Mudwings are underappreciated. They have an hour of underwater breathing, tanky scales, brute strength, they breath fire, and on top of that, a chance to have fireproof scales.
I agree! I think the only reason that they were put so low is their lack of representation throuout the series. If there were more books with mudwing pov characters the fandom would probably be much more loving of them. Book one was the only book with a main mudwing character, and that book focused mainly on worldbuilding and charachter development, rather than intricacies of the tribe. I personally would love to see the mudwings explored more with a Winglets or Legends novel.
Yes! I love mudwings. They are one of my favorite tribes and don't deserve to be underrated especially with the first main protagonist being I don't know, cLaY?? I also wish we got more time with them though. Because we didn't really see the queen often at all. I feel that we should have another book starring one. (And kinkajou too lol)
True. Cricket is my favourite character. I bet if Cricket had powers HiveWings could get ranked higher. And considering the only good HiveWing that we know has powers has fart powers, I think they got pretty good.
Perhaps it is because we are human that we hate them the most. We read about dragons to escape from who we are, from what we are, and we curse that which reminds us. Or, you know, maybe we just don't like them because they can't fly hahaha :P
The thing about Silkwings is that they never had a chance to be anything. We know next to nothing about their history, their culture, and even their abilities. Flamesilk is something that Queen Wasp tried to hide, and back when Beetlewings were around, they were said to have even more abilities. After the tree wars, Silkwings were essentially stripped down to their name alone. Their ability to make silk was useful to Wasp, and later on their antennae were too. But they could never do anything more than that. Luna got swept in a silk parachute all the way to Phyrria, isn’t that cool? What if Silkwings before the tree wars often made parachutes for wingless dragonets or injured Silkwings? What if they had a language of their own that they spoke through vibrations on silk lofts like strumming a guitar? What if certain colours on Silkwings were rumoured to show your personality, kind of like zodiac signs. It could be said that green Silkwings were fierce and competitive, or yellow Silkwings were curious and creative. Blue Silkwings could be loyal and Loving or purple Silkwings could be adventurous and hard-working. What if they had beautiful forests of colourful trees, calligraphic silk art along the bark and branches. Flamesilk lanterns painstakingly crafted for ceremonial celebrations or holidays for Silkwings to whisper their greatest wishes into, before setting them free. There could be little doctors appointments for getting dragonets ready for their metamorphosis, and trying to calm the worries of those who were scared. Synchronized dances to form pictures with their wing patterns, hide and seek games where the seeker only uses their antennae, murals of stories weaved together with silk. But unfortunately all of this is a what if. The tragedy of the Silkwing tribe is that they don’t have that, nothing in their world was made for them. They have no way of finding out who they once were, what it means to be a Silkwing. They don’t get to weave tapestries of their stories, their homes or their happiness. Everything they make is a what if, a dream of a life they couldn’t achieve without tragedy.
I may be a teensy bit obsessed with NightWings- They’re just so cool with their powers and connections to the moons, and I’d ponder about their secrets all day if I could. What would happen if they were hatched on a blue moon? Or a super moon? Or a micro moon? How long does it take for the egg to turn silver? Like, how long did Moon’s egg have to cook in the moonlight lol What would mutated powers of the NightWings look like? Did other dragons have the same idea as Secretkeeper and hide their eggs too? Is there just a group of telepaths and seers running around the continent? If an egg wasn’t laid in the moonlight but still hatched in it, would it still have powers? Does it have to be the exact night of a full moon or can it be around that time? I could go on. Btw, NightWings arguably have the most facial scales. They have the scales flat on top of their heads, scales right next to their snouts, silver teardrop scales for telepaths, and eyebrows.
I can just imagine Morrowseer and the other dragons frying and eating the ruined eggs. Fried eggs are delicious. If Secretkeeper actually ever has a cracked egg, let me know.
Tbh SkyWings are just the classic dragons that’d you see in fantasy stories and medieval stories -Red -Big Wings and body -Can breathe fire with no problem -Fly very far -And more So SkyWings are just Classical Dragons basically with a few things added of course
I thought the same thing when I first read the books! I didn't like them at first because they seemed basic and also grumpy, but for some reason I grew to kind of love them over time, and now they're the tribe I'm most personally attached to, aside from Rainwings
@@JadeMountainArchivein a fact video, courtesy of Bellasauras, it is true Skywings were based off traditional dragons. Mudwings were also based off Crocodiles, and sandwings scorpions. I forgot the others tho, sorry.
I honestly really like Dragonslayer! I usually don't like books with people as the main characters when set in a world like Wings Of Fire because I just didn't think they would be able to do it good but they really did in my opinion! I loved the boon and would love to see a second Dragonslayer book.
@@willowthewarriorwolf7153 well dragons are an escape and humans not so much, I mean, I see humans every day. Lots of them. But dragons? Now you have my attention.
I can't believe I was 1 out of the 1500 people who responded. It just amazes me how so many people like the thing I like! puts a smile on my face every time, keep up the great content JMA!!!
SkyWings have some religous things about them, they believe in reincarnation and this was proven in book 6 when they wanted to put Carnelian's body somewhere where she could be released to the sky so that she would be reincarnated as a SkyWing instead of another tribe. :D
@@Wingedlizar ... Maybe. But they are SkyWings and they believe they're the best. So maybe just a little bit, but it's not mean to the other tribes or anything, it's just that they think they're the best.
7:07, I loved Dragonslayer, but here's the thing. They literally just took over book 14 and 15! This is, indeed, A dragon book series. not a human one.
I really wish we get more on silkwing culture before or during the tree wars. Just things like how did it play out, or what key events led up to monarch giving up the throne. Silkwings aren’t my favorite but I still want to know more about them. If anyone wants to know, my fav tribe is sand wings. I just like the way their tribe was portrayed through the books and how the eye of onyx can choose anyone. Also thorns mentality towards being queen seems great to me. (Edit) I could go much more into detail about sandwings or any other tribe, but I won’t because that would require a comment that takes you a while to read. (Like right now)
Spoiler: The Flames of Hope could have been a good book for Sora and the MudWings. Sora could have easily learned the morale about vengeance killings in place of Luna.
I guess...But in what world would anyone allow Sora on the team? Even if she sneaks into the group to avoid having to interact with the icewing, skywing, rainwing and mudwing queens, remember that Qibli and Moon are part of the team.
If I could choose to be any dragon tribe in Wings Of Fire, I would be a SandWing. They’re clever, they know how to survive on rough circumstances, they’re always up for a good time, and they love music! They’re definitely my favorite tribe. I already have my dragon life planned out for if that did happen: I would immediately travel to the Scorpion Den and become an Outclaw. That way I could proudly serve for Thorn, go on epic missions under the command of Sixclaws, and become best friends with Qibli. It’s the perfect dragon life.
The sandwing your talking about is ghibli or thorn the rest? Neust non important dragon bc otherwise Sutherland would have given them a role in the story or something. Basically there are only 2 sandwings which are like the ones you described them being
Yes, that's perfect. I'd probably be either a SandWing, a SeaWing, or RainWing since my parents are from Jamaica. If I was SandWing, I'd choose this life too.
@@judovanviegen2786 Jerboa 1 2 and 3, the three sandwing sisters, Sunny, Vulture. Some slightly less important ones are Onyx, Palm, Prickle, Smolder, Sixclaws, Cobra, Dune.
It is so cool how the continents are shaped like dragons and how they are facing each other. I just noticed that while looking at the maps in the books.
I cannot describe the sheer wasted potential in Carnelian ._. Wings of Spirit on AO3 is a pretty good Carnelian-central fic that will never be finished
Hihi! I wondered if you'd prefer people to rate the queens in a 'Who is the best Queen of their tribe?' way, or in a 'I really enjoyed reading them' way. Since for characters like Scarlet it really swings one way or another depending on what I'm trying to rate 😅 Fun video as usual!
Yeah... the Mudwings don't have much of a spotlight... don't get me wrong, I love Cleril. But the fact Clay happens to be a Mudwing is irrelevant. And you put it absolutely right. Peril is just built different. As for the SandWings, you said it perfectly. Absolutely adore Jerboa. I tend to agree with her on the whole not socializing much part. And her backstory is... yeah. Like Peril, theres just a lot to unpack. I've spent way too much time thinking about how things would be different if she'd been spotted book 9, and also have Qibli find about about her book 10 and team up and bounce ideas and her freaking a little at finding out Glacier is dying, but beong utteely unable to do anything about it. Oh and Moon is freaking cute.
I’m hereeeeeee IM One of the FIRST Omg rainwings are like so good and they deserve their place SKY WINGS ARE UNDERRATED WWHHHAAAATTTTTTTT sky wings have religious rituals and everything! They have so many things about their tribe like how they have fire scales And how they beliven reincarnation They also cut off the animus blood line! Which was SMART but also sad But still I’m not surprised that leaf wings and sand wings got high! They are amazing tribes and so are rain wings My personal favorites are sky wings and sea wings
I love seeing your videos I'm glad I subscribed the first video I saw! I always voting for the tier list. I'm glad darkstalker was on the new tier list I rated him 10 out of ten ofc!
JMA i love your content and thank you because you are the first RUclipsr who has included my question and impute in your vids your great keep up the good work and I will definitely do the best queens thing
I actually find scavenger's a very interesting part to the plot. Its kind of dissapointing that everyone hates them so much. Whenever I talk to someone who doesn't like scavengers they alwasys say, "well I read wings of fire for the dragons not humans!" Like, really? So what if there not dragons there still a really interesting part of the plot. But noooo, since there not dragons they obviously are the WORST
Man I had no idea I was in such a minority but the "awww look at the little reading monkey I wanna keep them" might be my favorite dynamic for the entire series. Then again I am also the idiot scavenger who would be like "I bet I could make friends with that dragon, I just gonna get good at charades"
skywings are my personal favorite. they have key characters and drive the plot for several of the other tribes. scarlet was controversially the main villain in the first arc and ruby was vital to the academy in passive ways. scarlet contributed to the sandwing succession, entirely book 8, albatross' fiasco, and more
Just found this video, and I think either I have NightWing powers or dumb luck, because I started thinking during school. "Well JMA did the character ranking, what if he did a tribe ranking too?" I turn on my phone just now, and the notification for this video pops up. SOMEONE HELP ME!
I think Sandwings are a little overrated... they are fine but the only reason why the tribe is popular is because of the characers instead of the actual traits.
I disagree, personally I think that is what makes the sandwing tribe the best tribe, they have awesome characters and the abilities this tribes has makes they one of the most dangerous tribes. (Plus they have Qibli but he is in a league of his own).
i think the scavengers, while just being normal humans, are always very appalling. they had the bravery to steal dragon eggs and expect nothing from it- they sailed into the ocean, knowing nothing about whether they'd be trapped at sea or not after the scorching, and the fact that they're described to never be together by dragons, and are seen rarely, which is why dragons don't enjoy eating them- they haven't built up an appetite for them. they live in super cool, all unique societies- some underground with smart wingwatchers, hiding effortlessly from their biggest predators on pyrrhia, some not even living in societies- perhaps alone in an underground cave filled with the othermind- or maybe a whole other underground one on pantala, or some that live openly in towns and sacrifice their children to dragons so they'll spare them- or even a gigantic, walled, indestructible city that shoots fireballs at dragons, with a prince who wears dragon scales in pyrrhia- they're truly interesting and different than us- and it's extremely interesting. personally i wouldve given them an A at least.
I think RainWings deserve to win. :D And SandWings for second (Or tied for first, because I like them quite close). :D Edit: pretty happy about the results, my three favourite tribes got first equal. :D
My favorite part: Ahem Ahem QIBLI 😹 also the nightwings where under a erupting volcano with no food and got chased to that place out of terror and desperation they where forced to do the rainwing kidnapps and probably felt sorry for them ( a few nightwings tho not the whole tribe)
Bit of random here but I kinda wanna say what I think the best hybrid would be for an assassin or scary combatant. Hivewing/Rainwing, the reason being that if the hybrid got lucky with the genepool, they'd have like 3 or 4 ways to poison or melt someone. Cause Hivewings have their paralyzing venom, and Rainwings have their melty venom, imagine if the 2 combined. It would be like an irl tarantula's venom, paralytic flesh melting scary time but in a dragon dozens of times bigger than a person.
That’s cool how about another subject for the best hybrid? How about the weakest try just like ordinary hybrid no unique powers that have a chance of spawning in them
AYYYY THE TIER LISTS ARE BACK!! honestly I am not surprised about most of them, but mudwings definitely deserved better, and honestly, rainwings are a bit overrated but I agree nonetheless. I am so proud of the fan base of rating the leaf wings high though. Have a good day!
I really like the silkwings mainly just because theyre the only tribe with dragonets who arent born with wings. They're interesting and unique with that factor. Like actual butterflies but instead Dragons.
Can we get a tier list of what tribe you’d most want to be in? I think that would be cool. :) I’m also rereading all the wings of fire books and I’m already on book 7. :P
idk why im typing this but y does peril have a HUGE!!!! crush on clay like what if i was him i could not stand it btw can you make a video on relationships and clay and peril?
I think the scavengers deserve a direct sequel to dragonslayer mainly because I want to see more undauntable and wren I don’t hate on them that much except for a few certain parts in dragonslayer but I don’t really mind them they’re just kind of neutral for me
Sand wings and rain wings are my favorite tribes and I’ll never be able to choose between them. I rated the tribes and made sure those two got 10. Then I like sea wings and Ice wings the same, sky wings a little more than mud wings. I haven’t read the pantala books yet but from what I heard, I already love the three tribes. I need to finish Darkstalker legends then i can read the lost continent, etc.
NIGHTWINGS ARE UNDERRATED. They are probably the smartest of all the tribes, and their otherworldly powers are absolutely amazing and they have so much opportunity
I was fine with, and even enjoyed, the scavengers during the first and second arc, Dragonslayer, and even the beginning of arc three (The Dangerous Gift, meeting Wen and Sky). But then they became like, main plot points and fairly important characters and I was disappointed. I liked the idea of them having their own civilizations and stuff and even having an impact on the War of SandWing Succession but I really started reading Wings of Fire because it was the first dragon series where humans had very little effect on the dragons. I was very disappointed when Tui made them solely responsible for the Scorching.
It was always implied that humans caused the scorching. I predicted that they were also the cause of the othermind months before flames of hope came out.
I think the only tribe that didn’t deserve a+ was probably leafwings even though they are probably my 3rd favourite tribe because it was just carried by one of my favourite characters as well and that is partially true with the sand wings. Though they definitely could earn that spot if we had a little more time to explore both their cultures and even though we had 1 book for rain wings they are the coolest tribe with all their abilities. Other than that that is basically in order of which tribe I would be if I were in the wof world except that I would swap sandwings and leafwings. Regardless I love the video and keep making them :)
I agree, leafwings are extremely underdeveloped. I believe they are three key reasons why they are so popular despite that. First, they are the tribe that didn't submit to the hivewings and continued to survive for decades despite losing their home and being forced to live in the poison jungle. People simply admire their determination. Second, they like Sundew, which I don't get personally(I view her a far less interesting version of Tsunami).Third, Sundew is also the first main serie pov character to not be straight and that made the fanbase happy.
I pretty much agree with this tierlist (my favorites are Rainwings and my least favorites are mudwings/scavengers if they count) but i actually hate leafwings and love skywings, silkwings, and hivewings.Also icewings deserved the top tier
I hate how he’s like: we probably don’t like nightwings bc of the fact that they had a bunch of bad dragons in the first arc, I LOVE MORROWSEER, AND Fierceteech
I recently have been obsessed with rainwings, Nightwings and a new one, seawings! I've made a oc that their parents were a nightwing sea wing hybrid and a rainwing so I could get a character with all three >: ) But I love all tribes, some more than others(sorry mudwings) I'm so sad I was in D teir :(
Mudwings are underappreciated. They have an hour of underwater breathing, tanky scales, brute strength, they breath fire, and on top of that, a chance to have fireproof scales.
I agree! I think the only reason that they were put so low is their lack of representation throuout the series. If there were more books with mudwing pov characters the fandom would probably be much more loving of them. Book one was the only book with a main mudwing character, and that book focused mainly on worldbuilding and charachter development, rather than intricacies of the tribe. I personally would love to see the mudwings explored more with a Winglets or Legends novel.
@@medorasack6419 Me too! I always thought it was dissapointing how little we got to see of the Mud Kingdom. I would love to learn more about them
Fr
Yes! I love mudwings. They are one of my favorite tribes and don't deserve to be underrated especially with the first main protagonist being I don't know, cLaY?? I also wish we got more time with them though. Because we didn't really see the queen often at all. I feel that we should have another book starring one. (And kinkajou too lol)
5:34 Cricket singlehanded carried the HiveWing tribe to mid-B tier. She’s just that awesome.
Big fact.
Yes
Facts
Straight facts!
True.
Cricket is my favourite character. I bet if Cricket had powers HiveWings could get ranked higher.
And considering the only good HiveWing that we know has powers has fart powers, I think they got pretty good.
Sea wings: ‘Some really intriguing family drama’
Night wings: join the club
Anyone else find it ironic that we literally HATE our own species the most? As humans ourselves?
Perhaps it is because we are human that we hate them the most. We read about dragons to escape from who we are, from what we are, and we curse that which reminds us.
Or, you know, maybe we just don't like them because they can't fly hahaha :P
@@JadeMountainArchive yep. Sounds right. Humans? I see hundreds of them every day. Dragons? NOW you’ve got my attention!
It would mainly be because, people read the books to see dragons. That’s why a lot of people didn’t like the wings of fire book ‘DragonSlayers’
@@hyzmarie Exactly.
We see dragons almost NEVER.
lol that true
The thing about Silkwings is that they never had a chance to be anything. We know next to nothing about their history, their culture, and even their abilities. Flamesilk is something that Queen Wasp tried to hide, and back when Beetlewings were around, they were said to have even more abilities. After the tree wars, Silkwings were essentially stripped down to their name alone. Their ability to make silk was useful to Wasp, and later on their antennae were too. But they could never do anything more than that. Luna got swept in a silk parachute all the way to Phyrria, isn’t that cool? What if Silkwings before the tree wars often made parachutes for wingless dragonets or injured Silkwings? What if they had a language of their own that they spoke through vibrations on silk lofts like strumming a guitar? What if certain colours on Silkwings were rumoured to show your personality, kind of like zodiac signs. It could be said that green Silkwings were fierce and competitive, or yellow Silkwings were curious and creative. Blue Silkwings could be loyal and Loving or purple Silkwings could be adventurous and hard-working. What if they had beautiful forests of colourful trees, calligraphic silk art along the bark and branches. Flamesilk lanterns painstakingly crafted for ceremonial celebrations or holidays for Silkwings to whisper their greatest wishes into, before setting them free. There could be little doctors appointments for getting dragonets ready for their metamorphosis, and trying to calm the worries of those who were scared. Synchronized dances to form pictures with their wing patterns, hide and seek games where the seeker only uses their antennae, murals of stories weaved together with silk. But unfortunately all of this is a what if. The tragedy of the Silkwing tribe is that they don’t have that, nothing in their world was made for them. They have no way of finding out who they once were, what it means to be a Silkwing. They don’t get to weave tapestries of their stories, their homes or their happiness. Everything they make is a what if, a dream of a life they couldn’t achieve without tragedy.
Really interesting points! I love all the ideas about how they could have been - I'm making them my headcannons hahaha
God imagine an animated scene like the one from Rio 2 were a bunch of SilkWings dance and make patterns with their wings
@@CopperYeen YOOO THATS AN AWESOME IDEA
AWW YEAHH CAN'T WAIT TO BE BOTH DISSAPOINTED AND PROUD OF MY FANDOM!!!
I’m dying this is so accurate XDXD
lol, it's so true hahaha
AYE
Yea
lol tru
I may be a teensy bit obsessed with NightWings-
They’re just so cool with their powers and connections to the moons, and I’d ponder about their secrets all day if I could. What would happen if they were hatched on a blue moon? Or a super moon? Or a micro moon?
How long does it take for the egg to turn silver? Like, how long did Moon’s egg have to cook in the moonlight lol
What would mutated powers of the NightWings look like? Did other dragons have the same idea as Secretkeeper and hide their eggs too? Is there just a group of telepaths and seers running around the continent? If an egg wasn’t laid in the moonlight but still hatched in it, would it still have powers? Does it have to be the exact night of a full moon or can it be around that time? I could go on.
Btw, NightWings arguably have the most facial scales. They have the scales flat on top of their heads, scales right next to their snouts, silver teardrop scales for telepaths, and eyebrows.
So many egg questions, so little time! Definitely interesting questions.
I totally agree with you
I can just imagine Morrowseer and the other dragons frying and eating the ruined eggs. Fried eggs are delicious. If Secretkeeper actually ever has a cracked egg, let me know.
@@JadeMountainArchive You should make that into a vid
@@Pazzively-Aggrezzive oohhhh what a great video that would be!
Tbh SkyWings are just the classic dragons that’d you see in fantasy stories and medieval stories
-Red
-Big Wings and body
-Can breathe fire with no problem
-Fly very far
-And more
So SkyWings are just Classical Dragons basically with a few things added of course
True! They always felt the most basic to me. The flamescales are a cool addition, but it's so rare it almost doesn't count.
@@JadeMountainArchive ya that’s why they have a reserved spot in my favorites list since they are basically a nod to classical dragons
I thought the same thing when I first read the books! I didn't like them at first because they seemed basic and also grumpy, but for some reason I grew to kind of love them over time, and now they're the tribe I'm most personally attached to, aside from Rainwings
@@VictoriaToucan yeah lol
@@JadeMountainArchivein a fact video, courtesy of Bellasauras, it is true Skywings were based off traditional dragons. Mudwings were also based off Crocodiles, and sandwings scorpions. I forgot the others tho, sorry.
I honestly really like Dragonslayer! I usually don't like books with people as the main characters when set in a world like Wings Of Fire because I just didn't think they would be able to do it good but they really did in my opinion! I loved the boon and would love to see a second Dragonslayer book.
Dragon slayer is honestly really underrated. Having only 1 human based book in a dragon series is perfectly fine.
@@docfox4353 Same! I really want Dragonslayer 2! She wrote an epiloudge so I think it's coming!
@@ExploreTheWorldWithBri I know!!! Hyped!
Yeah idk why the fandom hates it smh
@@willowthewarriorwolf7153 well dragons are an escape and humans not so much, I mean, I see humans every day. Lots of them. But dragons? Now you have my attention.
I can't believe I was 1 out of the 1500 people who responded. It just amazes me how so many people like the thing I like! puts a smile on my face every time, keep up the great content JMA!!!
Sameee
I forgot to vote ahhhhhhhhh
lol same 😂
SkyWings have some religous things about them, they believe in reincarnation and this was proven in book 6 when they wanted to put Carnelian's body somewhere where she could be released to the sky so that she would be reincarnated as a SkyWing instead of another tribe. :D
I completely missed that!
@@JadeMountainArchive :)
isnt that a tiny bit racist
?
@@Wingedlizar ... Maybe. But they are SkyWings and they believe they're the best. So maybe just a little bit, but it's not mean to the other tribes or anything, it's just that they think they're the best.
@@Wingedlizar I’m pretty sure they do that to all dead SkyWings.
Cool, rain wings are my favorite tribe out of all of them and it’s nice to know that the fandom also loves them.
They're so pretty!
Agreed
I agree.
Same, RainWings are my favorite :D
Silkwings: Am I a joke to you?
7:07, I loved Dragonslayer, but here's the thing. They literally just took over book 14 and 15! This is, indeed, A dragon book series. not a human one.
I really wish we get more on silkwing culture before or during the tree wars. Just things like how did it play out, or what key events led up to monarch giving up the throne. Silkwings aren’t my favorite but I still want to know more about them.
If anyone wants to know, my fav tribe is sand wings. I just like the way their tribe was portrayed through the books and how the eye of onyx can choose anyone. Also thorns mentality towards being queen seems great to me.
(Edit) I could go much more into detail about sandwings or any other tribe, but I won’t because that would require a comment that takes you a while to read. (Like right now)
I wish the silkwings got to show off their powers a little more. So many cool things could be done with silk.
Spoiler:
The Flames of Hope could have been a good book for Sora and the MudWings. Sora could have easily learned the morale about vengeance killings in place of Luna.
That plotline would have fit surprisingly well into arc 3, oh my goodness.
@@JadeMountainArchive what a burnnnnnnn
I guess...But in what world would anyone allow Sora on the team? Even if she sneaks into the group to avoid having to interact with the icewing, skywing, rainwing and mudwing queens, remember that Qibli and Moon are part of the team.
As someone whose favorite tribe is MudWings, my disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined 😔
Tui really did them dirty smh.
Trueeee ^^^
Exactly.
Same
@@JadeMountainArchive Still holding onto the hope of getting a MudWing protagonist who's actually involved with their tribe...
Maybe one day 😮💨
Yeah same
If I could choose to be any dragon tribe in Wings Of Fire, I would be a SandWing. They’re clever, they know how to survive on rough circumstances, they’re always up for a good time, and they love music! They’re definitely my favorite tribe.
I already have my dragon life planned out for if that did happen: I would immediately travel to the Scorpion Den and become an Outclaw. That way I could proudly serve for Thorn, go on epic missions under the command of Sixclaws, and become best friends with Qibli. It’s the perfect dragon life.
The LeafWings and RainWings are also deserving of the top tier. This is a really good tier list.
The sandwing your talking about is ghibli or thorn the rest? Neust non important dragon bc otherwise Sutherland would have given them a role in the story or something. Basically there are only 2 sandwings which are like the ones you described them being
This is beautiful. I love this life idea.
Yes, that's perfect. I'd probably be either a SandWing, a SeaWing, or RainWing since my parents are from Jamaica. If I was SandWing, I'd choose this life too.
@@judovanviegen2786 Jerboa 1 2 and 3, the three sandwing sisters, Sunny, Vulture. Some slightly less important ones are Onyx, Palm, Prickle, Smolder, Sixclaws, Cobra, Dune.
I was almost expecting ice wings to be a little bit lower they are my favorite tribe though
icewings are my favorite tribe too
Mudwings are my personal favourite and I think their really underrated
Same
It is so cool how the continents are shaped like dragons and how they are facing each other. I just noticed that while looking at the maps in the books.
I cannot describe the sheer wasted potential in Carnelian ._. Wings of Spirit on AO3 is a pretty good Carnelian-central fic that will never be finished
I'll have to check it out!
wait it was fanfiction net not a03- darnit year old me
Hihi! I wondered if you'd prefer people to rate the queens in a 'Who is the best Queen of their tribe?' way, or in a 'I really enjoyed reading them' way. Since for characters like Scarlet it really swings one way or another depending on what I'm trying to rate 😅
Fun video as usual!
Glory is best and you can’t change that
Rate them however you feel is best! I like leaving the interpretation up to people and getting a mix of everyone's perspectives.
@@judovanviegen2786 I don’t like Glory TOO much
I'm only playing I'm just and addict once one way always one way
Yeah... the Mudwings don't have much of a spotlight... don't get me wrong, I love Cleril. But the fact Clay happens to be a Mudwing is irrelevant. And you put it absolutely right. Peril is just built different.
As for the SandWings, you said it perfectly. Absolutely adore Jerboa. I tend to agree with her on the whole not socializing much part. And her backstory is... yeah. Like Peril, theres just a lot to unpack.
I've spent way too much time thinking about how things would be different if she'd been spotted book 9, and also have Qibli find about about her book 10 and team up and bounce ideas and her freaking a little at finding out Glacier is dying, but beong utteely unable to do anything about it.
Oh and Moon is freaking cute.
I’m hereeeeeee IM One of the FIRST
Omg rainwings are like so good and they deserve their place
SKY WINGS ARE UNDERRATED WWHHHAAAATTTTTTTT
sky wings have religious rituals and everything! They have so many things about their tribe like how they have fire scales
And how they beliven reincarnation
They also cut off the animus blood line! Which was SMART but also sad
But still
I’m not surprised that leaf wings and sand wings got high! They are amazing tribes and so are rain wings
My personal favorites are sky wings and sea wings
I'm surprised to see LeafWings and SandWings get placed into the top tier. I was expecting IceWings and NightWings to be there instead lol
I love seeing your videos I'm glad I subscribed the first video I saw! I always voting for the tier list. I'm glad darkstalker was on the new tier list I rated him 10 out of ten ofc!
Darkstalker is one of my favorite characters along side qibli
Hahaha, it didn't feel right without him on it.
Just finninshed the queen tier list 😁
Mudwings deserved better, I think Rainwings are a bit overrated- but I love all the tribes apart from scavengers
Same
same
This guy gets it
Same
Ah yes, my favorite dragon tribe, *scavengers*
JMA i love your content and thank you because you are the first RUclipsr who has included my question and impute in your vids your great keep up the good work and I will definitely do the best queens thing
Glad I could do that! And thank you!!!
Wohooo! GO ICEWINGS! My Winter made 'em go up there...
I think the ice wings look the coolest
I actually find scavenger's a very interesting part to the plot. Its kind of dissapointing that everyone hates them so much. Whenever I talk to someone who doesn't like scavengers they alwasys say, "well I read wings of fire for the dragons not humans!" Like, really? So what if there not dragons there still a really interesting part of the plot. But noooo, since there not dragons they obviously are the WORST
It's not cuz they're not dragons, it's cuz they make pretty much ruin stuff, lol.
They were literlly the ones who caused the SandWing war
Literally*
@@estrellaraldama1710 um yeah? Your point being?
@Snowberry, oh i don't have a point just saying, I do find kinda silly how we humans, hate the humans in the wof books tho
We should appreciate scavengers more without them sky would be dead and winter would be boring
Man I had no idea I was in such a minority but the "awww look at the little reading monkey I wanna keep them" might be my favorite dynamic for the entire series.
Then again I am also the idiot scavenger who would be like "I bet I could make friends with that dragon, I just gonna get good at charades"
Glory: we’re not calling it magic death spit
WOF fandom: oh, yes we are
Leafwing, rainwing, and skywing gotta be my fav tribes, maybe just cuz i like aerodynamic dragons over big bulky ones
Woah I’m surprised the icewings got so high, not that I’m complaining though! Great video as always JMA
another epic video, good job, man.
Thanks :)
skywings are my personal favorite. they have key characters and drive the plot for several of the other tribes. scarlet was controversially the main villain in the first arc and ruby was vital to the academy in passive ways. scarlet contributed to the sandwing succession, entirely book 8, albatross' fiasco, and more
SO EXCITED TO WATCH!
Early ish keep up the good work buddy you really make some good funny content!
Oh my gosh yeees! Thank you for all your hard work on these tier lists!
JMA: with there magic death spit
Glory: we are NOT calling it that!
Just found this video, and I think either I have NightWing powers or dumb luck, because I started thinking during school. "Well JMA did the character ranking, what if he did a tribe ranking too?" I turn on my phone just now, and the notification for this video pops up.
SOMEONE HELP ME!
No. no. This is a good thing. Just don't go Darkstalker on us and we'll be fine!
Right... And what comes next? "I asked (xyz) people to rate every wings of fire book"? "I asked (xyz) to rate every Arc"?
I think Sandwings are a little overrated... they are fine but the only reason why the tribe is popular is because of the characers instead of the actual traits.
I disagree, personally I think that is what makes the sandwing tribe the best tribe, they have awesome characters and the abilities this tribes has makes they one of the most dangerous tribes. (Plus they have Qibli but he is in a league of his own).
same goes with rainwings, theyre literally only loved because of glory
i think the scavengers, while just being normal humans, are always very appalling. they had the bravery to steal dragon eggs and expect nothing from it- they sailed into the ocean, knowing nothing about whether they'd be trapped at sea or not after the scorching, and the fact that they're described to never be together by dragons, and are seen rarely, which is why dragons don't enjoy eating them- they haven't built up an appetite for them. they live in super cool, all unique societies- some underground with smart wingwatchers, hiding effortlessly from their biggest predators on pyrrhia, some not even living in societies- perhaps alone in an underground cave filled with the othermind- or maybe a whole other underground one on pantala, or some that live openly in towns and sacrifice their children to dragons so they'll spare them- or even a gigantic, walled, indestructible city that shoots fireballs at dragons, with a prince who wears dragon scales in pyrrhia- they're truly interesting and different than us- and it's extremely interesting. personally i wouldve given them an A at least.
Thank you for making these videos :)
I think RainWings deserve to win. :D And SandWings for second (Or tied for first, because I like them quite close). :D
Edit: pretty happy about the results, my three favourite tribes got first equal. :D
Hello Luna the goat :D
@@Sharkdragon4129 Hello! :D
Nice!
Same!
1:52 “We’re not calling it magical death spit” -Glory
Nice! And one of the first!
my favorite tribes are the rainwings, the seawings, and the nightwings
they're pretty cool
same
Hmmm I wonder where mudwings will rank???????????????????????????????????????????????
NOOO ITS C
Oof.
@@JadeMountainArchive lol
My favorite part: Ahem Ahem QIBLI 😹 also the nightwings where under a erupting volcano with no food and got chased to that place out of terror and desperation they where forced to do the rainwing kidnapps and probably felt sorry for them ( a few nightwings tho not the whole tribe)
Bit of random here but I kinda wanna say what I think the best hybrid would be for an assassin or scary combatant. Hivewing/Rainwing, the reason being that if the hybrid got lucky with the genepool, they'd have like 3 or 4 ways to poison or melt someone. Cause Hivewings have their paralyzing venom, and Rainwings have their melty venom, imagine if the 2 combined. It would be like an irl tarantula's venom, paralytic flesh melting scary time but in a dragon dozens of times bigger than a person.
That’s cool how about another subject for the best hybrid? How about the weakest try just like ordinary hybrid no unique powers that have a chance of spawning in them
Sigh… I voted 10 for scavengers
You and about 150 others - unfortunately over 450 people rated them 1/10 hahaha
Wow 😂
I love Rainwings, they are my favourites so I’m glad they got A+! I hope Tui makes more Rainwing POV books
Camo scales. Magical death spit. Let’s be honest, if the RainWings wanted to, they could murder all the other tribes.
Yep. All they have to do is turn invisible, seek in the, say the sanding, kingdom, and spary them with magic death spit
You know this actually really good nice man
This is my, awfully weird s-tier.
S. Skywings Silkwings
A+. Hivewings Sandwings
A. Leafwings Icewings.
B. Seawings
C. Mudwings
D. Rainwings Nightwings
11 missed calls from Jade Mountain Archives
1:52 and their *magic death spit* I can imagine glory just yelling at you
AYYYY THE TIER LISTS ARE BACK!! honestly I am not surprised about most of them, but mudwings definitely deserved better, and honestly, rainwings are a bit overrated but I agree nonetheless. I am so proud of the fan base of rating the leaf wings high though. Have a good day!
Now do a tier list on all the different human tribes💀💀💀
I voted in the thingo, btw, this was an amazing video! Your uploads make my day! :)
I'm glad you enjoy the content!
@@JadeMountainArchive omg! Thanks!
bro i remember when you had under 500 subs how did you grow so fast
A couple of videos exploded so that helped a lot :)
You should do a ranked dragons in specific tribes. Like seawings. Or rainwings. A tribe who gets a lot of fans but for specific characters.
That's a really good idea!
I really like the silkwings mainly just because theyre the only tribe with dragonets who arent born with wings. They're interesting and unique with that factor. Like actual butterflies but instead Dragons.
I liseted to your this video while doing the queens tier-list lol
I love these videos
Wings of Fire fanbase: This is Snoodoo, hurt Snoodoo and I will hurt you
lol
I, personally, think that Scavengers should be higher. Purely because of Wren. Wren was my favorite character (Scavenger-wise, at least)
I feel like they should get a book of each tribe, mostly so mudwings can go up!
Can we get a tier list of what tribe you’d most want to be in? I think that would be cool. :)
I’m also rereading all the wings of fire books and I’m already on book 7. :P
Nice! And that idea could be gooooood!
@@JadeMountainArchive :D
idk why im typing this but y does peril have a HUGE!!!! crush on clay like what if i was him i could not stand it btw can you make a video on relationships and clay and peril?
Maybe!
What if... Qibli had taken the deal with Darkstalker?🤔
Now, that is an interesting question indeed.
I think the scavengers deserve a direct sequel to dragonslayer mainly because I want to see more undauntable and wren I don’t hate on them that much except for a few certain parts in dragonslayer but I don’t really mind them they’re just kind of neutral for me
LMAO 6:47 I love this part. Thank you for making me laugh
Haha, I'm glad you liked that joke!
I believe skywings might be based off of medieval european society.
I love your videos so much they are so enjoyable I just love them thank you so much
I'm glad you enjoy the content!
"magic death spit" 1:53
Before he said Qibli, I'm like, "no way he forgot". And then when he said "Qibli!" I'm just like "Phew!"
Mud wing are underrated please someone tell tui to give mud wings the spot light i need ittt
You could probably rank the scavengers too. Pretty sure Wren would be at the top, though.
Awesome vid
Sand wings and rain wings are my favorite tribes and I’ll never be able to choose between them. I rated the tribes and made sure those two got 10. Then I like sea wings and Ice wings the same, sky wings a little more than mud wings. I haven’t read the pantala books yet but from what I heard, I already love the three tribes. I need to finish Darkstalker legends then i can read the lost continent, etc.
NIGHTWINGS ARE UNDERRATED. They are probably the smartest of all the tribes, and their otherworldly powers are absolutely amazing and they have so much opportunity
Can you rated tribe powers in a video such as Rainwing Venom, Sandwing tail barb ect.?Your amazing have a great day thank you bye!
Thanks for giving me the shout-out! :3
No, thank YOU for supporting the channel all this time!
@@JadeMountainArchive You're welcome Turtle! ;3
Rainwings , Sandwings and Leafwings are my fav tribes , they have such interesting characteristics , history's , powers and are very pretty in my eyes
I was fine with, and even enjoyed, the scavengers during the first and second arc, Dragonslayer, and even the beginning of arc three (The Dangerous Gift, meeting Wen and Sky). But then they became like, main plot points and fairly important characters and I was disappointed. I liked the idea of them having their own civilizations and stuff and even having an impact on the War of SandWing Succession but I really started reading Wings of Fire because it was the first dragon series where humans had very little effect on the dragons. I was very disappointed when Tui made them solely responsible for the Scorching.
It was always implied that humans caused the scorching. I predicted that they were also the cause of the othermind months before flames of hope came out.
Our NightWings are(no hybrids included) :
1.Starflight
2.Moon
3.Deathbringer
4.Fierceteeth
5.Clearsight
6.Foeslayer,
And(I guess)
7. Seceretkeeper
I love how we’re hating on ourselves
I love your vids! Scavengers are my least fav (except wren) and icewings, leafwings, and rainwings are my favorite.
Wren is pretty great.
I think the only tribe that didn’t deserve a+ was probably leafwings even though they are probably my 3rd favourite tribe because it was just carried by one of my favourite characters as well and that is partially true with the sand wings. Though they definitely could earn that spot if we had a little more time to explore both their cultures and even though we had 1 book for rain wings they are the coolest tribe with all their abilities. Other than that that is basically in order of which tribe I would be if I were in the wof world except that I would swap sandwings and leafwings. Regardless I love the video and keep making them :)
I agree, leafwings are extremely underdeveloped. I believe they are three key reasons why they are so popular despite that. First, they are the tribe that didn't submit to the hivewings and continued to survive for decades despite losing their home and being forced to live in the poison jungle. People simply admire their determination. Second, they like Sundew, which I don't get personally(I view her a far less interesting version of Tsunami).Third, Sundew is also the first main serie pov character to not be straight and that made the fanbase happy.
It’s funny that we call it magic death spit when glory hates it when you call it that
Get off my bed, Pikachu or parol mean like 7000 people who come knocking at your door with a gun
I pretty much agree with this tierlist (my favorites are Rainwings and my least favorites are mudwings/scavengers if they count) but i actually hate leafwings and love skywings, silkwings, and hivewings.Also icewings deserved the top tier
I think this was a really good representation of the tribes. I’m happy to see that most people have the same opinion as me.
There was no reason to diss my man Blue like that
I hate how he’s like: we probably don’t like nightwings bc of the fact that they had a bunch of bad dragons in the first arc, I LOVE MORROWSEER, AND Fierceteech
I recently have been obsessed with rainwings, Nightwings and a new one, seawings! I've made a oc that their parents were a nightwing sea wing hybrid and a rainwing so I could get a character with all three >: ) But I love all tribes, some more than others(sorry mudwings) I'm so sad I was in D teir :(
Hahahaha, we're all in D tier together so at least there's that.
HiveWings were a bit underrated in this one. But as for LeafWings, heck yeah! Snoodoo forever!!