EEVblog 1553 - World's First Commercial Solar Power Station

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 сен 2024
  • Dave visits the world's first commercial solar power station in White Cliffs, a small opal mining town in outback Australia.
    Built in 1981 and using 14 heliostatic tracking 5m diameter dishes, this concentrated thermal solar plant produced 25kW of power using a steam generator.
    Links:
    en.wikipedia.o...
    Analysis report: eevblog.com/fi...
    Mirror efficiency data: www.nrel.gov/d...
    Heritage Listing: portal.enginee...
    History: ehive.com/coll...
    Steam genertor assesment: www.researchga...
    wiki.opensourc...
    Forum: www.eevblog.co...
    If you find my videos useful you may consider supporting the EEVblog on Patreon: / eevblog
    Or with crypto:
    BTC: 33BsprBQNBtHuVzVwDmqWkpDjYnCouwASM
    ETH: 0x68114e40ff4dcdd384750500501e20acf3875f8c
    BCH: 35n9KBPw9T7M3NGzpS3t4nUYEf9HbRmkm4
    USDC: 0x68114e40ff4dcdd384750500501e20acf3875f8c
    LTC: MJfK57ujxy55su4XicVGQc9wcEJf6mAoXF
    Web Site: www.eevblog.com
    Other channels:
    EEVblog2: / eevblog2
    EEVdiscover: / eevdiscover
    T-Shirts: teespring.com/s...
    #ElectronicsCreators #Solar #Tour

Комментарии • 339

  • @SeanBZA
    @SeanBZA Год назад +110

    Yes do more. Solar thermal is great for things that need heat, like sintering metal or doing smelting of ore, where you have lots of sunlight, but are far from ant fossil fuels to do it otherwise. So you can use that sort of large central tower to take the red ground, almost all of it being iron oxide from the greatest biological event in the history of the planet, the first oxygen releasing blue green algae evolving. Then turn it into ceramic blocks for building. But solar panels, lower temperature and easier to handle, also got better, leaving this as a relic, though the high temperature research did help in making the consumer panels better, as they also run hot, though with more sunlight into them you do get much better conversion efficiency.

    • @YounesLayachi
      @YounesLayachi Год назад +3

      Also cheaper and don't degrate under the sun since now the heat and UVs are not your enemy

    • @rehanb637
      @rehanb637 Год назад +3

      We can also store heat fairly easily and have been converting heat into electricity for a while now

    • @mehow357
      @mehow357 Год назад

      In Finland they made storing high heat (like +400 C or so, easy to google it) in the siloses filled with sand. Super cheap and efficient. Then the heat was taken back from those "heat banks".

    • @SeanBZA
      @SeanBZA Год назад +1

      @@mehow357 Yes, a way to store "low grade" heat, and then later on use it for things like heating a house, as otherwise it is too expensive to extract energy out of what is likely to be a low temperature differential.

    • @mehow357
      @mehow357 Год назад +2

      @@SeanBZA I don't remember how do they extract the heat back, but most probably you're right that they extract the heat to heat up homes. BUUUT, few years ago i was reading about the place where they heat up metal alloy that emits (in low Temps, definitely way below 1000C) some spectrum of light and optimized solar panels for those wavelengths. The efficiency of this system was enormously high as those panels were optimized, plus it was not in open space, but in special building where "lost" or bounced photons were "bounced back" again into panels. That was extremely interesting article.

  • @kjlovescoffee
    @kjlovescoffee Год назад +39

    Interestingly, the modern Concentrated Solar Power (CSP) plants have one huge advantage. They don't heat the water directly. Instead they heat molten salt, which adds as a heat battery and allow the plant to continue producing power well after sunset.

    • @matsv201
      @matsv201 Год назад

      Well, everything have a flip side, the back side of salt storage is that you lose heat gradient and there for efficency.

    • @OliverHamilton
      @OliverHamilton Год назад +6

      Although they can release the stored thermal energy after sunset, does this not create a lag at sunrise? The salt needs to get back up to temperature in the morning to reach efficient levels again. There's no free lunch.

    • @kjlovescoffee
      @kjlovescoffee Год назад +2

      @@OliverHamilton that’s a good question. I don’t know how much heat is retained through the night. But then, CSP today is not an alternative to PV. It’s complementary.

    • @OliverHamilton
      @OliverHamilton Год назад +2

      @@kjlovescoffee yeah it can help smooth out the output, being less variable to clouds etc. I think it can almost be thought of as analogous to the inertia of rotating mass in other power generation systems, a kind of thermal inertia.

    • @hariranormal5584
      @hariranormal5584 Год назад

      @@kjlovescoffee is a CSP more economical?

  • @Ladadadada
    @Ladadadada Год назад +9

    Amazing to see this again. I went to White Cliffs as a kid on a family holiday back when this was operational. I have a photo somewhere of the white-hot glowing coiled steam pipes. Yep, we were the sort of family that went to see an array of parabolic solar collectors when we were on holiday.

  • @Sabrinahuskydog
    @Sabrinahuskydog Год назад +19

    I wish you could of spoken with some town officials and orginze a tour of the insides along with some of the people who managed the facility still alive today. That would of made this video +5000% more amazing.

  • @microcolonel
    @microcolonel Год назад +15

    One quick thing: those things feeding into the fat arrow on the loss diagram are actually *gains* rather than losses, they are counting 7kW of free enthalpy from the feed water in the energy going to the Engine Room.

  • @spokehedz
    @spokehedz Год назад +14

    I love that I knew about this, because in school I was given an assignment to see if solar was viable anywhere in the world, and I used that town/installation as a source/example in my report! Glad to see the town is still using solar in some form all these years later.

  • @slypig24
    @slypig24 Год назад +17

    That was a instresting look at early Australia solar. More episodes like that please.

  • @nonna_sof5889
    @nonna_sof5889 Год назад +14

    I love the look of original configuration. Real sci-fi vibes.

  • @damingrail3655
    @damingrail3655 Год назад +28

    I worked on a project for some Sterling Solar dish project. They were Hydrogen Turbines. The project got scrapped cause the test plots they were running were under performing. It was a super cool concept. I would love to have seen the project come full circle.

    • @gildardo
      @gildardo Год назад +2

      I always fond sterling engines fascinating.

    • @iaadsi
      @iaadsi Год назад +3

      @@tripplefives1402 Stirling engine thermal dishes don't have piping, the whole engine is packaged into the dish head unit, right in the focal point. It's a membrane linear motor with a linear generator, basically a giant speaker with a few extras. One moving part only.
      But like you said PV won due to its simplicity and therefore (still) plummeting cost. Stirling engines are after all engines with lots of machining steps, the costs involved have a floor that we hit decades ago. Semiconductors are still finding that cost floor.

    • @vitordelima
      @vitordelima Год назад +1

      @@iaadsi Nah, if you need to power your whole home solar panels cost orders of magnitude more than solar heat. A big solar evacuated tube costs 50 dollars for example.

    • @iaadsi
      @iaadsi Год назад +1

      @@vitordelima were talking about electricity, not heat. The stirling engine plant makes electricity same as the OP video.

    • @vitordelima
      @vitordelima Год назад

      @@iaadsi You understood what I meant.

  • @molivil
    @molivil Год назад +21

    This was very interesting. I hope to see more real world examples of power distribution systems, and stuff talking about civil infrastructure. Your commentary was great.

  • @raystone4673
    @raystone4673 5 месяцев назад +1

    Ive never seen it, but spoke to Professor Kaneff at the Perth Solar Energy Congress in mid 1983. He was there talking to visitors about the technical details of the instsllation. I thought it was brilliant at the time, and wanted to make a small scale copy. They used high transmission glass for the cut mirrors, and i recall he mentioned a certsin Dow Corning silicon (which didn't hurt the backing) to glue the 4 corners of each mirror where they touched the curved fibreglass surface. He said they first made a smaller section of a parabolic sector on the mould, then attached mirrors, and tested it in full moonlight rather than the Sun for testing functionality. The mirrors were approx 100 mm each side, and the reflected light could focus on a spot not much bigger than that from memory. He had lots if photos of the construction steps. It was brilliant. From memory, the pistons in the converted motor, lifted the steam inlet valves off their seat at TDC, and there was a clever overflow method to remove lubricating oil from the surface of the condensed steam, which was recycled. I must go and see it one day if still there.
    Great video, thanks.

    • @FrainFreeze
      @FrainFreeze 17 дней назад

      amazing, thank you for sharing!!

  • @christianelzey9703
    @christianelzey9703 Год назад +8

    What an interesting system, thanks for sharing. Didn't realize a dish so small could create superheated steam!

    • @SeanBZA
      @SeanBZA Год назад

      Flow rate is your friend, keep it low enough and you can superheat steam to 500C easily, and then keep it dry for a good length in well insulated pipes.

  • @MrJugsstein
    @MrJugsstein Год назад

    There is a fantastic tour of the installation. Did it this year

  • @redsquirrelftw
    @redsquirrelftw Год назад +3

    That's really cool, always been intrigued at the idea of thermal solar as in a way it's simpler, ex: you could build this in a post apocalyptic setting with scrap stuff. PV cells, not so much. But never realized the efficiency was so low. I guess something like this would be better for actual heat but even then PV might still be better and also have less moving parts. No pumps etc.

  • @aatheus
    @aatheus Год назад

    Really neat view into a bit of solar history!

  • @robbennett2829
    @robbennett2829 Год назад +6

    Learning curves can take a long time. At least it was tried and things were learned.

    • @xiaoka
      @xiaoka Год назад +1

      and it actually worked!

    • @vitordelima
      @vitordelima Год назад

      @@xiaoka And it got constantly improved but the energy lobby didn't like it. SolarPACES is a web site with some examples of how far the technology went.

  • @ChrisBentle
    @ChrisBentle Год назад

    10:25 @davejones your boys are growing up fast! Nice family pic at the end. We are planning on a trip to Sydney and I think we’ll make a stop by White Cliffs to check that out since my boy wants to see the outback. Now I have an actual place to take him rather than roaming around out there! Thanks for the vid!

  • @GraemeHanigan
    @GraemeHanigan Год назад

    Hi Dave, It is open for inspection whenever we have volunteers available, but in such a small town they are in short supply.

  • @steveslater7885
    @steveslater7885 Год назад +3

    "All the dishes are now stowed in a position away from any sun."
    - Mainly just worried about the big one that's real close to us.
    🤗 Love the travel episodes.

  • @LJSpit
    @LJSpit Год назад

    I worked on the bigger brother of the White Cliffs Solar converted system. The bigger brother was a 100 square meter dish focusing into about a 350mm X 350mm water cooled high efficiency solar cell colleting head.
    There was only one built in Forster near Bendigo Australia,.

  • @slomotrainwreck
    @slomotrainwreck Год назад +2

    It's great to see the old tech! If you can do more of these types of videos please do! 👍

  • @NoLandMandi
    @NoLandMandi Год назад +9

    That was much Betterer than what I expected! Nice job!
    Also let him know, I subscribed from my work PC so he made me double a sub!

  • @tiitsaul9036
    @tiitsaul9036 Год назад +37

    One of these would make a nice domestic hot water generator.

    • @MeppyMan
      @MeppyMan Год назад +3

      I would have thought a modern solar panel running a modern heat pump electric hot water heater would be more efficient and you can use the grid when needed.

    • @teagueman100
      @teagueman100 Год назад +9

      Yeah it would be nice except solar PV is still better. I have a 4kw PV array that is directly connected to an ordinary electric 250L hot water tank. And it produces 90C hot water all year round. I originally had a evacuated tube solar hot water and it didn't perform well in winter at all. That's because concentrated solar or evacuated tubes require direct sun light where as PV can work well enough to produce boiling water even in diffuse light. My PV based hot water is the best thing I ever built. Its almost as if I have nuclear power providing my hot water lol.

    • @tiitsaul9036
      @tiitsaul9036 Год назад

      @@teagueman100 sounds like a good system. It's good idea to eliminate converting DC current to sine wave if not needed.

    • @isbestlizard
      @isbestlizard Год назад +2

      Not really - having to track the sun for the parabolic mirror to work is a nightmare. If all you're doing is heating water, just flow water through channels on a flat collector of equivalent area - in fact it could be used to cool a PV layer ON TOP to provide flat panels that both generate electricity AND use the waste heat to heat water.

    • @MechAnism820
      @MechAnism820 Год назад

      @@tiitsaul9036 DC is only good for short runs as the voltage is typically low and line losses are high. AC can be efficiently transformed to very high voltages which greatly reduce transmission line losses then transformed back to low usable voltages at the destination. The other advantage is the high voltage wires can be smaller diameter which reduces cost and weight.

  • @Peter_S_
    @Peter_S_ Год назад +4

    Was this first though? In 1981 the Solar One thermal demonstrator plant in the Mojave Desert in California was providing 10,000W into the Southern California Edison grid to power the little town of Daggett, California and they ran power generation 24 hours a day using heat stored in a giant tank of granite boulders in an oil bath. That plant was the prototype for the central tower type solar thermal plants used today. I got an inside tour of the plant in 1981 with an employee and I recall pictures of the building of White Cliffs at the time.

    • @EEVblog
      @EEVblog  Год назад +1

      No idea, but that's the claim.

    • @Lazy_Tim
      @Lazy_Tim Год назад

      Got a link for that mate? Wiki says different.

    • @Peter_S_
      @Peter_S_ Год назад +3

      @@Lazy_Tim I stood next to the generator, at the time. It was a General Electric and was GE locomotive blue. My father was friends with the site manager for Sandia National Labs. There was also another solar thermal plant next door to the East which was already operating and was based on horizontally oriented cylindrical reflectors at ground level which didn't need any active tracking of the sun, but it was as efficient and suffered from wind blown desert dust on the reflectors. I don't know if that other demonstrator was connected to the grid, but I knew the guy who flipped the switch to connect Solar One.

    • @EEVblog
      @EEVblog  Год назад +4

      @@Peter_S_ My research says this one was "arguably the first commercial solar plant" as it had legit paying customers in the town for the energy produced from it. If another system was grid connnected, maybe it wasn't done so with an actual customer contract?

    • @EEVblog
      @EEVblog  Год назад +1

      Wikipedia for Solar One says "Solar One was completed in 1981 and was operational from 1982 to 1986"

  • @qzorn4440
    @qzorn4440 Год назад

    A great sight for thermocouple thermoelectric generator and upgrade the mirrors. Just need new can-do people on an old project. 😎 Great info, thanks.

  • @TNTom67890
    @TNTom67890 Год назад +8

    Molten Salt solar is actually a really good overnight solution as apposed to batteries.

    • @issacwessing4945
      @issacwessing4945 Год назад +2

      The efficiencies every time I've looked have been really bad. You'll end up with all the losses of this one here and more. Batteries and solar normally ends up being 2-4 times more efficient. There are a few things that might make them viable but it doesn't look like the pros are outweighing the cons for grid storage except in maybe a few niche cases like heating in places with already setup waste heat piping for city heating. Even then it might be a hard sell to not have everything switched over to electric instead.

    • @Muonium1
      @Muonium1 Год назад +1

      No it isn't. Round trip efficiency of real world molten salt energy storage is 70%, li-ion batteries are 90%+
      The only benefit is the low cost.

    • @issacwessing4945
      @issacwessing4945 Год назад

      ​@@Muonium1 Thats an overly optimistic round trip efficiency too. If you hit 60% you're already pretty high for a molten salt battery. You'll often see marketing for these molten salt companies claiming 90-99% efficiency while failing to disclose thats thermal storage efficiency or rather how much of the heat is lost while its stored. Efficiency ratings for heating, pumping, storing, and converting back to electricity are much worse.

  • @djsbriscoe
    @djsbriscoe Год назад +1

    Nice to see you out on location, and I'm keen to learn about small town Australia. Thanks.

  • @stationplaza4631
    @stationplaza4631 Год назад

    Nice seeing Dave out and about.

  • @matsv201
    @matsv201 Год назад +2

    Power tower is a competing technology, not a dish solar replacement. Dish solar is still around and efficiency is up to about 35%. Also have to remember that a dish have almost twice the interception rate as a Flatt panel solar. So area for area they produce almost 4 times as much energy, and over a wider span of the day.
    Its really grid subsides that make PV profitable today, not low price or efficiency.
    One have to consider the cost of storage. A flat panel solararray produce a peak during mid day. A parabol mirror produce about the same energy from the very morning to the very evening. This partly produce much more power per installed MW, but it also lower the usage of batteries considerably

  • @BastetFurry
    @BastetFurry Год назад

    There is one thing that speaks for this, you can theoretically build such a solar collector in you own shed. I would heat a wind tunnel with it tough, abusing that warm air wants to go up, no need to handle steam. On the other hand, here in Germany it would make more sense building a small vertical wind turbine, a scrapyard version could be made from an old drum and a generator out of an old car.

  • @pumptronics
    @pumptronics Год назад

    Beauty Dave! I saw your old photo and realised I had visited White Cliffs in 2001 when it was still operational with PV collectors. You could walk around the dishes and be immersed in the amazing saturated blues. The dishes brought the blue sky closer to the red dirt and it all looked so intense and futuristic. Also it made a slight hissing noise...would that have been the water cooling?

  • @universeisundernoobligatio3283
    @universeisundernoobligatio3283 Год назад +2

    Looks like the day you visited it was cloudy, not a peek power day. Good to see some history.

    • @EEVblog
      @EEVblog  Год назад +2

      Yeah, they had a rare spate of terrible weather.

  • @douglasengle2704
    @douglasengle2704 Год назад

    I think this was a very thorough experiment in thermal electric power generation. It also was very clever in avoiding unknown risk such as thermal towers have with long open air stretches of concentrated solar energy that in the US southwest turned out to ignite birds flying though it on fire! With all that effort and very good implementation over all those reflective parabolic thermal dishes, the housing, steam driven generators and battery electric storage it only originally generated 25 KW. A high end bus conversion RV can have 20 KW generator housed in half a storage bin. That doesn't include Diesel storage.
    It wasn't covered in the video, but how many days can it provide power when there is little sun? In California a Tesla solar roof and power wall home owner was equipped to run 4 days without sun before having to use grid power. During the California wild fires his home lost grid power due to the forest fire risk or maybe the forest fires themselves and the wild fire smoke was so thick the solar cells didn't make much electricity for two weeks until the smoke thinned out. He struggled through having to go with little AC during times they really needed it to clean the smoky air. With some regret in his voice his opinion was he should have a backup generator.

  • @joelmurphy9369
    @joelmurphy9369 Год назад

    I've been fascinated by the solar collectors. Parabolic and The other with the mirrors focused on one point.
    It is great to see the science and engineering behind it all, and to get more of an understanding of how efficiency is measured. Good on ya for doing that research back in the 80's!
    And yes, I love to be taken on tour with you to some fool thing that you want to show your kid! Please keep being an awesome dad!

  • @thomasgaliana6288
    @thomasgaliana6288 Год назад +1

    Yes. Please do more. I found this interesting.

  • @Whatiwantedwastaken
    @Whatiwantedwastaken Год назад

    I got a tour of a very similar installation at Lajamanu in the Northern Territory about a decade ago. It was cool, but it was generating naff all power. I gather they probably rolled it out into the communities after the trial at White Cliffs.

  • @dinkc64
    @dinkc64 Год назад +2

    Love this kind of content, thanks Dave!

  • @The_dislike_guy
    @The_dislike_guy Год назад

    It’s crazy how far technology has come, I have 25 kW of solar at my house, and the panels only cost 6 grand

  • @RavenLuni
    @RavenLuni Год назад +1

    If you set up some funky lights and rotate the dishes they could act like disco balls and you could have a party

  • @seanwilkinson2291
    @seanwilkinson2291 Год назад

    Very cool! Awesome video!

  • @IanSlothieRolfe
    @IanSlothieRolfe Год назад +13

    I've always thought solar thermal has more legs on it for large scale commercial solar energy, in countries with the sunlight to drive it. Photoelectric panels are great for smaller installations on roofs end such, but for a large scale installation they are somewhat fragile, whereas a mirror is basically indestructible if cleaned regularly and carefully. I am sure the lessons learned from White Cliffs have been fed into subsequent projects, so even though it is no longer complete or operating, it has earned its heritage status. It looks like there's quite a lively community at White Cliffs too!

    • @EEVblog
      @EEVblog  Год назад +14

      It's a very small community. Dirt roads, one pub, one corner store, and a huge lot of people live in underground dugouts. We stayed two nights in an underground hotel, and went opal mining with the Young Guns youtube channel. Very cool place if you ever get the chance.

    • @wobblysauce
      @wobblysauce Год назад

      You got to start somewhere

    • @FutureChaosTV
      @FutureChaosTV Год назад

      Solar panels are not really fragile.
      And not more fragile than these mirrors.
      The greatest danger to medium sized solar fields is that criminals steal them.

  • @emwave100
    @emwave100 Год назад +6

    Yes please do more tours of interesting power facilities around the world. Will give you a reason to travel. Do a nuclear facility, hydro facility, and geothermal facility. Just a recommendation.

    • @EEVblog
      @EEVblog  Год назад +1

      I doubt a nuclear facility will let me film inside. I've done a Syncrotron video.

    • @SeanBZA
      @SeanBZA Год назад

      @@EEVblog You can try Olympic Dam mine, which probably will be amenable to offering a tour, as it seems amenable to public outreach. You just have to fly to Adelaide first, to catch the daily flight there.
      Otherwise there is only one nuclear isotope producer in Australia, right by you in Sydney, and any others you would need to endure at least 14 hours on Quantas first.
      Most nuclear plants are visitor friendly, at least to those who they see as either unbiased or proponents, though the one I did some training at was not so amenable, as it officially did not exist. Something about the number 6, and the South Atlantic, with a malfunctioning Vela satellite, I think. It definitely does not exist now, just some very clean ground.

  • @claytonkeltto3239
    @claytonkeltto3239 Год назад +1

    Very cool...I enjoyed it and would like more. Thanks!

  • @T2D.SteveArcs
    @T2D.SteveArcs Год назад +2

    Awsome video Dave really cool thanks mate, nice to see not so little Sagan out with his Daddy too, ❤ I dont think the losses really matter so much when you have a huge piece of land and a small town in the outback especially if energy source is free, its more running and maintenance costs vrs the alternative ie diesel generators or connecting upto the grid etc in my opinion at least..
    Steve Arcs

    • @EEVblog
      @EEVblog  Год назад +1

      That was Huxley at the end of the video. Sagan is now bigger than Mrs EEVblog.

    • @T2D.SteveArcs
      @T2D.SteveArcs Год назад

      @@EEVblog 😮 wow, I guess I've been watching your channel a while 😅... ❤👍...
      Hope your all well mate
      Steve

    • @shazam6274
      @shazam6274 Год назад

      Yeah, that's the problem with all the "Free energy schemes": They're SO EXPENSIVE! 😂

  • @CharlesGregory
    @CharlesGregory Год назад

    Very cool system and great to see videos like this!

  • @Rob2
    @Rob2 Год назад +1

    Also interesting is a solar furnace that was built in the south of France in the sixties. It is used for material research etc, not power production.
    (although there has been a powerplant near that site as well, but it was operating from 1983 so indeed later than what you visited here)

  • @frankowalker4662
    @frankowalker4662 Год назад

    That was fascinating. Yes, more please.

  • @n0madfernan257
    @n0madfernan257 Год назад

    Would like to go back in time with Mr. Dave as my Field trip tour guide for these awesome structures.

  • @jimwithheld7217
    @jimwithheld7217 10 месяцев назад

    A big vote YES from me for this type of content please.

  • @LucasCarter2
    @LucasCarter2 Год назад

    Solar thermal from what I understand can also just sort of operate without needing to have massive replacements like photovoltaic panels do which have their own battery lives where they just stop working and need to be disposed of.
    Ultimately it turns out we got it right the first time by using heat energy as that remains the most viable and long lasting method of electricity generation.

  • @tra757200
    @tra757200 11 месяцев назад

    It is amazing out much of our power is still generated the same as 100 years ago.

  • @somedude-lc5dy
    @somedude-lc5dy Год назад

    great tour! thanks for the insight!

  • @joshnabours9102
    @joshnabours9102 Год назад

    Yes, Very interesting! Love it!

  • @LittleSpot
    @LittleSpot Год назад

    cool idea and installation

  • @bertblankenstein3738
    @bertblankenstein3738 Год назад +4

    I went by a solar installation is in the US near the CA/NV border. They had mirrors reflecting light up to a central tower. I swear, you drop a chicken in that concentrated light, it'll be cooked before it hits the ground.

    • @SeanBZA
      @SeanBZA Год назад +1

      Inside will be raw, though much of the outside will be burnt off. 1000C jet exhaust does the same, though you also tend to find the things that get into it vanish fast, and the walls it impinged on took hours to cool down again. The birds that flew into it got plucked,before they got ripped to pieces impacting the ground, or made flat against a wall.

  • @SuperVstech
    @SuperVstech Год назад

    “The ducks guts” amazing idiom there… just when I thought I’d heard them all…

  • @echelonrank3927
    @echelonrank3927 Год назад

    2:55 .......not only contained the superheated steam TURBINE generator but batteries as well !
    while showing us a drawing of a steam piston engine block LOL

  • @hippie-io7225
    @hippie-io7225 Год назад

    Love to see more of your Aussie roots!

    • @ianmason.
      @ianmason. Год назад

      You can't now he has started dying his hair! 🤣

  • @lorenwilson8128
    @lorenwilson8128 Год назад

    Current efforts to commercialize this have run into serious issues and have not performed to expectations. Tonopah Solar is a good example. This is nice for remote areas but has been superseded by PV in terms of cost and ease of maintenance.

  • @tonynicholson3328
    @tonynicholson3328 Год назад +3

    Solar powered tourist generator, that's unique.

  • @PiotrSepski
    @PiotrSepski Год назад

    Please do more of this. Good stuff

  • @GrumsPlace
    @GrumsPlace Год назад

    The solar generator in Lake Cargelligo is not operating but there is a website with some information about it as well.

  • @jankcitycustoms
    @jankcitycustoms Год назад +3

    thats crazy they went with piston engines instead of a turbine.

  • @gutloja
    @gutloja Год назад

    I want to visit!
    Soil looks great!

  • @hillarious2393
    @hillarious2393 Год назад

    Wery interesting to know about reflectors in solar energy produce

  • @richardbrobeck2384
    @richardbrobeck2384 Год назад

    Great video and what I thought would be cool is if they could have a smal working model there and have a small museum .

  • @grayaj23
    @grayaj23 Год назад

    Loved it!

  • @jeremycrisp4488
    @jeremycrisp4488 Год назад

    It always upsetting when sites like this shut down. The idea of solar thermal is almost completely lost due to how cheap solar panels cost. Being able to store massive amounts of heat that would allow generators to run at night is a good alternative to having chemical batteries that store electricity. Stored heat can be used in more than one way, unlike stored electricity. It sure seems that governments really don't want to solve the problem of intermittent energy production of alternative energy.

  • @JWH3
    @JWH3 Год назад +1

    Love these side videos, wouldn't even mind less technical stuff if you happen to be going past any "deep history" you run across.

  • @jfwfreo
    @jfwfreo Год назад +1

    I wonder why solar thermal isn't more popular as a technology (especially the sort that can hold the heat in a thermal mass of some kind and generate power with it at times when the sun isn't shining and avoid the need for any kind of batteries).

    • @xponen
      @xponen Год назад

      seems too large compared to PV. It needs turbine or engines running off that hot liquids to create electricity. Like sort of steampunk-ish tech.

  • @samhklm
    @samhklm Год назад +2

    Very interesting. Do more solar history.

  • @Veptis
    @Veptis 3 месяца назад

    there being a spinning turbine is actually a smoothing capacitor, buffering kinetic energy. And the heat is buffering thermal energy.
    Which means it's much less sensitive to a single cloud.
    The turbines in coal power plants are massive flywheels too. They can spin for days.... So blocking the coal delivery railtracks isn't any effective form of protest.
    There is some larger thermal solar generator plants around the world. One of them is curiously in Germany, near a research center.
    It could also be repurposed as a radio telescope at night. If the tracking is any good. But you usuallx used s cryocooled NLA. And these might not be best located directly next to the hottest spot.

  • @ericksagaguara
    @ericksagaguara Год назад

    Thanks!

    • @ericksagaguara
      @ericksagaguara Год назад

      Not because of this video. It is because your channel is amazing.

  • @davedamngood1076
    @davedamngood1076 Год назад

    Thank you

  • @tommy12345abc
    @tommy12345abc Год назад

    do these tours - it's interesting to know what works and what doesn't when it comes to clean energy; do one on recycling the solar panels - it is something to consider when manufacturing new panels

  • @BradKwfc
    @BradKwfc Год назад

    Great video, very interesting.

  • @Crisdapari
    @Crisdapari Год назад +1

    I wonder if this technology could work better for desalinization or pump water than other methods

  • @TheRealBanana
    @TheRealBanana Год назад +2

    All those heavyduty electronically controlled az/el mounts. 🤤I hope they don't let them fall into complete disrepair.

  • @jafinch78
    @jafinch78 Год назад

    Neat, I had no idea. Lot's of areas of opportunity for solar systems there down under. The only local argument I've heard regarding the systems implemented in the U.S. southwest was like a thermal death zone. Though was hear say and seems can greenhouse like enclose to possibly better control and manage.

  • @radioactive4388
    @radioactive4388 Год назад

    I can see them from my place , its a shame its not still operating now with newer technologies available. Whitecliffs could be fully of grid , mite be not much left if the town soon if the government stops the Opal mining like it has for the last 5 years .

  • @BartJBols
    @BartJBols Год назад

    You misinterpreted a part of the efficiency graph, enthalpy and pumping power ADDED to the efficiency. Being that a larger enthalpy and pumping power meant more power conversion.

  • @leviath0n
    @leviath0n Год назад

    I think it's more the bees knees, or the dogs bollocks, rather than the ducks guts.

  • @jodywhitehead9173
    @jodywhitehead9173 Год назад

    Hey mate, first in Australia maybe. 1913 88kw plant in Cairo.

  • @fogelmclovin6815
    @fogelmclovin6815 Год назад

    Cool! Thanks for the info!

  • @alexscarbro796
    @alexscarbro796 Год назад +1

    You are going to have to contact the university and see if they’ll send you a concentrated solar cell module to tear down …..

  • @no_more_free_nicks
    @no_more_free_nicks Год назад

    Interesting, something new for the channel.

  • @leerman22
    @leerman22 Год назад +2

    I don't like CSP but I am seeing a lot of places where it has been improved over the years. I want to see if some press can stamp these curves out of a single sheet of stainless steel.

    • @mariusbendiksen163
      @mariusbendiksen163 Год назад

      Could probably do a lot to cut the costs, and the shapes will be less expensive to get just right now, so interesting to see what we could do without Russian and Chinese quartz. These things do seem like they can outlast the photovoltaics, but the real question is total life cycle emissions per kWh and m2.

  • @landspide
    @landspide Год назад +1

    They had one of these at the back of ANU on the lake in Canberra (can see it from the foot path), not sure if it is still there.

    • @EEVblog
      @EEVblog  Год назад +2

      Yes, they had a much bigger reseach dish.

  • @AnvilDragon
    @AnvilDragon Год назад

    Efficency isn't the best measure when excess area is available. At the time I believe the installed cost vs power output was beating solar cells rather easily. However, small solar panels are being installed at a cost that would only buy a few square inches of cells back in the 70's. Now panels can provide power at less than the maintenance cost of a solar thermal/steam system. The production process of making solar cells got that much more efficient.
    There were a number of solar projects that predicted the cost of the refined silicon continuing to rise, not be cut in half and then cut in half again. Yield and production rates of scale slashed the attached labor costs of silicon cells and most all the less efficent but cheaper (at the time) solar programs are all but gone.
    Power storage is now the thing. Could see Edison Cells make a comeback for a time. Inexpensive and abundant materiels and size/weight efficency isn't a factor if bolted to the ground, it's the very long life and low maintenece requirement that make them attractive. A home install that can go over 50 years with little upkeep and not catching fire is a thing. Twice the weight and footprint much less so. Just don't bet everything on it since something will change the playing field.
    Pridicting futures is tough. Supercomputers never did get to cover a full kilometer square.... ah well. Did get the Trek-like comunicators with the flip phone. Never did make the noise when opened so.... Rockets do land on their tail, just rather miss the large deco fins... 🙂

  • @GNARGNARHEAD
    @GNARGNARHEAD Год назад

    random content idea, what about finding a young-in who have a project just out of their grasp, anything from the most basic powering a LED to an intermediate project that can be knocked out in an hour, and tutoring them through it, that way you're finding unique ways to communicate the fundamentals for specific applications, brings in new people by covering random topics, and refreshes the old hats on the basics.. just a random thought

  • @klassichd10
    @klassichd10 Год назад +1

    Thanks a lot! I really appreciate the milestones of engineering. Even if we can do it better nowadays. But this is the fate of engineering: Today leading edge, tomorrow common stuff and afterwards just obsolete old scrap.

  • @jaye1967
    @jaye1967 Год назад

    I did laugh at the fact Dave was there on a cloudy day.😁 It's interesting though.

  • @chrisheath2637
    @chrisheath2637 Год назад +1

    What might be interesting is to compare the output of that plant, with the output if the area was covered in modern solar cells. I read that if the area of a nuclear power plant was covered instead with solar cells, they would be roughly equal in output (obviously not at night !)...

    • @fredbloggs5902
      @fredbloggs5902 Год назад

      The claim about Solar having the same ground area footprint as nuclear for the same output is obvious nonsense. The difference is 50x.

  • @closertothetruth9209
    @closertothetruth9209 Год назад

    man id love one of those, save building one

  • @nndorconnetnz
    @nndorconnetnz Год назад

    What a shame not allowed in and have a look around from an engineering perspective. That would be something to see. To see a plant that can adjust to a wide variety of power inputs.
    That said, there is a reason why exothermic based power plants are used as base loads (whether coal, gas, geo thermic or nuclear) is because the efficiency drops when the boiler pressure gets lower.
    Getting the balance right takes time cause of getting the amount of steam being produced to adjusting the turbines for the amount of steam to the load on the turbines to the condensers efficiency for the heat coming in by adjusting the cooling water depending of the temp of the cooling water etc etc etc. Not like just turning on more water at a hydro plant.

  • @5th_decile
    @5th_decile Год назад

    To be fair, I think there was already a concentrated solar power plant at the end of the 19th century. If I recall correctly it was made by an Italian inventor, somewhere in Northern Africa...

    • @5th_decile
      @5th_decile Год назад

      But the one of this video is perhaps the first one of the 'modern era'?

  • @adamadamhoney
    @adamadamhoney Год назад

    Love this shit Dave. What's so good spots within a days drive of Brisbane to check out?!

  • @danielbuckman2727
    @danielbuckman2727 Год назад

    Awesome 👍

  • @timewave02012
    @timewave02012 Год назад +1

    I guess they had to find a use for all those little mirrors once the demand for disco balls dried up.

  • @alch3myau
    @alch3myau Год назад +1

    0:41 ... Wasnt that car in Mad Max... ;p