@@Mouse_Metal E.K. Johnston's Queen trilogy. Sabé has a massive crush on Padmé since age 12. Yané and Saché fell in love at age 12 during the Naboo crisis.
Trivia: In the EU (it will always be the EU, not "Legends"), female stormtroopers did exist (this was after they started recruiting normal humans to replace the aging clones), but they looked (and sounded) the same as their male counterparts after putting on their combat armour (a function of the armour), to reinforce the "faceless army" trappings (and quash any potential snowflake-ism). (Also, they were very rare compared to the males.)
Also... like, Disney could have put the sparti clones earlier in the timeline and added female clones and other bits of diversity through more logical means, they were the good candidates to bulk up the clone army. In the EU female stormtroopers became a thing post endor when numbers needed bulking up and commonplace by the legacy era, same with 'alien' stormtroopers. In canon the empire pulled both male and female humans... which honestly doesn't really matter, you wouldn't be able to tell in public anyways.
Yeah, the Kaminoans would have terminated Sister immediately when he is confused about his identity. That's not ideal for warfare, and the Kaminoans crave perfection
That and they became ruthless eugenicists to survive a biblical flood that killed a vast majority of there population, she'd be lucky if they made her a janitor if not out right kill the clone, the clones also were treated like property by there creators
Apparently they forgot that once Order 66 is declared, the Clone Troopers lose any sense of individuality and turn their guns on the Jedi. Meaning that they created a trans character, who'll inevitably contribute to the murder of almost every Jedi. Smart move on their part.
The trans clone really bothers me. Not that trans people exist in star wars, it is a big galaxy so if it is done well (it wouldn't be but that isn't my current point) it would be fine. The issue is we don't know what causes gender dysphoria, but whatever it is it literally could not show up in a clone. The clones are of the same genetic stock, grown in the exact same way, exposed to the same hormones, develop in the same place, are taught the same things. It would literally be all of them or none of them. If something managed to make a single one pop up they would have been purged instantly. I miss when the Kaminoans were eugenicist monsters that culled battalions of literal children because they didn't have perfect 20/20 vision, were willing to waste the investment of an entire squad of commandos that ran a few seconds slower than the rest. The kind of psychopaths you'd expect from a species willing to accelerate the growth of children to make a slave army.
@@mpsuorsa Legends says so, the TRUE Canon. How? By absence of mention, and that all of Jango's clones WERE MALE. The clones were all male. No room for interpretation. END OF BLOODY STORY. Star Wars has nothing to do with with this nonsense. You want that PC trash? Go read SAGA the comic. Woke-as-hell.
The fact folks still try to act like his work holds validity when all he did was sexually assault a pair twins until one LITERALLY KILLED HIMSELF TO ESCAPE THE SICK BASTARDS 'EXPERIMENTS' shows just how fucked up they REALLY are
Now finally transgender clonetrooper is we were all waiting for!!! Can't wait for Black Lives Matter clonetrooper and Free Palestine clonetrooper, I just love the excapeism in STAR WARS nowadays
Star wars is an allegory for the Vietnam War and the rise of authoritarianism in America, specifically Star Wars has always been about calling out Republicans for trying to be dictators (Nixon in the og trilogy, Bush in the prequels), by far the most escapist/ least political of the films would definitely be the sequels. I don't really see how transgender people ruin escapism for you, are you really that upset that oppressed minorities receive representation that it ruins the entire fantasy? Damn that sucks for you.
Another 'creative' who doesn't understand the basis concept of a foot soldier. The clone troopers were not designed to act autonomously outside of their respective military force, they were bred solely for one purpose: serve the Republic in the Clone Wars (and by extension Palpatine). Identity politics would literally be one of the last things that a clone trooper could be asked to think about, and if anyone disagrees with that, then they need to reevaluate how they process fiction. This 'inclusive' aspect to the lore does more harm than good, as this would be considered a glaring design flaw in the clone troopers themselves; the point is that they were NOT meant to think for themselves on such a level, and if more clones thought this way, they would be terrible in a war. In times of direct, physical conflict, like war or surviving the apocalypse, for example, ideologies would be one of the first thing to be discarded, in order for one to try and survive. The biggest poison to escapism and fantasy, is forced modern-day political takes, and authors trying to lecture their audience. This proves that Disney doesn't care about their audience, or the licenses which they own.
How exactly could a storm trooper, or in this case, a clone trooper came to this ideas? They were born and thought a specific thing all their life, then thrown in the meat grinder... Alongside hundreds of the same individual. The creators have no interest in that and the Jedi do not deal with that. The other guy is a machine with weird quirks... None of this would make them have ideas about gender.
Sick of these people sitting at their desks writing in somebody else’s universe talking about “being brave” and “challenging the status quo”. Make your own shitty IP for your terrible ideas.
The funniest thing is that there are different ways to do trans representation in Star Wars. Species of beings can be created that can be gender fluid, or have multiple sexes, or males can give birth. The worst solution was chosen - a human clone was put into it, even though clones are only supposed to follow orders and do not care about gender identity.
As others have pointed out, it took clones 10 years to mature on kamino, and the clone wars lasted about 3 1/2 years, so when did the trans clone have time to express their gendee identity?? In kamino surrounded by men?? During combat across the galaxy?? Its stupid, makes no sense, and only exists for fake meaningless diversity. Why make a clone trans?? And not some other character with a little more weight??
E K Johnston is massive prog activist, so she definitely wasn't "forced" to do this by anyone. In fact, I saw in another video talking about this, that she said that it was her idea, and that Disney didn't push back at all. There's photos of her where a top with various made up gender flags on her sleeves, so this is fully her inserting her politics into Star Wars. She also tried to give Ahsoka a lesbian love interest in the Ahsoka novel, which was extremely cringe. This definitely takes the cake in the cringe department though. I don't have time for this made up, unscientific, nonsense in the real world, so I sure as hell don't want it in Star Wars. Everything Disney makes now is just propaganda to push their evil ideology. You're right about them just using these people as tools and shields, but the real objective is power and cultural control. All such activists need to be purged from the entertainment industry or nothing will change.
Trans people are obviously valid. Anyone who thinks otherwise is just a pathetic pos loser who wants to dictate how other people live. Nothing worse than control freak zealots foaming at the mouth.
Reading those words coming from Anakin, of all characters, feels incredibly wrong. Even if I sided with this matter, he's not the kind of character who would say such wise-sounding things, especially since, you know, he's the man who became Darth Vader.
Omega is a far better character than Sister. Omega had a good story to tell and was written well. Sister is a mascot for diversity in Star Wars and nothing else. You can write an essay on Omegas character and her importance to the Star Wars galaxy. Sister's importance can be summed up in a short paragraph. In conclusion, Sister is not in the same league as Omega. She isn't even in the same league as Dr. Emerie.
Her brothers literally _named_ her Sister for being The Girl, that's her name now as her one definining feature instead of just talking to her with girl pronouns and moving on. It almost feels like bullying if Rex hadn't specified it was meant to be the opposite, not very sensitive of Dickney. 🏳️⚧️ And why is Rex selling the _Secrets_ of the Clone Troopers to the Magic Empire anyway!? That seems a touch out of character, as if Disney even cares about that anymore. Are they stupid?
Do these kinds of writers really want readers to think, "Oh, that's the trans one!" when they see this character? I would rather have readers associate the character with their personality rather than being a representation tick on a checklist.
You Know J J You Should Absolutely Destroy Mr Plinkett’s Pathetic Reviews Of The Prequel Trilogy Since It Literally Destroyed George Lucas’s Career As A CEO Of Lucasfilm And Because Of It We Have To Experience Forced Reparations And Also You Should Do An Analyzing Evil On HelloGreedo And Chris Stuckmann
@@James_Bee And Mr. Plinkett is supposed to be a comedy. It's not serious film criticism, even though it does have valid points. But the gang at RLM are mostly there for laughs and film criticism second. Dubbing them "evil" is petty. And yes, the prequels were laughably bad. These guys are now basically saying anyone who doesn't like Lucas' entire body of work is evil, which is not only ridiculous but pretty messed up
Kaminoans were inspired by the Greys. Everything for them is in terms of perfection, sterility and cold detachment. They are Mengele level scientists. The ultimate scientists. How exactly do they allow this guy to be confused and not terminate him? He would be an afront to their way. A mistake that should never be allowed to exist in their eyes. Did the weirdo writing this not bother to ask what George and the special effects department thought when designing them and their world?
Just imagine that this guy would refuse to follow orders because someone have been called him "he"" or tell him the "truth" that he's a man, he only put on risk the rest of his squad and the republic itself. So, no, a tr3ns trooper is impossible and couldn't exist..
The only way that could happen is if the Kaminoans wanted to create a ‘Trans’ clone. But they were not taken to whimsical “ooooh .. what if we do this..?” random acts. They were hard nosed scientists and business minded. They were trying to create the perfect soldiers. A ‘trans clone’ would have certain characteristics and weaknesses that were unnecessary and unwanted. The Kaminoans would have terminated any clone embryo that was ‘defect’. I hate it when these writers shove our world into Star Wars. All so certain people can “See themselves” in Star Wars. That’s pandering to modern politics. It’s a FANTASY in Space, we’re not supposed to compare it to our culture and we aren’t so dumb that we have to “see ourselves” in order to watch and enjoy something. If you think about it, it’s fucked up, because they’re saying that the ‘Trans’ clone is a “mistake”, or a ‘freak’. That’s not very PC Lol
They fucked it up the moment Omega and other female clones were created in the Shit Batch. We need to make this noncannon as fast as possible, also this trans trooper makes no sense just like female clones from a male gene. It's just lazy writing to push a completely bullshit agenda that does nothing but kill this IP even more than it already is. One thing is to write a character as trans and be smart about it, and a completely other to create something this way because if Phone Balonne can do whatever shit he wants with Star Wars so can she as I guess( i don't care about the pronoun or whatever else). It's no longer about creativity and risk, just pointless pandering while offending everyone else but the "minorities".
buddy, you are the minority here. absolutely nobody gives a shit about things like this except you for weirdos on the internet. you guys are the most sensitive and pathetic group of people lmao the “we need to make this non cannon as fast as possible” lmaooo grow up and find a hobby or a girlfriend
The Nazis had a lot of homosexuals and sexual deviants in their ranks.The most prominent example is Ernst Rohm, Hitler's right hand man and head of the SA.
@@imperialhonorguard1483 Yeah, so really it's not that big of a gotcha as some here are trying to make it. Unless the lesson is supposed to be "no matter who you are, don't put your trust in some guy who has openly made his contempt for you very clear." Which is actually a perfect lesson for the LGBTQ+ community and their toxic relationship with Hollywood. The Anti-woke assume that the gays, lesbians, trans, etc. are a parasitic brood that infests everything. Really, there are decent people in those groups, the real problem is the companies who want to advertise themselves to a very vocal and very toxic portion of the community that has a stranglehold on the rest of the community. This culture war is a scam fueled by Hollywood and grifters on the left and right.
The fact they only know sexualization is disturbing. If George Lucas did interviews talking about how attracted to women he is, people would be creeped out.
I’m honestly surprised he didn’t lose everything during the me too movement regarding the bit about how he told Carrie Fisher “there’s no underwear in space.”
they don't even understand that this man pretending to be a woman is playing the part of a character that would have only been a man in ANY context in star wars. these people are insane.
Men need to fade away. Remember when they lobbied against Gamers by spreading that Mass shooters are gamers? Well, this is the logical next step, they're trying to get you Bums out the house
It’s shit like this that makes me feel better about Star Wars having two timelines because at least the EU/Legends is safe from these shit authors like Sam Maggs and EK Johnston. Maybe you could make an analysing good video on Jar Jar Binks?
The hardest thing I’ve ever struggled to believe is that Disney is at the mercy of cei scores and the human rights foundation pulling their advertisers and yknow ads = money. Do they seriously think pandering is a better strategy then just making better movies and shows
There's a tight bubble of people working in media and a lot of them have transhausens by proxy kids. Not the whole reason, obvs, but it's another factor that comes up again and again
He was the beginning of the end for Star Wars, and effectively proto-Disney. Put bluntly: Filoni CW _was completely unnecessary and should never have existed._
Remember what Lama Su said in Attack of the Clones when comparing Boba to the standard clones, of which Sister is? "No tampering with the structure to make it more docile... and no growth acceleration." More docile. Clones have very little autonomy. Any that do are wiped out as per the Kaminoans' strict eugenic 'ethos'. We were all entirely too unfair to Omega.
So to not sound like someone who doesn't care about "transgender" if there even is such a thing. I think people who choose that lifestyle is due to them not being happy with themselves. Think about it, everyday they are constantly bombarded about how perfect someone else's life is and how much their's sucks because theyre not like them. People today are being encouraged to be someone else rather than being themselves their true selves. I grew up with a lot of cartoons and movies which expressed how important it eas to improve yourself, not so that others can like you, but that others will like you for it. Being true to yourself and always striving to be a better you is the most important message that isn't taught anymore. These Transgender people that just because they're "someone else" their old problems will go away. Bobby is and alcoholic, but now identifies as Felicia now, but guess what? Felicia still has Bobby's alcohol abuse. Just because you change who you are, doesn't mean life will certainly be for the better and all of your old problems will dissappear. God made you who you are for a reason. And we should be proud of the gender we were given not ashamed of it. Giving birth to a baby is the most painful thing a human can endure, meaning if you're a female you sre incredibly strong to go through that pain snd endure. As for Men, they were given muscular strength to fight and defend what they love, not abuse it. Be proud of who you are and don't let anyone. Not social media, not your so called friends or anyone, tell you to be someone else. You can rise above your problems and improve, and no amount of gender swapping will chnage that. Cheers.
@@Ihavethetouch Oh okay. Because I was simply trying to provide sympathy and a message for everyone to not be ashamed of themselves and that trying to be someone else isn't the solution.
I don’t know how she ever got a job at Lucas film, but I highly doubt she understands what fascism is and I doubt trans. People would be welcomed into a fascist government.
You know why they got a job at Lucas-Film. We're all just too uncomfortable to say it. The wrong people in charge, making decisions that sound good on paper, but when executed in reality, are disastrous. Choosing who should get the job, and why; and the 'why' isn't based on their previous work, but what they represent as an individual. Classism.
@@fairytaleandfablebooks Remember when they lobbied against Gamers by spreading that Mass shooters are gamers? Well, this is the logical next step, they're trying to get young men out the house
@@fairytaleandfablebooks I'm saying, the Left and Right wing aren't enemies as people think. They work together actually, and make people think they have choices. Republicans want Able bodied young men working or in the military, and women in the kitchen. Can't do that if millions of young men are gaming hermits. That's a wasted resource. So Republicans probably fund Leftists to push LGTBQ stuff in male dominated media to get them to quit it. Why else are companies willing to lose money on this? It's not about inclusion
Remember when they lobbied against Gamers by spreading that Mass shooters are gamers? Well, this is the logical next step, they're trying to get you bums out your mom's house
The clones in the EU and Prequels were the best,they each could have personality but were still fully loyal to the cause of the Republic no matter what which made their sudden turn to Oder 66 and the empire more tragic,TCW changed all this by having Clones with too much free will and often disobey orders or acted as traitors or the Retcon of those chips being what made them turn on Jedi while in EU they knew about Order 66 and had no second doubts about it cause that's what they had to due as they were bred only as soldiers.
First of all, "she" cannot be a clone when freaking Jango Fett served as a template for Palapatine's clone army. Second, "her" fucking HAIRSTYLE is very distinct from the male clone trooper's; meaning that if "she" were to have "her" helmet voluntarily or forceibly removed, someone would know the difference. Thus, the character makes no goddamn sense at all.
Not like it matters. They're pushing this out because you're not making babies. Remember when they lobbied against Gamers by spreading that Mass shooters are gamers? Well, this is the logical next step, they're trying to get young men out the house
J.J. I recently saw a Revenge Of The Sith review that was negative towards the movie so I know the Bad parts however in that review there was a lot of contradictions and just surface level reviews from the guy it was made by NTMA productions, figured you could show the complications with the review
I hate woke ideology, but the way you did this rubbed me the wrong way until you said _“Diversity is the last thing you want in an army.”_ Ok. You’re out of line, but you’re entirely right.
I mean, a droid with masculine programming could be reprogrammed with feminine programming and vice versa. This is just about the only thing I have in favor of such a notion.
I would really like to see you debate Turf Nation, another predominantly Star Wars focused channel. I think both yours and his channel resonate with me, but his less so. I see how your videos can compare to his videos in general and I can see the substance of yours and his videos in the contrasting way the opinions differ from either persons ultimate wisdom. If I saw you two debate I’d want you to know that I’m rooting for you. Cause you’re awesome.
The Kaminoans would have terminated this clone, unironically. Keep in mind these are the same Kaminoans who would terminate members of their own species at birth for having the wrong eye color.
The other implication, did they give that specific clone trooper gender disphoria? If thats the case thats horrific, imagine making a clone and then performing that kind of experiment? Downright evil to do to an individual you completely control every aspect of. I dont think the writers even considered that implication.
I’m personally bi and really hate when companies do this crap I like when representation is done correctly this just sucks and that type of thing is just really rare to talk about in Star Wars the worst part is that they choose a clone trooper he’s a clone the original wasn’t trans why make this one it’s just a slap in the face to real trans people and makes it look like it’s a choice
Absolutely disgusting! I'm seriously thinking about selling my entire collection of Star Wars figures and vehicles. The 6-ft rat and Lucasfilm is making it difficult to keep collecting with the unnatural crap they are doing. The mental illness is strong with Disney.
Go ahead, sell your SW stuff. If one trans side character of thousands non trans characters is going to bother you so much, your transphobia is showing.
It was actually George Lucas who pushed for the individuality in the clone troopers. During the development of the Republic Commando video game, he urged the writers and developers to differentiate the characters in multiple ways like armor coloration/design, personality, and even voice. The game predated clone wars (2008) by what, 3 years? I guess the concept was carried over. However, Sister makes no sense, but I do not blame Dave Filoni for their creation, since it was George’s l idea that changed the clones throughout the clone wars series and bad batch.
I like your analysis but I should point out that having a sister clone trooper isn’t odd given that genetic defects are common occasionally in the cloning process, resulting in unique mutations sometimes. And more than likely Sister was born with women brain chemistry and began to understand her gender when she was becoming a young adult Clones generally don’t have a female/mother figure to interact with and likely Sister at home with that role, fulfilling it by taking that role
I once asked her on Twitter if this Clone Trooper committed Order 66, I was blocked.
Classic cowardly behavior by them.
Wow, was just a simple yes or no answer.
It’s because she knew her bullsh*t character was likely about to suffer a canonical assassination!😂
>her
lol
Didn't E.K. make a bunch of 12-14 year old handmaiden girls from TPM be attracted to each other? They are minors! Even by Naboo standards.
Gross.
DAFUQ
What kind of Tumblr fanfic is that? :D
@@Mouse_Metal E.K. Johnston's Queen trilogy. Sabé has a massive crush on Padmé since age 12. Yané and Saché fell in love at age 12 during the Naboo crisis.
Yes. She's a horrible pervert.
Trivia: In the EU (it will always be the EU, not "Legends"), female stormtroopers did exist (this was after they started recruiting normal humans to replace the aging clones), but they looked (and sounded) the same as their male counterparts after putting on their combat armour (a function of the armour), to reinforce the "faceless army" trappings (and quash any potential snowflake-ism). (Also, they were very rare compared to the males.)
"But what's the point of a character being female if we can't see that she is female?!"
-Modern Audience
No. The Empire did not allow female stormtroopers. Although females were allowed as pilots and commanding officers.
Also... like, Disney could have put the sparti clones earlier in the timeline and added female clones and other bits of diversity through more logical means, they were the good candidates to bulk up the clone army.
In the EU female stormtroopers became a thing post endor when numbers needed bulking up and commonplace by the legacy era, same with 'alien' stormtroopers. In canon the empire pulled both male and female humans... which honestly doesn't really matter, you wouldn't be able to tell in public anyways.
@@vetarlittorf1807 If they didn't, why am I reading of one in my Essential Guide?
Personally, I don't mind "Legends", since it's simply a title that distinguishes it as the superior canon.
Yeah, the Kaminoans would have terminated Sister immediately when he is confused about his identity. That's not ideal for warfare, and the Kaminoans crave perfection
That and they became ruthless eugenicists to survive a biblical flood that killed a vast majority of there population, she'd be lucky if they made her a janitor if not out right kill the clone, the clones also were treated like property by there creators
She probably hid herself for a long while before actually comming out
a transgender clone trooper? Ko-sai would like to know of this product's location. A doktor's appointment is in that clone's future.
“What a waste of good genes…”
- RC-1138 aka “Boss”
Boss is a wise Commando beyond his years.
I bet durge would have killed this clone lol
@@xxcaptninjaxx4301 someone needs to make that a thing, just have Durge go full Oni-man at a squad of them.
Any dude with a nickname like "Sister" is a red flag.
Why?
@@suzygirl1843 because nicknames like that are given to booty warriors.
The clones got to watch themselves in the Shower around “ sister”
@@thomaswatson1739 LMAO
@@thomaswatson1739pervert
Apparently they forgot that once Order 66 is declared, the Clone Troopers lose any sense of individuality and turn their guns on the Jedi. Meaning that they created a trans character, who'll inevitably contribute to the murder of almost every Jedi. Smart move on their part.
As if clones had that much individuality before Order 66 to begin with. Only Republic Commandos were allowed to have such independence.
Not unlike what happens in real life with these people. It's still lore accurate lmao
Watch geestly’s video on the topic they explain the inhibitor chip just enhances their personality using it to make them execute order 66
It is sad to hear that George’s work being destroyed by a nut case.
💯💯Indeed
nut cases plural
Atleast you know you are a nutcase
No it’s not, 1 character isn’t ruining his work
The trans clone really bothers me. Not that trans people exist in star wars, it is a big galaxy so if it is done well (it wouldn't be but that isn't my current point) it would be fine. The issue is we don't know what causes gender dysphoria, but whatever it is it literally could not show up in a clone. The clones are of the same genetic stock, grown in the exact same way, exposed to the same hormones, develop in the same place, are taught the same things. It would literally be all of them or none of them. If something managed to make a single one pop up they would have been purged instantly. I miss when the Kaminoans were eugenicist monsters that culled battalions of literal children because they didn't have perfect 20/20 vision, were willing to waste the investment of an entire squad of commandos that ran a few seconds slower than the rest. The kind of psychopaths you'd expect from a species willing to accelerate the growth of children to make a slave army.
It is known but it´s forbidden to talk about it.
Were does it say that there were no trans clones or trans people in general in star wars? Your head canon does not count...
@@mpsuorsa Legends says so, the TRUE Canon. How? By absence of mention, and that all of Jango's clones WERE MALE. The clones were all male. No room for interpretation. END OF BLOODY STORY.
Star Wars has nothing to do with with this nonsense. You want that PC trash? Go read SAGA the comic. Woke-as-hell.
The trans clone trooper actually means Star Wars is advocating for the "transgenderism is environmental, not innate" stance.
@@mpsuorsa The literal backstory of the clones says so.
From the chads X1 and X2 in EU to Sister in Disney Canon...
Even in a galaxy far away John Money's degeneracy flourishs.
at least campaign for X1 and X2 was interesting what could have been for free radical battlefront 3
The fact folks still try to act like his work holds validity when all he did was sexually assault a pair twins until one LITERALLY KILLED HIMSELF TO ESCAPE THE SICK BASTARDS 'EXPERIMENTS' shows just how fucked up they REALLY are
Now finally transgender clonetrooper is we were all waiting for!!!
Can't wait for Black Lives Matter clonetrooper and Free Palestine clonetrooper, I just love the excapeism in STAR WARS nowadays
I bet all get killed by durge lol
Burn, Loot and Murder clone would cause a great disturbance in the force, as if dozens of stores were trashed, then suddenly silenced.
@@ltb1345 Don't forget the *Grape Trooper
The blue markings 501st legion will be retconned/renamed to “Vote blue no matter who” legion :P
Star wars is an allegory for the Vietnam War and the rise of authoritarianism in America, specifically Star Wars has always been about calling out Republicans for trying to be dictators (Nixon in the og trilogy, Bush in the prequels), by far the most escapist/ least political of the films would definitely be the sequels.
I don't really see how transgender people ruin escapism for you, are you really that upset that oppressed minorities receive representation that it ruins the entire fantasy? Damn that sucks for you.
Sister has the trans flag colors on his armor which makes no sense when this is suppose to be in a galaxy far, far away
A long time ago, even.
Another 'creative' who doesn't understand the basis concept of a foot soldier. The clone troopers were not designed to act autonomously outside of their respective military force, they were bred solely for one purpose: serve the Republic in the Clone Wars (and by extension Palpatine). Identity politics would literally be one of the last things that a clone trooper could be asked to think about, and if anyone disagrees with that, then they need to reevaluate how they process fiction.
This 'inclusive' aspect to the lore does more harm than good, as this would be considered a glaring design flaw in the clone troopers themselves; the point is that they were NOT meant to think for themselves on such a level, and if more clones thought this way, they would be terrible in a war. In times of direct, physical conflict, like war or surviving the apocalypse, for example, ideologies would be one of the first thing to be discarded, in order for one to try and survive.
The biggest poison to escapism and fantasy, is forced modern-day political takes, and authors trying to lecture their audience. This proves that Disney doesn't care about their audience, or the licenses which they own.
How exactly could a storm trooper, or in this case, a clone trooper came to this ideas? They were born and thought a specific thing all their life, then thrown in the meat grinder... Alongside hundreds of the same individual. The creators have no interest in that and the Jedi do not deal with that. The other guy is a machine with weird quirks... None of this would make them have ideas about gender.
Sick of these people sitting at their desks writing in somebody else’s universe talking about “being brave” and “challenging the status quo”. Make your own shitty IP for your terrible ideas.
How can they when there's a MONOPOLY?
Clone troopers are raised around men most of their lives. There's a higher chance of a clone turning turn gay opposed to being trans.
“The fraternal birth order effect”
Bro, they could have done that instead if they really want "diversity" while making scenes
And this is where we have the “If you bang your clone is it gay or masturbation.” debate.
"Johnston is biromantic and demisexual."
No. Way.
I would never have guessed
Who ever wrote that on the Wikipedia page is def on board with this nonsense.
For a demisexual she sure likes sexual stuff
The fucking what and what?
This is what happens when the Tumblrettes everyone used to make fun of start writing official works in a franchise.
How can a genetically male clone created in a tank by master geneticists think they KNOW what a woman is?
The funniest thing is that there are different ways to do trans representation in Star Wars. Species of beings can be created that can be gender fluid, or have multiple sexes, or males can give birth. The worst solution was chosen - a human clone was put into it, even though clones are only supposed to follow orders and do not care about gender identity.
Why does there need to be trans representation in Star Wars at all
@@logat1847 I don't need it.
We don't need trans people in star wars, you gringos are obsessed with that 1 percentage.
As others have pointed out, it took clones 10 years to mature on kamino, and the clone wars lasted about 3 1/2 years, so when did the trans clone have time to express their gendee identity?? In kamino surrounded by men?? During combat across the galaxy?? Its stupid, makes no sense, and only exists for fake meaningless diversity. Why make a clone trans?? And not some other character with a little more weight??
E K Johnston is massive prog activist, so she definitely wasn't "forced" to do this by anyone. In fact, I saw in another video talking about this, that she said that it was her idea, and that Disney didn't push back at all. There's photos of her where a top with various made up gender flags on her sleeves, so this is fully her inserting her politics into Star Wars. She also tried to give Ahsoka a lesbian love interest in the Ahsoka novel, which was extremely cringe. This definitely takes the cake in the cringe department though.
I don't have time for this made up, unscientific, nonsense in the real world, so I sure as hell don't want it in Star Wars. Everything Disney makes now is just propaganda to push their evil ideology. You're right about them just using these people as tools and shields, but the real objective is power and cultural control. All such activists need to be purged from the entertainment industry or nothing will change.
I’m so sick of troons and the alphabet squad in general.
People are more sick of you and your ilk inventing bullshit to get madge about.
@@DCN2049 People are suck of you and your ilk pushing an evil message.
nobody cares you crying isn’t gonna change anything it just makes you extremely annoying along with the other man children
All this was is a demented way of her saying “Anakin Skywalker says trans people are valid so take that, bigots!”
Trans people are obviously valid. Anyone who thinks otherwise is just a pathetic pos loser who wants to dictate how other people live. Nothing worse than control freak zealots foaming at the mouth.
The Sith Lord who aided in the genocide of billions of Innocents across the galaxy supports trans rights.
Reading those words coming from Anakin, of all characters, feels incredibly wrong. Even if I sided with this matter, he's not the kind of character who would say such wise-sounding things, especially since, you know, he's the man who became Darth Vader.
I mean, he does straight up quote Satan in Episode 3 so it’s fitting.
Omega is a far better character than Sister. Omega had a good story to tell and was written well. Sister is a mascot for diversity in Star Wars and nothing else. You can write an essay on Omegas character and her importance to the Star Wars galaxy. Sister's importance can be summed up in a short paragraph. In conclusion, Sister is not in the same league as Omega. She isn't even in the same league as Dr. Emerie.
I can't believe I'm going to say this but I think that the transgender clone is worse then inhibtor chips
Why?
I miss when Clone troopers were cold soldiers. Instead of Dave Filoni's Dollar Store Power Rangers like Bad Batch
I liked season 1, season 2 was shit, season 3 was decent.
I probably would rate have a season about rex than BB.
Captain Fordo will be missed
The Closes Clonetroopers ever got for an Identity were the A.R.C. Troopers, & The Null.
Her brothers literally _named_ her Sister for being The Girl, that's her name now as her one definining feature instead of just talking to her with girl pronouns and moving on. It almost feels like bullying if Rex hadn't specified it was meant to be the opposite, not very sensitive of Dickney. 🏳️⚧️
And why is Rex selling the _Secrets_ of the Clone Troopers to the Magic Empire anyway!? That seems a touch out of character, as if Disney even cares about that anymore. Are they stupid?
Rex doing what?
This isn't Star Wars. It's Troon Wars.
@@Hello-bi1pm What the dude doin'?
Do these kinds of writers really want readers to think, "Oh, that's the trans one!" when they see this character? I would rather have readers associate the character with their personality rather than being a representation tick on a checklist.
You Know J J You Should Absolutely Destroy Mr Plinkett’s Pathetic Reviews Of The Prequel Trilogy Since It Literally Destroyed George Lucas’s Career As A CEO Of Lucasfilm And Because Of It We Have To Experience Forced Reparations And Also You Should Do An Analyzing Evil On HelloGreedo And Chris Stuckmann
He should do one on hellogreedo definetly, that guy is a complete joke
I don't think HelloGreedo is evil. He's a good guy with a terrible opinion.
"pathetic review"
That's an opinion. And if you think one guy destroyed Lucas... well.l then, maybe that one guy was right.
Prequels suck.
@@James_Bee And Mr. Plinkett is supposed to be a comedy. It's not serious film criticism, even though it does have valid points. But the gang at RLM are mostly there for laughs and film criticism second. Dubbing them "evil" is petty. And yes, the prequels were laughably bad. These guys are now basically saying anyone who doesn't like Lucas' entire body of work is evil, which is not only ridiculous but pretty messed up
Kaminoans were inspired by the Greys. Everything for them is in terms of perfection, sterility and cold detachment. They are Mengele level scientists. The ultimate scientists. How exactly do they allow this guy to be confused and not terminate him? He would be an afront to their way. A mistake that should never be allowed to exist in their eyes. Did the weirdo writing this not bother to ask what George and the special effects department thought when designing them and their world?
Just imagine that this guy would refuse to follow orders because someone have been called him "he"" or tell him the "truth" that he's a man, he only put on risk the rest of his squad and the republic itself. So, no, a tr3ns trooper is impossible and couldn't exist..
perfect example why disney always has DEI propaganda
DEI was actually created for white people, believe it or not
The only way that could happen is if the Kaminoans wanted to create a ‘Trans’ clone. But they were not taken to whimsical “ooooh .. what if we do this..?” random acts. They were hard nosed scientists and business minded. They were trying to create the perfect soldiers. A ‘trans clone’ would have certain characteristics and weaknesses that were unnecessary and unwanted. The Kaminoans would have terminated any clone embryo that was ‘defect’. I hate it when these writers shove our world into Star Wars. All so certain people can “See themselves” in Star Wars. That’s pandering to modern politics. It’s a FANTASY in Space, we’re not supposed to compare it to our culture and we aren’t so dumb that we have to “see ourselves” in order to watch and enjoy something. If you think about it, it’s fucked up, because they’re saying that the ‘Trans’ clone is a “mistake”, or a ‘freak’. That’s not very PC Lol
Although it would be hilarious to see the Kaminoans just wipe out another defective Clone battalion.
The fastest video in the west! I admire your work ethic!
A legend.👍
They fucked it up the moment Omega and other female clones were created in the Shit Batch.
We need to make this noncannon as fast as possible, also this trans trooper makes no sense just like female clones from a male gene. It's just lazy writing to push a completely bullshit agenda that does nothing but kill this IP even more than it already is.
One thing is to write a character as trans and be smart about it, and a completely other to create something this way because if Phone Balonne can do whatever shit he wants with Star Wars so can she as I guess( i don't care about the pronoun or whatever else). It's no longer about creativity and risk, just pointless pandering while offending everyone else but the "minorities".
Was gonna say. This is all because of the Bad Batch and the idea that you can make radically different clones from the rest.
buddy, you are the minority here. absolutely nobody gives a shit about things like this except you for weirdos on the internet. you guys are the most sensitive and pathetic group of people lmao the “we need to make this non cannon as fast as possible” lmaooo grow up and find a hobby or a girlfriend
@@yvngsn0w Considering absolutely no one has been happy with this abomination, it's safe to say we are in the majority.
She looks EXACTLY how you would expect.
He*
@@1who4me Oh. Now I get why they look like that.
He.
@@MenBeingHappythank you for using pronouns 😜
@@1who4me Is she a TIM (tr4ns identified male)?
The Nazis had a lot of homosexuals and sexual deviants in their ranks.The most prominent example is Ernst Rohm, Hitler's right hand man and head of the SA.
That he ordered to be killed when he was not usefull anymore.
Man that's crazy it's almost like every accusation is a confession
all of which were put in camps or executed in Hitler's purge of the SA in 1934.
@@imperialhonorguard1483 Yeah, so really it's not that big of a gotcha as some here are trying to make it. Unless the lesson is supposed to be "no matter who you are, don't put your trust in some guy who has openly made his contempt for you very clear." Which is actually a perfect lesson for the LGBTQ+ community and their toxic relationship with Hollywood.
The Anti-woke assume that the gays, lesbians, trans, etc. are a parasitic brood that infests everything. Really, there are decent people in those groups, the real problem is the companies who want to advertise themselves to a very vocal and very toxic portion of the community that has a stranglehold on the rest of the community. This culture war is a scam fueled by Hollywood and grifters on the left and right.
Hitler also may have been gay too.
The fact they only know sexualization is disturbing. If George Lucas did interviews talking about how attracted to women he is, people would be creeped out.
I’m honestly surprised he didn’t lose everything during the me too movement regarding the bit about how he told Carrie Fisher “there’s no underwear in space.”
they don't even understand that this man pretending to be a woman is playing the part of a character that would have only been a man in ANY context in star wars.
these people are insane.
Wait that monstrosity also did Padme dirty?!
Yes, it sure did.
Star Wars needs to fade away.
Men need to fade away. Remember when they lobbied against Gamers by spreading that Mass shooters are gamers? Well, this is the logical next step, they're trying to get you Bums out the house
>clone army acknoweldges her transgernderism
>performs surgeries etc
>goes into battle
>immediately dies
wow amazing
The time and resources spent on that could have been put to so many more pressing matters….
It’s shit like this that makes me feel better about Star Wars having two timelines because at least the EU/Legends is safe from these shit authors like Sam Maggs and EK Johnston.
Maybe you could make an analysing good video on Jar Jar Binks?
You talking too soon. They endeavor to break into every nook and cranny of boys entertainment.
The hardest thing I’ve ever struggled to believe is that Disney is at the mercy of cei scores and the human rights foundation pulling their advertisers and yknow ads = money. Do they seriously think pandering is a better strategy then just making better movies and shows
There's a tight bubble of people working in media and a lot of them have transhausens by proxy kids. Not the whole reason, obvs, but it's another factor that comes up again and again
They made clones with downs syndrome?
Don't you know that kaminoans, Republic and Empire all believe in diversity when it comes to child soldiers?
@@Ihavethetouch very progressive of them
this is why I got into EU novel and comic than Disney canon comic and novels
Dave Filoni ruined everything with the 2008 Clone Wars show with the lore breaking and continuity snappings
That's why the Genndy's Clone Wars will always be the GOAT
He was the beginning of the end for Star Wars, and effectively proto-Disney. Put bluntly: Filoni CW _was completely unnecessary and should never have existed._
@@UltimaSpark50 Well said.
@@Ihavethetouch lol. That show had literally no story.
@@seanmurphy7011 Would you prefer connect the dots?
Never heard of her before this video, but from everything that you’ve said in the video, I wish it had stayed that way.
Me neither.
Same here
Disney Canon will never be legitimate.
Remember what Lama Su said in Attack of the Clones when comparing Boba to the standard clones, of which Sister is? "No tampering with the structure to make it more docile... and no growth acceleration."
More docile. Clones have very little autonomy. Any that do are wiped out as per the Kaminoans' strict eugenic 'ethos'. We were all entirely too unfair to Omega.
And this all came out in a young adults book. Makes perfect sense
Sound like a bad soldier and first to go under the leadership of Palpatin.
So to not sound like someone who doesn't care about "transgender" if there even is such a thing. I think people who choose that lifestyle is due to them not being happy with themselves. Think about it, everyday they are constantly bombarded about how perfect someone else's life is and how much their's sucks because theyre not like them. People today are being encouraged to be someone else rather than being themselves their true selves. I grew up with a lot of cartoons and movies which expressed how important it eas to improve yourself, not so that others can like you, but that others will like you for it. Being true to yourself and always striving to be a better you is the most important message that isn't taught anymore. These Transgender people that just because they're "someone else" their old problems will go away. Bobby is and alcoholic, but now identifies as Felicia now, but guess what? Felicia still has Bobby's alcohol abuse. Just because you change who you are, doesn't mean life will certainly be for the better and all of your old problems will dissappear. God made you who you are for a reason. And we should be proud of the gender we were given not ashamed of it. Giving birth to a baby is the most painful thing a human can endure, meaning if you're a female you sre incredibly strong to go through that pain snd endure. As for Men, they were given muscular strength to fight and defend what they love, not abuse it. Be proud of who you are and don't let anyone. Not social media, not your so called friends or anyone, tell you to be someone else. You can rise above your problems and improve, and no amount of gender swapping will chnage that. Cheers.
The Clone Troopers were nothing but shock troops. Your cancerous gender politics has no place in the brainwashing
Nothing about that is an issue exclusive with trans people. Also who said they are bombarded with images of perfection?
@@zzodysseuszz I never said it was. How old are you anyway?
@@Red-Renegade-Studios I think he's still in single digits
@@Ihavethetouch Oh okay. Because I was simply trying to provide sympathy and a message for everyone to not be ashamed of themselves and that trying to be someone else isn't the solution.
I would not want my kids reading this book
@@mrboost4186 there are better Star Wars books to be found at your local Half Price books.
I don’t know how she ever got a job at Lucas film, but I highly doubt she understands what fascism is and I doubt trans. People would be welcomed into a fascist government.
You know why they got a job at Lucas-Film. We're all just too uncomfortable to say it. The wrong people in charge, making decisions that sound good on paper, but when executed in reality, are disastrous. Choosing who should get the job, and why; and the 'why' isn't based on their previous work, but what they represent as an individual. Classism.
@@fairytaleandfablebooks Remember when they lobbied against Gamers by spreading that Mass shooters are gamers? Well, this is the logical next step, they're trying to get young men out the house
@@suzygirl1843 Oof, that grammar. I can't understand your point, man. Sorry.
@@fairytaleandfablebooks I'm saying, the Left and Right wing aren't enemies as people think. They work together actually, and make people think they have choices. Republicans want Able bodied young men working or in the military, and women in the kitchen. Can't do that if millions of young men are gaming hermits. That's a wasted resource. So Republicans probably fund Leftists to push LGTBQ stuff in male dominated media to get them to quit it. Why else are companies willing to lose money on this? It's not about inclusion
I Had no idea she existed, tbh.
You'd need to read the books after finding them first.
@@chasehedges6775 you are better off that way.
@@theunknowncommenter725 💯🙏
More proof why Disney's so called "Star Wars" canon is absolute trash. As you say, that is all thanks to Filoni the hack's trash ideas.
Remember when they lobbied against Gamers by spreading that Mass shooters are gamers? Well, this is the logical next step, they're trying to get you bums out your mom's house
It's always AGP gigahons winning these roles and positions. They even discriminate against certain types of trans people.
Say no to Troons and the Alphabet Mafia.
Clone Troopers are ruined by the current writers of Lucasfilm, besides Dave Filoni. It seems they missed the point of the clones themselves.
Looking at some of the comments here, I'd say most of the EU and Comic fans _missed the point as well._
Wouldn't say Filoni is ruining the clones, but boy he is running his live action content to the ground.
They've been ruined since the inhibitor chip retcon.
@@_MaZTeR_ he undid all progress he made with Ahsoka Tano, even ruined all of his Rebels characters.
The clones in the EU and Prequels were the best,they each could have personality but were still fully loyal to the cause of the Republic no matter what which made their sudden turn to Oder 66 and the empire more tragic,TCW changed all this by having Clones with too much free will and often disobey orders or acted as traitors or the Retcon of those chips being what made them turn on Jedi while in EU they knew about Order 66 and had no second doubts about it cause that's what they had to due as they were bred only as soldiers.
They always look the same-every time. There is nothing new under the sun.
The current Lucasfilm never ceases to surprise negatively, it is KK's only consistency.
This is why I support the Confederacy and the Droid army over the Clones and the Republic.
Best case scenario, Sister would be scrubbing toilets along side 99 on Kamino.
First of all, "she" cannot be a clone when freaking Jango Fett served as a template for Palapatine's clone army. Second, "her" fucking HAIRSTYLE is very distinct from the male clone trooper's; meaning that if "she" were to have "her" helmet voluntarily or forceibly removed, someone would know the difference. Thus, the character makes no goddamn sense at all.
All that makes no sense
That's a woman?!
Unoriginal comment
Johnston ought to join the "halfway there" club
No one would know of her propaganda without her abuse of Star Wars.
Chuck Wendig for sure was terrible too
I am so sick of the trash they keep putting out. It's downright criminal and filthy.
Not like it matters. They're pushing this out because you're not making babies. Remember when they lobbied against Gamers by spreading that Mass shooters are gamers? Well, this is the logical next step, they're trying to get young men out the house
At least this reinforces the idea that Galactic Republic is a mix of Roman and Weimar Republics 😂 We know what Romans were into
It's a fanfic character
All movies are fan fic characters.
Not really. Fanfics are made by fans, not activist posers.
that's a dude
You forgot the meaning of Trans?
@@suzygirl1843 yeah, it just means insane.
These are the videos we like from you.. Analyze more evil, my guy!
That’s Mister Sister to you Sir!
I never asked for a gay clone trooper 😭🙏
Kids you go real men and real women everything else a lier.
This explains a lot. Have you done Bob Iger? If not, please do.
Men need to stop playing video games, get off line and touch grass
@@suzygirl1843 and you need to stop simping for make-believe genders and gender identities
J.J. I recently saw a Revenge Of The Sith review that was negative towards the movie so I know the Bad parts however in that review there was a lot of contradictions and just surface level reviews from the guy it was made by NTMA productions, figured you could show the complications with the review
Where's the video?
Revenge Of The Sith is the best Star Wars film, IMO
@@JinxTheLooneyToon915 well the title is Revenge Of The Sith and why it sucks by NTMA productions
@@chasehedges6775Sure, after Empire Strikes Back
@@Ihavethetouch And ROTJ.
Im done with SW. Was lookin forward to Andor season 2 but I cant suport disney in anyway. They failed spectacularly
Homely looking *and* insane.
I hate woke ideology, but the way you did this rubbed me the wrong way until you said _“Diversity is the last thing you want in an army.”_
Ok. You’re out of line, but you’re entirely right.
Imagine if one Battle Drones started to question its gender identity and decided to become trans. 🤣🤣🤣
I mean, a droid with masculine programming could be reprogrammed with feminine programming and vice versa.
This is just about the only thing I have in favor of such a notion.
Troons ruin EVERYTHING
I would really like to see you debate Turf Nation, another predominantly Star Wars focused channel. I think both yours and his channel resonate with me, but his less so. I see how your videos can compare to his videos in general and I can see the substance of yours and his videos in the contrasting way the opinions differ from either persons ultimate wisdom. If I saw you two debate I’d want you to know that I’m rooting for you. Cause you’re awesome.
The Kaminoans would have terminated this clone, unironically. Keep in mind these are the same Kaminoans who would terminate members of their own species at birth for having the wrong eye color.
You would think it was the Jurassic Park dinosaur clones who would have the gender identity crisis
Johnston with a T
How do they not learn time and time again.
The other implication, did they give that specific clone trooper gender disphoria? If thats the case thats horrific, imagine making a clone and then performing that kind of experiment? Downright evil to do to an individual you completely control every aspect of.
I dont think the writers even considered that implication.
Now you know how 40k fans think
That was a quick response lol
I’m personally bi and really hate when companies do this crap I like when representation is done correctly this just sucks and that type of thing is just really rare to talk about in Star Wars the worst part is that they choose a clone trooper he’s a clone the original wasn’t trans why make this one it’s just a slap in the face to real trans people and makes it look like it’s a choice
They never hire writers with logical thoughts.. it would make more sense to make boba trans haha
Please do Analyzing evil: Formula 1 Las Vegas
It's so weird to hear CPT rex speaking as a modern day left wing activist , it's bizarre
I ignore this nonsense
1:25 Silly moustache man😂
That's no woman. That's a man, baby.
Absolutely disgusting! I'm seriously thinking about selling my entire collection of Star Wars figures and vehicles. The 6-ft rat and Lucasfilm is making it difficult to keep collecting with the unnatural crap they are doing. The mental illness is strong with Disney.
Go ahead, sell your SW stuff. If one trans side character of thousands non trans characters is going to bother you so much, your transphobia is showing.
@@mpsuorsa
Spotted the escaped mental patient.
@@sonofeyeabovealleffoff5462 looked into a mirror , did you?
@@sonofeyeabovealleffoff5462spotted the massive man child who cries online about shit that has 0 effect on him or his day to day. pathetic little boy
Very based of her to argue that being trans isn’t genetic and is learned apparently
It was actually George Lucas who pushed for the individuality in the clone troopers. During the development of the Republic Commando video game, he urged the writers and developers to differentiate the characters in multiple ways like armor coloration/design, personality, and even voice. The game predated clone wars (2008) by what, 3 years? I guess the concept was carried over. However, Sister makes no sense, but I do not blame Dave Filoni for their creation, since it was George’s l idea that changed the clones throughout the clone wars series and bad batch.
I like your analysis but I should point out that having a sister clone trooper isn’t odd given that genetic defects are common occasionally in the cloning process, resulting in unique mutations sometimes. And more than likely Sister was born with women brain chemistry and began to understand her gender when she was becoming a young adult
Clones generally don’t have a female/mother figure to interact with and likely Sister at home with that role, fulfilling it by taking that role
@cyborgpunk6668 Someone clearly didn't do their research.