The problem with waiting to fire Cashman until the off-season is this... They are right. This team likely won't make the playoffs. This team should almost certainly be sellers this deadline. They don't have any money to spend and even if they did, this team is not a quick fix away from contenting. So if they need to get rid of the GM and if they need to sell and start another retooling, then you can't have Cashman be the one in charge at this deadline while he is trying to save his job. He needs to go now and his replacement should be the one picking and choosing what pieces to keep, who to trade off, and what they are getting in return.
agreed. Let the new guy get in there and start working. If you suck now who cares if you suck more. It's WS or bust. If they aren't going to make make series then start the repairs.
Stop protecting Boone Michael! Please stop it! You sound utterly ridiculous right now saying that Boone is not responsible. Boone is the manager, he's the one that decides whether they should bunt or not, he's the one that decides whether he should come out the dugout or not, he's the one that decides whether he should complain about a call or not, what are you talking about Michael? Cashman is the general manager, he does not sit in the field and call plays. You're talking to a fan base that for the most part is entrenched in baseball for decades at a time. How can you even say that Boone shouldn't be responsible? He defends Sanchez not Brian. If it's up to me, if I was one of the owners of the New York Yankees, I will get rid of Boone first, see where that goes and then Brian will be out right after him. If it's the front office with their old stuck ways about doing things, which they are, and everybody knows how they are, nothing but an old bunch of cronies still stuck in the old ways of doing things. Then maybe it's time to restructure the whole damn staff excluding the owners. The players are pawns they're told what to do and what not to do it's like that in every sport except individual sports like golf and tennis. Stanton, and 11 game streak? And he's been hurt ever since he's come to the Yankees for over 2 years now and counting! Really! That's forward progress huh? They got rid of Pavano because he just decided not to play, and they ate the contract, so what's the difference right now with Stanton, he hasn't done anything since coming to the Yankees and that's a fact, and nothing but a bare essential fact! They have the money and they could eat that contract and send them off to where theye ever want to go. Who cares if they miraculously get better on another team? That's a bunch of nonsense, which you guys always come up with when it comes to Sanchez! Oh he might get better on another team. Who cares if they get better on another team, he's not doing anything for you right now. That's two players that need to get out of their pronto. Stop defending Judge because he's the face of the organization! There you guys go again always hitting the money huh.
Dont get excited b/c they beat up on the lowly Twins... going to Buffalo will be disastrous Cashman provides the personnel Boone makes the lineups. The K/BB/HR philosophy sucks... you could see it slowly crumpling the past few seasons Its on Cashman and the rich buffoons in the office
Mike is right. I love the Yankees but there isn’t any progress within them. Who do you blame? They are supposed to be The Yankees, and they’re losing to teams that they shouldn’t be. Something has to change.
The last dynasty had good left handed hitters and two great switch hitters . Tino Martinez Knoblach Paul Oniell Scott Brocious and Ricky Ledee we’re lefties Bernie and Jorge Posada were clutch switch hitters in 2003 Hideki Matsui came from Japan and was a great clutch left handed hitter
Boone is also responsible. A modern manager isn’t responsible for a lot, but in my opinion, if Boone can not teach, help or manage his players to run the bases correctly, then he isn’t capable of contributing anything to this team’s success.
The Rangers lost a game to the capitals and subsequently fired the entire front office. The Yanks need to pull George move and send a few guys packing.
The problem with DJ LeMahieu is the ball itself. MLB changed it this season and it's had a deleterious effect on players like LeMahieu with mid-range power. And not just him either, other players like him - Jeff McNeil, Eddie Rosario, Eric Hosmer, Anthony Rendon - all were players of similar high-contact, 20 HR power that are watching their flyballs fall short of the wall this season.
The worst GM in ALL sports is cashman. When you have blank checks to a tune of 200 million yearly and you win 1 world series is not acceptable!!!!!! End of the 90s dynasty was stick micheals.
This is my opinion on all of this. And in another forum, I had someone take issue with it, but if you think carefully about what I'm about to say, you'll see it similarly if not the same as I do. It starts at the top. Hal is a really nice guy, articulate and not a mercurial buffoon like his Dad could frequently be. BUT, you have to blame some of this on him. His father valued winning, the Yankees brand, and championships above all else. He paid (actually he frequently overpaid) top dollar but expected results and held people accountable. He sets the budget, he seems far more concerned about that than winning. This team is not well put together and that's on Cashman, period. The players are not motivated, not prepared, and seem to be going through the motions. The base running is so poor it looks like a T Ball team. That's on Boone. What existed 15, 25, 30, 40 years ago under George is still true today. Other than a fire sale before July 31, you can't fire 25 players. Barring a 15 game winning streak, this team may not get a sniff anywhere near the playoffs and if they do, they won't last long. What we all anticipated after 2017 hasn't even come close to paying off dividends. We took passes on several players when they were available; who wouldn't want Harper in say left field and his left handed bat coming up 4 or 5 times a game at Yankee Stadium? The patience with Sanchez is beyond reasonable and although he's been better, he isn't exactly making us forget Thurman or even Jorge either at or behind the plate. Moving Torres to short is this team's equivalent of how Joba Chamberlain was handled. If you aren't careful, you'll ruin that kid; he belongs at second base, period. You waited so long on Andujar he no longer has any real value in a trade. Anybody miss Mariano yet? Enough said. Stanton? I'm at least grateful he's on the field (for the most part). I'm waiting for him to get a paper cut opening his fan mail and hear he's on the 60 day IL (lol). Hicks? $70 million for a social justice warrior. Noble, but that doesn't win games. He gets paid to play and he spends so much time either in the operating room or on the trainer's table. You have to wonder if Cole is saying to himself, "What the **** was I thinking?" This is an absolute mess and very hard to watch. It may be time to simply move as many players out as they can and rebuild. You aren't winning with this team.
Are you kidding? Michael flip flops more than politicians. He justifies the Yankees not laying down a sac bunt because he says it’s giving up an out, but then he praises the Red Sox for playing small ball and hitting sac flies.
This team is boring and bad, and somehow they also manage to be arrogant and woke. I watched the Mets yesterday and saw some exciting baseball for a change,
That's the problem with MLB is the umpires!!! If they want to bring back hitting and runs to the game then you got to quit calling balls strikes!!! Make the pitcher throw the ball over the plate and you'll fix the lack luster performance! Quit changing the damn balls every year!!!! Hell there needs to be an asterisk with the statistics every year. Ball was tampered with this year!
Can u imagine if Gerrit coles numbers are so good because of the "sticky" stuff? His career numbers would be scrutinized and questioned he probably would get released
@@dme1016 im aware of that fact just hypothetically speaking because I'm noticing ever since this rule is finally being enforced pitchers are bitching up a storm
The problem is philosophical. They have plenty of talent, even with the lack of LH hitters (and very few good lefty hitters are available). HRs are great, but you can't go up there swinging for the fences. You have to go with the pitch and put the ball in play. They are capable, but everyone is trying to pull, even DJ. Also, way too many guys are guessing what pitch is coming instead of see ball, hit ball. Their swings are too long, because they are trying to kill it. They don't situational hit either - there are times where you just have to hit the ball to the right side to advance runners; and singles with RISP win games. They hit into a ton of DPs, because they are mostly RH and pull everything. Love Gardy, but he needs to retire to give Florial a chance to play CF (also happens to be a lefty). I also believe Frazier would be a good CF, it's the easiest OF position to play if you have speed and an arm, he has both. Odor is a dud, move DJ to 2B and Andujar to 1B until Voit gets back. Btw, I knew Voit would get injured because he was swinging so hard.
The mid power hitters should have figured out a while ago they are not going to hit home runs and need to play some small ball swing for contact get on base make something happen.
Here’s my take: Tim Naehring as GM and then hire ALL the following ➡️ Dana Brown - scout VP (ATL), Randy Flores (STL) Ass. GM, Dan Kantrovitz (Cubs) - ⚾️ Ops. HAL should absolutely have no saying in ⚾️ after he puts this people in motion! Just sign the checks and that’s all!! Blake, Nevin (bench coach), Harkey, Mendoza should be the only i think deserve to stay!! Bring Peña back as the catching coach Odor, Frazier, VOIT, Stanton (even if you have to pay 1-2yrs of his salary to trade him), Wilson, Wandy, Taillon, trade OFF!
Small ball is the key to scoring runs yankees is not playing it.the manager is not calling it so fire him anyone else who want to go fire them too,yanks need new ideas
Boone and Marques thames should have been fired along time ago and I like both also Cashman needs to end a great career this team is weak they have no pride they don't fight can't hit can't field can't run if im hal everyone is available except cole face it this season is a wash I can't watch I have already turned down 2 free games already I'm not wasting my time you have to break it down you have no choice my god sell sell sell torres Sanchez judge Frazier dump them all get what you can don't let these clowns wear this uniform
Aaron kicks was one of the worst signings cashman has ever made, hicks in and out of the lineup makes no difference, he can't hit righties anyways if he is the one giving balance to the lineup, then we are dead, we need changes, we need quality bats from the left side of the plate not HR hitters, we need a change on the coaching staff and we also need changes in the front office, cashman has to go his philosophy has not worked for years now.
The team has no leader and zero chemistry. Cashman needs to go - he does not understand pitching and the Yankees have not had a good pitching staff since Pettitte left. The coaching staff needs to go because the Yankees are not executing the fundementals. This team is dull. They are way over paid and lazy. The Yankees need guys who can hit .300 and they need to relearn to play the game - you know, hit, run, steal, bunt and stop striking out. Homeruns are way over rated. Boone probably needs to go too. Heck, replace everyone.
Boone is responsible for the bad ball playing. Poor base running, poor defensive (Torres), poor lineup writing. Whomever is writing the lineup is responsible for a lack luster batting. Every time somebody gets hot, Boone sets 'em down!!! Are you frickin' kidding me??? Ball players are streaky. You don't set 'em down when they're hot! Kay you're an idiot if you think somebody better than Sanchez out there. Name him and show me his numbers. And you consistently talk how good Torres is over Andujar but if you look at their statistics in the field and at bat it's no contest! Andujar is better!!! I just laugh every time Torres hits into a DP or has an error. He has more bad plays than good plays!!! I just found out that while watching the ballgames I can click over to the radio and listen to Sterling instead of you!!!
You cant hold a Yankee GM to the same standard as other GM's. Yankees are above most other teams, there is a higher standard. You cant say Cashman has done a good job, maybe if he did this in San Diego or Detroit you could. And they would have fired him by now. Yuck.
Where have you gone 2017... Such promise,. The future was bright, we had 4 young players with unlimited ceilings. Judge,. Sanchez, Torres, andujur
And now with the exception of Judge, they're all bums.
Cashman can't be fired won't be fired, no matter what. That is the main problem
The problem with waiting to fire Cashman until the off-season is this...
They are right. This team likely won't make the playoffs. This team should almost certainly be sellers this deadline. They don't have any money to spend and even if they did, this team is not a quick fix away from contenting.
So if they need to get rid of the GM and if they need to sell and start another retooling, then you can't have Cashman be the one in charge at this deadline while he is trying to save his job. He needs to go now and his replacement should be the one picking and choosing what pieces to keep, who to trade off, and what they are getting in return.
agreed. Let the new guy get in there and start working. If you suck now who cares if you suck more. It's WS or bust. If they aren't going to make make series then start the repairs.
Totally agree!!!
To
We
Y
Stop protecting Boone Michael! Please stop it! You sound utterly ridiculous right now saying that Boone is not responsible. Boone is the manager, he's the one that decides whether they should bunt or not, he's the one that decides whether he should come out the dugout or not, he's the one that decides whether he should complain about a call or not, what are you talking about Michael? Cashman is the general manager, he does not sit in the field and call plays. You're talking to a fan base that for the most part is entrenched in baseball for decades at a time. How can you even say that Boone shouldn't be responsible? He defends Sanchez not Brian. If it's up to me, if I was one of the owners of the New York Yankees, I will get rid of Boone first, see where that goes and then Brian will be out right after him. If it's the front office with their old stuck ways about doing things, which they are, and everybody knows how they are, nothing but an old bunch of cronies still stuck in the old ways of doing things. Then maybe it's time to restructure the whole damn staff excluding the owners. The players are pawns they're told what to do and what not to do it's like that in every sport except individual sports like golf and tennis. Stanton, and 11 game streak? And he's been hurt ever since he's come to the Yankees for over 2 years now and counting! Really! That's forward progress huh? They got rid of Pavano because he just decided not to play, and they ate the contract, so what's the difference right now with Stanton, he hasn't done anything since coming to the Yankees and that's a fact, and nothing but a bare essential fact! They have the money and they could eat that contract and send them off to where theye ever want to go. Who cares if they miraculously get better on another team? That's a bunch of nonsense, which you guys always come up with when it comes to Sanchez! Oh he might get better on another team. Who cares if they get better on another team, he's not doing anything for you right now. That's two players that need to get out of their pronto. Stop defending Judge because he's the face of the organization! There you guys go again always hitting the money huh.
Cashman constructed the team, he's the problem.
Boone made us the New York Spank-mes
Dont get excited b/c they beat up on the lowly Twins... going to Buffalo will be disastrous
Cashman provides the personnel
Boone makes the lineups.
The K/BB/HR philosophy sucks... you could see it slowly crumpling the past few seasons
Its on Cashman and the rich buffoons in the office
They play half of their games in Yankee Stadium and have no left handed hitters
Cashman has been slapping band aids and getting miracles for years. Like Tauchman and Maybin for example. It's just now finally catching up with him.
It's pretty sad when Rafael Devers hits a 1st-inning, 3-run homer, and I'm pretty sure it's already a fatal blow.
Mike is right. I love the Yankees but there isn’t any progress within them. Who do you blame? They are supposed to be The Yankees, and they’re losing to teams that they shouldn’t be. Something has to change.
The last dynasty had good left handed hitters and two great switch hitters . Tino Martinez Knoblach Paul Oniell Scott Brocious and Ricky Ledee we’re lefties Bernie and Jorge Posada were clutch switch hitters in 2003 Hideki Matsui came from Japan and was a great clutch left handed hitter
Knoblauch and Brosius were not lefties
Rick
Cashman is solely responsible
Boone is also responsible. A modern manager isn’t responsible for a lot, but in my opinion, if Boone can not teach, help or manage his players to run the bases correctly, then he isn’t capable of contributing anything to this team’s success.
exactly cashman is solely responsible.
I always thought he sucked. For 20 years..
100% this guy has set the organization back 100 years. They haven’t had a championship drought like this since 1903 - 1923. What a joke.
I wonder what he has to say now after the Yankees swept again against the Red Sox.
I’m putting that up tomorrow
The Rangers lost a game to the capitals and subsequently fired the entire front office. The Yanks need to pull George move and send a few guys packing.
that was the day they got eliminated from the playoffs
Only Michael Kay can scream Fordham University
Ya blaming Dj too much. It’s not fair. Blame everyone else but him ya crazy
This is Boone's last year as a manager barring some kind of divine intervention.
1. LeMeihu 2. Judge 3. Andujar 4. Urshella 5. Torres 6. Stanton 7, Sanchez 8. Voit 9. Gardner #1 Cole #2 German #3 Monty Chappy & Britton
As a Ray's fan here. I think the Yankees need no changes.
You come here just to comment that, that’s how you spend your Saturday? Go do something my guy
Yes I did, you dont have anything better to than comment back. Go drown in your 😢
@@robho3308 Oh so the Rays do have a fan base. I didn’t know that.
The problem with DJ LeMahieu is the ball itself. MLB changed it this season and it's had a deleterious effect on players like LeMahieu with mid-range power. And not just him either, other players like him - Jeff McNeil, Eddie Rosario, Eric Hosmer, Anthony Rendon - all were players of similar high-contact, 20 HR power that are watching their flyballs fall short of the wall this season.
The worst GM in ALL sports is cashman. When you have blank checks to a tune of 200 million yearly and you win 1 world series is not acceptable!!!!!! End of the 90s dynasty was stick micheals.
and not enough credit is ever given to Bob Watson either.
@@stevencolatrella3257 soooo true
@Kuracti Uguzicu I think a buffoon will get offended lol
This is my opinion on all of this. And in another forum, I had someone take issue with it, but if you think carefully about what I'm about to say, you'll see it similarly if not the same as I do. It starts at the top. Hal is a really nice guy, articulate and not a mercurial buffoon like his Dad could frequently be. BUT, you have to blame some of this on him. His father valued winning, the Yankees brand, and championships above all else. He paid (actually he frequently overpaid) top dollar but expected results and held people accountable. He sets the budget, he seems far more concerned about that than winning. This team is not well put together and that's on Cashman, period. The players are not motivated, not prepared, and seem to be going through the motions. The base running is so poor it looks like a T Ball team. That's on Boone. What existed 15, 25, 30, 40 years ago under George is still true today. Other than a fire sale before July 31, you can't fire 25 players. Barring a 15 game winning streak, this team may not get a sniff anywhere near the playoffs and if they do, they won't last long. What we all anticipated after 2017 hasn't even come close to paying off dividends. We took passes on several players when they were available; who wouldn't want Harper in say left field and his left handed bat coming up 4 or 5 times a game at Yankee Stadium? The patience with Sanchez is beyond reasonable and although he's been better, he isn't exactly making us forget Thurman or even Jorge either at or behind the plate. Moving Torres to short is this team's equivalent of how Joba Chamberlain was handled. If you aren't careful, you'll ruin that kid; he belongs at second base, period. You waited so long on Andujar he no longer has any real value in a trade. Anybody miss Mariano yet? Enough said. Stanton? I'm at least grateful he's on the field (for the most part). I'm waiting for him to get a paper cut opening his fan mail and hear he's on the 60 day IL (lol). Hicks? $70 million for a social justice warrior. Noble, but that doesn't win games. He gets paid to play and he spends so much time either in the operating room or on the trainer's table. You have to wonder if Cole is saying to himself, "What the **** was I thinking?" This is an absolute mess and very hard to watch. It may be time to simply move as many players out as they can and rebuild. You aren't winning with this team.
Long post. But spot on
Are you kidding? Michael flip flops more than politicians. He justifies the Yankees not laying down a sac bunt because he says it’s giving up an out, but then he praises the Red Sox for playing small ball and hitting sac flies.
This team is boring and bad, and somehow they also manage to be arrogant and woke. I watched the Mets yesterday and saw some exciting baseball for a change,
That's the problem with MLB is the umpires!!! If they want to bring back hitting and runs to the game then you got to quit calling balls strikes!!! Make the pitcher throw the ball over the plate and you'll fix the lack luster performance! Quit changing the damn balls every year!!!! Hell there needs to be an asterisk with the statistics every year. Ball was tampered with this year!
get rid of gardner bring tyler o neil from st louis
We gotta embrace our strengths. Ummm any ideas what they are??? Anyone??? Lol
Mike any updates on Yankee?.
Yanks need someone like Brandon Crawford
They shouldn't have let Didi go.
Can u imagine if Gerrit coles numbers are so good because of the "sticky" stuff? His career numbers would be scrutinized and questioned he probably would get released
You're crazy. Pitchers have been using something or other, forever..
@@dme1016 im aware of that fact just hypothetically speaking because I'm noticing ever since this rule is finally being enforced pitchers are bitching up a storm
Cash man makes good trades. Fire Thames.
The problem is philosophical. They have plenty of talent, even with the lack of LH hitters (and very few good lefty hitters are available).
HRs are great, but you can't go up there swinging for the fences. You have to go with the pitch and put the ball in play. They are capable, but everyone is trying to pull, even DJ. Also, way too many guys are guessing what pitch is coming instead of see ball, hit ball. Their swings are too long, because they are trying to kill it. They don't situational hit either - there are times where you just have to hit the ball to the right side to advance runners; and singles with RISP win games. They hit into a ton of DPs, because they are mostly RH and pull everything. Love Gardy, but he needs to retire to give Florial a chance to play CF (also happens to be a lefty). I also believe Frazier would be a good CF, it's the easiest OF position to play if you have speed and an arm, he has both. Odor is a dud, move DJ to 2B and Andujar to 1B until Voit gets back. Btw, I knew Voit would get injured because he was swinging so hard.
The mid power hitters should have figured out a while ago they are not going to hit home runs and need to play some small ball swing for contact get on base make something happen.
I didn’t like the DJ deal at the time, seemed like too much money for a player who I thought would regress
Idk why they’re not giving florial a chance….. smh this team is too In love Gardner
batting like .100 in triple a
Here’s my take: Tim Naehring as GM and then hire ALL the following ➡️ Dana Brown - scout VP (ATL), Randy Flores (STL) Ass. GM, Dan Kantrovitz (Cubs) - ⚾️ Ops. HAL should absolutely have no saying in ⚾️ after he puts this people in motion! Just sign the checks and that’s all!!
Blake, Nevin (bench coach), Harkey, Mendoza should be the only i think deserve to stay!! Bring Peña back as the catching coach
Odor, Frazier, VOIT, Stanton (even if you have to pay 1-2yrs of his salary to trade him), Wilson, Wandy, Taillon, trade OFF!
DJ has been a major problem.
The Yankees can't hit....period....lefty righty stuff would be less obvious if the players could hit....
Small ball is the key to scoring runs yankees is not playing it.the manager is not calling it so fire him anyone else who want to go fire them too,yanks need new ideas
Andujar is an error machine...horrible fielder who belongs in AA short-season ball
Yanks need more "color". Need to put Torres back at 2nd base. Run more..Need to bat Judge 3rd. And let Boone go.
Why do people blame cash when he answers to hal!
You’ll get the answer tonight when I do a live podcast
Boone and Marques thames should have been fired along time ago and I like both also Cashman needs to end a great career this team is weak they have no pride they don't fight can't hit can't field can't run if im hal everyone is available except cole face it this season is a wash I can't watch I have already turned down 2 free games already I'm not wasting my time you have to break it down you have no choice my god sell sell sell torres Sanchez judge Frazier dump them all get what you can don't let these clowns wear this uniform
Aaron kicks was one of the worst signings cashman has ever made, hicks in and out of the lineup makes no difference, he can't hit righties anyways if he is the one giving balance to the lineup, then we are dead, we need changes, we need quality bats from the left side of the plate not HR hitters, we need a change on the coaching staff and we also need changes in the front office, cashman has to go his philosophy has not worked for years now.
The team has no leader and zero chemistry. Cashman needs to go - he does not understand pitching and the Yankees have not had a good pitching staff since Pettitte left. The coaching staff needs to go because the Yankees are not executing the fundementals. This team is dull. They are way over paid and lazy. The Yankees need guys who can hit .300 and they need to relearn to play the game - you know, hit, run, steal, bunt and stop striking out. Homeruns are way over rated. Boone probably needs to go too. Heck, replace everyone.
Boone is responsible for the bad ball playing. Poor base running, poor defensive (Torres), poor lineup writing. Whomever is writing the lineup is responsible for a lack luster batting. Every time somebody gets hot, Boone sets 'em down!!! Are you frickin' kidding me??? Ball players are streaky. You don't set 'em down when they're hot! Kay you're an idiot if you think somebody better than Sanchez out there. Name him and show me his numbers. And you consistently talk how good Torres is over Andujar but if you look at their statistics in the field and at bat it's no contest! Andujar is better!!! I just laugh every time Torres hits into a DP or has an error. He has more bad plays than good plays!!! I just found out that while watching the ballgames I can click over to the radio and listen to Sterling instead of you!!!
Why do people blam cash when he answers to hal!
don't blame umpires. then you blame fans, it's never the manager's fault or the player's fault. Michael Kay is an apologist for Cashman and Boone
He literally said it was Cashmans fault dude
Blame the "PLAYERS"..that's where the fault is at.
Are umpires ever disciplined? Fired? Sent down to the minors?
Too strong a union BUT the umps are 100% not to blame for the lackluster yanks this year!
@@JustMe-nf1mf Yup. I meant in general.
Thaaaaaaaaaa Yankees lose.....lol
Remember when Michael Kay was a good announcer? Yeah, me neither
You cant hold a Yankee GM to the same standard as other GM's. Yankees are above most other teams, there is a higher standard. You cant say Cashman has done a good job, maybe if he did this in San Diego or Detroit you could. And they would have fired him by now. Yuck.
Lolol above other teams huh 🙄
@@JustMe-nf1mf 27
@@thomas1630 Ancient history of an ownership willing to pay anything to get one ffs lol ;o)
oh you poor babies! yankees aren't dominating this year! fire everyone!!!
Why is Boone always blamed
Best part of Covid & WFH is avoiding these bullshit talk shows...now I gotta duck RUclips!