GOYO: ANG BATANG HENERAL I PART 8 OF 9 I Paulo Avelino I Jerrold Tarog I TBA Studios
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 апр 2024
- With this film (the second war trilogy set during the Filipino-American war in the early 1900s), the revolution marches on against the Americans after the bloody death of General Antonio Luna. The conflicted philosophies behind the heroic struggle continue and become personified in the colorful character of General Gregorio “Goyo” del Pilar.
Directed by : Jerrold Tarog
Starring : Paulo Avelino, Art Acuña, Alvin Anson, Epy Quizon,
Mon Confiado, Empress Schuck, Gwen Zamora, Rafa Siguion-Reyna, Carlo Aquino, Arron Villaflor
Subscribe to TBA Studios RUclips channel: bit.ly/TBAStudios
Visit our Official Website: www.tba.ph
Connect with us in our Social Media Accounts:
Facebook: / tbastudiosph
Instagram: / tbastudiosph
Twitter: / tbastudiosph
#ProudlyTBA 
Развлечения
i like how both sides act like real soldiers, most films have that generic american suicide charge just to be cinematic, but this does actual military tactics pretty well.
US films don't usually have suicide charges.
@@FloofyMinarifix bayonets that was in the Patriot, was and we were soldiers, Glory, Gettysburg, gods and generals, does there to name a few of when Americans fixed bayonets and they basically a suicide charge into enemy gunfire
@@Darth_Traitorous fixing bayonets was a legitimate tactic though, not to mention historically accurate.
It's rather unfair to cite Gettysburg/Glory and the Patriot since thats literally how people fought in the 19th and 17th century.
We were soldiers was based on real events where US Marines did fix bayonets as they were outnumbered and overwhelmed.
@@FloofyMinari it's shown in movies of something that we the viewer do not have the ability to time travel and see for ourselves. Also Japan did the bayonet charge they called it banzai which is a death charge because they died a lot from that. The idea of bayonet charges was to terrify your enemy. Bayonet Hill in South Korea was named after a colonel who would continuously fix bayonets until the US government told him not to terrify the Chinese. Because he read from a leaflet that the Chinese believed that Americans were wusses because they were not fixing bayonets and fighting like they used to and he did and prove them deadly wrong
Kung gagawin iyan ng mga sundalo sa totoong buhay, eh maraming mamamatay sa kanila.
I really liked how intelligent both sides are. First time seeing this, I fully expected the Americans to immediately bayonet charge just to be cinematic. But I'm pleasantly surprised.
Hindi naman sila reckless para sumugod.
This blew my mind.
The Philipinos had such perfect positioning and then the US marines patiently re-strategized and outflanked them taking the high ground.
I remember briefly learning about this in school but this really brings it home. Both sides fought valiantly and in truly in their own fashion. We’re such good allies now it’s hard to believe that we were ever enemies.
Interms of tactic we win also but the Filipino in the past has no unity. Either the cabinet of the meeting in past they want to kneel because of economic.thats why it was perfect why Luna die there is no peace and freedom in our country. We are just blind to see the truth
С такими союзниками и врагов не надо
Pretty sure those were Spanish soldiers.
US Army.
@@Psalm144.1 if they’re Army in the vid, that’s a historical inaccuracy. They were Marines, my man.
Ito rin ang naapreciate ko sa movie na 'to, detalyado yung ginawang taktika ang mga kapwa natin Pilipino at ng mga Amerikano, parang nandoon ka rin sa mismong giyera kasi pinakita sa'yo yung dinanas ng mga characters.
At walang bida at kontrabida sa movie na ito.
@@MichelNey1813 Oo, kaya mas maappreciate mo kasi taong-tao ang portrayal sa mga characters na may mga flawed moments, mas nagkaroon ng buhay ang mga bayaning nababasa lang natin noon sa textbooks.
@@MegaBendell Yung moment na nagmalfunction ang riple ng isang sundalo at dumampot ng bato
Realistic yung sa rifle kasi nung araw kahit nung Napoleonic at American Civil War may tendency talaga na malfunction or "jam" ang rifle kahit sa WW1 and 2 nawala lang yang problema na yan pag introduce ng auto weapons
@@jomareyd.parreno5112correction lang, nag mamalfunction o nag ja jam pa rin yung mga automatic rifle depende sa klema tulad ng mga unang version ng m16 rifle na prone sa jamming noong kasag sagan ng Vietnam war. O di kaya ay hindi maayos ang iyong pagkalinis sa baril kaya mag jam.
As a Filipino. It's more often than historical perspectives because the philippines have been involved in American colonization when Spain is allowed to receive the Philippine island by American after Spanish-American war.
Nakakalungkot lang talaga na natatalo tayo dito pero ganito talaga kasaysayan natin kung di lang talaga namatay siguro si Heneral Luna at ng mga ibang bayani tulad niya
tapos pag natalo iniiba ang pangalan no. mang gogoyo. o isda tulad ng lapu lapu. sinu kaya ng imbento nyan??
Tama nakakalungkot. Pero kung nanalo tayo isipin mo na lang yung "morale" na mabibigay sa atin bilang bansa. May magiging proud tayo maging Pilipino. Napatalsik na natin mga Kastila at natalo pa natin ang Amerika. Napatunayan sana natin sa mundo na may lugar tayo sa araw bilang malakas at matapang na bansa.
Pero wala na tayong maggawa. Nangyari na ang nangyari. Hindi na nstin maiiba ang kasaysayan.
Ang tangi na lamang nating maaaring gawin ay tiyaking hindi na mauulit ang masalimuot nating kasaysayan.
Kaya SAY YES TO ROTC 🪖
Mapapangalagaan lamang natin ang ating kasarinlan kasangkapan ang matalino, matapang at masinsinang pagsasanay upang depensahan ang ating bansa.
Mabuhay ang Lupang Hinirang!
I mean kung iisipin mo rin, dehado sila sa specific na laban ng pasong Tirad. 60 na Filipino laban sa nasa 300 na mga Amerikano ayon sa Wikipedia. Masmarami ding bala ang mga amerikano at mapagdedebatihan na masmagandang gamit.
@@vilecreature5801 hinding hindi tayo mananalo dahil sa buong kasaysayan ng pinas merong mga taksil na pilipino walang pag kakaisa
@@ConanAnimeRecap At Isa na nga sa mga dahilan kung bakit maraming taksil sa bansang to, kasi nga mababa ang "morale" natin bilang bansa, kasi nga wala tayong naipagmamalaki sa nakaraan natin na pwede nating panghugutan para pagbutihin ang hinaharap.
Pero tayo talo.
Talo sa Espanya.
Talo sa Amerika.
Talo sa Japan.
Nakakahiya ang kasaysayan natin. Yung ang nagpapababa ng "morale" natin. Kaya iba nating kababayan nagpapakaAmerikano nalang o nagpapakaHapon o nagpapakaKoreano dahil wala ka naman kasing maipagmamalaki sa bansang to eh
I hope they will push for more Bayani Cinematic Universe in their own version. I would want them to finish Quezon's movie and maybe it's high time to do a remake of Jose Rizal with a twist and that includes those that haven't been shown in the old films and his human side.
1:26 what a lucky throw 😂
Yeah fr
0:05 Some audiences may or may not noticed this detail, the 33rd Infantry were doing the *rebel yell* when they're charging up the hill.
Yep that was an unintended side effect of the wars between the civil war and ww2. Northerners and southerners were fighting on the same side again and it helped heal the scars of the civil war
@@tomaslopez2940
Didn’t do much for civil rights. The “heal the wounds” was propaganda, and incidentally one reason the US declared war on Spain. You’re getting your history from comic books!
@@TheBabashee Not a reason at all seems your History is coming from 21st century woke; Civil Rights is a term about BLACKS AND WHITES NOT NORTH AND SOUTH; Ignorance of the woke is just unbelievable;
ang makakatalo sa ating filipino ay kapwa filipino din
Panarap ko ay maging isang ring bayani kaya maduuuuhay
Pensé que era una película sobre la revolución mexicana pero me di cuenta que era de Filipinas. Empecé a investigar más y me sorprendió la similitud en la forma de vestir de los revolucionarios filipinos con los revolucionarios de México. Ellos son muy similares.
Me parece interesante esta historia 💪
Because of his brother Juan Luna the painter he create the symbol of military uniform to the Philippines that time. He wants unite to the army of other region in Philippines
Filipinas formó parte del Virreinato de Nueva España hasta 1815. Hubo mucho contacto cultural y económico entre México y Filipinas
I love this movie
The Americans "soldiers" should have been armed with the M1895 "Potato Digger" machine gun, but I understand they don't have the budget nor the donors to have it on the set.
I think if either side had artillery, the battle would have been a lot quicker
Well... Most of the potato diggers are Naval Guns, meaning they have been used in the Movie (check the coast scene in the initial invasion scene). And they were notoriously unreliable, so outside of the navy... They wouldn't have been used
Lupet ng riffle ni goyo
Winchester ang baril niya
Today in our times I love that the US and the Philippines are allies with a history to include being enemies at one point. Much respect from the USA to our Filipino friends, may we strengthen our bond as time goes on.
The Philippine Republic died at Tirad Pass. Long live the Republic.
Napakaganda ng TERRAIN Defense nila, aabot yan ng ilang buwan, kaso ang hindi alam ni Heneral Goyo ay may iba pang ruta na masisira ang kanilang depensa. Gayunpaman, dinepensa nila ang kanilang lugar hanggang sa huli.
Nanalo rin sila dahil may guide ung mga americano.
Sana gumawa ulit sila movie tungkol kay macario sakay...
Mas maigi yung story naman ni Leon Kilat.
oo, kasi siya ang huling katipunero
O kaya si Miguel Malvar.
O ky kay Luciano San Miguel
Ang ganda ng movie nakaka miss
madali man lunukin bilang sustensya sa kaunlaran. mihirap naman tangapin and mga sinapit ng mga tanyag na bayani ng ating kasaysayan.
I just really want the Castilian War Movie it would be cool
Counties with a history of colonizing by conquest; England, France, Portugal, Spain, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, China, America. Maybe I missed a couple but you get the picture. Interesting America is the only one colonized and then turned colonizer.
Really good movie.
การต่อสู้เพื่อชาติของชาวฟิลิปปินส์ภาพยนตร์เรื่องนี้หาดูได้ยากมากครับผมรู้สึกโชคดีที่ประเทศไทย🇹🇭สามารถเจรจาด้านการทูตได้ดีมิฉะนั้นคงต้องพบกับความลำบากเช่นชาวฟิลิปปินส์ในภาพยนตร์
1:20 no way he hit that shot
素晴らしいフィリピン😊
Magaling pa rin na heneral si heneral Luna,
Kahit maraming talo pero panalo sya sa taktika
@@CervantesBlog14he lost lol with those tactics too, best general goes to Cailles
@@apollovakarian7472cailles betrayed his former comrade like malvar to the Americans
maganda yung representasyon at moralidad ng bawat panig. sa gyera, sa mata ng sundalo walang mali sa pagtupad ng utos. mali man sila pero sa kabilang panig pareho rin ang pananaw nila.
Movie sana tungkol kay Simeon Ola ang huling heneral na sumuko sa mga Americano
As an Albayano, I would be very proud kung meron
Si Miguel Malvar yung kahulihulihang Heneral na sumuko sa mga Amerikano
I need to see y'all doing something like this for 1941-1942. It would be cool to see what y'all would do with say the actions of the Philippine Scouts.
10:55 at least he didn’t commit a war crime bro has heart
War between American and Filipinos taught two things ; one change the Krag rIfles to use Spanish Mauser , w/c developed to the Springfield Mauser, and dump the 1878 Gatling in favor of Maxim Hiram Machine gun. In one encounter Filipino soldiers who used a couple of Maxim machine guns against the Americans . It happened with the British vs the Boers, having the Maxim machine gun .
Support for Philipinos from Italy
Muy entretenida la película, pero el ejercito de Estados Unidos cometió graves atrocidades contra los civiles filipinos. Se calcula que hubo sobre un millón de muertos, sale algo de esto en la pelicula ?
1:25 tinamaan ba naman ng bato HAHAHAHAHAHA
10:34 tumambling HAHAHHAHAHHA
American : we love freedom
The freedom :
Kung walang nagturo ng sekretong daan sa likod,hndi sna matatalo....tsk...
Siguro manalo tayo sa labanan nato pero matatalo parin sa giyera
Matatalo parin Tayo dahil kulang kulang na Ang kagamitan pagkain at bala
❤
olé o Cangaceiro
The casualties for this battle was so lopsided! Total American Victory!
I wish they continues Luna's gorilla fortress
From what I've read and researched, this was Heneral Luna's tactic against the imperialist Americans if he had lived and built his planned fortress north of Luzon. He knew he can't defeat the Americans head on what with their superior numbers and technology.
Therefore he wanted to wage a war of attrition against the Americans and with the Philippines' strategic locations and impenetrable terrain of mountains and forests he would constantly harass the American military for years until it would become very costly for the Americans to hold the entirety of Luzon. His plan would involved inciting civil unrest back on American soil so that their Congress is forced to withdraw American forces in the Philippines by referendum of the American public.
It is akin to how the Vietnamese were successful in repelling any and all of their adversaries be it the Chinese or Western Imperialist powers during the Vietnam War.
He had it all planned out too. Training sharpshooters to target high valued military personnel and conducting night time raids against American camps. Building his fortress in the mountains of Cordillera to withstand long and costly sieges against American forces.
Had Luna lived to carry out his plans, who knows if it would be successful. Though, knowing Luna's insane genius and tactical acumen, it would have been a very long and bloody war for the Americans to even contend with him and the entire Philippine army.
That was a different age. Losing men doesn’t get them to give up back then. Much like the Zulu and the british, losing men would just incite more rage against the audacity of the savages
@@5678sothourn true that and Luna may still lose against the Americans but who knows, maybe he'll stall for time. Maybe he's hoping that the Filipino leadership would finally stop their squabbles and provide the much needed support the Philippine Military needs.
Luna could also take the mantle by a coup, instill martial law and make alliances with the militarist Imperial Japan and gain external support. But that's just what we did with the Spaniards. We kicked out a colonial power just so we could invite an even bigger and more powerful one.
And besides, if we had been a satellite state of Japan, we would be on the losing side of the biggest war in the history of mankind. So yeah in a sad kind of sense I suppose Luna losing still poses a positive spin on Philippine politics.
Saan yung source sa fortress sa luzon? Never heard of it to be fair
@@apollovakarian7472 the source I had was mostly from the film "Heneral Luna" which was thoroughly researched btw and was considered historically accurate by most. It's also a really great film and was considered decent even by western standards.
And now were doing Balikatan Military Exercise with eachother
Kung wala lang naging guide ang mga Amerikano, naiba malaman ang history ng Pilpinas kasi nakakalamang sa laban ang mga sundalo ni Heneral Del Pilar, isang malaking what if.
true
Matatalo pa rin sila Goyo pero maraming Amerikano ang patay at sugatan kung wala silang guide.
@@cashewnuttel9054 What ifs usually have facts in common, so that's an unlikely what if because the US has more allies than the other powerful countries do.
Here is a better what if, and a far more interesting one than any what ifs you can think of: what if the Philippine had remained under US rule?
@@cashewnuttel9054 Unlikely what if. What ifs have to be believable.
They already have the upperhand but... Meron parin talaga traydor.
Kulang sa disiplina ang mga sundalo noon kaya yan, tinarayduran sila
Dahil din kasi sa diskriminasyon nila sa mga Igorot kaya sila natalo sa laban.
@@MichelNey1813 It was Goyo's shortcoming as a leader that the guides were entrusted by his officers to ordinary soldiers who treated the guides badly and caused them to leave. It was Goyo's 2nd in command, Col. Enriquez (Carlo Aquino) who left the guides with another officer, who then left them with non officers. The guides were so important and yet they were passed down as if they didn't matter.
@@MichelNey1813 oh I see thanks for the info kaya pala binigay nila information sa mga amerikano
9:08 dont move! "wait! shoots anyways
dito mo makikita kung gaano nag struggle ang grupo ni goyo sa mga amerikano (poor generalship) at yung mga naging lapses nila like hindi nila gaanong nasuyod yung terrain na pwde silang ma outflank at yung hindi sia nag ingat nang balaan nang aide nia na minamanman na sia nang mga snipers
Pilipino lang 🎉🎉🎉
Goyo is like victor from the LinLang
Philippines 🤝 Brazilian Cangaço
Guerrilla Tactics with
fancy hats
kung hindi lang dahil ki galut di yan makaka pasok HAHA
6:29 bat natamaan si Lt Garcia sa dibdib? Namatay ba siya sa Battle of Tirad Pass? Sana masagot
Binaril siya ng sharpshooter kaya siya tinamaan sa dibdib at namatay. Wala po siya sa labanan ng Tirad Pass sa katunayan.
@@pauldee7504at wala na tayong balita sa kanya pagkatapos pinatay si Luna.
Omg
Bilib na ako sa bato haha
0:39 What rifle is that? Thats a nice looking rifle.
Krag Jørgensen 1898
Movie name?
kahit dati pa, may bida bida talagang pinoy ahaha,, binenta kapwa pinoy ahaha
If u watched the whole movie, ung nag turo ng daan na umakayat sa bundok ay Yan mismo ang hinarass ng mga Pilipinong sundalo. Kung naging pantay lang sana trato nila sa bawat Pilipino, walang traydor na mangyayare
One of America's worst mistakes.
España fue reemplazada en la Filipinas por la nueva potencia imperialista: EEUU.
Los filipinos lucharon por su indepencencia armados de machetes y fusiles Mauser españoles.
Ce qu'elle film svp
I was watching in queue for a bit and i thought they were Mexican
3:58 lol
американские солдаты очень точно стреляют.
13:26 another use of the low port carry 100 years too early.
farb hahahaha
10:44 may pinakabat kaysa kay goyo🤣🤣🤣
Philippine history is full of treachery yun ang masakit na katotohanan
pano tinuro ba naman 🤦♀🤦♀🤦♀🤦♀
Di Djadjah Spanyol kok malah bangga
May Winchester pala si Goyo?
Mauser
@@jeremiahmontejo9625 eh ba't hawak niya yung Winchester sa eksena na yan?
@@jeremiahmontejo9625 kung Mauser yan eh dapat bolt action yan, di katulad ng Winchester na lever action.
@@MichelNey1813 mauser ang dapat dala ni goyo kung susundan ang historicity ng panahon niya. Kung sa realistic wala dapat siyang riple kasi opisyal siya ang trabaho niya ay magmando ng sundalo at magplano ng taktika.
@@jeremiahmontejo9625 pwede na rin.
Lets roll out men? Not the best line considering the year.
Wagons and early cars were a thing, but "saddle up" would have been better.
Ben futbol oyunları bıraktı
Soldiers acting like soldiers? What is this?
A question : Why do some Philippino soldiers have red fabic on the straw hat? Is it meant to be symbollic (like military unit or something else)?
It's called cockade. It acts like unit identifier but nowadays we use arm unit patch.
This is the phillipines war wuth usa they had a truce after the war
Today usa is a big help to phillipinez
Some ant bit his balls😂
Is this fake or real😮
It's real
Bakit nmn putol2 yung pag release? Pangit niyo ka bonding TBA. Hindi nmn kayo gnyan mag release dati
They tried uploading the whole movie, pero pangit kabonding ng RUclips. Yung mismong uploader at creator ng movie, na-copyright ng RUclips
One sided as hell tbh
И тут без предателя постуха не как.