When I 1st watched this show Lukas was a clear winner, but after watching this years later he was just above average.....his songwriting def helped him win the show
I always felt Storm was the clear winner. Now I see that she coasted the whole time. Didn’t even try. I’m glad she found success and continues to make her own lane. She’s a force.
Watching this for the first time since it aired. I always remembered Ryan throwing his guitar in this episode but just realized that he did so RIGHT after Tommy and Jason suggested that Magni should have done so during Teen Spirit LOL. Ryan was special.
totally agree! I loved her song, though I still felt her vocal performance was lacking... the whole time I was imagining how great the song would have sounded with the right voice doing it.
I think we need a new series and make the final 4-5 contestants into a band, go with me here. I think they should have like vocal week workshops for them and get some of the best heavy rock vocalists work with the contestants, then a guitar workshop then next, then so on and so forth, VH1 have the resources and contacts to make it happen for sure
Lukas was meh and probably an alcoholic, Dlana was a modern day Cyndi Lauper who had that pack a day smokes voice, top three should have been Storm, Ryan and Toby
To this day, I'm still disappointed that Luckas won. Magni, Storm, Toby and Ryan were great. Dilana was arrogant and couldn't write a good song to save her life, but she had a kick-ass rock & roll voice. It should have been any one of those five over Luckas.
I've been defending Lukas for 14 years... even Supernova online forums have people talking about how much they hate him. I was 12 when this was on tv and fell in love with Lukas. He's hot!
Now Toby thinks he's Axl Rose.....and sorry, but I don't understand why people think Lukas's voice is so cool. For me, he always sounds strained. It hurts to hear him sing.
Lukas was way overrated. He sounded much better when he didn't close his voice. Unfortunately, he did it all the time and it wasn't good. Ryan was the best by far. Too good for this band.
tracieMac Lukas Rossi is a really good singer when he doesn’t close his throat. I know. I have all his music that’s available on iTunes AND I’ve seen him live twice.
Yheae redemption songs are lame. None of these threw out anything risky. Try doing some priest . Ifvyou xan pull off rob halford then you're a shoe in.
I Class myself as a rock chick, can't believe i missed this show, just found out about storm from a clip on AGT, love her! So just been watching few performances here and there, and yes i 100% agree with you, i think Lucas was the weakest off of what i have watched so far anyway, boring and not what a call a strong rock voice, and i don't mean just shouting either!
Man, Ryan's song it's still amazing after all these years. I miss this type of show
As I kid I never really gave much thought to the house band. They are legitimately an amazing group of musicians.
BudduredToast they really are... I have friends that are studio musicians and they are just amazing.
gotta love storm form being so comfortable in her own skin and who she is.
I miss this show so much!
Ryan Star. Star indeed, nuf said.
uggghhh. that guy is so boring.
Ryan looks like a crazy Ross from friends
When I 1st watched this show Lukas was a clear winner, but after watching this years later he was just above average.....his songwriting def helped him win the show
I always felt Storm was the clear winner. Now I see that she coasted the whole time. Didn’t even try. I’m glad she found success and continues to make her own lane. She’s a force.
well. ryan, back of ur car, damn wat agreat tune!!!
Watching this for the first time since it aired. I always remembered Ryan throwing his guitar in this episode but just realized that he did so RIGHT after Tommy and Jason suggested that Magni should have done so during Teen Spirit LOL. Ryan was special.
Dilana's vocals on Every Breath You Take were breautiful. "I'll kick Bambi's ass" LOL. I love Bambi.
Although I was never a big fan of Patrice's covers, I actually quite liked her original song here.
totally agree! I loved her song, though I still felt her vocal performance was lacking... the whole time I was imagining how great the song would have sounded with the right voice doing it.
It is a good original. It could be a Hole song.
She had no idea. What made her think that's a song Supernova would like. "Im beginning to think, Its a beautiful thing" lol those lyrics.
@@TheJwwintersupernova was a flop anyway. Her song was much better than anything on their debut and sole album
I think we need a new series and make the final 4-5 contestants into a band, go with me here. I think they should have like vocal week workshops for them and get some of the best heavy rock vocalists work with the contestants, then a guitar workshop then next, then so on and so forth, VH1 have the resources and contacts to make it happen for sure
Ryan's song is totally dope!
Magni was awesome this week! He TOTALLY Rocked Smells Like Teen Spirit!
29:45-29:47 Look at Toby, Magni and Lukas! Hahaha that was hilarious.
Wow, Ryan's original song is brilliant.......and far too good for Supernova!
meh... I always think he should be a Broadway stage show performer.
Ryans voice is such a marketable rock voice. Not the best voice, the best rock voice imo.
Ryans voice was the best.no doubts. That solo tune was impressive
um... no.
Ryan kind of reminds me of Bush.
Lukas was meh and probably an alcoholic, Dlana was a modern day Cyndi Lauper who had that pack a day smokes voice, top three should have been Storm, Ryan and Toby
My favourite performance by Lukas!
If only Lukas ripped off his shirt at some point, too. He never did, BTW. I watched this whole show back in 2006 on TV.
To this day, I'm still disappointed that Luckas won. Magni, Storm, Toby and Ryan were great. Dilana was arrogant and couldn't write a good song to save her life, but she had a kick-ass rock & roll voice. It should have been any one of those five over Luckas.
Cuz his personality and voice fit the band perfectly
Lukas won it for his voice, his stage presence, his star power and his song writing skills. the top 4 were exactly as they should have been.
Dilana - So far, shitty song writing skills and the journalists really exposed her.
Look at her now. She ISN’T arrogant!!!
I've been defending Lukas for 14 years... even Supernova online forums have people talking about how much they hate him. I was 12 when this was on tv and fell in love with Lukas. He's hot!
Ryan’s original is better than anything supernova wrote.
Sadly it was the only rocking song on his “songs from the eye of an elephant” album.
Technically it was also a piano ballad on that album
12:00
What Toby did to the classic Layla was criminal, and taking off his top stinks of desperation!
wow, I had forgotten this performance. I found it unlistenable.
Now Toby thinks he's Axl Rose.....and sorry, but I don't understand why people think Lukas's voice is so cool. For me, he always sounds strained. It hurts to hear him sing.
you have something wrong with your ears.
Lukas was way overrated. He sounded much better when he didn't close his voice. Unfortunately, he did it all the time and it wasn't good. Ryan was the best by far. Too good for this band.
tracieMac Lukas Rossi is a really good singer when he doesn’t close his throat. I know. I have all his music that’s available on iTunes AND I’ve seen him live twice.
@@tayl2991 eh Lucas closed his throat too much. Not impressive
@@pingpongballz5998 Lukas. K not C.
How can you be a " rocker " and not know the lyrics to Cryin?
was Lukas drunk?
+Stephanie Armstrong
Probably most likely yes!!!
He didn't seem drunk to me
SPOILER ALERT...lukas won...the band flopped...the rest of the talented artists are still going strong
Glad to know my opinion was kinda of valid, i thought he was shit lol
In 2021 they would shut this down for mysongany or what ever. Life is dead in 2021...
Yes because how lovely is “mysongany”
its awesome@@acornhead666
Brooke , aarrgghh wasteland
Damn I hated and still hate Lukas and Ryan
I always felt that toby tried too hard.nothin was instinctive or natural he just copied everyone else and forced cheap moves
Yheae redemption songs are lame. None of these threw out anything risky. Try doing some priest . Ifvyou xan pull off rob halford then you're a shoe in.
Inxs was a good band but gee.. Supernova... They sucked
Lukas sucked. Wtf. Is it just me?
I Class myself as a rock chick, can't believe i missed this show, just found out about storm from a clip on AGT, love her!
So just been watching few performances here and there, and yes i 100% agree with you, i think Lucas was the weakest off of what i have watched so far anyway, boring and not what a call a strong rock voice, and i don't mean just shouting either!
@@Darkangel-hy8ev I wonder if he finally destroyed his voice.