I am astonished at how he manages to reply to these gigantic questions within such a narrow time. Damn, they cut him short with the happiness topic which I thought was the peak of these 15min.
I'm surprised at the shock because the gossip theory is hardly new. It was put forward by Elaine Morgan in her Aquatic Ape Hypothesis in the 70s. Hunting is a silent activity where noise would be counter-productive. But, forming social networks through language is hugely beneficial to survival. She also provides the mechanism by which speech is made possible: the holding of breath in water.
He is sitting 30 days silent meditation retreats annually and he doesn’t even mention meditation as a useful tool. What the...?? dhamma.org by the way!!
Plus a brain which doesn't work as much because it is plugged in (relying on a computer for things like memory recollection and spatial awareness) would decay
Money is not story but created as medium to replace gold for ease of trading. The same with credit cards. What is so new about this and why everyone seems excited?
Reading between what he says I would think he is into eugenics especially when he calls possible future people "the useless class.' That's pretty disrespectful to future humans. It's as if he is saying they have no value as people. Disgusting in my opinion.'
Read Harari's books, do not base your comment on what you hear here only. He is making a statement of fact. If you stop and think about it, this is what people would turn out to be: economically useless, in the hundreds of millions. And stating this does not call for killing these people, unless you want to hear that. What I heard Harari doing is calling for debating now, and agreeing now to find policies enforced on a global scale to give those people income and a sense of worth, while their economic value will be zero.
Right at the end he says "nobody knows how to teach emotional intelligence on a massive scale", but this is not true. James Roswell Quinn, author of the Love-Based Leader knows how to do that. The problem is we just don't value emotional intelligence. You can get people to go into a lifetime of debt and spend years to indoctrinate themselves into a left-brained "education", but getting people to part with four days of their life and a few measly hundred dollars is a difficult proposition for some reason. I'd love to see Quinn's method taught at every school and in every corporation, but the corporations do NOT want an emotionally intelligent workforce. As Carlin says, they want "obedient workers". Passive, just dumb enough to stay quietly slaving away in their cubicles for next to nothing while accepting their own exploitation.
Sure - even though money is one of the most important inventions and the fact that it is the only thing everyone believes in - MONEY CAN BE USED BIG TIME TO INVEST IN PROPAGANDA, SMEAR CAMPAIGNING AND DECEIVING A WHOLE POPULATION IN RELATION TO TRUTH AND FACTS!!! 😡😡😡
Why would you think that? Hunting is an activity where making too much noise would be counter-productive as it would alert the prey to the predator's presence.
Yuval Harari gets far too much attention. Making judgements based on historical or scientific trends is a dangerous business. Extrapolating from the success of AI in performing amenable logical tasks like playing chess, Yuval thinks that the historical and ethical human self is something downloadable onto a machine or hackable like a computer. Yet it is clear that we are not just a set of logical and biological functions with some emotions added on. We can also see the necessity of 2 + 2 = 4, Euclid's theorems or General Relativity, the intangible beauty of Michelangelo's David and the wrongness of selfishness. We can also detect the inherent contradiction in an author asking us to accept or 'value' (a word entirely missing from Yuval's vocabulary) a subjective worldview that does away with the human subject.
Видеоклипы
When Dr. Harari speaks everybody shuts up snd get their mind blown by a genius.
It´s just because the most of the People are stupid and they like such modern and smart fools!
His book changed my view of the world
Francesco Martella which book?
@@jalalkarimov5754 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sapiens:_A_Brief_History_of_Humankind
I am astonished at how he manages to reply to these gigantic questions within such a narrow time. Damn, they cut him short with the happiness topic which I thought was the peak of these 15min.
Sapiens might be the most profound book i`ve read. Make it a principal book in high schools, and the world would be a lot more enlightened.
What! Ricky Gervais and Yuval on the same stage! Fuakkkkk!
and pamela Anderson(?) mfg!!
met at a strange time in your life, fabian monge?
Just finished Homo dues and been binging Ricky on RUclips hahahaha, freaked me out a bit seeing this.
Yea!!
Yuval you the wisest person so far!
Every time I see Harari interviewed, all the other guests and host seem so nervous and in awe of him.
I'm surprised at the shock because the gossip theory is hardly new. It was put forward by Elaine Morgan in her Aquatic Ape Hypothesis in the 70s. Hunting is a silent activity where noise would be counter-productive. But, forming social networks through language is hugely beneficial to survival. She also provides the mechanism by which speech is made possible: the holding of breath in water.
Ah, no surprises that a woman came up with that theory...
Brilliant discussion!
Brilliant mind, amazing heart!
10:22 Yuval thinking: that woman really wants to be called the youngest
I would love to see Yuval in Rickey's podcast
ricky reaction is muahhhh
Very interesting discussion, much to consider.
Marshal Rosenberg taught emotional intelligence on a large scale
🗽
tak.
❤
When he said nobody can teach emotional intelligence at a large scale. That made me think of Jordan Peterson.
then Ishrat Hussain have to be the speaker of ? In that way! i mean Dedeeedat you said Mileetray accent
He repeats:" humans are animals". No Sir, Humans are not animals.
wahnano human are a multicellular organism with an internal digestive tract. Aka an animal
Intellectual Comedian, being socialized to make his critical work a joke.
MD Fav
jihararii
introduction of sitar was given by Omar
You are too smart and brilliant to argument in a show like that.
Hes not having a debate, hes chatting about a topic and promoting his books.
How big should they make them, ladies?
4:43 Ricky reaction 😂 Lol
Much of what he says has already been imagined/conceived in science fiction & theories of education. It is perceptive.
Pamela Anderson?
Her sister?
Ricky😂hairdressing
Skavlan to me feels like a modern day version of Dick Cavett
Even blondie forgets to pout her mouth when he speaks.
He is sitting 30 days silent meditation retreats annually and he doesn’t even mention meditation as a useful tool.
What the...??
dhamma.org by the way!!
Hope this young smart philosopher leave the Commercial world soon and go back to study and writing as before getting famous
Nancy Mohass I hope he becomes more famous so that more people read his books.
sibtay its a msg from lee , he is still in Tate and I knew you hated Richard
zamzkey , LOC
1:20 What? No, I'm a grad student in linguistics, it's not the/a standard scientific theory
Nobady knows the origin of language.
He is a public intellectual: it means he is paid to chat shit about every field without having any expertise in any.
Plus a brain which doesn't work as much because it is plugged in (relying on a computer for things like memory recollection and spatial awareness) would decay
Scratching my head... why Pamela Anderson on the panel?
she is a a human and looks Swedish
Lee Majors
Many things he is predicting are horrifying.
once upon a tame , Khaatun came as Aurat -like a
shes not the youngest shes the most botoxed
We already did split without these robots.
Money is not story but created as medium to replace gold for ease of trading. The same with credit cards. What is so new about this and why everyone seems excited?
You miss the point.
gold is story
......... :D
Reading between what he says I would think he is into eugenics especially when he calls possible future people "the useless class.' That's pretty disrespectful to future humans. It's as if he is saying they have no value as people. Disgusting in my opinion.'
Edward Newborn His comment is more of a warning (about future eugenics) than an advocacy for it.
Read Harari's books, do not base your comment on what you hear here only. He is making a statement of fact. If you stop and think about it, this is what people would turn out to be: economically useless, in the hundreds of millions. And stating this does not call for killing these people, unless you want to hear that. What I heard Harari doing is calling for debating now, and agreeing now to find policies enforced on a global scale to give those people income and a sense of worth, while their economic value will be zero.
Right at the end he says "nobody knows how to teach emotional intelligence on a massive scale", but this is not true. James Roswell Quinn, author of the Love-Based Leader knows how to do that. The problem is we just don't value emotional intelligence. You can get people to go into a lifetime of debt and spend years to indoctrinate themselves into a left-brained "education", but getting people to part with four days of their life and a few measly hundred dollars is a difficult proposition for some reason. I'd love to see Quinn's method taught at every school and in every corporation, but the corporations do NOT want an emotionally intelligent workforce. As Carlin says, they want "obedient workers". Passive, just dumb enough to stay quietly slaving away in their cubicles for next to nothing while accepting their own exploitation.
What? The language developed cos the first humans wanted to Gossip?
Yes ..It is all signs / signals till the survival , above that ???
@@rangaKikkeri i think was more an issue of surviving and cooperating with others to chase animals to get food. To gossip?? maybe...
i like Ricky , but he just doesn't know when to shut up.
Ted subviet
Sure - even though money is one of the most important inventions and the fact that it is the only thing everyone believes in - MONEY CAN BE USED BIG TIME TO INVEST IN PROPAGANDA, SMEAR CAMPAIGNING AND DECEIVING A WHOLE POPULATION IN RELATION TO TRUTH AND FACTS!!! 😡😡😡
KKwwaaJJJJaa ,,,,, Iqra
Evil
Shuttup Ricky!
"Language evovled to gossip." Well it's a good theory for a chat show, but linguistic nonsense.
I think language developed to help with the hunt, not for gossip
No ...in fact hunters don't need to talk too much that is bad for success in hunt . but women back in village have that need
:)
Just read his book...
Why would you think that? Hunting is an activity where making too much noise would be counter-productive as it would alert the prey to the predator's presence.
Yuval Harari gets far too much attention. Making judgements based on historical or scientific trends is a dangerous business. Extrapolating from the success of AI in performing amenable logical tasks like playing chess, Yuval thinks that the historical and ethical human self is something downloadable onto a machine or hackable like a computer. Yet it is clear that we are not just a set of logical and biological functions with some emotions added on. We can also see the necessity of 2 + 2 = 4, Euclid's theorems or General Relativity, the intangible beauty of Michelangelo's David and the wrongness of selfishness. We can also detect the inherent contradiction in an author asking us to accept or 'value' (a word entirely missing from Yuval's vocabulary) a subjective worldview that does away with the human subject.
Up my my ggfdsdttttpoppohgggguyttlllpooogghc
Sorry for those texts. My grand daughter of 2 years has put
You lost me, and I think you lost it too.
He is a verbose charlatan.