Folk music from Scotland - Ye Jacobites by name

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 авг 2024
  • #scottish #folkmusic #aranyzoltan
    / arany-zolt%c3%a1n-musi...
    aranyzoltan.hu/

Комментарии • 305

  • @LowSkillSurvival
    @LowSkillSurvival 2 года назад +26

    "Arany Zoltan"
    Then you know it's great.

  • @federicalosi5051
    @federicalosi5051 3 года назад +20

    So beautiful melody, song and beautiful places, animal and natures 👍👍👍🎶🎵🎼

  • @user-vt3me2ms8b
    @user-vt3me2ms8b 4 года назад +100

    Hello, I am your music fan living in Korea. I've been interested in folk music for a long time, and I've heard many songs, but you're the first person to sing the characteristics of folk songs by country. It's great to be able to feel the peculiarities of each country in folk songs, and it's also influenced by my imagination. Thanks to you, I listen to your music yesterday and today😄

    • @wonjubhoy
      @wonjubhoy 3 года назад +15

      Annyong ha say yoe! I am from Scotland and I lived in Korea from 2003 to 2005. I knew a Korean woman from Seoul called sunju who married a Scotsman. She teaches foreigners Korean. When i was in korea the Koreans would tell me of their discomfort with American soldiers in Korea and being too closely identified with America. I told them the last time Scotland was independent Scotland relied on the french for protection. Like korea scotland was a mountainous country on the margins of her own continent with a powerful neighbour and needing a strong foreign ally.

    • @JollyRoger1775
      @JollyRoger1775 2 года назад +2

      Hello! It is surprising that in Korea they are fond of European folk.

    • @JollyRoger1775
      @JollyRoger1775 2 года назад +2

      @@wonjubhoy my first love was a Korean girl 😁

    • @hondacbrification
      @hondacbrification 2 года назад +1

      @@JollyRoger1775 GaL moved between PortuGaL,BenGaL and MonGolia and connected Iberian with CaucaSIAN Iberian Kingdom and Siberia and none of them called themselves Evropean at all but like our Hungarian ancestors called themselves ManGAL,AVár,ALán,MagYar,MacAr,MakAr…Where there where Korean who joined the call of Kuria,Huria or KUrultai have some called not to be Evropean but simply to take part in a tribal gathering where they ancestors did belong.

    • @CraigYoung-gz3ml
      @CraigYoung-gz3ml Месяц назад

      There are many Scottish battle and folk tunes and songs for you to get into 👍 My football team in Scotland, Glasgow Celtic have a Korean player Oh Hyeon-gyu you should check them out if you like football 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇰🇷

  • @milvache
    @milvache 10 лет назад +9

    Beautiful scottish folk music, just as the Scottish people. They will never betray you and stand by your side ad belive in you, even when you at times fail to belive in yourself.

  • @TheRaksya
    @TheRaksya 9 лет назад +55

    great song!greetings from Siberia

  • @RaggaR28
    @RaggaR28 11 лет назад +38

    Scotland, the best music in the world!!!

  • @Ashling92734
    @Ashling92734 5 лет назад +29

    I love your music, Arany. It's out of our times and it's perfect. It places me in unknown lands.

  • @Londonfogey
    @Londonfogey 3 года назад +51

    Very nice. Scotland and Hungary have historic links dating back to Saint Margaret, Queen of Scotland (born in Hungary). There is also a Church of Scotland in Budapest (built for the Scottish workers on the Chain Bridge in the 1840s) and the Anglican (Episcopal) church in Budapest is also named after St Margaret of Scotland. There is also a very good Scottish pub in Budapest called the Caledonia.

    • @makoado6010
      @makoado6010 2 года назад +2

      actually celtics peoples live in a karpatian bashin before attila and used as broder guards. there is still many celtic motif in a hungarian folk music.

    • @ahad1609
      @ahad1609 2 года назад

      @@makoado6010 Well in the Southern part of Pannonia which is hungary Illyrians/Albanians lived and in the norther Celtic people and later Germanic tribes moved to Austria. Also the Scordisci lived south of Pannonia and north of Modern Kosovo, before they got pushed out and killed together with their Illyrians bretheren by Serbian Slavs.

  • @nelsun95
    @nelsun95 13 лет назад +12

    I love this music... It's so... magical, unique, sweet, original, cool... It makes my heart warmer.

  • @aestpunk4
    @aestpunk4 11 лет назад +32

    Fantasztikus!:) Nagyon meglepődtem, ahogy rábukkantam erre a dalra, főleg látva, hogy magyar kézből való. Gratulálok!:)

  • @ionescuion1215
    @ionescuion1215 3 года назад +4

    Ez is egy gyönyörű zene.
    Gratulálok ismét Arany Zoltán.

  • @elayneyoung1837
    @elayneyoung1837 7 лет назад +15

    Best version I've heard ...love your music

  • @juandediossantacruzmiranda8867
    @juandediossantacruzmiranda8867 2 года назад +11

    Highlands !

  • @adelemarieish
    @adelemarieish 8 лет назад +21

    A great version of this song.

  • @HarryPotter-pw9xw
    @HarryPotter-pw9xw 5 лет назад +96

    LYRICS
    Ye Jacobites by name lend an ear, lend an ear
    Ye Jacobites by name lend an ear
    Ye Jacobites by name your faults I will proclaim
    Your doctrines I must blame, you shall hear, you shall hear
    Your doctrines I must blame, you shall hear.
    What is right and what is wrong by the law, by the law
    What is right and what is wrong by the law
    What is right and what is wrong, a short sword and a long
    A weak arm and a strong for to draw, for to draw for to draw
    A weak arm and a strong for to draw.
    Ye Jacobites by name lend an ear, lend an ear
    Ye Jacobites by name lend an ear
    Ye Jacobites by name your faults I will proclaim
    Your doctrines I must blame, you shall hear, you shall hear
    Your doctrines I must blame, you shall hear.
    What makes heroic strife famed afar, famed afar?
    What makes heroic strife famed afar?
    What makes heroic strife, to whet the assassin's knife
    Or hunt a parent's life with bloody war, bloody war
    Or hunt a parent's life with bloody war.
    Ye Jacobites by name lend an ear, lend an ear
    Ye Jacobites by name lend an ear
    Ye Jacobites by name your faults I will proclaim
    Your doctrines I must blame, you shall hear, you shall hear
    Your doctrines I must blame, you shall hear.
    Then leave your schemes alone in the state, in the state
    Then leave your schemes alone in the state
    Then leave your schemes alone, adore the rising sun
    And leave a man alone to his fate, to his fate
    Oh leave a man alone to his fate.
    Ye Jacobites by name lend an ear, lend an ear
    Ye Jacobites by name lend an ear
    Ye Jacobites by name your faults I will proclaim
    Your doctrines I must blame, you shall hear, you shall hear
    Your doctrines I must blame, you shall hear.

    • @Phobos1483
      @Phobos1483 3 года назад

      Not entirely correct. Peasants lives are hunted by their bloody wars. Not parents lives.

    • @Schwarzvogel1
      @Schwarzvogel1 3 года назад +12

      @@Phobos1483 Both of you are slightly incorrect. The line says, "to *haunt* the parent's life (not hunt). War haunts parents' lives because in peacetime, sons bury their fathers, but in wartime, fathers bury their sons. It is young men who fight and die in war.
      Also, peasants have children as well... and their sons got slaughtered like flies in those wars.

    • @froggystyle642
      @froggystyle642 2 года назад +3

      Cheers Harry. By the way, you're a wizard.

    • @froggystyle642
      @froggystyle642 2 года назад +1

      @@Schwarzvogel1 You are both fuds. Make of a poem what you will, instead of analysing it for everyone else's "benefit". I have my interpretation, you have yours.

  • @ilyairick2448
    @ilyairick2448 6 лет назад +4

    I love this song

  • @PalestinianOrthodox1846
    @PalestinianOrthodox1846 3 года назад +10

    Greetings from Ireland

  • @atlantascot3432
    @atlantascot3432 11 лет назад +9

    If you listen to the words carefully, you will hear it is an anti-Jacobite song. The battle of Culloden was the climax of the Jacobite uprising of 1746. By that time Scotland and England had united to form Great Britain and the battle was about who would be king of Great Britain - the Stuarts or the Hanoverians. It was not about political independence.

    • @maximilianolimamoreira5002
      @maximilianolimamoreira5002 3 года назад +1

      yeah,but it's said some Jacobites had independent Scotland in mind,though,it was a minority within the movement

  • @truefalse207
    @truefalse207 11 лет назад +4

    Nearly everyone outside the British Isles think England/UK/Britain are all the same thing and when you tell them Scotland is part of the UK/Britain they get confused and start asking if it's also part of England. Britishness also means different things in different parts of the UK, ask a protestant Scot or Northern Irishman what Britishness means they'll tell you the completely opposite from someone who is Welsh or English.

  • @Fortune66
    @Fortune66 8 лет назад +36

    I've heard Zoltan singing this in Kosice, it was totally awesome ! :)

    • @ferim.4186
      @ferim.4186 7 лет назад +5

      Don't hurt Zoltán. The "kosice" ' original/hungarian name is Kassa.

    • @erikkollar66
      @erikkollar66 5 лет назад +9

      @@ferim.4186 That is wrong. Original name was Villa Cassa. Later it was called simply Cassovia. The historical name is irrelevant in this matter anyway. Zoltán was in Košice because that is it's current name. We aren't calling Istanbul Byzantium or London Londinium. Grow up.

    • @ferim.4186
      @ferim.4186 5 лет назад +4

      No, the greek people and othet really christian didn't call istambul, but also constantinopolis. :) Villa Cassia. ::D is this the newest slovakian chauvinist "fakestory". :)? Kassa('s place) were not pannonia/roman empire. :D And grow up you. i believe difficult to process "Slovakia" don' t exist the history but try you.

    • @erikkollar66
      @erikkollar66 5 лет назад +1

      @@ferim.4186 Maybe firstly learn English before you want to debate something.

    • @ferim.4186
      @ferim.4186 5 лет назад +4

      @@erikkollar66 if you have a problem with my english, you can' t answer me. :) Formallogic and intelligence, if you want for me...😉 but show me please the history map, where i can find "villa cassa" and "slovakia"..😁

  • @SoupMistro
    @SoupMistro 11 лет назад +9

    This is amazing! I just stumbled across it, and have just kept playing it over again. Good job Zoltan!

  • @MaryOHara
    @MaryOHara Год назад +3

    Nagyon szép.

  • @josephdodd5770
    @josephdodd5770 5 лет назад +2

    Love this wonderful song and singer and band

  • @Epsillion70
    @Epsillion70 8 лет назад +16

    I am a MacKenzie Aye !!!

  • @noddypopable
    @noddypopable 7 лет назад +3

    tapadh leabh arany zoltan. you captured that song more perfectly than I've heard. I'm in love 💖

  • @lunicola8037
    @lunicola8037 9 лет назад +7

    Beautiful pictures, Mr Arany. My compliments also on your versatility.

  • @DrakeMonroe
    @DrakeMonroe 3 года назад +6

    03:28 IMO, represents Fowlis Castle, home of the Munro Chiefs, which was burned out by Jacobite Rebels in 1745.

  • @euridicesacramentomariani6953
    @euridicesacramentomariani6953 4 года назад +2

    Wonderful! Thank you!

  • @Birsa88
    @Birsa88 4 года назад +39

    Translation of a song into russian language:
    Якобиты на словах,
    Вам пою, вам пою.
    Якобиты на словах,
    Вам пою.
    Якобиты на словах,
    Обличу я вас в грехах
    И ученье ваше в прах
    Разобью.
    Что есть правда? Что есть ложь?
    Где закон? Где закон?
    Что есть правда? Что есть ложь?
    Где закон?
    Что есть правда? Что есть ложь?
    Длинный меч ли изберешь
    Иль короткий вырвешь нож
    Из ножон?
    Героической борьбой
    Что назвать? Что назвать?
    Героической борьбой
    Что назвать?
    Героической борьбой
    Звать ли распри и разбой,
    Где в отца готов любой
    Нож вогнать?
    Хватит происков, ей-ей!
    В этот век, в этот век.
    Хватит происков, ей-ей,
    В этот век.
    Хватит происков, ей-ей.
    Без непрошеных друзей
    Пусть идет к судьбе своей
    Человек!

    • @viewerontube
      @viewerontube 3 года назад +4

      Перевод Самуила Маршака стихов Бернса

    • @tolikhab8280
      @tolikhab8280 3 года назад +3

      @@viewerontube верно)

    • @FortitudeInMorale2316
      @FortitudeInMorale2316 2 года назад +2

      Much love to Russian brothers and sisters. Not everyone hates you

  • @louiewolffreeman8036
    @louiewolffreeman8036 5 лет назад +2

    purely beautiful

  • @nannybooboo7380
    @nannybooboo7380 9 лет назад +29

    Beautiful

    • @nannybooboo7380
      @nannybooboo7380 9 лет назад

      Thank you Alaa 😃😃😃😃😃💃🎵🎵🎵🎻🎶🎵🎺🎺🎵🎧

    • @nannybooboo7380
      @nannybooboo7380 9 лет назад

      Ty marieanna. Ty man man. 😃😃😃😃😃😃

    • @nannybooboo7380
      @nannybooboo7380 9 лет назад

      Ty calvin. Ty all. Good night 🌜🌠🌛⭐⭐⭐⭐

    • @GeorgeMillerSr
      @GeorgeMillerSr 9 лет назад

      sorry was bad mood

    • @nannybooboo7380
      @nannybooboo7380 9 лет назад

      George Miller Sr everything thats what

  • @EliteHalo5
    @EliteHalo5 9 лет назад +6

    Great track!

  • @noddypopable
    @noddypopable 10 лет назад +2

    For Lucas There is a ballad for MacDonalds ( my family are a sept of 3 including macdonalds) it is the massacre of glencoe. The corries have sang it, a canadian band The real MacKenzies cheered the solemn song up mixing it with punk and bagpipes. X

  • @ahmedtoufik3302
    @ahmedtoufik3302 8 лет назад +3

    beautiful rythme

  • @noddypopable
    @noddypopable 10 лет назад +3

    For lucas, The Corries are a scottish band who sing plenty jacobite songs. You will probably recognize them. X

  • @ErikaMaria-lw8en
    @ErikaMaria-lw8en 6 лет назад +2

    Kosonom sepan from Australia xx

    • @Techn1kal
      @Techn1kal 5 лет назад

      *Köszönöm szépen
      it's not a problem if you can't write in hungarian, but at least look it up first, or just don't bother

  • @josephdodd5770
    @josephdodd5770 6 лет назад +2

    This is great

  • @RafikiSykes
    @RafikiSykes 10 лет назад +10

    to all you who say "stuart" already replied to one guy correcting him on this its Stewart. Stuart is English.

    • @jajanesaddictions
      @jajanesaddictions 10 лет назад

      yes, they call it being "anglicised". meaning the "angles" or English changed it around so they could more easily spell it and pronounce it. just like they did to thousands of people's names at Ellis Island. all the same stock, if you get my drift.

    • @joekerr9197
      @joekerr9197 9 лет назад +5

      Stuart is actually the French variant of Stewart. It originates from 100-years war when the Scottish participated on the French side. It was then brought back to Scotland and used as such.

    • @scottishnarrator8005
      @scottishnarrator8005 3 года назад

      French. But the English started using it. Just so you are clear in yer heed, Nat.

    • @twentytwo138
      @twentytwo138 3 года назад

      S2art

  • @RoyalGiraffe
    @RoyalGiraffe 3 года назад +4

    Can you do a recording of the full version? I don't think any exists on YT.
    You Jacobites by Name, now give Ear, now give Ear,
    You Jacobites by Name, now give Ear;
    You Jacobites by Name, your Praise I will proclaim,
    Some says you are to blame for this Wear.
    With the Pope you covenant, as they say, as they say,
    With the Pope you covenant, as they say,
    With the Pope you covenant, and Letters there you sent,
    Which made your Prince present to array.
    Your Prince and Duke o'Perth, where they go, where they go,
    Your Prince and Duke o'Perth, where they go,
    Your Prince and Duke o'Perth, they're Cumb'rers o' the Earth,
    Causing great Hunger and Dearth where they go.
    He is the King of Reef, I'll declare, I'll declare,
    He is the King of Reef, I'll declare,
    He is the King of Reef, of a Robber and o' Thief,
    To rest void of Relief when he's near.
    They marched thro' our Land cruelly, cruelly,
    They marched thro' our Land cruelly,
    They marched thro' our Land with a bloody thievish Band
    To Edinburgh then they wan Treachery.
    To Preston then they came, in a Rout, in a Rout,
    To Preston then they came, in a Rout;
    To Preston then they came, brave Gard'ner murd'red then.
    A Traitor did command, as we doubt.
    To England then they went, as bold, as bold,
    To England then they went, as bold;
    To England then they went, and Carlisle they ta'en't,
    The Crown they fain would ha'en't, but behold.
    To London as they went, on the Way, on the Way,
    To London as they went, on the way,
    To London as they went, in a Trap did there present,
    No battle they will stent, for to die.
    They turned from that Place, and they ran, and they ran,
    They turned from that Place, and they ran;
    They turned from that Place as the Fox, when Hounds do chace.
    They tremble at the Name, CUMBERLAN'.
    To Scotland then they came, when they fly, when they fly,
    To Scotland then they came, when they fly,
    To Scotland then they came, and they robb'd on every Hand,
    By Jacobites Command, where they ly.
    When Duke William does command, you must go, you must go;
    When Duke William does command, you must go;
    When Duke William does command, then you must leave the Land,
    Your Conscience in your Hand like a Crow.
    Tho' Carlisle ye took by the Way, by the Way;
    Tho' Carlisle ye took by the Way;
    Tho' Carlisle ye took, short Space ye did it Brook,
    These Rebels got a Rope on a Day.
    The Pope and Prelacy, where they came, where they came,
    The Pope and Prelacy, where they came;
    The Pope and Prelacy, they rul'd with Cruelty,
    They ought to hing on high for the same.

  • @alanbrown1039
    @alanbrown1039 Год назад +3

    just a history lesson gealic is my heritage

  • @TagmaCL
    @TagmaCL 8 лет назад +58

    Hello. I'm studying journalism at Alberto Hurtado University from Chile. We are making a documental film about Highlands Games in Chile. Can we use your song "Folk music from Scotland - Ye Jacobites by name - by Arany Zoltán" on our documental? Withou lucrative way obviously. Greetings

    •  8 лет назад +28

      Would you write to me in private please! arany.zoltan@yahoo.com

  • @JorgePueyo95
    @JorgePueyo95 11 лет назад +4

    Awesome music! It reminds me the music from Aragón, that country between France and Spain ;) thanks for that music!

    • @jakublubocki7998
      @jakublubocki7998 2 года назад +1

      ⚫🟡Aragòniô nie je krajã midzë Francëją, a Szpaniama. Królestwò Aragònië je dzélã Szpaniów.
      🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿Aragón isn't a country between France and Spains. Kingdom of Aragón is a part of Spains.

    • @danielchristiansteinkellne6214
      @danielchristiansteinkellne6214 4 месяца назад

      Sim mas foi um reino que se uniu a Castela formando a união ibérica junto com os outros reinos espanhóis de Galícia e Navarra ( bascos) entre outras regiões como Andaluzia apenas Portugal ( Lusitânia) se salvou da anexação definitiva formando um país independente graças a Deus....Deus vult

  • @gartnait1
    @gartnait1 11 лет назад +3

    your right about the tribes moving around-just liked the idea of the egyptian link

  • @cheerydavie
    @cheerydavie 15 лет назад +2

    One of the very best versions ive heard

  • @axelfalk1
    @axelfalk1 10 лет назад +12

    Actually Highland 'clans' (the very term is dubious!) were also split - Campbells for example were strongly pro-Hanoverian. The political (as opposed to personal) Union came about because a) Scotland was bankrupt and b) most Protestant Scots were wary of their Catholic compatriots, and feared a Catholic monarch. I speak as one who had (mercenary) ancestors who fought for Stuart and for Hanover.

    • @RafikiSykes
      @RafikiSykes 10 лет назад +1

      its Stewart. Stuart is English mate

    • @axelfalk1
      @axelfalk1 10 лет назад +4

      Ally Stewart Stuart is French actually - Stewart is English from Steward - Oliver Cromwell's mother was a member of that particular Anglo-Saxon 'clan' (the word 'clan' of course derives ultimately from the Latin stamma, like the German Stamm which has a similar meaning - whatever: the whole concept is bogus 19th century codswallop).By the way, if you wish to be pedantic one could refer to the dynasty as Stiùbhard - which is a Gaelicisation of an English name.

    • @andrewwigglesworth3030
      @andrewwigglesworth3030 3 года назад +1

      @@axelfalk1 The clan system in Scotland was an early modern development, it's not some ancient "celtic" inheritance.

    • @patpearce8221
      @patpearce8221 10 месяцев назад

      😂this is a rewriting of history...
      The political union came about :
      a) To commonly exploit North America.
      b) Scottish opponents were suppressed by Hanoverian agents.
      Very much doubt that the Scots at the start of the 17th century would have voted for it without extra legal assassinations and promise of North America 🌎

  • @strubbeljuergen
    @strubbeljuergen 15 лет назад +1

    Great thanks for upload.
    greetings from a scout out Germany

  • @noddypopable
    @noddypopable 10 лет назад +2

    I noticed folk commenting on norse connections. The scottish isles were taken by the norse until king alexander claimed them back. Macdonalds have norse blood, mind macdonalds lord of the isles.

  • @madscally1
    @madscally1 14 лет назад +1

    this song still stirs the hackles

  • @martyfan11agnosticalienfan
    @martyfan11agnosticalienfan 13 лет назад +1

    @sputtttnik
    I was at Celtic Connections earlier this year but for Marty Stuart, and some of the stuff that he does on the guitar and mandolin are originally scottish tunes but bluegrassified by Bill Monroe and the likes.

  • @YannM
    @YannM 12 лет назад +6

    Jacobites are the real Kings of Scotland ! Long live France and Scotland, long live THE AULD ALLIANCE !

    • @l0gan359
      @l0gan359 4 года назад +7

      This song is anti Jacobite

  • @fumpfi
    @fumpfi 15 лет назад +1

    Great song! Greez from a girlscout from Germany =)

  • @gaconnochie
    @gaconnochie 13 лет назад +2

    Fergus. Many Scottish historians now question that. There is absolutely no evidence of any mass movemenet and certainly no evidence of mass displacement of original Britons in Argyl. Some claim that it is probably that there was no significant coming over from Ireland (bar Fergus moving his centre) and that the Epidii of the area were possibly already Gaels. In other words it is possible that the seaboard area was already a pan-Gaelic cultural area and that there was no need for mass movements

  • @barbiebarbue47
    @barbiebarbue47 11 лет назад +2

    iam french and... british, i wont argue with u, no need u just made me laugh

  • @reflective_lights
    @reflective_lights Год назад +1

    "The scots are a mad people. All their wars are merry, and all their songs are sad."

  • @mfjdv2020
    @mfjdv2020 14 лет назад +1

    Long live the King over the water!!!

  • @albinotatertot
    @albinotatertot 10 лет назад +7

    Clan Keith! Veritas Vincit!

  • @markcargill9734
    @markcargill9734 2 года назад +1

    Aye.

  • @noddypopable
    @noddypopable 10 лет назад

    Love the wee pic of castle stalker at the end x

  • @markcargill9734
    @markcargill9734 2 года назад +1

    Mee Coo

  • @Marsali1984
    @Marsali1984 13 лет назад +1

    ♥♥♥ SCOTLAND 4 EVER ♥♥♥

  • @macpduff2119
    @macpduff2119 2 года назад +2

    My genealogy research and DNA tests show that I am a straight descendant from The Skye MacPhersons, - official Pipers to The MacPherson Clan Chiefs. My grandfather was born into a Scots Gallic speaking home on Cluny MacPherson's Estate. His father Malcolm MacPherson was official Piper. The position of official Piper was handed down thru the family, father to son.

  • @Thefootofthetree
    @Thefootofthetree 13 лет назад +2

    so proud tae be cottish

  • @raimhol
    @raimhol 14 лет назад +1

    Minden elismerésem!

  • @captaincallum24
    @captaincallum24 10 лет назад +41

    you realise the original of this song was written by the victorious whig forces after the '45 and that Robert burns rewrote it to have an anti-war message? nothing about Scottish independence or freedom

    • @Jc-ul9ff
      @Jc-ul9ff 4 года назад +13

      It's not an anti war song it's an anti Stewart/anti monarchy song

    • @parmindersingh885
      @parmindersingh885 3 года назад +2

      really
      !!!!! some one said this the best scottish rebel song

    • @victoriapennyblythe7479
      @victoriapennyblythe7479 3 года назад +2

      @@Jc-ul9ff Both versions are anti-Jacobite.

    • @victoriapennyblythe7479
      @victoriapennyblythe7479 3 года назад

      @@thehistorystudio1227
      Exactly what I am saying. This is a *Whig* song, why ask me _as if_ I am saying this song is pro-Jacobite?

    • @leonmcnair4615
      @leonmcnair4615 2 года назад

      You are correct, against what the others are saying. Robert Burns did indeed tweak the original lyrics in 1791 to have a more humanitarian view against war. His intention on the song itself, whether as an anti-Jacobite or not is ambiguous in itself, but Burns was a complex fellow. He saw both sides, and entrenched himself on both sides of the camp.
      With all that said, one thing is absolutely clear. He was a patriot.

  • @demdave24
    @demdave24 14 лет назад

    wow! Szuper!

  • @Marsali1984
    @Marsali1984 14 лет назад +1

    i love scotland

  • @noddypopable
    @noddypopable 10 лет назад

    If Arany Zoltan could update these and give a blow like this tune it would be phenomenal !

  • @SavePuppiesNow
    @SavePuppiesNow 8 лет назад

    I love the Coo. :)

  • @vampirekisses95
    @vampirekisses95 11 лет назад +3

    You're music is amazing! It's some of the best I've found so far. Can I order your CD to the U.S?

  • @elayneyoung1837
    @elayneyoung1837 7 лет назад +1

    proud to be scottish

  • @gaconnochie
    @gaconnochie 13 лет назад +1

    from Ireland. In truth we don't actually know. We do know that the base of our (Scottish) ancestry comes from the inhabitants of Scotland though and not anywhere else. Though there have been many influxes including Irish, Anglians, Norse, Flemish, English, Normans plus of course all the later arrivals.

  • @gaconnochie
    @gaconnochie 13 лет назад +2

    @halifaxtanning Of course there are similarities (we are neighbours) and of course people have moved. Especially Scots moving to Ulster in the 17thC and mass Irish immigration to Scotland at a later date. The fact remains though there is no hard arcaheological evidence for a mass movement from Ireland to Argyl in 500AD or there abouts.

  • @upyr1
    @upyr1 13 лет назад +1

    @gun220 The Scots did not have Ilrian roots the Celts did live that far east for ecample the City of Galatia was built after the Celts migrated into the area. The Celts were called the Gaels if they lived in the British Isles and Gauls if they lived on Contental Europe. The Ilirians from my understanding where there before the Celts entered the area from western europe.

  • @pashedmotatos
    @pashedmotatos 11 лет назад +1

    neat

  • @lucasdelaguila1202
    @lucasdelaguila1202 10 лет назад +8

    Hey, i love it, but i want to ask you for something, can you upload a MacDonald's clan himn please? I'm a MacDonald clan member and I'd love it.

  • @RenneAtha
    @RenneAtha 11 лет назад

    You, sir, win the internets.

  • @AnthropoidOne
    @AnthropoidOne 9 лет назад +6

    Willie nae come back to us, Bonnie Charlie?

  • @MignonJuju
    @MignonJuju 13 лет назад +1

    Alba gu brath! (Scotland Forever!)

  • @LunarFlower
    @LunarFlower 12 лет назад +1

    I love all your folk music!! I am buying your CDs! Are you on iTunes? When are you going on tour?

  • @EliteHalo5
    @EliteHalo5 6 лет назад +1

    devon aye!

  • @cooljuan4728
    @cooljuan4728 4 года назад +2

    My ancestors were Jacobites, some of them , and this sounds to me as though it is written against them not for them.

    • @terralp2062
      @terralp2062 3 года назад +4

      It is. And its good that you noticed that.

  • @wilderenss24
    @wilderenss24 11 лет назад +1

    congrats, really nice piece
    do you have others like this?

  • @doodmonkey
    @doodmonkey 9 месяцев назад +4

    I hope Scotland can find independence from England. Rejoin the Union!

  • @fritzliburli8470
    @fritzliburli8470 9 лет назад +4

    Beautyfull song, land and people. Regarding history and nowadays... : Who should be more ashamed? Redskirts or voters, for havig missed the one and only change to separate and get free. Time'll tell, ey!

    • @gartnait1
      @gartnait1 8 лет назад

      +Fritzli bürli I voted yes to a sovereign Scotland but also think the UK is a stable unit compared to most other countries.The policies of the current government will change the views of some people who voted no.Probably enough to make an independant Scotland a reality in the near future.

    • @fritzliburli8470
      @fritzliburli8470 8 лет назад

      +gartnait1 A free and sovereign stable state, combined with an appropriate policy, should be wished to the all Scots and their whole country. Perhaps we should make a similar wish to every single citizen - in the rest of s.o.'s private registered continent as futher colony... Folk to the polls.pls. ! Ay.

    • @alistairthompson8311
      @alistairthompson8311 8 лет назад +1

      +Fritzli bürli What's a redskirt?

    • @alistairthompson8311
      @alistairthompson8311 8 лет назад +1

      Apemanwithcalculator Well, that's generally what armies are for, yes, sad fact of life as it is.
      They actually wear camo these days I hear! And before that they wore khaki. They haven't worn red except for the Queen's birthday & other special occasions for a very long time.

    • @snippsnapp123
      @snippsnapp123 7 лет назад

      And what about now, mates? Many things have changed since the last referendum, would you like to see a new one? I think the odds might be in the favour of and independent Scotland now.

  • @mfjdv2020
    @mfjdv2020 14 лет назад +2

    Actually we Gaels and Brythons are supposed to be related to the Turks and the Hungarians :-). Thank you for posting and for your interest in our culture.

    • @suleymantaskn5065
      @suleymantaskn5065 Год назад

      How can be that possible, I mean to the Turks specifically? Could you explain a bit?

  • @FirstFallSnow
    @FirstFallSnow 12 лет назад

    @svarunnavi Just google it-it's a pretty easy to find it like that. Or look up the original poem.

  • @Druidenhaus
    @Druidenhaus 13 лет назад

    well done!

  • @patrickhughes1790
    @patrickhughes1790 10 лет назад +13

    Oh ye Thatcherites by name, we see you!

  • @FelixFelisis
    @FelixFelisis 12 лет назад +1

    This makes me want to eat some Walkers cookies.

  • @janhajahmad8678
    @janhajahmad8678 8 лет назад

    like it

  • @uptonsavoie
    @uptonsavoie 13 лет назад +1

    One of the very few songs from the whig/hanoverian/williamite viewpoint. Even the Queen's piper bands play Jacobite tunes today. Of course, Queen Victoria claimed to be a Jacobite....

  • @noddypopable
    @noddypopable 10 лет назад

    The skye boat song tells ( not mentioning dear flora) how bonnie prince charlie was sailed to skye disguised as a maiden by flora macdonald to aid his escape from scotland after culloden.

  • @MEHRLICH86
    @MEHRLICH86 3 месяца назад

    Hey, i chumä ou vo Heiländs👍

  • @mrsuperger5429
    @mrsuperger5429 2 года назад +1

    Rule Britannia ! ❤

  • @truefalse207
    @truefalse207 11 лет назад +1

    Where in Scotland are you from?? Antrim lol??

  • @axelfalk1
    @axelfalk1 10 лет назад +1

    pps ar ndóigh, más mian amháin i ndáiríre a dhéanamh níos mó ar an gceist ar féidir le duine pointe ar an bhfíric gur shíl an Stuarts iad féin an Ghaeilge!

  • @sputtttnik
    @sputtttnik 13 лет назад

    @aranzoltan I will look forward to it! I am enjoying your celtic uploads very much.
    If you ever make it over to Scotland for any concerts let me know and I will make a video recording of your performance. Are you aware of the Celtic Connections festival in Glasgow? I once had the pleasure of seeing Kepa Junkera play at this festival.

  • @nancydelu4061
    @nancydelu4061 2 месяца назад

    As the grandkid and great grandkid of 2 Scots women, I would hear of longing for home. BUT, BUT it would end with talk of shoeleather! Scots don't waste shoeleather on women. In the USA, they do! That simple thing meant all the difference.

  • @jeannegrob
    @jeannegrob 13 лет назад +1

    And so is HIstory....

  • @Samuel20BH
    @Samuel20BH 7 лет назад +1

    Please, could you tell me the name of the 1:36 painting?