That comment is taken out of context. Ryan had earlier asked the class if we knew how to care for black pines and everyone responded that they did. Having taken several workshops with Ryan as well as spending a week with him at his garden I feel I know him well enough to say he is a very humble person. Another trend in the bonsai community is to develop opinions of profession teachers without having spent any time actually working with them.
Hello please tell me professional advice. which brand of tools for bonsai. can be given preference. Japanese brand which produces high quality tool. Thank you
Are you familiar with pines? In spring the buds swell and new shoots come out of them. They look a bit strange as immature new growth as first. These are called candles. Only later their needles fold more outward and it starts to look properly.
JWP, (I have very long extended necks from the pollen cones this year with no needles below new needles, often 1 inch bare necks) when the sheaths drop, where should I cut the new growth to promote back budding? This is the 1st year in more than 10 years I have not pinched the candles and got such tall bare necks due to the pollen cones.
so, i'm trying to get a great big old white pine to budback, so i as i understand it, I wait for the candles to harden off, after the sheath is shed i then cut it back, how far/much of the candle should i cut back?
Outdoors. Almost every bonsai trees needs to be outside. They are only brought inside to admire for a brief period of time, or during the winter if they are a tropical plant. Otherwise they should be left outside
Great teacher. This dude knows what time it is and his trees do the talking. Some of the comments on here are surprisingly negative. I would love to see the trees owned by the folks that say this dudes" a bad teacher "or "annoying." Guarenteed you fools have sticks in pots and if ya paid money for it then it's a Guarenteed malsai.
Can soneone please sunmarise the decandle and fertiliser process according to season as to when to do or not. Ryan is confusing with all the question and pause and answe etc...
Ok. Very informative. BUT since I'm not familiar with terminology so much, i have a question. What are they referring to as CANDLES? Are those maybe new shoots, or is it something else?
Well, here he was still a bit fresh out of that japanese nursery/school/torture place where he learned/studied bla bla. So ok, if i could i would go there too and watch what masters do... anyway he got a bit.. well like you said arrogant, or it just looks that way. Still very good advices and lessons. Very valuable. For me at least. And thanks for that. Will try some of those on my Douglas Fir.
Vicki Kielar he's a teacher he's teaching his class there are many other bonsai video's that cover this topic pretty well or you can go to one of the many bonsai school I did it for 10 month's and it's honestly worth the money.
I know that by asking your audience questions keeps them engaged and thinking for themselves, but this guy is just too much. "What can I get you sir?"..."what am I here for?"..." Err a drink?" ..."right a drink, but what kind of drink?"..."err a hot one?"..."right a hot one, but what kind?"..."coffee?"..."right, but what kind of coffee?"..."yes but what 3 ingredients?"..."err coffee, milk and sugar?"..."right, but what order?"..."JUST TAKE YOUR DAM COFFEE!!!!!"
"C'mon...I thought we knew black pines..." If we did (whether we are in the room, or in our computer chair) we wouldn't be listening to you. This is the most arrogant way of giving a "crash course" I've seen lately, and it saddens me how often this happens in the bonsai community.
Having studied with a North American master trained by Japanese in the oldest school traditional style, I can tell you that Ryan's approach is somewhat influenced by that tradition of "no talk, watch, you only progress when you demonstrate you have understood what you have observed." Given that experience, Ryan is trying to be extremely generous by encouraging the viewer to demonstrate their understanding before proceeding. The traditional Japanese training approach consists largely of silence, gesture, some scowling and grunts. You learn what you observe. Only once the body knowledge of the kata is internalized does the verbalized and written teaching begin. It's FUCKING frustrating to anyone wholly unfamiliar with it and coming from a Prussian-style educational system, it drove me up the wall for a good long time. In retrospect, it is better in terms of developing fluid intelligence and real-time problem solving skills, but it was mighty unpleasant for the first while.
This guy is really knowledgeable but it is so annoying when he waits for answers from a crowd that obviously doesn’t have them. Worst kind of teacher. Just answer your own rhetorical question and move on.
This was a lecture to a knowledgeable audience, not for novices. They have grown the pines you see in a video and they are capable of caring for them. They DO know the answers. They came to this lecture to refine their knowledge, not to be taught basic info. If you know nothing about bonsai, educate yourself first, learn basics, and only THEN attempt more advanced material which Ryan is teaching.
@@bigfunky4976 mirai live is the best thing about bonsai on the internet. far better than any book, also better than some bonsai braindead masters that do things without knowing why. explain why you think is awful, without rfering to this 15 min long video taken out of context
![Pine Tree Growth Rate Comparison; White Pine, White Spruce, Red Pine [Screen your Property Fast]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Bshr5k-n00I/mqdefault.jpg)
That comment is taken out of context. Ryan had earlier asked the class if we knew how to care for black pines and everyone responded that they did. Having taken several workshops with Ryan as well as spending a week with him at his garden I feel I know him well enough to say he is a very humble person. Another trend in the bonsai community is to develop opinions of profession teachers without having spent any time actually working with them.
The knowledge Ryan has about trees and perfecting Bonsai is astounding, love watching his videos!!!!
He is making people think , these people already know the basics.
Great lecture thanks
Helpful video, thanks for sharing.
Thanks for sharing.
Great Vid and keep them coming.
Thanks
Hello please tell me professional advice. which brand of tools for bonsai. can be given preference. Japanese brand which produces high quality tool. Thank you
I've got a small black pine I want to chop. It's January here in North alabama. Is it early or to late to do that?
I could not catch what Ryan said at the very end regarding hardening off with white pines.
Ryan is awesome. Candles are the individual buds, I believe.
I like the tips about white pine.
Are you familiar with pines? In spring the buds swell and new shoots come out of them. They look a bit strange as immature new growth as first. These are called candles. Only later their needles fold more outward and it starts to look properly.
Do these rules apply to Sherwood compact mugo pines?
JWP, (I have very long extended necks from the pollen cones this year with no needles below new needles, often 1 inch bare necks) when the sheaths drop, where should I cut the new growth to promote back budding? This is the 1st year in more than 10 years I have not pinched the candles and got such tall bare necks due to the pollen cones.
Check out Eastern Leaf on decandling JBP - he has a short video that is excellent.
are Black Pines imported from Japan inspected for Pine Wood Nematode?
Great info.thanks.
Very informative vid - thanks.
now THIS is how a video should be. !!
very good info
so, i'm trying to get a great big old white pine to budback, so i as i understand it, I wait for the candles to harden off, after the sheath is shed i then cut it back, how far/much of the candle should i cut back?
This guy is an asshole
Wow Wonderful Bonsai ^^
Thank you for good sharing~
Like 563
My friend, have a good day
아주조은분재임니다
I have a Japanese Black Pine do I need to keep it indoor or outdoor?
Outdoors. Almost every bonsai trees needs to be outside. They are only brought inside to admire for a brief period of time, or during the winter if they are a tropical plant. Otherwise they should be left outside
+Aarin Packard I live in canada and its a bout get real cold real quick do you recommend me not getting any kind of bonsai tree?
Great teacher. This dude knows what time it is and his trees do the talking. Some of the comments on here are surprisingly negative. I would love to see the trees owned by the folks that say this dudes" a bad teacher "or "annoying." Guarenteed you fools have sticks in pots and if ya paid money for it then it's a Guarenteed malsai.
Can soneone please sunmarise the decandle and fertiliser process according to season as to when to do or not. Ryan is confusing with all the question and pause and answe etc...
almost all the way was my impression. leaving only a few sets of needles.
cây ngon qyuá
oss
Ok. Very informative. BUT since I'm not familiar with terminology so much, i have a question. What are they referring to as CANDLES? Are those maybe new shoots, or is it something else?
New shoots they kind of look like candles I think they look more like worms.
Well, here he was still a bit fresh out of that japanese nursery/school/torture place where he learned/studied bla bla. So ok, if i could i would go there too and watch what masters do... anyway he got a bit.. well like you said arrogant, or it just looks that way.
Still very good advices and lessons. Very valuable. For me at least. And thanks for that.
Will try some of those on my Douglas Fir.
i would say confident. its a matter of view.
I hate teachers asking too damn questions bc if knew the answer I wouldn’t be on the damn class.
I hate stundents who just talk shit and have no idea
I would have liked to see actual pruning and much less questioning of others. Give the lecture and then a ask if there are questions.
Vicki Kielar he's a teacher he's teaching his class there are many other bonsai video's that cover this topic pretty well or you can go to one of the many bonsai school I did it for 10 month's and it's honestly worth the money.
I agree
I know that by asking your audience questions keeps them engaged and thinking for themselves, but this guy is just too much. "What can I get you sir?"..."what am I here for?"..." Err a drink?" ..."right a drink, but what kind of drink?"..."err a hot one?"..."right a hot one, but what kind?"..."coffee?"..."right, but what kind of coffee?"..."yes but what 3 ingredients?"..."err coffee, milk and sugar?"..."right, but what order?"..."JUST TAKE YOUR DAM COFFEE!!!!!"
"C'mon...I thought we knew black pines..."
If we did (whether we are in the room, or in our computer chair) we wouldn't be listening to you. This is the most arrogant way of giving a "crash course" I've seen lately, and it saddens me how often this happens in the bonsai community.
Having studied with a North American master trained by Japanese in the oldest school traditional style, I can tell you that Ryan's approach is somewhat influenced by that tradition of "no talk, watch, you only progress when you demonstrate you have understood what you have observed." Given that experience, Ryan is trying to be extremely generous by encouraging the viewer to demonstrate their understanding before proceeding. The traditional Japanese training approach consists largely of silence, gesture, some scowling and grunts. You learn what you observe. Only once the body knowledge of the kata is internalized does the verbalized and written teaching begin. It's FUCKING frustrating to anyone wholly unfamiliar with it and coming from a Prussian-style educational system, it drove me up the wall for a good long time. In retrospect, it is better in terms of developing fluid intelligence and real-time problem solving skills, but it was mighty unpleasant for the first while.
This guy is always on a power trip.......he’s not the genius he thinks he is....it isn’t school, just tell the audience, don’t badger them.
This guy is really knowledgeable but it is so annoying when he waits for answers from a crowd that obviously doesn’t have them. Worst kind of teacher. Just answer your own rhetorical question and move on.
This was a lecture to a knowledgeable audience, not for novices. They have grown the pines you see in a video and they are capable of caring for them. They DO know the answers. They came to this lecture to refine their knowledge, not to be taught basic info. If you know nothing about bonsai, educate yourself first, learn basics, and only THEN attempt more advanced material which Ryan is teaching.
Anna Y Nope. His teaching style is awful. Still holds true a year later.
@@bigfunky4976 mirai live is the best thing about bonsai on the internet. far better than any book, also better than some bonsai braindead masters that do things without knowing why. explain why you think is awful, without rfering to this 15 min long video taken out of context
@@alessandromassimo5717 no