14:00 this would be really cool but how could a federation mixed between monarchies and 2 republics (technically even Veneto) work? As a system Germany's imperial one with an emperor full of kingdoms loyal makes much more sense too I absolutely love the concept btw
Why would Russia collapse in revolution and civil war if in this Timelapse they don’t loose the war , also if they joined Germany in the war would mean that Russia and Germany would have good relations since it’s unification so Russia could push for modernization and better strands why revolution ?
This is great video, btw: 29:57 Why would Russia have civil war if they literally won war by having Consantinopole and control over Turkey, even interestingly their economy will sky roket as they are in alliance with strongest economy in continental Europe and controling whole central and eastern Europe. That means maybe revolution like decembrist or just little bigger revolution crushed by Russian army. Tsar will do its reforms and everyone happy. 17:30 In Vojvodina and Banat, historically referred to as Vojvodina, Serbs predominantly resided. I believe they might rebel and seek support from Russia, potentially joining forces with Hungary in a revolution. This could also involve Croats from beyond Krajina, leading to one of two possibilities: 1. The creation of a Yugoslavia that includes Croatia, the Duchy of Serbia, and Bulgaria. 2. The emergence of three strong states: Hungary, Serbia, and Bulgaria, with each expanding territorially. Could you create a video exploring the scenario of "What if Mihajlo Obrenović's Union of South Slavs succeeded?" It would be fascinating because his vision treated all Slavs equally while emphasizing Serbia's role as a major unifier. If this had happened, it could have given Russia total dominance in the Balkans and Anatolia. Maybe even make World War 1 far early? This could make an interesting video due to its complication with British and Germany with Ottomans.
18:57 while the central Austrian state wouldn't be able to do anything in bohemia, there is a massive German population in bohemia they demanded the central Austrians and the Czechs dissolve historical borders and create an official separation of German areas in bohemia from Czech ones with their own autonomy. The german bohemians even sent representatives to frankfurt. There is no way the Czechs would get their demands of autonomy without the german-bohemians getting theirs too as the germans controled all the major cities and industry, and the strategic mountains. Even Prague was majority german in 1848. And if they were denied their autonomy they would contest the Czechs' and this would give thr central Austrians the ability to crush both one way or another (like in the OTL). Plus to have a complete reversal of the orginal 1848's outcomes the german bohemians need to get their demands accepted too.
Small question: You note the uprisings in Ireland in 1848 in the intro, but we hear nothing about what happens to Eire in this revision; was that by choice?
Russia going through a revolution is a stretch. Historically a big reason for the revolution was being largely cutt off from trade combined with failures on the frontline combined with the government refusing to end the war. They didn't have these problems here, their trade partners in this timeline would be mainly Germany rather than France which they are not cut off from. Their main weakness being a lack of equipment for their troops is also not an issue here. They had complete success in their theatres and any lack of advancement elsewhere has easy blame shitting totheir allies. And ofcaurse they are part of the victorious powers. They gained greater Armenia and I don't see why they wouldn't also gain territory in central Asia.
They didn't really talk about colonies, I assume colonies were also exchanged (African ones for germany and probably Hungary, and central Asian ones for Russia) They also didn't mention how this affects japan and thus the far East.
The video was not realistic because making most of the revolutions in 1848 happen all together is unlikely and also all of this events occurring at the same time would radically butterfly away events and replace them with unintentional ones as well as changing the mind of people living at that time It is easier to make a realistic video if you focus on just the success of one of the revolutions and for a shorter period of time However the video was really entertaining for me and I'm optimistic for the continuation of this story HAVE A GOOD TIME 😁❤
Why would the Bohemians leave? They didn't want independence, much like the slovaks, they thoyght they were best guarded by the empire itself from the tyranny of the majority.
Indeed. There was 1848 nationalist demands in bohemia. Both the Czechs and the bohemians germans wanted greater autonomy (the later not just for bohemia from Vienna but also for the german majority areas from from bohemia itself) a reversal of 1848 outcomes is not bohemian independence but bohemian and 'sudeten' autonomy within the empire.
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
u r underrated dude, this production is insane
Aye another great Alternate scenario from le underrated creator
Si vis pacem para bellum, NUSIA!!
@@The1Gen ;-;
Happy 4K subscriberssss
🎉 Catching up to you!
@@TheCrazyHistorian Ya think 😉
We need a part 2 asap.
Hey I know this guy
Can't say I know you. Are you sure?
No you don’t
@NibanoTransmontano they must because if not this video would not exist
@Aq_3i'm shocked
@NibanoTransmontano not my problem i guess....
Austria got hella screwded up
Love your content ! Happy 4k subs😊😊😊😊
This needs a part 2.
PART 2 PLEASE, YOU AND DEAN ARE UNDERRATED
14:00 this would be really cool but how could a federation mixed between monarchies and 2 republics (technically even Veneto) work? As a system Germany's imperial one with an emperor full of kingdoms loyal makes much more sense too I absolutely love the concept btw
Nice
Congrats for 4 k
Very interesting and high quality Video you deserve much more attention!
Nice video, especially seeing two of my favourite alternate historians collaborate
Superb
Why would Russia collapse in revolution and civil war if in this Timelapse they don’t loose the war , also if they joined Germany in the war would mean that Russia and Germany would have good relations since it’s unification so Russia could push for modernization and better strands why revolution ?
In russia many unhappy people are coming Home to russia and they have guns.After the war
This is great video, btw:
29:57 Why would Russia have civil war if they literally won war by having Consantinopole and control over Turkey, even interestingly their economy will sky roket as they are in alliance with strongest economy in continental Europe and controling whole central and eastern Europe. That means maybe revolution like decembrist or just little bigger revolution crushed by Russian army. Tsar will do its reforms and everyone happy.
17:30 In Vojvodina and Banat, historically referred to as Vojvodina, Serbs predominantly resided. I believe they might rebel and seek support from Russia, potentially joining forces with Hungary in a revolution. This could also involve Croats from beyond Krajina, leading to one of two possibilities:
1. The creation of a Yugoslavia that includes Croatia, the Duchy of Serbia, and Bulgaria.
2. The emergence of three strong states: Hungary, Serbia, and Bulgaria, with each expanding territorially.
Could you create a video exploring the scenario of "What if Mihajlo Obrenović's Union of South Slavs succeeded?" It would be fascinating because his vision treated all Slavs equally while emphasizing Serbia's role as a major unifier. If this had happened, it could have given Russia total dominance in the Balkans and Anatolia. Maybe even make World War 1 far early?
This could make an interesting video due to its complication with British and Germany with Ottomans.
Simple the serf peasents and semi middle class, they won't be happy still if there farms and rural regions are not improved.
@@eidoneverchoosen1171 It would be, propaganda is doing its job.
This comment deserves more likes.
Based timeline
Bros only been here for 6 months yet already has 4k, I’ve been here for almost 2 YEARS and still only have 640
He’s making me jealous😭😭
Be better or never go up.
Ok fine I will give you a shot I’m now subscribed to you
same
part 2 is needed
Part 2 please
Madness!
18:57 while the central Austrian state wouldn't be able to do anything in bohemia, there is a massive German population in bohemia they demanded the central Austrians and the Czechs dissolve historical borders and create an official separation of German areas in bohemia from Czech ones with their own autonomy. The german bohemians even sent representatives to frankfurt.
There is no way the Czechs would get their demands of autonomy without the german-bohemians getting theirs too as the germans controled all the major cities and industry, and the strategic mountains. Even Prague was majority german in 1848. And if they were denied their autonomy they would contest the Czechs' and this would give thr central Austrians the ability to crush both one way or another (like in the OTL). Plus to have a complete reversal of the orginal 1848's outcomes the german bohemians need to get their demands accepted too.
Epic colab!
Small question: You note the uprisings in Ireland in 1848 in the intro, but we hear nothing about what happens to Eire in this revision; was that by choice?
part 2 when?
🔥
Nice video
23:00 is that what I think it is?
🤫
here's a comment, don't know why just wanted to help the Algor rhythm
7:47 is this Vic3 political groups i see?
Btw both are in my government in my current playthrough, but im not good at all
Not sponsered
Russia going through a revolution is a stretch.
Historically a big reason for the revolution was being largely cutt off from trade combined with failures on the frontline combined with the government refusing to end the war.
They didn't have these problems here, their trade partners in this timeline would be mainly Germany rather than France which they are not cut off from. Their main weakness being a lack of equipment for their troops is also not an issue here. They had complete success in their theatres and any lack of advancement elsewhere has easy blame shitting totheir allies.
And ofcaurse they are part of the victorious powers. They gained greater Armenia and I don't see why they wouldn't also gain territory in central Asia.
In Austria, didn't the Slovaks also have a revolution but eventually sided with the government against the Hungarians?
Your voices are surprisingly similar
What if Portugal didn’t attack The whole world 💀
Why did Russia gain little? Would they not have received extensive territory in Central Asia from Britain?
They didn't really talk about colonies, I assume colonies were also exchanged (African ones for germany and probably Hungary, and central Asian ones for Russia)
They also didn't mention how this affects japan and thus the far East.
For the Algorythm
*Balgorythm
The video was not realistic because making most of the revolutions in 1848 happen all together is unlikely and also all of this events occurring at the same time would radically butterfly away events and replace them with unintentional ones as well as changing the mind of people living at that time
It is easier to make a realistic video if you focus on just the success of one of the revolutions and for a shorter period of time
However the video was really entertaining for me and I'm optimistic for the continuation of this story
HAVE A GOOD TIME 😁❤
Someone need to make HOI4 mod out of this scenario... NOW!
PART 2
Would make a good HOI4 mod ngl
Why the hell would Russia accept that treaty???? They got nothing like bruh
Why would the Bohemians leave? They didn't want independence, much like the slovaks, they thoyght they were best guarded by the empire itself from the tyranny of the majority.
Indeed. There was 1848 nationalist demands in bohemia. Both the Czechs and the bohemians germans wanted greater autonomy (the later not just for bohemia from Vienna but also for the german majority areas from from bohemia itself) a reversal of 1848 outcomes is not bohemian independence but bohemian and 'sudeten' autonomy within the empire.
@@matthiuskoenig3378 But also the Slovak Regiment having more of an impact. Suggesting Slovakia should remain with Austiria.
yessir
this feels like it was made by a lib or a hungarian, love the content though
CROATIA-SLAVONIA
Russia wont collapse in this timeline
w
K
E