This HAS to be the most kindest and just way to talk about the brother in question. We know who the Sheikh is referring to, may Allah swt guide him and everyone. People have mostly mocked, laughed and jeered, but this explanation is beautiful. This explanation says it exactly how it is WITHOUT the nastiness. There is enough nastiness. Certain brothers have become like vultures tearing the flesh from a Muslim brother for a mistake and they have used their platform for DRAMA. I hate this. It is deflating. No one is perfect. We should ALL be rooting for one another to get to Jannah and we should be guiding and supporting, NOT laughing and mocking. Bottom line is this: Refee to Quran and Sunnah and you will not falter... Use kindness. It's a beautiful tool.... Have a peaceful day...:)
Nobody is "laughing" & "mocking", even though YQ has given us plenty of reasons to mock him and his giant ego, and his own so-called "academic excellence", when it is clear that he must not be within 100 ft of any public platform preaching about Islam. And I am absolutely amazed at how you still have no damn clue how to differentiate between a "mistake" and an open manifest misguidance, like this is the first time YQ came up with an "innocent mistake" like this, and he didn't know any better (a supposed "PhD" doctor who always derives each of his arguments and positions based on "thorough academic research", yet somehow this is still a "mistake"). This perfectly displays your ignorance. People like you never cease to amaze me at how mindblowingly naive and gullible all of you are. Every da'ee who has been refuting YQ is doing it because it is an OBLIGATION. This is not even remotely funny, and a matter to be laughing about. We have better things to do with our time than mocking him. We are only exposing him for an innovator and a charlatan he is PUBLICLY, and only cares about pleasing his Orientalist bosses.
they arn't "mocking and jeering" if anything people are upset and angry, teering the flesh of who? the videos are up on youtube for everybody to see, nothing is said behind his back or not confirmed. he is doing fatwa on very dangerous things which are clearly wrong, the biggest of wrongs. he could have made a fatwa saying you can have sex without marriage, eat pork, do drugs and drinking alcohol as all not haram and it would still not be as bad as this fataw. can you even comprehend the blunder that he did? (that is if it was a blunder and not intentional) as a principle, you can't make fatawi so lightly and especially when it has to do with shirk. every person who follows what he said and commits shirk will also add to the sin they committed over the one he did. so it's like him doing the sin of shirk thousands of times over. that's why doing a fatwa is a heavy responsibility that shouldn't be taken lightly.
Sheikh , thank you so much for a beautiful explanation of this form the Quran and Sunnah. May Allah swt preserve you. Barak Allah feekum wa JazaakAllaah khairan
There is nothing wrong in naming a person who is openly spreading misguidance. When Clarifying to the masses the truth, aswell as privately advising him. And that person also when realises and acknowledges the truth, must retract openly his mistakes and clarify the truth
Jzk khairan sheikh for this video ❤️ It’s very important that we expose those who were once ahlul sunnah , who have a large following and are now deviants and corrupting our deen.
Haqq Always Prevailing... "Al-Anbiya 21:18 Rather, We dash the TRUTH upon falsehood, and it destroys it, and thereupon it departs. And for you is destruction from that which you describe."
" very prominent scholar " . Sister you don't know the definition of a scholar and yasir qadhi is a deviant individual who misguided a lot of people . may Allah save us from his fitnah . ameen
@@luisgatmaitan9897 Someone doesn't become a scholar by graduating from Madinah university. Most Madinah University graduates are only students of knowledge.
@@luisgatmaitan9897 brother Luis, just because someone graduates from madinah does not mean they are scholars. If this was the case then every year we have hundreds of new scholars? Also, what he learned in madinah university is not what he holds anymore. He states it himself, I don’t follow that way anymore. He has created his own version in the west. May Allah preserve us all. Ameen.
@@luisgatmaitan9897 graduating from Madeenah does not make you a scholar. it just gives you the keys and lays the foundations to being a strong student of knowledge
At first I thought it said making dua for the dead muslim to Allah Subhanahu wa ta'ala, like "Inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi raji’un". But it actually is about invoking after watching a bit of the video. Of course we should only worship the only one worthy, Allah Subhanahu wa ta'ala. Allah knows best.
I love this sheikh who does not make an apple in China becomes a mango in London. Frankly, truth is true and a lie is a lie and surely, he does not camouflage like a camellia lizard 🐊 . I pray 🙏 to Allah to keep him steadfast in the deen and admit him to the highest level of paradise with his family 👪 .
We can not call such a person who makes these claims a scholar. The true scholars are those who are firm on the Quran and the Sunnah and have the understanding of the first three generations in Islam.
every person that commits shirk because of what he said will not only gain the sin of shirk (one of the biggest you can ever get) but he will also gain the same sin so it's like him commiting shirk houndreds or thousands of times over...that's why making fatwa shouldn't be taken lightly
I understand when it comes to Yasir Qadhi and Omar Suleiman, but you gotta understand that Nouman Ali Khan is probably in a fitnah. We must understand as a muslims, we should remove these unwanted suspicious as it will lead to backbiting and if the evidence were wrong, lying deliberately to another muslim
Idols are not the same as dead people, because the souls of dead people are alive in the Barzakh. In fact, Moses assisted this ummah after he died, but no idol did. The Prophet ( sallalaahu alaihi wasalaam) also benefits us, by praying for us in his grave as mentioned in the ahadith, and God commands us to sent blessings on the Prophet even now until Qiyaamah. My point is we cannot equate idols with dead people, get it through your skulls.
Brother Sol sak please refrain from speaking if you don't have knowledge especially when it comes to important matters like tawheed and shirk. Idols and dead people are heavily connected. Shirk started on the face of the earth with extreme ghulu with graves and dead people. Please go study yourself. The people of Nuh (alayhi salam) were declared to be mushrikeen/polytheists because they used to worship the status of righteous people who died. And you all know how Allah dealt with the people of Nuh alayhi saam. May Allah protect the muslims from shirk. Moreover, when we ask Allah to bless our Prophet ﷺ we are not seeking help or reward from the Prophet ﷺ but rather by doing so we are seeking reward from Allah. This because the Prophet ﷺ said: “Whoever sends blessings upon me once, Allah will send blessings upon him tenfold and will erase from him ten misdeeds and raise him ten degrees in status.” Narrated by an-Nasaa’i (1297); classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Saheeh Sunan an-Nasaa’i.
Jazakum Allahu Khairan but this is not Sh. Assim's style. I have learned from him that the best dawah is the one that is given diplomatically and indirectly.
@@Justalayman yeah brother but more pple will watch and be saved from hellfire bc this call sheikh is misguiding pple. SubhanAllah May Allah SWT protect us from hellfire
@@Justalayman BarakAllahu for your work and your warmed heart, but I have to agree with the brother. If someone spreads misguidance and falsehood publicly we have to warn the people from him. Yasir Qadhi also doesn't listen to advise and so on. And this is not the only thing he is saying in front of hundrets and thousands. He is changing the religion. May Allah guide us all
The issue is that the people in the sub continent believe in the concept of Walis, Now Walis do exist in Islam as its clearly mentioned in the holy Qur'an however that does not necessarily mean that the way certain sects believe them to be. So the belief is that if a shaheed is still alive in his grave then prophets and walis are too, so as they are more loved by Allah swt and are more closer to him then making dua and including their names as a means to get closer to Allah is acceptable. They also believe that the area where the Prophets and walis are buried are full of Rehmat and blessings that's the reason why they stand by their graves and make dua at that particular place, as I understand it's not to the graves and Allah swt knows best. It would be beneficial if someone can talk about the "real" concept of Walis and what it means. I have many relatives who follow that belief but I know they are not praying to the deceased per se as described above but having said that I can see how it can lead to shirk.
As far as the Shahid is concerned, it is clear in the Qur'an and Sunnah that their souls are placed within the bodies of green birds. They're earthly bodies decay though. To be honest there's NO TEXTUAL EVIDENCE and no way of knowing whether the bodies of the Awliyaa are still preserved in their graves. Wallahualam
Yeah unless u have the proper understanding and firm heart and faith dont do it , especially if u fear that u fall in shirk...the rest of tawassul is ok but the al madad type is a bit confusing
Asking the death for help is haram and shirk it's logical and was always known. Those that attempt to dilute Islam and corrupt young people minds will verily fail
7.20 dear Sheikh, what about Yunus 18 and Az Zumar 3, the pagans or arab considered the objects they worshipped to have the power of rooboobiyyah, i.e. shafaat givers and protectors.
You have to look at the technicalities of things and not get emotional . Yasir Qadhi is not merely a daee but has a PHD in theology, has an in indepth knowledge of islamic issues, such as legal etc. He does not change his views out of ignorance unless he has researched and analysed the matter throughout historically and based on evidences from Qur'aan and Sunnah. People tend to think what he brings is new but actually it is not new at all when you look at the evidences that he has gathered.
Sister Najma, he is well aware of the right from wrong but chose the wrong. A perfect example, he stated that in his humble opinion, shaking the hands of the opposite gender is not haram. And I can provide a link to this if you are not aware of this. You stated he derives his analytical opinion from quran and sunnah correct? Then please tell me how can this be so, when the prophet stated: It was narrated that Ma’qil ibn Yassaar said: the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “For one of you to be stabbed in the head with an iron needle is better for him than that he should touch a woman who is not permissible for him.” How can you rectify this? When the prophet stated such be states otherwise. The phd is meaningless sister. There are many many phd holders in islamic studies that are not christians and jews, but does the phd have any significant value? If you look at his views from the past when he is a student in madinah and he himself said a couple of years ago, i use to be like this but not anymore. He clearly changed his view and rebuked the scholars from whom he learned from in madinah. He has placed his phd from Yale above his studies in madinah. Even his masters thesis was a refutation against the shia. We need to preserve the deen, sister. If we allow this type of analysis and rhetoric, then nothing of this religion will remain. This analysis that he provided has never been provided by any previous scholars since the prophet until now. So we must ask ourselves, have they all been astray because apparently yasir qadhi was able to come Up with this view that no one else had from the scholars of the quran and sunnah. May Allah preserve you and all of us on the haqq. Ameen.
I'm not here to say if Sh. Yasir Qadhi is right or wrong. But the sister said that he gave a "fatwa" that is incorrect. He said its an opinion he follows meaning some Scholars believe that it is haram but not shirk.
i thought what was meant, was the other way around. as in the living doing dua to allah to forgive the dead so on and so forth which is diffinitly not haram and has nothing to do with shirk but once the sister explained it i got what she meant. i thought it was general knowledge that it's shirk. even if you "invoke" them in a non godly way (which doesn't make sense btw) why would you do it when you can invoke the name of allah thiker which is much much better than invoking the name of any human. so at best AT BEST for these people, it's a very bad habit and and worse, the are doing shirk which literally one of the worst things you can do ever. so why risk it?
Just bc you are doing something without the bad intention doesnt mwan its automatically halal. So i can celebrate Christmas as long as i see it as a joliday for presents and not have intention to celebrate jesus's pbuh birthday eventho its not his birthday? No. Shirk and doing anything that leada to it is haram
Today we have the claim that the Majority of the Ummah has fallen into Major Shirk, where as the Prophet [Peace be upon him] had clearly mentioned to us that he does not fear his Ummah of committing major Shirk. Sahi Muslim, Book 30, Number 5689: Narrated 'Uqba bin 'Amir: إِنِّي لَسْتُ أَخْشَىٰ عَلَيْكُمْ أَنْ تُشْرِكُوا بَعْدِي. وَلٰكِنِّي أَخْشَىٰ عَلَيْكُمُ الدُّنْيَا أَنْ تَنَافَسُوا فِيهَا "I am not afraid that you would associate anything with Allah after me, but I am afraid that you may be (allured) by the world". Sahih al-Bukhari, Volume 8, Book 76, Number 434: Narrated 'Uqba bin 'Amir: وإني والله لا أخشى عليكم الشرك من بعدي "By Allah! I am not afraid that after me you will worship others besides Allah, but I am afraid that you will start competing for (the pleasures of) this world."
Asalam alikom Can someone break this down for me please ? Basically i don’t say or sum say “ rest my mothers soul ya allah n forgive her and forgive us and all my brothers n sisters “ zakk allah khair to all the help may allah bless us forgive us and have mercy upon us ameem
Walaykumus salam wa rahmatullah. Praying for the deceased isn’t the problem, praying to the deceased or setting them as intercessor between you and Allah is considered Shirk.
Studying doesn't necessarily make you a scholar and it doesn't mean you're going to be upon the Haqq. Guidance comes from Allah and He guides whomsoever he wills. However, I'm not saying we should not study. Studying and learning the Deen it's infact obligatory upon every Muslim, but we should always ask Allah to guide us and keep us firm, we should constantly humble ourselves to Allah and ask Him for guidance and steadfastness.
I pray for people who are in the grave I don't pray too them even though in the last revelation it says the dead don't die and there is no fear on the friends of God there bodies are preserved in graves anyway next time the people who think that people are praying too the people in grave .....when you are ill or need money don't go too doctor or bank and go direct to the Lord watch what response you get 😂☝️
Is Yasir Qadh spread this misguidance Allah protect us non can ever spread this lay Yasir Qadh need counseling one day i was listening to Imam Kareem Abuzaid( may Allah keep him with long life and bless him ) talk about situation of Yasir Qadh also shekh Alhakeem talk about Yasir Qadh problem and my self i have listened to Yasir Qadh what he talk about is totally misguidance may Allah protect people to follow Yasir Qadh because its very dangerous with islamic faith
You said that we should not seek fatwa from likes " you, " .means that all what the on internet is not correct. So if you are not an authority on religious matters then who on earth is knowledgeable?
So , muslims visiting Dargahs or the mausoleum of these preachers of islam is shirk ... Therefore , don't pray or sing hymns for Muhammad nizamuddin ,or khwaja moinuddin chisty
Farook Mow, this is how shirk begins if you believe this is not shirk. Read on the origins of shirk. Ir started before Propher Nuh. 4 righteous men who passed away. The shaytaan didnt come to the people right away to make duaa to them. He said to these people, perhaps you should erect some statues for them in honor of them. Generations passed until knowledge was lost about these reasons for these erected statues of the dead pious men. Shaytaan came back to the people and said don’t you know these are illahs (gods) that your forefathers use to worship and so paganism began. The lesson for us all in this is: even if you don’t believe this isn’t shirk, which it is, then at least look at the dangers of this. Because shaytaan is our sworn enemy and he his ploys are many to take us to jahanam with him. Don’t ever tell yourself that this only a sin but not a major one. Once you allow that belief into our heart, shaytaan will start his work on you. May Allah preserve us All. Ameen.
Sheikh Wallah we are happy to have you, Alhamdulillah
He is one of the best blessings from ALLAH S.W.T
Sheikh assim being very humble regarding himself aswell. Mashallah
This I liked very much
Yasir Qadhi should fear Allah for spreading misguidance!
Is yasir qadhi a salafi?
@@tazboy1934 he was this he was that. he flip flops with his views and opinions.
May Allah bless you Sheikh for helping us stay on the right path. These type of videos are significant for the Ummah.
This HAS to be the most kindest and just way to talk about the brother in question.
We know who the Sheikh is referring to, may Allah swt guide him and everyone.
People have mostly mocked, laughed and jeered, but this explanation is beautiful. This explanation says it exactly how it is WITHOUT the nastiness.
There is enough nastiness.
Certain brothers have become like vultures tearing the flesh from a Muslim brother for a mistake and they have used their platform for DRAMA.
I hate this.
It is deflating.
No one is perfect.
We should ALL be rooting for one another to get to Jannah and we should be guiding and supporting, NOT laughing and mocking.
Bottom line is this: Refee to Quran and Sunnah and you will not falter...
Use kindness. It's a beautiful tool....
Have a peaceful day...:)
Nobody is "laughing" & "mocking", even though YQ has given us plenty of reasons to mock him and his giant ego, and his own so-called "academic excellence", when it is clear that he must not be within 100 ft of any public platform preaching about Islam.
And I am absolutely amazed at how you still have no damn clue how to differentiate between a "mistake" and an open manifest misguidance, like this is the first time YQ came up with an "innocent mistake" like this, and he didn't know any better (a supposed "PhD" doctor who always derives each of his arguments and positions based on "thorough academic research", yet somehow this is still a "mistake"). This perfectly displays your ignorance. People like you never cease to amaze me at how mindblowingly naive and gullible all of you are.
Every da'ee who has been refuting YQ is doing it because it is an OBLIGATION. This is not even remotely funny, and a matter to be laughing about.
We have better things to do with our time than mocking him. We are only exposing him for an innovator and a charlatan he is PUBLICLY, and only cares about pleasing his Orientalist bosses.
they arn't "mocking and jeering" if anything people are upset and angry, teering the flesh of who? the videos are up on youtube for everybody to see, nothing is said behind his back or not confirmed. he is doing fatwa on very dangerous things which are clearly wrong, the biggest of wrongs. he could have made a fatwa saying you can have sex without marriage, eat pork, do drugs and drinking alcohol as all not haram and it would still not be as bad as this fataw.
can you even comprehend the blunder that he did? (that is if it was a blunder and not intentional) as a principle, you can't make fatawi so lightly and especially when it has to do with shirk.
every person who follows what he said and commits shirk will also add to the sin they committed over the one he did. so it's like him doing the sin of shirk thousands of times over. that's why doing a fatwa is a heavy responsibility that shouldn't be taken lightly.
Sheikh , thank you so much for a beautiful explanation of this form the Quran and Sunnah. May Allah swt preserve you. Barak Allah feekum wa JazaakAllaah khairan
Best to stay away from things that are doubtful
There is nothing wrong in naming a person who is openly spreading misguidance. When Clarifying to the masses the truth, aswell as privately advising him. And that person also when realises and acknowledges the truth, must retract openly his mistakes and clarify the truth
correct
You speak Misguidance to the public then you will get refuted public. This is the way. Correct brother
The sheikh who said this is Yasir Qadhi watch out for him
Alhamdulillah, Sheikh ,we found scholars like you❤.
sheikh assim your my sheikh love you for the sake of allah jazakallah khair
Thank you sheikh for clarifying
May Allah reward you with good.
Jzk khairan sheikh for this video ❤️
It’s very important that we expose those who were once ahlul sunnah , who have a large following and are now deviants and corrupting our deen.
May Allah guide Yasir Qadhi back to the right path, amen.
It is important to understand the ayaats of the Qur'an and the hadiths.
MashaAllah Shaykh
Start Memorizing Hadith Today!!! Insha Allah
As Salaamu Alaikum just browse thru your channel & subscribe Jazallah Khair.
جزاك الله خيرا
MashaAllah, the best possible explanation, jazakAllah khairun sheikh
Thank you Sheikh 😊
Haqq Always Prevailing...
"Al-Anbiya 21:18
Rather, We dash the TRUTH upon falsehood, and it destroys it, and thereupon it departs. And for you is destruction from that which you describe."
" very prominent scholar " . Sister you don't know the definition of a scholar and yasir qadhi is a deviant individual who misguided a lot of people . may Allah save us from his fitnah . ameen
Yasir kadhi?
Yasir Qadhi is not a scholar. May Allaah save us from the likes of him.
He is a scholar otherwise he won't graduate in Madinah university
Yes he is?
@@luisgatmaitan9897 Someone doesn't become a scholar by graduating from Madinah university. Most Madinah University graduates are only students of knowledge.
@@luisgatmaitan9897 brother Luis, just because someone graduates from madinah does not mean they are scholars. If this was the case then every year we have hundreds of new scholars? Also, what he learned in madinah university is not what he holds anymore. He states it himself, I don’t follow that way anymore. He has created his own version in the west. May Allah preserve us all. Ameen.
@@luisgatmaitan9897 graduating from Madeenah does not make you a scholar. it just gives you the keys and lays the foundations to being a strong student of knowledge
People in west need to know the definition of a scholar
Jazakallah Khair
At first I thought it said making dua for the dead muslim to Allah Subhanahu wa ta'ala, like "Inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi raji’un". But it actually is about invoking after watching a bit of the video. Of course we should only worship the only one worthy, Allah Subhanahu wa ta'ala. Allah knows best.
Jazakallahu Khairan
Wa Jazakum
Asalamualiakum shiekh had given good answer
I love this sheikh who does not make an apple in China becomes a mango in London. Frankly, truth is true and a lie is a lie and surely, he does not camouflage like a camellia lizard 🐊 . I pray 🙏 to Allah to keep him steadfast in the deen and admit him to the highest level of paradise with his family 👪 .
I love you sheikh❤️
The Scholar that said this is "Abu Ammaar Yasir Qadhi"
The same opinion is also said by Ibn Taymiyyah.
We can not call such a person who makes these claims a scholar. The true scholars are those who are firm on the Quran and the Sunnah and have the understanding of the first three generations in Islam.
@@shadowwhowalk bring your proof!
every person that commits shirk because of what he said will not only gain the sin of shirk (one of the biggest you can ever get) but he will also gain the same sin so it's like him commiting shirk houndreds or thousands of times over...that's why making fatwa shouldn't be taken lightly
Thanks sheikh
Salafis should protect their aqeeda..
Unsubscribe YASIR QADHI.
I unsubscribed this charlatan a year and a half ago. It's a shame others are slow in picking up his deviancies
Yasir qadhi is not salafi.
La ilaha illallah wahdahu la sharika lah.
The Daee who said this is Yasir Qadhi btw
Really where?
@@almukhlabi ruclips.net/video/MGCy24mMKuc/видео.html there is the link him saying the blasphemous fatwa🙂
You cant take knowledge from Yasir Qadhi, Omar suleiman and Nourman Ali Khan.
Why?what they did?
I understand when it comes to Yasir Qadhi and Omar Suleiman, but you gotta understand that Nouman Ali Khan is probably in a fitnah.
We must understand as a muslims, we should remove these unwanted suspicious as it will lead to backbiting and if the evidence were wrong, lying deliberately to another muslim
Don't follow Yasir qadi
Follow ahlu sunna walnjama'a
Yasir Qadhi is not a scholar! dear questioner
Idols are not the same as dead people, because the souls of dead people are alive in the Barzakh. In fact, Moses assisted this ummah after he died, but no idol did. The Prophet ( sallalaahu alaihi wasalaam) also benefits us, by praying for us in his grave as mentioned in the ahadith, and God commands us to sent blessings on the Prophet even now until Qiyaamah. My point is we cannot equate idols with dead people, get it through your skulls.
May Allah bless you my brother
Astaghfirullah. Sending blessings upon the Propher SAW is completely different than worshipping him or the dead!!!
U right...u need to have deep knowledge ...this thing confuses me...
@@zoltan506 Ameen, may Allah Bless You too Brother
Brother Sol sak please refrain from speaking if you don't have knowledge especially when it comes to important matters like tawheed and shirk. Idols and dead people are heavily connected. Shirk started on the face of the earth with extreme ghulu with graves and dead people. Please go study yourself. The people of Nuh (alayhi salam) were declared to be mushrikeen/polytheists because they used to worship the status of righteous people who died. And you all know how Allah dealt with the people of Nuh alayhi saam. May Allah protect the muslims from shirk. Moreover, when we ask Allah to bless our Prophet ﷺ we are not seeking help or reward from the Prophet ﷺ but rather by doing so we are seeking reward from Allah. This because the Prophet ﷺ said: “Whoever sends blessings upon me once, Allah will send blessings upon him tenfold and will erase from him ten misdeeds and raise him ten degrees in status.” Narrated by an-Nasaa’i (1297); classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Saheeh Sunan an-Nasaa’i.
The guy there talking about is yasir alqadi
Admin my advice to u is change the title of the video, make refutation to yasir qadhi. And thumbnail also
Jazakum Allahu Khairan but this is not Sh. Assim's style. I have learned from him that the best dawah is the one that is given diplomatically and indirectly.
@@Justalayman yeah brother but more pple will watch and be saved from hellfire bc this call sheikh is misguiding pple. SubhanAllah May Allah SWT protect us from hellfire
@@Justalayman BarakAllahu for your work and your warmed heart, but I have to agree with the brother. If someone spreads misguidance and falsehood publicly we have to warn the people from him. Yasir Qadhi also doesn't listen to advise and so on. And this is not the only thing he is saying in front of hundrets and thousands. He is changing the religion. May Allah guide us all
The issue is that the people in the sub continent believe in the concept of Walis, Now Walis do exist in Islam as its clearly mentioned in the holy Qur'an however that does not necessarily mean that the way certain sects believe them to be. So the belief is that if a shaheed is still alive in his grave then prophets and walis are too, so as they are more loved by Allah swt and are more closer to him then making dua and including their names as a means to get closer to Allah is acceptable. They also believe that the area where the Prophets and walis are buried are full of Rehmat and blessings that's the reason why they stand by their graves and make dua at that particular place, as I understand it's not to the graves and Allah swt knows best.
It would be beneficial if someone can talk about the "real" concept of Walis and what it means. I have many relatives who follow that belief but I know they are not praying to the deceased per se as described above but having said that I can see how it can lead to shirk.
As far as the Shahid is concerned, it is clear in the Qur'an and Sunnah that their souls are placed within the bodies of green birds. They're earthly bodies decay though.
To be honest there's NO TEXTUAL EVIDENCE and no way of knowing whether the bodies of the Awliyaa are still preserved in their graves.
Wallahualam
Yeah unless u have the proper understanding and firm heart and faith dont do it , especially if u fear that u fall in shirk...the rest of tawassul is ok but the al madad type is a bit confusing
Yes I believe on you Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem. Dr Yasir Qadi is innovating something that confuses pepplet.
Asking the death for help is haram and shirk it's logical and was always known. Those that attempt to dilute Islam and corrupt young people minds will verily fail
To the dead and for the dead
Big difference
7.20 dear Sheikh, what about Yunus 18 and Az Zumar 3, the pagans or arab considered the objects they worshipped to have the power of rooboobiyyah, i.e. shafaat givers and protectors.
You have to look at the technicalities of things and not get emotional .
Yasir Qadhi is not merely a daee but has a PHD in theology, has an in indepth knowledge of islamic issues, such as legal etc.
He does not change his views out of ignorance unless he has researched and analysed the matter throughout historically and based on evidences from Qur'aan and Sunnah.
People tend to think what he brings is new but actually it is not new at all when you look at the evidences that he has gathered.
He is not ignorant and you are right. But he is misguiding people even after knowing the truth
Sister Najma, he is well aware of the right from wrong but chose the wrong. A perfect example, he stated that in his humble opinion, shaking the hands of the opposite gender is not haram. And I can provide a link to this if you are not aware of this. You stated he derives his analytical opinion from quran and sunnah correct? Then please tell me how can this be so, when the prophet stated:
It was narrated that Ma’qil ibn Yassaar said: the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “For one of you to be stabbed in the head with an iron needle is better for him than that he should touch a woman who is not permissible for him.”
How can you rectify this? When the prophet stated such be states otherwise.
The phd is meaningless sister. There are many many phd holders in islamic studies that are not christians and jews, but does the phd have any significant value? If you look at his views from the past when he is a student in madinah and he himself said a couple of years ago, i use to be like this but not anymore. He clearly changed his view and rebuked the scholars from whom he learned from in madinah. He has placed his phd from
Yale above his studies in madinah. Even his masters thesis was a refutation against the shia.
We need to preserve the deen, sister. If we allow this type of analysis and rhetoric, then nothing of this religion will remain. This analysis that he provided has never been provided by any previous scholars since the prophet until now. So we must ask ourselves, have they all been astray because apparently yasir qadhi was able to come
Up with this view that no one else had from the scholars of the quran and sunnah. May Allah preserve you and all of us on the haqq. Ameen.
@@mohammadsaeed1321Ameen
Sir, how about dua from our mother? The concept is similar
I'm not here to say if Sh. Yasir Qadhi is right or wrong. But the sister said that he gave a "fatwa" that is incorrect. He said its an opinion he follows meaning some Scholars believe that it is haram but not shirk.
i thought what was meant, was the other way around. as in the living doing dua to allah to forgive the dead so on and so forth which is diffinitly not haram and has nothing to do with shirk but once the sister explained it i got what she meant. i thought it was general knowledge that it's shirk.
even if you "invoke" them in a non godly way (which doesn't make sense btw) why would you do it when you can invoke the name of allah thiker which is much much better than invoking the name of any human. so at best AT BEST for these people, it's a very bad habit and and worse, the are doing shirk which literally one of the worst things you can do ever. so why risk it?
Shiekh should have mentioned its about yasur qadhi
He probably doesn’t want to cause hate. People just need to know whoever says it, it’s wrong.
Just bc you are doing something without the bad intention doesnt mwan its automatically halal. So i can celebrate Christmas as long as i see it as a joliday for presents and not have intention to celebrate jesus's pbuh birthday eventho its not his birthday? No. Shirk and doing anything that leada to it is haram
Today we have the claim that the Majority of the Ummah has fallen into Major Shirk, where as the Prophet [Peace be upon him] had clearly mentioned to us that he does not fear his Ummah of committing major Shirk.
Sahi Muslim, Book 30, Number 5689:
Narrated 'Uqba bin 'Amir:
إِنِّي لَسْتُ أَخْشَىٰ عَلَيْكُمْ أَنْ تُشْرِكُوا بَعْدِي. وَلٰكِنِّي أَخْشَىٰ عَلَيْكُمُ الدُّنْيَا أَنْ تَنَافَسُوا فِيهَا
"I am not afraid that you would associate anything with Allah after me, but I am afraid that you may be (allured) by the world".
Sahih al-Bukhari, Volume 8, Book 76, Number 434:
Narrated 'Uqba bin 'Amir:
وإني والله لا أخشى عليكم الشرك من بعدي
"By Allah! I am not afraid that after me you will worship others besides Allah, but I am afraid that you will start competing for (the pleasures of) this world."
Asalam alikom Can someone break this down for me please ? Basically i don’t say or sum say “ rest my mothers soul ya allah n forgive her and forgive us and all my brothers n sisters “ zakk allah khair to all the help may allah bless us forgive us and have mercy upon us ameem
Walaykumus salam wa rahmatullah.
Praying for the deceased isn’t the problem, praying to the deceased or setting them as intercessor between you and Allah is considered Shirk.
Shaikh Asim it was not yusuf estes the daee who said that it was shaikh yasir qadhi who studied in Madinah for 10yrs and has PHD in Yale.
Studying doesn't necessarily make you a scholar and it doesn't mean you're going to be upon the Haqq. Guidance comes from Allah and He guides whomsoever he wills. However, I'm not saying we should not study. Studying and learning the Deen it's infact obligatory upon every Muslim, but we should always ask Allah to guide us and keep us firm, we should constantly humble ourselves to Allah and ask Him for guidance and steadfastness.
I pray for people who are in the grave I don't pray too them even though in the last revelation it says the dead don't die and there is no fear on the friends of God there bodies are preserved in graves anyway next time the people who think that people are praying too the people in grave .....when you are ill or need money don't go too doctor or bank and go direct to the Lord watch what response you get 😂☝️
What surah is 5:32 ???
Can someone explain me this video? I dont quite understand.
It's yasir qadri who has mentioned this
Warning beware of this guy
The fame has got to him
Is Yasir Qadh spread this misguidance Allah protect us non can ever spread this lay Yasir Qadh need counseling one day i was listening to Imam Kareem Abuzaid( may Allah keep him with long life and bless him ) talk about situation of Yasir Qadh also shekh Alhakeem talk about Yasir Qadh problem and my self i have listened to Yasir Qadh what he talk about is totally misguidance may Allah protect people to follow Yasir Qadh because its very dangerous with islamic faith
Ability to analyse is what makes a scholar. Looks like today we have Imam al Ghazali at every corner
You said that we should not seek fatwa from likes " you, " .means that all what the on internet is not correct. So if you are not an authority on religious matters then who on earth is knowledgeable?
People reached Mars,
They still debating on this,
What will you get in the hereafter if you reached Mars?
Okay reached mars... then what happen?
Is not scholar.
Its imam/daee.
He is qualified enough to be a scholar.
So , muslims visiting Dargahs or the mausoleum of these preachers of islam is shirk ...
Therefore , don't pray or sing hymns for Muhammad nizamuddin ,or khwaja moinuddin chisty
For the simple minded it's shirk, for the men of knowledge it's the smell of the rose garden.
NOT Shirk but may lead to shirk
Are your Ears ok?
Read the Quran
What is shirk then?
Farook Mow, this is how shirk begins if you believe this is not shirk. Read on the origins of shirk. Ir started before Propher Nuh. 4 righteous men who passed away. The shaytaan didnt come to the people right away to make duaa to them. He said to these people, perhaps you should erect some statues for them in honor of them. Generations passed until knowledge was lost about these reasons for these erected statues of the dead pious men. Shaytaan came back to the people and said don’t you know these are illahs (gods) that your forefathers use to worship and so paganism began. The lesson for us all in this is: even if you don’t believe this isn’t shirk, which it is, then at least look at the dangers of this. Because shaytaan is our sworn enemy and he his ploys are many to take us to jahanam with him. Don’t ever tell yourself that this only a sin but not a major one. Once you allow that belief into our heart, shaytaan will start his work on you. May Allah preserve us All. Ameen.
@@tahaanwar2807 Shirk is when you call upon anything or anyone or worship anything/anyone other than Allah.