The Vanishing Island | Op-Docs | The New York Times

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 фев 2025

Комментарии • 38

  • @ricksaunders
    @ricksaunders 10 лет назад +15

    Beautifully shot. I've seen a lot of fine videos from NYT, but this is exceptional. Kudos.

  • @adrianrichards7253
    @adrianrichards7253 10 лет назад +28

    the oil companies caused this they should pay to fix it

  • @JTrahanUSA
    @JTrahanUSA 8 лет назад +15

    The Corp of Engineers and the Oil Industry owe the people of Isle de Jean Charles Island off the coast of Terrebonne Parish, Louisiana. The United States forced these Native American people from their original native lands in the early 1800's, which is why these people ended up on this island. They adapted and learned to love their adopted land, however....The Corps of Engineers channeled the Mississippi River to prevent it from growing Louisiana as it had with silting in the past. Earth pacts through years, so if no silt is added, the land mass pacts and, thus, sinks. The oil industry cut canals through the island giving salt water routes into the interior of the island thus killing salt water plants and allowing more entry through the island by hurricanes. I hope something is done to help these people. The people of this island do not deserve the bad hand they have been dealt. None of what they are going through is "natural". It is all man-made...man-made by the government and man-mad the oil industry. I do not know how much good this project will do, but any help for these people is better than no help at all. But, although I see a lot of "Shell Oil" tee-shirts, I do not hear any south Louisiana accents in the voices of the people promoting this project. I hope it helps, but I am not holding my breath. Having lived in bayou country in south Louisiana, I know how good life could be. Yes it was living off the land and the water, but it was a good life. From the land and water around you, you had what you needed to feed your family, and your family grew and you were happy. It was their home.

    • @mrsaye499
      @mrsaye499 6 лет назад

      thanks for posting this. a lot of people don't know this. I am only now becoming aware of this.

  • @chattigre
    @chattigre 10 лет назад +1

    Your DP is a badass. Thanks Andrew Watson.
    And those poor people are doomed. Very sad.

  • @Themsbeatlesrock
    @Themsbeatlesrock 5 лет назад +3

    "she's pregnant, poor thing" lol aw so cute

    • @Clark1967
      @Clark1967 5 лет назад

      Yes I could watch those two fish all day 🙂

  • @scasey1960
    @scasey1960 10 лет назад +7

    Why should we spend any money mitigating the consequences of global warming that of been ignored by the oil industry? Should not the oil industry pay for the levees needed to protect their refineries?

  • @Moonsabie
    @Moonsabie 10 лет назад +1

    lovely people.

  • @marlongeli1586
    @marlongeli1586 3 года назад +2

    beautiful place..

  • @skweeji
    @skweeji 4 года назад +2

    For those still here and those still curious. This island was 2 x .5 miles in area as of april 2019. I'm sure almost everyone has evacuated by now but even so, this was an entire island.. disappeared. Families and culture, sunken. Like an old ship, hah...

    • @skweeji
      @skweeji 4 года назад +1

      Brown John uhh no actually it’s a real issue i’m not “fear mongering” anything i’m stating facts for those who are curious. at the time of filming this it was a lot bigger so obviously it was drowned more since then.

  • @granadilla4585
    @granadilla4585 4 года назад

    Good luck my boys.

  • @noahpwsc9505
    @noahpwsc9505 4 года назад +7

    This came out 6 years ago. Do you wonder how well they're doing now? So do I. We've already brought the apocalypse. The question is, how long can we make until that apocalypse comes?

  • @careywyatt1327
    @careywyatt1327 4 года назад +1

    clean the trash up off the bottom of the sea , keep the top soil for fertilizer to build the land back up , and to sell to pay for the clean up job , it will make the water a lot cleaner , and lower the sea level , and give people jobs , ever body will be happy .

  • @C_C_SEA
    @C_C_SEA 10 лет назад

    stunning
    #AGW #sealevelrise

  • @GigRick
    @GigRick 3 года назад +2

    pov: college assignment.

  • @jaywalker8309
    @jaywalker8309 6 лет назад +1

    the ocean is reclaiming the coastal regions us

  • @solopolo
    @solopolo 10 лет назад

    This is free?!

  • @noahpwsc9505
    @noahpwsc9505 4 года назад +1

    Lieutenant Dan

  • @misxha3240
    @misxha3240 3 года назад

    i love u shrimp fisher stay high

  • @joannmossa5509
    @joannmossa5509 10 лет назад +2

    Unfortunately, Louisiana is in cahoots with the oil industry.

    • @laman491
      @laman491 6 лет назад

      not so much as you would think..
      www.lmoga.com/issues-initiatives/economic-impact

    • @cjedd9704
      @cjedd9704 5 лет назад +3

      OH, right! lol That's why the oil industry takes such good care of the coastline. No, the oil industry is not in cahoots with La, it's in cahoots with the wealthy 1% who don't care about the land, the planet, or ordinary people - just about their profits. Louisiana is the victim, its beautiful lands being washed away, the estuaries and wetlands destroyed, the forest of dead cypress a testimony to the oil field's channels funneling salt water deeper and deeper into the state's waterways, killing plant and animal life and making it increasingly difficult for the people who live there to hang onto their homes and way of life.

    • @nifty1940
      @nifty1940 5 лет назад +1

      @@cjedd9704 You got that right mate.

  • @shanaemays1039
    @shanaemays1039 6 лет назад

    So sad...

  • @owakonzee
    @owakonzee 5 лет назад

    Nothing to do with rising sea level nor “more severe storm.” The land is sinking. Sea level is the same; storms are the same.

    • @MattJohno2
      @MattJohno2 4 года назад +1

      If the land sank the sea level would follow. Earth isn't made of water.

  • @stephanierandolph2520
    @stephanierandolph2520 9 лет назад

    Jj

  • @teddyrose3142
    @teddyrose3142 6 лет назад

    Rising sea levels, ha

  • @unaninanine3743
    @unaninanine3743 7 лет назад

    More like poverty island...