Wife Opens Up About Accepting Husband's Desire To Transition: No, It's Not Over | Megyn Kelly TODAY
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 июн 2018
- Cindy and Lucy, a couple from the TLC series “Lost in Transition,” join Megyn Kelly TODAY to share about their personal journey since Lucy, who previously identified as Troy, revealed her desire to become a woman. "When you love somebody you want them to be happy, too,” Cindy told Megyn.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: on.msnbc.com/SubscribeTomsnbc
About: MSNBC is the premier destination for in-depth analysis of daily headlines, insightful political commentary and informed perspectives. Reaching more than 95 million households worldwide, MSNBC offers a full schedule of live news coverage, political opinions and award-winning documentary programming -- 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: on.msnbc.com/Readmsnbc
Subscribe to MSNBC Newsletter: MSNBC.com/NewslettersRUclips
Find MSNBC on Facebook: on.msnbc.com/Likemsnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: on.msnbc.com/Followmsnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: on.msnbc.com/Instamsnbc
Wife Opens Up About Accepting Husband's Desire To Transition: No, It's Not Over | Megyn Kelly TODAY
While my heart goes out to everyone involved, I'm not sure I would be able to stay with my husband if he revealed this to me. I wouldnt stop loving him or wanting to be in his life, but I don't think I would be okay being "married" anymore. I'm a straight woman and I thought I was marrying a MAN. This is incredibly unfair to expect these women to be okay in a now "lesbian" type relationship. I'm not saying it's wrong, but I'm saying that these women shouldn't be looked down upon for divorcing.
I agree 100%...
Did anyone else notice that he kept reaching over for his wife's hand but she wouldn't hold hands with him. I don't think she is as OK with this life change as she portrays.
Cathy Zuehlke no shes not open to it, you can find several other videos on their progression as a couple..and it gets downright ugly..
She is not for it.
I really think Cindy is afraid to start a new chapter of her life alone so she's trying to stay in the marriage. Despite all the laughter and discussions about learning to accept Lucy etc, it's painfully obvious she's not happy.
Cathy Zuehlke
I think she doesn't want him to think that she's down with moving on with their marriage...
Cathy Zuehlke he lived a lie for years I imagine Cindy's angry
SweetAzzPie W They are not married
HUNNY you gave him an ultimatum because YOUR'E NOT A LESBIAN! And here again is another case of selfishness. He said he knew since he was 3 yet he'll drag a poor lady into his mess.
I don't think he ever thought he'd come out, it seems like he intended to hide it forever but he just couldn't anymore.
Exactly! Lead her on for all those years and expect her to be ok with it.
@@ljovanovich4737 no one said she had to be okay with it but also no one said she had to be a b**** when she decided to stay with Lucy and punish Lucy emotionally for not being what she wanted.
@@bekahface4484 umm your comment means nothing to me. I wasn't talking to you
@@ljovanovich4737 it meant enough for you to reply but okay...for sure
If you know you're transgender you should not involve people in your life unless you're up front and tell them the truth first it is not fair to bring other people into your life without them knowing the truth first
FACTS if u KNEW all this time that something was wrong with u then why involve someone else in it? so if he had aids would he had just given to her? i mean take any word and fill in the blank... these mofos lied period. also these women arent the prettiest women in society so they would have been none the wiser when they got that attention bc it would have been all they wanted
amanda powell would u want 2 b told if u were going 2 marry a transgender or would you want it to be hid from u
Nathaniel Bayley i was in a relationship with an undercover homosexual for 5 yrs. I would have liked to have known before i had fell in love with a man who was using me as a cover. These people didn't tell bc they wanted to be accepted. Im not a person speaking with no experience.. ive lived this
@2manynegativewaves 😂
I didn't even know until I was 14. I didn't even know what transgender was for my whole childhood. So how am I supposed to know?
You can’t ignore the amount of selfishness that comes with dragging a woman into a lifetime of lying to her. And no, saying it wasn’t accepted and fear of judgment is not an excuse to exact this kind of cruelty on someone else.
Kara InSD he's not lying he's just sick in his head
I can't imagine ... She needs to leave him
100% agree... I cannot feel sympathy when he lead this woman into a lie. I would be very upset and heartbroken, and yes, angry!
Kara InSD his intention was not to hurt her. He always treated her well. Its not something you can discuss easily with anyone. He loves her so much that she was the only person he opened up to. He is attracted to her so its not a sexual thing. He woild like to maintain his manhood because they have a good intimate relationship. It's really complicated.
FACTS they cannot say there wasnt some premeditation in this at all. ALso i feel that if trans was not in, then none of them would come on this show...or ever have come out
The wife has every right to feel this way he lied for years
Most humans aren't authentic or truly vulnerable in life. Most love is conditional and not unconditional.
*She* She lies to her
Seriously. She shouldn’t be mad just because it’s politically correct to “accept” transgenders???
Yes , she had a right to be angry but she has to understand that he was lying to himself for years .
I do wish there was some way that could be given to trans people to help them style themselves better . Like the Lucy said, he made a mistake with that choice of dress . Maybe a transformation programme could do a show on this and show the hair , makeup and clothes that work for them .
Maybe on a local level some female makeup and wardrobe professionals, who or could, run classes to include men who are transitioning .
She will leave "Lucy" when he is female 24/7. There is no way she will be able to live like that, not if she prefers men.
@L F Have you noticed that none of the Drs he goes to suggested he should seek therapy for the real under lying problem. They just start with the hormones and surgery.
I agree. It is a betrayal.
If you view love as gendered based attraction then you’re really downplaying the power of such an emotion
@@trumpwon2081 www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/05/180524112351.htm Maybe there is a biological problem and as has been shown that when the body is brought into alignment with how the brain thinks, then most of the psychological problems brought forth because of social psychological abuse go away.
I probably knew early that I was, nearly was killed by my brother as a child, suppressed my feelings as to who I am, did a good job until I had an emotional breakdown because I worked 12 hour days trying to be something I am not and came to the realization as to who I am.
Maybe one should not be so quick to judge... while I empathize with those negatively effected by the fact many people who had no idea what was going them became involved in relationships, had families and yep probably caused issues for their partners - many had no idea as society was not accepting, and obviously still are not based on comments here.
I hope to stay as I am, but as I have all my life not knowing why, I have stared at women not sexually but admiring how they look their clothes and .... This past weekend was looking at womens clothing store, while waiting for my wife in the car, and a woman caught me looking at her for probably too long... and while I was just admiring what I will never be, I am sure that most women would feel very uncomfortable having a man stare at them.....
Heck recently I had a physical and had all of my hormones tested and while my testosterone levels were in line with a typical males, my estrogen levels were that or higher than the typical women's. Sorry, but what we were taught about the sexes in biology is not 100% right and gee to the bible thumper, gee maybe not everything that was written and translated by men (and women) is true to gods word. Gods word is to love thy neighbor and gosh there is an awful lot of hate and disgust.
@@sashasunatta8925 don't get involved with women then.
The best thing Cindy said was "it's not about you". She is right. This man entered into a commitment with her based on lies and is now selfishly putting his own needs ahead of his wife's, and he just expects her to be on board with it. If he wanted to transition he should have done it and not pulled her into a fraudulent marriage. Once he made commitment to her, at that point he gave up his right to put his own needs first.
Another Caitlyn Jenner story!! 🤦🏽♀️
THIS HAPPENED TO ME 45 YEARS AGO. I FELT THEN AND I FELT NOW IT WAS WRONG FOR HIM TO WASTE MY TIME. SHE HAS A RIGHT TO FEEL HOW SHE FEELS. SHE SHOULD NOT HAVE TO BE SO COMPLIANT. WE ARE WHO WE ARE.CINDY IS DELUDING HERSELF. SHE IS NOT A LESBIAN. CINDY SHOULD WALK AWAY AND FIND WHAT SHE WANTS-A MAN. WHY SHOULD SHE HAVE TO CHANGE?
This is....sad...
this is a classic autogynephile.
Was she angry? She’s still angry.
Raquel Pazos I would be’
And so she should be - he has been lying to her all these years and i bet she still doesnt even know the half of it...
This guy had no business getting married.
AnniesDaughter1 they aren’t married.
this woman *
motivatedmadison GUY*
ImaginaryEvil yes they are for 10 years
This couple especially upset me because the husband (now wife I guess) married her and basically tricked her into thinking he loved her for all these years and then drops this devastating bomb, but only to act like she’s the selfish one and acting wrong about it. If anyone in this situation is the most mentally damaged, it’s the wife. He gets to come out and live his life now as a woman, but she has to deal with the loss of her husband and the loss of trust. She spent these years loving him and thinking he loved her, which turns out to be all a lie. So unfair and so cruel. I understand that it wasn’t his intention to hurt her but in the end he did and its understandable but not forgivable
Glad the wife's situation is taken more into account. It used to be all about the one who was transitioning.
I'm fully on her side. What he's done is wrong! She is not attracted to women and there is NOTHING WRONG WITH BEING STRAIGHT! She has every right to leave. I believe the relationship is already over.
You can't love someone, and LIE TO THEM!!!! THAT ISN'T LOVE!💔
@@stardustgirl2904 No, but you can learn to forgive and replace hatred,blame and anger with understanding, empathy and compassion.Don't forget they BOTH suffered a betrayal during their marriage.Troy betrayed himself by denying Lucie a life.He also suffered .Maybe if you realize his suffering,you can forgive him for his lie to Cindy and feel some compassion.Its not like he is a bad person.He was a deeply shamed person who couldn't come out due to shame.Its entirely forgivable.Thats why Cindy does eventually forgive him.
@@blissfulbaboon This is just pure SELFISHNESS, AND LOVE HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH HIS SELFISHNESS! He wasted her life, with taking her VALUABLE Time SHE CAN'T GET BACK ! I would HATE KNOWING I LIVED A LIE !!! I love life, and it should not be spent with lies!
She married him based on his lies ~ pretty sick start up ~
@@janhomes50 I agree, but in part two of this, she seems to be excepting of it ,and that's really Sick, she has wasted time she can't get back in her life, SO SAD PEOPLE ARE THIS SELFISH!!!!!!This is why we have so many problems it society!!! DISHONESTY IS EVERYWHERE! SADLY!😂
He lied to her and she trusted him. He has shattered what she knew to be the truth. He seems to have no sympathy for what he has put his wife through...
When did he explicitly lie to her
He has lied to himself his entire life. Those lies will affect those around him. It's not his intent; he spent 42 years really not wanting to be trans. That will cause depression and all sorts of behavioural problems and it will hurt him and all those around him until he stops pretending and start living.
*She* She
They need to be true to themselves and separate. He needs to live his truth as Lucy. She needs to be with a man who's happy with his manhood. They're staying together is hurting both of them.
I agree with you 100%.
BTW, I Love your name. I have a Grand Daughter named Zerinity. God Bless You! 💕
Your right, but something inside me wants them to work it out, as they do love each other
I am trans and if my bf come to me saying he is transgender I would be devastated! And probably lose all the interest. It’s a HORRIBLE situation for both.
it's ridiculous, she won't be a lesbian, so when he is a girl, then what. And if being a girl makes him happy, let him leave and be a gitl.
We all have to make sacrifices when we transition.
I am glad that Lucy's wife has come to terms with it more. It's a long journey and I hope they can work things out together. I wish them all the best.
Why can't a person like this gentleman - just stay as he is? He has love - she accepts him emotionally and spiritually as a woman. He looks ridiculous in drag - he is BIOLOGICALLY MALE.. Why do the dresses and makeup matter ?
I love these two, didn't at first, but I do. They have a beautiful love for eachother and it shows 100%
Noooo you gave in to a selfish, narcissistic man. Cindy, you are stronger than that and deserve better!!!!!
Steph P - You nailed it, Troy is a total narcissist! He is also controlling, egotistical and self-serving with a huge sense of entitlement - all qualities most associated with the MALE and not the female psyche. Go figure! Run for your life Cindy, this toxic man has made it clear his desires come far above yours - he will only make you miserable if you stay. Life is too short to be a narcissist's doormat!
Steph P - I now think it was all staged, predetermined, as more MSM propoganda-. Think about it, would this story have, otherwise, gotten the kind of notoriety as it did, if I were anything BUT this outcome? More BS, moral of the story, we can all be molded to change, if we are continually conditioned, amd if we just get used to it and accept it all....6:25 Cindy: (laughing) I was ANGRY! Hahaha, bit it's all OK, now!
Ha! Ha! And your comment, Krypton, says that you are a male - and exactly what kind! Thanks for the laugh!
Krypton - Sorry to hear you're so boring, blinkered and conventional you assume I'm a single, heterosexual woman.
Preach!
He’s a lucky man to have this woman in his life let me tell you...I’d be gone
Why do the men always think it's about the clothes. Most day in just in pants and plain top yet of course I'm female and still feel that dressed in pants. Be confident with your spirit no matter what clothes you have on.
Megyn kelly is the new jerry springer
Zane Perkins This is real life
I am glad the men came out that they are women now the men can be happy life is short be who you want to be If a person loves you they will stay with you know matter what .If they don’t stay then they don’t really love you It’s hard but you will get through it Jesus loves you
tina kletter how can you say that? The wife wants to be with MAN and is not sexually attracted to a woman.
Haha she really is .. just more sophisticated about it lol. .. or so it seems
Holly Kurmis cry me a river
If she’s straight then she should just leave Lucy and move on
Butter the 'dude' is used to wear the pants and dominate him, he never dared to tell her about his true feelings
It isn't really that simple, they have been married for a long time. She may leave in time but anyone going through this definitely needs that time to process the situation.
At that age, I would probs just stay as a dude
WIG BIG right
But it’s not good to hold things in
It comes down to living the rest of her life as an ugly woman or dying a man full of regrets. No winner here.
Ryan x that sounds like an illness he needs therapy
That's gonna be a old ugly woman.stay a man it's way too late
This is very sad situation, but it's nobodys fault. We live in a society where being transgender is not an easy thing to be and it's been even harder in the past. Lucy needs to transition and be her true self (life is too short), but I don't blame her partner for saying that she doesn't want to be with her if she transitions from male to female, because she's straight. All the best for them and hope they can be friends in the future!
Nikki Fresquez We ARE overpopulated lol
Nah we can never be over populated.
It’s a shame these people in today’s society can’t get the help they need. This is a mental disorder.
Nikki Fresquez that’s funny tell an other one
Nikki Fresquez uhm yes we could lmao
Beautiful story, it shows people can grow and finally come to terms with happiness, and first reaction ignorance can be dealt with and it's possible to learn and become more educated, so I commend both Lucy and her partner for voicing their journey and luckily being able to have it together that shows love is more dynamic than being a surface thing!
I don't get why so many people don't like Meghan Kelly, she seems great to me.
I agree 💯🙃
My cheek muscles hurt from cringing so hard. How messed up. That man is so immoral and needs a reality check
Well these days there are so many girly MEN!!!!! HOW CAN A STRAIGHT PERSON DATE THESE DAY'S! GLAD I'M MARRIED TO A REAL MAN!
He never should have pursed a relationship with her or any woman.
He can't date men. He is straight.
You say that as if he was crystal clear about everything, the whole time. He didn't lie to Cindy, in my opinion, he was confused and not sure about what. Not completely. Doesn't mean he has no love for her. People date one another all the time and one wants marriage, the other isn't sure. They don't stop dating! I know some like that personally. They just talk along the way and if they go separate ways...so be it. Happens often. Don't be so simple minded. The best minds are always open and complex!
Julie Sprik its a fetish called autogynephilia
So Megyn Kelly went from interviewing Putin to hosting her version of The Jerry Springer Show? How sad.
Beautiful story thanks for taking us on your journey.
I think he (now Lucy) was being totally unfair to think that he could start up a relationship with a standard heterosexual woman and lie to them by omission like that. Such a major fact is something any potential partner should be told right at the outset of a potential relationship and then it's their choice as to whether to have a relationship with that person or no and what level of relationship to have with them if so. As a standard heterosexual woman myself - if I got together with a man and he then subsequently told me he felt he was really a woman - his feet wouldnt touch the ground as he had to head straight out the door pronto before I threw something at him. The reason I would be furious with him and would never see him again in any way (even just for friendship) wouldnt be because he was that way - but because he'd lied to me and conned me into a sexual relationship with him and not given me the chance to say "Sorry - if you believe you are a woman - then you will only ever be a friend to me". I would be totally sickened to have been conned into a sexual relationship with someone that I believed was a man - but who regarded themselves as a woman and hadnt had the decency to be honest with me about it in advance of anything sexual.
its just such a horrible and disrespectful thing to do to a woman, you know you have this secret you're keeping and you still take over a decade of her life not telling her who shes really married to. mans got ZERO respect for her and its really sad to watch
The person, the soul doesn't change... they're still the same person. I love that!!!
Leni, yes but you have to know your own soul first. The other's you don't
I watched this when it came out and really appreciated the depth and the scope of the material. What an emotional journey for all parties involved and to Lucy’s spouse, Cindy, I couldn’t be more proud of you for your emotional maturity and your openness to realize that love is love. I’m rooting for the two of you all the way!
No, this wife has been groomed into accepting, validating, affirming and normalising this guy's autogynephilia, via encouragement from gender specialist, family 'counsellors', whose sole aim is to breakdown family 'resistance'.
Ive been watching this series. I think all the men were so wrong getting into these relationships and marriages all based on a lie. What do they expect as a reaction? They act like it not that big a deal, which is such a selfish and unrealistic view to take. One couple was married for 23 years, but they are divorcing.With this one Troy and Cindy when he dressed up as Lucy he looked absolutely ridiculous. I would be out of the relationship in a heartbeat. Why should Cindy have to change her whole life just to suit him? Thats what shes doing. Love him or not her life will totally change, and having watched this each week ,Cindy may say shes going to stay now, but i doubt that will last. She comes across as someone who really knows her mind, and i just dont see her being able to keep her word and stay.
Sue Post well said!
It seems like they just feel too sorry for their spouse to leave them.
Yes, she is not going to be able to last with this facade.
I remembered when I was 3 or 4 at school I always wanna play with dogs instead of boys or girls. Now I know What I really am😖😖😖😖😖😖
Even though she doesn’t like the fact he want to transition I respect that she is willing to try to make it work because it’s not easy to leave someone you love hopefully they get through this seems like strong couple
Honestly he should have stayed single
Please you got to be Kidding me ? He knows since he was 3 years old 😂
At this age, you cannot act your way.
He should have told her at the beginning. To choose her life for herself.
I feel bad for both of them omg....it was definitely wrong he entered into a marriage without telling her, but it's also wrong that society made him feel he couldn't be himself (aka herself) and targets trans people. He deserves to be Lucy in all of her glory, and his wife deserves to say, you know what "love you and respect you Lucy but i'm not a lesbian and i can't do this as a marriage. I hope we can find a way to be friends."
I had no idea that Nicolas Cage was transgender.
Is that supposed to be funny? taken in wrong context.
JessyBeezy Blu stfu dummy 😂😂😂😂😂😂 omfg that was great 😂😂😂
Wasted 13yrs of this women life he didnt leave because she is the breadwinner from what i can see from the other videos
He needs some therapy and counseling...not surgery.
Yes
YES!
Well of course
Well you have to do that before surgery.
@@deniserothwell6325 Nailed it.
I say if you "HAVE ALWAYS KNOWN N FELT LIKE THIS FROM A YOUNG AGE" THEN YOU SHOULD HAVE NEVER STARTED A RELATIONSHIP WITH HER ESPECIALLY W/THE RELATIONSHIP SHE JUST ESCAPED FROM!!!!! I'm sorry but you were completely wrong because to her and other people's perspectives you basically lied and led her on from the moment y'all meet!! Now w/that said you have all the right in this deviled run world to be what you want! Let me say as a woman who whole heartily "BELIEVES IN GOD OUR FATHER AND JESUS CHRIST OUR LORD AND SAVIOR!!!" DO YOU BELIEVE IN GOD AND JESUS? If you do how are you not in turmoil w/your relationship and belief in the ALFA N THE OMEGA! One more thing I don't want you believing because I believe whole heartily in our FATHER N MAKER means I hate you or anyone else like you and "IT IS NOT MY PLACE TO JUDGE" NOR WOULD I EVER BE MEAN TO ANYONE IN THIS WORLD THAT IS STRUGGLING AND TRYING TO FIND OUT WHO THEY ARE! I'M NOT RACIST, HOMOPHOBIC AND TRY NOW W/MY WHOLE SPIRIT AND HEART TO LOVE AND HELP EVERY PERSON ON THIS EARTH. I AM "FAR!!!" FROM PERFECT AND HAVE SINNED GREATLY IN MY 41 YEARS OF LIFE N I TRY N "THANK!" THE FATHER EVERY DAY OF MY LIFE. I HAVE NOT ALWAYS BEEN A PERFECT CHILD, MOTHER, WIFE OR FRIEND IN MY LIFE. I AM A DRUG ADDICTED N ALWAYS WILL BE N I'VE BEEN GOING TO THE METHADONE CLINIC FOR YEARS TO KEEP MY ADDICTION IN CHECK. I have Lied, manipulated and have done horrible things in my life and I will never be perfect n I'm telling you this so you don't think I think I'm better than you or anyone on this planet. Please pray to God and Jesus weather you believe in him or not he will always be there for you. With love
When you love someone you tell them the truth!!!
I have heard of people accepting when their partner says they're trans and things working out well after all of the shock wears off. I would have left Lucy though because of how she reacted to her wife reacting. If someone told me to "just get over it" after 13 years of lies, I would have left. That's abusive. 13 years of lies is not easy to get over and getting mad at your S/O having a normal reaction is unacceptable. I would have left.
Well done to the wife for keeping the boundaries under what must have been an onslaught of gaslighting and betrayals - but this is still a very toxic situation for both of them.
His autogynephilia and resentment will never go away and unless he voluntarily accepts and learns more about his condition they will both pay a high price in the long-term.
Its natural for a truly loving partner to want to protect their spouse and i think that is what the wife is trying to do - i hope he doesn't turn around in ten years time and throw it in her face. she's lucky - many wives in her situation who unwittingly find themselves married to autogynephilic men have been attacked, insulted, ostracised, vilified and excluded from their own marriage for less and that's the truth.
Love this couple. I understand I would be in emotional utter shock if I was in her shoes.
Their love is conditional. When in unconditional love, you foster the best self in another even if it doesn't include you. Both are co-dependant and the relationship is comfortable so they stay. The world only needs humans who are their best authentic selves.
Interesting.
Unconditional love is unhealthy.
@@aubreynaarcher8916 unhealthy can't even exist in unconditional love. If something is unhealthy, toxic, or lower vibe - it is conditional love.
@@namehere4954 No, you have to respect someone elses sexual orientation and not shame them for it, especially as they were not the liar who knew from childhood that your gender and orientation were something else than you said they were. Some people do not have a hard orientation, but the majority of people do and noone should be emotionally manipulated to be in a physically intimate relationship that they cannot help but find unsatisfying or even distasteful and traumatic and certainly they should not be criticised or demeaned by others for it.
He says he can't change who he is, but he is asking her to make a TOTAL about face on who she is. Sounds like because he has been lying/denying himself all this time, he feels he is entitled, and she should just hop on board. She's already been through an abusive relationship with her first husband, and now this? Life is way too short.
She's staying for that reality show check...
H.S. Henry she's been an aerospace engineer for over 30yrs tho lol
H.S. Henry Secure the bag sis
She really doesn't seem like the type..she seems like she doesn't want to be there at all, whether there are TV cameras or not..
They broke up after she saw him as a women
She is an aerospace engineer. She was doing fine before that mental case came into her life
Ur responsibility is to be a husband and father. Forget about how you feel and man up. Don't transition or ur life will fall apart
Awe bless this couple!
You can accept it but that doesn't mean you have to stay , Cindy he should've been honest from the beginning with you.
Those are just labels you can connected with your femininity without putting on girl clothes or mutilating your body. Which is why they are often still depressed after the “transition” because they are who they are
JC , Oh wise one you have all the answers, you don't ! Look in a mirror the check yourself out.
The wife needs to sign up for tinder if she wants to be with a man.
If you love a spirit, you love them regardless of the form.
So both of them needs to say
“I love you enough to let you be happy.”
I feel desperately sorry for them both. If society wasn't so filled with bigotry and prejudice, as a lot of these horrible comments clearly illustrate, these sad situations would be totally avoided.
He is a liar-deceiver with low- self esteem. He knew at a young age that he wanted to be a girl. He should have told her at the beginning and she could have decided for herself. Its so many things wrong with this story. I hope she finds a man that is sure he is a man.
Kelly ask the wife a stupid question similar to this, "Well if he really wants to turn into a female why would that bother you?
I agree the person never changes they stay the same. I’m glad they are staying together. This is proof of a perfect soulmate couple
You really think all soulmates end up together happily ever after?
@@revekat2053 Not always but they can
@@revekat2053 true soulmates do
Good interview. I've watched lost in transition & it's a good show. I hope season 2 comes out. In regards to this interview I kinda feel equally sorry for both of them. It is a tough situation either way you roll the dice. Poor Lucy/Troy has suffered with gender dysphoria since childhood. People tend to forget it's both a medical & psychological condition that makes life hard. Lots of trans people don't want to accept themselves either because it's so painful & a lot to face. I totally agree it's not fair & wrong to get married or enter a relationship with a huge secret/lie. You should at least come out & tell someone you're really falling in love with any of your secrets before committing long term. See how they'll react & be honest. Poor Cindy thought this was her dream man. But I give both of them credit for working together on this. They show that love is love. Think about the good times & what brought you together. The persons heart, soul, & personality all stay the same but their physical appearance just changes. Learning & accommodating each other's wishes are the best ways to cope. It's their new normal & I hope both can adapt to this new chapter in their relationship. Best of luck & I hope to hear/see an update soon.
From the early times in my learning about this, I felt for both people in the situation. When I saw documentaries on a girl child wanting to, or knowing, they were a boy or vice versa, I had no doubt the child should be allowed to do what they needed to do.... the opposite gender toys, clothes, etc. This is real. The child becomes so happy and loses anxiety and depression and becomes accepted, at least in the families I've seen on programs.
Glad they are working it out!
I watched part of the documentary on You Tube. Troy talked about meeting Cindy in absolutely male-attracted-to-female terms. He was attracted to her like a man is to a woman. And when he first tried on being a woman, he didn’t like it. I think he harbored this “desire to be a girl” in his imagination that he built it up in his mind but the reality of looking that way was shocking to him. And society and the documentary are now part of the pressure on him. He came out and said he realized he was being selfish. I think he finally told Cindy because they were so close he felt like he could open up to her. It’s good they are getting therapy, I also think for whatever reason, he does feel comfortable as a man, too. I think Cindy loving him enough to stay and take it one day at a time is a good thing, if that’s what she wants.
I’m glad Cindy accepts Troy ❤️💗
Troy is a great guy and he deserves to be happy
Good luck to you both. This is such a difficult situation to be in & hopefully you can both live fulfilled lives but I don’t think you can do that together.
That Caitlin Jenner started all this mess
I love them together and I hope it works out for them.
How?
Elaine Rojas-Peralta I totally agree. They truly love each other.
No. She wants a man.
cemetary mama how with a guy who has mental issues
Me too. I think what Troy is going to realize is that transitioning will not fix his problems. Hopefully he learns this sooner than later and his wife is still around.
Oh God, these two again! I can’t even listen to it again!
Why do transphobic people even watch a show called "Lost in Transition"?? Idk. But this is a sad story. Lucy shouldn't have hidden her true self from her wife all these years, if she wasn't ready to tell her before marriage, she should've waited until she was or found someone else, because obviously Cindy does not want to marry a woman, and that's fine. Now their in such a tough position. I hope they both find a way to live their happiest life.
He* his* they're*
wow edgy
The only way Cindy can find happiness is if she leaves the man who lied and deceived her for 13 years, she deserves better than to be locked in another abusive relationship with another controlling man
@@piratesfan123 I agree Cindy should leave the *woman* who hid her true self from her for so long, as she made it clear she does not want to be in a relationship with another *woman*, and it is true that Lucy should not have lied to her and put her in such a hard situation. I don't disagree with any of that. I was simply saying I hope, now that the truth is finally out, they can both find a way to live a happy, fulfilled life.
@@traaaashmouse How do you know Lucy is his true self? It may take Troy spending time as a woman to realize that he isn't one.
I'm glad that she has enough self respect to take a stance.
First I have to say,, so Glad to see the Classy Real Lady,, Megyn,, As usual did this show with class,, Also I am glad that it is now working for this couple. Neither are young,, and everybody needs someone. None of us are perfect. But it is what it is,, if they can both live with this Partnership,, God Bless Them Both,,, Still Missing Megyn,, 2019,, hope she doing well.
Stop calling him a woman. Troy/Lucy will ALWAYS be a man, no matter how he "presents". He is male, adult human = MAN, also a man who thinks he is a woman = there is something seriously wrong with this person. I am out, you sold me a lie so you "breached the contract".
What I find worrisome is not that this man wants to be a woman but that for reasons unknown we as a society are now being pushed into accepting this as heroic and wonderful. His wife said she only began to accept his transitioning after she went to therapy...but why did she need therapy?...And what did this therapy entail...constraining her to accept her husband of eleven years as female with the assumption she was the one needing psychological help ! By contrast, "Lucy" is lauded as a hero(ine) ..the audience nodding and clapping as Kelly smirks and grovels. Somebody needs to speak the truth...this man will never ever even remotely resemble a woman, only a ridiculous and tragic parody at best. I doubt this will end well.
Cindy will hate him/her if she continues to pretend she can love her/him as a woman.
Meghan doesn’t seem like a good person
How do u focus on Meghan in this top button topic? I mean, does she bother u that? More than lucys pick of dress?
Why you think that lol,,???
If aliens were watching, America would be great on their T.V. 😂
Megyn tried to act all conservative by bashing black people on Fox News, but now wants to act like she’s a fan of these situations that most liberals support.
She didn't "bash black people." You have no idea what you're even saying, which is absurd.
WHY SHOULD WE CARE?
I swear it this were 5 years ago I would think this is from "the onion"
Now Cindy is a proud lesbian woman! This guy is an extreme narcissist who never became self aware. He said he saw the way girls dressed when he was 3 and he always wanted to do that. He thinks that dresses, makeup and a desire will make someone a girl. He seems like he rarely thinks past the superficial layer. He said that working out takes you to the pinnacle of manhood. Also she literally explained him as being soft, sweet and meek as long as she met him. He's not in touch with reality, not sorry
@Tewdy Quew absolutely, spot on. Lots of gays are the same. (Not all of course)
YES! ITS NOT OVER! I LOVE IT.
I feel sorry for both Troy (Lucy) and Cindy. Troy had to bury all these feelings of wanting to be a woman for years, he was in denial for years and even got married to ignore his feelings. His feelings became too strong to keep secret eventually. And Cindy, imagine marrying a man and being in a relationship for 10+ years just for your husband to come out as trans. That would be heartbreaking news. I understand Cindy's pain and anger but, the way she treated/ reacted with Troy was not good at all. She should've respected his decision and tried to be supportive as possible. I wonder how they're doing now. Hopefully they are both doing okay.
Yay they caring about 'each other' now with time and therapy. A special couple
This woman is crazy as bad as him staying with this thing that lied to her all their life together sorry I would have said Bye Bye
This is not about one side or the other - it is about BOTH. Their are factors to BOTH sides of the equation that need to be factored into the equation. “When you love someone, you want them to be happy.” I like the fact that she did not to sugarcoat a thing.
Call it's so painful to have to watch his wife play along with this masquerade and call him her.
Wow this is really amazing to see people overcome social norms and work through all the intricacies that life brings. All the best to them and thank you for sharing their story.
I miss normalcy! WTF?!🙃
I do feel he/she should have told her in the very beginning, it wasn't fair to live with her all these years as a man, knowing deep down u want to be a woman.
I love how she talks about her husband and saying " him being a woman " and such. I think obviously they have been to a dr or councilor. Thats good. More understanding more hope, less stressed about it.
Good for this guy. I can’t imagine harbouring a secret of such magnitude.. you are the only one who can free yourself ❤️
THEY HAVEN'T SEEMED TO ASK WHAT HE EXPECTS OF H E R IN THEIR RELATIONSHIP. Does he want to live together as roomies, or "girlfriends", i.e. stay together? So is she supposed to live single, no dating, no husband? He will certainly want to date eventually, but how about HER? HE WANTS HIS CAKE AND EAT IT TOO. WILL HE BRING HIS DATES HOME FOR SLEEPOVERs? I DON'T SEE HOW THEY CAN PRESERVE A "MARRIAGE" LIKE THAT. IT IS TOO UNFAIR TO HER. THEY SHOULD DIVORCE AMICABLY, REMAIN FRIENDS, BUT GO THEIR SEPARATE WAYS -- CUT THE CORD. Maybe if she sees him through the Transition, holds his hand, then they could physically separate and she can have a new life too.
the video start shows him thinking: Yes dear, I'll do what YOU want