F1 Game Comparison: 2010 - 2022 Gameplay Comparison (PC)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 30 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 153

  • @still_guns
    @still_guns  Год назад +11

    This video keeps getting all the views, despite the fact it is the older version.
    The New UPDATED Version is here: ruclips.net/video/9IN_csLOTXY/видео.html

  • @samuelgreenhalgh2955
    @samuelgreenhalgh2955 Год назад +64

    Pos. Game Lap Time Time Difference
    1. F1 2020 1:42.466 +0.000
    2. F1 2011 1:42.500 +0.034
    3. F1 2010 1:42.846 +0.380
    4. F1 2021 1:43.446 +0.980
    5. F1 2018 1:43.939 +1.473
    6. F1 2019 1:45.003 +2.537
    7. F1 2022 1:45.669 +3.203
    8. F1 2017 1:45.672 +3.206
    9. F1 2012 1:47.405 +4.939
    10. F1 2016 1:48.833 +6.387
    11. F1 2013 1:48.852 +6.386
    12. F1 2015 1:49.739 +7.273
    13. F1 2014 1:51.806 +9.340

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад +18

      F1 2010 and F1 2011 times are wholly inaccurate compared to the real life times. Way too fast. 2010 is about 3 seconds faster than IRL 2010 pole, and 2011 is 6 seconds faster that IRL 2011 pole.

    • @PINKPEE111
      @PINKPEE111 Год назад

      okay

    • @alexsalvi1824
      @alexsalvi1824 Год назад

      so, f12020 is the best, 2014 is the worste f1 game. This is how averange F1 gaming user think about it

  • @danort17
    @danort17 Год назад +132

    Even if F1 2011 is rated as one of the worst, it still has a good place in my heart. It was my first game by Codies and as a kid I had so many great memories with it, that I still like coming back to it.

    • @TiagoDSilvaf1
      @TiagoDSilvaf1 Год назад +1

      i like this game.

    • @Idk56373
      @Idk56373 Год назад +5

      I understand you’re feeling I love 2015 for the same reason.
      But I must say the handling in 2015 feels so much better when the front end just turns in (controller rotation is like a wheel and not full lock to lock) like in newer titles.

    • @Cimmerian_Iter
      @Cimmerian_Iter Год назад +15

      I don't understand at all the hate F1 2011 has.
      Its gameplay may had some issue it was actually an improvement on the 2010 game. As for the engine sound they are also an upgrade I don't know why he says they sound worse. They actually sound like blown diffuser.
      It brought up real steering wheel, better graphics, safety car and a more immersive career mode.
      People who hate it probably didn't play it at launch and have learned how to drive with 2013+ games

    • @CometDeManokit
      @CometDeManokit Год назад +1

      Same here bro

    • @thund_07
      @thund_07 Год назад

      Same here

  • @robertmarton3561
    @robertmarton3561 2 года назад +31

    Well made video, brought back some very good memories. I started to play with F1 2010 and played with every title since than. I just realized a whole decade have passed.

  • @opoc_x37
    @opoc_x37 Год назад +14

    I still have and play F1 2010, 13 years later, it's a great game, really

  • @Matt231985uk
    @Matt231985uk Год назад +17

    How can you talk about F1 2010 and not mention the Ian Brown F.E.A.R intro and the paddock menus. They're iconic for the series!!

  • @miscioCenaWWEJeffTNA
    @miscioCenaWWEJeffTNA 2 года назад +14

    I started playing from F1 1998😂 so I saw a lot of improvements through time😂 this video is very accurate and well made! Nice jobs! I truly miss Classic Cars… I loved F1 2020 for the range of classics it had

  • @SpaceXplorer13
    @SpaceXplorer13 Год назад +10

    One thing I hated about the newer games is that they completely removed the camera shake that was in 2013. Going to the newer titles just feel like I'm playing a silly arcade; surprising honestly, how one feature getting removed completely broke the immersion.

    • @Galois-88
      @Galois-88 Год назад +1

      Maybe it was on purpose, after all, the chassis and wheel shock absorbers are better than the old cars, the drivers feel trembling of corners less

    • @WatcherKoops4677
      @WatcherKoops4677 Год назад +1

      @@Galois-88 On purpose to avoid anyone getting sick with these effects...

  • @Sam._.Santos16
    @Sam._.Santos16 Год назад +3

    Is it just me or the 2014 V6 engine sound is more interesting then the og V6 sound

  • @TheVietnameseThatTouchedGrass
    @TheVietnameseThatTouchedGrass Год назад +3

    0:45 the brake got me out💀

  • @DracBola
    @DracBola Год назад +2

    Thank you for this video, it made me relive some of my memories from this game! I enjoyed 2012, I remember I could lose the rear of the car easy. I recently played 2016 to 2021, 2016, tyres are wearing out so fast. 2017, the car can get through corners so much faster. I enjoyed 2022 a lot, though I could lose the rear so easily and it was unpredicable. I really do enjoy 2023 so far! We are far from Gp2 and Gp4 from Microprose, which was my fist ever F1 games that I played! Thank you again!!

  • @keitv4519
    @keitv4519 Год назад +3

    F1 2014's Ferrari F14T has a classic F1 car engine sound 9:06

  • @Rando101
    @Rando101 7 месяцев назад

    The Ferrari engine sound from 18, 20, 21 and 22 is mesmerizing to me

  • @Blueflag04
    @Blueflag04 Год назад +4

    Before EA comes in to ruin everything, the F1 games are still good especially 2012 and 13

  • @adamantiteB
    @adamantiteB 2 года назад +6

    Did you go ahead and buy a physical copy of F1 2010? I've been looking everywhere for a Steam key or something but can't find any

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  2 года назад +5

      Yeah, I had to buy pbysical, it was delisted in 2016. I don't imagine theres any keys left for it.

    • @adamantiteB
      @adamantiteB 2 года назад

      @@still_guns Ok then, thank you for answering

    • @SweetFlexZ
      @SweetFlexZ 2 года назад +1

      @@adamantiteB The only way to play is downloading it "legally"

    • @adamantiteB
      @adamantiteB 2 года назад

      @@SweetFlexZ I've considered it but this game has very little legitimate cracks. Most of them are just PUPs, Malware or some sort of crypto miner or some shit.

    • @SweetFlexZ
      @SweetFlexZ 2 года назад

      @@adamantiteB I don't know if you know this but just a few weeks ago a mod was released for F1 2010, remastered edition, look for it on RUclips it gives everything and I'm playing it right now and it's AMAZING

  • @facundoferrero2775
    @facundoferrero2775 Год назад +3

    _2014 not one of the worst, it is the WORST but also the most realistic as you can see the F-14T with ridiculous understeer and oversteer_

  • @WyneSw2
    @WyneSw2 Год назад +1

    I feel so bad i can't find 2012, 2013 , 2014 for my ps3 anymore cause its sold us everywhere from used market (Malaysia) 😔

  • @einfachferdinand5578
    @einfachferdinand5578 Год назад

    14:42 actually in even in 2010 there was an car upgrade system u had to be 1st driver to be able to choose what to upgrade but it was there!

  • @derrosso7082
    @derrosso7082 Год назад +1

    The Reel OGs playin since F1 2008

  • @Maskeli_YT
    @Maskeli_YT Год назад

    İn my childhood I loved F1 sooo much because of F1 2010, I can't download it but its still my favourite. F1 2012 too.

  • @kaisserreich9226
    @kaisserreich9226 2 года назад +6

    I don’t like the new f1’s because of 4 things:
    1-Ea
    2-the new ers mode of use is really difficult to me
    3-classic cars are gone
    4-the new version of start-up and going to your pit-stop in immersive mode is another of my difficulties
    And 5-unfairly,jeff being fired of team radio engineer
    …but i kinda liked some things of the new f1 games:
    1-solo carrer mode road to f1 glory in the new games
    2-solo my team carrer’s
    3-breaking point in f1 2021
    4-coop carrer mode in f1 2021 and 2022
    5-contracts carrer mode in f1 2021 and 2022
    6-turbo sound system since f1 2021
    And 7-legends mode in f1 2019,personally to me,it was…GLORIUS!
    A TOTALLY MASTERPIECE!
    ALELUIA!ALELUIA!ALELUIA,ALELUIA,ALELUUUUIIAA!

  • @LFGamer2004
    @LFGamer2004 Год назад +2

    I still love F1 2010, 2011, 2012 & 2013. So much memories This have left!
    :,)
    And also the Codemasters doesnt cares more about put good content in their games as the cars F1 classics included in the previous games like as: F1 2017, 2018, 2019 and 2020, Such a shame.

  • @WyneSw2
    @WyneSw2 Год назад +1

    I bought f1 2021 just because of the last year F1 car with no plastic cover on the wheel

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад +1

      You were lucky to pick it up then, it was delisted just 2-3 days ago

  • @boredstudent
    @boredstudent Год назад +5

    The first Codemasters F1 game I played was 2020. It actually got me back into Formula 1 after moving away from it. As a very young kid I was into motorsports and especially Formula 1 so seeing how much it's changed was new for me. The halo was just part of it. I also ended up buying a steering wheel so I could play those games and it's all the better. I also ended up getting F1 2021 and it wasn't bad. Funny enough, I liked the Braking Point story. It was a pretty good addition to the Codemasters F1 games but yeah I would agree that it was a gimmick. Then came F1 22. I do like that they have the Miami track and the new cars but I would also agree that F1 Life is....blah. And I don't care for the supercars in that game. I wouldn't mind seeing a story in F1 23 or whatever Codemasters calls their 2023 game. Since EA bought Codemasters, it'll most likely be called F1 23. Who knows? We might even see Devon Butler again. He was in the 2019 game and the 2021 game.

  • @caroltegar
    @caroltegar Год назад +2

    Aah F1 2014 my first F1 game on console
    I know this game is the worst but this game still living thanks to modders. They're hard working for new season for each year thanks to V6 Engine not like it's predecessor

  • @PINKPEE111
    @PINKPEE111 Год назад +1

    f1 2011 will maybe the best NEW KERS DRS

  • @shrimpfry880
    @shrimpfry880 Год назад +1

    i wish studio liverpool games were ported to pc

    • @shrimpfry880
      @shrimpfry880 Год назад

      so we could have a fair comparision between the 2 approaches to this sport

  • @Gyatpotato
    @Gyatpotato Год назад

    I started having f1 games in 2020 when i was 10
    Now i am 12 (i will be 13 in September)and now i have: F1 2015 ,16,17,18,20,21,22,23

  • @GURken
    @GURken 2 года назад +5

    The only codemasters racing game I truly loved was ToCA Race Driver 2. And even then I thought that it would've been better if Gran Turismo 4 was ported to PC from PS2 which I didn't had. Since then their games were somewhat of a mystery for me. Their change of a Colin McRae Rally series into Dirt was somewhat confusing at that time. Same with ToCA and Grid. When they started to make F1 games I was sceptical and indeed when 2010 came out I didn't get it: how can a car in a game that specifies on one and only championship feel worse than the same car in GT5, a game with a 1000 different cars from WWII military vehicles to LMP1 rockets. Since then I tried from time to time different iterations of F1 series but without much respect to every game. These games all felt a bit childish, a waste of time. One good race in iRacing gave me more emotions that a whole season in F1 because of its, I don't know, emptiness.

  • @AverageArtz
    @AverageArtz Месяц назад

    In retrospect, F1 22 still has the best sound. Both F1 23 and F1 24 are massive let downs in sound.

  • @davidjohnconradie8966
    @davidjohnconradie8966 Год назад +3

    Absolutely brilliant.I still want to buy F1'05 from somebody please?

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад +1

      You'll have to find a physical copy somewhere. It never got sold digitally.

    • @sebgames3355
      @sebgames3355 Год назад +2

      Use a pirate version

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад +2

      @@sebgames3355 Playstation 2 exclusive, you can't get a pirate for it

    • @sebgames3355
      @sebgames3355 Год назад +2

      @@still_guns use a emulator

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад +3

      @@sebgames3355 Still need a copy of the game to make an iso

  • @dashrendar655
    @dashrendar655 9 месяцев назад

    Sound of F1 2013 wow

  • @__.Shhh__.41
    @__.Shhh__.41 Год назад +4

    F1 2022 has one of the worst handings of the modern era especially if you play without tc in my opinion the best ever f1 game is the 2020 one apart from some online bugs it was perfect

  • @einfachferdinand5578
    @einfachferdinand5578 Год назад

    I started playing with 2010 as a kid booting up the PS3 I was so quick there I got P1 in a Lotus on Max difficulty 😂 Saving the car is EZ as u only have to lock the tyres and the car will 95% of the time go straight

  • @itachi-ff8sx
    @itachi-ff8sx Год назад

    wow how absurd it is that 12 years have made such a little difference in-terms of graphics.

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад

      Or my PC hasn't been able to keep up and it doesn't look as impressive as it should.

  • @tun04
    @tun04 2 года назад +4

    Steven HeartStone Gaming ? ıs that you ?

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  2 года назад +2

      Sadly no, but I was inspired by his videos and to continue the series after he vanished.

    • @tun04
      @tun04 2 года назад +3

      @@still_guns thanks

  • @SilverT3ch
    @SilverT3ch Год назад

    10:48 err... F1 cars don't have that turbo sound

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад +2

      Yeah, it's one of those things about F1 2014. The V6 Turbo sounds are not accurate at all.

  • @Noloo1
    @Noloo1 Год назад

    if you use a controller on f1 2013 the handling is better or your just straight up bad if it feels like the same thing

  • @MrRacerGuy16
    @MrRacerGuy16 Год назад

    F1 2014 sounds like classic V12 f1 engines.

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад

      No it doesn't

    • @MrRacerGuy16
      @MrRacerGuy16 Год назад

      @@still_guns WTF?! It does lol i heard that weird noise when you throttle they put a V12 in 2014 f1 cars.

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад

      @@MrRacerGuy16 No they don't sound like V12's and no they didn't put V12 sounds into the game. Where the hell are you getting this from?

    • @MrRacerGuy16
      @MrRacerGuy16 Год назад

      @@still_guns The ferrari you drove with poor engine sounds

    • @MrRacerGuy16
      @MrRacerGuy16 Год назад

      @@still_guns Watch this video by THE RACE 'The best and worst F1 games ever'

  • @samuelrodrigeuz7228
    @samuelrodrigeuz7228 Год назад

    I really want to play my f1 2010 but my laptop is broken and the laptop i have is old and slow

  • @Crankflame8
    @Crankflame8 Год назад +1

    F1 2009!

  • @pflegefalldeutschland
    @pflegefalldeutschland Год назад +1

    Unfortunately, hardly anything has changed in the graphics. Same nonsense for 10 years.

  • @Jan-565
    @Jan-565 Год назад

    F1 2010 was not the first F1 Game from Codemaster! F1 2009 is the first one of F1 Game. At Wii do you can play the game.

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад

      Was it on PC though? No.

    • @FranciscoFJM
      @FranciscoFJM Год назад

      @@still_guns Dolphin is a thing that exists and you should use

  • @vittosphonecollection57289
    @vittosphonecollection57289 Год назад

    3:53 That's why my F1 2011 doesn't work 😭😭
    At least my motorbike games should work

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад

      When I'm back at my PC later, I can try and help you get it working

    • @vittosphonecollection57289
      @vittosphonecollection57289 Год назад

      @@still_guns Ah ok, thank you very much 😃😃

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад

      @@vittosphonecollection57289 Download the ZIP folder in this link and follow the instructions in the Read Me. I know it says Dirt 2, but it works with F1 2010 and 2011. drive.google.com/file/d/1WycIt54mMYDCAjjoW7DzBrw27xAG4Wmi/view

    • @vittosphonecollection57289
      @vittosphonecollection57289 Год назад

      @@still_gunsthx a lot, I'll try this tomorrow!
      (And for tomorrow I mean today in about 8 hours 😁)

  • @AceAndToe
    @AceAndToe Год назад +1

    You put an extra 't' in 'better' 4:53 ( no criticism intended)

  • @FloppyFiona
    @FloppyFiona Год назад

    You mean after 7 years F1 games returned to PC. You forgot about F1 Challenge 99-02.

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад

      No I didn't.

    • @FloppyFiona
      @FloppyFiona Год назад

      ​@@still_guns F1 Challenge 99-02 came out in 2003.

  • @fredyshred
    @fredyshred Год назад

    13 years and they still can't do Spa correctly. Look at the chicane, Raidillion,..

  • @LickedTip
    @LickedTip Год назад

    how do you buy or get these games?

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад

      Aside from F1 22 and 23, you have to find physical copies or buy codes from sites like cdkeys now they are all delisred from Steam.

  • @supragaming3668
    @supragaming3668 Год назад +1

    F1 23 red flags

  • @walterwhite3395
    @walterwhite3395 Год назад +1

    F1 2013 is Good

  • @Super-Godzilla99
    @Super-Godzilla99 Год назад

    i don`t like that every good thing one title has the next removes and makes it another way why i will never understand.
    games are all like this, why remove or change something that works.
    game development can be so easy, just improve on what works and make new what doesn`t, so the games will get better with every new edition. but no they remove stuff that works and only improves what doesn`t work, so long till it works than remove it.
    logic we don´t need that.
    imagine get classic cars in one game than in the next the same classic cars just more of them and so on.
    the same with tracks, get the actual tracks and a few additions, than in the next all these tracks from the previous game and even more.
    the same with my team mode, in 2020 it was new, and in 2021 it could have been even more with optical changes with every update, with sound updates if you improve the engine and so on. we would love too play the new game if it was like that. but no can`t do what players want ever.
    better remove what they like and make new things with every game.

  • @Kupferstecher2007
    @Kupferstecher2007 Год назад +2

    F1 2011 was the worst? No. In my opinion it was F1 2014. Horrible F1 Game

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад +1

      I said ONE of the worst, not THE worst.

  • @suppress4872
    @suppress4872 Год назад

    Really? I think f1 2010 and 2011 were the best for me (granted I didnt play any up to 2022) but f1 2022 doesnt feel right and the cars feel sluggish which is why I can never get used to it

  • @boltgaming248
    @boltgaming248 Год назад

    you forgot to mention but spa from 2010 - 2023 from the game were not good
    like look at the kerb at the top of raidillon in the f1 game now look at it in the real life version
    the one in the f1 game is thin asf while irl its as wide as the average American after mcdonald's like bruh
    that its inaccuracy at its finest

  • @Gabriel3537
    @Gabriel3537 Год назад

    27:55 -> "Graphics are also better..." You are speaking about a recent game stuff... 😒

  • @MikeAnderson4523
    @MikeAnderson4523 Год назад

    I cannot run F1 2010 on my steam account :( Any fixes?

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад

      Is it Steam or PC copy? Maybe GFWL is interfering with it.

    • @MikeAnderson4523
      @MikeAnderson4523 Год назад

      @@still_guns yeah I needed two files to paste in game folder but I struggled to find any active source, but finally I got it

    • @adamzirig
      @adamzirig Год назад

      is it possible to ask you to send me that folder to paste into my Steam folder? its my favourite game and i always wanted to play on laptop. i dont have a trustful source or anything...

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад +1

      @@adamzirig I'll do you one better: drive.google.com/drive/folders/1oygiKDtZQCCcPnzJCfX_BFHP3R2f9R_9
      Link for remastered mod. Includes cracked copy of the game, but since you already own the game, I don't have to feel bad about sharing it.

    • @adamzirig
      @adamzirig Год назад

      @@still_guns thanks but I would prefer the original game, I knew about it but thanks so much!!

  • @viunetwork5142
    @viunetwork5142 2 года назад +2

    Like, sub, comment... just to appreciate the work you done... thx... BUT: WHICH IS THE BEST?

  • @wahyuardiansyah1266
    @wahyuardiansyah1266 2 года назад

    try to f1 22 vs the crew 2 supercars sound

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  2 года назад

      I don't have the The Crew 2, and it's a bad game anyway

  • @MrRacerGuy16
    @MrRacerGuy16 Год назад +1

    F1 2014 is just like driving a shopping cart at deadly speeds and is soo unrealistic bruh never play it!!!

  • @oldsingleplayer3012
    @oldsingleplayer3012 Год назад

    2012 the best for sure!

  • @Arch3i
    @Arch3i 8 месяцев назад

    Why does everyone hate 2022

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  8 месяцев назад

      Handling model mostly. Multiplayer wasn't great either.

    • @Arch3i
      @Arch3i 8 месяцев назад

      @@still_guns Personally I’ve always thought the handling is fine. Great video btw! Watched the whole thing

  • @alessandrosanna1270
    @alessandrosanna1270 Год назад

    F1 2010 is the decent game and 2011 is horrible not is the horrible f1 game is f1 2014

  • @billybreath2387
    @billybreath2387 Год назад

    Strange review video. Half the lap spent praising the games then the next half saying how bad they are.

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад

      Yeah, its departed from Steven Heartstones formula, but I can't go back and watch those to see how it should be anymore.

  • @okphone7393
    @okphone7393 Год назад +1

    Kokoko🥰🥰🥰🥰

  • @Alex-UM7GTE
    @Alex-UM7GTE Год назад

    I think you missed 2009...
    Sorry...

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад

      No I didn't. It's specifically for the PC games, and 2009 did not come to PC.

    • @Alex-UM7GTE
      @Alex-UM7GTE Год назад

      @@still_guns Oh.....🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Год назад

      @@Alex-UM7GTE There's a new version of this video BTW, check pinned comment for link.

  • @VroomAC
    @VroomAC Год назад +3

    unpopular opinion, f1 22's handling is perfect, f1 21 has horrible handling

    • @derrosso7082
      @derrosso7082 Год назад

      I have 2 Questions
      1.Since when r u playing F1 ?
      2.What Assists r u using ?

    • @VroomAC
      @VroomAC Год назад

      ​@@derrosso7082f1 22 is way better handling than 21 unfortunately

    • @indian_crocodile
      @indian_crocodile Год назад

      @@VroomAC f1 23 is better

    • @VroomAC
      @VroomAC Год назад

      @@indian_crocodile well obviously, but people for some reason adore 21 and all the games before it when 21 is the worst handling model lol, 22 was amazing in my opinion

  • @Mysteriuslyy
    @Mysteriuslyy 25 дней назад

    not the best than f1 2006