In those five institutions that mr guha have mentioned which is not really independent today. I think judiciary is independent Mr. Guha. You can't say that judiciary is not independent bcz they are not giving judgement as left want them to be. And yeah judges knew the constitution better than us and they know how to interprete them.
Dr. Guha's clarity, satire, and insights into power struggles and instability are not only exceptional but also noteworthy, underscoring the significance that his nuanced perspectives bring to understanding the intricate dynamics of historical and contemporary socio-political landscapes.
People's say freedom of speech is in danger .he is bashing the pm who is loved so much in india ..these people who were are getting paid earlier for no brainers
court historians are like pet dogs - you give them a biscuit and they wag their tail. Watching Mr Guha rant about personality cult is like watching a dog wail and wag its tail in front of the body of its dead master - not knowing that there wont be any more biscuits. But key takeaway from his wailings is that the fate of many today's modi's court poets will also be like this in about 30-40 years - that's the inevitable kalachakra's act.
-Bills passed without discussion without consulting to parliamentary committee -Talking the power of NCRDelhi -Governors abuse in non bjp states -Reduce power of RTI 2019 amendment, election commission -UAPA on political dissent So on.... b/c of bukts and there cult
that penultimate question answer is so worth ... most indians dont have spine , the people in power bowing to modi is shame and they all are have a role for loss in declining indias democracy
How much ego! I, Guha, was disinvited. How dare they? And he talks of personality cult!😢 He is one of key members of the "praise durbar" of Nehru and his progeny. Thank you BLF was helping us understand the biases of the speaker. Hindus are seekers not followers of blind faith or 100% belief in "Books". Self annointed "certificate giver" of all issues under the sun.
You seems to be ignoramus as expected of any “ cult follower” and doesn’t “ listen too” as sycophants don’t. Guha is “ bitterest” critic of Nehru progeny, sadly you miss the point once your cult deity is referred to negatively anywhere , anytime. Have a good sleep - nightmare will follow, sooner than you can envisage.
I think that you missed what he has said about the Gandhis for the past few years. And was Atal ji a part of any "praise Durbar" when he called Pandit Nehru Bharat Mata's "favourite prince"? People like Pandit Nehru, Mahatma Gandhi, and Swami Vivekananda understood Hinduism and India at a much more profound level than Mrs Gandhi and many of our subsequent leaders. We should certainly seek the truth rather than dogmatically preferring any extreme position. 🙏🇮🇳☮️☮️
All the quotes attributed to Atal ji about Nehru being great or Indian being durga are fake. He clearly said that media would carry whatever news and his denials would never be printed. Thanks to social media that people get to know the real faces of people
He is an American, he doesn't need to talk about his country of origin all the time; however, he doesn't disparage his Hindu and/or Indian roots (remember the likes of Preet Bharara?). He takes pride in being a Hindu (hasn't converted to Christianity and fall in line with political requirements), is vegetarian and doesn't drink.@@ramaswamyvaidyanathan2121
In the name of personality cult, his total concentration is aimed at Modi and Modi only. Only for references only he talks about other cult leaders . But his only sim is to attack Modi only. Best example is his comparison between Barua and Nadda. His intentions are very clear. He is totally biased.
Excellent analysis on Modi's Hitler's Erdogens Putins.True ...after Modi there will never be a Modi in Indian politics just as after Hitler there was never a Hitler in Germany. This is History
Indira haha, Nehru was bigger than Indira, Gandhi was baap of cult, and his naked sleeping with his niece, still no one dare to speak about that till today.
Great session. Anybody who wants to be good professor in a globally reputed institute should study this session. Start from introductioc n generality, describe the specific wven and its likely impact, generalize it for all and then conclude. Introductiom n conclusion to be supported with references and your views in middle. And your specifoc answer in bullet points.
Loved it, totally! His thoughts about personality cults, and how democracy is being destroyed in the process. A real-time example shows how the speech ends and what is the current democracy doing to freedom of expression What a thorough historian and gentleman! I hope you get to see in your lifetime this regime going away. God bless you!
Great historian , enlightened indian, have certain political views, humanitarian, secular thoughts, such writers makes the nation great . Great Nation has been made by good human resources not by infrastructures .
What's your history ? Let's debate. If ready fix up date with J Saideepak & Vikram Sampath. I wish you better live next 100 years to know what historians write about Modi Era . You are epitaph of intellectual evil & mind poison ing divide. Don't blame IIMs for turning back because you are not even worth for post cast .
First they are not trained historian. Second go and read some historiography and populism based books. Your modi is not that good person as you think. Watch Prashant kishore's interview eventhough he admire Modi's strategy to win election, he's not that good heart person as your psedo historians claim.
Democracy has never been successful anywhere in most parts of the world. You cannot keep debating and discussing endlessly, nor can anyone (either a person or a party) make "flawless and perfect" decisions. Democracy brings the intelligent and the fool, the capable and the incapable, the dutiful and the irresponsible all at the same level because if works on the principle giving importance to the lowest common denominator (LCD, as we have in math) as well as the mood-of-the-mob mindset. This way it de-incentivises all talented people to be productive and creative to the best of their abilities, ultimately leading to poor performance of the country as a whole.
@@anon7641 I hope that now you have understood why talented people leave this country, or want to do so. It's because this country and its systems were designed by the Anglo-Americans and not changed after independence, like for example China did. That's why China, despite not even having the so-called "English advantage" (it makes me laugh to hear how learning a foreign language can ever be an "advantage" 😂), is doing much better than India. Because we are merely coolies for the Western establishment not making our own decisions.
Modi is not the greatest personality cult, that gold medal goes to Moahamd bin Abhulhha. Modi is milder verson of Mohamad. Modi has fewer followers than Mohamad has and will have in the future.
![[4K] Watch SpaceX Catch A Starship Rocket From Space!!! #IFT5](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pIKI7y3DTXk/mqdefault.jpg)
It's beautiful to see our beautiful India through the beautiful eyes of dr. Guha
41:32 this quote is mentioned in Political Science NCERT class 12th.👍
What a great speech it is, wonderful! Thourghly enjoyed this. I want "India after Modi" book from him.
In those five institutions that mr guha have mentioned which is not really independent today. I think judiciary is independent Mr. Guha. You can't say that judiciary is not independent bcz they are not giving judgement as left want them to be.
And yeah judges knew the constitution better than us and they know how to interprete them.
Dr. Guha's clarity, satire, and insights into power struggles and instability are not only exceptional but also noteworthy, underscoring the significance that his nuanced perspectives bring to understanding the intricate dynamics of historical and contemporary socio-political landscapes.
Problem is these people have ready made templates made for western culture n they impose on Indian culture.
Personality cult ? We only show in past slave of personality in gandhi family
Weak governments do not do their job this is the reason of strong personality and strong leader to do job as needs to be done
Democratic governments have nothing to do with weakness or strength.
Guha weeping is music to the ears.
I want louder wailing and crying
This hypocrite has never done anything in life produced worthless books on worthless Gandhi!
People's say freedom of speech is in danger .he is bashing the pm who is loved so much in india ..these people who were are getting paid earlier for no brainers
👍
👏👏 wonderful speech 😂👍
court historians are like pet dogs - you give them a biscuit and they wag their tail. Watching Mr Guha rant about personality cult is like watching a dog wail and wag its tail in front of the body of its dead master - not knowing that there wont be any more biscuits. But key takeaway from his wailings is that the fate of many today's modi's court poets will also be like this in about 30-40 years - that's the inevitable kalachakra's act.
Devotees of cult started barking without any reasoning 😂
Banglore literature Festival i request you to please dont call such people you are decreasing your creadibality as a platform.
It hurts when someone speaks truth right
-Bills passed without discussion without consulting to parliamentary committee
-Talking the power of NCRDelhi
-Governors abuse in non bjp states
-Reduce power of RTI 2019 amendment, election commission
-UAPA on political dissent
So on.... b/c of bukts and there cult
Cults are many in history. Gandhi had a cult, Nehru had a cult, Indira had a cult. Lord Ram has a cult. personality cults are many.
Lord Ram has a cult? Wow, you are really intelligent.
@@saurabhgrover863 Nothing negative- Islam is also cult group of 'you know who pbuh'. Cult - Followership is not a bad word.
Uff what an exceptional lecture, love this man and his thoughts! May India fight for its democracy
His false history must also be appreciated.
good to see still neutral intellectuals fighting for the constitutional values and democracy
Superb..
that penultimate question answer is so worth ... most indians dont have spine , the people in power bowing to modi is shame and they all are have a role for loss in declining indias democracy
44:00 he is liberal as long as he hears what he wants. What a hypocrite
IS THIS THE BEST THAT THE FAR LEFT HAS TO OFFER???😂😂😂 THAT CROWD WAS FULL OF PAPPU MUTTARS.
In any case better than your esteemed colleagues Mr. Kunal Pandey, Mr. Abhishek Chauhan and Mr. Saksham Patel.
How much ego! I, Guha, was disinvited. How dare they? And he talks of personality cult!😢
He is one of key members of the "praise durbar" of Nehru and his progeny. Thank you BLF was helping us understand the biases of the speaker.
Hindus are seekers not followers of blind faith or 100% belief in "Books". Self annointed "certificate giver" of all issues under the sun.
You seems to be ignoramus as expected of any “ cult follower” and doesn’t “ listen too” as sycophants don’t. Guha is “ bitterest” critic of Nehru progeny, sadly you miss the point once your cult deity is referred to negatively anywhere , anytime. Have a good sleep - nightmare will follow, sooner than you can envisage.
@@literarymusings8886 Yes. We all carry within ourselves the qualities of a shudra.
So you'll don't do bhakti of Modi?... what happens to your seeking then? Or are you not Hindu?
I think that you missed what he has said about the Gandhis for the past few years. And was Atal ji a part of any "praise Durbar" when he called Pandit Nehru Bharat Mata's "favourite prince"? People like Pandit Nehru, Mahatma Gandhi, and Swami Vivekananda understood Hinduism and India at a much more profound level than Mrs Gandhi and many of our subsequent leaders.
We should certainly seek the truth rather than dogmatically preferring any extreme position. 🙏🇮🇳☮️☮️
All the quotes attributed to Atal ji about Nehru being great or Indian being durga are fake. He clearly said that media would carry whatever news and his denials would never be printed. Thanks to social media that people get to know the real faces of people
The great Nehru-Ghandi Family history project goes on (they omit Feroze Ghandi all the time though he was a genuinely nice person).
True that they are rascals! But u know pheroze!???? Ur chacha eh that u defending him????
Totally Western orientation. Never heard him talk about our great Bharatiya Civilization. Obsession with West.
He is an American, he doesn't need to talk about his country of origin all the time; however, he doesn't disparage his Hindu and/or Indian roots (remember the likes of Preet Bharara?). He takes pride in being a Hindu (hasn't converted to Christianity and fall in line with political requirements), is vegetarian and doesn't drink.@@ramaswamyvaidyanathan2121
❤❤❤ Great guys who rejected. 🎉🎉😂😂 Due to unavoidable reasons stuffs. 😮
In the name of personality cult, his total concentration is aimed at Modi and Modi only. Only for references only he talks about other cult leaders . But his only sim is to attack Modi only. Best example is his comparison between Barua and Nadda. His intentions are very clear. He is totally biased.
For a gaumutra ideologue like you, everything is biased.
Goumuthra ideology is always superior to bull shit talk.
This bigot is a Nehru fan! What about Nehru's personality cult, Indira's personality cult?
You are liar , please go to Pakistan
Excellent analysis on Modi's Hitler's Erdogens Putins.True ...after Modi there will never be a Modi in Indian politics just as after Hitler there was never a Hitler in Germany. This is History
After Modi , Yogi is coming then HBS.Deal with it dumb@$$
Indira haha, Nehru was bigger than Indira, Gandhi was baap of cult, and his naked sleeping with his niece, still no one dare to speak about that till today.
Agree with Guha. Indeed Intellectual of our times.
Marxist intellectual true, but still not of any time.
He's so funny😂😂😂 good
Great session. Anybody who wants to be good professor in a globally reputed institute should study this session. Start from introductioc n generality, describe the specific wven and its likely impact, generalize it for all and then conclude. Introductiom n conclusion to be supported with references and your views in middle. And your specifoc answer in bullet points.
Loved it, totally! His thoughts about personality cults, and how democracy is being destroyed in the process. A real-time example shows how the speech ends and what is the current democracy doing to freedom of expression What a thorough historian and gentleman! I hope you get to see in your lifetime this regime going away. God bless you!
Forget Ram Guha! Your own entire bloodline will cease to exist before one might see an end to this regime! Now bark somewhere else! 😂😂😂
modi is indira gandhi on steriods ... that line made my day ... what a great fact in single line ,,,,,
I think Hes run out off his history script
But he did become standup comedian 😂
Arguably Independent India's greatest fiction writer
Hahaha his name wont be in top 100
Great historian , enlightened indian, have certain political views, humanitarian, secular thoughts, such writers makes the nation great . Great Nation has been made by good human resources not by infrastructures .
He is an egotist
Good talk thankyou
What's your history ? Let's debate. If ready fix up date with J Saideepak & Vikram Sampath. I wish you better live next 100 years to know what historians write about Modi Era . You are epitaph of intellectual evil & mind poison ing divide. Don't blame IIMs for turning back because you are not even worth for post cast .
First they are not trained historian. Second go and read some historiography and populism based books. Your modi is not that good person as you think. Watch Prashant kishore's interview eventhough he admire Modi's strategy to win election, he's not that good heart person as your psedo historians claim.
Topic has to be Gandhi then.. otherwise there is no point of debate..
Everybody gets it at 5:10
Too much ego
Exceptionally good. Thank you Ram sir.
Kolkata village’s UC Bhadralok who bombed opposition party workers month back getting orgasm by Ram guha’s democratic fiction.
Banglore literature Festival i request you to please dont call such people you are decreasing your creadibality as a platform.
Democracy has never been successful anywhere in most parts of the world. You cannot keep debating and discussing endlessly, nor can anyone (either a person or a party) make "flawless and perfect" decisions.
Democracy brings the intelligent and the fool, the capable and the incapable, the dutiful and the irresponsible all at the same level because if works on the principle giving importance to the lowest common denominator (LCD, as we have in math) as well as the mood-of-the-mob mindset.
This way it de-incentivises all talented people to be productive and creative to the best of their abilities, ultimately leading to poor performance of the country as a whole.
Best description of democracy i have ever come across
@@anon7641
I hope that now you have understood why talented people leave this country, or want to do so.
It's because this country and its systems were designed by the Anglo-Americans and not changed after independence, like for example China did. That's why China, despite not even having the so-called "English advantage" (it makes me laugh to hear how learning a foreign language can ever be an "advantage" 😂), is doing much better than India. Because we are merely coolies for the Western establishment not making our own decisions.
i think democracy will die in future either we will live in dicatorship or puppet gov controlling things behind the scenes @@anon7641
3rd world intellectuals like you would obviously beat your own drums.
Modi is not the greatest personality cult, that gold medal goes to Moahamd bin Abhulhha. Modi is milder verson of Mohamad. Modi has fewer followers than Mohamad has and will have in the future.
These urban naxals have lost it. So keep crying.
Guys please watch it at 1.5x and don't miss this. Best thing on internet today.
Banglore literature Festival i request you to please dont call such people you are decreasing your creadibality as a platform.
Bhakts cannot tolerate democracy, not your fault..you stay blinfolded. Kudos to BLF@@themyself1212
@@themyself1212blr slut fest never had a reputation
@@satarkinsaanlol americau akbar America is allah
Lapdog of foreign agents give us lectures
He's saying the truth
oh really? i think he is talking absolute bull crap
What kind of historian
As a GenZ😂 as long as our country is rich n nobody discriminate any other caste n sex place of birth etc.
Keep barking
Ramachandra Guha is a complete clown. He speaks rubbish 😡
This is good but you are not historian
Why do he looks like he lost his mind.
Banglore literature Festival i request you to please dont call such people you are decreasing your creadibality as a platform.
Speak proper English first.
You have PhD in English gomutra 😂
@@icxcnika345 when you have vile against a government without giving any coherent justification as to why personality cults exist in first place
Yawn
Shut up untouchable