The Big Fight: Will Science be able to define God?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 фев 2025
  • Physicists say the potential discovery of the "God particle" was a gateway to a new era that could see humanity unlock some of the universe's great mysteries including dark matter. In the backdrop of the discovery of the Higgs Boson, on this episode of The Big Fight, we discuss God, science and the universe.
    Watch full show: www.ndtv.com/vi...

Комментарии • 2,3 тыс.

  • @chetanjadhav9730
    @chetanjadhav9730 5 лет назад +936

    This is how Educated people do debate. Simply Beautiful!!!

    • @namanchauhan4916
      @namanchauhan4916 5 лет назад +21

      Yes poor joe😂😂

    • @anamikakhan593
      @anamikakhan593 5 лет назад +9

      @@namanchauhan4916 joe can make a really good meme content 🤣👌

    • @saptarshibose3234
      @saptarshibose3234 5 лет назад +2

      It was so beautiful and healthy conversation

    • @Katappa_Mama
      @Katappa_Mama 5 лет назад +5

      All men in the conversation were highly reputed and simple . Varna machi bazar ban jata hai jaise news channel pe banta hai 😂😂😂😂

    • @bhargobbhattacharjee1606
      @bhargobbhattacharjee1606 5 лет назад

      @@namanchauhan4916 joe🤣🤣

  • @yomaddy
    @yomaddy 7 лет назад +739

    This doesn't looks like a debate. Those 6 jems are aligned to their conclusions beautifully and support each others. The fight was only fighting that anchor alone lol.

    • @mohsinmannan2463
      @mohsinmannan2463 5 лет назад +6

      Maddy Be it's not debate just discussing with out point nobody proves theyer spiritual matter with since only AL Quran can give properly answer

    • @aniket19931993
      @aniket19931993 5 лет назад +2

      Maddy Be yes...truly intelligent beings dont fight

    • @adad-ec6ht
      @adad-ec6ht 5 лет назад

      No gem box is complete without Dr Zakir Naik. These are amateurs.

    • @Praveenkumar-xz8rt
      @Praveenkumar-xz8rt 5 лет назад +8

      @@adad-ec6ht cause he gives illogical theories.....

    • @adad-ec6ht
      @adad-ec6ht 5 лет назад

      @@Praveenkumar-xz8rtAll theories are illogical? Which one is illogical?

  • @abhishekkhandelwal3582
    @abhishekkhandelwal3582 5 лет назад +72

    Ramakrishna mission has true leaders in spiritual and secular fields. Good to see Swami Atmapriyananda here.

  • @zainshaikh23
    @zainshaikh23 5 лет назад +521

    7 years later and Sadhguru still looks the same.

  • @Aslan9er
    @Aslan9er 6 лет назад +251

    vivekanand monk was awesome. he knew what he was talking about.

    • @neojohns2487
      @neojohns2487 6 лет назад +18

      Lohar he tought physics(particle physics)for 20 years...monks of Ramakrishna Order are of high quality

    • @yourlandlord6374
      @yourlandlord6374 6 лет назад +11

      HIGGS BOSON---SN BOSE. The man is from land of Bose. He knows his business.😁

    • @neojohns2487
      @neojohns2487 6 лет назад +2

      Your Landlord
      no idea of Higgs Boson was theorize by professor Higgs.
      For example Photon is also kind of Boson.

    • @yourlandlord6374
      @yourlandlord6374 6 лет назад +4

      @@neojohns2487 I know that genius. I was referring to BOSON (BOSE EINSTEIN CONDENSATE)

    • @neojohns2487
      @neojohns2487 6 лет назад

      Your Landlord Bose Einstine condensate is just a state of a matter genious(like at around absolute zero all the atoms of a gas behaves like one single quatum system). Bosons are those particle, which follows Bose Einstine statistics(as their spin(which is quantum number) is zero)

  • @JMenglish
    @JMenglish 6 лет назад +536

    Swami Atmapriyananda is a true blending of spirituality and science.

    • @sunildharan2968
      @sunildharan2968 6 лет назад +6

      Swami atmapriyanda

    • @neojohns2487
      @neojohns2487 6 лет назад +20

      Yeah he is...monk like him reminds us, becomning a monk is not easy business and it is not everybody's cup of tea.
      As per Vivekananda, Monk has to study hard everyday. As contribution of the monk in the society, is to give teachings.

    • @JMenglish
      @JMenglish 6 лет назад +18

      @@neojohns2487 Right.... A true monk is not ignorant to the world around him , rather true knowledge sets him free from this transient world.

    • @rajdeeppaul333
      @rajdeeppaul333 5 лет назад +2

      where does he blend? he specifically spotted the distinction between those..

    • @shuvojitraychaudhuri8751
      @shuvojitraychaudhuri8751 5 лет назад

      @vikas chaudary why do we need to bring up religion?

  • @hrishabhbhardwaj5676
    @hrishabhbhardwaj5676 6 лет назад +612

    Sadhguru seems impressed by swami atmapriyananda
    I also found his explanation best...

    • @neojohns2487
      @neojohns2487 6 лет назад +30

      Please don't mind as I can understand Sadguru is your dear guru, but I think monks of Ramkrishna Math does not care(to be very frank, he is not even close to monk, as per Ramakrishna Math's standard)
      It is very difficalut to even become a monk. First thing is joinging the order, and after that it takes 8 years for one to became monk.

    • @raghavanv9977
      @raghavanv9977 6 лет назад +5

      @@neojohns2487 appreciate your acharya bhakthi

    • @siddharthroy189
      @siddharthroy189 6 лет назад +33

      @@neojohns2487 It is inappropriate to compare . The monks of Ram krishna order are gnyan yogis, they are on the path of intellect . Sadhguru is kriya yogi on the path of dhyana meditation . The paths are different.

    • @samtora1043
      @samtora1043 5 лет назад +10

      I only care about truth.. Not somebody opinion.. Fortunately I listen to only sadhguru.. The rest sorry.. Not my jnterest

    • @amulyadhal5227
      @amulyadhal5227 5 лет назад +4

      I found both are telling the same. Both are telling spirituality and science should stay apart

  • @excelcorporation391
    @excelcorporation391 8 лет назад +1651

    if zakir naik was here, he would have started with chapter number 1 2 3 ...verses 4 6 7 ...this and that.... just imagine if zakir naik becomes a chief of NASA or ISRO...he would start chapter number 5 7 8 verses 12 55 34 ..ok now you launch your mission to moon or Jupiter etc .... ;)

  • @kartikfu1700
    @kartikfu1700 6 лет назад +124

    swami atmpriyananda and sadhguru ! love

    • @neojohns2487
      @neojohns2487 6 лет назад +2

      Kartik FU yeah, Swamy was fully aware about what he is speaking, and Sadguru have no idea what he is speaking.

    • @kartikfu1700
      @kartikfu1700 6 лет назад +7

      Shut the fhook up john

    • @neojohns2487
      @neojohns2487 6 лет назад

      @@kartikfu1700 "Bhakt" the hindu Fundamentalist spoted..

    • @kartikfu1700
      @kartikfu1700 6 лет назад +9

      Jesus wont like your behavior, john

    • @shounaksaha2838
      @shounaksaha2838 5 лет назад +2

      once i liked sadhguru, after watching this video.

  • @manojpawar6785
    @manojpawar6785 5 лет назад +139

    Swami Atmpriyanda is himself a scientist.
    He has done his P.hd in physics.
    He has got profound knowledge of this universe.

    • @thyagarajant.r.3256
      @thyagarajant.r.3256 3 года назад +1

      Yes,he didhis ph.d in A.C.Collegeof technology,Guindy,chennai

  • @conscious3714
    @conscious3714 6 лет назад +281

    Out of all five prominent participants Swami Atmpriyanand spoke brilliantly !

  • @fatelvis6924
    @fatelvis6924 7 лет назад +591

    Swami Atmapriyananda's explanation was the best

    • @neojohns2487
      @neojohns2487 6 лет назад +35

      abc yeah, he is a particle physicist and vedantist, he holds a cordial command on Buddhism and Shunnyata(best explanetion available in the internet. Like no rubish, straight to the point)

    • @surajsontakke4629
      @surajsontakke4629 6 лет назад +15

      I've had the opportunity to meet him in person. TRUE!!!

    • @shyanroy1532
      @shyanroy1532 6 лет назад +5

      @@surajsontakke4629 lucky man.... 😊

    • @amitk7042
      @amitk7042 6 лет назад +4

      Swami atmapriyananda rocks

    • @Rk.751
      @Rk.751 5 лет назад

      chutiya

  • @pragnayadav
    @pragnayadav 7 лет назад +3711

    Who is here for Sadguru

  • @jphande77
    @jphande77 6 лет назад +365

    I used to like sadgurus debate. But here I liked Swamy athmapriyanand.

    • @Rish0716
      @Rish0716 5 лет назад +18

      Yep search about other missionaries of Ramkrishna math 🙏.. Ocean of wise ppl u will get ..Also do read about swami Vivekananda (founder of Ramkrishna math)..The philosophy of Vedanta explained very well by them❣️🤘

    • @fluxfine5503
      @fluxfine5503 5 лет назад +1

      same here

    • @shounaksaha2838
      @shounaksaha2838 5 лет назад +7

      I liked Swamy athmapriyanand's silence. Because God and vedanta can't be explained in 46 minutes.

    • @Rish0716
      @Rish0716 5 лет назад +3

      @@shounaksaha2838 yeahh very well said bro🙏💯

    • @slayerizzed
      @slayerizzed 5 лет назад

      ditto.

  • @lightningbolt4560
    @lightningbolt4560 4 года назад +60

    The host called it the BIG FIGHT, yet how calm and disciplined is each and everyone of them
    Two reasons
    1. They are well educated and knowledgeable
    2. It's not a meaningless topic, you can't speak anything rubbish about it, it's high level stuff like boson particals, matter creation, addition of masses.
    You can manipulate dumb crowd but not a group of high intellectuals by talking nonsense.
    It's looks so nice and organized unlike debates and discussons on TV these days.

    • @kaizen_monk
      @kaizen_monk 4 года назад +1

      Godi media has ruined the tv debates

    • @adityapalsingh2473
      @adityapalsingh2473 3 года назад

      Because it's a spiritual debate.....its not any political debate

    • @ravimoodley7486
      @ravimoodley7486 3 года назад

      It would have been the "Big Fight" if a representative from the "other religion" was invited..

  • @GopalRaju
    @GopalRaju 6 лет назад +162

    appreciable....his intellect, knowledge, way of presentation & simplicity. never like to miss his any video....i gain a lot.....thanks
    guru ji

  • @amarnathsinha163
    @amarnathsinha163 3 года назад +16

    Swami Atmapriyananda is on different level of Science & Spirituality ❤️

  • @shadows4419
    @shadows4419 5 лет назад +148

    Hand up , i am here for Sadhguru !

  • @Faazthetruthseeker
    @Faazthetruthseeker 3 года назад +93

    The interesting thing I understood from watching this is Sadguru's thought level is higher than our mind can even think about.. Actually Sadguru is trying hard to come to the level of other people to converse and explain in simple way..

    • @LIFE-fq9kv
      @LIFE-fq9kv 3 года назад +5

      Rightly said I would recommend you to take Sadhguru exclusive from Sadhguru app.
      I am 💯 sure it will be your most valuable investment

    • @Executor8
      @Executor8 3 года назад

      @@ssddkar3577 where is this audio available?

    • @cyanjam6116
      @cyanjam6116 3 года назад +4

      Yeah most people are dumb like you anyway...so it ain't hard for gurus like him to deceive mass public

    • @Faazthetruthseeker
      @Faazthetruthseeker 3 года назад +4

      @@cyanjam6116 I understood what Sadguru said..so in your opinion Sadguru is dumb?? Try to read and understand what I wrote above first..

    • @relaxingmindfoodandmma5108
      @relaxingmindfoodandmma5108 3 года назад

      DON'T LISTEN TO THESE IDIOTS. LISTEN TO FRANK TUREK.

  • @IIEthanGamingII
    @IIEthanGamingII 5 лет назад +256

    Y’all clicked for sadhguru. I clicked for Swami atmapriyananda 😂🖤

  • @iyohaisado7293
    @iyohaisado7293 5 лет назад +58

    Why i believe Sadhguru so much is that there are so many things he is saying that i know by myself already without hearing it from someone or any books he has makes me believe in myself 100% he is the best sence of human i have ever come across in my life.

    • @shuvojitraychaudhuri8751
      @shuvojitraychaudhuri8751 5 лет назад +6

      Which means that you have not met enough scholars.

    • @atheismistheway581
      @atheismistheway581 3 года назад +3

      @@shuvojitraychaudhuri8751 😂😂😂😂 pseudoscience is reaching new heights these days

    • @premamyname4300
      @premamyname4300 2 года назад

      @@atheismistheway581 and so Called modern Wikipedia Atheists/scholars are busy and desperate in proving themselves they are scientists. Lo! We don't need Atheists help to understand science. Improve youse first.

    • @atheismistheway581
      @atheismistheway581 2 года назад

      @@premamyname4300 get yourself an english teacher first ...we can take it from there ...fight the argument not the person ...

    • @venktesh6600
      @venktesh6600 Год назад

      people who can't define themselves debating on science defining god sounds ironical. Jaggi especially lot of videos are there how fake that man was media still buy him..

  • @nandans2506
    @nandans2506 5 лет назад +34

    Swami atmapriyananda doesn't get his science from religion... He is one of the very few who actually knows what he is talking about.... Often people just try to confuse others... I am an atheist but i respect him for this

    • @KapilSharma-qt3xo
      @KapilSharma-qt3xo 5 лет назад

      But he knows vedic is itself a science but leave that just enjoy

  • @TheRicokilla
    @TheRicokilla 7 лет назад +117

    If zakir was here, he would put the Muslims to shame.

    • @GameMedinsights
      @GameMedinsights 6 лет назад +6

      Sorry for this
      QURAN COMPLETELY EXPLAINS HOW UNIVERSE WAS CREATED
      that is why they have no Muslim expert there
      They know Quran has the answers

    • @MrPhysicist
      @MrPhysicist 5 лет назад +20

      @@GameMedinsights muslims 1000 sal hua peda huye hein..they have no history likw u

    • @unknown-sz9yg
      @unknown-sz9yg 4 года назад +27

      If Zakir Naik take part in this program , Allah said in Quran, chapter no 20,Verse no 420 , " when the holy month is over, then if any idol worshiper is found ,then cut them in little partical in the name of Allah , it's called God particle 😂😂😂😂

    • @flowerinthewild-x5u
      @flowerinthewild-x5u 4 года назад +9

      If kalam was there we would have heard a lot of beautiful thoughts ❤

    • @flowerinthewild-x5u
      @flowerinthewild-x5u 4 года назад +2

      @@GameMedinsights no

  • @youthindian1593
    @youthindian1593 5 лет назад +14

    Ramakrishna Mission is Great all-time...

  • @gbibhav
    @gbibhav 6 лет назад +46

    Beautiful debate we need more like this , I liked all the intellectual thoughts 💭 most moving for me was by RKM Swami ji

  • @Owlbe
    @Owlbe 8 лет назад +439

    If Zakir naik was here: He would started saying Chapter number 30 surah (***) according to Qur** this is sin and we would og to hell if we deny the god...Take Shahada to go for heaven :)

  • @vaibhavkumar8133
    @vaibhavkumar8133 5 лет назад +93

    I have to say Swami atmapriyananda excelled here

    • @Sincerelycec_Official
      @Sincerelycec_Official 5 лет назад +6

      whole vedanta society from ramakrishna order are divine check out savapriyananda

  • @mesinjana
    @mesinjana 5 лет назад +41

    Belur Math Ramkrishna Mission has some great mathematicians and physicists as monks. Swami Vivekananda himself was a genius in academics and a cynic in his childhood who used to questions everything. Probably that's the spirit that runs within the organization. They do some great work at Grassroot level but couldn't commercialize it the way "art of living" or Sadhguru does.

    • @gautambuddha8815
      @gautambuddha8815 3 года назад +3

      It's actually good they don't seek to commercialize

    • @vishwa1767
      @vishwa1767 2 года назад +1

      They are not business men like the other two and it is a conscious choice to remain that way.

    • @RaksLife
      @RaksLife 2 года назад

      half knowledge is dangerous...

  • @shubhradipta3728
    @shubhradipta3728 5 лет назад +21

    Each and Every Monk of Ramakrishna mission is a treasure of knowledge....they don't come into limelight like Sadhguru and works silently that's it.

  • @VivekaVani
    @VivekaVani 5 лет назад +1

    Swami Atmapriyananda gave the most logical answer.

  • @abzeekhan4398
    @abzeekhan4398 5 лет назад +20

    Brother asked a very good question! 😂

  • @learntospeakenglishlearnto9819
    @learntospeakenglishlearnto9819 5 лет назад +11

    Best answer by Swami ji.

  • @manishdebnath1258
    @manishdebnath1258 5 лет назад +11

    Ramkrishna mission Swamiji is the best among all the speaker. He is true scientist and spiritual seeker.

  • @rudrashankarghoshroy1607
    @rudrashankarghoshroy1607 6 лет назад +6

    Look at the body language and gesture of sadhguru at introduction, so warm and welcoming. Beautiful human being

  • @symphony12399
    @symphony12399 4 года назад +9

    Ur presence sadhguru make me feel calm no matter where ever u are....lots of love and respect....

    • @arefinhoosain654
      @arefinhoosain654 2 года назад

      Why Sadguruji don't like to talk or debate with international Islamic scolers including Zakir Naik?
      Is he (Sadguru) thinking about Sri Sri Ravi Shankar's condition in the debate event?
      It shows his weakness.

  • @saurabhjain9785
    @saurabhjain9785 5 лет назад +8

    Such intelligence,such mannerism and such calmness all together.

  • @KapilSharma-qt3xo
    @KapilSharma-qt3xo 5 лет назад +8

    Deep knowledge of science and dharma will lead you to the same thought and logics. Swami ji is the one example here.

  • @nitinjadhav7676
    @nitinjadhav7676 4 года назад +5

    Hope these types of discussion held everywhere !

  • @prateiksharma9007
    @prateiksharma9007 5 лет назад +9

    Satguru looks so excited that it can finalize the debate all by itself

  • @vivekmohanrajoriya15
    @vivekmohanrajoriya15 3 года назад +1

    This is when,you don't have any significant news.

  • @arkadeepghosh1649
    @arkadeepghosh1649 3 года назад +14

    Sadhguruji and swami atmapriyananda ji explained the main thing ❤️

    • @arefinhoosain654
      @arefinhoosain654 2 года назад +1

      Why Sadguruji don't like to talk or debate with international Islamic scolers including Zakir Naik?
      Is he (Sadguru) thinking about Sri Sri Ravi Shankar's condition in the debate event?
      It shows his weakness.

    • @yourstrulytk12
      @yourstrulytk12 10 месяцев назад

      ​@@arefinhoosain654
      Please don't compare the textbook guy (he who beleives) with he who knows.

    • @arefinhoosain654
      @arefinhoosain654 10 месяцев назад

      ​@@yourstrulytk12
      From the dialogue with Sadhguru and Javed Akhter, it is proved Sadhguru is believer in Hinduism and Javed Akhter is an atheist.
      But he didn’t like to expose himself as a Hindu. Because from the result of the dialogue with Shree Shree Rabi Shankar and Dr. Zakir Naik he realised that now a days it's not possible to stand with Hinduism.
      So Sadhguru falsely introduces himself as a seeker.

    • @yourstrulytk12
      @yourstrulytk12 10 месяцев назад

      @@arefinhoosain654
      No. Sadhguru is not a seeker.
      Sadhguru is he who knows.
      We are seekers.
      The sadhakas.
      We can argue on philosophy and all other nonsense forever but what will that get us? Better use our time wisely. (Do sadhana)

  • @dakaarys8424
    @dakaarys8424 6 лет назад +18

    Science = defining the world objectively.
    Religion = defining the world subjectively.
    *You cannot compare E=mc^2 and "Aham bhrahmasmi"*

    • @neojohns2487
      @neojohns2487 6 лет назад +2

      DaKaaRYS yeah both are looking at two different things(if they converge, they will)
      Even before Einstine, Nichola Tesla tried to establishes the relationship between mass and energy but he died before completing his work.
      Physics is trying to difine a model through which working of the physical universe can be explained.
      Many people do not know this, Tesla was a great admirer of Vivekananda. They used write letters to each other, where Vivekananda used provide the input about Indian philosophy. Even Tesla used term like "Akasha" and "Prana" in his notes(as unlike the Idea of Space, "Akasha" has some property)
      But Vivekananda no where in his letter or in any of his writtings mentioned he tought physics to Tesla.

    • @dakaarys8424
      @dakaarys8424 6 лет назад

      @tilak raj ???

  • @vishalvishal-ym7gb
    @vishalvishal-ym7gb 4 года назад +24

    Swami Atmapriyananda maharaj is simply amazing!!!!A great thinker!!!He stands "head and shoulders" above Sadhguru!!!!

    • @rajat_music
      @rajat_music 3 года назад +4

      But he himself looks upto Sadhguru in whole discussion.

  • @AA-xd8dp
    @AA-xd8dp 6 лет назад +61

    Paadri has surrendered in his first sentence, he knows that he following an idiotic idea of West Asia.

    • @roshanchaudhary9522
      @roshanchaudhary9522 4 года назад +1

      Anchor already knew that he would blundred the all debate thats why he was not invited

  • @dr.ashwinikumarnigam7953
    @dr.ashwinikumarnigam7953 6 лет назад +30

    The one who can be defined, cannot be GOD

    • @learnersense7446
      @learnersense7446 5 лет назад +2

      As a Muslim we know only about the qualities of Allah and his commands , neither His form, location etc.

    • @adwaitvedant3297
      @adwaitvedant3297 4 года назад +6

      @@learnersense7446 God is formless

    • @samippoudel1235
      @samippoudel1235 4 года назад +5

      @@learnersense7446 yes, but some commands could be completely unsuitable after long time (centuries) . Just don't believe to that extent that you become blind to know what is practical or completely unsuitable now. If this sense is in human beings, then no religion is ugly.

    • @arnabroychoudhury8064
      @arnabroychoudhury8064 4 года назад

      True.

  • @LionEntity
    @LionEntity 11 лет назад +41

    Sadhguru loved what the Sociologist had to say at the end :D I love when he laughs like that vibrating in every way hahahah

    • @the.cosmic.archive
      @the.cosmic.archive 5 лет назад

      That was not the end. Watch the full video through the link given in the description.

  • @rahulgholap4658
    @rahulgholap4658 6 лет назад +10

    Sadgurijee is only one among panelist who joined hands. thats the message at the beginning.

    • @utjoker8180
      @utjoker8180 5 лет назад +1

      Swami atmapriyananda also

  • @changa3012
    @changa3012 6 лет назад +19

    Sadguru started on a wrong assumption. Actually, God Particle has nothing to do with the existence of God. Thanks.

  • @RaghuveerUPL
    @RaghuveerUPL 3 года назад +2

    Anchor is humble and good in knowledge which related to science and spirituality,I think so.

  • @AmolPatil-xu9og
    @AmolPatil-xu9og 5 лет назад +2

    The best debate i have ever seen.
    Thanks NDTV

  • @gamegal1090
    @gamegal1090 4 года назад +3

    Sadguruh and Swami Atmapriyananda are the best spokesmen among them.
    Very good and well mannered show.

  • @shuvayandutta4519
    @shuvayandutta4519 5 лет назад +2

    This kind of topic used be discussed in media in 7 years back and what we are discussing now. God save us.

  • @MalkeetSingh-fm4kx
    @MalkeetSingh-fm4kx 3 года назад +4

    The most interesting perspective, according to me, was of Shiv Vishwanathan.
    It’s true that the misnomer created a headline and got interjected into our society leading to a much wider audience and hence creating interest not only in scientists and the scientific community but to other diverse groups as well.

  • @shafisaqib
    @shafisaqib 4 года назад

    The fact that people here are talking about someone who is not even present in this debate nor is he concerned by any means implies what a great influence he has put on their minds.

  • @isaacmayen4596
    @isaacmayen4596 4 года назад +5

    From South Sudan, any video involving Sadhguru is what I normally watch

  • @AB-ux5pp
    @AB-ux5pp 6 лет назад +21

    The name of the particle they are talking about was actually 'Goddamn particle'. But this name didn't go very well so they changed it to God particle.

    • @mohithraslana3838
      @mohithraslana3838 6 лет назад +1

      🤣🤣that was hilarious

    • @neojohns2487
      @neojohns2487 6 лет назад +2

      Yes, publisher thought that would be very catchy.

    • @WouldIwasShookspeared
      @WouldIwasShookspeared 3 года назад +1

      yeah i already know. no no not because I did research on it. IT WAS SAID IN THE VIDEO

  • @victordemelofernandes1815
    @victordemelofernandes1815 5 лет назад +16

    THERE IS NO CONFLICT BETWEEN SCIENCE AND GOD. GOD IS THE AUTHOR OF SCIENCE.

    • @neojohns2487
      @neojohns2487 5 лет назад +2

      And god does not exist

    • @victordemelofernandes1815
      @victordemelofernandes1815 5 лет назад +2

      @@neojohns2487 when you see different species of butterflies,animals etc with different designs, how can you say there is no intelligent designer? Look at you in the mirror, you are a product of that intelligent design. You are a beautiful creation. Don't believe the lies of satan. Satan too exists. God says in the bible "before I formed you I knew you. I have seen you in your mother's womb". This is an intelligent and awesome God you have to believe. God says further without faith it is impossible to please him. Faith is the substance of things hoped for the evidence of things not seen. Science has different realms. One of them is spiritual realm. God is spirit. Worship God in TRUTH and spirit. Jesus says IAM THE WAY, TRUTH AND LIFE. NO ONE COMES TO GOD BUT BY ME. ONLY BELIEVE, YOU AND YOUR FAMILY WILL BE SAVED FROM ETERNAL DAMNATION.

    • @adarshv.s6437
      @adarshv.s6437 5 лет назад

      what an incredibly stupid comment 🙄😒

    • @adarshv.s6437
      @adarshv.s6437 5 лет назад

      @@victordemelofernandes1815 babble...more babble....😁😁😁

    • @buntmaszyn3358
      @buntmaszyn3358 3 года назад

      @@neojohns2487 What if big bang was His job ? (-;

  • @thebhaskarrajput
    @thebhaskarrajput 5 лет назад +3

    Little science takes you away from God, but more of it brings you closer to it.

  • @themagician191
    @themagician191 5 лет назад +41

    Love sadhguru looks like he could burst into laughter at any time

    • @shuvojitraychaudhuri8751
      @shuvojitraychaudhuri8751 5 лет назад +1

      Yeah
      That happens when you sit with people whose conversation makes no sense to you.
      Like a lost kid.
      And you have a typo in your comment.
      I think you meant to write this:
      "he could burst into tears at any time"

    • @drmanitkumar1889
      @drmanitkumar1889 5 лет назад +2

      @@shuvojitraychaudhuri8751 Make sure you wear Gloves while shaking hands.. Stupidity is Contagious, Make sure you don't spread it.

    • @shuvojitraychaudhuri8751
      @shuvojitraychaudhuri8751 5 лет назад

      @@drmanitkumar1889 Love your comment!

    • @anshuuu9708
      @anshuuu9708 4 года назад +1

      @@drmanitkumar1889
      【coronavirus enters the chat】

    • @WouldIwasShookspeared
      @WouldIwasShookspeared 3 года назад +2

      @@drmanitkumar1889 when I read the first line, the first thing I did to immediately check the time
      1 year, I freacked for a second and them continuous to read the whole sentence
      "Oh!"

  • @sreelakshmichandramohan7115
    @sreelakshmichandramohan7115 3 года назад +2

    Yes,Sadguru tells clearly ,what message that has to reach the listeners.pranams.

  • @abhishekreddy8801
    @abhishekreddy8801 6 лет назад +119

    I don't know what's wrong with me I can only understood what sadguru had said...

    • @Harry-fh6hv
      @Harry-fh6hv 6 лет назад +19

      Please contact a psychiatrist

    • @abhishekreddy8801
      @abhishekreddy8801 6 лет назад +38

      @@Harry-fh6hv which psychiatrist ? The one whom you regularly visit!!

    • @suvrojitroy1093
      @suvrojitroy1093 6 лет назад +19

      abhishek reddy That's why he is popular, he speaks for the common people explaining things simply. It's all good, however complicated things exist and to understand them you need to be more aware. Sadhguru can speak for a lot of issues that you would easily understand but he can't teach you theoretical physics. It depends on you what you want to seek and know, people usually only like to hear what they want to hear, from my experience.

    • @abhishekreddy8801
      @abhishekreddy8801 6 лет назад +9

      @@Harry-fh6hv ppl call mad which they don't understand...you think you know everything.. It's a big problem than being mad my friend.. There r so many things exist in this universe which are beyond your experience that doesn't mean they doesn't exist... It is ur inability to perceive

    • @neojohns2487
      @neojohns2487 6 лет назад +2

      Concentrate on your studies and then listen the discussion....then you will be able to understand what other pannelists are saying....In my opinion professor Vargabh and Swami Atmapriananda are the sensible speakers as they are not speaking vague..

  • @rpat17
    @rpat17 3 года назад +3

    I am proud ex student of rk mission🙏🙏

  • @vaikunthabhogte9665
    @vaikunthabhogte9665 5 лет назад +9

    Nice combination , this is real and meaningfull convention , show this type of vedio instead of showing Muslim maulla Vs Hindu vedio

  • @vineflower
    @vineflower 2 года назад +1

    This was actually excellent. What a great snippet!

  • @mafiaundertakers
    @mafiaundertakers 6 лет назад +16

    Science ends where spirituality begins. The only person who knew everything but didn't interrupt anyone was sadhguru.

    • @DivyaPrakash1
      @DivyaPrakash1 5 лет назад

      Please !! Every one of the panellist were great!

    • @belapcela
      @belapcela 5 лет назад +2

      He he ... Yeah, I had the same feeling. I like how he was loughing at the end, like a father watching kids at play.

    • @adarshv.s6437
      @adarshv.s6437 5 лет назад +2

      Similarly science ends where weed action begins😁 you'll have revelations, you'll see and feel things that science can't explain..and it goes on..💨💨💨

    • @shuvojitraychaudhuri8751
      @shuvojitraychaudhuri8751 5 лет назад +1

      Hey Madhav, we need to understand that no one is competing and we also need to understand that all the people up there are highly educated so the comment you made is a bit insulting.

  • @Rookie353
    @Rookie353 5 лет назад +4

    This is how civilized people untertake a debate on such a sensitive topic.👍👍👍ndtv

  • @razemusik3466
    @razemusik3466 5 лет назад +10

    This happens when you have a discussion among intellects not blind followers

  • @peaceandhumanrelieffoundation
    @peaceandhumanrelieffoundation 5 лет назад +33

    I am a fan of sadhguru .I think he should debate with Dr Zakir Naik. Are you ready??

    • @peaceandhumanrelieffoundation
      @peaceandhumanrelieffoundation 5 лет назад +5

      @Bhushan Raut brother i believe sadguru have more knowledge from Dr Zakir Naik.Don't worry we will destroy Dr Zakir Naik..Are you agree????iitna to damm hei hamm logo mei ke Dr Zakir Naik ko insult kar sak te hei..Jaise Dr Zakir Naik ne Vadas,Upanishads, Bhagavad Gita,Puran se hawala deke Sri Sri Ravi Sankar ka bolti band kar diya tha, uusitara hamm log vi Dr Zakir Naik ko insult karenge and uuska bolti band kar dengge....jai hind...jai jawan...

    • @vinodraghuvanshi8802
      @vinodraghuvanshi8802 5 лет назад

      Read comment of vinod u

    • @kumarvikash6122
      @kumarvikash6122 5 лет назад +2

      @@peaceandhumanrelieffoundation noooo, even god can't beat zokar naik 😂🤣🤣

    • @peaceandhumanrelieffoundation
      @peaceandhumanrelieffoundation 5 лет назад

      @@kumarvikash6122 hahaha

    • @AchieveSI
      @AchieveSI 5 лет назад +1

      @@kumarvikash6122 zoker nike😂😂🤣🤣

  • @DerekP777
    @DerekP777 4 года назад +1

    Fr. Dominick Emanuel explanation was really reasonable and what he said was truly incorporation of Spirituality and Science....Just Amazing Mindset.

  • @kuldeeplakhawat365
    @kuldeeplakhawat365 4 года назад +2

    Wow...blown away by Swami Atmapriyananda Ji's explanation.
    Swami Atmapriyananda ji should be the only one on the podium... Rest of them seems to have no idea about particle physics or God.

  • @bhanujha1511
    @bhanujha1511 3 года назад +5

    Always impressed with sadhguru and his intense knowledge 🙏

  • @gourangabiswas2504
    @gourangabiswas2504 4 года назад +3

    Swami ji is the best and I am lucky that I am studying in Ramakrishna Mission Vidyamandira Balur Math

  • @Rahul-lp3rk
    @Rahul-lp3rk 5 лет назад +75

    Earth is flat according to a great book

    • @PradeepKumar-fn5zv
      @PradeepKumar-fn5zv 5 лет назад

      Can you tell me which great book?

    • @healthybeautywithk5155
      @healthybeautywithk5155 5 лет назад +1

      😀😀😃😃😃😁

    • @iNDOmOTO1
      @iNDOmOTO1 5 лет назад +1

      Yea just like your brain

    • @arnoldschafernaker512
      @arnoldschafernaker512 5 лет назад +16

      @@PradeepKumar-fn5zv Qurand

    • @gagan_sikhi
      @gagan_sikhi 5 лет назад +2

      agr ek baap ki aulad ho to btao
      kis book mai likha hai k earth is flat
      with chapter number and verse number
      open challenge

  • @sayakghatak
    @sayakghatak 5 лет назад +1

    This is how science and many religions have always coexisted in India for centuries in harmony. Live and let live! A lesson to many parts of the world.

  • @sabitapanigrahi1197
    @sabitapanigrahi1197 8 месяцев назад

    Best debate on science and religion... And we lack these now 😢

  • @riwaz1236
    @riwaz1236 6 лет назад +8

    Sadhguru 👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌

  • @zterke
    @zterke 6 лет назад +47

    Thanks GOD there is no Nair Zaik🙏

    • @DivyaPrakash1
      @DivyaPrakash1 5 лет назад +2

      Coz he doesn't have to do with either science or spirituality !!!

    • @prasantachetri7446
      @prasantachetri7446 5 лет назад +1

      Because He creates terrorist

    • @teufelhunden2764
      @teufelhunden2764 5 лет назад

      He doesn't have anything to do here. He's the leader of Shitheaders 😅😅😅😅

    • @Vigneshwaran018
      @Vigneshwaran018 5 лет назад

      There's no book for this. That's y he's absent or esle he would be chapter 1-10,verse 100.

    • @vinodraghuvanshi8802
      @vinodraghuvanshi8802 5 лет назад

      Correct. Read comment of vinod raghuvanshi

  • @meghanathreddy190
    @meghanathreddy190 5 лет назад +6

    Bishop was busy managing the situation.

  • @eugeniuswilliams5457
    @eugeniuswilliams5457 5 лет назад +2

    6 guests of quality,; a compere who totally understands his subject; scholarly yet interesting answers to questions, and on national television! This could never happen in my country, {australasia)!

    • @eugeniuswilliams5457
      @eugeniuswilliams5457 5 лет назад

      Quantum Physics is not a 'physical' science, it deals with light and energy, hence it is dealing with a spiritual outlook; and hence why so few "scientists" actually understand it!

  • @utayanponnuthurai6733
    @utayanponnuthurai6733 4 года назад

    The debate is pretty good... no fight / personal attack,,,, well done !

  • @arupdutta7833
    @arupdutta7833 6 лет назад +3

    In the Chicago speech made my SWAMI VIVEKANANDA he explains about universe and god.. hear it once all of you

  • @JaberAhmed-jf8qk
    @JaberAhmed-jf8qk 5 лет назад +3

    Little knowledge of science makes you an atheist. In depth knowledge of science makes you a believer

    • @civi12132
      @civi12132 5 лет назад

      I think there is no god.......can you prove me sir

    • @JaberAhmed-jf8qk
      @JaberAhmed-jf8qk 5 лет назад

      Sachin Saurabh. The proof is the sky, ocean, trees, mountains the whole earth and yourself (human beings) what else proof do you want? Why are we here what do you think we just here to eat sleep live then die? But why?

    • @civi12132
      @civi12132 5 лет назад

      @@JaberAhmed-jf8qk the sky is there because there is thick layer of atmosphere........trees and human beings exist due to present to habitable situation like normal temperature and oxygen........universe has not creator....it has been made by own

    • @JaberAhmed-jf8qk
      @JaberAhmed-jf8qk 5 лет назад

      Sachin Saurabh. How is it possible that you came to earth? Without a creator there won’t be no creation

  • @Sandy-to7oo
    @Sandy-to7oo 5 лет назад +12

    If zakir naik is there
    Anchor : science can define god?
    Zakir : that is very good question brother.. that is very good question.. According to quran surah 4:11..blah blah (with loudest voice) and thats it..

    • @learnersense7446
      @learnersense7446 5 лет назад

      Truth is bitter. He talks with proof. Not only from other religious books but from your believed book also. Its a fundamental right by constitution that you should respect other religious sentiments. Moreover try to bring a book in comparison to Quran, you will definitely fail.

    • @Jeet12680
      @Jeet12680 4 года назад +2

      Learner sense hhahaha zakir is dumbest person in the world

    • @kaitanuhiwatari4744
      @kaitanuhiwatari4744 4 года назад +1

      @@learnersense7446 He purposely misinterprets non-muslim text in Islam's favour deliberately because he knows the audience won't make effort to review his references about non-muslim texts.

  • @alankritsahachaudhuri2970
    @alankritsahachaudhuri2970 4 года назад +1

    Religious language-God
    Scientific language-Mother Nature
    Both of them are the same.

  • @pritranjanjha
    @pritranjanjha 5 лет назад +1

    Mantra chanting has benefited me, and we are very weak species on many respects, so we have no option then to believe in God. But science and rational thoughts do attracts me. Due to various Risk & uncertainty, even scientists are often forced to believe in God.

  • @qeeranrana7030
    @qeeranrana7030 6 лет назад +3

    One thing is pretty clear, even so called intellectuals around here sound limited in front of the vast answer of Sadhguru. I could see his patience and humbleness with the knowledge beyond.

  • @oneoneoneone-m2f
    @oneoneoneone-m2f 2 года назад +3

    Swami atmapriyananda 🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @philbaxter9372
    @philbaxter9372 6 лет назад +11

    In the beginning, man created God in man's image and through the ages He has evolved and will continue to do so; always being a mystery.

    • @mangeshchalan8786
      @mangeshchalan8786 6 лет назад

      How will you create something without having an idea about it

    • @davidregi7571
      @davidregi7571 5 лет назад +1

      @@mangeshchalan8786 they formed the idea.
      We didn't have electricity ,but scientists made it after they deduced the idea of it

    • @asahama8173
      @asahama8173 4 года назад

      shut up

    • @anjalichaurasia2271
      @anjalichaurasia2271 4 года назад +1

      @@davidregi7571 we have electricity but science made it easy to manifest. Science is all about manifestation of natural forces in consumable form it does not make anything new just keep changing forces of nature. That is what sanatan dharm does worship nature and it's forces.

  • @nramakrishna8585
    @nramakrishna8585 3 года назад +1

    Disappointed when the scientist says the life started by chance as it amounts to say that you put all the components of a CPU in a box & rotate the box for thousand years & by a chance it gets assembled & starts working!. Being a science student I agree that science has understood this world very little with all the efforts made so far. Yet the universe works from atomic to cosmic level in a precise way.

  • @gitasn1769
    @gitasn1769 4 года назад

    so soft debate yet poweful, no loud conversation but very meaningful

  • @beoriginal9363
    @beoriginal9363 5 лет назад +14

    Everyone looks happy due to Zakir outstation. 😜😜😜

  • @thenomad5652
    @thenomad5652 5 лет назад +5

    Voice of sadguru
    Voice of these Bub's
    Enough to tell who achieve what

  • @skgyri
    @skgyri 4 года назад +9

    Who is here for Swami Atmapriyanandaji Maharaj

    • @thetroll1887
      @thetroll1887 3 года назад

      No one. Everyone is here was sadguru, but Swamiji turned put to be the star of the show.

  • @ChefAshutoshAwasthi
    @ChefAshutoshAwasthi 3 года назад +2

    The smallest particle is atom, and that too has neutron and proton, all revolving around each other, so does the bigger version as commented earlier, which got posted by mistake. So will be posting in parts for better understanding.
    Any thing that vibrates releases energy, although we humans can’t see or feel it, so even a small steel bed is actually vibrating continuously, So if Ramkrishna Paramhans had stated that he feels god in every bits and pieces was not wrong, only the way he explained was according to the mind set of people during that time. This is the closest scientific explanation that every thing that vibrates is a part of the same source energy that started after Big Bang

  • @ChefAshutoshAwasthi
    @ChefAshutoshAwasthi 3 года назад +1

    Also Hinduism states of Neer, Nar, Narayan, that life starts from water and ends as an energy, it’s also scientifically proved that life started in water, and the first form of organisms were found in water. And when a person dies the energy remains.
    Another link if seen also explains about Galaxies been referred as Brahma, so as stated in one of the stories that a messanger came and informed Krishna about the arrival of Brahma, the creator of a Galaxy, Krishna asked the messanger-Which Brahma?? There are shahstra Brahma’s, meaning thousands of Galaxies. Which has also been proven that after Big Bang thousands of Galaxies were created , so it’s not wrong if stated Param Brahma -Was the Big Bang from where existence of this universe started

  • @ZeroOne46
    @ZeroOne46 6 лет назад +10

    "Will science be able to define God?"
    Wow. What a silly question. If man's science can define an eternal being who created all, how great could that being possibly be? This is the problem with trying to prove everything by science, it ultimately MUST reduce God to man's level of knowledge and understanding. This is a most ignorant thing for any human being to even consider. God will make fools of man if he insists on such foolishness.

    • @27499
      @27499 4 года назад

      I find your answer to be a correct one

  • @medicoslifestyle
    @medicoslifestyle 5 лет назад +5

    God particle ❌-higgs bosson particle❤

  • @ayanmukherjee8255
    @ayanmukherjee8255 2 года назад +3

    You need a different level of ignorance to interrupt Swami Atmapriyananda, a scholler of physics, and a monk of RK Mission. I don't know how the anchor was able to do that in his right mind.

  • @rudrax2148
    @rudrax2148 3 года назад

    When Genius people Debate, there is also fight but calmly, Patiencefully.
    Worth watching.

  • @saptarshibose3234
    @saptarshibose3234 5 лет назад +1

    Swamiji briefly gaved the explanation of science and god that they are two aspects of one single coin I am not a student of science but like swami ji told not inspite of it but because of it and human being needs to understand physics essentially if we want to God