DIY Robotic Arm 3D Printed (an Initial Prosthetic Prototype)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 дек 2024

Комментарии • 247

  • @abslol8827
    @abslol8827 7 лет назад +38

    When I first clicked the video I was blown away at first glance, this project has insane potential, please dont give up!

  • @DeltaKreations
    @DeltaKreations 3 года назад +6

    Thank you for sharing. Learning from other's "mistakes/failures" helps everyone improve on their first try. Very helpful.

  • @darshansk139
    @darshansk139 6 лет назад +3

    You are really making a change in the way we think about robotics. I thank you for that.

  • @eduardosalgado9423
    @eduardosalgado9423 3 года назад

    thaks for showing what most people don't see in great and successful ideas or projects, all the way you have to go trough in order to success, they just see a finish good but never thinks about how hard is the effort invested, you are the kind of people that this world needs, greetings from Mexico!!

  • @MindTrip888
    @MindTrip888 4 года назад +1

    Prototyping is all about learning as you go and modifying. Sometimes before you build.
    Thanks for completing the original design and sharing so we can all learn.
    I have some ideas of my own which I have concentrated on for many hours to have 2 types of clutches related to each joint in legs, hips, ankles. With combinations of Brake Clutch to LOCK each joint in place. And Drive Clutch to engage the pulley to the shaft. With free rolling pullies on each joint to get to the lower ones. I noted none of the joints move more than 45 deg + 90 deg = 135 deg. So the DRIVE mechanism for each drive shaft to the clutches also only engages for 135 degrees. Meaning Nothing but the motor turns more than that. Another drive shaft and clutch for reverse direction. Each clutch is about being moved by a lever in progression via programming to engage drive, disengage brake and so on. In effect ONE MOTOR could be used to drive all the cables to all the joints. And could spin fast to be a stabilising Gyro with a gear box for torque for the 135 deg movements. It a very interesting puzzle to consider.

    • @MindTrip888
      @MindTrip888 4 года назад

      Tesla was able to design prototypes in his mind and modifying them before building. Though of course such things take practice to build the mind skills.

  • @jesusfreak316
    @jesusfreak316 4 года назад +1

    Brother don't be too hard on yourself man. I proved how clear and concise the tutorial was. I am in love with the design, but most importantly you taught me a lesson of perseverance and dedication. For that I am eternally grateful my friend👍🙏🤖👀🛠📖

  • @billfield8300
    @billfield8300 4 года назад

    Hi Will. Although you consider this project a partial failure I'm sure you can see that many ppl here consider it a success. For me, you have offered some unique and, I believe, valid design ideas which I will consider in my own projects. I agree 100% that the need for a functional wrist joint is important and your solution of the ball and springs is indeed inspirational. Thanks for sharing. We are ALL just working on the shoulders of giants. (and for the record, those giants had many, many failures on their way to success.) Keep the faith.

  • @dunyabaradari9116
    @dunyabaradari9116 2 года назад +4

    This must have been frustrating but your progress is actually amazing! Respect for pulling through and sharing the project with all of us! Love it ^^

  • @paigelooney6117
    @paigelooney6117 3 года назад +1

    Brilliant design, truly professional grade. I could only image a fully built robot made by you.

  • @bonganishilenge1084
    @bonganishilenge1084 3 года назад +2

    NICE , NEVER GIVE UP , I LOVED IT

  • @TheGreatTimSheridan
    @TheGreatTimSheridan 2 года назад

    ha, my logo looks the same as the guy before me. I was just gonna say that you really learned a tremendous amount about unexpected problems, unintended consequences methods of failure, modes of interaction. That's a huge model. You could probably develop equations for the things that go wrong based on how complex it is.
    that said it's an amazing effort, and it'll be interesting if you keep the momentum on new designs.
    One interesting aspect is that the fingers and thumb have and wrist have specific pivot points. They're kind of tricky to find. virtually no one gets it all correct.
    So many curves and twists and angles are truly amazing. Wonderful video.

  • @aminerahal9419
    @aminerahal9419 5 лет назад +1

    Thanks for the video, it is not a failure, it is just an initial step for success

    • @jedrzejbiaokryty1925
      @jedrzejbiaokryty1925 5 лет назад

      It is called a prototype buddy sometimes prototypes don't work propelly ☺️

  • @lachlanraidal5100
    @lachlanraidal5100 7 лет назад +1

    Very good video, don't be bummed about it not turning out as good as you expected on the first try, first try is always a learning experience. Thankyou for sharing this, even if you consider it a failure; I for one would rank this among the best robot hand tutorials on youtube, because it demonstrates not only the craft of building but also the design process in action (love the ongoing evaluation). Until we meet again, keep building. :)

  • @SiliconSmack
    @SiliconSmack 4 года назад +1

    Glad you posted your failure here it could easily be fixed and rebuilt. Thank you for sharing!

  • @mography4563
    @mography4563 7 лет назад +49

    I appreciate your time and afford that made this video a great lesson for beginner like me. Keep up the good work!!!!!!!

    • @modus8256
      @modus8256 4 года назад +1

      I think u mean "effort" instead of "afford"

  • @AntonioCorneal
    @AntonioCorneal 2 года назад +1

    Man, this is still great! I didn't get very far with my first attempt at a prosthetic arm really similar to yours. The CAD model looked pretty, but it needs a lot of work. I respect you for sharing this, especially since it wasn't working perfectly. Mine barely worked at all! I am yet to get a chance to redesign and re-try one, but I really want to. I hope by now since this was a few years ago, that you've made good progress!

  • @edisonong825
    @edisonong825 5 лет назад

    I dont consider it failed, success is a process, now you know the issue, you can address it. nice video. the community thanks you.

  • @iamatardis
    @iamatardis 7 лет назад +2

    Well mate, all I can say is WELL DONE!
    You have accomplished what I am looking to do (Hands, Arms, Legs, Feet et al). It is NOT a small feat to print and build a piece of human anatomy. You should be congratulating yourself for your tenacity alone :)
    Being 'old school' (a dinosaur lol) I will do it without electronics, electric only. 18 volt cordless batteries, limit switches, ABS, simple, rough, but effective.
    My hat goes off to you big fella. Keep going, you have a very bright future ahead of you should you choose to seize the opportunity...
    Best of luck Will. Keep up the great work!

  • @DeepSohelia1
    @DeepSohelia1 3 года назад

    This video has been really inspirational in my final year orthotic project, so thank you for posting it! I cite this video in my work!

  • @palmtrees9474
    @palmtrees9474 3 года назад

    Do not be hard on yourself! Kreep up the great work, u rock!

  • @MetaVIRTUAL
    @MetaVIRTUAL 5 лет назад

    As a disabled person with an incomplete right hand. I think the focus should be lower forearm or just above the wrist prosthetics such as what u did. Creating a circle or half rounded flexi mould for the wrist on your design and taking the black outta cabling and internalising it.
    All in though great first attempt

  • @tigerchen1085
    @tigerchen1085 7 лет назад +129

    Great video. I'm planning to do something similar in the future. Even though your attempt did not meet your expectations, I learnt a lot of techniques, ideas and prob saved me from a bunch of mistakes (Failure is the key to success!). Thanks mate

    • @WillDonaldson
      @WillDonaldson  7 лет назад +13

      I am glad you found it useful, I would be interested in seeing your work when finished!

    • @Scotty-vs4lf
      @Scotty-vs4lf 6 лет назад +2

      same bruh i was going to comment this word for word

    • @alfred601
      @alfred601 2 года назад

      Please help me im from Philippine.

    • @alfred601
      @alfred601 2 года назад

      @@WillDonaldson pls help me i need robotic arm my problem is no money.

  • @Aussie50InspiredDavidZ
    @Aussie50InspiredDavidZ 3 года назад

    I feel like you should revisit this so you can prove to yourself and fix all the flaws in your design/electronics. This was amazing by the way. But it can be excellent if you're willing to spend more time on it and fail thousands of times over and over until you solve each flaw in your robotic hand.

  • @neoncommander
    @neoncommander 7 лет назад +13

    Nice video keep doing things like this!

  • @SplashyAnimatronic
    @SplashyAnimatronic Год назад

    Dude! good job! i'm actually excited to make my own now! i got the palm of my hand printing right now, i'm surprised out compact your arm is. great work.

  • @RoadRunnerMeep
    @RoadRunnerMeep 4 года назад +1

    Excellent work. To me the question "is it all worth it", never factors. No matter what challenges or difficulty, my end goal is to make a more functional prosthetic which can benefit people. I give up,I let them down. So it's just another challenge to me if I can't solve something

  • @psilocyrapter
    @psilocyrapter 5 лет назад

    I like the idea that wrist is interesting. From personal experience power of the grip is not from the hand but from the forearm. 4^th & 5^th metacarpals (full Boxer's fracture) and a growing list... Think open along with wrist up/and so below to close. On the wrist pieces make it so the small side goes to the ball. Maybe scrap the springs for curved telescoping about where Tib./Fib. are on top and bottom respectively. To accommodate for your lines (tendons).
    Really cool knowledge. Physical therapy along with the correct workout. After 9 years. Start to feel like Doctor Strange. Hope this was helpful.

  • @roselldessert1377
    @roselldessert1377 6 лет назад +13

    Hey Will,
    BTW great job! This is one step closer to your goal of a final product. I would like to try this and modify it on my own to maybe improve it. If I can I will come back with helpful feedback. I'm speechless at how awesome this design is! Keep up the good work!

  • @huraibyel-huraiby7462
    @huraibyel-huraiby7462 5 лет назад +1

    Your project was very ambitious and highly successful. Overall amazing and inspiring! Well done!

  • @sekiko7183
    @sekiko7183 6 лет назад +1

    Its great to see this design in the video and how you constructed this arm. I am more interested in the prosthetics field, but I would love to make an electronic arm myself; and I have from scratch a long time ago. I am still working on designs to this day, and you are just a great inspiration for me to keep doing this. Keep up the good work. 👍

  • @dongeonpoltzer4344
    @dongeonpoltzer4344 5 лет назад

    success and all good videos on youtube suck... you showed the short comings too that enlighten a careful viewer and a curious student and makes him aware of what all problems people might face while creating something. you did a fantastic job. thanks

  • @amadeusbojiuc2613
    @amadeusbojiuc2613 4 года назад

    Hey just a thought, you don’t need to use a servo for each finger, you could have a single servo control multiple or all fingers. Depends on how much force you’d expect though.

  • @patrickcunningham1242
    @patrickcunningham1242 5 лет назад

    Excellent work. You learn more from your failures than success. Thanks for the video.

  • @dwrobotics2180
    @dwrobotics2180 7 лет назад +12

    Good to see your ideas around having motors in the hand itself. I've often thought the hand should have some of the motors in the hand itself to make the most of the space and reduce power loss from cable transmission. Interesting project, will follow.

  • @lifeinchina7758
    @lifeinchina7758 5 лет назад

    You did an amazing job.....this is how you and others will learn. Fantastic!!!!!! Well Done!

  • @vvv2170-v8y
    @vvv2170-v8y 4 года назад

    Excellent Video !! Seriously inspiring... Keep sharing such projects.

  • @leviackerman2042
    @leviackerman2042 Месяц назад +1

    Why is the file missing?????

  • @tanmaywho
    @tanmaywho 6 лет назад +3

    GREAT video exactly what I was searching for.
    Thx

  • @SoundFantasy
    @SoundFantasy 6 лет назад +14

    6:43
    Got em 👌

  • @haneen3731
    @haneen3731 3 года назад

    Wow great job, this is awesome!

  • @Mystic0Dreamer
    @Mystic0Dreamer 4 года назад

    I'm always looking for ideas for robotic hands. Just meant as constructive comments: I would personally drop the background music. And perhaps explain things in more detail. Just my thoughts for whatever they might be worth.

  • @battledroidmk129
    @battledroidmk129 4 года назад

    As a robot i aprove your creation

  • @armadillostudios2720
    @armadillostudios2720 4 года назад

    appreciate the honesty and realistic view on everything, thinking of doing something similar for my senior year project and this was a good inspiration!

  • @ShaneGadsby
    @ShaneGadsby 7 лет назад

    Amazing work so far! I'll be following your work closely from now on!

  • @greggeshelman
    @greggeshelman 7 лет назад

    Fix the weak thumb by supporting the rotation with a metal tube epoxied into the thumb base and ball bearings in the palm. That way the motor shaft doesn't have to resist bending stress.
    Metal gear servos!
    Eliminate the servos' housings and design the plastic parts to directly hold the motors and gears. It'll be stronger and less bulky.

    • @WillDonaldson
      @WillDonaldson  7 лет назад

      Those are good ideas. I agree, the shaft of the servo which the thumb is currently attached to is too small and weak. I also hadn't considered directly putting the motors and gears in the hand without the plastic cases, that should be a fair easy modification to save space

  • @WawanSetiawan-ez5ro
    @WawanSetiawan-ez5ro 2 года назад +1

    Tanks very much Master..
    Good..I'm is Ciamis West Java Indonesia.

  • @farscape3100
    @farscape3100 7 лет назад +4

    keep at it some times its best to walk away for a while then come back to it with a clear mind

  • @jackbower8846
    @jackbower8846 7 лет назад +3

    I like it not bad for a first attempt!

  • @nikhiljdhv
    @nikhiljdhv 7 лет назад

    This is amazing. Keep working on it. You hardwork will never go waste. Keep it up😃

  • @rc-y
    @rc-y 5 лет назад

    Kudos to your dedication..! Great work. Keep pushing.

  • @heyyou5680
    @heyyou5680 6 лет назад

    I’m so proud of you. You have no idea...

  • @melindapocsai590
    @melindapocsai590 2 года назад

    All the connections are right, everything is done the same, however the servos won't stop from running. Did you had this issue?

  • @vinodkumarvlogs1159
    @vinodkumarvlogs1159 4 года назад +1

    Which software was used to design the model

  • @akashleenasarkar998
    @akashleenasarkar998 4 года назад

    Thanks Will for this tutorial. I was looking for an arm which is cheap to build and I found the one.

  • @dhruvseth8702
    @dhruvseth8702 5 лет назад

    What an amazing work , sir . I am planning forward to do something like this in my college .Thanks a lot

  • @kilianstarzengruber6835
    @kilianstarzengruber6835 5 месяцев назад

    Eyo, great job! Next one will be eben better💪💪

  • @annawright8049
    @annawright8049 7 лет назад

    That project was amazing keep on trying 👍👍👍👍👍👍🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂😆😆😆😆😁😁😁😁😄😄😄😃😃😀😀

  • @PhG1961
    @PhG1961 7 лет назад

    Great video and a great effort of building this arm. Congratulations and continue the good work.

  • @bos4t
    @bos4t 4 года назад

    very good! I enjoyed your video and the work involved to make it and the hand!

  • @s.sradon9782
    @s.sradon9782 6 лет назад

    you could've redesigned the hand of the arm to be slightly larger and you could've used nylon in order to make the build stronger

  • @Chris4366100
    @Chris4366100 5 лет назад

    Thanks man for this video , appreciate you for the effort and "never give" up attitude

  • @info-kl4cx
    @info-kl4cx 4 месяца назад

    I think this is cool. I would definitely make servos for each of the fingers not leave the ring and pinky out next time. I'm sure you have all that worked out now.. how did future iterations come out? There has been a lot of innovation in arduino area development in the last 7 years.

  • @rockstarfreddyworld2251
    @rockstarfreddyworld2251 4 года назад +1

    What field of study should I be in if I want to learn more about motors, soldering circuit boards, engineering etc.?

    • @ziadsheriff6363
      @ziadsheriff6363 4 года назад

      Either Mechatronics or electrical engineering

  • @apsThala
    @apsThala 7 лет назад

    Great work, don't give up, if you make some changes it will work...I learnt many things from your work.

  • @anizammuddeen5355
    @anizammuddeen5355 6 лет назад

    Great effort!! Hats off👌👏👏

  • @aymansaleh8915
    @aymansaleh8915 7 лет назад

    Excellent job man, seriously this is awesome, i am going to try to build open this design!

  • @BS-zf9cj
    @BS-zf9cj 3 года назад

    This looks so tricky but it so cool what app did you use what things did you use

  • @MartinBgelund
    @MartinBgelund 7 лет назад

    Very inspiring video - it's packed with good design ideas!

  • @DaveWard-xc7vd
    @DaveWard-xc7vd 5 лет назад

    Use water soluble support material.

  • @aaqibkaif1750
    @aaqibkaif1750 4 года назад +1

    I want to konw about to robot which kind of part is very important for make a human robot

  • @joao_paiva
    @joao_paiva 4 года назад

    what is that black thing that you used in the wrist??

  • @THOMASTHESAILOR
    @THOMASTHESAILOR 5 лет назад

    I like it.. I would have bet money those blue china servos would fail.. ..You always need to buy 8 of them to get 6 working ones..

  • @shreeramashivasaibharadwaj5708
    @shreeramashivasaibharadwaj5708 4 года назад

    Sir how did you calculated the payload for hand?? and have you done any simulations?
    Great video

  • @jamesharris6062
    @jamesharris6062 6 лет назад

    This is a great projected you must have lots of patients I have a muscle wasting condition which is starting to effect my hands more on my left hand then the right hand but it it will get progressively worse. I will hope to fined a glove like this to help.

    • @WillDonaldson
      @WillDonaldson  6 лет назад

      Thanks for the support! Unfortunately this is not a medical device, merely an experiment. If you are interested there are other open source robotic hand projects online that may be more functional in a real life situation

  • @user-ys1hh5pl4t
    @user-ys1hh5pl4t 5 лет назад +1

    very well job ....
    could you tell me how can i make some edits on Fusion 360 file like open it in SolidWorks and make some edits ??

  • @Alyks_the_Emerald_Sage
    @Alyks_the_Emerald_Sage 3 года назад

    Damn, it sucked that it didn't turn out as expected, but hey, maybe if enough engineering research is applied, we could very well just 3d print prosthetic limbs!

  • @opless
    @opless 7 лет назад +11

    Arrived from hackaday.com/2017/07/28/fail-of-the-week-good-prosthetic-hand-design-goes-bad/ ... It's a great fail. You know what went wrong, and now are much more knowledgable than when your started. Well done! Keep doing things like this dude!

    • @robotin3192
      @robotin3192 4 года назад

      build your own robotic arm with parts for printing or machining. download parts and manufacture your own robot with precision and quality. access our hotmart link
      go.hotmart.com/I43664641H?dp=1

    • @فضلعبداللهالانقط
  • @govindsinghrathore4671
    @govindsinghrathore4671 4 года назад +2

    If i had a 3d printer i would have definitely tried this
    I had this in my mind for las t 6 months

  • @rimurutempesta1868
    @rimurutempesta1868 4 года назад

    What is the name of the program you used to model the hand?

  • @sakshammadan6243
    @sakshammadan6243 6 лет назад

    Great work sir

  • @MegaCoolshot
    @MegaCoolshot 7 лет назад

    What kind of printer are you using? It doesn't look like it's dialled in correctly, you should be getting much better prints then that.

    • @WillDonaldson
      @WillDonaldson  7 лет назад +1

      You are right, I was sloppy and lazy with calibrating the settings (I'll fix them up for future videos). It is a Qidi Tech I, which is essentially a blatant of the Makerbot Replicator 2X

    • @MegaCoolshot
      @MegaCoolshot 7 лет назад +1

      Will Donaldson Ok so when you fix that take a look at the tolerances for the finger joints, I think they are just binding up.

  • @rahuljoshi8331
    @rahuljoshi8331 5 лет назад

    Hey what material do you use in making the arm.. and how much does 3d printing cost

  • @w5im597
    @w5im597 6 лет назад

    very nice video ...... really appreciate the sharing ..... I really have an idea like this , was thing about the same servo motor to use with raspberry bi and python , and thinking about the design ....... you it really helped me out and encourage me to try it .
    I will share it with you later , hope you still working on it .
    for now I am thinking about the best way to get and EMG signal and what the tool I would need , and do I need to use machine learning to improve it .
    I am still beginner and self learning , so deciding these thing will be hard .
    I planing to buy the Creality3D Ender so what do you think ?
    any more advice ?
    thanks a lot , hope you doing well :)

  • @monhoobatraa3967
    @monhoobatraa3967 5 лет назад +1

    Great video, It's telling me everything I need to know. Thank you

  • @kiranSharma-bx4xk
    @kiranSharma-bx4xk 6 лет назад +1

    you deserve to be subscribed bro you don't afraid to post your mistake on RUclips great
    btw I really like the design of the 4 springs at the wrist
    I want to help poor people to provide them cheap prosthetic or free
    for their living and I'm now working on this project how to make a arm which works like normal the servos are really very slow I want something like our muscles hope that we can build this

  • @rw86347
    @rw86347 7 лет назад +1

    Nice work!

  • @DoUKnowMee
    @DoUKnowMee 3 года назад

    Can you do something like this with modern technology solutions

  • @donovantrevillato4869
    @donovantrevillato4869 5 лет назад

    Omg its amazing i want to be your student from Brazil! Thank you teacher!

  • @tim40gabby25
    @tim40gabby25 4 года назад

    Servos for the thumb in the palm, others in forearm? Great video, more informative than edited triumphs.

  • @NO4H1C
    @NO4H1C 7 месяцев назад

    For the price range how much did it cost

  • @melindapocsai590
    @melindapocsai590 2 года назад

    Hi! From where did you get the pulley for the servos? I can't find them anywhere!!!

    • @WillDonaldson
      @WillDonaldson  2 года назад +1

      the black pulleys? I custom 3D printed them

    • @melindapocsai590
      @melindapocsai590 2 года назад

      @@WillDonaldson is there any possibility to send the files for them please? I was trying to find them to buy them, but can't find it anywhere

    • @WillDonaldson
      @WillDonaldson  2 года назад

      @@melindapocsai590 the CAD model is linked in the description. This project is 5 years old, and so beyond the files that are already published, this is not a project that I am actively working on or supporting

    • @melindapocsai590
      @melindapocsai590 2 года назад

      @@WillDonaldson that's the thing, I've checked the files, and the black pulley is attached to the servos, in such way, it doesn't let me sellect the pulley separately to save it as STL. File and print it. It is understandable that you don't work anymore on it, it's been a long time.

  • @ThePrakharSahu
    @ThePrakharSahu 5 лет назад

    Keep up your good work .
    I'm looking forward to.

  • @cognisant307
    @cognisant307 6 лет назад

    If that's a failure I can't wait to see what you call a success, putting the servos in the hand and getting it to work at all is extremely impressive, maybe try getting someone with a better 3d printer to make your parts?

  • @ascabusi
    @ascabusi 5 лет назад

    kEEP IT UP, it looks amazing..

  • @juancarlosabad3298
    @juancarlosabad3298 4 года назад

    good try...but i would have never "redesigned" (= destroyed) the servos to start with as you did...the inner closed loop controller need the feedback of the resistor to complete the closed loop and stop rotating the motor...even if that would not be the case the use of servos for such application is extremely tricky because they are position controlled and there is no pressure feedback to stop them from pressing when the prosthetic hand grabs and object...in those cases the servos will be stressed , unless you use the strings and additional springs to absorb part of the stress, i guess....

  • @protechprogramming6095
    @protechprogramming6095 6 лет назад

    Which software do you use for designing ?

  • @Jai_Lopez
    @Jai_Lopez 7 лет назад

    This design like great Although I would Def change a couple things myself, I'm building a andros now a year and I'm currently doing toes and fingers as well as orbital socket and it is a challenge, keep up the good work my man the only a few of us who are no bodies but can take on projects like this.
    If I may spend more time in fusion 360 with this model and play around with your caliper once you get this done printer model orientation will be the best next thing to play with, in other words don't keep positioning your model the same way on the printer and STOP using support only use raft

  • @mikedobson7453
    @mikedobson7453 4 года назад

    great project.......more!!

  • @karismcconnellcoulsonlives7898
    @karismcconnellcoulsonlives7898 6 лет назад

    i hope do do a science project on this, and i was wondering if there was any way that you could share the 3D printing coding so i can work off that.

  • @briannawilliams5655
    @briannawilliams5655 6 лет назад

    How much did all the materials on average cost you?