+TheBiteSizedCrafter I bet those enzymes love giving us cancer while eating them too...think of all that shit they put into the ocean to eat up the oil spill....Cancer causing according to wikipedia....but noooooo no one ever talks about that! Ugh...if air pollution doesnt kill us the media will
I was gonna say the same thing BronzeOrwin Do you think that would be any more pretty? Either way, the fish ain't gonna be be doing much swimming after that.
@@dasbakon Traded typos, eh? And the worst part is yours is arguably more shameful since it's far more common than metal vs medal. *They're, as in they are, not "their" as in possession. God!
It would be considered public indecent to display this. Which both RUclips and national television wouldn't of approved. It's have nothing to do "wanting to hide something".
@@rickytorres9089 That's literally "wanting to hide something", namely, what you describe as indecent. You don't seem to have a particularly strong grasp on language. I recommend you fix that.
I just saw this episode on tv and that’s what I though. Harvested ovaries and eggs..🤔 they should show it all, see how many ppl still continue to eat them 😡
To all the preachers and environmentalists and vegetarians/vegans: 1. These fish are farmed. Like chickens. It is far better this way so that the natural wild population isn't harmed. 2. The fish is killed yes, but the rest of the meat is sold. Just like any other caught and sold fish in the world. The only difference is the main meat is the eggs. 3. They are killed in a humane way. The fish are put to sleep first. It's far better than other methods used in the world. I get cruelty to animals. I really do. That's why I argue FOR methods that are specially not cruel. Animals are killed and eaten as part of life and yes, I understand caviar is not required to survive I know. But the rest of the fish is still eaten. Please, please stop complaining about it. I get your points, but there's no reason to rage and argue on a youtube video about how caviar production is carried out. It's done this way, it is humane, doesn't affect the wild endangered population and is above all else, sustainable.
Hey professor... isn't it amazing how many people can't understand a simple video on caviar farming..? I couldn't believe some of the comments I read on this informative video... Show these imbeciles how the chicken they eat is "harvested and packaged"... then maybe they'll start understanding how we get our food to that supermarket at the corner up the street... I'm embarrassed for them... I wish I could afford good caviar, the protein levels are very beneficial, and the different types of protein, vitamins and minerals it contains are some of the best... (education is the cure to stupidity)
John Grindinger Yes! I completely agree! I try in most cases to be as nice as possible but some really do escape me with their lack of knowledge. I don't mean to sound all elitist either. If a person wants to learn I commend them, caviar is excellent for the body, I eat it often in sushi as sushi is my favourite food. I just wish that people would be a little less criticizing to what they learn from videos like this. Nice to find someone on here who is like me. :)
+StringStorm Although bacon is delicious, you should definitely at least try it. It tastes like small pearls bursting full of very flavourful fish soup.
Caviar is actually quite tasty, most people just dont have the gut to try it because they can't get over the fact of what it is. Some roes will even pop in your mouth like candy almost. Its also healthy for you as well.
I had caviar one time. Bought a little jar of it while it was on sale. I actually really liked it, and might get some more in the future when I feel like treating myself with a splurg buy.
Although this video was highly interesting and informative, I found different things the lady said to be quite funny. How she called the bacteria casings "nuggets" and how she was talking about how the egg filled ovaries are "extremely fragile and need careful handling" while the person grates them on a board to detach the soon to be money pits known as caviar.
I found that part where she ground the ovary against the grate odd too, but I figured she had to know what she was doing. It looked like it worked out, so I guess she was gentle enough. Edit: okay, after seeing that thing with the paper towel, I'm kinda doubting that this is the most high end factory.
As i see it, fishes to feel pain, but they obviously lack the mental capacity to think about it or react in any way that is not reflexive. Many die in ways that aren't pain-free, to say the least. The fact that these sturgeons get to be put to sleep being being killed is a privilege they have, they wouldn't be that lucky in the wild.
Farms fish for caviar and meat so no wild fish can be harmed and thus the population will stay abundant, people still scream 'abuse'. Humans are so naive.
***** Uhmm... My kids are human? Those are fishes? You know biology right? The difference between a humans and fishes. I did't know that my kids have gills
***** that's a terrible idea for a business, no one wants to eat humans. Caviar on the other hand is worth millions. Its a good thing you're not a business man.
***** That's good business to the ones who wants dirty money, but still bad cause you know why? Its illegal. Unless you want to recreate that movie where they make clones of wealthy people who pays them only for the clones' organs to be harvested.
over hyped stuff... make tacos 1000$ each and it will achieve the same level of 'delicacy'...only difference would be that tacos accually taste good unlike the tiny salted water baloons
Still curious how someone has came up with all this shit! Not just caviar. Just 80% of the shit we eat. I love food but damn who was the Guinea pig that was like ok I'll try or was like look what I stumbled on. What is it? Here man just take a bit I don't know what it is yet.
h8ncars I'm always wondering about shit like that! Like when we were wandering about foraging for things like mushrooms before we had books and stuff to refer to were we just like 'well Geoff just died I guess we don't eat that'
This only for the Sturgeon, there are other less expensive fish eggs. I just ate a chicken egg sandwich, and I have fish eggs in several jars in a box I ordered for myself and a friend. I also eat ant larva from time to time. So am I a bear or a man?
No, Never heard of the dude till I saw him acting in a TV show, and while it isn't a slight, he was acting before a camera, When you live like that all the time, and do it even if you aren't being watched, then it is a lifestyle not a TV show.
+Almac x It's pretty simple really, if they were using wild ones, the fish would go probably extinct, but seeing as they're using captive ones, no such danger is posed to that breed of fish.
I still don't see why people are so disgusted by practices that allow even the poorest of people to actually eat. IF all our domesticated animals were treated like pets, meat would become expensive. Would you really pay 50 dollars more for a pound of chicken? Also think about it if you take away the meat industry you would put millions of people out of work. Farmers would become bankrupt as 80% of the crops produced here in the states goes to feed animals. Why do you think the government didn't just close all nicotine factories? Because taking one industry away would have a cascading effect on the current economy, unless you can create new jobs for all the people you want to put out of work, current practices will not change.
surely those farmers just go into vegetable production, which would equal a food surplus which will help with world hunger. this caviar farming is not sustainable, you have to feed them protein and where does that protein come from meat or other types of fish both of which are unsustainable
Sam Irwin Do you know the reason why farmers became bankrupt in the 1920s, even before the great depression? It's because there was a food surplus, this caused prices for farm goods to drop which caused the farmer's income to drop, economy slowed down for farmers and most of them lost their farms due to foreclosure. Just because there's a surplus doesn't mean it's any good. Also world hunger is present because we don't distribute the food well enough, not because we don't have enough. Not only that thanks to technology only 3% of Americans need to hold farming jobs to sustain the entire nation. But this doesn't mean that if farmers were to go out of business that it won't have an impact in economy because most farms are connected to large corporations with a large amount of employees.
man, really shitty caviar. sturgeon should live at LEAST 16 years for good caviar, and you add the salt to taste, not by % mass, because 2 sturgeons can produce very different levels of saltiness of eggs.
mesahusa Lol and I asked you how did you know, not whether you knew or not. You totally didn't answer my first question but whatever. You don't own a sturgeon farm, thats for sure.
Jon Doe Yes it is. It is very different. Why do they use fish? Because fish don't eat grains, they eat fish. Only in the last few weeks have there been two scientific organisations who have claimed to of solved the problem of fish feed, by creating a non fish containing version. Why would they do it that way though? Catching wild fish to feed the farmed fish? Because that's the only way they've been able to feed them. Please do some research first.
Paratrooper 6 Well actually, things like the membranes from the sturgeon ovaries that they harvest are likely what they'd add to the feed. They would not go out and capture fish to feed farmed ones, that is wasteful and expensive. Instead, they would use offcuts of farmed fish with nutrients added in to make it more beneficial. "Please do some research first" ;)
Paratrooper 6 As it happens, the majority of shrimp aren't predators at all. Many eat via filtration of the water around them, or through consuming parasites or dead tissue off other fish that they clean. Hardly what you'd call a predator...
The fishes eggs are unfertilized so their not pregnant. It's just like when a women ovulates. They have an egg but unless its fertilized your not pregnant
If you think about it - i's pretty nasty, murdering a pig, cutting it up and draining it&'s life sustaining blood from it's once living body. You then proceed to filet the flesh and sear it over intense heat, then put it in a mouth hole at which point an appendage manipulates it around your mouth and enamel covered pieces of living flesh grind the bacon.
sometimes I just wonder where people got the idea to eat half of the things that we eat. I mean who was the person who thought that hey we should cut out the ovaries of fish and eat the eggs!? Yeah that sounds like a great idea! I understand that everyone has their own taste and that things that I find strange are delicacies for others, but just the process itself seems like a head scratcher. Just my opinion.
Still doesn't explain it. It's not something that is easy to obtain, the process is kind of out there so I still don't get who came up with the idea cut the eggs out of fish ovaries salt them and then eat them...weird just weird.
***** They caught a fish, one of them is female, they cut open the fish and clean it up, but because it's hard to get food, they try to utilize most part of the fish, this include their eggs. Same goes for liver or blood from farm animal.
tnt ntn Seems Legit lol No but I can understand the process of discovering new food sources, but my comment (take from my 21st century Western Schema) was just remarking on how odd a process it seemed to get such a seemingly out of the blue food, and why anyone would do it. Obviously Aesthetic Brah was right with the survival of the fittest comment, but I was just making a comment on the odd nature of the food and its processing
Presumably early hunter gatherers were not particularly picky about what to eat. If they could get it, and it was edible it was going to get eaten. If it tasted good then bonus points for that but it was probably going to get eaten anyway. Its highly doubtful that anyone initially went after fish roe specifically, early fisherman probably ate half the parts we don't really consider edible anymore.
why is everyone complaining about this? we eat chicken eggs on a regular basis and no one is whining about that. do we suddenly not care about chickens?
Alex Draper no you just pump it with steroids, force it to pump out the eggs like a machine for its short life living in horrible conditions before it dies of exhaustion and is sold for meat, so yeah i can see that killing fish in a nice manner with no pain is so much worse than chickens
Harry Page It truly depends on where the chickens are raised, because many chickens are treated nicely but some unfortunate chickens are treated horribly, but most die after they have had a decent life. Sturgeon have a decent life span too, so they are equal as USSPhoenix23 said
Alex Draper hahahahaha i don't give a shit how they treat the animals as long as it tastes good :') i was just pointing out how framing caviar is no different to farming any other animal, you cant bitch about how something is killed because of its eggs when every other farmed animal gets the same or worse.
so... just to be sure, they cut the fish open to get to the ovaries, right? man, i'm no fish hugger but isn't it cheaper if they just let the damn thing lay eggs?
Pretty bad how a fish/living thing is kept captive its entire life to be used for money which is most likely spent on material things to impress other humans
It's actually not that sustainable. The high protein feed is usually made of smaller fish that have to be caught in the wild. In the States, it might be a little different since there's lots high protein waste meat that people don't eat so it might be little more sustainable but still.
they could turn the waste meat into black soldier flies, and red worm. turn that into a meal and mix it with plant life to create the pellets. with a little bit of another farm fish like catfish or something that has a decent amount of oil in it
This argument comes up more with Salmon and especially Tuna. The Sturgeon on the other hand, I'm not so sure about. If you haven't already, I recommend the book "Four Fish" to anyone interested in the topic.
Thanks. I'm more familiar with salmon and shrimp farms. Didn't even know sturgeons were farmed until I watched this video. High protein usually = meat of some kind so I just assumed.
They use a large sharp knife to split open the fish and then they use sharp scissors to cut out a large chunk of the fish's abdomen. After that the remainder of the fish is put into a grinder and made into compost and animal feed. Some say this process does harm the fish… yes.
narrator: "we harvest the flesh and eggs" most of you clowns in the comments: "OMG does the fish survive?!" They literally slice it open and rip out the ovaries, do you honestly think the fishes' life is valuable enough to perform a oophorectomy then stitch it back up so it's swimming by dinner time?
Just goes to show how sick rich people are....plain sick SOB's. Who the hell would eat the producing eggs of another species?? Oh shit I forgot about chicken eggs, lol.
I know that, but I typed "eat the producing (fertilized or un) of another species" meaning eggs from birds, chickens, dinosaurs, ostriches, snakes, lizards, ect.
Why's everyone getting so mad that they have to kill the fish to get the eggs? They are going to take the meat of the fish for food as well. A good cut of sturgeon should be an adult anyway. All they are is using as much as they can from the animal.
Fortunately, there’s at least one other facility that harvests the eggs with a different technique. They use pressure and positioning to massage the eggs out of the body of the fish. The fish then goes back into the tank to grow another batch instead of being killed or having surgery. The eggs are more valuable than the meat so it makes more sense to farm them repeatedly in this way.
@@spencertang5155 ruclips.net/video/QUF4tEknk_s/видео.html This is one method that I’ve seen. But I saw another company that simply flexes the fish and the eggs come out, and it takes seconds to harvest before the fish go back in the water. I’ll try to find that video for you as well.
@@spencertang5155 couldn’t find that video, but I did find some others. These fish live for something like 100 years if they’re not killed. Most companies who raise them for caviar kill them to harvest their eggs when the fish are only 7-10 years old. That’s how long it takes for them to be able to have their first batch of eggs.
@@spencertang5155 that video where he just flexed the fish to harvest the eggs it took only seconds. He moved them to a kiddie pool size holding tank, picked up a fish out of the water, basically did a chiropractic adjustment that sprayed the eggs into a catcher by bending the fish backwards over his knee, and then put it back into the water to finish spawning before grabbing another fish out & doing the same quick motion. No slits or hormones or anything. Really wish I could find that video again.
why do they kill the fish? isn't there a way to remove the eggs without the fish dying? then the fish can grow more and eventually produce more eggs. there must be a way to encourage the fish to release the eggs on her own and allow herself to produce again in a year or so..it's like a dairy farm slaughtering all their cows for the milk......
They removed the ovary. Ovaries don't grow back. Even if a female fish laid the eggs she isn't going to make more. Females are born with a set number of eggs inside them and they would eventually run out. It's faster to just cut out the ovaries from the fish.
Jordan Beers not fish......they produce the eggs themselves in the ovaries every spawning season unless they're a single time breeder like west coast salmon. sturgeon are multi time breeders, they can return to the sea after spawning and reproduce again in the future. there must be a way to force the fish to release her eggs naturally and not need to kill her.
***** Even if there was a way to force the sturgeon to release their eggs, it would most likely be more expensive. Also, if the farmers were to remove just the eggs out of the ovaries, it would still make the cost of the operation higher as they would have to stitch the incisions back up and make sure the wound didn't become infected with antibiotics. You also have to remember that these are farm animals, and they're being raised for their eggs.
kyyang28 expensive? raising a new batch of sturgeons for years is likely more expensive than making these adults spawn on command., also, the caviar is worth A LOT of money, there's a reason they're doing this......but as I already explained, this is like killing the cows for their milk or killing the honey bees for their honey(which I know that's what they had to do in the past). it's clearly advantageous to have the fish release their eggs naturally instead of having to kill the fish for the eggs.
They can't spawn on command though, which is what I was trying to say. I was saying if you surgically remove the caviar, leaving the ovary, it would be a more lengthy and expensive process. People also eat the sturgeon's flesh, and older sturgeons don't taste as good.
+Angelo Cipollaro Those fish wouldn't have existed had the farm not made them. And they had no positive or negative effect on the ecosystem. so its not wild
The sad thing is that these fish could reach 100 years of age if you would let them. But nowadays it's basically impossible for them to become that old even in the wild.
How did you state a fact if you don't know what I eat? Are you assuming I eat junk food or could I be a vegetarian perhaps? So it's really a matter of opinions and you're entitled to your wrong opinion, that's fine with me.
ItsSomeDeadGuy That and the expensive king crab is actually a infestation destroying ecosystems with no natural predators. The fish market is fucking horrible.
I never ate caviar to feel rich, I love anything that comes from water pretty much. As a kid I ate a lot of caviar and crayfish. We caught crayfish ourselves in lake by leaving traps with rotting fish in them and then simply collecting them in the morning. Boiled crayfish with dill and salt... mmm.....
"They're extremely fragile, and need careful handling to separate them from the membrane. This worker grinds the fuck out of the eggs against tough metal."
This is basically how they do chickens. lol With hens they harvest there eggs until there infertile, then they just kill the chicken and put them on supermarket shelves. How many chickens do you eat per year lol?
None smarty pants. I´m vegan. And for that matter. Just because i don´t give a list of EVERYTHING i think is as i put it SO WROOOOONG doesn´t mean i don´t know whats going on in this crasy world and the food market. It makes me pissed to say the least.
How is this wrong? I'd say what you're doing is wrong. Taking away your nature of being an omnivore is something I'd consider wrong. You're trying to change nature by removing the "survival of the fittest" principle (which is a key feature to nature). Bringing morals into this is just illogical, as Spock would say.
id love to take a month off and visit this plant or any similar. that filtering system was amazing and the molasses injection is so smart :). They must have so many tanks if they cycle out fish every 12 years to keep up with demand. so cool !
How exactly is it more sustainable to farm it rather than catch it wild (as this video keeps saying) They literally are condensed into small pool areas for years before being taken and having their ovaries taken. So much energy and resources are used to keep the pools at certain temperatures, remove toxins, and feed them.
+Danny B how is it inhumane? you said yourself a lot of effort goes into making sure water conditions are just right so I'm genuinely wondering how these conditions are inhumane
At 1:58 she says "at 5 to 7 years...". I watched a video entitled 'Gordon Ramsey Caviar' and they were farming caviar in Andalusia, Spain. They very clearly stated that their caviar was taken at 18 to sometimes 20 years old. Why? Is the Spanish caviar more mature and better? More of it? Also, the Spanish caviar farm was almost entirely outdoors. I bet that caviar is far more expensive than the kind seen here. But, who knows?
"No wild animals were harmed in the process" or some shit like that but obviously that's a lie they have to cut open the fish and cut the ovaries out for consumption and they're not gonna' sow the fish back up and let them live and keep feeding them that's a waste of money for them damn bastard
i think you may be right for the most part but there really weren't any wild fish killed. the fishes were farmed, and they made caviar from those fishes.. they didn't go out to catch wild fish in order to make the carviar
The fish were farmed for the purpose of producing caviar, so they aren't wild. After they remove the ovaries, they cut up the rest of the fish and sell it as meat, so that nothing goes to waste. And the fish die in their sleep before they get their ovaries removed, so it's humane. And it's not "sow" it's "sew". Unless, you were talking about distributing seeds.
roma lauren i'm not sure if you've noticed. But humans are a product of nature. Everything they do is natural and a part of nature. And no, we're not the only animal that will use other animals to our own ends. If you think THIS video is bad you don't know what a mud wasp is.
Well, I don´t approve this but.. there is a silver lining if you want to see it.. this way of getting the eggs is less aggressive against the wild Salmon and can help if needed to increase the endangered species too... yeah its better if the live in the wild, but, nowadays wilderness is a luxury some animals cant have :(
I really am happy all these different seafoods and fish can now be farmed. Wild does taste a little bit better and is better for you but almost every fish is overfished and extremely hard to get. This can cause a massive price increase for something that will become less and less sustainable due to the price. Farming is for sure the better option.
1:07 "The fish produce tiny metabolites that are toxic to them."
Translation:
The fish are swimming around in their own piss and shit all day.
That's why it's filtered dumbass
+tohopes They filter it with enzymes to kill those toxins. It said so in the episode.
+TheBiteSizedCrafter I bet those enzymes love giving us cancer while eating them too...think of all that shit they put into the ocean to eat up the oil spill....Cancer causing according to wikipedia....but noooooo no one ever talks about that! Ugh...if air pollution doesnt kill us the media will
infringinator
Wikipedia is never a reliable source. Anyone can edit them to their liking.
TheBiteSizedCrafter still more reliable than watching some dude with a toupee on tv
"we're not gonna film the part where they rip the ovaries from the fish"
Hahaha I thought that same thing!!!
I doubt it is ripping as much as it is just cutting the fish open and prepping it to become meat.
I was gonna say the same thing
BronzeOrwin Do you think that would be any more pretty?
Either way, the fish ain't gonna be be doing much swimming after that.
Ryan Mitchell Yes, I think it would be more pretty.
It's on one of the videos with gordon ramsey when they open it up
careful handling ..... rubs the egg on the mish of metal
I was thinking the EXACT.SAME.THING! lol
exact thought.
Fucking GRINDING the eggs into that metal.
It's a special tool that doesn't break the egg even with a little bit of pressure pushed on it, but still separates it from the membrane
Hoodiefoodie
Lol 😂 it's a mesh screen lol
They're rubbing it to separate it from the membrane. If you look carefully you'll see the eggs falling to the bottom of the boul
Mmmm... Three months rent in a single bite.
I'm trying to find the lie
your rent is 10 dollars over 3 months?
@@looneyirish007 good deal
"They are extremely fragile" *starts grinding eggs on metal strainer*
that was my thought like hmm the eggs broke from grinding them too hard
Bruh, they rub it on a mesh to separate the eggs from the membrane. It also doesn’t break the eggs.
It’s not a metal mesh it’s actually rubber
Must be pretty difficult to strain medals. Their pretty big
@@dasbakon Traded typos, eh? And the worst part is yours is arguably more shameful since it's far more common than metal vs medal. *They're, as in they are, not "their" as in possession. God!
I like how they just totally skip the part where they cut the fish open.
It would be considered public indecent to display this. Which both RUclips and national television wouldn't of approved. It's have nothing to do "wanting to hide something".
@@rickytorres9089 That's literally "wanting to hide something", namely, what you describe as indecent. You don't seem to have a particularly strong grasp on language. I recommend you fix that.
Think of how much it would suck if you tipped that bowl into the sink.
in Russia? they'd probably kill you! Lol
Mazaroth That's like destroying your desktop. Caviar is so expensive that one year of my allowance is equal to an ounce of caviar.
Yuukei I know
😂😂😂😂
5-7 years of a fish growing literally down the drain!
"Plastic nuggets that house the all important bacteria"
Aka: Children's pasta.
MacDonald's playplace parts
"tHEY KILLED HER FOR HER EGGS!!1!!"
Wow, It's like meat comes from live animals. Amazing, right?
I just saw this episode on tv and that’s what I though. Harvested ovaries and eggs..🤔 they should show it all, see how many ppl still continue to eat them 😡
At the beginning they said they are farmed for their meats too (flesh). So at least it's more sustainable in that aspect.
"Highly absorbent paper towel"
Lindsey 04 Did you notice the amount of eggs that were stuck to it?
@@blackmonfarms9681 I did. It's really wasteful since it's so expensive and valuable.
To all the preachers and environmentalists and vegetarians/vegans:
1. These fish are farmed. Like chickens. It is far better this way so that the natural wild population isn't harmed.
2. The fish is killed yes, but the rest of the meat is sold. Just like any other caught and sold fish in the world. The only difference is the main meat is the eggs.
3. They are killed in a humane way. The fish are put to sleep first. It's far better than other methods used in the world.
I get cruelty to animals. I really do. That's why I argue FOR methods that are specially not cruel. Animals are killed and eaten as part of life and yes, I understand caviar is not required to survive I know. But the rest of the fish is still eaten.
Please, please stop complaining about it. I get your points, but there's no reason to rage and argue on a youtube video about how caviar production is carried out. It's done this way, it is humane, doesn't affect the wild endangered population and is above all else, sustainable.
Hey professor... isn't it amazing how many people can't understand a simple video on caviar farming..? I couldn't believe some of the comments I read on this informative video... Show these imbeciles how the chicken they eat is "harvested and packaged"... then maybe they'll start understanding how we get our food to that supermarket at the corner up the street... I'm embarrassed for them... I wish I could afford good caviar, the protein levels are very beneficial, and the different types of protein, vitamins and minerals it contains are some of the best... (education is the cure to stupidity)
John Grindinger Yes! I completely agree! I try in most cases to be as nice as possible but some really do escape me with their lack of knowledge. I don't mean to sound all elitist either. If a person wants to learn I commend them, caviar is excellent for the body, I eat it often in sushi as sushi is my favourite food. I just wish that people would be a little less criticizing to what they learn from videos like this. Nice to find someone on here who is like me. :)
If only more people were actually smart like you.
Stfu
I don't know where you live but I've never ever seen stergin meat for sale. How much does it cost?
You’ll never know why i got so many likes
+giang tram lol fr gently scratches on screen
Gently*
Yeah whats with that
It doesnt damage the eggs actually
The tool is actually smooth
French Fry 2 years ago mate
I'm not PETA member, but something feels fucked up about this.
those eggs are not fertilized so wtf is your problem.....its like eating a plant...its just protein strands.....
Gary Kline I'm not talking about the eggs. I'm talking about the fish being in tiny tubs for their entire lives. So wtf is your problem?
Gary Kline ...and yes, you look like an idiot.
Candy Caldwell easy troll, easy
How am I a troll? Because I called you out for blindly disagreeing with me without even knowing what I was actually talking about? Okay.
I don't like caviar at all. Blech. The rich can keep their brunt matter tasting delicacies. I'm sticking with Bacon!
YEAH! BACON!
Ben Duncan I love you
+StringStorm Although bacon is delicious, you should definitely at least try it. It tastes like small pearls bursting full of very flavourful fish soup.
+StringStorm bacon is nasty
but so is caviar
+Hacked Your Account fish soup....lemme go and vomit.. blerrfghhhgh
It's 5am, why am I watching this?!
same
3:33aʍ ɨ ċaռ't sʟɛɛք...
Same
Same lmfao
Same
Caviar is actually quite tasty, most people just dont have the gut to try it because they can't get over the fact of what it is. Some roes will even pop in your mouth like candy almost. Its also healthy for you as well.
I had caviar one time. Bought a little jar of it while it was on sale. I actually really liked it, and might get some more in the future when I feel like treating myself with a splurg buy.
When the worker was packing in the cavier, i immediately thought of Nickelodeon floam lmao
WOLFINX Oh gosh, I remember that.
Matt Lothe I'll okay
Wow, I forgot that stuff existed until I read this comment!! What a blast from the past!!!
Forbidden Nickelodeon floam
This is way more fucked up that i thought it would be.
Actually the process offers a great benefit to the world as a whole
I agree with this 100%.
Now learn about how cowboy caviar is made!
Although this video was highly interesting and informative, I found different things the lady said to be quite funny. How she called the bacteria casings "nuggets" and how she was talking about how the egg filled ovaries are "extremely fragile and need careful handling" while the person grates them on a board to detach the soon to be money pits known as caviar.
I found that part where she ground the ovary against the grate odd too, but I figured she had to know what she was doing. It looked like it worked out, so I guess she was gentle enough.
Edit: okay, after seeing that thing with the paper towel, I'm kinda doubting that this is the most high end factory.
chopping ovaires ...for delicacy..really ??
You eat fruit
+Pragya Surjan Lol there are many countries that consider animal's testicles and penises delicacy. Ovaries are not surprising.
As i see it, fishes to feel pain, but they obviously lack the mental capacity to think about it or react in any way that is not reflexive. Many die in ways that aren't pain-free, to say the least. The fact that these sturgeons get to be put to sleep being being killed is a privilege they have, they wouldn't be that lucky in the wild.
and yes, i realise that i just called the fishes privileged.
Proper plural for fish is fish!
I have a feeling that we will get along XD
@@adunakhyr Well, that's if you're talking about fish of the same species. If you're talking about, for example, beta and angel fish, you'd say fishes
I don't remember disliking this comment but I have returned and liked it... What a fucking life I live
I want a bunch of those fish, not to farm thy just look fucking cool
XDDDDDDDDDDDD
I agree. They're so cute looking
Derlim Sandres Sturgeon is delicious, and adorable. I'd definitely keep one as a pet.
***** I wanted to rub it's belly when they were ultra-sounding it.
Eleonora Smith They look so soft and smooth, don't they?
Farms fish for caviar and meat so no wild fish can be harmed and thus the population will stay abundant, people still scream 'abuse'. Humans are so naive.
Finally a smart person
Ram Seda Exactly!
***** Uhmm... My kids are human? Those are fishes? You know biology right? The difference between a humans and fishes. I did't know that my kids have gills
***** that's a terrible idea for a business, no one wants to eat humans. Caviar on the other hand is worth millions. Its a good thing you're not a business man.
***** That's good business to the ones who wants dirty money, but still bad cause you know why? Its illegal. Unless you want to recreate that movie where they make clones of wealthy people who pays them only for the clones' organs to be harvested.
LOL @2:52, they are extremely fragile, yet they are rubbed onto the screen like its hard marbles.
over hyped stuff... make tacos 1000$ each and it will achieve the same level of 'delicacy'...only difference would be that tacos accually taste good unlike the tiny salted water baloons
Tacos don't need to be grown for 5-7 years lol
EM Lux you can say they do. "special beans that take 10 years to grow" SOLD
+moon ar Only in Disney
Obviously your broke ass has never tasted them
+moon ar Yeah I agree, caviar tastes like fish flavored salt. It's really underwhelming considering how much it costs.
Still curious how someone has came up with all this shit! Not just caviar. Just 80% of the shit we eat. I love food but damn who was the Guinea pig that was like ok I'll try or was like look what I stumbled on. What is it? Here man just take a bit I don't know what it is yet.
h8ncars I'm always wondering about shit like that! Like when we were wandering about foraging for things like mushrooms before we had books and stuff to refer to were we just like 'well Geoff just died I guess we don't eat that'
Becky Teasdale so true
It is much better to farm the fish than to transfer them from the wild to a factory.
jtomally9681 This comment section apparently doesn't give a shit about ecological sustainability. "wahhh fish died"
*chops on fish sticks*
Its so the species is unaffected in the wild
This only for the Sturgeon, there are other less expensive fish eggs. I just ate a chicken egg sandwich, and I have fish eggs in several jars in a box I ordered for myself and a friend. I also eat ant larva from time to time. So am I a bear or a man?
Bear Grylls?
No, Never heard of the dude till I saw him acting in a TV show, and while it isn't a slight, he was acting before a camera, When you live like that all the time, and do it even if you aren't being watched, then it is a lifestyle not a TV show.
I'd say you're a man that's not afraid to try new things.
"No wild fish were destroyed" captive fish were still destroyed so I don't really see what they're getting at...
+Almac x It's pretty simple really, if they were using wild ones, the fish would go probably extinct, but seeing as they're using captive ones, no such danger is posed to that breed of fish.
+Hugh Darrow fair enough, thx
+Almac x Well.. they are also bred for meat... so yeah it's not just the eggs that are harvested. It's just like farming any other fish species.
alot of times they do these company's do fund research or research these fish species
+Hugh Darrow They're still endangered though
I still don't see why people are so disgusted by practices that allow even the poorest of people to actually eat. IF all our domesticated animals were treated like pets, meat would become expensive. Would you really pay 50 dollars more for a pound of chicken? Also think about it if you take away the meat industry you would put millions of people out of work. Farmers would become bankrupt as 80% of the crops produced here in the states goes to feed animals. Why do you think the government didn't just close all nicotine factories? Because taking one industry away would have a cascading effect on the current economy, unless you can create new jobs for all the people you want to put out of work, current practices will not change.
surely those farmers just go into vegetable production, which would equal a food surplus which will help with world hunger. this caviar farming is not sustainable, you have to feed them protein and where does that protein come from meat or other types of fish both of which are unsustainable
Sam Irwin Do you know the reason why farmers became bankrupt in the 1920s, even before the great depression? It's because there was a food surplus, this caused prices for farm goods to drop which caused the farmer's income to drop, economy slowed down for farmers and most of them lost their farms due to foreclosure. Just because there's a surplus doesn't mean it's any good. Also world hunger is present because we don't distribute the food well enough, not because we don't have enough.
Not only that thanks to technology only 3% of Americans need to hold farming jobs to sustain the entire nation. But this doesn't mean that if farmers were to go out of business that it won't have an impact in economy because most farms are connected to large corporations with a large amount of employees.
Sam Irwin Dude, farmers can't just "go into vegetable production"...
2:52 "They are extreamly fragile"
-rubs it hard on metal
I love caviar, but here is a little thought I have been dwelling on. Since we call Fish Eggs caviar, would we call unfertilized women eggs Cadaviar?
This is the most underrated comment I have ever seen
popular in Africa I believe
period=cadaviar time?
It's called menstruation
Oh nooooo
man, really shitty caviar. sturgeon should live at LEAST 16 years for good caviar, and you add the salt to taste, not by % mass, because 2 sturgeons can produce very different levels of saltiness of eggs.
Are you serious? How would you know how long sturgeon need to live for good caviar?
SuperKnowledgeSponge because i do
mesahusa Probably the Gordon Ramsay's caviar documentary.
But nice try anyway.
SuperKnowledgeSponge exactly. because i do
mesahusa Lol and I asked you how did you know, not whether you knew or not.
You totally didn't answer my first question but whatever. You don't own a sturgeon farm, thats for sure.
No wild fish were destroyed in the making? Really? Where do you think the fish feed comes from? Hint, it's made of fish (wild fish).
Jon Doe Yes it is. It is very different. Why do they use fish? Because fish don't eat grains, they eat fish. Only in the last few weeks have there been two scientific organisations who have claimed to of solved the problem of fish feed, by creating a non fish containing version.
Why would they do it that way though? Catching wild fish to feed the farmed fish? Because that's the only way they've been able to feed them. Please do some research first.
Paratrooper 6 Well actually, things like the membranes from the sturgeon ovaries that they harvest are likely what they'd add to the feed. They would not go out and capture fish to feed farmed ones, that is wasteful and expensive. Instead, they would use offcuts of farmed fish with nutrients added in to make it more beneficial.
"Please do some research first" ;)
kyogreblast Sorry. It's what they have to do for Salmon, prawns, and a few other fish types which are preditors.
Paratrooper 6 As it happens, the majority of shrimp aren't predators at all. Many eat via filtration of the water around them, or through consuming parasites or dead tissue off other fish that they clean.
Hardly what you'd call a predator...
kyogreblast www.abc.net.au/landline/content/2014/s3984247.htm
If you think about it -it's pretty nasty, harvesting pregnant fish and taking their eggs.
The fishes eggs are unfertilized so their not pregnant. It's just like when a women ovulates. They have an egg but unless its fertilized your not pregnant
+Hannah Rosenthal Hi Hannah - thanks for letting me know, but the fish are killed to get their eggs right? I guess that's the only way.
+Luyen Dao But it's not like the rest is wasted. The rest is used for flesh/protein.
If you think about it - i's pretty nasty, murdering a pig, cutting it up and draining it&'s life sustaining blood from it's once living body. You then proceed to filet the flesh and sear it over intense heat, then put it in a mouth hole at which point an appendage manipulates it around your mouth and enamel covered pieces of living flesh grind the bacon.
Shut the fuck up, you uneducated vegan.
sometimes I just wonder where people got the idea to eat half of the things that we eat. I mean who was the person who thought that hey we should cut out the ovaries of fish and eat the eggs!? Yeah that sounds like a great idea! I understand that everyone has their own taste and that things that I find strange are delicacies for others, but just the process itself seems like a head scratcher. Just my opinion.
Evolution, Survival of the fittest
Still doesn't explain it. It's not something that is easy to obtain, the process is kind of out there so I still don't get who came up with the idea cut the eggs out of fish ovaries salt them and then eat them...weird just weird.
***** They caught a fish, one of them is female, they cut open the fish and clean it up, but because it's hard to get food, they try to utilize most part of the fish, this include their eggs. Same goes for liver or blood from farm animal.
tnt ntn Seems Legit lol
No but I can understand the process of discovering new food sources, but my comment (take from my 21st century Western Schema) was just remarking on how odd a process it seemed to get such a seemingly out of the blue food, and why anyone would do it. Obviously Aesthetic Brah was right with the survival of the fittest comment, but I was just making a comment on the odd nature of the food and its processing
Presumably early hunter gatherers were not particularly picky about what to eat. If they could get it, and it was edible it was going to get eaten. If it tasted good then bonus points for that but it was probably going to get eaten anyway. Its highly doubtful that anyone initially went after fish roe specifically, early fisherman probably ate half the parts we don't really consider edible anymore.
why is everyone complaining about this? we eat chicken eggs on a regular basis and no one is whining about that. do we suddenly not care about chickens?
You don't kill the chicken to retrieve the egg....
Alex Draper no you just pump it with steroids, force it to pump out the eggs like a machine for its short life living in horrible conditions before it dies of exhaustion and is sold for meat, so yeah i can see that killing fish in a nice manner with no pain is so much worse than chickens
Harry Page It truly depends on where the chickens are raised, because many chickens are treated nicely but some unfortunate chickens are treated horribly, but most die after they have had a decent life. Sturgeon have a decent life span too, so they are equal as USSPhoenix23 said
Harry Page you're not happy with any animal production are you?? why did you click on this video?
Alex Draper hahahahaha i don't give a shit how they treat the animals as long as it tastes good :') i was just pointing out how framing caviar is no different to farming any other animal, you cant bitch about how something is killed because of its eggs when every other farmed animal gets the same or worse.
Well I'm a peasant so this isn't for me 😆
Fine bros?
Lol yes
Lol yes
Yup me too :)
Yesss
Haha yes
i was curious from furious, so i came here.
THEY KILLED THE FISH FOR HER OVARIES
yes, humans have done that in many years? Did you know, in order to get food we have to kill...
She actually has it better than most other fish. They kill her while she's sedated.
yeah but they use the flesh for food too. we eat kfc and beef and stuff everyday so....let's all be vegetarians!
and the meat is used
MISOGYNY!!!
I've never had sturgeon caviar but I like flying fish roe.
+ICUSeriously yeah that stuff is awesome
that tastes amazing
I agree with you, some things are expensive and the food that we can eat is good. who would want to eat salted raw egg?!?!
"As the fish grow larger, the feeding schedule ratchets down a bit."
-- get turnt
so... just to be sure, they cut the fish open to get to the ovaries, right? man, i'm no fish hugger but isn't it cheaper if they just let the damn thing lay eggs?
iirc that is past their prime state, by the time they're laid they are too mature or "overripe"
Lol people's demand for caviar
No they put the ovaries in, then close the fish up.
Marvin
wait how the hell does that work?
Javier Cx They cut them open and make blood loss low and steal their ovaries and then they die.
Pretty bad how a fish/living thing is kept captive its entire life to be used for money which is most likely spent on material things to impress other humans
But it's delicious.
But nobody seems to complain about how pet fish are kept in small little fish tanks to live a life of just swimming around in there to entertain us.
Matthew Dyer I assume you dont eat meat at all?
Matthew Dyer So are we captive at work used to get money to impress are customers
+Matthew Dyer, I bet those fish live a better life than you do
Nope, i want mine from wild sturgeon!! It goes great with my panda steaks and scrambled bald eagle eggs!
It's actually not that sustainable. The high protein feed is usually made of smaller fish that have to be caught in the wild. In the States, it might be a little different since there's lots high protein waste meat that people don't eat so it might be little more sustainable but still.
Protein feed does not only come from Animal waist but soy and corn waist products as well. Soy and Corn feed is much more sustainable.
they could turn the waste meat into black soldier flies, and red worm. turn that into a meal and mix it with plant life to create the pellets. with a little bit of another farm fish like catfish or something that has a decent amount of oil in it
This argument comes up more with Salmon and especially Tuna. The Sturgeon on the other hand, I'm not so sure about. If you haven't already, I recommend the book "Four Fish" to anyone interested in the topic.
Thanks. I'm more familiar with salmon and shrimp farms. Didn't even know sturgeons were farmed until I watched this video. High protein usually = meat of some kind so I just assumed.
How do they harvest the eggs? Are the fish killed or harmed after extraction?
of course they are
They use a large sharp knife to split open the fish and then they use sharp scissors to cut out a large chunk of the fish's abdomen. After that the remainder of the fish is put into a grinder and made into compost and animal feed. Some say this process does harm the fish… yes.
The fish are sleeping, so no harm is done to them. They are just slightly shocked when they are pulled from the tubs.
TY.
No they are not harmed or killed after extraction they are killed before you uneducated idiot
I was watching a video on engine block repair and somehow i ended up here...
Welcome to youtube
Welcome aboard
narrator: "we harvest the flesh and eggs"
most of you clowns in the comments: "OMG does the fish survive?!"
They literally slice it open and rip out the ovaries, do you honestly think the fishes' life is valuable enough to perform a oophorectomy then stitch it back up so it's swimming by dinner time?
Imagine if aliens did this exact thing with human eggs... yeesh
No need for aliens. Humans already do this to other humans. Animals would also do this to humans when they could.
Just goes to show how sick rich people are....plain sick SOB's. Who the hell would eat the producing eggs of another species?? Oh shit I forgot about chicken eggs, lol.
I know that, but I typed "eat the producing (fertilized or un) of another species" meaning eggs from birds, chickens, dinosaurs, ostriches, snakes, lizards, ect.
***** Difference here is you have to kill the fish to get the eggs, you don't have to kill the chicken.
Making it that much more crueler and sick. Kill an animal/fish to steal its eggs.
Paratrooper 6 Technically, when you eat chicken eggs, you're still killing chickens.
Damn it! Now, I want an omelette!
***** People generally eat unfertilised eggs. So no, you're not.
All the PETA Members commenting on this video.
The greedy companies could let a few fish go and help re-populate the oceans instead of continually keep every single one to kill.
Why's everyone getting so mad that they have to kill the fish to get the eggs? They are going to take the meat of the fish for food as well. A good cut of sturgeon should be an adult anyway. All they are is using as much as they can from the animal.
I FUCKING LOVE CAVIAR
So the fish died? Just for glamour?
And food. The entire fish was used. Your cans of flaked fish have to come from somewhere!
Just for food.
the pregnant fishes are never wasted bruh they are always used for seafood
Fortunately, there’s at least one other facility that harvests the eggs with a different technique. They use pressure and positioning to massage the eggs out of the body of the fish. The fish then goes back into the tank to grow another batch instead of being killed or having surgery. The eggs are more valuable than the meat so it makes more sense to farm them repeatedly in this way.
Do you know what company does this method?
@@spencertang5155 ruclips.net/video/QUF4tEknk_s/видео.html
This is one method that I’ve seen. But I saw another company that simply flexes the fish and the eggs come out, and it takes seconds to harvest before the fish go back in the water. I’ll try to find that video for you as well.
Hmm… I wonder what the fish feel during that process…
@@spencertang5155 couldn’t find that video, but I did find some others. These fish live for something like 100 years if they’re not killed. Most companies who raise them for caviar kill them to harvest their eggs when the fish are only 7-10 years old. That’s how long it takes for them to be able to have their first batch of eggs.
@@spencertang5155 that video where he just flexed the fish to harvest the eggs it took only seconds. He moved them to a kiddie pool size holding tank, picked up a fish out of the water, basically did a chiropractic adjustment that sprayed the eggs into a catcher by bending the fish backwards over his knee, and then put it back into the water to finish spawning before grabbing another fish out & doing the same quick motion. No slits or hormones or anything. Really wish I could find that video again.
Absolutely Fascinating.....
Makes you wonder who caught and gutted a female sturgeon 400 years ago and saw those eggs and said: "I think I'll eat these ugly black things"
Who came here from kids vs food?
ME
Needs to eat every 4 mins?
me too
You won that conversation.
that was disgusting.. and i feel bad for the fish.. this is fucked up
A 4.5 oz tin of caviar is around $500. so just that mesh alone has like $10000 worth of caviar.
why do they kill the fish? isn't there a way to remove the eggs without the fish dying? then the fish can grow more and eventually produce more eggs. there must be a way to encourage the fish to release the eggs on her own and allow herself to produce again in a year or so..it's like a dairy farm slaughtering all their cows for the milk......
They removed the ovary. Ovaries don't grow back. Even if a female fish laid the eggs she isn't going to make more. Females are born with a set number of eggs inside them and they would eventually run out. It's faster to just cut out the ovaries from the fish.
Jordan Beers not fish......they produce the eggs themselves in the ovaries every spawning season unless they're a single time breeder like west coast salmon. sturgeon are multi time breeders, they can return to the sea after spawning and reproduce again in the future. there must be a way to force the fish to release her eggs naturally and not need to kill her.
***** Even if there was a way to force the sturgeon to release their eggs, it would most likely be more expensive. Also, if the farmers were to remove just the eggs out of the ovaries, it would still make the cost of the operation higher as they would have to stitch the incisions back up and make sure the wound didn't become infected with antibiotics. You also have to remember that these are farm animals, and they're being raised for their eggs.
kyyang28 expensive? raising a new batch of sturgeons for years is likely more expensive than making these adults spawn on command., also, the caviar is worth A LOT of money, there's a reason they're doing this......but as I already explained, this is like killing the cows for their milk or killing the honey bees for their honey(which I know that's what they had to do in the past). it's clearly advantageous to have the fish release their eggs naturally instead of having to kill the fish for the eggs.
They can't spawn on command though, which is what I was trying to say. I was saying if you surgically remove the caviar, leaving the ovary, it would be a more lengthy and expensive process. People also eat the sturgeon's flesh, and older sturgeons don't taste as good.
She said no wild fish were destroyed to get the caviar to the market but they have to kill and cut open the sturgeon to get it so?????
+Angelo Cipollaro They have "farm fish".
+Angelo Cipollaro Those fish wouldn't have existed had the farm not made them. And they had no positive or negative effect on the ecosystem. so its not wild
+Oliver Casey she gets that, her point is, the advertisement is an oxymoron.
Oliver Casey oh I don't care about that homie, if I got my hands on some Caviar I'd slurp that shit up
louisasmiles tfw I'm a man
it sounded a bit alien when she said "harvesting ovaries" o-o
The sad thing is that these fish could reach 100 years of age if you would let them. But nowadays it's basically impossible for them to become that old even in the wild.
That looks disgusting. How can ppl eat that.
It's delicious.
some would say that about foods you eat regularly so keep that negative comment to yourself
But you don't know what I eat so it really doesn't change the fact that it looks nasty. Sorry not sorry lmaoooo
LOL you state an opinion of yours and i state a fact. lets hear your come back now :)
How did you state a fact if you don't know what I eat? Are you assuming I eat junk food or could I be a vegetarian perhaps? So it's really a matter of opinions and you're entitled to your wrong opinion, that's fine with me.
In China by the Russian border, caviare is POOR MANs food and is served at breakfast
Lobster and crab also used to be the moor man's food since no one expected people would want to eat scum eaters.
Depending on the crab it's still poor food.
ItsSomeDeadGuy That and the expensive king crab is actually a infestation destroying ecosystems with no natural predators. The fish market is fucking horrible.
So was lobster, then they realized they are overfishing it and it's suddenly very rare.
THEY TOOK HER OVARIES OH GOD
Did anybody else laugh uncontrollably when they sedated the fish and gave it a fucking ultrasound?
I never ate caviar to feel rich, I love anything that comes from water pretty much. As a kid I ate a lot of caviar and crayfish. We caught crayfish ourselves in lake by leaving traps with rotting fish in them and then simply collecting them in the morning. Boiled crayfish with dill and salt... mmm.....
No fish were destroyed? What happens to the fish whose ovaries are removed?
+ClaustrophobicCarrot they put them to sleep...
vincent112233445566
It's a caviar farm. What use do they have for fish with no ovaries?
no use they kill them afterword
vincent112233445566
They said no fish were destroyed though.
they were talking about not endangering the animal
tHE FISH ARE CUTE wHAT
Mertalia WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU!!😣😣😢😢😢😭😭😭😭😭😭
Captive or wild, it's still sad
And delicious. The sadder the harvesting, the more tasty the food is.
Quality always comes with a price weather it’s money or commitment.
If you eat too much vegetables, you will hallucinate that all animal could live happily forever.
"They're extremely fragile, and need careful handling to separate them from the membrane. This worker grinds the fuck out of the eggs against tough metal."
Caviar looks like it could be done at home if you had the certain fish.
that's like like housing a cow in your house, because it's possible...
***** well true. but there isnt much factory devices is what i mean, everything is so simple it could be done at home
VexxLoL please watch the video again.
It could be, but getting the fish is a major pain.
Jim Mowreader And the feeding system, and the food, and the bacteria, and the water filter, and the chilling room, and the ultrasound sensor...
"they are very fragile"
*_scrape scrape scrape_*
this is so wrooooooong. i really hope ragnarök kills os on saturday
This is basically how they do chickens. lol
With hens they harvest there eggs until there infertile, then they just kill the chicken and put them on supermarket shelves. How many chickens do you eat per year lol?
None smarty pants. I´m vegan. And for that matter. Just because i don´t give a list of EVERYTHING i think is as i put it SO WROOOOONG doesn´t mean i don´t know whats going on in this crasy world and the food market. It makes me pissed to say the least.
UDIO That sounds tasty, care to cook a little chicken for me? :3
How is this wrong? I'd say what you're doing is wrong. Taking away your nature of being an omnivore is something I'd consider wrong. You're trying to change nature by removing the "survival of the fittest" principle (which is a key feature to nature). Bringing morals into this is just illogical, as Spock would say.
it's been 4 months. Did it happen yet?
ummm...i dont think rich people back in the day had this equipment😞
So happy that the sturgeons don't get killed. they just harvest the eggs.
Imagine falling into that tank with the grown fish
_In an alternate dimension where fish are the dominant species:_ "Oh boi, I can't wait eat these *human babies!* ".
Human eggs you mean....
this just proves my point, caviar is disgusting.
+flukes777 Can I come?
Pussy
Sebastian Björck your life is disgusting
KingGotCash_ LMAO
No,caviar is beautiful and tasteful,what makes you think that its disgusting?
Looks like a perfect place for a Caviar farmer
id love to take a month off and visit this plant or any similar. that filtering system was amazing and the molasses injection is so smart :). They must have so many tanks if they cycle out fish every 12 years to keep up with demand. so cool !
They never mentioned how they seperate the males from female fish! lol I bet there are alot of fish wasting room in the tanks that dont produce eggs!
only females in the holding tanks
I'm sure they would check and separate. Males would then go to be processed and turned into fishsticks or however people eat sturgeons.
Yoachan More likely to be turned into the "high protein pellets".
"Harvest" the ovaries. That's how sick we are.
all meat is like this it’s just some looks more different
Go bitch about how chicken are killed for their legs on a chicken drumstick recipe vegan
How exactly is it more sustainable to farm it rather than catch it wild (as this video keeps saying) They literally are condensed into small pool areas for years before being taken and having their ovaries taken. So much energy and resources are used to keep the pools at certain temperatures, remove toxins, and feed them.
Because they would all be used to quickly, and go extinct.
Matthew Eschuk The extinction part yes saves their species to continue on, but you're giving inhumane conditions to these animals in the process.
+Danny B how is it inhumane? you said yourself a lot of effort goes into making sure water conditions are just right so I'm genuinely wondering how these conditions are inhumane
your dumb as fuck
At 1:58 she says "at 5 to 7 years...". I watched a video entitled 'Gordon Ramsey Caviar' and they were farming caviar in Andalusia, Spain. They very clearly stated that their caviar was taken at 18 to sometimes 20 years old. Why? Is the Spanish caviar more mature and better? More of it?
Also, the Spanish caviar farm was almost entirely outdoors. I bet that caviar is far more expensive than the kind seen here. But, who knows?
is it a different species of fish?
if so thats probably why
*****
I thought about that Jordan and I believe you're right. The fish looked the same to me, but of course that means very little.
This was very informative I learned a lot about farmed caviar
"No wild animals were harmed in the process" or some shit like that but obviously that's a lie they have to cut open the fish and cut the ovaries out for consumption and they're not gonna' sow the fish back up and let them live and keep feeding them that's a waste of money for them damn bastard
i think you may be right for the most part but there really weren't any wild fish killed. the fishes were farmed, and they made caviar from those fishes.. they didn't go out to catch wild fish in order to make the carviar
The fish were farmed for the purpose of producing caviar, so they aren't wild. After they remove the ovaries, they cut up the rest of the fish and sell it as meat, so that nothing goes to waste. And the fish die in their sleep before they get their ovaries removed, so it's humane. And it's not "sow" it's "sew". Unless, you were talking about distributing seeds.
do they kill all those fish just for people to eat the eggs....
No.
Then what do they do it for....
The video states that they are used for their eggs and their meat...
here, let me explain it. they cut open a female fish's stomach, then take the eggs. what do they do to the dead mother.
Just as I said, and the video stated, they use the eggs and the meat. So that means they process the rest of the fish also, not just the eggs.
kind of evil when you think about it :(
+roma lauren Nah mate it's just nature.
You got a problem with it bring the shit up with nature.
Haze Stratos i was talking about the fish harvesting in itself...fish farming aint nature
roma lauren i'm not sure if you've noticed.
But humans are a product of nature.
Everything they do is natural and a part of nature.
And no, we're not the only animal that will use other animals to our own ends. If you think THIS video is bad you don't know what a mud wasp is.
+Haze Stratos hero
U look gay
Well, I don´t approve this but.. there is a silver lining if you want to see it.. this way of getting the eggs is less aggressive against the wild Salmon and can help if needed to increase the endangered species too... yeah its better if the live in the wild, but, nowadays wilderness is a luxury some animals cant have :(
I really am happy all these different seafoods and fish can now be farmed. Wild does taste a little bit better and is better for you but almost every fish is overfished and extremely hard to get. This can cause a massive price increase for something that will become less and less sustainable due to the price. Farming is for sure the better option.