I built a 1Hz Redstone Computer...
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 июн 2021
- 1Hz Minecraft Redstone Computer
Join the ORE community to learn about computational redstone like this at:
mc.openredstone.org
Litematica Schematic: drive.google.com/file/d/1KXbe...
World Download: drive.google.com/file/d/1V7E2...
Music used in this video:
• Sweden (C418 synthwave...
• C418 - Aria Math (Synt...
I do NOT own any of the music used in this video! 
Наука
First computer in real life
The size of a room
First computer in minecraft
The size of an airport
Well mine isnt the first one but you statement is still true.
Just realize that some genius guy can make a computer in a game in a computer
@@beethoven5984 and that game can be played in a virtual machine making it a computer inside a game inside a computer inside another computer
@@limmelime7491 Now u just need to play minecraft on the computer in minecraft and the loop can continue forever
*an
"I need more RAM"
"Just build more lmao"
If someone else builds it for you and sends it to you then... it's true, you can finally Download More Ram. Unfortunately, trying to practically utilize Minecraft RAM would be like plugging a power strip into itself to try to get infinite electricity
Yes the problem on Roblox my Xbox which I believe has like 1500 ram still oofs to a few dynamite blocks in build a boat
@@heheheha.grr.heheheha 1500 ram? Like 1500 bytes of ram? Lol. 1500 ram doesn't make any sense. Unless you mean your xbox has 15 gigs of ram, which would make a bit more sense.
There is a Star Trek TNG episode about this. In "The Quality of LIfe" S6E9, they had these AI based devices called ExoComps that could replicate additional command processors and increase their own memory based off interactions. Theoretically a redstone computer could do the same thing with a command block as it could replicate additional memory as needed.
You can't BUILD RAM. You gotta download it. Smh these rookies
I can’t even comprehend the amount of patience this must’ve taken to layout. Absolutely incredible work mate.
i can barely comprehend that we have humans who can do this. unreal
1 water bucket could burn a lot of time
@@DDD1234AAA1accurate to real life computers :)
I’m not impressed. It can’t run doom.
I'm pretty sure half of it is automated with programs lol. No one does that by hand
Most impressive top picks
1) "easily" programmable. You made it so you just plop some torches down. This reminds me of earlier computers in real life
2) the screen. I can't comprehend the screen, out of all the things.
3) 1hz. For Minecraft, the fact it only takes a second for a code is amazing. I would have expected more like a minute.
isn't it 1 instruction per second? or does 1hz mean something else in this context
It’s one instruction per second. Modern CPUs can do 4-5 billion per second per CORE
The screen on your device uses three numbers for every pixel. Each of the three is 8 binary digits long… this allows us to achieve values 0-255 which correspond to the brightness level of a red, green, and blue LED. Thousands of these RGB pixels allow us to create any image just from binary numbers.
The idea here is very similar. Each cell in the display can receive a red stone value. In this case, we only need one 36 (6bit) value so that each letter and digit maps to a unique value. From there, some sort of decoder is put in between the redstone value and the display so that the correct pistons will fire when the value reaches the display
“hey guys welcome back to my let’s play, I did a little bit of offscreen work”
"I've been doing a little bit of building here and there and now i have a calculator the size of a fucking city."
"But you can easily repeat it yourself if you want - thanks me leaving the blueprints in a description link"
"So what's your processor's clock speed?"
"One."
"Like, 1 GHz?"
"ONE."
not 1 Ghz. 1 Hz
@@kingfetchd9889 read it again and imagine a conversation
same
@@kingfetchd9889 yes we know brother
@@ReiLN my bad
Imagine the work he put in this video , this man is beyond genius
The work he put into the video is impressive in itself but the computer he built is off-the-scale, beyond amazing.
@@ChristmasEve777obviously that’s what he meant
*9 missed calls from Alan Turing 💀
"So what can you do for us?"
Him: "I can build 1Hz Minecraft Redstone Computer."
"You're hired."
I’m about to graduate with my bachelors in computer science and I’m barely past these fundamental concepts. Many of which are actually electives. So I’d say this demonstrates his abilities quite well.
@@cstwister yeaa seems soo
man he literally could be an architecture Engineers for CPUs, SoCs, Microprocessor etc...
@@cstwister aaa at a
Such a skillset is quite valuable
Me: still trying to make an automatic door
This guy: computer inside a game in a computer
Inside a simulation
@@dislike__button inside another universe
inside another dimension
@@detrax_1866 inside another simulation
automatic door is basic
This is a lovely build fr. It’s amazing to think about how a person can build a computer inside a computer game which clocks on a freq on 1hz and we also get to see on what gets into all of this. Fr, some real great work in here 💪✌️
Simply amazing. That's dedication. Well done Bro!
Yeah this is cool and all but just wait till you see my secret redstone door behind a painting
Old
I love you bluejay keep up the content bro!
@@hammatime94 so is your RUclips channel
I'm kidding sorry but you shouldn't reply something like that that's offensive
@@psybon1498 but how can facts be offensive?
@@corinthiansdaniels3728
Facts offend people. Welcome to human civilization!
A few years later:
"Running DOOM on Minecraft computer "
I think I know a way to have super basic 3d in minecraft. No idea how to do the commands but I imagine an armour stand shoots fishing rods or snow balls to a few 1 block tall walls and it takes the distances into account to make a 3d image on redstone lamps. Maybe this could be done without commands?
Basically a raycaster.
To run DOOM: (it would require windows to run so this isn't all)
Processor(Hz): 3.3 GHz (3.3 billion times more powerful)
Operating memory: 64 Gb (8GB) (533.3 milion times more)
Processor: 8 bytes(64 bits)
Video card: 16 Gb(2GB) (16 bilion switches)
Disk: 360 Gb (45GB) (360 bilion switches)
Monitor: 640:480 px (probably minimal)
Ray Tracing in a few more years
@@diago2805 that's too much power
dood this is so freaking cool, like it made me think how people gets inspired to build on the work of others in research but seeing what u made in game somehow ignites this hope in me that people will continue to build on this idea and create more amazing feats, truly inspiring
This is beyond amazing for me. The time and effort it must've took to make this. Amazing work!!!
It's amazing to think about the fact that computers are now at a point where we can build a functioning computer inside a game inside a computer.
The next step would be to have a functioning game ran on the computer inside a video game
@@tudhatnad1766 Yes, but that is using virtualization with the help of VirtualBox/VMWare and provides an interface that can display the screen and interact with the headless VM instance running under the hood. So not running in the game (i.e. using vanilla blocks like redstone).
@@dealloc Oh, I didn't know that, thanks :D
@@dalirkosimov4623 its been done in factorio already man,
found the link ruclips.net/video/7lVAFcDX4eM/видео.html
@@dealloc nono, you are thinking of another mod, oc is literally lua coding in mc
“Yeah bro I’m just gonna build some RAM on our survival server today”
Alright today's work is done ram is completed tomorrow I'm gonna build a motherboard
Alright i'm done building the motherboard let's do the gpu now
Alright motherboard is done, let's put it all together and make an entire server inside this server
If your PC runs out of RAM just build yourself some more in Minecraft
Can this be built in survival tho? as far as I am aware some contraptions can't be build due to weird block placing
the craziest redstone i've seen in my entire life for real! lovely work man GG
Amazing that this is so (relatively) easy to program as well as being this fast. Great Job!
Interviewer: “What are your qualifications?”
Me: “I can code a simple world program”
Interviewer: “How is that supposed to qualify you?”
Me: “In a Minecraft computer”
"I made the computer to run the Hello World code"
"In a Minecraft computer I made"
“I re invented programming inside of Minecraft”
And I created another computer in a Minecraft computer I made in Minecraft
“Congratulations, you’re hired.”
See y'all in about 5 years when someone figures out how to make this thing run Doom.
fr a calculator did it, so why wont a minecraft computer do it
brb
@@nopawse1711 we will watch your career with great interest
@@georgearabatzis8578 Because i would say at least a 20hz computer for playabality and you would need An ACTUALL display as only white 16p isnt enough...
hell yeah
This is amazing man ! Well done !
My redstone friend adding small details before finishing the house:
Him: Why is this program not working properly again?
The enderman: *LMAO*
Oh no that would be a nightmare for him to debug this
@@manzero134gd Damn 🤕
*turns off mob greifing*
@@someguy-hc8gi Modern problems require modern solutions.
Need that bit flip protection
"Infinite wonders, endless possibilities."
Seems legit.
you got a point
Endless possibilies til u decide u wanna making a working, turning biplane lmao
Exactly what i was gonna say
In five years
“I made a working turning biplane”
@@shaun5657 look at the comments again
This is awesome, excellent job!
This is incredible... I cant belive you can make a functional computer and everything it needs with just redstone
Never say that you're a hardcore programmer when you're not climbing through the interior of your computer like a termite with a CE degree when you code.
You could probably run tetris on the thing but it'd be slow
Romans 8:37-39
No, in all these things we are more than conquerors through him who loved us. For I am sure that neither death nor life, nor angels nor rulers, nor things present nor things to come, nor powers, nor height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord
@@e_s.0848 what is this church?
@@e_s.0848 I am confused by the relevance of this verse in _this_ situation.
Like, why? Honest question.
@@danielawesome36 No relevance. Just Bible.
@@e_s.0848 although i have my opinions against the bible for very serious reasons i respect ur faith
Everyone else playing minecraft: "Let's build a house and a farm"
Electrical engineers playing Minecraft: "Let's build a 1Hz computer"
Electrical engineers don't have the background to build computers.
@@attractivegd9531 You may don't, but a lot of EEs do. Depends on the classes you took.
@@billigerfusel I didn't knew that, thank you.
@@attractivegd9531 you didn't know that!
@@doowoppyify In fact it is the case!
Thank you for teaching me a simpler understanding of computers.
Sheer engineering masterpiece. The passion, the dedication and the understanding of the core principles shines right through
Some random troll at internet: "Just download more RAM lol"
Torb: *builds more ram*
Wait, can that actually work?
@@patrickfrost9405 no
lol
When you use 4gb of ram to build 15 bytes of ram:
STONKS
*downloads a swap file*
Friend: Hey can I borrow your calculator
Torb: wait let me open minecraft
lol
@Furious guy 09 XD
what if its mobile you can make computers on mobile?
@@fridge399 mini nuke
@@fridge399 yes my friend, but it will turn into a nuke to your phone
SO AMAZING, that was soo cool. If i was building this, i will send it around the world
Very cool clip ,very cool song and a very cool presentation bro you are a very cool legend
Villager after first computer is built: "What if life is just a simulation?"
Villager buddy: "Huh."
imagine someday creating a npc in minecraft with AI and becoming a very smart AI self aware he is in a simulation.
@@JulioCesar-wx2pr LOL. No doubt!
@@JulioCesar-wx2pr that's literally the concept of the movie free guy
@@GameOver-nm2us And a lot of other games and movies
@@ripinkhanna6075 games...GAMES? LIKE?
10 years from now, We’ll be playing Minecraft on a computer built in minecraft, in a computer. Great stuff.
Minecraft-ception
you can do it now
if you are going to write code to lay down the tiles
ok now think about that in a virtual machine
@@suicidehotline3733 Now think of the virtual machine
In minecraft
@@moinuddinkassmi9671 maybe all inside a raspberry
Actually impressed! Im only able to make 4 bit computers but this is next level! Great job dude
I'm impressed... because, when you write the instructions or programs to the logical processor it's actually Assembler just for that processor
Imagine if Alan Turing could see this. A computer inside a program running on a computer and the video is then sent around the planet to be watched on computers that fit in your pocket and don't need to be plugged in.
Yeah but imagine if Behtovan could listen to Darude - Sandstorm tho
@@KrossFire330 he would appreciate it maybe
@@KrossFire330LOLOLO
@@KrossFire330I would give him sheet music for Megalovania and probably cause Germany to win WW2 butterfly effect.
@@KrossFire330 you would need to give him hearing aids to listen to it (before he went completely deaf) then after you need to invent a cure for deafness
The fact that he has this much computer knowledge mixed with thus much Redstone knowledge is absolutely insane
Technically the same knowledge
@@wwiizzaarrdd808 how it is the same, sorry im dumb when it comes to computers and redstone, but im kinda curious about their similarities
@@bogomilblagoikov6407 redstone represents an electrical signal, you can make logic gates as well in minecraft. real life computers operate on the same basis
@@bogomilblagoikov6407 pretty much the exact same thing actually. Computers at their cores also just use on and off switches the way redstone does. The forst thing you'd learn in a digital systems class is logic gates. Logic gates are things that take 2 inputs (either on or off) and spit out an output accordingly. Classic examples are the and gate (both inputs need to be on to have an on output) and the or gate (at least one input on means an on output). These gates can all be built out of redstone pretty easily. And all computation in a computer are done by a series of logic gates. If you slap logic gates together in a smart way, you can have a logic gate circuit that can do addition. And with a bunch more complexity, you get this in the video. Essentially a redstone computer is pretty much the same exact thing as a real 8 bit computer. The redstone repeaters even simulate the delay in digital circuits.
If you know how to make an 8 bit computer in real life, you're 99 percent of the way there to building one in redstone. You still need to know some of the game mechanics, but in principle they're the same exact thing.
@@ronan8881 I'm no Minecraft player, but I think it can also do quantum entanglement, where a bit state can be taken to the other side ot the world without using wires and causing a time delay.
I cant imagine how long this took to make, this looks awesome!
Pure genius
You made a great work
I mean, the fact that you managed to build a computer in minecraft is just amazing and it always blows my mind when I see people who did it. What's more amazing, however, is that you actually managed to build one with a 1Hz clock speed. I don't think I've ever seen a minecraft PC that fast. Absolutely amazing.
EVERY redstone contraption functions at 20 Hz as that is 20 CYCLES PER SECOND!
protoborg you are comparing 2 very different things, a 20hz simple redstone clock is not the same as a whole computer running at 1 hz, the tasks it accomplishes are complex, and doing it this fast is a true challenge
@@protoborg Someone already said this, but I'll elaborate. 1Hz here doesn't mean one redstone tick - it means one clock cycle by the CPU's clock and a corresponding one instruction executed by the CPU. Even simple instructions such as integer arithmetic (not even floating point) or committing a data value to RAM takes a few in-game ticks in an ideal situation. Unfortunately, the computer also has to decode the instructions into actual actions it will take, there's the time it takes for piston extension and thus for data output on the screen, and probably a few more details that I can't think of off of the top of my head.
Put simply, one clock cycle in a CPU has to do a lot more than can be fit into a single redstone tick.
@@protoborg actually its 10hz since 1 redstone tick = 2 ticks
1Hz means it makes cycle a second. Because thats what Hertz is. That means it takes 1 second for the CPU to run a instruction cycle. Remarkably fast, for minecraft.
This guy's worst fear: A bucket of water.
Why do you think electronics hate it?
@@clarkstone439, in minecraft water destroying redstone, comparators, retranslaters and a lot else staff what using in this computer
@@Eremitis and in real life, it provides electronical short circuits that ALSO damage and destroys key parts.
@@clarkstone439 this isn't the biggest problem. The biggest problem with corrosion of metal contacts and bga or smd chips
@@clarkstone439 In a way, it's worse in Minecraft because it completely erases everything you've placed. In real life, you can see where each component goes and replace it, in Minecraft all that would be left is the skeleton of a colossal computer, with no indication of where each piece belongs.
I love the way your mind works.
This is absolutely amazing!
This is absolutely insane. How much knowledge and time and work was put into this. This is something the developers have to see
a lot. First person i saw to do this was a hardware engineer student and did it as part of his disertation IIRC as the functioning model and to demonstate he was so good he could make a computer within the limited realm of a game. no idea what this guy's story is.
@@oceanbytez847 yo but did he get a good grade on his dissertation?
@@megaultra5005 LMAO HAHAHAHA
@@oceanbytez847 not that much it's not that hard it takes time and if you going to program it instead of laying down things manually it's even faster
making logic gates it's not much these things we study a back in college (COmputer Science) 3'rd semester after you finish your Computer Architecture and OS 1 & 2 classes
later on, we make way more advanced Compilers and interpreted in Elective classes you can take
*cooy rights for music
The fact that it calculated the Fibonacci sequence so perfectly and quickly just made my jaw drop to the floor. Pure genius, amazing work dude.
Hoping Prof. Gnembon sees this video. He'll love it, I'm sure.
hes like gnembon 2.0
amazing bro .. no words to discribe so many smartness bro.
Inspiring work!
nobody:
me trying to build a Redstone door but not succeeding.
Torb: I built a 1Hz Minecraft Redstone Computer
"when you try your best buy you dont succeed"
i think that when i will understand how to make a kinda complex redstone door in minecraft, this guy will make a computer in minecraft as powerful as a computer from this days
@@frabbo03 he's .02% there
everyone starts somewhere
Thats what I like about redstone. It can be applicable across all levels of skill.
And just like real older computers, a bit of water ruins all the circuitry.
Upgrade to bedrock edition and your pc will be water resistant
Minecraft water is not comparable to rl water
@@als0689 "upgrade"
@@fisherfresh6708 dude he meant that water will destroy redstone and pc will be out of order
@@ghostfrostkoshar2288 dude it's you spoilin the fun
This video made me smile, it’s so amazing
Congratulations to you, absolute genius!!! 👏
He literally developed the whole "chipset" himself. You can't even imagine how much work this is.
the madman
Computer in minecraft was already incented...
@@barmaley8033 not one like this, although it may seen like it's just another one, but this one is way ahead
@@barmaley8033 They aren't the same, this one is highly modular and programmable
@@zimboiii9025 Not really: there have already been programmable computers, modular computers, ones that operate faster than 1Hz, multi-core ones
Since the smallest you can go is one block, in-game computers will always be at least somewhat big. But as more blocks get added, mechanics change, and features arise, the computers will gradually get smaller and smaller. Truly, this game is beautiful
There is a mod that turns redstone components a block's pixel big. Maybe that could work. Tiny Redstone mod. Looking at the description does sound promising. Maybe combining it with Create mod with sorters and other things can improve this.
@@aaron-gz image if he build whole pc on mc it would be dope
@@aaron-gz I feel like create mod would be used more for quantum computing
@@aaron-gz the borders between two blocks that hold mini redstone blocks are buggy at best so it's not really an option
Finally someone said it
Absolutely Phenomenal Bro.
That's just simply amazing. Congrats for this achievement uwu
I could not Imagine trying to troubleshoot this if it didn't work. Everything is so compact and clean it's actually incredible
That's why modular testing is so important. I created a very basic CPU in a circuit simulator and had to dig down through a bunch of components to find one that was producing a wrong output. If I had done tests to make sure every input produced the proper output, it wouldn't have been a problem.
Developers : Lets make a game in a computer and call it "minecraft"
Gamers : Lets make a computer in a game called minecraft
let's make a game called "minecraft" on a computer created in a game called "minecraft" created on a computer...
We've gone full circle in a game composed of blocks
Me: let’s make a Minecraft in a computer called game
@@thehoptohell4 most underrated comment ever
This means that Minecraft is turning full
Wow, incredible work
Bro how is this even possible bro...soo cool bro nice work😊
Imagine removing just one block from this and he has to debug where it's missing.
Jesus that's Evil
he would probably figure it out pretty easily tbh... he built the damn thing from scratch.
Cocoon like ring of impenatration needed
@@_.-._.-._.-._.-._.-._.-._.-._ have you ever code?
@@asadrahman6123 when you forget a ;
"So guys, I did a bit of redstone off-camera"
Jokes aside, this is truly epic. Good work
Edit: Thanks for 2.5K likes!
@don't read my pfp 🅥︎ ok
@@madboii5678 😂😂
@Dartixon did he?
@Dartixon show me where he downloaded it first and i’ll believe you
epic music dude! :)
when i took my first architecture class, it dawned on me that you could theoretically replicate almost everything in a basic CPU in minecraft.... i'm so glad i looked this up because this is just awesome!
Stuff like this makes you appreciate the real life inventions. Like how do we go from smashing sticks together, to making a computer within a computer game? It's insane
In minecraft in particular, it stuck out to me. It's not just that technology has progressed, but rather we have advanced technology to the point of re-inventing old technology using current technology as a simulation. Like we as people went from cavemen, to scientists, then cavemen in minecraft, then scientists in minecraft. Can't wait to make a computer in real life, to run minecraft so I can build a computer in there, and then play a game on that computer, and so on.
@@10Gpixels Let me amplify your senstation.
Meditate with me. How would you fare if you get stripped from your clothes and banished to the wilderness, lets say a savannah (our first natural habitat). All while KEEPING the knowledge you got in your head (languages, arethmetics, what you learned from nat geo documentaries about survival etc)
Would you be able to survive, let alone thrive? ⚠️
You quickly realize something... you cant even qualify as a "stick banger".
You would gladly offer yourself as a slave to a passing group of "stick bangers" so you survive.
Keep in mind all animals even heavily domesticated ones will do alright in the wild.
What are you? You dont even qualify as an animal! ⚠️
@@bozomori2287 I'm one of the lucky ones with years of boyscout and survival experience, and a decent amount of historic knowledge that'd make everything much easier. Assuming I'd be stripped of that knowledge aswell, then I might be in trouble, but humans very much are animals built for survival too. We have capable hands for crafting and holding, and the brains to make a pointy stick, so we wouldn't need claws or fangs. I do see what you mean though, as most humans today (including myself) will never know how it feels to be one of the first humans.
@@10Gpixels 👍👍👍
@@bozomori2287 That is a stupid question because humans don't naturally live alone. We live in groups. Saying an individual person would have a low chance of survival is like saying an ant separated from it's colony would have a low chance of survival. It's true, but it doesn't mean much.
If nothing else, this is a great representation of how impossibly complicated microchips are.
I would love to see the scale of a modern microchip blown up to the minecraft dimensions! Even though Minecraft would never able to handle it turned on
If anything I believe it shows how simple it really is, being broken down and shows it on a macro scale
Una vez que llevas estudiando y trabajando un largo tiempo la electrónica digital/analógica, se te vuelve muy fácil, rápido y es tu pensamiento de cada día (creas sistemas impresionantes en tu mente, como si fuesen simples sumas...).
Siendo diseñador de sistemas electrónicos digitales digo que no es tan complicado (los analógicos son laboriosos), pero si confirmo que quienes no han llevado ese conocimiento seria algo muy complicado debido a muchos factores de síntesis de circuitos... Ya lo demás es fabricación, pero eso es otra cosa.
@@r4v3nyt32 That's assuming either of us actually understand how it works. Do you?
@@marcdumont2275 Ofcourse
As you can see the circuitry within the vid it says it all really.
Based on input the transistors open and close access to specific circuits to relay a current.
I seriously have no clue how the hell you absolute madlads do this type of stuff, but it is seriously impressive!
thought of making this about 6 years ago and then stopped when i realised how big of a project it would be and to see someone who actually finished it is mindblowing
i thought of this build as a little kid too but i knew it would be really complicated so i just waited to see if anyone would build it and someone actually did
Never give up. Never surrender.
What would be the point of making this in Minecraft help me understand
@@jonathancasey5063 there is no point bro it's just insane
@@jonathancasey5063 your comment implies that, the guy didn't build it becuase he wanted to. That you can only do something if there is a point to it.
But if you argue like this, then really anything and everything becomes pointless so, at which point you might aswell off yourself.
It doesn't matter who it is. If you like something, then you like it. It's that simple. And if you want to do something because of that, then you shall by all means do it.
This guy most likely liked computers and were good at understanding how they worked and maybe also liked minecraft a tad...
Which leads us to conclude, that he made what he liked :) and such things need not be explained.
You on the other hand are a real asshole for calling someone else's will pointless. You are also an asshole for making it sound like you are all innocent with that "help me".
You are not fooling anyone, the others might just not be able to put it into words, but people like you truely ruin the fun and exitement out of everybody else.
maybe this is what drove you to write that comment.
You know when your build is good when you need a programming degree to understand what is happening.
Its impressive, but if you put up google, you can learn everything about it in 2-3 weeks. You could even build one by that knowledge, it just takes a lot of time to build and concentration.
@@parthmanadam2485 sure buddy, you learn all that in 2-3 weeks.
@@benfrese3573 Sure you could. It's just logic gates, memory circuits and some display logic.
@@benfrese3573 I did learn that in the past, when I was in university. I started a project like this, then I realized its pointless to do something like this bc of the dozens of hours you need to put in it. You learn assembly 4 times whilst you do this.
@@rdococ edit: so a lot of you are telling me how it's taught in college and stuff and I want to say IM WELL AWARE, IM DOING IT CURRENTLY TOO. Perhaps it's my country with its low standards of living, education and social issues because I sure as hell haven't met ANYONE here who was allowed to be bought Minecraft because their parents (asian) consider it a waste of time they could spend on studying.
I haven't met a single person who liked technology and said they made processors in their teens for the hell of it.
Maybe it's a bias where only the gifted ones will reply to me because they do not see the difficulty in the subject due to their passion in it. The ones who aren't gifted wouldn't reply.
Before you read original message,
Just imagine a single technologically illiterate person in life. Maybe your grandparents, parents, uncle's or aunts. Try teaching them ALL of this in 3-4 weeks. That's the general level of students in my country. Because our exams focused on memorising physics chemistry and maths for an entrance exam into a goddamn computer science degree. They haven't touched a computer until they passed highschool. Where making people downloading anything that isn't a simple executable installer is an arduous exercise of playing tech support.
This is what is 'normal' around me. This message was originally a full on anecdote from my experience. Where I sometimes had to teach the professors what they were doing wrong.
Original message:
it's not just logic gates you sweet summer child. It's far more complex than that.
Wait till you hit sr latches, which is the point where most people lose their ability to comprehend the subject.
There's a lot of states, a lot. They probably even had to hard code the Minecraft program into the computer memory. That's a lot of assembly.
The monsters that come after sr latches are registers, and those things... When I was learning them in college, I could barely understand everything going on at the speed they were going at.
That thing will require years of computer experience to program, code and debug something like that. Years that even I don't have when I am currently studying btech.
The reason every single programmer is impressed by this is because making a computer like that, is an insane task. You need to have knowledge all the way from hardware to software. Hardware alone is a skillset which is really difficult, you will take atleast a year understanding the ins and outs of that part. Software... Assembly was mind boggling enough to teach me how much easier the traditional languages are for coding... They didn't use assembly, they just... Hardwired the coding like bios...
I don't think I can tell you just how impressive that I'd and how few coders can do that (from the younger generation)
Note : to all the people, the concepts you need for this is in theory of computation for making assemblers and the higher order thinking required. Basic electrical and electronics, to understand the basics of logic gates and how they are formed. Digital Logic and design for all of the circuitry, computer architecture and organisation for understanding the von Neumann architecture and how we will utilise it for interfacing processor with memory. This is not including ones software skills. One would need to know how to code in assembly, the common practices, experience with debugging, the debugging process itself depends on how much practice you have.
Yeah, teach this in 2-3 weeks. People seem to really forget, that they once to were a clueless boy/girl that took information from multiple sources for years before they managed to develop the mindset of an engineer.
Good job, you're a genuis!
this is mind blowing, awesome
The most impressive thing about this is that eventually the end result of this kind of work is Doom playing inside of minecraft.
Oh no, some poor soul is going to spend like 3 years doing that
@@thebigbonk thats what i thought, too xD
@@thebigbonk they can use an editor to craft it outside of minecraft at work several months
No, eventually there could be a high-end make of Minecraft capable of containing a simple, but legitimate, make of Minecraft. And from there, nothing says more layers are impossible.
@@nameforcomments4092 a simulation inside a simulation inside another simulation?
This is truly incredible. As a computer science guy from the 90s this is the coolest thing I have seen on the internet. Well done sir.
Really Nice Redstone
It's awe-inspiring how well you know electronics to be able to build circuits in a simulation game.
I feel like anyone who can build an 8Hz processing computer in minecraft of all places should be give an automatic pass for at least a college level intro to computer science.
I think that getting it would be easier than building an 8hz pc in minecraft if you are already on IT profile in high school
Yes XD
@@claytonkristiansen47 Junior year stuff? You guys designed an 8 bit computer in the 1st year by using cables and couple simplistic already made gates? Cmon
@@TaidaDave It would be one million times easier to go in a intro level college class.
I just completed a digital systems class where we had to create a cpu and that was really hard stuff with all the fancy bells and whistles the college had to offer. That being said, this must have taken a lot of brain power and dedication to figure out and pull off. Amazing job! :)
@@janos1945 sure thing! The book I used for my class was called: Designing Digital Systems With SystemVerilog (v2.0) by Brent E. Nelson. The book starts with binary, works through logic gates, and ends with some circuitry and machine coding. I also think it was pretty cheap too so that's a bonus haha!
@@janos1945 Yep! Also I think earlier you asked what program we used to make the cpu. Sorry, It took me awhile to find the name. It was called logisim evolution. For writing anything is system verilog we used a program called vivado. But that was to program a micro controller that I can't remember the name of.
I feel like a CPU would have been less complicated than this... RAM and ROM systems (especially within something as restrictive as minecraft) at speed is really quite the challenge. Obviously the ALU in this is no match to complexity of a specific CPU, but still i think as a whole this is still a very very very complicated contraption.
@@fregyt yep that's what I was saying lol. It was hard for me using proper equipment. I can't imagine how difficult it would be to make in minecraft
So you didn’t use any Tech, props to you!
This guy can bring a revolutionary change in world of computers
i watched this when i was freshman in university. I watch it again now I have my electrical engineering degree, this is still beyond me how insane this is i could've probably convinced my program to let me use minecraft computer as my capstone :o
"Lol Minecraft is for ki-"
Torb: "hold my torch"
Lol
underrated comment
@@thenutbucket1799 not really honestly kinda cringe
@@Anthony-lz8ju I mean its not about wether its cringe its about the humor behind it
@@thenutbucket1799 whether*
oops sorry my adhd alarm just went off my bad
This is historical. Quite literally. Build a computer within a computer within a game with simple materials.
This has been done before boss
Ever seen The Game Of Life inside The Game Of Life?
@@UCCYQaunfn4d4H-kIkEq0DsQ someone's been watching Veritasium ;)
Seriously tho it is so cool and mind bending
Well this video in specific is not historical. There has been bettter computers built before this in Minecraft
Build a computer within a game within a computer*
Your computer is great!
Woah well done.
me: My pc can't even run minecraft with some fancy mods
Torb: Here, I made one.
why do people use this format of comment for the most random unfunny things
@@theomann1534 to make them funny 😄
This is amazing. :) The fact that someone can make a computer in Minecraft. Human ingenuity ceases to amaze me. I don't even play this game, but I love computer technology.
@@StorytellerAo To make you look funny
@PC Gamer 650 people have liked this comment already, so this much of people laughed at it.
"It's actually quite simple"
-Mumbo
This is awesome!
The work that this took is amazing
It's amazing how much Minecraft computers have shrunk over the years.
suuuuure
@@tirzahsmith4624 ?
Engineer gaming
@@tirzahsmith4624 Go look up minecraft computers from 2013-2014 genz idiot
It’s insane to me how someone made Minecraft in Minecraft a couple weeks ago
Impressive.
It shows us how old computers, even though they look simple compared with today's standards, were complicated.
Computers still work basically the same, very little of the basics have changed except for scale
@@SandTurtle Oh, that makes sense.
@@gbilo24 yeah, redstone is equivalent to wire, and the many redstone parts can act like electrical components
@@SandTurtle I know quite much about redstone,
Some of the first computers were actually fairly complicated when it came to operation. We eventually got a terminal then once there was enough processing power to spare GUIs became popular and simplified the experience for the end user. Doesn't mean there aren't complicated GUIs though because some definitely are.
Now let's do this on survival. Nah all jokes aside, this is quite amazing. Well done!
This is the biggest build, which i saw in Minecraft. AWESOME!!!!!!!
This is INSANE. Just the fact that people with this skill exist makes me happy.
Ikr it's good to see that these things are still being built
Romans 8:37-39
No, in all these things we are more than conquerors through him who loved us. For I am sure that neither death nor life, nor angels nor rulers, nor things present nor things to come, nor powers, nor height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord
This is something beyod skill.
@@e_s.0848 Amen! I'm Roman Catholic
@@layz6243 Nice
@@e_s.0848 Good to know 😉
"I wasn't hacked.
That's right, I'm a human who willingly posts Bible verses.
Why? Someone may need it.
Have a nice day, God loves you and Jesus does too."
notch: "I wanted to make a game where you can build a dirt house and chop down a tree."
Fans: this video
Fans in 2022: "we have built a computer in Minecraft. You can run a game where you can build a dirt house and chop down a tree on this computer."
@@vladilak36 here we go again
@@tacoeater16 does bmw i8 have manual transmission?)
@@vladilak36 no
@@vladilak36 fans in 2042: " the simulation computer has successfully solved all of our real world issues, war, hunger, hate, money....
This is absolutely incredible
It looks so incredibly complex. And it shows how much more complex an actual computer that can run modern operating systems is.
I cannot express how much respect I have for redstone engineers. People that can build that will be incredibly valuable in our (real life) future because of how they, their brain works and because of their incredible dedication to a project
I agree, some of the redstone contraptions ive seen are incredible.
This is a basic ALU, You learn to build this during first semester as a computer engineer student, it isn't as difficult as it may seem
Yes! It's not just a waste of time. Who knows how much these players have learned by making these redstone machines. Theory leads to practice.
but you know that this is nothing (and I mean it) compared to today computers. People like this alredy exist. They're just called engieneers.
@@algot34 the creator of this machine probably studies computer engieneering