There's just something about Nick caves voice that gives off this vibe like you should be careful of him but he could also be charming. I don't know I feel like if you came across all creepy and sinister right away it would not make sense, but the way he originally sounds so charming and then it gets darker and darker as the song goes on… I love it! This is Art. Real honest work of musical art, not like the crap coming out nowadays.
He does have serial killer tones and creepy voice that could convince you that you are safe. Beware Nick cave is different from other artists he has alot of charisma in his lyrics and voice. Like he could make you smile and laugh and tell you you going to be his next victim of sacrifice to the wild Rose of kylie and her sexy but not much else to go on . It'd be your fault cause you fell under his spell. 🥶🤯🎵🎶♥️💉
An absolutely fab song! I'd forgotten all about it until I watched TOTP on BBC 4 last week. Now I cannot get this tune out of my head. But, just want to acknowledge how beautiful Kylie was in this video.
Today is my birthday, I baked a red velvet from wild roses I collected from my backyard as we're in lockdown can't find vanilla at the supermarkets. The flavor was so intense and that cake was addictive it reminds me of this song, sweet and wild 🌹❤️
@@penny-t6f А я то все думала, почему он все время камушек в руке вертит. Так это он её получается? А, ну да- перевод прочитала. "Красота должна умереть"
i was in a very nervous and chaotic state of mind, kinda lost myself and was willing to change for society and somehow today my uber driver was playing this song and i shazamed it and i felt so peaceful. i don’t know what it is about it but i feel like it’s one of those precious songs i don’t want to share because it brought me back to me and that’s an intimate feeling. it reminded me of how peaceful i am and how i always had higher aspirations than just the regular joes
Underrated? Girl listen, when this song came out it was a blast during my time on Mtv. Absolute hit! And it ages with time so well. Love it till this very day!
They call me The Wild Rose Меня зовут Дикой Розой, But my name was Elisa Day Но мое имя Элайза Дэй. Why they call me it I do not know Почему меня так называют? For my name was Elisa Day Ведь мое имя Элайза Дэй... From the first day I saw her I knew she was the one Увидев ее в первый день, я знал - она единственная. She stared in my eyes and smiled Она посмотрела мне в глаза и улыбнулась, For her lips were the colour of the roses Её губы - цвета роз, That grew down the river, all bloody and wild Что растут вдоль берега реки, такие алые и дикие... When he knocked on my door and entered the room Он постучал в мою дверь, My trembling subsided in his sure embrace И мой трепет растворился в его уверенных объятиях. He would be my first man, and with a careful hand Он был моим первым мужчиной и заботливой рукой, He wiped up the tears that ran down my face Нежно вытер слезы, что текли по моему лицу. Припев☺ On the second day I brought her a flower На второй день я принес ей цветок, She was more beautiful than any woman I'd seen Она была красивее всех женщин, что я видел, And I said, 'Do you know where the wild roses grow И я спросил: "Знаешь ли ты, где дикие розы растут, So sweet and scarlet and free?' Такие ароматные, алые и вольные?" On the second day he came with a single red rose На второй день он пришёл с одной красной розой Said: 'Give me your loss and your sorrow?' И сказал: "Доверь мне свою потерю и печаль" I nodded my head, as I lay on the bed Я лишь кивнула и легла на кровать. If I show you the roses will you follow?' "Если я покажу тебе розы, ты последуешь за мной?" Припев☺ On the third day he took me to the river На третий день он повел меня на реку, He showed me the roses and we kissed Он показал мне розы, и мы целовались. And the last thing I heard was a muttered word Последнее, что я увидела, As he knelt above me with a rock in his fist Как он встал надо мной с камнем в руке. On the last day I took her where the wild roses grow В последний день я привел ее туда, где дикие розы растут. And she lay on the bank, the wind light as a thief Она лежала на берегу, и дул ветер, быстрый, как вор. As I kissed her goodbye, I said, 'All beauty must die' Поцеловав ее на прощание, я сказал: "Красота должна умереть!", And I lent down and planted a rose between her teeth Затем наклонился к ней и поместил меж её зубов розу...
Просто удивительно.. лет 20назад увидела концовку, что -то запало ,много лет я пыталась найти исполнителя по описаниям кадров из клипа ...и ничего.А сегодня .....сразу узнала...
Одна из моих самых любимых песен! Лет в 15 я её выучил наизусть и перевёл (достаточно простой английский, и поют как нормальные люди должны петь, а не как сейчас модно - как умственно неполноценные с полным ртом х**в).
I find nick cave mesmerising and compelling. I love music from many genres but theres something about nick that draws me back time and time again . He is magnetic
They call me the wild rose But my name was Elisa Day Why they call me it I do not know For my name was Elisa Day From the first day I saw her I knew she was the one She stared in my eyes and smiled For her lips were the color of the roses That grew down the river, all bloody and wild When he knocked on my door and entered the room My trembling subsided in his sure embrace He would be my first man, and with a careful hand He wiped at the tears that ran down my face They call me the wild rose But my name was Elisa Day Why they call me that I do not know? For my name was Elisa day On the second day I brought her a flower She was more beautiful than any woman I've seen I said, "Do you know, where the wild roses grow So sweet and scarlet and free?" On the second day he came with a single red rose He said "Give me your loss and your sorrow?" I nodded my head, as I lay on the bed If I show you the roses will you follow alone They call me the wild rose But my name was Elisa Day Why they call me that I do not know For my name was Elisa Day On the third day he took me to the river He showed me the roses and we kissed And the last thing I heard was a muttered word As he knelt above me with a rock in his fist On the last day I took her where the wild roses grow She lay on the bank, the wind light as a thief And I kissed her goodbye, said "All beauty must die" And I knelt down and planted a rose between her teeth They call me the wild rose But my name is Elisa Day Why they call me it I do not know For my name is Elisa Day My name was Elisa Day For my name was Elisa Day
Cant rem the title nor tune of this song but I rem I first heard this back in the late 90s maybe or early 2000s. All I rem was it's a Kylie Minogue song. Glad I found it tonight! Thanks for uploading this.
The song is about the irish urban legend of Elisa Day, who was courted and then killed by a new man in town. She was beautiful and he said all beauty must die when he smashed her head in with a rock. They depicted the story perfectly and kylie looks the part, awesome both of them.
Judging from the title of this RUclips video, I'm not surprised a lot of people don't realise this is a Nick Cave And The Bad Seeds song and not a Kylie Minogue one. She's just a guest performer, albeit a very memorable one.
These are the songs that make a person insane Man I'm the metal head , but this is so fucking good . . . I'm here because the first video had a blocked comment section.
@@anastasssi8464 "Все красивое должно умереть [пока оно еще на пике своей красоты]". Это песня о маньяке, который по этой причине убивает своих возлюбленных. Причем с возлюбленными у него все сильно и взаимно -- и вот именно поэтому он...
It’s a beautiful song but plz change the original video to something loving than this sadist theme and remove it because it will create negative fantasies for psychos. Kylie,I love nearly all ur videos but this song’s official video needs to be redone, original video will inspire men to kill beautiful women and then molest them. Guys , plz report this video , not the song ( they can make a better video for it). I have heard this song before but watched the video only today and it has really disturbed me.
@@Sasha.999 Most people aren't that easily inspired to murder. I've listened to plenty of Johnny Cash & never got around to shooting a man in Reno just to watch him die. Don't assume the rest of the world is as easily disturbed as you are.
It's based on an irish urban legend, the ghost of Elisa Day. She was murdered by her boyfriend by the river, and some people see her ghost walking with blood all over her head, holding a single wild rose. But the drowned maiden do remind me of Ophelia.
@@darkb4light06 None of the above. The album Murder Ballads is written with just that in mind, and Nick Caves said he wrote it with Kylie Minogue in mind.
One of the reasons I come to you tube is to read the comments Agree with all and feels like being in a concert with people once again (this comment is written during COVID-19 pandemic)
Nick here used the old legend, the lady in the water. Those are old Celtic things. The lady of the lake, things like this. Here Nick, an Australian, is trying to find his roots. He is doing it very cleverly, but, man, to put Kylie in this water, not many guys can do this. Nick, this was fantastic. And Kylie was so beautiful here, I am speechless. My Irishman. Love. EDIT: Wild roses grow in Ireland. That is common for the Irish hedgerows. But, there is one more dangerous rose that grows in Ireland. Roisin Dubh, a Black Rose.
It’s a beautiful song but plz change the original video to something loving than this sadist theme and remove it because it will create negative fantasies for psychos. Kylie,I love nearly all ur videos but this song’s official video needs to be redone, original video will inspire men to kill beautiful women and then molest them. Guys , plz report this video , not the song ( they can make a better video for it). I have heard this song before but watched the video only today and it has really disturbed me.
This a maniac's song, absolutely! He finished her life so easy, even if he should be her "first man" (but it didn't happen)… Brrrrr… Nick Cave has not only sang the song perfectly, but also played the role above all the praises! Bravissimo!
@@marit1901 I don't think so.. According to the Lyrics it says: ..."he WOULD BE my first man..." Well, it means, it never happened...😱🤔😥 Wish you all the best in New 2022 year! 🧑🎄🎄🎉🐯
This is my number one song that tells a story. It's a beautiful song with a sad story... And all the symbolism kinda like a dark Romeo and Juliet. The Rabbit, the Snake, her wearing white, The hanging roses for me is like she died but she watching but hasn't passed over
2024 and I still listen to this song
So am I.
И я тоже
Me too
I can safely say I will never stop, this song is a masterpiece ❤❤
Meee! Each time when i listen it, somehow it gives me piece!!!!
2023 and this still an extraordinary piece of art. How can something so dark sound so beautiful 💖👌
So true
as long as the police is not involved, it's romantic, gothic and cool.
Було дуже красиво і обратка теж пішла коли ви вже всі виздихаєте ?
Urhm... i. Im 2024....😂😅😮
Same 💀
There is something so lunatic, so creep, so hypnotic.. have to listen over and over again..
i ecommantd :)
ruclips.net/video/QzmMB8dTwGs/видео.html&ab_channel=NickCaveandtheBadSeeds
Me too
Pic9pkpjppóócpap3prpjpmphpáptpup
Pcpep
7+56
The magic of this song, the magic of the story of Elisa Day. The voices. The melody. It is 2023 and this is a masterpiece.
Dude, this was a masterpiece the day it was released. I remember when it came out, the phrase instant classic didn't do it justice.
And it will always be a masterpiece
Eu aqui ouvindo esta OBRA PRIMA
Nick Cave is such an original musical genius…Yes, still listening 😊
Песня на века.Потрясающее исполнение.Мурашки по коже.
Это будет так смешно после смерти Путина. Смотреть, как 140 миллионов россиян целуют его голую мертвую задницу
There's just something about Nick caves voice that gives off this vibe like you should be careful of him but he could also be charming. I don't know I feel like if you came across all creepy and sinister right away it would not make sense, but the way he originally sounds so charming and then it gets darker and darker as the song goes on… I love it! This is Art. Real honest work of musical art, not like the crap coming out nowadays.
That entire album is art. Creepy and sinister art.
He has a such Erotic Voice, I'm ready to be his Elisa Day...😍💖💋😘👍💋💕👅
"Not like the crap coming out today"
lol original comment, and so stupidly false I don't even know where to start.
Nick Cave sings with soul
Everything true, you had me until the last sentence "Not like the crap coming out nowadays"... *o k b o o m e r*
2021 someone?
100 percent
Me
And me 🤣
Always...
Always
Murder Ballads is one of the best albums in the entire world.
Es
I've always loved this song and video. Kylie looks simply beautiful!
I loved this song, I've not heard it for year's. I had it on cassette tape and it ended up being played so much it broke. So great to find this again.
This is the most haunting hypnotically with the most dark murder message you ever hear.
hm, hypnotic yes, but about murder message, I think Nomy - I love you Diane hits even harder. ;)
He does have serial killer tones and creepy voice that could convince you that you are safe. Beware Nick cave is different from other artists he has alot of charisma in his lyrics and voice. Like he could make you smile and laugh and tell you you going to be his next victim of sacrifice to the wild Rose of kylie and her sexy but not much else to go on . It'd be your fault cause you fell under his spell. 🥶🤯🎵🎶♥️💉
I listened to this as a kid and was fascinated by how creepy it was. Such a masterpiece
July 2024 and wish I had taken more notice of it when it was released.Its haunting yet beautiful.
Кайли так прекрасна и музыка !!! Август 2024 год а я так же слушаю эту прекрасную композицию !!! Эти классика никогда из моды не выйдет
Have never been interested much in Kylie Minogue. But this is a timeless masterpiece.
Same
Nick cave made it happen
Eu Concordo com você
What a beautiful song to gift the world with. Hauntingly beautiful .Thank you Kylie & Nick
Yes and yes
Nagyon nagy kedvencem ez a csodálatos duett! Köszönöm, hogy megosztották!❤ Szép napot kívánok Mindenkinek sok szeretettel!❤
2024 is here and this song still sends shivers down my spine when I hear it. Truly great. They don't make them like that anymore 😢
ESSA É UMA OBRA PRIMA
An absolutely fab song! I'd forgotten all about it until I watched TOTP on BBC 4 last week. Now I cannot get this tune out of my head.
But, just want to acknowledge how beautiful Kylie was in this video.
Same
1995... back when the singers still sang
wtf? I thought it was around 2008 or something
@@nr1NPC 1996
Nick Cave still do it - sings...
Singers still sing. It’s it the name.
'95? I was thinking the 80's.
Kylie looks sooo beautiful in this video.
honestly...this is one of the greatest songs of all time.
I'd been into the Bad Seeds for years,but when I heard this I was amazed with Nick's songwriting!!
beautiful and sick song at the same time
May 2024 here who else?
Am with you
Me too!
Me too
Io
Me too..in June '24!😉
What a beautiful combination of voices... I love this song... it might be creepy but still..
It is
That’s why, it’s a masterpiece
Еще с 90-х, когда была ребёнком, этот клип завораживал. И сейчас, почти 30 лет спустя, ничего не изменилось❤❤❤
2020 someone..?
Yesss
Yeah!
In 2020 and forever
But I have know idea why lol
Ja. 👋
It is said that the song is based on the medieval English folk story about a blacksmith's daughter
This is just ART
Today is my birthday, I baked a red velvet from wild roses I collected from my backyard as we're in lockdown can't find vanilla at the supermarkets. The flavor was so intense and that cake was addictive it reminds me of this song, sweet and wild 🌹❤️
Оба непревзойдённые! Маниак и красотка...
ruclips.net/video/cv7NEbacamQ/видео.html
October 1st 2024 and still as awesome ❤
Очень много лет прошло, но жду от этого клипа волшебства. Завораживает, волшебно.. Благодарю
prof. Dr. w ho?
Это вообще-то убийство, а не волшебство
@@penny-t6f А я то все думала, почему он все время камушек в руке вертит. Так это он её получается? А, ну да- перевод прочитала. "Красота должна умереть"
@@КсенияПастернак-й6ъ да! Очередная попытка романтизации маньяков-убийц через песни, фильмы и книги.
@@КсенияПастернак-й6ъ, ага. Тюк по голове и оттеребил пока тёпленькая. Потом в воду 😂
i was in a very nervous and chaotic state of mind, kinda lost myself and was willing to change for society and somehow today my uber driver was playing this song and i shazamed it and i felt so peaceful. i don’t know what it is about it but i feel like it’s one of those precious songs i don’t want to share because it brought me back to me and that’s an intimate feeling. it reminded me of how peaceful i am and how i always had higher aspirations than just the regular joes
😂Nothink good about, only music, the story is seek
І де ти зараз? Хоча б не пішов воювати ?
How are you going these days
ruclips.net/video/qW8JKIMcMuU/видео.htmlsi=DRbf4AE5bCwn9KTe
The story is about a murder…passion killer. I was 12 years old when I heard this on MTV ♥️😉😊
Неожиданно попала на эту песню. Просто чудо. Столько лет а все ещё прекрасно.
Клип как мини-фильм. Исполнители очень талантливо сыграли, реально лучшие актеры.
Marilyn...
@@Blueluise ?...
@@Blueluise Monroe?
Song is a masterpiece. Video clip is also very good
КАКАЯ ПРЕЛЕСТЬ,КАК ПРОНИКНОВЕННО И ТРОГАТЕЛЬНО,БРАВО!
Спасибо
Да, Кайли тут на высоте!
Confide in me... Тоже на диско не тянет!
Хотя она - до сих пор Королева Диско!
Шедевр на все времена, молодость и страсть
Depuis toutes ces années, en le revoyant aujourd'hui, je l'adore tjs autant ! C'est donc ce que j'appelle "une Oeuvre d'Art" Authentique !
Wow, over a decade old. How have I missed this great vocals and a haunting song
This song is massively under-rated. It’s really good! Cx 🌹
nothing underrated here. it was a massive hit when came out, skyrocketed kylies career, brought cave to the masses, and is still considered a classic.
Underrated? Girl listen, when this song came out it was a blast during my time on Mtv. Absolute hit! And it ages with time so well. Love it till this very day!
Massive hit here in their homeland 🇦🇺🇦🇺
Masterpiece
Well, I remember seeing this video multiple times on TV in Ukraine, so it’s hardly underrated
They call me The Wild Rose
Меня зовут Дикой Розой,
But my name was Elisa Day
Но мое имя Элайза Дэй.
Why they call me it I do not know
Почему меня так называют?
For my name was Elisa Day
Ведь мое имя Элайза Дэй...
From the first day I saw her I knew she was the one
Увидев ее в первый день, я знал - она единственная.
She stared in my eyes and smiled
Она посмотрела мне в глаза и улыбнулась,
For her lips were the colour of the roses
Её губы - цвета роз,
That grew down the river, all bloody and wild
Что растут вдоль берега реки, такие алые и дикие...
When he knocked on my door and entered the room
Он постучал в мою дверь,
My trembling subsided in his sure embrace
И мой трепет растворился в его уверенных объятиях.
He would be my first man, and with a careful hand
Он был моим первым мужчиной и заботливой рукой,
He wiped up the tears that ran down my face
Нежно вытер слезы, что текли по моему лицу.
Припев☺
On the second day I brought her a flower
На второй день я принес ей цветок,
She was more beautiful than any woman I'd seen
Она была красивее всех женщин, что я видел,
And I said, 'Do you know where the wild roses grow
И я спросил: "Знаешь ли ты, где дикие розы растут,
So sweet and scarlet and free?'
Такие ароматные, алые и вольные?"
On the second day he came with a single red rose
На второй день он пришёл с одной красной розой
Said: 'Give me your loss and your sorrow?'
И сказал: "Доверь мне свою потерю и печаль"
I nodded my head, as I lay on the bed
Я лишь кивнула и легла на кровать.
If I show you the roses will you follow?'
"Если я покажу тебе розы, ты последуешь за мной?"
Припев☺
On the third day he took me to the river
На третий день он повел меня на реку,
He showed me the roses and we kissed
Он показал мне розы, и мы целовались.
And the last thing I heard was a muttered word
Последнее, что я увидела,
As he knelt above me with a rock in his fist
Как он встал надо мной с камнем в руке.
On the last day I took her where the wild roses grow
В последний день я привел ее туда, где дикие розы растут.
And she lay on the bank, the wind light as a thief
Она лежала на берегу, и дул ветер, быстрый, как вор.
As I kissed her goodbye, I said, 'All beauty must die'
Поцеловав ее на прощание, я сказал: "Красота должна умереть!",
And I lent down and planted a rose between her teeth
Затем наклонился к ней и поместил меж её зубов розу...
Гимн маньякам
Ни фига себе трагедия! Прям как у "КИШ"
Спасибо
Гугл перевод...сама песня красивее.
Thank you for the translate 🤗👍❤️💯🙌🏼 I am very grateful for 🙌🏼🙏💯❤️💓💞
Страшноватенько! Классная песня и прекрасное исполнение
Прямо психологический фильм... Столько лет уже этой песне, а все равно класс
без "Б" угусь!:*
У Кайли был рак груди. только узнала
@@Axera703 ллллллллллллллллллл от
Это песня про некрофилию?
soglasen 25 kak ne slyshal vot tak vot
Absolutely perfect song. Kylie is awesome.
I am still listening this song in the year 3067.
I love that
What a beautiful combination of voices... I love this song... it might be creepy but still..
1995... back when the singers still sang
💯
Einer seiner besten Songs... zusammen mit Kylie Minogue this is one of my absolutely favourite songs... thank you for sharing it.... !!
💞 Ellá
This give me the creeps in a good way and the shivers down my spine... timeless ⚘
когда-то услышала эту песню и не могла найти, кто поёт. Сегодня услышала по радио , записала время и нашла. Супер!
Супер 🥰🤗😏♥️
Шазам в помощь
Просто удивительно.. лет 20назад увидела концовку, что -то запало ,много лет я пыталась найти исполнителя по описаниям кадров из клипа ...и ничего.А сегодня .....сразу узнала...
Мтв надо было смотреть , когда оно было бесплатно
Одна из моих самых любимых песен! Лет в 15 я её выучил наизусть и перевёл (достаточно простой английский, и поют как нормальные люди должны петь, а не как сейчас модно - как умственно неполноценные с полным ртом х**в).
I find nick cave mesmerising and compelling. I love music from many genres but theres something about nick that draws me back time and time again . He is magnetic
They call me the wild rose
But my name was Elisa Day
Why they call me it I do not know
For my name was Elisa Day
From the first day I saw her I knew she was the one
She stared in my eyes and smiled
For her lips were the color of the roses
That grew down the river, all bloody and wild
When he knocked on my door and entered the room
My trembling subsided in his sure embrace
He would be my first man, and with a careful hand
He wiped at the tears that ran down my face
They call me the wild rose
But my name was Elisa Day
Why they call me that I do not know?
For my name was Elisa day
On the second day I brought her a flower
She was more beautiful than any woman I've seen
I said, "Do you know, where the wild roses grow
So sweet and scarlet and free?"
On the second day he came with a single red rose
He said "Give me your loss and your sorrow?"
I nodded my head, as I lay on the bed
If I show you the roses will you follow alone
They call me the wild rose
But my name was Elisa Day
Why they call me that I do not know
For my name was Elisa Day
On the third day he took me to the river
He showed me the roses and we kissed
And the last thing I heard was a muttered word
As he knelt above me with a rock in his fist
On the last day I took her where the wild roses grow
She lay on the bank, the wind light as a thief
And I kissed her goodbye, said "All beauty must die"
And I knelt down and planted a rose between her teeth
They call me the wild rose
But my name is Elisa Day
Why they call me it I do not know
For my name is Elisa Day
My name was Elisa Day
For my name was Elisa Day
Was
thanks bro
He said give me your lust, not loss
Thanks
Beautiful, both the singing/music and the video.
Something is in this song so hypnotic and make that Listen this song over and over again.
ruclips.net/video/rpo8VQDvoQU/видео.html 🤘
Me too
THIS SONG DIGS DEEP IN MY SOUL!!! The original sin
this is the most psychopathic song in the world.!
this is an albanian urban legend
Yeah but it's beautiful.
@@darkb4light06 of course it is ,especially when im in psychopatic mood(it happens sometimes) :)
There is also The Blackest Eyes by Porcupine Tree
@@ersingjigolli8819 what's the name of that urban legend
Cant rem the title nor tune of this song but I rem I first heard this back in the late 90s maybe or early 2000s. All I rem was it's a Kylie Minogue song. Glad I found it tonight! Thanks for uploading this.
Thank you for this song.. she sings verry good, and NickCave is soooo good....
The song is about the irish urban legend of Elisa Day, who was courted and then killed by a new man in town. She was beautiful and he said all beauty must die when he smashed her head in with a rock.
They depicted the story perfectly and kylie looks the part, awesome both of them.
She certainly doesn't look as if a rock had just smashed her head.
Спасибо что внесли ясность, иначе ничего не ясно🌷👍👍👍👍
Ужас
kylie needs to do more music like this. Nick awesome as usual
That's so right, her voice is totally different and so....much better, found her soul with Nick C.
Judging from the title of this RUclips video, I'm not surprised a lot of people don't realise this is a Nick Cave And The Bad Seeds song and not a Kylie Minogue one. She's just a guest performer, albeit a very memorable one.
Heard this on Radio 2 18/8/2020, instantly hooked, the music/ lyrics, & Kylie is So beautiful
goddamn i love this song . we need more morbid beautiful songs like this
zuembekinder sullivan It’s off a whole album of them (Murder Ballads).
Check outHenry Lee, with PJ Harvey.
Gloomy sunday is kinda morbid and beautiful :)
Try dimmu borgir XD
Sickly sweet,no?
When a song binds two hearts, that bond will be forever.
2021.
For a beautiful song.
These are the songs that make a person insane
Man I'm the metal head , but this is so fucking good . . .
I'm here because the first video had a blocked comment section.
Просто НЕЧТО, шедевр!
азуеть, на повторе
У нас подобной музыки не бывает
@@evgenyklickin5972 Женя. Да Он же петь не умеет, но это, которое вернулось опять.
@@tanyatimurovna2768 музыка хорошая , у нас такую почему то делать не умеют. И он же не в опере поёт.
2024. and I just discovered this. Hauntingly beautiful.
Intresting I loved this song since I was kid, and now at 35 I realize the lyrics for the first time. So disturbing and beautiful at the saqme time..
I ja isto
@@myahollandia3552 Istripovano skroz kad čuješ o čemu se radi,a? )))
aaaaaaaa!!!! i find it thanks for all, this son i listen last time before 25 years:))))) life is go on
utwór mojej młodości....2021r i nadal aktualne treści, przepiękny. 😢😢😢
I was 8 years old when this song came out and I still come back from time to time.
Мало того что красиво сняли, спели, дак ещё и какой смысл и слова. Браво
А какой смысл
@@anastasssi8464 "Все красивое должно умереть [пока оно еще на пике своей красоты]".
Это песня о маньяке, который по этой причине убивает своих возлюбленных. Причем с возлюбленными у него все сильно и взаимно -- и вот именно поэтому он...
My late Mom loved this song...as do I.
A Masterpiece.
Point.
These are the songs that make a person insane
this is an albanian urban legend
@@ersingjigolli8819 could you tell me the legend?
It’s a beautiful song but plz change the original video to something loving than this sadist theme and remove it because it will create negative fantasies for psychos.
Kylie,I love nearly all ur videos but this song’s official video needs to be redone, original video will inspire men to kill beautiful women and then molest them.
Guys , plz report this video , not the song ( they can make a better video for it). I have heard this song before but watched the video only today and it has really disturbed me.
@@Sasha.999
That's not true
@@Sasha.999 Most people aren't that easily inspired to murder. I've listened to plenty of Johnny Cash & never got around to shooting a man in Reno just to watch him die.
Don't assume the rest of the world is as easily disturbed as you are.
Nice song n video. Lovely. Siapa yg dgr lagu ni di thn 2022.
Anyone else think this may be based off of "Hamlet" by Shakespeare? It's a lot like the story of Ophelia. I dunno but I love that play.
It's based on an irish urban legend, the ghost of Elisa Day. She was murdered by her boyfriend by the river, and some people see her ghost walking with blood all over her head, holding a single wild rose.
But the drowned maiden do remind me of Ophelia.
Kat Illustration Someone else said it was an Albanian urban legend. Lol Which is it?
hi hi ! But Ophelia committed suicide? This is murder...
@@darkb4light06 None of the above. The album Murder Ballads is written with just that in mind, and Nick Caves said he wrote it with Kylie Minogue in mind.
Not really. Ophelia had gone mad and commited suicide because her fiancee had killed her father.
October 2024 - still one of the best❤
One of the reasons I come to you tube is to read the comments
Agree with all and feels like being in a concert with people once again (this comment is written during COVID-19 pandemic)
Это шедевр! Магия какая-то. Хочется чтобы песня не заканчивалась.
Superbe chanson. J'adore. Merci beaucoup 🌟
Listening in 2021 .. still sounds haunting.. I timeless peice of work x
How about 2024?
@kyragd2009 still the same 😂xx
Completely forgot about this record totally different Kylie, Nick brought something out absolutely love it
Quand 2 artistes mêlent leur talent respectif...ça donne une merveille dans ce genre là....juste grandiose...merci d'adoucir ma pauvre existence..
I love this song always chills me out ❤❤ to Kylie
Nick here used the old legend, the lady in the water. Those are old Celtic things. The lady of the lake, things like this. Here Nick, an Australian, is trying to find his roots. He is doing it very cleverly, but, man, to put Kylie in this water, not many guys can do this. Nick, this was fantastic. And Kylie was so beautiful here, I am speechless. My Irishman. Love.
EDIT: Wild roses grow in Ireland. That is common for the Irish hedgerows. But, there is one more dangerous rose that grows in Ireland. Roisin Dubh, a Black Rose.
Какое красивое сочетание музыки, голосов и картин!!!
Everlasting divine song !! Nick with Kylie...WOW !!!!!
My favourite song from the childhood 😍
Still masterpiece decades later. ❤
Piękny utwór ❤️
fantasy catalyst, thanks for the composition 🌹
I REMEMBER I was so scared of this song when I was a kid. Now I love her 💘
Why?
This is Emotion! Wonderfull dream sound!💔
Have people realised this song is about murder?
Admittedly, I find it even more fascinating after knowing that.
It is about lost inocence
@@p.k.9485 A bit but mainly it is indeed about murder.
The album is literally called murder ballads
Yeah I realized it wad about murder when I was about 10. I guess I'm screwed up
It’s a beautiful song but plz change the original video to something loving than this sadist theme and remove it because it will create negative fantasies for psychos.
Kylie,I love nearly all ur videos but this song’s official video needs to be redone, original video will inspire men to kill beautiful women and then molest them.
Guys , plz report this video , not the song ( they can make a better video for it). I have heard this song before but watched the video only today and it has really disturbed me.
Hauntingly beautiful I love it
This a maniac's song, absolutely! He finished her life so easy, even if he should be her "first man" (but it didn't happen)… Brrrrr… Nick Cave has not only sang the song perfectly, but also played the role above all the praises! Bravissimo!
I seems to me that he was her first man, if i read the lyrics. He took her virginity and then killed her on the third day.
@@marit1901 I don't think so.. According to the Lyrics it says: ..."he WOULD BE my first man..." Well, it means, it never happened...😱🤔😥 Wish you all the best in New 2022 year! 🧑🎄🎄🎉🐯
Elena, you are probably right. At least hope so. Thank you for your kind wishes, happy 2022 to you.
Anyone forever? ❤❤❤❤❤》
This is my number one song that tells a story. It's a beautiful song with a sad story... And all the symbolism kinda like a dark Romeo and Juliet.
The Rabbit, the Snake, her wearing white, The hanging roses for me is like she died but she watching but hasn't passed over
It’s Shakespearean but the wrong couple. It’s Hamlet and Ophelia. See John Millais painting.
Bob Dylan wrote a few 😅