The robust steel chariot with spoked wheels ,could only have been made in the iron age 1200bc to 500bc. The Steppe pastoralist immigrants arrived in 1500bc. The Harappan culture ended in 1900bc and the inhabitants moved camp to the south.
Most archeological excavations gave birth to new theories unless and untill there is a common pattern in these excavations these theories will not become conclusive enough to include it in school history textbooks more archeological research needs to done for it. Would also like to appreciate your efforts in creating such history related videos. It would be nice if you could make videos on historical wars
Indian arecheaology, genetic analysis and linguistic studies needs more investmentment to become more advanced to a point where we can confidently write our own history backed up with objective evidence to satisfy the scientific mind. I mean western narrative at first was that India had no prehistory. Then when Mohenjo-daro site was found, they were forced to admit it and the narrative became Aryan Invasion Theory and when that was disproven, it became aryan migration theory. And now with the evidence mounting (such as with the Saraswati river dating and such when it comes to the origin of the early Vedas), even the migration theory or at least the origin of Vedic literature as being outside the subcontinent is standing on flimsy ground. The Indian subcontinent always had a huge population throughout history. Wherever there's a mass concentration of people, there's always civilisation. This can be seen all across the world throughout history. We find it easy to accept that Indian systems had a profound influence on South East asia (though it was harder to reach via land in those days) yet somehow it becomes illogical to imagine Indian systems having an impact in the opposite direction (westwards) even though it was easier to reach via land. Throughout history, people have migrated out of India in all directions and people have migrated to India from all directions (especially among the west coast and eastern side of the landmass). Looking at the big picture and reading between the lines, it's absolutely clear that western sources (especially those from the 1800s 1900s) are biased. In my mind, the Indian story is incomplete and I hope Bharat will invest more of its effort to find the truth.
Thank you for a thought provoking and well researched video. These archeological findings remain latent evidence until they are operationalised within multi- disciplinary paradigms and fields of analytics. Your expose will be invaluable in broadening the Indic knowledge space. Thank you.
These discoveries do not confirm the Mahabharat period as 1800 BC. They only confirm that people used horse driven chariots around 1800 BC in Sinauli region. Mahabharat text has many astronomical observations which, when calculated properly, give the date of war as 5561 BC.
@@particularlyindian Watch videos by Shri. Nilesh Oak. He has explained the scientific dating of Mahabharat & Ramayan from astronomical observations. He has also shown corroborative proofs from different science fields such as climatology, oceanography, genealogy supporting 5561 BC for Mahabharat war.
The robust steel chariot with spoked wheels ,could only have been made in the iron age 1200bc to 500bc. The Steppe pastoralist immigrants arrived in 1500bc.
The Harappan culture ended in 1900bc and the inhabitants moved camp to the south.
Most archeological excavations gave birth to new theories unless and untill there is a common pattern in these excavations these theories will not become conclusive enough to include it in school history textbooks more archeological research needs to done for it. Would also like to appreciate your efforts in creating such history related videos. It would be nice if you could make videos on historical wars
Your comment reminded me of the proverb A LIE IS HALF WAY ROUND THE WORLD WHILE THE TRUTH IS STILL PUTTING ON ITS SHOES😅
But if you take all of these into consideration, we can at least introduce these cultures to young minds. They don't have to be in obscurity.
@@particularlyindian I think that there is point of thought in that it is important to introduce these cultures to youth..
Indian arecheaology, genetic analysis and linguistic studies needs more investmentment to become more advanced to a point where we can confidently write our own history backed up with objective evidence to satisfy the scientific mind. I mean western narrative at first was that India had no prehistory. Then when Mohenjo-daro site was found, they were forced to admit it and the narrative became Aryan Invasion Theory and when that was disproven, it became aryan migration theory. And now with the evidence mounting (such as with the Saraswati river dating and such when it comes to the origin of the early Vedas), even the migration theory or at least the origin of Vedic literature as being outside the subcontinent is standing on flimsy ground. The Indian subcontinent always had a huge population throughout history. Wherever there's a mass concentration of people, there's always civilisation. This can be seen all across the world throughout history. We find it easy to accept that Indian systems had a profound influence on South East asia (though it was harder to reach via land in those days) yet somehow it becomes illogical to imagine Indian systems having an impact in the opposite direction (westwards) even though it was easier to reach via land. Throughout history, people have migrated out of India in all directions and people have migrated to India from all directions (especially among the west coast and eastern side of the landmass). Looking at the big picture and reading between the lines, it's absolutely clear that western sources (especially those from the 1800s 1900s) are biased. In my mind, the Indian story is incomplete and I hope Bharat will invest more of its effort to find the truth.
Thank you for a thought provoking and well researched video. These archeological findings remain latent evidence until they are operationalised within multi- disciplinary paradigms and fields of analytics. Your expose will be invaluable in broadening the Indic knowledge space. Thank you.
Thank you for your comment!
These discoveries do not confirm the Mahabharat period as 1800 BC.
They only confirm that people used horse driven chariots around 1800 BC in Sinauli region.
Mahabharat text has many astronomical observations which, when calculated properly, give the date of war as 5561 BC.
Yes... that's quite possible as well. Thank you for your input 😇🙏🏻
@@particularlyindian
Watch videos by Shri. Nilesh Oak.
He has explained the scientific dating of Mahabharat & Ramayan from astronomical observations.
He has also shown corroborative proofs from different science fields such as climatology, oceanography, genealogy supporting 5561 BC for Mahabharat war.
@@pranav21047 he is a fraud 😢
Superb