Denting It Up Good
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 май 2024
- The plaintiff is an Uber driver, and the defendant arranged for a pickup. The plaintiff claims the defendant smashed his door into a metal garbage can, damaging it, so the plaintiff is suing. The defendant says the plaintiff refused to take him to his destination. When he got out of the car, the defendant gently opened the door. The defendant admits he lightly scratched the door but nothing more. The defendant is countersuing for counseling and lost wages.
Subscribe to our channel:
/ @peoplescourttv
Case # 32-272
#PeoplesCourt #RealityTV #Court 
Развлечения
![Jelly Roll - Dead End Road (From Twisters: The Album) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_Mb8CqKW4R8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Chk Chk Boom - Stray Kids ストレイキッズ 스트레이 키즈 [Music Bank] | KBS WORLD TV 240719](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/63QPwqCRGcw/mqdefault.jpg)
As an Uber driver the plaintiff was totally telling the truth
Does it at least show the mileage & pay?
Exactly because if I could see that you need to go 1 mile to the store, I'm not coming to get you
@@fintyeli3sometimes I think it doesn’t neither we got pick up a couple of time and the driver ask how much is the ride going far
I can concur. Kinda annoying how unwilling she was to accept that. It's simple, if they asked to go 4 hours you can reject the ride and risk a penalty. Pretty simple.
@@fintyeli3nope, not until after accepting, picking up, and then starting the trip! I’m a former Uber driver BTW. Uber doesn’t treat or pay their drivers as well as some would like to say and think, trust me!!!
Man she treated the Uber driver like a lying felon, and the poor med student like an angel.
Agree.
Yes I Agree
That was not right.....
She was totally biased on this one. Pissed me off and I normally like her rulings.
I agree.
I'm so mad I agree with you. I missed off
Unfortunately this is one of those time when Miliana has NO IDEA WHAT SHES TALKING ABOUT
"One"?
That's, let's say, conservative.
She often thinks she knows it all. I love it if she says to Douglas he shall tell them who she is. Sometimes he must say “daughter of a contractor” and sometimes “repo-man”.
Sorry my mother is retired now but was working in a bank and my dad was a mechanical master (Mechaniker-Meister in German don’t now how it s called in US) and I do not know more about banking or mechanic as f.e. my neighbours!!! It s a bit like judge Judy and her dentist-father 😂🤦♀️
One of MANY! She’s never wrong!
😑😑😑😑 🙄🙄🙄
Yah, she's nationally known, probably owns a few homes. How about you?
I totally agree I'm pissed off soooooo biased
And she grilled him like felony
How is she going to tell the person who does that for a living what the work flow is? Kmdt
Right!?!
Kmdt?
@@Hazel.Eyed.Gemini kissing my damn teeth.
There must be some sort of way for the driver to roughly know how long the trip is. They know up front how much they'd be making on it. There's no way he doesn't have a clue about the ride before he accepts it.
Who the heck writes “kmdt” like it’s a thing? Stop making the world a dumb place!
Judge was so mean to the Uber driver and so nice to the med student who did the actual damage. It's very wrong the way she is treating the Uber driver; it's just pure bias based on looks or profession.
Absolutely biased behavior by JM
She's often biased. She's also completely out of touch with 'the common man' and has literally no idea about the finances of the poor and what people have to do to get by.
Oh please! Get over yourself. Your jealousy is showing.
I agree! The Uber driver just wanted justice for the destruction of his property. The defendant was wrong and he should have been fined AND paid for the damage!
@@ceeceepascoe4293 i know , she actually told the uber driver what uber's policies were and HE works for uber on a daily basis and she does not . i have noticed that alot of people who graduated from law school think they now know everything about everything , she needs to stick to what she knows best and thats only the law and nothing else .
How is she speaking as if she is a Uber driver..I hate when the judge acts like the knower of all.
Well, maybe I can show some light. I think she's explaining it for the viewers so they understand the process so they can understand the case better
@@xyztrade but her explanation is wrong. She's objectively incorrect.
Yeah I think you’re correct
She sometimes has an attitude.
Exactly. A passenger view and the driver's view of the app is completely different
As an fellow uber driver AND a reason I cut back on driving IS because you cant see the ride destination until you start the ride. It is not shown at the time you accept the ride... i actually had a 4.5 hour drive from Hyattsville MD to VA Beach because of this and because I really needed the money, i did the ride... the plaintiff is ABSOLUTELY TELLING THE TRUTH!
But you can see the estimated pay before you accept, so if it’s high you can assume it’s a long trip…
What is the judge talking about? You don't know where you are taking them until you get the customer, then swipe 🤷I was an Uber driver for 4 years
This! I myself was an Uber driver and I never got to see the destination until I started the trip. The judge was very harsh on the plaintiff.
Dang, I always thought like the judge. That's crazy u can't see where you are driving.
Geezus! And I never knew this. That is crazy.
I wasn’t aware that taking an Uber on a regular basis makes you an expert witness on being a driver for Uber. Learn something new everyday…
😂😂😂
According to the know it all Judge, it does make her an expert after all she knows it all hahaha she’s delusional and very rude in this case…..
Maybe don't be a jerk and pay for your damages.
This case was so disgusting, even if it was an accident it was still his fault. She's encouraging entitled behavior, it's just gros.
The students repeated refusal to give his address and ignoring all texts was so immature. I'm glad at least that it cost him more than the generous $300 that the plaintiff offered him to pay.
She also was waaaaaaaay to much empathy with the defendant than to the plaintiff and I feel is because in her eyes the Uber driver is worth less than the defendant.
So dude fails his exam and somehow it’s someone else’s fault and now their financial responsibility?!?! In what world???🙄😳🤣
How can he prove that he wouldn't have failed anyway?
I've seen it all. 😂
its actually not a pass / fail test. you get a percentil ranking. so he probably either didn't do well, or chose not to take it (or perhaps chose not to report it, if that is an option).
there are tons of people who take the MCAT more than once. its not a big deal.
That is my thought.
That isn't his fault either.
Lmao FR IM like poor him happens to plenty others and thet don’t get special treatment 😂✌️
Wow, judge, your bias is showing. I can't stand how she comes across in this one. She was terrible to the plaintiff for no reason!
racist as hell!
Hopefully JM ate humble pie and sent a letter of apology to the P.
I’ve never heard of that before😢 imma start using that!🙏 “Humble PIE” huh.
I wouldn't be surprised if this case is quietly pulled down because this is the first time I've seen the comments be so overwhelmingly against HER. I know the show is off the air already, but damn. 😆
@@familytv9585 we say humble pie here in England 🇬🇧
WHY? She was right. The Uber driver is an idiot.
😂😂😂@janicester your idiot is showing
Waiting 10 minutes for an Uber is quick in my experience
I can’t even finish watching this case because I need to, with all my being, respectfully defend the plaintiff against the Judge on one point! As a former Uber driver, I can assure her that one is NEVER given the actual destination of the passenger until AFTER THE TRIP HAS BEEN STARTED!!! Which means that if the person wants to go from Connecticut to NYC, the driver has to either take them or cancel the trip and get dinged by Uber! I usually agree with JM but right is right! ❤
Yes, I can't even finish the episode. Very annoyed.
my problem with that is, you "can" see the destination, but i never get dinged when I'm stationary. It's always while I'm driving. Therefore, he could've seen it, but accepted anyways.
I also stopped watching because she was so, so wrong and rude as shit to the plaintiff. I feel terribly for him.
@@AsusanXT when I was an Uber driver, pre-COVID, the app DID NOT show the final destination until AFTER the trip was started. The only thing we were told was where the people were to be picked up and how many miles it was to get to their pickup location, but their destination was unknown until I started the trip through the app! IDK, but Uber may have changed the app since then. But my REAL argument was with JM for outright refusing to believe the plaintiff and accusing him of lying, because he wasn’t!!! She can be overly aggressive towards litigants, without knowing material facts, such as in this case!
@@ruthcalfee7868 it was probably updated and more afterwards. Currently it's better, but that's all I can assume. I don't Uber too much, but on weekends for sure.
The defendant is a snotty privilege jerk that intentionally did. The judge is so wrong Uber/Lyft drivers can’t see the drop off locations bc drivers would start cherry picking at that point.
He even has that jock bully haircut from every college movie.
I also feel like she was easy on the defendant because she's impressed with him... But the plaintiff is out there working an honest and hard job too... She was kind of hard on him and nice to the defendant giving him life advice when I believe with all my heart he was a jerk when he didn't get his way....
So I been watching the show for a long time she act exactly how she always act. If you in college she will give you advice and baby you. She done this for all college student.
For the Uber driver she feel like he lying about the ride info and once she feel like you lied she treat you cold and act like everything you do is a lie.
She is too much. When was she ever an uber driver?
who is SHE?
Judge is 100% wrong about the Uber ride. This happened to my boyfriend when he didn't know where he was going until the rider got in the car. The ride was to NY and we live in Philly. I usually rock with the Judge but she was wrong.
😂😂😂😂
Never!!
JM should realize that she does not know EVERYTHING!! She’s highly offended when someone says something about the law because she’s a lawyer in a judge but this guy is a full-time Uber Driver and he knows what he’s talking about. And if she doesn’t believe him she should take a recess and Google it.
I was hoping to find a comment like this because JM always saying she knows the law but then to tell the uber driver she knows his job as well get a grip JM and as for that smirking jerk want to be doctor what a 🤡 this absolutely stinks of privilege she bang out of order this time 🇬🇧
Maybe it's a good thing he failed his test.
Can you imagine if he is wrist deep in someone's guts doing surgery and a nurse says the wrong thing and pisses him off?!?!?
Why is she being so hard in the victim
Why did Uber EVER think it was a good idea to blindside the people they rely on to get requests completed?
Bait and switch for profit- driver won’t accept low pay/long drive…
They don't want drivers to discriminate against blacks and other minorities going to unsavory parts of town. It also stops drivers from ignoring short-distance trips since they don't make money on them.
@@hottuna2006 - I can't imagine any Uber driver wants to get robbed and carjacked.
@@hottuna2006i can understand that but just as the minorities have rights to non discrimination, i think the uber drivers should have the right to know where they are taking their property and themselves. There are so many "what if" situations, such as someone not being allowed on the property of a certain establishment or within a certain distance from someones house, etc. it seems like a safety risk to not tell them before accepting and on top of that, penalizing them if they cancel the ride when they do find out. Its like a "da**ed if you, da**ed if you dont" situation.
@@hottuna2006 not just “blacks” or minorities go to “unsavory parts of town”
Marilyn Millian demonstrated exactly what’s wrong with our legal system. The hubris to try and tell the plaintiff how the platform he uses each day, and she’s never used, works.
You can tell who the judge likes…😉
I feel for the uber driver. This ruined his ability to get higher paying uber jobs all because of an entitled, drunk student who thinks he can ignore someone. Good for the uber driver sticking to his guns. He looked close to tears
Judge Milian was not objective in this case. She was overly empathetic towards the med student. She almost seemed in awe of him and disregarded the idea that the med kid could have hit the trash can intentionally Why? Because he's a med student? What about the Uber driver who was working hard at 1am? Although the driver was very respectful and thoroughly explained Uber's protocol, she decided not to believe him simply because she's an uber customer...please! In this case, she showed us that she was biased. If she had been fair and objective, she would have awarded the plaintiff the mid-range quote and acknowledged what a mess this was for the plaintiff not just advising the defendant about his future...PLEASE!!
He said was not a medical student. He was a college junior who was taking the MCats twice because he did so poorly on the first test.
Thank god you explained that,it changes nothing!
I’m a bit confused didn’t she rule in favor of the plaintiff? She objectively ruled the case appropriately. I think your view is more subjective and emotional. I’m not an Uber driver myself, but that sucks if the driver isn’t notified of the destination prior to accepting a job… seems very counterproductive.
I already see what type of “doctor” this defendant will be. Very arrogant and thinks he’s the smartest lol
His demeanor says it all. Smh and the way JM basically stroked his head and kissed his boo boo is going to add to his arrogance! SMH just disgusting!
He still won't take responsibility in the hallway. This is worrisome.
But, what do you call the person who graduates at the bottom of their class in medical school?
"Doctor"
He is not in medical school, much less graduated from it.
The future doctor has a lot to lose...poor Uber driver doesn't. Judge, your attitude is disgusting. One thing about it, the young man already thinks he's special...should be a fine dr.
How dare she make judgements on whose life trajectory has more value than someone else's. Disgusting. I'm not watching her any more. She's left a bad taste in my mouth.
Where is Adrian when you need him. I would actually agree with him on this case because her bias was so blatant. 😅
Lmaoo don’t summon him
I was literally looking for his comment
@@Lrlindsri😂😂😂😂😂
Why doesn’t the judge do her dam due diligence !!!! I have driven Uber/lyft for 7 + years and within the last year did it become available to see where the rides are taking you! I HATED it before hand. He was right but she just assumed he wasn’t telling the truth! I cancelled so many trips because I didn’t want to drive all over the world
The judge: "I use Uber all the time. That's not how it works!"
She honestly thinks that her experience on the customer side makes her the be-all, end-all expert. 😒😒😒😒
Sad to see. The drivers view is completely different. Driver's do not know where they are going.
Judge is totally wrong here about Uber, I love the show but hate her arrogance at times
It’s sad this low integrity guy is going to be in the medical system.
He's telling the truth.
The whole truth
As a ex-uber driver. Judge you're incorrect. Uber drivers don't see final destination until they've picked up the passenger. I've done multiple pick-ups at the LAX airport and it takes me to a location in San Diego county which is almost 2 hrs away. I take em because I'm stuck and have integrity to fulfill my duty. But hated those rides. Because then the ride back? Was empty. I'm driving for free technically
Damn she won’t let the Uber driver talk once the other party said MCAT that was a wrap.
I’ve had an Uber driver kick me out of his car because he couldn’t drive to my destination that was an hour away. I booked another Uber and told him about getting the boot from the previous driver and he explained that Uber does NOT inform the driver how far away your destination is until AFTER the passenger gets in their vehicle. The plaintiff told the truth.
Judge is 100% wrong about the Uber ride. This happened to my boyfriend when he didn't know where he was going until the rider got in the car. The ride was to NY and we live in Philly. I usually rock with Judge but she was loud and wrong.
Totally agree Rude, drag out and biased against the plaintiff
@deborahfrance9807 she rule for him for everything he was sueing for how is that biase
Not her arguing with him about HIS actual job and title of what he does and how it works! SMH 🤦🏽♀️
Unfortunately, its the truth about Uber. I learned that when I was booking a trip to an airport that was an hour away. The person came, I sat in the car, and then she asked me if I had put in the right address. It was too far for her.
This millian lady need to chill tf out. I hate when she speaks out of her ass like she knows everything when she doesn’t. Just because you are a judge and went to law school that don’t mean you know everything. She’s getting on the plaintiff like the plaintiff is the one getting sued or was the one who damaged the car. She needs to apologize! I’ve seen her done this to many color skinned plaintiffs and defendants on her show.
Sorry JM is wrong. Uber drivers don’t see where the ride is going !
I was a Uber driver in Boston while in college, back in 2017 and I must say Judge, the driver is right, the destination does NOT SHOW on the driver side until he accept the ride.
The judge was more understanding about the inconvenience of the med student than the actual damages he caused to the driver
The plaintiff wasn’t treated right by Judge Milan nor by the police officers who attended the scene of the incident.
Judge milian was DISGUSTING on this case. She treated the plaintiff, an uber driver, like a criminal even though he was telling the truth, and placated the defendant bc he's a future dr., even though he admittedly said he hit plaintiff's car door on the garbage can. She's pathetic!
she was over sympathetic to the defendant, she's laid into to people for far less and shes out here giving him life advice. OK judge
I hate the judge when she just assumes people understand court shit… And she screams at you until you blurt out something that you don’t know what you’re talking about. She gets so angry.
Judge Judy is the worst at it😂
Yeah she really can be a C U Next Tuesday at times. There's nobody in the courtroom so she doesn't need to shout as her voice echos.
Her, Judy and Mathis!! The three often talk over the litigants and don’t hear what they say and then claim that the plaintiff or defendant said something completely different! That’s so mean! BUT as we all know it is only a TV show and the plaintiff may although file the claim “again” in a real case.
@@naanra301When they come on The People’s Court, they agree to have JM settle their case, and they dismiss their actual court cases. They cannot be retried in another small claims court. This is the last stop-win or lose.
The plaintiff is right about the Uber destination thing. From what I’ve heard, it was/is common for drivers to not know the destination until they would start the ride after they’ve already picked someone up, but I think it’s changed where you can now see a general area of where the persons destination is on the map.
Judge, admit it you just didn’t like the Asian guy, liked the gay guy…your judgement was clouded
For a second I thought you were Adrian!! 😅 I totally agree with your sentiment!🫡
Always the race card when someone doesn't have a valid argument....the Asian guy. . maybe he doesn't even liked to be called the Asian guy. You know the Asian guy's name from the episode and you chose not to use it tells alot about your views on racism and gives us the fact that you yourself are racist. I think it better if you didn't tell everyone how you really are 😅 which isn't a good person.
@@familytv9585smh .... racist
Both Milian and Mathis will argue someone down without first fact-checking. Just because you’re a judge doesn’t mean you know everything 🙄🙄🙄
It’s why I can’t stand Mathis. He believes he’s the smartest man in the world.
This is why I ONLY do Uber eats. I don’t want trashy people in MY car acting like they run the show.
See he should’ve gave the $300 instead of being an airhead
The defendant really gives me the icks....so smug and arrogant....he grosses me out....he's going to medical school? I certainly wouldn't want him treating me....
He’s a walking demon
Bet he wished he paid that $300 🤣
He had a constant smirk on his face. He did it on purpose, and he should be ashamed of himself. He knew he got away with it, and thought it was funny.
Why the “ cheapest” estimate when typically it’s the average?
I noticed that too.
Whenever a litigant testifies that police or court proceedings dont follow the procedure or jump the rails, JM always has trouble believing it. Like a govt bureaucracy is incapable of mistakes.
Defendant replying "Mmhmm" was lowkey annoying me lmao
Unfortunately what he's saying is true we dont see it
The plaintiff is right, Uber drivers don’t see the destination until the rider gets in and the confirm the ride.
Anyone notice the defendant kept closing his eyes in that smug way.
I think he was high
Like he shops at ambercrombe n fitch
He definitely did it deliberately, and his privilege card was faster than the Uber driver 😂
the judge is a snob!!!!
She is irritating!!!
I can't believe the defendant, I change my mind now I hope the defendant loses for being such a liar such an idiot
the comments are spot on in recognizing and calling out how rude the judge was to the plaintiff and soft towards the defendant. i think its because she see's the plantiff the way she sees the youth whom she mentioned she helped with applications to medical school and her daughters applications to law school. ive been seeing alot more instances of behavoir like this from the judge and now im realizing why ppl compare her to judge judy and judge mathis. the other 2 judges arent as blantantly bias like this but idk if they post their full episodes on youtube if they do can someone drop a link so i can start watching their episodes more.
The plaintiff was telling the truth I do Uber eats delivery and I don't know where the food go until I go to the restaurant and say I got the food then it tells me where to deliver it to
As a former lyft driver, they don’t tell us how far these people are going until they get in our car and we hit that “Start ride” button
"I've never applied for medical school" But apparently she was an Uber driver before 😂
If defendant is that fragile, he's not going to be able to handle medical school.
Defendant: was it worth it??
Judge needs to make a public apology on her incorrrctly saying the uber driver is lying without saying the word lie, then treating the entitled smug would- be doctor in a manner different from the plaintiff.
And many believe the "halls of justice " are equal to all. This case serves as a prime example of how biases, intentional or unintentional "seep" to the surface in all people, regardless of position or authority. It's shameful the way this defendant was coddled throughout the entire testimony, despite him having admittedly caused the damage, then purposely ignored requests for payment to make things right. Then, the audacity to file a counter claim comprised of absolute nonsense, all the result of his own actions. We even witnessed the "softer side " of Doug post case, with the defendant. Ridiculous
OUTRAGEOUS that she just assumes she knows how the uber app works for driver's just because it doesn't sound logical to her. That angered me SO MUCH!!!
HATED the judges take on this one. She favoured the "poor med school student" from the very start and shamed the uber driver at every opportunity even though he did nothing wrong. She was elitist, and it was DISGUSTING!!! This is why those private school kids get away with so much in the justice system!! They're all birds of a feather!! The privilege is just oozing throughout this case😡😤
Yeah this judge knows EVERYTHING so theres no need 2 ever argue
He’s definitely telling the truth all of the Uber drivers have told me the same thing that they can’t see the destination until they arrive to pick up the rider ! She’s definitely wrong on this one !
Why is Madam Judge being so mean to plaintiff? I find he's honest and trustworthy and did nothing wrong
What a prissy defendant. He doesn't need to be a doctor if he can't take responsibility for something this menial.
Millian is DEAD WRONG about Uber. WTF is she so mean to the plaintiff? The defendant looks and acts like a lying, entitled rich kid.
When I got into my car accident the police refused to give me the lady's information. He said I had to pull it off the internet when the crash report was available. Which I knew he could've given me that info.
Milian was so biased in this case it was outrageous. This was so obvious, yeah, treat the poor like shit and the entitled rich drunk with kid gloves.
The judge was not nice to the Uber driver! She took the other guys BS because he was studying to be a doctor?
Uber and Lyft has gotten better far as letting you know how long the ride will be. Hes right tho, you dont see the address til u start the ride. Even tho u know the ride is 20 minutes, u still dont know which direction youre going until u start the ride. JM has millions of dollars and need to sit this one out lol she has no idea how it works from the drivers standpoint. I still love her tho.
I swear sometimes the judge makes me cringe, as much as I love the people's court tv show, she thinks she knows everything sometimes. Who doesnt know that about the Uber app from the drivers end of things?!
I wonder if the judge has since realized that she was totally wrong in the Uber destination situation.
Was it just me or was the judge playing a little favorite here with the plaintive?.
She was absolutely wrong about the Uber process.
Being an over driver is a very humbling job … Although I drive and rarely uses Uber or Lyft … I have the utmost respect for the drivers. 🙏🏾♥️
Kid should not be a doctor. Of any kind. Period.
The defendant is going to medical school and he already needs counseling? Lord help us all.
This Uber driver is courageous and good for him for never giving up. $300 to fix it was better than $1000 not to mention the court costs. The defendant was rude, so was the judge & the guy doing the exit interview was rude, disrespectful & obnoxious. No hand shake!
Wtf was wrong with her this day!? She was dead wrong!
The judge talking over him, cutting him off mid sentence to tell them how exactly it is as if she was there and knew everything about everything...
No offense to Judge but i have see alot of these and she has ALWAYS said from day 1 " i know all about construction, my family has been doing it for EVER" Then i saw a case where a carpenter said something about crowning and she said "i have no idea what crowning is" the defendant explained it and she said "i have no idea what crowning is"
Unbalanced scale! Can you see it? Zesty shouldn’t be in nobodies medical school…he should be in a straight jacket
Frankly shocked Uber doesn't show the destination before accepting the ride... That's ridiculous
Right?! That's absolutely ridiculous!
That med student please we don’t need any more douchey doctors