older than Spencer. Have you ever looked at a 5 and a 12 yr old and say you two look like twins? No! i think Spencer was having memories of an actual twin? plus, why would Mary say that when she knows she's her mother. idk
Only fraternal twins run in the family, identical twins are random occasions, but I get that it's weird to call 5 and 12 year olds twins.
There's a 7 year gap between me and my sister and people have always commented on how we looked so similar we could be twins altho usually a comment about he age gap was mentioned as well, but people could have just been commenting on the similarity of Spencer and Melissa as sisters. However I find it weird that they would make a point of saying just how similar Melissa and Spencer look when at the very most they're half sisters as far as we're aware. It doesn't seem like something they'd say just so we'd think Peter is still Spencer's biological dad it seems like a more pointed clue. Don't think I'll last til April I want more episodes now 😫lol
The twins were Mary and Mrs.D. Doubt they would double twin something
I don't think Spenser has a twin cause the doc who delivered her confirmed there was just one child
Bran
this was really good explain alot more sense
thank you💖
Spencers birth name was always hastings because of her dad :)
this is such a smart theory, it actually makes tons of sense
I really enjoyed this 👏
This is a REALLY good theory!!!!❤️❤️ smart👍🏼
thank you💖
I cried when you played everything is lost
makes so much more sence! thankyouuu♡
It's really good I love it
yeah but if Veronica thought that Jessica was pregnant with Spencer then where the heck did Alison come from haha. i mean they ARE the same age.
because Spencer isn't Jessica's she's Mary's
I was just about to say that
I love this so much
YES I LOVED IT it all makes scene now THANK U
Nice theory.
This was fantastic!!!!!!!
BUT, I think it was Wren behind spencer in the doll house. The person was taller than Spencer it looked like. But then I also wonder why would he have been in there? And yes Charles and Jason in the video, but I think the little girl was Alison not Spence
Omg it makes a lot of sense this is a good theory
Great theory!
wow your story is actually on point.. 👌
this makes so much sense!
Hi! :3
What is the name of the song? (The first one)
It's so accurate it's kind of scary 😅
I don't think Charlotte/Cece/Charles lied. I think Spencer's real dad or Wren or Melissa (maybe not) or Detective Wilden is A.D. It could be Wilden cuz A.D. Stands for After Death. Wilden was also on the Halloween episode, on the train
sooo good!!
that explains so much!
till what episode is out of PLL
I love this
I want to watch this video so bad but I can't cause of that song when ali was judged😂😭
This is a very good theory now I feel like peter killed miss D
SPOT ON..
make part 4,5,6
thank you
The only thing I'm having trouble understanding is the family home video Spencer discovered in Charles' vault. You said that the baby is Spencer but isn't in Alison? Jessica didn't give birth to Spencer, she have birth to Jason and Alison and adopted Charles/CeCe/Charlotte. I just don't understand how it can be Spencer when Spencer was born in Radley and Jessica didn't want anything to do with her or the Hastings Family.
CDancer Ade I'm still not convinced that was necessarily Jessica in that hime video. the hair was pretty dark- like Mary's. It could've been Mary, Jason, Charles and Spencer. I'll be surprised if they ever give us a definite answer though..
There are probably 100+ unanswered questions with so many plot holes that I doubt we will get all of them answered before the series end! I hope they will have a Q&A or some sort of an episode dedicated to all the questions and how 'A' came to be! It would be really cool if we had an episode from A's perspective
Exactly! And I agree. It's ridiculous that we've had so many questions answered via twitter or interviews than the actually show but at this point I'd take whatever I can get. An episode from A's perspective would be amazing!
Right? For example, they never confirmed that Wilden killed Garrett on the show and technically , I dovn't think they ever solved his murder on the show. Also, they never confirmed what really happened to Ian after Alison pushed him off the bell tower. I mean we know he committed suicide, but we don't really know it it was at hands of 'A' or his own doing. A lot of people still think Maya is alive because Nate/Lyndon never explicitly stated on the show "I killed Maya..."! All the questions should be addressed THROUGH THE SHOW and not through Twitter; it just makes everything confusing 😳 Also, I don't understand how Jenna and Charlotte/CeCe could be friends when they hated each other in Season 4?! Wasn't CeCe the one who pushed Jenna in the lake at Emily's Birthday party and wasn't Jenna also afraid of her?! It doesn't make sense
Its so frustrating. I was upset about Jenna and Cece as well. Doesn't add up. Unless Jenna was just pretending to be afraid of Cece to cover for her.. But that doesn't make a lot of sense either. As far as Wilden, I guess we're supposed assume that he killed Garrett because he was going to expose him for being a crooked cop but clarification would be nice..
so are spencer and cece sisters?
floraldream xo yes they are. they share the some mother (Mary). and possibly the same father. I do believe like this theory says that Spencer is Peter's, just because of all he's done for her. but I'm not convinced he fathered Charlotte. her dad could be literally anyone lol.
what's song?
Wasnt Mary in Radley? How could have been able to meet up with Peter?
My theory is that Peter went to Radley to meet up with Jessica (who was on the board at the time), but Mary got hold of Jessica's clothes and pretended to be Jessica...I mean think about it, Radley was never really fully contained, Mona managed to sneak in and out without the bat of an eyelid so I'm sure Mary could have slept with Peter in a closet or something and got away with it. Dr Cochran found out, and that was why Mary was 'naughty again' cause she did it before with Mr Young, hence why she gave birth to Charlotte, and then Spencer.
She snuck out ?¿
She may have not been in Radley at the time and because she slept with Peter, Jessica sent her back or she snuck out
love it
name of songs ??
IM SHOOK
i'm shook
This would explain why Jessica always had it in for Spencer. She couldn't stand Spencer because she was Marry's daughter. BTW if its true about Ezra knowing the truth then Spencer and Aria is going to hate him
yeah...i think he knows from his research, thats why he was so adament veronica and peter needed to be prepared for the secrets to come out..besides it wouldnt be the first time ezra has lied x
***** Yeah but he has the nerve for getting mad at Aria for not telling him about the phone call and he keeps this big secret about 1 of her BFF's
wow this is good
What's the name of the song during this theory
story*
maggie eckford - everything is lost and then alan walker - fade :)
+NickiiAnnaa thxs
as long as there is no Emison I'm okay
Please what is the song
everything is lost maggie eckford
Song??!?!?
Kalans Fun Channel everything is lost Maggie Eckford x
***** Thanks
I thinks all correct but Noel was all about the dollhouse
THE LAST EPISODE IS ONLY 80 MINS CAUSE OF ADVERTS 😢
This makes a lot of sense, but I don't think Mary will get Spencer back, her mother is and always will be Veronica.
You don't get it ce-ce did not know about Mary till after she reveled her self as A she still thaught Jessica was her mom
ben davis Well considering the fact that "Cece" (Charles/Charlotte) chose "Drake" as her fake last name, she must've known somehow that Mary Drake was her birth mother. She's quite clever to not figure it out. Jessica, however, raised Cece as her own and considers her as her mom.
so wait peter and mary slept? and they have spencer. peter and jessica had an affair? and they had jason. so wait? spencer and jason are like half siblings or step-siblings? cuz they have the same dad? but if mary is alison and jason aunt and mary is spencer real mom? what now jason and spencer are cousin instead of half siblings? i mean we know now that alison and spencer are cousin. what about jason?? someone explain to me!!
they're both half siblings in terms of same father, and also cousins because their moms are sisters
This is actually what happened omg
Hang on. If she's still Peter's daughter, she wasn't ever something other than a Hastings. She's still Spencer Hastings, just not Veronica's daughter.
I saw on Insta that Byron is Spencer's real dad
Sophie Gavin ewwww Mary and Byron
"Spencer drake" ... That sounds soo strange😅
Peter never wanted Jessica after she had Jason he didn't want anything to do with her.
Song??
everything is lost- Maggie eckford
candy eclipse 32 Alan walker - fade
That was good
Is Spencer FOR SURE Peter's daughter?
I think there's a very, very good chance that she is truly Peter's daughter, Idk why else they'd have adopted her!
But how did Mary get out of Radley to have sex with Peter then go back again?
Actually it's still spencer hasting because kids get there fathers last names and Peter Hastings is still her father plus Hastings goes better with spencer
the sentences changed to fast for me
Wow that's awesome but Charlotte Lied A LOT
Well duh she is A
was*
Amy LeBrun Then again was she really A
Very true. In this show, you never know.
Amy LeBrun Lat's face there were a lot of gaps in CiCi's A reveal story
well a story of bad parents
I mellisa found out and that's why mellisa is A
who drug jenna away who is AD ahhhhhhh
This show has turned into garbage they should have just made Aria 'A' and left it like that.
what's the first song?
what is the name of the second song