CAT Amongst The Pigeons!: 2019 Caterpillar 432F backhoe vs JCB Grey Cab

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 23 янв 2025

Комментарии • 69

  • @penningtoncolin
    @penningtoncolin Месяц назад +2

    Years ago we had an L reg 3cx tried every machine went for a cat 432f what a machine best machine I've driven ran rings around jcb I loved it little bit light on front end but a heavy machine think it was about 9ton was 12years ago now still miss that machine

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  Месяц назад

      Yes the F series wasn't a bad machine, I think most Cat backhoes have been a little light on the front, or back heavy. Yes you're correct - around 9ton! 💪👍 I didnt think much to the mid 90's 3CX's, under powered I thought! That also lead me to Caterpillar, starting with a 428 C series 👍

  • @hartleyhore9040
    @hartleyhore9040 2 месяца назад +2

    Yeah definitely something missing, great sketch 😂
    Nice job as always 😁

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  2 месяца назад

      Yeah.... its just not the P7 SiteMaster 💪💪👌👍

  • @MarkJones-ws6yo
    @MarkJones-ws6yo 4 месяца назад +2

    Another great video nice to watch on a sunday evening

  • @AbandonedandForgottenWales
    @AbandonedandForgottenWales Месяц назад +1

    New to the channel, it seems a capable machine, but I’ve only used 3CX over the last 20 years, remember the first 3CX 80s model with loads of slop in the back actor lol, 2004 3CX Contractor was the last one I used, nice machine, I did use a Volvo if I remember it was a BL61 was alright

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  Месяц назад

      Welcome to the channel. We hope you will enjoy the content and if you have any ideas or videos that you want us to make with the equipment we have, please tell us ! 👌👍

  • @johnmcclelland5265
    @johnmcclelland5265 4 месяца назад +1

    That 4 way bucket is a real bonus. The cab must be more comfortable at the end of the day.

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад +1

      Yes the 4in1 front bucket is very useful and most backhoes have them now. The cab, im really not sure if it is, you can see better out of the grey cab 3CX. the cab is also less 'cluttered' on the 3CX, very similar seat, the main difference is that the newer machine is quieter in the cab and it has servo control. 😊👍

  • @gordonwood3184
    @gordonwood3184 2 месяца назад +1

    I brought a 1990 3cx grey cab in 1994 for 15,500. I yousd to get £13.50 a hour fuel supplied by company. Used to do all the service myself. No big problems just the odd hose now and then .if i had any hoses that i thought might rub against eachother i wold wrap them in damp course and zip tie them . Sold it in 1999.for 10.000.pounds someone brought it and shipped it to the Outer Hebrides Scotland. I went to look at a 4 year old cat back hoe i think it was a 428 but it was about 25.000.pounds . so i packed up working for myself and went driving for someone.ps good to see the you still keep your jcb going .

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  2 месяца назад +1

      Hi Gordon, thanks for the message! 😊 I have fond memories of operating Cat backhoes, from the early C serires to the late E's, all very good machines, after the E series - it all went downhill or Cat backhoes. Thats just how I see it, im sure others feel the later Cat's are fantastic, Im just not a fan of the new tech and over the top safety equipment fitted to later machines. My 3CX is much like the early 428's, simple, reliable and gets the job done! 💪👌👍

  • @stephengoudie9747
    @stephengoudie9747 4 месяца назад +2

    JCB for me! I am in NZ what hourly rate is a 3cx now in the UK?

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад +1

      Thanks for the comment - as for the rates, a backhoe here in northen England, including the operator with certs and fuel will be around the £45-50/hr including traveling the machine to the job site. Would be nice to hear what other countries are charging for backhoes and equipment? 👍

  • @michaelwhitaker9188
    @michaelwhitaker9188 3 месяца назад

    Ey Up Paul,I had a Cat 428 2wd back in 1990,working for a Leeds Plant Hire Company,it was on a E plate prob 2 years old,I missed the 3cx at the last firm,the only thing it had on the 3cx was it could push like FK on the front end,anyway it's Mr Bamford all day long 😄🤙

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад

      Ha, I remember having a C series 428, 4x4, yes good pushers, good machines too I thought, but they all were simple to maintain back in the day 😊👌👍

  • @hedgehogjoe1605
    @hedgehogjoe1605 4 месяца назад +1

    A do love these new machines ( apart from all the computer crazy 🤪 voodoo magic ) to go wrong .can't beat the old school all u need is common sense n a spanner hahaha. I love my greycab 3cx just as tidy as yours. Dig all day 🙌

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад +2

      New machines are nice, til they break, then you can quickly fall out with it. My old 3CX doesn't let me down and requires little maintainace really for the work I do with it. Im always looking to see if I can make it better, can a pin or bush be replaced if I think theres too much play somewhere, or maybe a shim I can weld in on the stabilizer legs or extra-dig. I hope you use yours and keep enjoy using it, worth keeping the magic alive! 💪👌👍

  • @Anvil-Blacksmith
    @Anvil-Blacksmith 4 месяца назад +1

    👍👍

  • @glynrogers1018
    @glynrogers1018 4 месяца назад +3

    Hi old school jcb all day long

  • @FedorkoTV
    @FedorkoTV 3 месяца назад +1

    new backhoe loader?😀

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад

      No, just hired in for a job as mine was out of service at the time

    • @FedorkoTV
      @FedorkoTV 3 месяца назад +1

      @@PSExcavationsLLC aha, ok

  • @AdamHunt-n2r
    @AdamHunt-n2r 3 месяца назад +1

    Really better videos with your own voice over , be good to do a video showing over what you have done to your site master over the years running it main issues pros cons maybe

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад

      Thanks Adam, I try to make the content as enjoyable for everybody as possible, I will keep that in mind and may make a walk around video, explaining what I have done to my 3CX to make it better, more usable or for more operator comfort - thanks for the comment! 👌👍

  • @MarkJones-ws6yo
    @MarkJones-ws6yo 4 месяца назад +1

    Love the old jcb 3cx sitemaster better then the cat and less to go wrong more electric problems on new machines

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад +2

      Im with you on that one Mark, one important point in running the older equipment, Keep it maintained and in good working order. Stuff can soon be 'old' if not looked after properly. I dont think the newer machines will be around and working in 30 years, an electrical problem can be the end, or an electrical fire too which has happened to many newer, more complex machines / vehicles.

    • @MarkJones-ws6yo
      @MarkJones-ws6yo 3 месяца назад +1

      @@PSExcavationsLLC very ture

  • @bennybucknall341
    @bennybucknall341 4 месяца назад +2

    Another great video, paul the Old 3cx, any day, I like the cat's but always found them to be a bit clumber sum and heavier against the old sitemaster, definitely jcb for me😊💪🤙

    • @nickhill3362
      @nickhill3362 4 месяца назад +1

      @@bennybucknall341 totally agree

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад +2

      Thanks Benny, yeah, I find the Cats heavy on the back ends, or light on the front, cab doors have always been flimsy too on the Cats. Also ... running older equipment you have to think about parts and support, both of which I have no problem with running JCB, Cat and the Cat dealer near me are not all that helpful, and very expensive!!

  • @michaelpagett8063
    @michaelpagett8063 3 месяца назад +1

    It helps to have the teeth on the bucket

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  2 месяца назад

      Yes, true, I have teeth on my own machine, this is hired in and not owned by myself. I remember a time when most backhoes had teeth fitted, most now do not

  • @nickhill3362
    @nickhill3362 4 месяца назад +2

    I would rather use the grey cab mate enjoyed vid 👍

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад +1

      Thanks Nick, must admit that the old grey cab is great fun to put to work, and will keep up with the Cat on the job, and only 1-2 mph slower than the Cat on the road! 💪

    • @nickhill3362
      @nickhill3362 3 месяца назад +1

      @@PSExcavationsLLC as a full time operator owner driver that has put many thousands of hours on back hoe loaders since 1988 I can only think that any one that prefers the cat cannot have put anough hrs on a gray cab to have worked out there full potential they just feel right compared to a awkward cat and nothing will change my mind it's just a fact Paul a friend of mine has just bought a grey cab turbo Plus know were talking what a machine I've operated loads of white,black,and grey cabs but never a grey cab turbo Plus have you Paul

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад +2

      Nick - I think your right, anyone that has spent time operating and working a grey cab sitemaster will know what they can do. A hard machine to beat, just think of all the new backhoes out there now, wait until they're 36 years old, like my grey cab 3CX is, and see who wants to operate them, and thats IF they are any around thats still able to work! My 1988 grey cab is an early grey cab, but if you look at the sides of the hydraulic tanks it has decals 'SUPER 3CX' and that has the same spec's as the Turbo Plus or SiteMaster Plus and similar to the later Contractor models. More HP, more options built in from the factory and more comfort for the operator. Iv also added more options to mine, like heated seat, SRS, Aux cab heating, in-cab face level fan, better quality modern radio and speakers, front sun viser, front facing camara, back-up alarm and engine block heater. Im not going to say my 3CX is perfect, but its a working machine and maintainace on on-going with a list of jobs that i'd like to do to keep the machine in the best working condition possible. Anybody running any classic vehicle will understand what its like owning a classic, when I see and talk to anybody that owns a classic car, truck or tractor, they always have a great story to tell and tell it with a smile. Talk to somebody that runs a modern vehicle, normally a different kind of story and mostly without the smile.

    • @nickhill3362
      @nickhill3362 3 месяца назад +1

      @@PSExcavationsLLC sounds like we are singing off the same song sheet mate 👍😁

  • @IorwerthRoberts
    @IorwerthRoberts 4 месяца назад +2

    Prefer the Jcb 3cx any time grey cab

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад

      A good maintained grey cab (1988-1991) is a fantastic machine. Fun to work with, reliable and without all the electrical DPF/DEF nonsense. Sadly, most grey cab 3CX's are past their best now 😥

  • @njkip
    @njkip 4 месяца назад +1

    CAT by far....I used to be a jcb guy but not any more....driven the 428 and 432 ....get a CAT...

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад +2

      Really, I have owned or operated the 428's and 432's from the B series all the way through to the latest Cat backhoe. I will say that I will not be buying a new Cat or JCB any time soon, the newer machines are not easy to live with, and will not do what you could do with the older machines. I would have a pre DPF/DEF 428/432/450 Cat, but the Cat dealer will be harder to deal with than the JCB dealer im currently dealing with. A pre DPF/DEF 428/432 will not do the job any better or faster than the 3CX I have so why would I change it? 😊

    • @njkip
      @njkip 3 месяца назад +1

      @@PSExcavationsLLC I agree that the new ones have more to go wrong Paul, a 3cx that had a gremlin with the powershift, would change gear on is own when went down a bump while roading. A 4x4x4 that wouldn't change gear because of relay faults, or re align from crabbing because of lazer issues...I owned a 1980 3D 111 power train....had that 17 years....a numb noisey old thing to drive and operate but I will say a great work horse. As like anything I guess they become too complicated, a lot like cars...to much electronics and in some cases I think gimmicky....but they are a lot more comfortable to drive/ operate. What do you think of the case 580s. I had a stint in one of them in the the 90s. I guess it's down to operater preference and from experiences. I will say I do like your old 3cx..there was one on Ebay a while ago up for sale, completely refurbished....looked amazing...up for 25k for a while then dropped to 20k....heavy money I thought despite its condition....still nice tho! Keep up the vids they're great to watch ....always a pleasure...👍

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад

      Never really been a fan of the 4CX and the 4 wheel steer, I think a backhoe just looks right having the smaller front wheels. Ha ... reah very gimmicky... new Doosan excavators now have a powered door lock, so you can unlock and lock the cab door without using the key, I ask .. whats wrong with putting the key into the door twice a day like we've all done for the past how many years? Touch screen displays, all things that dont need to be fitted to industrial heavy equipment, and when it stops working, it will cost hundreds or even thousands to fix, progress they say?? Yes more cab comfort for the operator, but unless its really hot weather, I dont get out of my old 3CX at the end of the day feeling any worse than getting out of a newer machine, and most backhoes still dont have A/C as standard equipment. Not really had much to do with Case backhoes over the years, Case excavators seem to be a nicely put together machine and operate smoothly. Didnt see the grey cab on ebay, 25K seems a fair price if it had been refurbished properly, you can easily pay that and more for a newer one and still have pins, bushes, hoses, tires to replace. Thanks for the support with the Channel, and dont forget our Facebook page too - as we dont video everything we do!

  • @wildtimewithmatthew
    @wildtimewithmatthew 4 месяца назад +1

    I say that you should have one of each, so you have 2 tlbs, so if one breaks down and you are waiting for parts, then you can use the other one to get jobs done and make some money

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад

      Ha yeah, that would be nice, but I think that it would be the newer machine broken down the most, I did look at buying an older Cat backhoe but the price of them was too high at the time and dealing with the Cat dealer is not as pleasent as the JCB dealer I use 😊

  • @darrenfarrell-bn2cb
    @darrenfarrell-bn2cb 3 месяца назад +2

    Expensive when things Go Wrong with A lot of Electronics.
    But New JCB’s
    Are The same
    Never Boost Start them if you Have a Flat Battery

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад +1

      Yes, all the same, whatever the brand!

    • @darrenfarrell-bn2cb
      @darrenfarrell-bn2cb 3 месяца назад +2

      @@PSExcavationsLLC
      Trucks No Different
      Thousands in a blink of an eye
      Common Rail Fuel Systems are Not affordable for a Small Man car truck or plant.

  • @pastorkeri
    @pastorkeri 4 месяца назад +1

    I like the cat better machine than the modern jcb will out push out dig the only let down for me is the travel speed and it’s a bit heavy in comparison , the older kit is easier to keep running but parts will get harder to source on a 30 year old machine , the servo layout in the cat432 f is way better than the joystick on seat that’s in the new cat and the jcb I find your busy pushing buttons and levers to activate the controls on the new 3cx whereas the stick machine you’ve got instant action

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад +1

      Thats an interesting comment. I have owned newer and older Cat and JCB, but Iv ended up with a very iconic machine that people will remember from either ones childhood, or from an era where the JCB Site Master was king of the job site. Mine will push very very well as can be seen in my videos, Im not saying all 3CX's will push like mine, most Iv operated were poor to be honest, whereas most Cats are much the same, most could push very well. I like the earlier Cats, cab layout was thought about, buttons in the right places etc. The D and early E series were very nice usable machines, did what you wanted them to do, and simple enough to work on, then from the F series onwards, well .... something went wrong. Weight has never really bothered me, Cat seem to be too light on the front, so maybe the balance could be better? I guess some operators like the stick contols, some the servo. I dont mind either, if Im on a job using mine with sticks, I do 'sometimes' think I wish I had servo for this job, and yes the earlier servo Cats, much better, a step backwards to have them on the seat like the servo 3CX's, Cat have really lost their way with the newer backhoes.

    • @pastorkeri
      @pastorkeri 3 месяца назад +1

      @@PSExcavationsLLC my all time favourite machine though will surprise you, a Ford 555 direct drive could take it anywhere even in 2wd best backhoe I had the pleasure of

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад

      That is a surprise, Iv seen Fords around in the past, but thinking now its been quite some time since Iv seen one working, have Ford gone the same way as Volvo and stopped making the backhoe? Both of which I never had the chance to operate but had many people say both were good machines

    • @pastorkeri
      @pastorkeri 3 месяца назад +1

      @@PSExcavationsLLC case new holland now produce both makes , the only variation is the back end

  • @louishorrill6681
    @louishorrill6681 4 месяца назад +1

    It’s nice to see the old JCB still working hard but I know which machine I’d rather be sat in all day and that’s the CAT!

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад +2

      Thanks for the comment, after sitting in and using both machines, and both have good and bad points, I like the older machine better for several reasons. I am also an owner operator, which means that I get the repair bills and the cost of ownership. Its always nice to sit in a new clean crisp peice of equipment, but living with it is not always so easy.

  • @charlesburns6601
    @charlesburns6601 4 месяца назад +1

    If I'm working all day I want to be in the CAT not the jcb so I prefer the caterpillar over the JCB

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад +1

      Thanks Charles, its not a bad place to spend your day, but if you are an owner/operator like I am, you may think differently. I do like the older Cat's, the D and early E series were good reliable machines, but old now. You also have to think about backup and support, cost of ownership when your machine has a few hours on it (as an owner) 👍

  • @johnmcclelland5265
    @johnmcclelland5265 4 месяца назад +2

    That reversing alert is so annoying.

    • @pastorkeri
      @pastorkeri 4 месяца назад +1

      That’s an easy fix only a cable disconnect

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад

      It is a little annoying 😆

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад

      True, just that it is needed on some job sites

  • @robdixon786
    @robdixon786 4 месяца назад +1

    Cat every day they out rank jcb

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад +1

      Interesting. I am choosing my 3CX over the Cat in this video. I also know that the Cat in this video has cost more to service and maintain than mine has in all the years Iv owned it, which you have to think about when you're an owner operator and the equipment you own HAS to make money! I found the D and early E series Cats nice machine to own and operate, but like my 3CX, they are old now and unless properly maintained, will be no fun the be in. I also find the Cat dealer very unhelpful and hard to deal with, unlike the JCB dealer, which you also have to think about when you own equipment 👍

  • @andrewmawson6897
    @andrewmawson6897 2 месяца назад +1

    How much would the financing of the CAT add to your jobs - it's all down to finances the 3CX and the CAT will basically do the same job for you but using the 3CX presumably makes better sense as I assume that it owes you nothing. Go CAT and you may have to increase your day rate and get less jobs.

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  2 месяца назад +2

      Andrew, to have any backhoe loader on finance, you would need to keep it busy every week, Im not sure the work is there anymore at the moment, hopefully this will change. For me it wouldn't work out. Im also not a fan of the newer tech in machines, if it has DPF/DEF - its too new!! Old is gold 💪👍👌

  • @kennethhatcher5822
    @kennethhatcher5822 3 месяца назад +1

    Them cat are dreadful on cl tyres ! Different machine on Michelin xmcl !

    • @PSExcavationsLLC
      @PSExcavationsLLC  3 месяца назад +1

      Yeah the road manners of the Cat are poor, the transmission dosn't help either, the 6 speed is not as smooth as the eariler 5 speed 😕