The ONLY time I have ever swirled my brush in an eyeshadow is if it is a dry sheer piece of shit with no pay off, any pigmented shadow you only need to tap. Why people swirl their brush I don't know.
This is one of the best non biased reviews I've watched. Too many "makeup artists" seem like they don't know how to use shadows. I really liked that Sam showed how to use them properly. Great educated review.
Georgia Warren To be fair, there are lots of makeup artists also reviewing this and not having a good time. It seems like some people got one batch and some had a not so good one :(
This doesn't look that good though for her talent and usual looks..watch her Mod Ren tutorial right after this one and you'll see what I mean...a pallette should not be this difficult for that price point..ingredients don't lie...MAJOR difference in ingredients between this and MR pallette/ABH single shadows I just really wish abh would speak to the difference in ingredients it's nothing to do with how hard it's pressed it's the ingredients
well said, major ingredient change! and that is the main issue, especially that it is 'modern renessaince 2' so you would except tge formula to be the same :/ i'm really disappointed, as i was so excited gor this pallete
Even the person behind this admitted there are faults and urged people to return the palettes if not happy, and for the price why should people keep it, if it were an affordable palette you could make it work but for that price there are better
Thank you for not having a clickbait title and thumbnail photo and being as really as possible. Also shout out to Sam for being so consistent lately! You're my favorite person to watch on here and I love that you've been on it lately!
This is the only review I’ve watched where you zoomed in to the eye and how the shadows blend and work on the eyelid..very helpful. Other girls were zoomed far out asking us viewers if we see how blotchy and inconsistent the matte shadows blend out…like no bitch I can’t see that far away.
Without sounding stupid, I think I've finally found a Beauty Guru that lives up to my expectation (not that you have to live up to my expectations or anyone elses for that matter). I freaking love your honesty, the detail and depth you go into and provide, whilst keeping everything consise. There's a great balance between your professionalism and your personality. Right with that being said, I don't know how to end this! :)
Samantha, after watching a few of your videos this was the one that sold me on hitting that subscribe button. The professionalism, the thought process behind everything, how you taught me something new, that foiled hat!, and those beautiful looks. I cant believe that you did so many looks in one video!! I guess this note is to say I absolutely adore you already, and, more importantly, admire your hard work.
Sam, you are hands down the BEST youtube beauty guru... or better yet the best youtube beauty EDUCATOR! You are the most level headed, articulate, and clearheaded person on this website in this industry. You do not get enough credit. Keep up the great work. In regards to the pallet, I think I'm going to wait it out, just like you said. Norvina and Anastasia take their jobs very seriously, they will fix this. I know they will, they just care so much about their customers and products. In the mean time, I will patiently wait. Thanks Sam!
Great job with comparing the palettes top and bottom. Unique looks as well. I love the way you keep an open mind about this situation and never hopping on anyone's bandwagon to either hate or not hate. Keeping it real, as always! 👊
Samantha Ravndahl such a well thought out video. Excellent presentation loved the science approach and the comparison between the palettes. Loved the looks you created , very grungy , a true professional. I have the palette now I know how to approach it!! Thank You. Love your work.
You use them with so much care and they still start to look muddy and not as well blended as I would expect! And this bright yellow is a complete different color on your lid, even after blending! This is insane! Btw dying at this intro and the tinfoil hat! This comment is writing my actual ghost.
Only 5 minutes in and this is already my favorite review of the palette. You are always so educational and drama free. You speak very well and are thorough. I freaking LOVE ITTTT.
Not only was the editing and humour in this video top notch, the review and demos were probably the best I've seen. Once again, proving you are one of the RUclipsrs to go to for well thought out, informed reviews.
I just got this pallet and I am fairly new to makeup and I had no problems. It was quite powdery, but overall the pallet is very nice. I like it a lot.
This is such a YOU video. A good balance of comedy and information about the situation. Love it! (but kinda disappointed that all brushes weren't drenched in Fix+ :/// )
Right like who the hell SWIRLS Maybe if ur using a drugstore palette that u really gotta WORK to get any pay off BUT if ur using a $30+ palette u should never ever be swirling or feel the need to
I don't usually comment on videos.. but as someone who has begun to make content for YT... I must say... this is thee most educational and neutral review I've seen on this palette... thank you for covering all the bases and not being afraid to speak your mind.. also I appreciate how you phrase things lol.. I think you delivered censure admirably and gave praise where it was due.. I'm very glad you started making videos again.. you're definitely one of my favorites
You have the best review out there for this palette, very professional in your explanation and knowledge of how to correct issues you came across with the applications. No one else has done that. Also, loved the foil hat!
Oh my god thank you for this. I'm so tired of everyone losing their shit! Even the comments on Sephora are "I just bought it today but everyone said it sucked so 1 star!!!! I can't wait to use it though!!"
Your reviews are my absolute favorite. They're always so unbiased and professional. I love that you always make sure to encourage people to try a product out for themselves to determine their own thoughts. Also love the tin hat, it was a real treat 😂
I don´t know why people talk about talc and mica like they were chemist. Stephanie Nicole, has an amazing review, she explain the difference between those and why the colours "oxidize". Something pretty obvious, but not that obvious for those who gave a bad review.
I really LOVED that you had 3 looks in this video! That really helps get a feel for colors and how they look together. Also, the hat was just so so perfect
I love how your 3 looks are realistic every day makeup looks. I love you you made the point that normal people using a highly pigmented makeup palette wouldn’t “swirl” their brush around, I don’t even do that with my modern renaissance all I know is that I have no need to swirl my brush in because one dip is all I need to get the right amount of product. There is some kick back but hardly any which is the same with most palettes even my morphe palettes lol. Also I like how you pointed out the fact that if you mix some colours together it might turn muddy, I’m pretty sure we all learnt that in pre school it seems a lot of people have forgotten this haha. Thanks for your review
Lmfao "what's your batch code" 😂😂😭 I loved the intro. Yeah I've seen nothing but horrible reviews on this one, I'm so surprised her palettes are usually good. 🤷🏻♀️
cflowermakeup I really honestly think some people are being dramatic or are trying to get attention from ABH simply because it is such a different formula from the sister pallete so they want to make an even bigger deal of it.
Kat ? No not at all it actually sucks. I was super excited to get this and tried it before any negative reviwes were even posted. The palette sucks and it is very diff. From the modern renaissance and mario palette
Dominique N I have no doubt that its powdery and isn't blendable most people have that issue, but I feel a feeling some people are being over dramatic about it and purposely hitting pan just so ABH will notice them
These looks are BANGIN'. They are the kind of looks I was imagining when I first saw this palette. It makes me feel more inspired than any palette I've seen. Awesome video!!
Sams reviews are always the best. She also goes step by step which I don't see in the beauty community anymore. Just people doing their makeup on camera. SHOW US STEPS PEOPLE. BE LIKE SAM. ❤️
Thank you for using this palette correctly and not loading up your brush with shadow then wondering why it won't blend out.... You're legit the only youtuber I trust with reviews so thanks. :)
I love that you showed 3 different looks, not only to show how the different colors wear/apply but also for tutorial purposes. You are starting to become one of my most trusted reviewers bc zero f's are given by you about PR lists. Keep up the great work. Ps I love the timestamps
Absolutely loved all three looks!!! You're literally the Bob Ross of makeup! On that 3rd look, just when I thought you F'd it up, you transformed it into a beautiful look! You're truly a talented artist and I appreciate how genuine you are. I'm no expert on makeup application by no means, I'm learning as I go and I still bought the palette. The colors are like nothing I've ever owned. If anything it might teach me how to work with color and really pigmented shadows.
I absolutely love this palette and I just don't see why people are freaking out 😂 The colors are so unique and I love the softness and pigment of the shadows
wow so i just finished the whole video sam and i absolutely LOVED how you did a few different eye looks with the pallet!! this helps people like me who it looking for a new pallet will give me a couple looks i can do witn it! i wish everyone did this with every pallet! You never ever fail to impress me samantha 😊
This is by far the most in depth, knowledgeable review and info about the subculture palette. I feel like I actually understand what is going on now. Thanks so much Samantha!
The tin hat is everything Sam! Thank you as always for a well thought out review offering tips & techniques. This palette is finally available from Naimie's for me to order at my pro discount. Looking forward to getting it.
When people I saw how much kickback there was, I still wanted to buy it because I love the colors so much and I dip my brush in the same way you do so I feel like I can work around the kickback. However, what drew me away from buying it was seeing the lack of blendablity, how patchy the shadows were, and the lasting power they had.
Does anyone else think that maybe since this is described as a grungy palette that maybe this is how it is supposed to preform? To me grunge is a little messy, bold, and smudgy/not perfect, blended, and seamless.
Sam, you're my favorite youtuber! You're fun, creative, and talented without being disingenuous or annoying. I love you! Thanks for this clarifying review!
Norvina said they were going to press the shadows a little bit harder, and she said on Snapchat that they were going through the batches, sooo I'm sure they are going to solve this. Yes, people are having trouble, but I think it's a little bit to over the top. They are working on it so at least what I'm going to do is wait to have some news from the ABH team in regards to what they will do to solve it. Once they share that with us, I'll buy and if I don't like it, i can always return it. That's what you would do with anything you don't like, you return it and then move on. Loved this review by the way!!! Very informative and entertaining!!
I like this palette. I have done a couple nice looks with it. It is still ABH after all. I really like the looks you came up with! Can't wait to recreate! It was just half price at Ulta so I got a backup. Love your humor!
Sam I respect your honesty and reviews. You truly give us a in depth explanation with each shade and I thank you for that. You are a amazing artist and I enjoy all your RUclips videos
I really appreciate your reviews! I love how you're completely unbiased and list every pro and con of a product, so everyone watching can decide for themselves whether or not it's worth buying.
I love your approach to this review! I want to know why they changed the formula too, if it ain't broke...I'm finding my less dense brushes with a light hand are giving me the best results with this palette. Side note, this drama palette has introduced me to so many new youtubers!
I dont own the Subculture, but with all I have seen and heard. I feel like the Subculture has a similar formula to Lorac. Lorac shadows have kickback and tend to give you patches when blending. But even then who swirls their brush into the palette? I TOTALLY AGREE ABH SHOULD HAVE EDUCATED THE CONSUMER ABOUT THE DIFFERENT FORMULA BEING COMPLETELY DIFFERENT THE MODERN RENAISSANCE. I really liked how you talked about the issues with Subculture.
Lol nooo I have a really big Lorac palette and it has a little kickback but it's nothing like subculture or even modern ren. also it's way more blendable than subculture.
Despite all the drama and controversy out there over this palette, You nailed it. All three are great. I'm gonna go play with mine again. I got mine the day abh launched it and have been having a little bit of trouble. Watching youy and some others with similar reviews is motivating. Gorgeous colors Ann's anastasia is hands down, my favorite band. I'm loyal to them until the end. Thanks, xxoo
This was such an amazing review! Definitely my favorite review and this will be the LAST review I watch so that I can keep the feeling this has given me! I love that you covered everything, yes there is kick back, yes the colors are hard to blend, yes there is a ton of fallout. But knowing this, I honestly think people need to just learn to be more cautious of how they use this pallet. I have been seeing beauty gurus swirling their brushes around and then they get surprised when all of this product is falling out of the pan. I honestly would never swirl my brush around in the pallet like that, so when I watched most reviews I honestly wasn't getting, what I thought to be, a very helpful perspective on proper use of this pallet. I'm glad that you gently used it knowing the amount of fall out and kick back that you would receive. You created very beautiful looks with it, which are looks that I would have considered when seeing these colors. I honestly think this is just an all-around very good review, i'm so glad that I saved your review for last. Thank you! 💕
I love how you give this palette a chance and make it your b*tvh! I love the looks & how honest you are. To me, most of the beauty gurus have their opinion influenced by others who claimed that the palette is patchy, unblendable, etc. But your professionalism in this video had me subscribe to you. You are the reason why I wanted to buy this palette 💖
I absolutely love that second look, so beautiful. I've already commented about the controversy surrounding this palette on Twitter, so I won't be repeating myself here and adding fuel to the fire. But, as always, thank for your honesty!
These looks are so beautiful. You're one of the first "gurus" I've found that actually has an education in makeup, its so refreshing. This was very informative and unbiased I appreciate this type of content :)
there are like 800 reviews on this & ive watched about 11 but yours is truly the best. like you actually tried, actually attempted to do normal looks & weren't bias towards talking up a similar palette ☕️ so thanks for that these looks we're really pretty☺️
Discovered your channel recently and have been binge watching like Netflix; you are an absolute gem. I just got Subculture, consider myself an eyeshadow novice but walked through look 3 with you...loved my finished look. More confident now that I be able to use the palette using the tips in this video.
First of all...that tin hat!? Haha that was amazing! This is probably the best review I have seen on this product and in the past 2 days lord knows we have all probably watched a million. Personally I am more of a beginner I guess when it comes to eye shadows. The first high end eye shadow pallet I got was the ABH Mario pallet. And just going from only using morphe shadows to using ABH taught me not to swirl my brush in "more expensive" shadows. The pay off is way better and from my beginner experience more expensive shadows have kick back like that. I will still purchase cuz these colors are gorgeous
"Because FUCK MERCURY." I appreciate your reviews because you're fair, balanced, thorough, and use actual phrases aside from "SO PIGMENTED" and "FALLOUT CITY." Thank you for being so damn good at what you do.
I totally agree with the fact that ABH should've said beforehand that the formula was different. Calling it MR's "sister" was their mistake. Everyone came in with the mentality that it would be the same formula and everything as MR, just different colors. They should've marketed SC as "completely different" than MR. NOW, they're emphasizing the fact that this palette is "softly pressed" and you just need to "tap" into it. They should've been emphasizing this from the first moment they revealed it. Idk if that makes sense, but that's what I take from this whole situation.
Wauw, you did some of the most beautiful eye examples with this palette. I've seen a few and has not been sold on the colors because I couldn't see any pretty combos. You just made me interested in these types of colors. They were beautiful.
I find no matter how hard I try, certain colours in this palette just don't blend together... like you said; it's still usable, BUT should it really be this hard to make a cohesive look? Isn't that what palettes are for? Making it easy to find shades that go together? Idk.
LOVE this review! I love that you're so honest and real with your opinions. My issue with the palette is that Norvina is saying the way the shadows are pressed is the reason why people are having any issues, yet you look at the ingredients of Subculture vs MR and they're COMPLETELY different. ABH is one of my favorite brands, and I still wanna give this palette a try. I just hate that they ignore such an important factor like it's not actually an issue 😞
the fact that even your palette, which wasn't unusable or as bad as the others by far, wasn't super great makes me wonder if even the intended, original, "good" formula of the palette is that great? I initially thought that, ok, some people are getting bad batches clearly but i'm sure that the "good" batches are phenomenal just like the modern ren. but there's just... such variation even with the people who say it isn't horrible? i don't know anymore lol. i feel like, for people who aren't buying it for review purposes, it's much smarter to just wait the whole thing out, see if there's a reformulation or something. also i'm tired of people accusing the people who hate it of lying or not applying it right when it's obvious there are inconsistencies, so i'm glad you addressed that. anyways great video as always, love you
I've watched a few reviews now on this palette and Sam, you have done such a nice job! You are super talented and smart, and it shows in this review. I like that you did your research and did not apply it in the same way as every single review I've watched. You worked with the palette.
Perfect for fall!!! I have this pallette and love it with my green eyes, but I can see why some people don't like it. Nothing like the ABH MR, which it is easy and flows. This one you do have to work with and the looks are not as majestic, but more grunge. Love the looks you made with it!!!
I freaking love how cool toned Mercury is, but that's one of my favorite shades. I do very much appreciate this thorough video! I still want this palette, even though it may be a gamble what I'm going to get. I felt that Modern Renaissance was a really soft formula, but I still love it. I do need these shades though. I just don't want to shell out for Viseart Dark Mattes, so I'm sure I'll get this. This is a great video. I really appreciate that you showed the differences of the palettes, plus 3 different looks! I hope everyone sees this. Fantastic job!
Your video just proves that if you're skilled you can make beauty out of anything. I totally agree with what you said in your video, this is not a beginner palette. It takes expertise, skills, and creativity to be able to create such decent and beautiful looking eyeshadows. Btw, Love the looks that you made!
My thing is, I always thought modern renaissance had kickback so I'm not surprised with the subculture palette. If people know that it's pigmented because they sees it WIT THER EYEZ, then WHY are you swirling your brush around and complaining?? I totally agree with you, there' no reason to swirl and dig your brush in a color when they know first off, that it's high quality shadow, and that it has kickback. People 🙄
The ONLY time I have ever swirled my brush in an eyeshadow is if it is a dry sheer piece of shit with no pay off, any pigmented shadow you only need to tap. Why people swirl their brush I don't know.
This is one of the best non biased reviews I've watched. Too many "makeup artists" seem like they don't know how to use shadows. I really liked that Sam showed how to use them properly. Great educated review.
Georgia Warren To be fair, there are lots of makeup artists also reviewing this and not having a good time. It seems like some people got one batch and some had a not so good one :(
This doesn't look that good though for her talent and usual looks..watch her Mod Ren tutorial right after this one and you'll see what I mean...a pallette should not be this difficult for that price point..ingredients don't lie...MAJOR difference in ingredients between this and MR pallette/ABH single shadows I just really wish abh would speak to the difference in ingredients it's nothing to do with how hard it's pressed it's the ingredients
well said, major ingredient change! and that is the main issue, especially that it is 'modern renessaince 2' so you would except tge formula to be the same :/ i'm really disappointed, as i was so excited gor this pallete
yeah it was such a good review, so different from others I have seen!!! xox
Even the person behind this admitted there are faults and urged people to return the palettes if not happy, and for the price why should people keep it, if it were an affordable palette you could make it work but for that price there are better
Lmao the foil hat. 😂😂
RawBeautyKristi I found your channel, and have been binge watching ever since!!! You have become my new favorite!! Xo
RawBeautyKristi I love you
Yes my fave
Everyone that loves Sam will absolutely adore Kristi.
I died when I saw the hat! Lmfao!
Thank you for not having a clickbait title and thumbnail photo and being as really as possible. Also shout out to Sam for being so consistent lately! You're my favorite person to watch on here and I love that you've been on it lately!
Varica Taylor thank you :)
This is the only review I’ve watched where you zoomed in to the eye and how the shadows blend and work on the eyelid..very helpful. Other girls were zoomed far out asking us viewers if we see how blotchy and inconsistent the matte shadows blend out…like no bitch I can’t see that far away.
....Sam literally always zooms in to her eyes
I knowwww..it’s helpful that she zooms in.
Victoria Ashley yea I've seen some reviews and they're like do you see that line? But like no cause you're so far away
Dear Shayla...
lool ive seen so many that zoom in to the eye, who u trown shade at grl
Without sounding stupid, I think I've finally found a Beauty Guru that lives up to my expectation (not that you have to live up to my expectations or anyone elses for that matter).
I freaking love your honesty, the detail and depth you go into and provide, whilst keeping everything consise. There's a great balance between your professionalism and your personality.
Right with that being said, I don't know how to end this!
:)
This was the most incredibly thorough and beautiful scientific experiment that I have ever had the pleasure of witnessing ..bless you, Sam
Samantha, after watching a few of your videos this was the one that sold me on hitting that subscribe button. The professionalism, the thought process behind everything, how you taught me something new, that foiled hat!, and those beautiful looks. I cant believe that you did so many looks in one video!! I guess this note is to say I absolutely adore you already, and, more importantly, admire your hard work.
EmmaKate thanks for the sub!!
I'm so glad that you're so honest and never hold back despite any brand relationships! you're the one I trust most!
also, update on the Sunday Riley regime?
My modern renaissance palette has a lot of kick back, as well.. am I the only one orrrr?
Nope! Mine does too! Thought I was alone. lol
China Saylor mine does too but I don't really mind because it blends so easily and doesn't really impact the eye look :)
China Saylor what's your batch code ??
China Saylor WHATS YOUR BATCH CODE?! Lol but tbh mine does too
Mine too. But it blends out really pretty so I don't mind.
Sam, you are hands down the BEST youtube beauty guru... or better yet the best youtube beauty EDUCATOR! You are the most level headed, articulate, and clearheaded person on this website in this industry. You do not get enough credit. Keep up the great work.
In regards to the pallet, I think I'm going to wait it out, just like you said. Norvina and Anastasia take their jobs very seriously, they will fix this. I know they will, they just care so much about their customers and products. In the mean time, I will patiently wait. Thanks Sam!
Sara Smith thank you! And yes, I definitely think waiting it out will be worthwhile.
Great job with comparing the palettes top and bottom. Unique looks as well. I love the way you keep an open mind about this situation and never hopping on anyone's bandwagon to either hate or not hate. Keeping it real, as always! 👊
Amy Wilson thanks girl :)
Samantha Ravndahl such a well thought out video. Excellent presentation loved the science approach and the comparison between the palettes. Loved the looks you created , very grungy , a true professional. I have the palette now I know how to approach it!! Thank You. Love your work.
You use them with so much care and they still start to look muddy and not as well blended as I would expect! And this bright yellow is a complete different color on your lid, even after blending! This is insane!
Btw dying at this intro and the tinfoil hat! This comment is writing my actual ghost.
Only 5 minutes in and this is already my favorite review of the palette. You are always so educational and drama free. You speak very well and are thorough. I freaking LOVE ITTTT.
THE TIN FOIL HAT I CANT FUCKING BREATHE 😂😂😂😂 periscope fam will remember the conspiracy theories
Not only was the editing and humour in this video top notch, the review and demos were probably the best I've seen. Once again, proving you are one of the RUclipsrs to go to for well thought out, informed reviews.
Literally the only person I trust to give me REAL informative reviews.
I just got this pallet and I am fairly new to makeup and I had no problems. It was quite powdery, but overall the pallet is very nice. I like it a lot.
This is such a YOU video. A good balance of comedy and information about the situation.
Love it!
(but kinda disappointed that all brushes weren't drenched in Fix+ :/// )
Regan lmfao that eyeshadow and brush will never be the same
Its probably still drying 😂
Right like who the hell SWIRLS
Maybe if ur using a drugstore palette that u really gotta WORK to get any pay off BUT if ur using a $30+ palette u should never ever be swirling or feel the need to
I don't usually comment on videos.. but as someone who has begun to make content for YT... I must say... this is thee most educational and neutral review I've seen on this palette... thank you for covering all the bases and not being afraid to speak your mind.. also I appreciate how you phrase things lol.. I think you delivered censure admirably and gave praise where it was due.. I'm very glad you started making videos again.. you're definitely one of my favorites
You have the best review out there for this palette, very professional in your explanation and knowledge of how to correct issues you came across with the applications. No one else has done that. Also, loved the foil hat!
Oh my god thank you for this. I'm so tired of everyone losing their shit! Even the comments on Sephora are "I just bought it today but everyone said it sucked so 1 star!!!! I can't wait to use it though!!"
These are essentially pigment in soft press form. Hence the kickback. I personally love it!
Your reviews are my absolute favorite. They're always so unbiased and professional. I love that you always make sure to encourage people to try a product out for themselves to determine their own thoughts. Also love the tin hat, it was a real treat 😂
I don´t know why people talk about talc and mica like they were chemist. Stephanie Nicole, has an amazing review, she explain the difference between those and why the colours "oxidize". Something pretty obvious, but not that obvious for those who gave a bad review.
I really LOVED that you had 3 looks in this video! That really helps get a feel for colors and how they look together. Also, the hat was just so so perfect
Dear lord you are my hero! FOR SCIENCE! I just can't with your science hat! Thank you for making this so light hearted ❤️
This is why your reviews are my favorite. Super unbiased, informational, with a toych of sass. Yes girl!
I literally CHOKED when the foil hat popped up
I love how your 3 looks are realistic every day makeup looks. I love you you made the point that normal people using a highly pigmented makeup palette wouldn’t “swirl” their brush around, I don’t even do that with my modern renaissance all I know is that I have no need to swirl my brush in because one dip is all I need to get the right amount of product. There is some kick back but hardly any which is the same with most palettes even my morphe palettes lol. Also I like how you pointed out the fact that if you mix some colours together it might turn muddy, I’m pretty sure we all learnt that in pre school it seems a lot of people have forgotten this haha. Thanks for your review
Lmfao "what's your batch code" 😂😂😭 I loved the intro. Yeah I've seen nothing but horrible reviews on this one, I'm so surprised her palettes are usually good. 🤷🏻♀️
I also agree with you, she should have came out with something about how to use it and how it's different than her others BEFORE hand.
cflowermakeup I really honestly think some people are being dramatic or are trying to get attention from ABH simply because it is such a different formula from the sister pallete so they want to make an even bigger deal of it.
Kat ? Agreed
Kat ? No not at all it actually sucks. I was super excited to get this and tried it before any negative reviwes were even posted. The palette sucks and it is very diff. From the modern renaissance and mario palette
Dominique N I have no doubt that its powdery and isn't blendable most people have that issue, but I feel a feeling some people are being over dramatic about it and purposely hitting pan just so ABH will notice them
These looks are BANGIN'. They are the kind of looks I was imagining when I first saw this palette. It makes me feel more inspired than any palette I've seen. Awesome video!!
Sams reviews are always the best. She also goes step by step which I don't see in the beauty community anymore. Just people doing their makeup on camera. SHOW US STEPS PEOPLE. BE LIKE SAM. ❤️
Thank you for using this palette correctly and not loading up your brush with shadow then wondering why it won't blend out....
You're legit the only youtuber I trust with reviews so thanks. :)
I love that you showed 3 different looks, not only to show how the different colors wear/apply but also for tutorial purposes. You are starting to become one of my most trusted reviewers bc zero f's are given by you about PR lists. Keep up the great work. Ps I love the timestamps
Hands down, best subculture pallet review on the Internet! You nailed it. And I always love a good sprinkling of dry humor in the mix :)
I think this is the MOST NEUTRAL review I have seen so far 👍🏼 Sam you did a great job!
Absolutely loved all three looks!!! You're literally the Bob Ross of makeup! On that 3rd look, just when I thought you F'd it up, you transformed it into a beautiful look! You're truly a talented artist and I appreciate how genuine you are. I'm no expert on makeup application by no means, I'm learning as I go and I still bought the palette. The colors are like nothing I've ever owned. If anything it might teach me how to work with color and really pigmented shadows.
I absolutely love this palette and I just don't see why people are freaking out 😂 The colors are so unique and I love the softness and pigment of the shadows
wow so i just finished the whole video sam and i absolutely LOVED how you did a few different eye looks with the pallet!! this helps people like me who it looking for a new pallet will give me a couple looks i can do witn it! i wish everyone did this with every pallet! You never ever fail to impress me samantha 😊
Great review. I felt like raw beauty kristi also did a very honest and thorough review. Love your videos! Thank you for all you do💜
B.fleye Beauty Artistry love her videos
This is by far the most in depth, knowledgeable review and info about the subculture palette. I feel like I actually understand what is going on now. Thanks so much Samantha!
The intro LOLLL I love you so much
Dude Reddit gave me so much hate for liking the palette, too. It worked for me and I didn't have any issues with it. None of us deserve all this hate.
The tin hat is everything Sam! Thank you as always for a well thought out review offering tips & techniques. This palette is finally available from Naimie's for me to order at my pro discount. Looking forward to getting it.
When people I saw how much kickback there was, I still wanted to buy it because I love the colors so much and I dip my brush in the same way you do so I feel like I can work around the kickback. However, what drew me away from buying it was seeing the lack of blendablity, how patchy the shadows were, and the lasting power they had.
Dang girl! These are the best eyeshadow combo tutorials I've seen on this palette so far! And I've watched a lot of them!
Does anyone else think that maybe since this is described as a grungy palette that maybe this is how it is supposed to preform? To me grunge is a little messy, bold, and smudgy/not perfect, blended, and seamless.
Vanessa Daigle Yessssssssssssss
Yea, that actually makes sense
thought so too
Thats very true
Thank you for the look ideas, it's so refreshing to hear someone actually working things out instead of just dismissing it for its powderiness.
WHAT DO YOU MEAN YOU DON'T USE FIX+. It's almost like you expect eyeshadows to work straight out of the pan or something. Crazy talk.
Sam, you're my favorite youtuber! You're fun, creative, and talented without being disingenuous or annoying. I love you! Thanks for this clarifying review!
Norvina said they were going to press the shadows a little bit harder, and she said on Snapchat that they were going through the batches, sooo I'm sure they are going to solve this. Yes, people are having trouble, but I think it's a little bit to over the top. They are working on it so at least what I'm going to do is wait to have some news from the ABH team in regards to what they will do to solve it. Once they share that with us, I'll buy and if I don't like it, i can always return it. That's what you would do with anything you don't like, you return it and then move on. Loved this review by the way!!! Very informative and entertaining!!
I like this palette. I have done a couple nice looks with it. It is still ABH after all. I really like the looks you came up with! Can't wait to recreate! It was just half price at Ulta so I got a backup. Love your humor!
last time I was this early beauty bloggers were as honest as you are
I really like that you zoomed in so much while doing the eyeshadow! You're very talented with these types of colors. Thanks for the review!! 😘
Thank you for not using a blur filter like other channels so we can actually see your makeup! Xoxo
Sam I respect your honesty and reviews. You truly give us a in depth explanation with each shade and I thank you for that. You are a amazing artist and I enjoy all your RUclips videos
Samantha, can you please please please review:
1) Nars Loaded Eyeshadow Palette;
2) KVD Shade + Light Glimmer Palette;
3) The Balm Nude Beach Palette;
4) Urban Decay Naked Heat Palette;
You are AMAZING, thank you! I really want to know your opinion!
Anastasia K YES PLEASE
Anastasia K I second the nars
Yes definitely the nars!!
So you want Sam to spend her Money on things you want? Think about that. ;))
Diana that's her literal job.
I really appreciate your reviews! I love how you're completely unbiased and list every pro and con of a product, so everyone watching can decide for themselves whether or not it's worth buying.
I love your approach to this review! I want to know why they changed the formula too, if it ain't broke...I'm finding my less dense brushes with a light hand are giving me the best results with this palette. Side note, this drama palette has introduced me to so many new youtubers!
You use the most creative and unique color combinations that never cease to blow my mind. Gorgeous!
OMG the It's Always Sunny screenshot 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 you are seriously the raddest and most hilarious!
Yess and the " what's your batch number" lol
I love that you mention the difficulty!! I'm really excited for this pallet because I'm so OVER all the warm palettes and I love using "odd" colors
I dont own the Subculture, but with all I have seen and heard. I feel like the Subculture has a similar formula to Lorac. Lorac shadows have kickback and tend to give you patches when blending. But even then who swirls their brush into the palette? I TOTALLY AGREE ABH SHOULD HAVE EDUCATED THE CONSUMER ABOUT THE DIFFERENT FORMULA BEING COMPLETELY DIFFERENT THE MODERN RENAISSANCE. I really liked how you talked about the issues with Subculture.
Carolina Campoy agree when you say it's a set with MR then you find out you basically have to baby the fuck out of it.
Lol nooo I have a really big Lorac palette and it has a little kickback but it's nothing like subculture or even modern ren. also it's way more blendable than subculture.
Despite all the drama and controversy out there over this palette, You nailed it. All three are great. I'm gonna go play with mine again. I got mine the day abh launched it and have been having a little bit of trouble. Watching youy and some others with similar reviews is motivating. Gorgeous colors Ann's anastasia is hands down, my favorite band. I'm loyal to them until the end. Thanks, xxoo
YES YES YES ready for this video, I love Sam
This was such an amazing review! Definitely my favorite review and this will be the LAST review I watch so that I can keep the feeling this has given me! I love that you covered everything, yes there is kick back, yes the colors are hard to blend, yes there is a ton of fallout. But knowing this, I honestly think people need to just learn to be more cautious of how they use this pallet. I have been seeing beauty gurus swirling their brushes around and then they get surprised when all of this product is falling out of the pan. I honestly would never swirl my brush around in the pallet like that, so when I watched most reviews I honestly wasn't getting, what I thought to be, a very helpful perspective on proper use of this pallet. I'm glad that you gently used it knowing the amount of fall out and kick back that you would receive. You created very beautiful looks with it, which are looks that I would have considered when seeing these colors. I honestly think this is just an all-around very good review, i'm so glad that I saved your review for last. Thank you! 💕
I love how you give this palette a chance and make it your b*tvh! I love the looks & how honest you are. To me, most of the beauty gurus have their opinion influenced by others who claimed that the palette is patchy, unblendable, etc. But your professionalism in this video had me subscribe to you. You are the reason why I wanted to buy this palette 💖
This is the most well educated, in depth review I've seen so far of this palette. Thank you for clearing up a lot of the concerns
The introo thoo!!!!! 😂😂🙋🏻
I absolutely love that second look, so beautiful. I've already commented about the controversy surrounding this palette on Twitter, so I won't be repeating myself here and adding fuel to the fire. But, as always, thank for your honesty!
Holy shit I lost it at the tin foil hat though. 😂😂😂😂
These looks are so beautiful. You're one of the first "gurus" I've found that actually has an education in makeup, its so refreshing. This was very informative and unbiased I appreciate this type of content :)
there are like 800 reviews on this & ive watched about 11 but yours is truly the best. like you actually tried, actually attempted to do normal looks & weren't bias towards talking up a similar palette ☕️ so thanks for that these looks we're really pretty☺️
LMAOOO SAM THE INTRO IS EVERYTHING
AND THE TIN FOIL HAT I CANT WITH YOUUCJJCD
Discovered your channel recently and have been binge watching like Netflix; you are an absolute gem. I just got Subculture, consider myself an eyeshadow novice but walked through look 3 with you...loved my finished look. More confident now that I be able to use the palette using the tips in this video.
BUT WHO IS PEPE SILVIA?!?!
Helena P YES!
I GOT BOXES FULL OF PEPE
THERE ISSSSS NO PEPE SILVAAAAAAA
CAROLLLL CAROLLLLLLLL
CAROLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL
First of all...that tin hat!? Haha that was amazing! This is probably the best review I have seen on this product and in the past 2 days lord knows we have all probably watched a million. Personally I am more of a beginner I guess when it comes to eye shadows. The first high end eye shadow pallet I got was the ABH Mario pallet. And just going from only using morphe shadows to using ABH taught me not to swirl my brush in "more expensive" shadows. The pay off is way better and from my beginner experience more expensive shadows have kick back like that. I will still purchase cuz these colors are gorgeous
"Because FUCK MERCURY." I appreciate your reviews because you're fair, balanced, thorough, and use actual phrases aside from "SO PIGMENTED" and "FALLOUT CITY." Thank you for being so damn good at what you do.
I would love to see you play with this one again. Your skills have improved. This is a favorite of mine. With warm coloring, this is super glam on me.
I totally agree with the fact that ABH should've said beforehand that the formula was different. Calling it MR's "sister" was their mistake. Everyone came in with the mentality that it would be the same formula and everything as MR, just different colors. They should've marketed SC as "completely different" than MR. NOW, they're emphasizing the fact that this palette is "softly pressed" and you just need to "tap" into it. They should've been emphasizing this from the first moment they revealed it. Idk if that makes sense, but that's what I take from this whole situation.
The first review of this pallet that actually makes sense. Girl preach. You said everything I was thinking since the first bad reviews came out.
Maybe it's those dang Morphe Brushes😂
ALLY V 🤣🤣🤣🤮😂 because they’re SO AMAZING !
Lmao, omg
They're awful. I received two as a gift. I use them to clean the dust of my son's legos displayed on his dresser.
Rose Eeee 😂😂😂
xd hhahahahahahahahhahahaha
Wauw, you did some of the most beautiful eye examples with this palette. I've seen a few and has not been sold on the colors because I couldn't see any pretty combos. You just made me interested in these types of colors. They were beautiful.
I find no matter how hard I try, certain colours in this palette just don't blend together... like you said; it's still usable, BUT should it really be this hard to make a cohesive look? Isn't that what palettes are for? Making it easy to find shades that go together? Idk.
Warm tones are not meant to blend with cool tones, there is a color wheel to respect
LOVE this review! I love that you're so honest and real with your opinions. My issue with the palette is that Norvina is saying the way the shadows are pressed is the reason why people are having any issues, yet you look at the ingredients of Subculture vs MR and they're COMPLETELY different. ABH is one of my favorite brands, and I still wanna give this palette a try. I just hate that they ignore such an important factor like it's not actually an issue 😞
the fact that even your palette, which wasn't unusable or as bad as the others by far, wasn't super great makes me wonder if even the intended, original, "good" formula of the palette is that great? I initially thought that, ok, some people are getting bad batches clearly but i'm sure that the "good" batches are phenomenal just like the modern ren. but there's just... such variation even with the people who say it isn't horrible? i don't know anymore lol. i feel like, for people who aren't buying it for review purposes, it's much smarter to just wait the whole thing out, see if there's a reformulation or something. also i'm tired of people accusing the people who hate it of lying or not applying it right when it's obvious there are inconsistencies, so i'm glad you addressed that. anyways great video as always, love you
I love that you loved this palette! Still one of my favorite ABH palettes! Such a helpful tutorial!
I know this video is old but this is honestly one of my favorite palettes. I never had any issues. Thankfully.
I love how real you are. You don't bullshit, you're honest, straightforward and fair! Because of that I know you can be trusted. Thank you!
when you said "subculture-gate" i DIED and immediately liked lmfaoo
I've watched a few reviews now on this palette and Sam, you have done such a nice job! You are super talented and smart, and it shows in this review. I like that you did your research and did not apply it in the same way as every single review I've watched. You worked with the palette.
for some reason mines has a of fall out even just touching into it. also the shimmers are really terrible in mine :( like no pigment..
Cassie Kendrick Same. I think there are some batches that are just worse than others.
Perfect for fall!!! I have this pallette and love it with my green eyes, but I can see why some people don't like it. Nothing like the ABH MR, which it is easy and flows. This one you do have to work with and the looks are not as majestic, but more grunge. Love the looks you made with it!!!
😂😂 the foil ... Liked the review. I'm going to wait to see if the palette is re-pressed but I may go by Sephora and swatch to see what's up.
I freaking love how cool toned Mercury is, but that's one of my favorite shades. I do very much appreciate this thorough video! I still want this palette, even though it may be a gamble what I'm going to get. I felt that Modern Renaissance was a really soft formula, but I still love it. I do need these shades though. I just don't want to shell out for Viseart Dark Mattes, so I'm sure I'll get this.
This is a great video. I really appreciate that you showed the differences of the palettes, plus 3 different looks! I hope everyone sees this. Fantastic job!
Sam forgetting the name of the real techniques accent brush will never not be funny to me
Your video just proves that if you're skilled you can make beauty out of anything. I totally agree with what you said in your video, this is not a beginner palette. It takes expertise, skills, and creativity to be able to create such decent and beautiful looking eyeshadows. Btw, Love the looks that you made!
My thing is, I always thought modern renaissance had kickback so I'm not surprised with the subculture palette. If people know that it's pigmented because they sees it WIT THER EYEZ, then WHY are you swirling your brush around and complaining?? I totally agree with you, there' no reason to swirl and dig your brush in a color when they know first off, that it's high quality shadow, and that it has kickback. People 🙄
She is the realest youtuber, should've known to watch her review first than anyone else's!