rooferkim i am so glad you found and like The National. My mother is 71 and likes them, my daughter is 22 and saw them live last night for the third time in the last three years. They are without question my absolute faves, after 15 + years of listening they still [implorable emotions] make my eyes water!
Yours is the best comment I have read on RUclips, in like, the longest time. Thank you, my friend. The National have been my absolute favourite band for a decade and yet today - 7th November 2019 - is the first time I've ever landed on this song! I've since learned that it's an ode to a long-ago Scottish song, but Matt's voice and the boys musical arrrangement, is over-welmingly - beautiful. Long may you keep enjoying them, as I do.
this is an auld scots sang(bonnie lass o fyvie'o) that bob dylan adapted in the early 60s. he also adapted another scots sang......farewell to tarwathie to farewell angelina. he also adapted another scots sang.....the road and the miles to dundee to the walls of redwing. he also adapted another 4 scots sangs.
I got to experience this performance in person. I don't have much for words, but it was amazing. It's better heard in this video/clip, but the atmosphere that night was amazing. Huddle up among like-minded music-loving humans, in between concert stages (even though this was the only going on), and very little wind in the bottom of a river-bed near the Chippewa River.
I've seen these guys 5 times, and each night I saw them was amazing in its own right. Having said that, I've always wanted to hear this rendition of Peggy-O live, what a treat for those who got to experience this.
I’ve heard many versions and interpretations of this song and I’d have to say this band does a fantastic version. The vocals are clear for a live performance and the guitar work superb. Excellent upload.
This song!!! Wow and what a PERFORMANCE!! I cannot listen to this once; I have to re-listen at least twice. Goosebumps every time. Man. APPLAUSE for the band!
I am just moved and blown away with tears streaming down my cheeks. The sound ,the emotions of this guy...I wasn't expecting this. i had forgotten about this Civil War Song( I've heard it was originally Scottish) until I recently watched a clip of Lead Guitarist G. E. Smith of Saturday Night Live House Band in the 70's talking about first meeting Bob Dylan. Then weirdly enough I came upon one of the The Grateful Dead Versions just 2 days ago and now THIS. I am 68 , played (piano) and have listened to many versions of many Songs from long ago to present. But NEVER something this Hauntingly beautiful. Thank you for transporting me back to The Civil War Days (or to Scotland), a true love lost , and s broken Heart best 7 mins and 12 seconds in quite a long time. An excellent surprise. Love this and will share with many Thanks for Posting this !
it's an adaptation of a scottish sang called the bonnie lass o fyvie'o. a think bob dylan was the first to arrange it ."fennario" he also used other scots melodies for more of his sangs.
I will always regret not going to this concert when i had the chance. Its still my favorite live version of this song . No matter how many times I've seen them live .
this reminds me of when i saw the National live this year for their "sleep well beast" tour. Matt forgot the lyrics to 'i need my girl' and he screamed into the Mic "I CAN REMEMBER" I wanna go back to that night.
Thinking of a lovely friend who passed this week. Fly high Catherine, you were one of the nicest that I had the pleasure of having met. An extraordinary woman that was called way to early.
My dad introduced me to The National at a young age and we grew up listening to them together. I've for some reason always known since the first time I heard this cover that I want it to be my father-daughter dance with him at my wedding. Can't wait for that moment.
I love this song. And what an incredible interpretation! Never heard of The National before I found this. Comments are accurate. Heart wrenching and beautiful!
who exactly gave this thumbs down? Gee...what a masterpiece, and I just learned that Kaufman did an album with Bob Weir a few years back - Blue Mountain - just bought it a second ago - that's gonna be good, if this is any clue...
This is dope by all measure, that guitar solo notwithstanding. But what I really like, is when your man walks off after laying the vocal down for the first measured bit of the song there, then he quenches his thirst. I feel it was a still well-iced drink. I felt those ice cubes hit my own teeth. It was watery; the drink was watered down. It was likely whiskey and water. Or a watery whiskey. I want that it was.
Yes. Yes it does, and the dirt and grime and pain and longing and fears and regrets all wash down my cheeks and collide where she used to kiss me.., hoping she’ll come home soon and kiss me again.
@@elaztec.azteccaYes it DOES make me tear up. A beautiful rendition of a well loved song. But your comment crushed my heart to pieces while the tears flow freely , more than they have in so long. I do hope she did come home and all is well. Maybe she did not and you have moved on as Your comment was a year ago...maybe you'll see this maybe you won't but I'm sending you prayers, positive vibes and energy thru the cosmos - may they find you in peace, love joy and Contentment ..use them as you need them - wherever this finds you!
This and the first year might've been the strongest years. '15 was a low-key tribute to The Dead with 90% of the bands in lineup featured on the Day of the Dead comp. I heard a fair amount of them doing those covers at ExC. The collaborative efforts also made it the most energetic of years. Of course each year has something amazing to it - seeing John Prine in the pouring rain was a one of a kind experience!
heartbreaking and so true...a young poor soldier on his way to war falls in love but is rejected for his lack of funds then loses his life and is barely mourned....300 years old or did it happen yesterday..??
Timeless . I wonder if he ever could've imagined for one min -- that his story would be so loved ,and still told over and over and over again . 300 year later we are still a sensitive ,human race - mourning his ,heartbreaking loss and feeling his pain....
Heard the acoustic cover of this Grateful Dead original first and then this a couple of years ago and was blown away. It’s the crescendo half way though that gets me!
![Grateful Dead - The Grateful Dead Movie [HD Remaster] | 50th Anniversary Watch Party](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JOciFuV2APg/mqdefault.jpg)
He sang this song like he was possessed by the soul of a brokenhearted ghost
10/10 no one else should cover this again.
It's a traditional song. Everyone should cover it.
Great comment. Wow!
Love this…but just saying that Vampire Weekend did a pretty good job.
I'm 70 and thought I'd seen and heard eveything musical. This is an incredible find.
rooferkim i am so glad you found and like The National. My mother is 71 and likes them, my daughter is 22 and saw them live last night for the third time in the last three years. They are without question my absolute faves, after 15 + years of listening they still [implorable emotions] make my eyes water!
your still a young gossoon as we'd say in the green land
@@melissathornton3475 tell your mother, she has good taste...tell your daughter...go to school😁😎
Yours is the best comment I have read on RUclips, in like, the longest time. Thank you, my friend.
The National have been my absolute favourite band for a decade and yet today - 7th November 2019 - is the first time I've ever landed on this song!
I've since learned that it's an ode to a long-ago Scottish song, but Matt's voice and the boys musical arrrangement, is over-welmingly - beautiful.
Long may you keep enjoying them, as I do.
The National are one of America's greatest 21st Century bands.
this is an auld scots sang(bonnie lass o fyvie'o) that bob dylan adapted in the early 60s. he also adapted another scots sang......farewell to tarwathie to farewell angelina. he also adapted another scots sang.....the road and the miles to dundee to the walls of redwing. he also adapted another 4 scots sangs.
❤❤ I never knew and here I am in the historic city of Edinburgh next door to a guy with a helicopter 🚁 🏰❤❤🎶🎶
Haunting yet soulful and beautiful rendition. You can feel it surrounding your body. A++++++++
This song is a heartbreaker and this version just gives me goosebumps. Matt's voice is in my top 3 of all time.
what's your top 3? :) I really love Andy Hull and Gregory Isakov, together with Matt
The guitars on this are just immense. The Dessners are talented beyond belief
isn't it so freakin amazing how many songs the dead introduced us to...well done here....
Horay yes. This is one of my favorite of theirs. What a find.
this breaks me into pieces
@filippo barbetta I sounds like William O is threatening war crimes for being jilted by Peggy O. Or is that just internal monologue on his behalf?
I got to experience this performance in person. I don't have much for words, but it was amazing. It's better heard in this video/clip, but the atmosphere that night was amazing. Huddle up among like-minded music-loving humans, in between concert stages (even though this was the only going on), and very little wind in the bottom of a river-bed near the Chippewa River.
To quote "life of brian" ... you lucky,lucky bastard! ❤
Jerry would like this. Well done
Gary Long ~ Jerry Lewis?
I agree Jerry would be proud of this!
@@viita13 Bob Dylan would love this version -- it is his favorite song
@@josephsegura8687 Jerry Garcia
Cant deny that. Bravo
I've seen these guys 5 times, and each night I saw them was amazing in its own right. Having said that, I've always wanted to hear this rendition of Peggy-O live, what a treat for those who got to experience this.
Groupe pas très connu en France. Quel dommage. Le chanteur et la musique sont de très haut niveau
@@remidipietrantonio8753 they do tour Europe a lot though, be on the lookout for tour dates out there!
I’ve heard many versions and interpretations of this song and I’d have to say this band does a fantastic version. The vocals are clear for a live performance and the guitar work superb. Excellent upload.
There’s something “Joshua Tree’esque” about this version that jumps out at me. Love it
Deffo U2 vibe
What a sound. Its the whole package. Haunting, deliberate, complex and totally unique. The National has to be the best band out of Cincy EVER!!!
This song!!! Wow and what a PERFORMANCE!! I cannot listen to this once; I have to re-listen at least twice. Goosebumps every time. Man. APPLAUSE for the band!
I was there and this was my first time seeing The National. As a big deadhead, I found a strong connection with the band as they played this
His voice - pure velvet.
Matt's voice is a panties dropper.
Please remind me to quote you, the next time people say men are shallow :D
I still can't believe I was there live watching this. And the way this video was shot is incredible. Just wow
Matt is a superb vocalist. Long may he continue.
I am just moved and blown away with tears streaming down my cheeks. The sound ,the emotions of this guy...I wasn't expecting this.
i had forgotten about this Civil War Song( I've heard it was originally Scottish) until I recently watched a clip of Lead Guitarist G. E. Smith of Saturday Night Live House Band in the 70's talking about first meeting Bob Dylan. Then weirdly enough I came upon one of the The Grateful Dead Versions just 2 days ago and now THIS. I am 68 , played (piano) and have listened to many versions of many Songs from long ago to present. But NEVER something this
Hauntingly beautiful. Thank you for transporting me back to The Civil War Days (or to Scotland), a true love lost , and s broken Heart
best 7 mins and 12 seconds in quite a long time. An excellent surprise. Love this and will share with many Thanks for Posting this !
Quite simply to your comment, ❤
it's an adaptation of a scottish sang called the bonnie lass o fyvie'o. a think bob dylan was the first to arrange it ."fennario" he also used other scots melodies for more of his sangs.
Listening with headphones on.. beautiful.
I will always regret not going to this concert when i had the chance. Its still my favorite live version of this song . No matter how many times I've seen them live .
What a great rendition of a classic! The National never disappoint! Great guitar work and phenomenal voice.
this reminds me of when i saw the National live this year for their "sleep well beast" tour. Matt forgot the lyrics to 'i need my girl' and he screamed into the Mic "I CAN REMEMBER" I wanna go back to that night.
Haha
did they restart or just continued?
He messed up these lyrics too -first line is “we marched on” not rode??/. Still really good
Fantastic ... THE NATIONAL give Life Again to this very old song ...
VOCALS & GUITARS are falling from Heaven .
Have been going deep on different versions of this song. From George and Gerry Armstrong to the Grateful Dead, this is one of the best
when everything is just amazing: band, video, sound. speechless
Thinking of a lovely friend who passed this week. Fly high Catherine, you were one of the nicest that I had the pleasure of having met. An extraordinary woman that was called way to early.
My dad introduced me to The National at a young age and we grew up listening to them together. I've for some reason always known since the first time I heard this cover that I want it to be my father-daughter dance with him at my wedding. Can't wait for that moment.
Possibly my favorite Grateful Dead cover. A true chill bumps song. Thank you, Corrie Folk Trio, for putting inspiration for this song into the world.
Sorry but this is not a grateful dead song.The song is hundreds of years old .The grateful dead does a nice job covering this classic .
One of my favorite moments from last year. Magical
What a tone on that guitar! Who says that a "guitar band" cannot make original and different sounding music
Absolutely 💯 love guitar music. The Dessner brothers are just so good, though.
On my 300th listen. Just brilliant.
I'm getting there myself 😅
brilliant 10 out of 10 for this one
I love this song. And what an incredible interpretation! Never heard of The National before I found this. Comments are accurate. Heart wrenching and beautiful!
This makes me wanna go back to the night i saw them for their 'sleep well beast' tour. Best night of my life
Same.
So restrained, just waiting to explode, I really wanted this rendition to crescendo but it doesn’t, just trails off in sadness.
Just like sweet William love for pretty Peggy-O
Beautiful.. his voice is so calming 💜💜💜
I'd heard of this song but really didn't know how strong it was. Superb rendition by The National.
Love this! Close the lights, lay in bed and listen to this again and again. #cancersucks
Hope you're okay now. It indeed sucks
Heard this live in Vancouver tonight! Goosebumps!
So on love with Beringer. Amazing voice! Saw him last night with Bob Weir & John Mayer. Great show!
who exactly gave this thumbs down? Gee...what a masterpiece, and I just learned that Kaufman did an album with Bob Weir a few years back - Blue Mountain - just bought it a second ago - that's gonna be good, if this is any clue...
What a fantastic performance ! Thanks.
A really wonderful cover of a very, very, beautiful song.
Can't get better than this
This is dope by all measure, that guitar solo notwithstanding. But what I really like, is when your man walks off after laying the vocal down for the first measured bit of the song there, then he quenches his thirst. I feel it was a still well-iced drink. I felt those ice cubes hit my own teeth. It was watery; the drink was watered down. It was likely whiskey and water. Or a watery whiskey. I want that it was.
Wow. So patient deep and rich. Great work all of you, I could hear each of you, sweeeeeeeeeeeeet!!!!!
Wow. There are some tears I didn't see coming. Thanks. Great song choice and performance.
Thank God Great Minds STILL Exist....Beauty Comes In All Shapes, Sizes and At ANY GD Time✌
Beautiful.
Does this make anyone else tear up?
Yes. Yes it does, and the dirt and grime and pain and longing and fears and regrets all wash down my cheeks and collide where she used to kiss me.., hoping she’ll come home soon and kiss me again.
@@elaztec.azteccaYes it DOES make me tear up. A beautiful rendition of a well loved song.
But your comment crushed my heart to pieces while the tears flow freely , more than they have in so long.
I do hope she did come home and all is well. Maybe she did not and you have moved on as Your comment was a year ago...maybe you'll see this maybe you won't but I'm sending you prayers, positive vibes and energy thru the cosmos - may they find you in peace, love joy and Contentment ..use them as you need them - wherever this finds you!
@@maryoconnor9360 she came home 🧡♥️
Beautiful ! Thanks for posting.
please oh please release the full concert
YESSSSS..... LET'S PROTEST!! FULL CONCERT PLEASE
I haven't seen this whole show but you can find all things "The National" on https::/www.americanmary.com
Its so magical. Thank you so much.
goose bumps
Not sure what brought me here but I am glad I did ........
I was there and saw this live!! Eaux Claire 2015!!
What a song
Very nice gentlemen. Thank you.
This is so fucking beautiful.
This and the first year might've been the strongest years. '15 was a low-key tribute to The Dead with 90% of the bands in lineup featured on the Day of the Dead comp. I heard a fair amount of them doing those covers at ExC. The collaborative efforts also made it the most energetic of years.
Of course each year has something amazing to it - seeing John Prine in the pouring rain was a one of a kind experience!
Pretty amazing cover.
THis version is way better than the itunes one
Boy from instagram brought me here and I think I’m in the right place.
5/5
heartbreaking and so true...a young poor soldier on his way to war falls in love but is rejected for his lack of funds then loses his life and is barely mourned....300 years old or did it happen yesterday..??
Timeless.
Timeless . I wonder if he ever could've imagined for one min -- that his story would be so loved ,and still told over and over and over again . 300 year later we are still a sensitive ,human race -
mourning his ,heartbreaking loss and feeling his pain....
Wow ....wonderful 😊
This rendition of Peggy-O is the best I have ever heard.
it's really great but let's not get carried away
NOOOOO! But it is very, very good.
Love the National
Amazing voice, great cover!
you are from paradise ,national
No one has done it better
True Brilliance.
Fuckin' beautiful cover of a beautiful song, The Bonnie Lass of Fyvie-O and Jerry Garcia would be proud.
Heard the acoustic cover of this Grateful Dead original first and then this a couple of years ago and was blown away. It’s the crescendo half way though that gets me!
Great song all the way through, but you're right. The crescendo in the middle takes it to a way different level! Great comment and observation.
Perfection 👌
Wow best version ever!!!
try the Englishtown '77 version
Check out Joan Baez's crystalline finger picking to this, as 'Fennario'.
Sorry but this blows away 77 grateful dead
Amazing!
so beautiful :)
Excellent version of a classic old folksong, often done by the Grateful Dead.
Unreal, fantastic
They Played this at the St. Augustine Amp last night. The crowd was mesmerized, such a beautiful rendition.
Love this
I call this Peggy-Eaux
Peggy- Eaux brilliantl!! 🙌
Beautiful
Love it.
Do The National know this song from Grateful Dead something else the same way as I know this song or is it a coincidence?
Yes, they know this song
I love ❤it so much...
I’ve never heard anyone explain this song so well.
Maybe Jerry Garcia?
Heaven on earth 💓
Beautiful!
Beautiful!
Ich liebe seine Stimme 🥰
Saw the Dead do this in Vegas in the 94 I think.
Wonderfull
If you're here, listen? Listen to his tone. Observe his mannerisms. Art personified
I found this on a Days Gone playlist in Spotify :D
Same
საოცრება ❤
TYJ..nothing will ever compare to him. But nevertheless beautiful and haunting , great job guys!
if only I could see this live:’(
Try and make sure you do. Amazing experience.
Perfekt TNX
God bless the Grateful Dead
13 julho 2018. estou lá