"Non Veg" Debunked | Response to Dr Sivaraman | Vegan | Tamil |
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 фев 2019
- Watch my previous response video here : • Madan Gowri Debunked |...
Dr. Sivaraman is a very famous Siddha Medicine doctor from Coimbatore. He has lakhs if not crores of people who listen to his words. He has in one video however spread a lot of misinformation and also promoted the consumption of animal products. This video has become a highlight for many to put Veganism down as an unhealthy lifestyle. Watch my response video as I debunk all of his wrong claims in the video.
Links to mentioned studies :
Dietary Cholesterol raises serum cholesterol levels : www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9...
High LDL levels lead to plaque formation in arterial walls : www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2...
How much cholesterol and saturated fat is safe? :
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2...
Casein and cancer growth :
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
Choline and cancer growth :
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
Heme iron and cancer growth :
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
ALA consumption is enough to get appropriate EPA and DHA :
www.sciencedirect.com/science...
ALA consumption is not enough to get appropriate EPA and DHA :
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9...
Bacteria producing B12 :
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
B12 producing bacteria in the gut :
www.jstor.org/stable/2482180?...
Water Treatment leading to loss of B12 :
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
Arvind, hats off to your work on debunking Dr.Sivaraman's incorrect statements. Please keep up the good work. You are helping a lot of humans, animals and the planet by promoting veganism.
Flaxseed
Chia seeds , rich in Omega 3
Can u buy and supply to all...do you know the rates of those.?
@@shortcut420 😂 just shared some information, nothing to offend
@@rohan7ben655 it's k...even i too stopped eating n.v for the past 4 yrs after my 25 yrs of intense eating habit bec of family nurturing...but to be stable in avoiding n.v is much stressful thing...since I cannot forget the grown up taste along with it.so atleast avoiding the celebration of n.v foods decided to have little n end up.
And pursulane . Which is more higher
Great information 🙏
Are the B12 supplements free from meat and dairy ? How are they produced?
It is produced from the soil by a group of bacterias called Cyanobacteria. It is made up of mostly Cobalt (it is a chemical). Cows and animals meat has B12, because they come in contact with the bacteria in the soil. Hence, meat has b12. (They are eating B12 from the soil).
You can take a supplement of B12 - which is essentially Cobalt compounds - and you will get it normally. Otherwise, you can eat a lot of ground veggies - boiled (not fried).
But supplementing is the way to go.
Traditional Tamil food. Palaya soru (fermented rice) known to be a rich source of Vitamin B12 (probably due to the bacteria being produced in the fermented rice)!
It is an excellent info which will relieve N number of vegans who cringe on taking artificial supplements...
Please spread this info.
Great info. I am concerned about B12. I am now vegetarian. Planning to become vegan.
100% true on all your answers here Arvind... Even I became B12 deficient due to Vegan lifestyle; I was not aware of the B12 deficiency. Only on my recent blood test I came to know about this deficiency. Have started consuming B12 fortified foods now. Thanks a lot for the clarity. Keep it up.
Sir 32.30 to 33 u told plant have not B12 but b/w time plant having b12 it transfer to animal.it how pls explain??????
Plants innately don't contain B12. B12 is found in the soil (because the soil contains bacteria which produce B12). Now when cattle consume grass or plants from the soil, some amount of soil along with the bacteria is consumed by the animal, and hence the animal has B12 in its body.
Do you have a patreon?
Why are some people disliking this video?? Someone is trying to help us with RIGHT knowledge. Crazy mindset, dislike your thoughts and not this video.
Right mindset ??!! this guy brainwashes and pushes his ideology and sells this to vegan based products companies ,,,there is no animal love he has ,,,
@@dhineshkumars1991 No bro you got it wrong. He is the other way, he left his job only for saving the life of poor animals. Vegan is a loss business in India. Vegan need not buy anything, he showed us simple vegan recipes - which means he is promoting the local farmers. Take a try think through. I can assure Arvind is selfless soul he is sacrificing his luxury for the animals, i bow at him. He left is job a High paying Amazon for the sake of poor animals. its not easy in this world were selfishness in predominant. I am wonder-struck with his determination irrespective of the ill minded and the dirty comments by the most stupidest minds of TN. He is a warrior. He deserves Gods blessings and he is in my prayers too.
@@dhineshkumars1991 which company.. its people like you who are giving money to companies like KFC, MCd, dominoes and those who fucked the native poultry industry
@@VNalini....Nope being a vegan is not easy. Nowadays non veg eating vlog became a popular in social media. And you can't stop millions of chicken killed in KFC for food around the world per day
Arvind vallarai greens have a lot of b12 available please describe about this
Agreed about your point about B12 for vegans, but doctors are advising B12 supplement even for meet eaters these days, since the B12 in the soil is killed by the pesticides. So B12 deficiency is universal.
All contents are good. Except B12 matter, B12 is rich in pazhaya saadham, fermented rice. Matter solved.
@All in one Tamilan Da dude.. are you a Dr ? He's right. Cyanocobalamin is produced by a type of bacteria. Fermentation is caused by bacteria. So there could be a link here. I don't wanna argue about this how part bcz I'm not well informed here. But studies have shown that fermented rice is Rich in B12.
Before mocking, we should search a little bit. And I'm open to your remarks if I'm wrong. Thank you!
Jagadish J thank you so much for this info
@All in one Tamilan Da U r correct only. B12 can be obtained from animals only. Fermented rice have bacteria. Bacteria is also an animal. According to the law of phylum organisms which have protein in it are animals. So Bacteria, birds, reptiles, fishes, animals, men are animals only. All are sources of B12.
@All in one Tamilan Da there are only two types of cells in this world. Plant cell and animal cell. Since bacteria contains prokaryotic single animal cell it is also an animal. I don't how to explain further. Atleast as a doctor do you know we are also animals..
@All in one Tamilan Da You are in academic level still. Should become researcher level. Should follow Dr. B M Hegde.
Do Fermented rice has B12?
Arvind thank you for your great contribution
speaking off Noble prize example, this is what I interpretted from his speech "Eating non-veg makes people less intelligent is false, in fact there are people who are intelligent who also eat non-veg". but you interpreted eating non-veg makes you intelligent 😂.
exactly
Still logical. I am saying 99.9% Nobel prize winners are non vegans. What will the audience think suddenly?? They will tend to think non-veganism is better than veganism. Which will only mean non-veganism makes you smarter? So what he argued is clearly logical. You did not get the point? It's so easy to infer.
@@santhosh_se5476 What the doctor said was a reply to the stupid remark of non-vegans being unintelligent by a certain part of vegans
Yes when I saw Dr Sivaramans wrong info few years back in that q&a reg fiber in nonveg, I was shocked how much hez misinformed❗❗❗
I don't know why people dislike and discourage this angelic men, People can just skip if they dont like,please don't dislike or bad comments on this section, he is my visible dhev roop..please spread good if you don't atleast don't abolish goodness 🙏🙏
Great 👍🏻 zero fiber in non Veg food .. fiber only in veg ... Nowadays b12 defencicy to both veg & non Veg everyone must supplement..
That's not crt non vegetarians some have absorption problem and they avoid particular nonveg items so they affect but vegetarian mostly have vitamin b12 deficiency , Because b12 is high in non veg , im pure vegetarian , I have also deficiency 😥
@@gokulfashiontech3613 our saint are pure veg.olden days their is no b12 defencicy.b12 is current problem because of chemical life. High acid content animals product make gut problem.I know many non Veg people b12 defencicy.I know vegan of 18 year without b12 defencicy.vegan should check only b12.. Non vegan should have cholesterol,uric acid and many more.. Junk food Vegan is good.. Whole food vegan is healthy and disease free
@@antonyxaviour4685 I agree that's point😃& thank your long reply
Bro industry states agar agar vegan but algae lives in sea how its possible
Algae is not a sentient and pain feeling organism. It doesn't have a brain of its own. It doesn't have the ability to create an emotion. So it is vegan
Soyabean byproducts like milk has good content l, but it also has cancer producing substances. So what you say?
Bro I want subtitles
Yes He should add subtitles
Pls post your views on paleo diet ...
டாக்டர் சிவராமன் தாவர (சைவ) உணவை ஆதரிப்பவர் ௮ல்ல!
Be go vegan
Good work, even for vit b12 no need of supplements to be vegan we can get from fermented rice which consist of so many good bacterias which are able to produce vit b12
Hats off and thank you for the indepth analysis
Avar one by one answers pannitu irukaru time constraints la puranam solitu irukanuma. Avar 99% elam videos la veg than sapuda soli irukaru. Agasthiyar sidda maruthuvam books la non veg ah medicineku kuda use pannranga, google la search panni thane itana research screenshots share panninga, idaum search pannaavum, Still i wont eat not veg aduku vegan is only best nu solla mudiyadhu
Perfect and rational. Keep going Arvind. You ARE cent percent correct.
Like Sivaji says in the movie 'Dhevar Mahan ' ,people will change, but gradually only.
Thodarattum ungal theevira samuha saevai. Stay blessed Arvind !
I am vegetarian, Edo pesanume nu pesura, aduku nee eduvume sapudama irukanum, Keerai romba nalladhu ana adula use pannra fertilizer ah stop panna solu. namba sapudura elam food la chemicals iruku, life span in older year is more than current generation, Even mahabharam pandavas eat non veg, Alavuku meerinal amirthamum nanju.
can you tell to lions to not eat animals
Love your videos but the English subtitling translation is so bad..Is it possible that you can do the subtitling/ translation editing yourself. Thank you.
Sir you are great, thanks for your concern
How about oils
OK Aravind fine... I watch Sivaraman and yours videos...U are having lot of questions why can't u discuss with him directly and post that video, instead of telling who is right or wrong based on some published papers proof...
This will be good one right... As a audience and followers we will get more valuable points to follow in our life...
Only person on RUclips who use Research papers and quote them, whom I have seen. There are a lot of misnformation in RUclips.
Sir nenga milk sapida kudathunu soldringa ana manithan piranthu sapidura muthal unave milkthana sir
Yes exactly you only need milk when you are a baby and it is only for you and mom don't give milk after you grow up because it isn't necessary.
Matha vilangugal oda paal dhan sapda koodadhunu soldrar.enna andha paal adhoda kolandhai kaaga thai kitta secrete aagum adhu maari namma mother kitta kedaikura milk namaku dhan adha vera oru vilangu vandhu kudukadhu
Daiiii......entha food irunthalum....alavuku meerina amuthamum nanchu.... monthly 2 3 times edukurathu wrong illa...6 7 Times edukurathu tha wrong.....
👍👌
Bro singam meat thaan saappiduthu itanaala athu heart attack vanthu death aakanume
bro..there are many things that animals eat that humans dont
@@ilangonadar7669 maadum taavare unni thaan appa neenga ean tavaram saapitanum
@Vegan Vamshi Krishnan yellarum vegans ah maarunga food chain spoil Agatha
Hello brother all are right we want some amount of fat that absorb vitamins called fat soluble vitamins.
Non vegetarian increase ldl ok and also vegetarian carbohydrate foods also increase triglycerides that also cholesterol you know?
My long term doubts cleared bro....
Aravind Please speak about Paleo diet tooo
Balanced diet is always best.
I agree with you @ 5:57. Its exactly the same way you got so much " likes" and positive comments.
🙏 Thanks brother today only I seen your video. I am from Madurai. I see your history video. Recently 5 days before only I changed vegan. Sundar JC you tube channel. Now I was more clear from your video.
Bro iam vegetarian but y dnt talk about in india beef export is doing ur cast bhramin pls talk about this
Super bro thanks for the video
Yes non veg is an non alive thing oru non alive thimg la nalla protein and nutrition vida ketta bacteria will be high so youll may ask they plant also live so we killing that but oru plant da seed ,stem or plant part ah soil la vacha reproduce aagum
Reason for all vitamin,mineral and iron is not occuring due to consumption of food in ancient tym people use to eat palaya soru ,raagi and stuff this occurs due to unhealthy gut so stomach cleansing will help u to get rid of all deficiency thjs is mentioned by siddhars and now agreed by dr
Anna please could you Upload Videos in English too please. Because Im North Indian but Im your Big Fan.🙏😍😘🌺🌹🌷
english subtitle is already there for most of his videos.. press "CC" on the video.
நெஞ்சம்போல் நன்றூக்கா தொன்றன்
உடல்சுவை யுண்டார் மனம்
Translation: The mind of a person who carries murderous weapon to kill another person is same as the mind of the one who consumes meat.
Implication: Thiruvalluvar conveys that killing an animal and consuming meat is no different from killing another human being and thus he stresses how the life of other animals are as important as human lives. This reflects the state of Indian society at that time where many humans considered animals like cow as a part of their family, which is seldom to see in contemporary times.
Is it right to consume milk which is a mothers milk for a calf. If its ok to consume milk then why we human's milk is not intended for any other animals?
There is just no red blood oozing out of any tree or plant while you chop and murder. Does that mean you are not harming?
Batham pistha munthiri groundnut walnut ithalam thavarem illaya bro ithula fat illaya
Good point. Yes they have fat, but mono and Di saturated fats aren't present in nuts. They don't have any cholesterol or saturated fats, and hence are safe for consumption.
Valid....super explanation
Adha thavara most of the points that u have mentioned is correct
Bro let us union all the vegan follower .We all stand for one thing quote "SAY NO TO KILL ANIMALS FOR FOOD" organizations will
bring change and bring faith for vegan follower.Let us change happen bro.
Great counter bro... you just ripped this guy apart..
I change to vegan after hear Vallalar thaughts
Dr. Shivaraman is right 😎😎😎
I agree to the fact...I support veganism however, i am still not able to reduce the consumption of ghee in my diet. And i guess there cannot be any substitute for pure desi ghee. Veganism is still an underestimated concept in our country. I have few interesting raw vegan recipes in my channel - sugi talks. Do check out ! Came here after watching idiot box in kichdy!!!
Sir please go for vegan and help animals
When I see your debunking video, யார் சொல்லியிருந்தாலும், எங்கு படித்திருந்தாலும், நானே சொன்னாலும் உனது புத்திக்கும் பொது அறிவுக்கும் பொருந்தாத எதையும் நம்பாதே - தந்தை பெரியார்
Correct jii...
the way u present research journals is way more professional than Sivaraman.
Hello bro I am many times comments your video but your not responding and not answer my questions ORU video pota athuku genuine na reply panunga bro anyway I like your video's and last one year's subscription your Chanel
22:08 na chinna vayasula irundhu non veg sapudren but na obese ah illaye......gym poi workout pandravanga body builders ellam most ah non veg sapadravanga dhana.....avangala aarokyama illanu solringala?......apdi aama na edha vachi solringa.....(if needed I will give you proofs).....reply pls
Watch the game changers movie bro..,athula idha pathi clear ah explain pannirupanga
ruclips.net/video/ove9b16OeR4/видео.html
@@akash_sd ok thank you 😊
I follow a vegan diet and eat mostly Whole Foods and have a lot of vegetables. But I am still “clinically” obese. This has not come with the side effect of any health problems. I still have a great stamina. Please do not equate body shape and health. That is highly flawed and prejudiced
You can eat a high fat vegan diet, coconut, nuts, oils etc. have you tried eliminating oils and limiting nuts and coconuts? And then seen whether or not you lose fat?
Thanks anna for giving such great nutrients value 🙌
I'm a vegan
Super video bro great job😍👍👏👏👏💚💚💚💚
How can you even understand him
Can you understand this kindergarten tell me what it means
Underrated utuber❣️
1.60 முதல் 90 நாட்களில் வளரக்கூடிய பாரம்பரிய சிவப்பு வகை நெல் அவல் மற்றம் சிறு தானியங்கள்
2.அதிக அளவிளான கீரை வகைகள்
3.மிதமான அளிவில் பல வகையான தோட்ட காய்கறிகள் மற்றும் காளான்கள்
4.குறைந்த அளிவிலான பருப்பு, பயிர் மற்றும் விதை வகைகள்
5.கோதுமை புல் அல்லது அருகம்புல் துள்
6.பனைமரம் அல்லது தென்னைமர பதநீர்
7.குறைந்த அளவில் ஆங்காங்கே வளரும் பழங்கள்
8.சூரிய ஔியில் நடமாடுதல்
9.வாரம் இரண்டு வேளை மட்டும் 6 மாதங்கள் வளரக்கூடிய ஆதிக ஆற்றல் நிறைந்த அரிசி வகைகள்
சிவப்பு அரிசி சமைப்பதற்கு அதிக நேரம் மற்றும் எரி பொருள் தேவைபடுவதால் அவல் என்பது ஒரு நல்ல தீர்வு
மேற்கண்ட உணவு முறையை பெரும்பாலானோர் பின்பற்றினால் அதிக அளவில் தண்ணீர் சேமிக்கப்படுவதோடு அனைத்து இந்தியர்களுக்கும் ஊட்டச்சத்து மிகுந்த உணவு கிடைக்கும்.மேலும் யோகா, உடற்பயிர்சி, தியானம், மூலிகை மருத்துவம் அடிப்படை ஆரோகியத்திற்கு போதுமானது. இது அனைத்தும் யோகா மற்றும் இயற்கை மருத்துவர்களால் ஏற்றுக்கொள்ளப்பட்டது!!! தமிழராய் ஒன்றினைவோம்!!!
Vegetables and Fruits are disposals of a tree and plants hence they are not nails and hairs for a human.
Unga hard work research and detailed explaination romba nallaruku bro.. u deserve million subscribers.. and you will reach it soon..
கோழியை சாப்பிடுவதற்கு பதில் காடை சாப்பிடுவது நல்லது என்று சொல்கிறார்.சைவ உணவு சாப்பிடுபவர்கள் நிறைய பேர் குண்டாக இருக்கிறார்கள். அசைவ உணவு சாப்பிடுபவர்கள் ஒல்லியாக இருப்பவர்களும் இருக்கிறார்கள். அசைவ உணவு சாப்பிட்டு வந்தவர்கள்,தாவர உணவிற்கு மாறும் போது மிகவும் வீக்காக உணர்கிறோம்.ஆகவே அவர் அப்படி சொல்கிறார் என்று நினைக்கிறேன்.
Arvind You are wrong about your argument on intelligence. Dr. Sivaraman said eating non veg won't make you dumb/stupid and to support his statement he said 99% of the noble laureates ate beef. Noble laureates are some of the brilliant individuals on the planet where their non veg eating habits did not make them intelligent or dumb. So being a veg/non veg won't make you a dumb or intelligent. Arvind your are right in terms of fiber non veg do not have any fiber only vegan food has fiber.
Intelligence comes from the vision and not depends on food. If it comes from food, the world won't have many inventions.
Superb work bro 👌👌👌
This changed my life
Semmmmaaa iam unexpected but this is 100%correct,iam a big fan of sivaraman
யார் சொல்லியிருந்தாலும், எங்கு படித்திருந்தாலும், நானே சொன்னாலும் உனது புத்திக்கும் பொது அறிவுக்கும் பொருந்தாத எதையும் நம்பாதே - தந்தை பெரியார்
In my view, it is absolutely stupid to take sides on veg or non-veg. People who consume non-veg don't take them 3 times a day, and people who take meat also love taking veggies. Food should be considered a tool to nourish our health. A conscious choice is a result of what we become. There are a lot of factors that influence our food consumption. It could be availability, economic situation, geography, and personal preferences. Interfering in one's eating habits and supporting one diet and spreading hatred against another is just a waste of time.
It is not waste of time it is called making awareness...
Now you will say that okay Earth is destroying animals are dying but in my point of view there is absolutely no sense in Earth day and making awareness about Earth or the world environment day don't make awareness it's waste ot time
In this day and age, availability is not a problem anywhere, it’s excess. Also you should be asking what’s the optimal diet for human health? What nutrition science have you looked into? Forget the animals, it’s good for humans to eat plants and not consume animal products.
Good things your great👍👏 🌷👍🙏🙏🙏
Fiber content 😂 I agree with you 😂😂 he make have done Ph.D in Other stream I think so
Doctor thappana vishayam sonna dhan, avaroda hospital ku customers (patients) kedaippanga!
👍
First time hearing bro speaking tamil
Awesome
Hi brother. U r awesome
Non vegetarian rich in fibers. This statement alone shows what kind of doctor this guy is. Not sure why people are listening to this obese doctor. Truly amazing
Be conscious of what you promote. In this whole episode, you have subtly promoted hugo boss. Promote Veganism instead of wearing irrelevant t shirts.
The first statement that you make is absolutely make no sense. As a vegetarian, I do not eat for ethical reasons. Brilliance and Intelligence is nothing do with eating habits. Plants vs Animals. Both have life. But, between the two, Plants are better, though we know plants has life, as humans, we have to choose which is better of the two.
I support you bro
Sotru neer la b12 iruku brother
See mathavanga epdi nu theriyadhu.. I love animals.naa adhanala sapdama irkan.neenga vegans ku support pandran nu solitu naanga superior feeling panradhukaga apdi act pandren nu oru statement edhuku poteenga
நண்பரே வணக்கம் மிகவும் சிறப்பான பதிவு
Do you eat salt 🤔 it’s from sea.
Please also stop eating salt 🧂
It’s refine so you’ll eat that? 🤔🤔🤔
There is no single atom of poop in the salt you buy don't worry
True
👌
thanks i turned to vegan
Iduku Mela nee video pota enaku semmaya koovam varum
Koovam Ah ...
❤
Super bro
Am ur hater but this video of urs is nice though am nt a vegan.. Pls maintain this style and attitude unlike ur previous videos.. Its just my opinion, pls don't do those jump cuts like granny and other characters tats really disgusting.. This video really made me think wats wrong in becoming a vegan but ur previous videos made me think its better nt be a vegan..
Why BOSS ?? 👽
Super ji
Thambi.over ra pesa tha ok va you vegans have vitamin B 12 deficiency we non veggiterians dont have that ! Moreover your ancestors were non vegetarians ate paleo diet and they were healthy without any.diseases !
B12 defeciency has no major impact if you need it you can take pills