@@vishkumar5202 puchta kon hai ram krishna ko?😁😁iskcon k bare mai jara pata kro..thik se..pata chl jayega..ram krishna kon hai..jesus wale jhut bolke faile hai..duniya mai.. ISKCON mai jydaa christian log hi hai..jo hindu ban rhe hai..hare Krishna🤘🤘😊aur tum jaise sdk chaap 4 paise diye to bik jate ho..fikr mt kro ane wale wqt mai puri duniya pe hum waps raj krenge jaise aajse 10000 sale pehle krte the..
@@artistshreeraj6008 तेरे इन झूठे भगवानो का मजाक उडाते है बाहर के देशो के लोग शायद पता ही होगा आपको कैसे कैसे भगवान है तुम्हारे एक है वो हाथी की सूंड वाला गणेश हा हा हाआदमी के धड पर हाथी का सिर वाह रे मक्कार ब्राहमणो क्या गंडवा बनाया है लोगो का और ये साले चुतिये भारत के लोग 21 वी सदी मे भी इन चीजो को मानते हैं
hi i am a student of mythology 🙏 I actually want to make a small correction in ur comment that during early vedic period all people were following Hinduism as u have seen in various tv shows And during that time the religion was one that was Hinduism (cause it the oldest religion) and the cast system was based on your profession . And the people were having full liberty to choose their caste . But in later vedic period some monster like people people made this caste system very rigid. And they also made the religious practices very costly due to which the people started changing there religion. Can't say anything about Islam but yaa the Christianity religion was attracted by most of the people who were fed up or cannot afford the rich religion practices. Hope u guys understand
Dear Devdutt ji, Namaskar. sir,I have gone through your Episodes. Really marvoless. 🎉🙏👌You are one of the blessed soul to deliver the facts of NATURE , ltihasas, & GODLINESS in a simplified manner. THANKS TO BE WITH YOU & GOING THROUGH YOUR PROGRAMS. Regards. By.... Er. B. Yogeswara Rao., Vaastu Samrat, Vaastu Brahma. & CEO of Vaastu Science Academy.
Jesus said he is son of god, Mohammad said he is a prophet of god and you believe them, but when Krishna says he is GOD himself you do not believe him!
@@tejeswarreddybuggana6605 if you follow Hinduism then you can know that atheist also have a place in Hinduism. It's your right if you want to believe in God or not. We are noone to tell you that but as a responsible person you should maintain peace and not hurt others it's simple. Believe in God or not it's up to you. But you can read vagwat geeta as a guidance of life not as a religious scripture. I was an atheist now I am seeker.
Yogesh Desai BG as it is is an OK introductory version but Prabhupad was not a scholar of Sanskrit! end of story. I’m glad you’re reading it, something is always better than nothing. He got murdered in the end by his closest ‘Jewish’ devotees. He was a simple man carrying a simple truth but who never took the poisonous viper like attitude of the Europeans into account. I met him many times in London and still carry a love for him in my heart.
Ivar Hakuse Srila Prabhupada's 'Bhagavad Gita as it is' is used as a textbook in many universities around the world is enough to convey the message that he was a scholar and pure devotee of Lord Krishna. It is the only version of Gita which gives word to word translation of Sanskrit verses which makes it the most authentic. His followers of all religions are successfully spreading his mission all over the world today. As an Indian I can clearly see how Bhagavad Gita as it is written by Srila Prabhupada is more correct than other versions of Gita available.
Yogesh Desai don’t waste time arguing over petty matters. I told you something is better than nothing, learn to listen to your elders, boy! Always be open to new ideas otherwise we run the risk of becoming closed minded bigots like the Christians and Muslims. Regarding several universities around the world other than that old statement being reprinted on the back cover, I can’t say I could name a single one. In the 1960’s every Hindu automatically became a scholar of Sanskrit because of reciting a couple of memorized verses. Prabhupād made a mess out of his rendition of the isha upanishad for which he was given ample chiding. His quick glossing over the chapter on ‘The field and the knower of the field’ clearly shows that he was out of his depth here. He was after all a businessman by profession and not a philosopher. He never pretended to be a philosopher as he was a pure bhakta. Yes his translation of Bengali word for word translations does make it useful but the Sanskrit translation was not his. During a personal conversation he remarked ‘isn’t it a miracle that these Europeans are chanting the name of Krishna? To which he was answered ‘but the greatest miracle is that you made all this happen without knowing a single word of sanskrit’.
Yogesh Desai Bible is the best selling book and most influential book in history...Jesus is saviour of all humans...Jesus is the only way to God... believe in Jesus Christ and you will have forgiveness of sins and eternalife.
Jacob Mathew he should believe in whatever he wants to ....we are no one to instruct him .... atleast he is not an atheist ....M a Hindu who had his schooling in strict convent school ....and we discovered Christianity so well ..... No matter its Krishan or Jesus ..... at the end we all go to same place place ...
Expansion of Christian is not as smooth as Mr Pattanaik said . They converted Hindu in to Christan forcly. Like Kuran, in Bibal it is written that they should not accept god of Hindu, should not accept Prasada of any Hindu god.
First of all brother it's "Bible" not bibal If you are so much expert on Conversions into different Religions Can u pls explain the conversion to Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhism etc The *harsh truth* is The Shudras (low caste) people of India converted into Islam or Christianity by being exploited by upper caste Swami Vivekanad said "It was the shudras of India who spread the Islam & Christianityby converting" *and that prasad thing* First of all brother there are many hindu temples who doesn't allow Dalits or Non-Hindus first you are not allowing them to enter and then you are questing why aren't they accepting PRASADS
Like we forcefully grab SC ST OBC in India And don't let them intermingle as they may unite and our wrong use of religion for personal hegemony would go. It is not fluid to unite n love as free
Amol Chawhan Fact of patnaik is always baseless,he always tries to confuse hindus about their religion.Therefore self read grantha n books,because our owns knowledge helps us,not of other.N read the genuine books only.
Ankit Raj; Caste apartheid has been practiced for 2500 yrs against 15-20% Hindus called Shura also called Dalit, Harijan. untouchables. Yes Ankit, they are not allowed to enter many temples and come near the puja pandal. They have been raped, murdered with no consequence to the perpetrators. Buddha and Guru Nanak rejected Hinduism to chart separate paths.
Prosanto Mukerji , what do you actually wanna say , consent or partial disagree. Actually segregation of people had been given in our texts for karna(greater fighter,kshatirya than arjun) as shudra or eklavya as no one part odd vedic system/society, as no even. They have been kept away since always n not just 500BC. Vedic shashtras expel hatred-n-ghettos for shudras and calling tribals n non Vedics as rakshas asuras danav n daityas. Caste( strict groups of sexual restrictions outside out with other caste crimes prathas that contrive today in mindset of people) become prominent in @1AD but hatred deceit violence existed long before since always.
vasco da gama was a tyrant he killed many Indians , captured land forcefully..Devdutt misleading many things to show Hinduism Christianity are not much different
Bryan W.H. Schmidt, You forgot to add "and the other European Pirates that accompanied him" Why be mean on blessings? I always find it amusing how European pirates took their god along with them. guilty conscience? just a thought. Anyway on a lighter note, other than piracy, pillage and plunder anyone know any valuable contribution to human civilization made by the Portuguese? No? me neither, none that immediately spring to mind, guess we'll have to do a google search then. Loot, now that's a Hindi word used by Indians to describe what the Europeans did, funny how it ended up in the English language.
You are absolutely right but the history of Christianity in India actually dates back to the time of Jesus. There are some St. Thomas Christians or also known as Kurien Christians in Kerala who came to India in the second century. Although most of them were forced to convert by the European settlers or they converted themselves because of the caste system in Hinduism
5:16 devdutt is saying that abrhamic God is 'nirgun' while it clearly is not as he has anger, love hate etc. Devdutt is using nirgun to be synonymous to formless which is wrong and hee also abrahmic God does have form . For e.g. as per bible God created humans in his own image. Muhammad met Allah. So Devdutt's understanding of concept of nirgun and formlessness is shallow.
Sarvesh Dev bhai ye satya bol ra hi...main difference in their and ours is we worship human form,we worship ahimsa ..bhai ek bat janlo..krishna ho chaliya bola gya hi..I mean he is playing with all religion faith,even with every atom,...agar wo indra swarg k raja ko respect karte hi then..unne daityaraj bali ko bhi...amar hone ka vardan diya hi...so he respect everyone...so he say in geeta na mera koi apna hi na koi paraya he is not fix with any specific religion but ...when his ...land of leela means bharat get destroyed ..then he takes avtar...
Believe in god but don't depend on him😀. And if you believe that there is an energy beyond science then it god❤️... no matter which religion u belong or which god you believe. Pray to the power and not to the face.🙏🙏
koi yeh bataye ke us jamane mei jab log bahar se aate the tab vo communicate kaise karte the kyunki sabki.language alag thi... phir baat kaise karte the???
Calender start nahi hua use Zero mana gaya hai. Before Christ ko negative pattern mein aur After death ko positive pattern mein sequence kiya jata hai. Bilkul ek number line jaise.
1) Is there any evidence for Christ? 2) Why do you need evidence in faith? 3) Are you confused person? 3) RAM is follower of dharma not maker, so what is your issue? 4) You cannot understand metaphor that is a fact, people will laugh at your explanation 5) What do you want to say? 6) He should open mind in what? 7) when are you planning to open your mind? 7) How those things affecting your life? 8) Are you a murk? 9) Truth is bitter - you are using electronic system based on Hindu Binary system instead of being grateful to the people you are confused and abusing the very people who feeds you. 10) First stop learning Hindu numerals and binary system and then we will have conversation?
@@prosantomukerji3931 No need to get excited. He just meant that there is no historical evidence. There is no reference by any contemporary historians of the time about the coming of Thomas to India. The person who came to India might be another Thomas but not one of the apostles. You should check out the books by religious historian Robert Eric Frykenberg. As for Raam, it is a very old event to have physical historical evidence. It is like saying that there is no evidence of Abraham's stick or chappals so he did not exist. Nevertheless, there is a lot of circumstantial evidence to the existence of Raam. Like the names of places, locations and cities visited by Raam and co. during their Vanvasa. Also the existence of Rama Setu between India and Sri Lanka which has been identified to be an artificial structure and very old.
@Ashramedia That is not the verification of the book, novel or the movie but the incident that they describe. If multiple sources give you the same observation, that is scientific. Even historically, if multiple sources describe the same historical event, then it is taken as an actual event. The validity Ramayana and Mahabharata is not that it has description of different places. But the fact that all these places has the same events being recorded in their local folklore.
@@OblivionZXZ not necessary that we have to follow whatever religion we belong from. Religion & religious books r made by a human according to his principal, every individual have their own principal.
@@OblivionZXZ polygamy is allowed in most of the religion & marrying with their cousins is allowed in some of the religion including South Indian Hindus but civilized people don't follow these things. We r Indians and will only follow our constitution 🇮🇳🇮🇳
calling Christianity, Islam a dharma is the biggest mistake people always did. Dharma never means religion, Panth means religion. Dharma's definition is very much different and elaborate. So please never calls religion = dharma.
@@st.mephisto8564 Totally wrong definition of Dharma. ( Religion = Mahajab ) ≠ Dharma. 1) यतो अभ्युदय निः श्रेयस सिद्धि सह धर्मः | >अर्थात - जिससे हमारे जीवन का समग्र व भौतिक उत्कर्ष हो उसको धर्म कहते है | > Means - That which leads to the overall and material prosperity of our life is called Dharma. 2) धारयति इति धर्मः| अर्थात > जो धारण करने योग्य है वही धर्म है | Means > That which is worth ingurgitate is Dharma. 3) धृतिः क्षमा दमोऽस्तेयं शौच इन्द्रियनिग्रहः | धीर्विधा सत्यमकोर्धो दशकं धर्मलक्षणम् || अर्थात > धृति(धैर्य), क्षमा(दयालुता), दम(बुरे विचारों का दमन), अस्तेय (चोरी न करना), शौच( कार्मिक, वाचिक, मानसिक, आर्थिक वगैरह सब प्रकार कि पवित्रता), इन्द्रियनिग्रह (इन्द्रियों पर नियंत्रण), धीरे(सद्बुद्धि), विधा, सत्य भाषण, आक्रोश- ये धर्म के 10 लक्षण हैं | Means > i.e. Dhriti (patience), Kshama (kindness), Dum (suppression of bad thoughts), Asteya (not stealing), Shaucha (purity of all kinds, karmic, verbal, mental, economic etc.), Indriyanigraha (control of the senses), Dhi (good intellect), Rightful Education, truthful speech, resentment - these are the 10 characteristics of Dharma. Dharma is a very widespread concept, you cannot bind it into small and narrow path of religion. So please update your knowledge on DHARMA. Christianity starts from Jesus, Islam start from Muhammad, from where Sanatan Dhama start?
@@tushar1990able Lol you cannot just redefine Religion because of the stigma attached to it. Religion cannot be not a narrow path, because Religion is itself a category. Religion is a social-cultural system of designated behaviors and practices, morals, beliefs. All the examples you gave, of kindness, not stealing, purity, intellect are also taught in Religion. Hereby Dharma is also a Religion. What you can say is one Religion is better than the other, but it still remains a Religion. Sanatan Dharma has many founders, not one but I would suppose it began with the Vedas, Upanishads around 1500BC
@@st.mephisto8564 Ohk. Only one question and depend on your answer I will reply otherwise I will stop this conversation. According to you Ramayan and Mahabharat , REAL OR MYTH?
He says “Nirguna” and explains no form. No form is “Nirakaar” not “Nirgun”. He doesn’t know anything. Simply promoting Christianity. Vatican denied that St. Thomas arrived in India. At least learn that. Also learn that after Christ got crucified almost 50 years no one spread Christianity anywhere. In fact there were no concept of Christianity.
Hello bro ... He is very knowledgeable person ... Uske aas pas bhi nai hai humlog... Nirakar to aam janta bolti hai but philosophy me nirgun hi bola jata hai ... Nirgun and sagun ... Bhakism
Nirgun does not mean formless. It is Nirakar. In bible, God created humans in his own image, which means God has form of human. So all are fiction. We are talking about Man as God here.
So about in Jews mystic there is concept of en solf that is infinity Mam I respect every religion but you should 😅 understand everything about other religions and then speaks
@@ignacelakra6777 I was talking about bible. How talking about bible is same as talking about all religions? BTW concept infinity is also a bad qualifier for divinity. It is still a very narrow understanding
@@ignacelakra6777 divinity is not infinity. Divinity is all pervading beyond space and time. Infinity is still bound within the 3d dimension because infinity doesn't look beyond material perspective. Mathematics is material subject. All philosophy or knowledge about religion or spirituality is still material part. But spirituality itself is not.
Agar hinduo ko sanatan dharm k bare me janna hi h toh asli aur sahi granth pade thoda samay deke,na ki aise chuthiya shows aur chuthiya logo ki sune,khud ka gyan hi sach (satya) tk pahuchata h na ki dushro ka,aur ramayan sirf valmiki ji ki hi pade,aur thodi sanskrit shi source se sikhe na ki western sanskrit,kyunki kuch western professors ne kuch milawate kr di h.
sir christianity 52 ad my hi aagya tha 2000 sall sy try kar rahaya hai bharat ko christianty karnya ki ,magar na safal hua thay ,na hai aur na hi hogya
The best Host of This Show . Please bring her back . That another Anchor is very Rude / Sounds unprofessional / Amateur / Lack of Knowledge . If You guys want to increase the Standard of this Divine Show . Plz change that Anchor . I think , It's Ms . Shetty
It's simply proves tat before Christianity there was Hinduism religion and after christanity also there will be Hinduism.... And yeah those ppl who converted into Christian wer either small caste ppl or they wer force to accept christanity on the bases of power....
wrong ya hai ,ya log convert karatya hai ,issliya time batana zaroori hai 2000 say try kar rahya hai ,aur aaj bhi zari hai ,magar humarai sanskriti ko khatam karna itna asan nahi hai
Pehli bat christianity bharat me 2000 saal pehle nhi aayi h ,yeh bilkul galat h.Aur devendra jee aap santan dharm ko apne mutabik tod marod kr pesh krte h,jb santan dharm k bare me sare grantho me likha h to aap apni books me use apne mutabik pesh kr,use galt sabit kr logo ko gumrah kr rhe h.
If you have knowledge then please tell here, don't bark without knowledge !! First prove here !!! I m ready for a great debate !!! I have lots of facts ! Get set go buddy !!! Please reply
Bryan W.H. Schmidt, You forgot to add "and the other European Pirates that accompanied him" Why be mean on blessings? I always find it amusing how European pirates took their god along with them. guilty conscience? just a thought. Anyway on a lighter note, other than piracy, pillage and plunder anyone know any valuable contribution to human civilization made by the Portuguese? No? me neither, none that immediately spring to mind, guess we'll have to do a google search then. Loot, now that's a Hindi word used by Indians to describe what the Europeans did, funny how it ended up in the English language.
Sarvesh Dev bhai ye satya bol ra hi...main difference in their and ours is we worship human form,we worship ahimsa ..bhai ek bat janlo..krishna ho chaliya bola gya hi..I mean he is playing with all religion faith,even with every atom,...agar wo indra swarg k raja ko respect karte hi then..unne daityaraj bali ko bhi...amar hone ka vardan diya hi...so he respect everyone...so he say in geeta na mera koi apna hi na koi paraya he is not fix with any specific religion but ...when his ...land of leela means bharat get destroyed ..then he takes avtar
2000 pahel kaise? Syrian orthodox Cristian 5 vi sadi baad aaye hoge iska koi paka sabut nahi, pahel Jesus khud aaye thain North Tibet Buddhism Sikh ne unka ek kaber gha bhi North jis abhi kashmir kahte Russian author ki kitab unknown life Jesus crist padlo
yes, Muslim only belive that Jesus is not son of god, he was a messenger, and also that prophet Mohammad is the last prophet, and its also mentioned in BIBLE, A MUSLIM MUST LOVE JESUS (ISA) IN ORDER TO BE A MUSLIM....
These are all false things said to Hindus... devdutt is destroying Hindu Dharma and sanatan dharma Sanatan Dharma was the oldest religion that is all over bharat.....which was way before chritanity and Islam
devdut ji bhagwan or ishwar frak hai, bhagwan ek form hai jaise pahelwan hota Jo insaan karishma kar ta bhagwan kah te hai ishwar infinite hai woh brhamad har ek atom hai ishwar koi swar ya akar hai bhi or nahi bhi is koi samjha nahi sakta
I wish our history teachers were like that
Father of all messenger only SHRI KRISHNA..
पूछता कौन है इन राम कृष्ण को दुनिया मे ईसा मसीह को पूरे विश्व मे पूजा जाता है
@@vishkumar5202 puchta kon hai ram krishna ko?😁😁iskcon k bare mai jara pata kro..thik se..pata chl jayega..ram krishna kon hai..jesus wale jhut bolke faile hai..duniya mai.. ISKCON mai jydaa christian log hi hai..jo hindu ban rhe hai..hare Krishna🤘🤘😊aur tum jaise sdk chaap 4 paise diye to bik jate ho..fikr mt kro ane wale wqt mai puri duniya pe hum waps raj krenge jaise aajse 10000 sale pehle krte the..
@@artistshreeraj6008 तेरे इन झूठे भगवानो का मजाक उडाते है बाहर के देशो के लोग शायद पता ही होगा आपको कैसे कैसे भगवान है तुम्हारे एक है वो हाथी की सूंड वाला गणेश हा हा हाआदमी के धड पर हाथी का सिर वाह रे मक्कार ब्राहमणो क्या गंडवा बनाया है लोगो का और ये साले चुतिये भारत के लोग 21 वी सदी मे भी इन चीजो को मानते हैं
@@vishkumar5202 yeshu konsa sacha hey bey
@@vishkumar5202 yesu masiah ko sirf blind believer pujta hey apne apko toh nahi bacha paya
Rasika duggal is a really good actress..she is very talented.
Respect to devdutta, I find this show very interesting and watch it a lot
hi i am a student of mythology 🙏 I actually want to make a small correction in ur comment that during early vedic period all people were following Hinduism as u have seen in various tv shows And during that time the religion was one that was Hinduism (cause it the oldest religion) and the cast system was based on your profession . And the people were having full liberty to choose their caste . But in later vedic period some monster like people people made this caste system very rigid. And they also made the religious practices very costly due to which the people started changing there religion. Can't say anything about Islam but yaa the Christianity religion was attracted by most of the people who were fed up or cannot afford the rich religion practices. Hope u guys understand
Dear Devdutt ji, Namaskar. sir,I have gone through your Episodes. Really marvoless. 🎉🙏👌You are one of the blessed soul to deliver the facts of NATURE , ltihasas, & GODLINESS in a simplified manner.
THANKS TO BE WITH YOU & GOING THROUGH YOUR PROGRAMS.
Regards.
By.... Er. B. Yogeswara Rao.,
Vaastu Samrat, Vaastu Brahma. & CEO of Vaastu Science Academy.
Jesus said he is son of god, Mohammad said he is a prophet of god and you believe them, but when Krishna says he is GOD himself you do not believe him!
🤩🤩🤩vry right
Who doesn't?
How about not believing anyone
@@tejeswarreddybuggana6605 if you follow Hinduism then you can know that atheist also have a place in Hinduism. It's your right if you want to believe in God or not. We are noone to tell you that but as a responsible person you should maintain peace and not hurt others it's simple. Believe in God or not it's up to you. But you can read vagwat geeta as a guidance of life not as a religious scripture.
I was an atheist now I am seeker.
@@keshibaignad9760 completely agree with you. Our culture gives us liberty unlike western culture
Jai mataji to both of you
Read 'Bhagavad Gita as it is' best book to understand almighty God.
Yogesh Desai BG as it is is an OK introductory version but Prabhupad was not a scholar of Sanskrit! end of story. I’m glad you’re reading it, something is always better than nothing. He got murdered in the end by his closest ‘Jewish’ devotees. He was a simple man carrying a simple truth but who never took the poisonous viper like attitude of the Europeans into account. I met him many times in London and still carry a love for him in my heart.
Ivar Hakuse Srila Prabhupada's 'Bhagavad Gita as it is' is used as a textbook in many universities around the world is enough to convey the message that he was a scholar and pure devotee of Lord Krishna. It is the only version of Gita which gives word to word translation of Sanskrit verses which makes it the most authentic. His followers of all religions are successfully spreading his mission all over the world today. As an Indian I can clearly see how Bhagavad Gita as it is written by Srila Prabhupada is more correct than other versions of Gita available.
Yogesh Desai don’t waste time arguing over petty matters. I told you something is better than nothing, learn to listen to your elders, boy! Always be open to new ideas otherwise we run the risk of becoming closed minded bigots like the Christians and Muslims. Regarding several universities around the world other than that old statement being reprinted on the back cover, I can’t say I could name a single one. In the 1960’s every Hindu automatically became a scholar of Sanskrit because of reciting a couple of memorized verses. Prabhupād made a mess out of his rendition of the isha upanishad for which he was given ample chiding. His quick glossing over the chapter on ‘The field and the knower of the field’ clearly shows that he was out of his depth here. He was after all a businessman by profession and not a philosopher. He never pretended to be a philosopher as he was a pure bhakta. Yes his translation of Bengali word for word translations does make it useful but the Sanskrit translation was not his. During a personal conversation he remarked ‘isn’t it a miracle that these Europeans are chanting the name of Krishna? To which he was answered ‘but the greatest miracle is that you made all this happen without knowing a single word of sanskrit’.
Yogesh Desai Bible is the best selling book and most influential book in history...Jesus is saviour of all humans...Jesus is the only way to God... believe in Jesus Christ and you will have forgiveness of sins and eternalife.
Jacob Mathew he should believe in whatever he wants to ....we are no one to instruct him .... atleast he is not an atheist ....M a Hindu who had his schooling in strict convent school ....and we discovered Christianity so well ..... No matter its Krishan or Jesus ..... at the end we all go to same place place ...
Expansion of Christian is not as smooth as Mr Pattanaik said . They converted Hindu in to Christan forcly. Like Kuran, in Bibal it is written that they should not accept god of Hindu, should not accept Prasada of any Hindu god.
First of all brother it's "Bible" not bibal
If you are so much expert on Conversions into different Religions
Can u pls explain the conversion to Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhism etc
The *harsh truth* is The Shudras (low caste) people of India converted into Islam or Christianity by being exploited by upper caste
Swami Vivekanad said "It was the shudras of India who spread the Islam & Christianityby converting"
*and that prasad thing*
First of all brother there are many hindu temples who doesn't allow Dalits or Non-Hindus
first you are not allowing them to enter and then you are questing why aren't they accepting PRASADS
Like we forcefully grab SC ST OBC in India And don't let them intermingle as they may unite and our wrong use of religion for personal hegemony would go. It is not fluid to unite n love as free
Amol Chawhan Fact of patnaik is always baseless,he always tries to confuse hindus about their religion.Therefore self read grantha n books,because our owns knowledge helps us,not of other.N read the genuine books only.
Ankit Raj; Caste apartheid has been practiced for 2500 yrs against 15-20% Hindus called Shura also called Dalit, Harijan. untouchables. Yes Ankit, they are not allowed to enter many temples and come near the puja pandal. They have been raped, murdered with no consequence to the perpetrators. Buddha and Guru Nanak rejected Hinduism to chart separate paths.
Prosanto Mukerji , what do you actually wanna say , consent or partial disagree.
Actually segregation of people had been given in our texts for karna(greater fighter,kshatirya than arjun) as shudra or eklavya as no one part odd vedic system/society, as no even. They have been kept away since always n not just 500BC. Vedic shashtras expel hatred-n-ghettos for shudras and calling tribals n non Vedics as rakshas asuras danav n daityas. Caste( strict groups of sexual restrictions outside out with other caste crimes prathas that contrive today in mindset of people) become prominent in @1AD but hatred deceit violence existed long before since always.
vasco da gama was a tyrant he killed many Indians , captured land forcefully..Devdutt misleading many things to show Hinduism Christianity are not much different
naresh bandari May Jesus bless Vasco da Gama !! 🙏🙏🙏
kiska mama? Any how watch this to see Devdatt Patnaik's farce ... ruclips.net/video/vtkMFLuOa3M/видео.html
chrisinity kill many peopl for spred of theri religion
Bryan W.H. Schmidt, You forgot to add "and the other European Pirates that accompanied him" Why be mean on blessings? I always find it amusing how European pirates took their god along with them. guilty conscience? just a thought. Anyway on a lighter note, other than piracy, pillage and plunder anyone know any valuable contribution to human civilization made by the Portuguese? No? me neither, none that immediately spring to mind, guess we'll have to do a google search then. Loot, now that's a Hindi word used by Indians to describe what the Europeans did, funny how it ended up in the English language.
You are absolutely right but the history of Christianity in India actually dates back to the time of Jesus. There are some St. Thomas Christians or also known as Kurien Christians in Kerala who came to India in the second century. Although most of them were forced to convert by the European settlers or they converted themselves because of the caste system in Hinduism
Im loving the diversity here
Jain dharam ki Jai ho
JAI HINDU SANATANA DHARMAM
Hinduism also has a concept of No God or can not be known Agnostic. Hinduism has Monotheism, Polytheism, Pantheism and Agnostic concepts.
Tell me 😂 which Hindu did not believe in God of course you are not atheist to
5:16 devdutt is saying that abrhamic God is 'nirgun' while it clearly is not as he has anger, love hate etc. Devdutt is using nirgun to be synonymous to formless which is wrong and hee also abrahmic God does have form . For e.g. as per bible God created humans in his own image. Muhammad met Allah. So Devdutt's understanding of concept of nirgun and formlessness is shallow.
Sarvesh Dev bhai ye satya bol ra hi...main difference in their and ours is we worship human form,we worship ahimsa ..bhai ek bat janlo..krishna ho chaliya bola gya hi..I mean he is playing with all religion faith,even with every atom,...agar wo indra swarg k raja ko respect karte hi then..unne daityaraj bali ko bhi...amar hone ka vardan diya hi...so he respect everyone...so he say in geeta na mera koi apna hi na koi paraya he is not fix with any specific religion but ...when his ...land of leela means bharat get destroyed
..then he takes avtar...
twitter.com/Aabhas24/status/1082119964906012673?s=19
Check this Tweet. About this man
Jai shree karishna
nice sir 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏👌👌👌👌👌
Nice video
हमको इसका पुरा विडीयो देखने को कैसे मिलेगा
laxmi kant Chaurasia don't watch
This is something i was looking from long time ,short description of all my religious questions ...
Thanks devdutt patnaik
This guy is very dangerous... don't trust him
Please uplpad full episodes on the chennel so that we can see it if miss
Believe in god but don't depend on him😀. And if you believe that there is an energy beyond science then it god❤️... no matter which religion u belong or which god you believe. Pray to the power and not to the face.🙏🙏
Nice thought
Rasika Duggal??
Wnderful
koi yeh bataye ke us jamane mei jab log bahar se aate the tab vo communicate kaise karte the kyunki sabki.language alag thi... phir baat kaise karte the???
One big difference, Hindus like our natural secular culture but christianity like islam is naturally communal.
Comment me sab gyaani log gyan baat rhe😁
Devadatt sir! I'm big fan of yours.
Devdutt doesn't know anything about Hindu Vedas. Don't currupt your mind by listening his currupt thoughts.
He is talking about Christianity
@@gogolacc3837 I am saying in general... don't corrupt your mind by his currupt thoughts.
Veda dekhaa hai bey? teraa baap bhi nehi padhaa hogaa tu Brahmin nehi hai toh padhaa kab veda?
@@jogensahu mere baap ne padha hai....lagta hai tumhare baap ne nahi padha hai 😂 Naam se angrez lagti ho....baap angrez hai apka?
@@AmanSinghARSI iske baap ne bas rice khaya.
Adhyatma is to purify our atma enlighten the spirituality. It is essential for every human irrespective of Dharma cast and cread.
This time patnaik is talking like mohandas Gandhi ... Neglected the truth.... Goan inquisition has not been talked of.
Don't worry 90percent of his knowledge is wrong
Yesu Ka janm se calendar calu hy
T0 krition 2000years pshale kese Aaye
Confusion cler kare
Calender start nahi hua use Zero mana gaya hai. Before Christ ko negative pattern mein aur After death ko positive pattern mein sequence kiya jata hai. Bilkul ek number line jaise.
Devdutt ji 🙏 namaskar.
I am your big fan.. 💐
This guy is real mythologist, there is no evidence of Thomas coming to India.
1) Is there any evidence for Christ? 2) Why do you need evidence in faith? 3) Are you confused person? 3) RAM is follower of dharma not maker, so what is your issue? 4) You cannot understand metaphor that is a fact, people will laugh at your explanation 5) What do you want to say? 6) He should open mind in what? 7) when are you planning to open your mind? 7) How those things affecting your life? 8) Are you a murk?
9) Truth is bitter - you are using electronic system based on Hindu Binary system instead of being grateful to the people you are confused and abusing the very people who feeds you.
10) First stop learning Hindu numerals and binary system and then we will have conversation?
Prosanto Mukerji you obviously don't understand the difference between symbolic truth and literal truth. Stay cool, braj.
@@prosantomukerji3931 No need to get excited. He just meant that there is no historical evidence. There is no reference by any contemporary historians of the time about the coming of Thomas to India. The person who came to India might be another Thomas but not one of the apostles. You should check out the books by religious historian Robert Eric Frykenberg.
As for Raam, it is a very old event to have physical historical evidence. It is like saying that there is no evidence of Abraham's stick or chappals so he did not exist. Nevertheless, there is a lot of circumstantial evidence to the existence of Raam. Like the names of places, locations and cities visited by Raam and co. during their Vanvasa. Also the existence of Rama Setu between India and Sri Lanka which has been identified to be an artificial structure and very old.
@Ashramedia That is not the verification of the book, novel or the movie but the incident that they describe.
If multiple sources give you the same observation, that is scientific. Even historically, if multiple sources describe the same historical event, then it is taken as an actual event.
The validity Ramayana and Mahabharata is not that it has description of different places. But the fact that all these places has the same events being recorded in their local folklore.
Wait bro do you not a follower of God
यह अंग्रेजी में बाइबिल है। आराम करने या सोने के लिए सुनो
Nice
I'm Catholic 😊 guy ... Before that I'm an indian ...
Shubham Tigga before everything we r Human being .. Beautiful Souls 🙏🙏
Do you believe that earth is flat?
@@OblivionZXZ not necessary that we have to follow whatever religion we belong from. Religion & religious books r made by a human according to his principal, every individual have their own principal.
@@OblivionZXZ I believe that religion is just a life style & nothing more than that. For ex- the outfits, the designs of church, temples .
@@OblivionZXZ polygamy is allowed in most of the religion & marrying with their cousins is allowed in some of the religion including South Indian Hindus but civilized people don't follow these things. We r Indians and will only follow our constitution 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Sanatan Dharma se nikla ek A Brahamn ka manegement.
Sir Devdutt sant of India like kabir or guru nank and other sant should be discussed in detail
Ashok Talreja ,
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
3:54 Hindu religion Vs Abrahamic
Khajuraho Mandir ka nirman Chandel Rajaon ne karaya . Jinki Rajdhani Mahoba Bundelkhand thi .
3:56 You're dead wrong, All 'ism' are bound by the law of karma.
It is the one eternal law.
calling Christianity, Islam a dharma is the biggest mistake people always did. Dharma never means religion,
Panth means religion. Dharma's definition is very much different and elaborate. So please never calls religion = dharma.
Religion is Dharma! There is no difference. Every Religion or Dharma teaches, philosophy or way of life through its teachings.
@@st.mephisto8564 Totally wrong definition of Dharma.
( Religion = Mahajab ) ≠ Dharma.
1) यतो अभ्युदय निः श्रेयस सिद्धि सह धर्मः |
>अर्थात - जिससे हमारे जीवन का समग्र व भौतिक उत्कर्ष हो उसको धर्म कहते है |
> Means - That which leads to the overall and material prosperity of our life is called Dharma.
2) धारयति इति धर्मः|
अर्थात > जो धारण करने योग्य है वही धर्म है |
Means > That which is worth ingurgitate is Dharma.
3) धृतिः क्षमा दमोऽस्तेयं शौच इन्द्रियनिग्रहः |
धीर्विधा सत्यमकोर्धो दशकं धर्मलक्षणम् ||
अर्थात > धृति(धैर्य), क्षमा(दयालुता), दम(बुरे विचारों का दमन), अस्तेय (चोरी न करना), शौच( कार्मिक, वाचिक, मानसिक, आर्थिक वगैरह सब प्रकार कि पवित्रता), इन्द्रियनिग्रह (इन्द्रियों पर नियंत्रण), धीरे(सद्बुद्धि), विधा, सत्य भाषण, आक्रोश- ये धर्म के 10 लक्षण हैं |
Means > i.e. Dhriti (patience), Kshama (kindness), Dum (suppression of bad thoughts), Asteya (not stealing), Shaucha (purity of all kinds, karmic, verbal, mental, economic etc.), Indriyanigraha (control of the senses), Dhi (good intellect), Rightful Education, truthful speech, resentment - these are the 10 characteristics of Dharma.
Dharma is a very widespread concept, you cannot bind it into small and narrow path of religion. So please update your knowledge on DHARMA.
Christianity starts from Jesus, Islam start from Muhammad, from where Sanatan Dhama start?
@@tushar1990able Lol you cannot just redefine Religion because of the stigma attached to it.
Religion cannot be not a narrow path, because Religion is itself a category.
Religion is a social-cultural system of designated behaviors and practices, morals, beliefs.
All the examples you gave, of kindness, not stealing, purity, intellect are also taught in Religion. Hereby Dharma is also a Religion.
What you can say is one Religion is better than the other, but it still remains a Religion.
Sanatan Dharma has many founders, not one but I would suppose it began with the Vedas, Upanishads around 1500BC
@@st.mephisto8564 Ohk. Only one question and depend on your answer I will reply otherwise I will stop this conversation. According to you Ramayan and Mahabharat , REAL OR MYTH?
@@tushar1990able They are stories which could be based on Real history
Beena bhabhi aap yaha kaise?????
I am joining
Christianity & Bible ( 2000 Years Before ) !
Love him because he never bashes other religions he just provide a simple explanation behind everything
Believing in God is not centrality of Hinduism.
❤❤🙏
Like only for epic channel....
मुझे आज पता चला जोनी लिवर गीता विश्वास नगमा इत्यादि खुलेआम इसाई धर्म का प्रचार करते हैं
दोनों को ही धर्म का मतलब नहीं पता । धर्म का कोई भी पर्यायवाची शब्द नहीं है।
आर्य विशु मंढान chal nikal
जो धारण करने योग्य हो धर्म है।
Bhai ki naak band hai thodi Verna awaz bahut achhi hai
बुद्ध हि सत्य हे
try to experience God not to Believe God
Believe change
Insan ki aastha hi kisi ko bhi bhagvan aur bhakt bnati h🙏
Mai hath jodkar ek vinti karna chaunga ki apne channel mai se gobar bhakto ki comments ko delete kijiye
पता नहीं क्यों मुझे ये कालीन भईया को पत्नी लग रही हैं 😍😂😂😂🙏🙏just kidding
What about Portuguese who killed thousands of Hindus in Goa.
He will not talk about that because he will loose the tag of intellectual
Portuguese were oppressing Orthodox Christians in India too, ever heard of Coonan Cross Covenant?
He says “Nirguna” and explains no form. No form is “Nirakaar” not “Nirgun”. He doesn’t know anything. Simply promoting Christianity. Vatican denied that St. Thomas arrived in India. At least learn that. Also learn that after Christ got crucified almost 50 years no one spread Christianity anywhere. In fact there were no concept of Christianity.
Please provide evidence that Christ ever existed first?
Hello bro ... He is very knowledgeable person ... Uske aas pas bhi nai hai humlog... Nirakar to aam janta bolti hai but philosophy me nirgun hi bola jata hai ... Nirgun and sagun ... Bhakism
And st. Thomas ki coffin with his body is kept in india... Kaha se pdhe likhe ho yar
Where did he promote Christianity?
Say something about buddhism caves in maharashtra
Whatever devduttji said is absolutely right.
amazing
Facts based knowledge 👍
Karma dharma moksha
Kaleen bhaiya.......
Nirgun does not mean formless. It is Nirakar. In bible, God created humans in his own image, which means God has form of human. So all are fiction. We are talking about Man as God here.
So about in Jews mystic there is concept of en solf that is infinity
Mam I respect every religion but you should 😅 understand everything about other religions and then speaks
@@ignacelakra6777 I was talking about bible. How talking about bible is same as talking about all religions?
BTW concept infinity is also a bad qualifier for divinity. It is still a very narrow understanding
@@maddybharathi so what is divinity then
@@ignacelakra6777 divinity is not infinity. Divinity is all pervading beyond space and time. Infinity is still bound within the 3d dimension because infinity doesn't look beyond material perspective. Mathematics is material subject. All philosophy or knowledge about religion or spirituality is still material part. But spirituality itself is not.
@@maddybharathi so which religion is true then ?
Agar hinduo ko sanatan dharm k bare me janna hi h toh asli aur sahi granth pade thoda samay deke,na ki aise chuthiya shows aur chuthiya logo ki sune,khud ka gyan hi sach (satya) tk pahuchata h na ki dushro ka,aur ramayan sirf valmiki ji ki hi pade,aur thodi sanskrit shi source se sikhe na ki western sanskrit,kyunki kuch western professors ne kuch milawate kr di h.
Get Thrilled Bhai loog decided Kar lege kaun sahi Hai kuan galat
Get Thrilled u r right
Hihi aub yay granth bataingay😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Devdutt patnaik is real gem of India.
Isai dharam 2000 Saal pahle duniya me Aya 200 Saal pahle bharat me Aya 800 Saal ham hinduo aur sikho ne jang ladi pta nhi us time ye Jesus kha tha
sir christianity 52 ad my hi aagya tha
2000 sall sy try kar rahaya hai bharat ko christianty karnya ki ,magar na safal hua thay ,na hai aur na hi hogya
@@aryawartaabhishek6654 ji ha ap Sahi kah rhe h
Hindu sabhi dharm ke bhagwaan ko sweekar krte hai sabme ishwar ko hi dekhte hai
Don't read comments it is filled with hatred , ignorance and arrogance.
app yeh Sach kah rahe ho Roman Catholic or Hinduism bahut baat Same hai
Too good
The best Host of This Show .
Please bring her back .
That another Anchor is very Rude / Sounds unprofessional / Amateur / Lack of Knowledge .
If You guys want to increase the Standard of this Divine Show .
Plz change that Anchor .
I think , It's Ms . Shetty
KonFusion Band no she is miss rasika dubey
Teen din to hue nhi the Friday to crucify hue nd sunday to ressurect hue
He said "hathya huyi" like it's nothing
Check Rajiv malhotra video on him.
Rajiv Malhotra is that joker who said we will take money from Bill gates and give to him after his death
It's simply proves tat before Christianity there was Hinduism religion and after christanity also there will be Hinduism.... And yeah those ppl who converted into Christian wer either small caste ppl or they wer force to accept christanity on the bases of power....
😂😂😂 thoda goa inquisition ke baare mai padho uske baad yahan aakar bakchodi Krna.
There are Syrian Christians in kerala
Wait the St Thomas tale is proven fake
Wrong answer about इसाई धर्म भारत कब आया
wrong ya hai ,ya log convert karatya hai ,issliya time batana zaroori hai 2000 say try kar rahya hai ,aur aaj bhi zari hai ,magar humarai sanskriti ko khatam karna itna asan nahi hai
Jesus is not god he is just a buddhist monk
Kaal; What an ignorant bigoted murk!
He never existed, so can you provide evidence of a non-existed person to be a monk? What do you drink?
Hahahahaha isliye bharat me.pdhe likhe gawaar hai
ha ha ha ha you are best comedian.
ABE PAGAL GAND , JESUS IS SON OF GOD NOT BUDDHIS MONK . JESUS IS NOT GOD BUT SON OF GOD .
All the chutiyas in the comments be talking like they're saints
Ace Jiffers yeah😂😂😂
Pls convey this information in english
Pehli bat christianity bharat me 2000 saal pehle nhi aayi h ,yeh bilkul galat h.Aur devendra jee aap santan dharm ko apne mutabik tod marod kr pesh krte h,jb santan dharm k bare me sare grantho me likha h to aap apni books me use apne mutabik pesh kr,use galt sabit kr logo ko gumrah kr rhe h.
If you have knowledge then please tell here, don't bark without knowledge !! First prove here !!! I m ready for a great debate !!! I have lots of facts ! Get set go buddy !!! Please reply
Misleading and ignorant
Bryan W.H. Schmidt, You forgot to add "and the other European Pirates that accompanied him" Why be mean on blessings? I always find it amusing how European pirates took their god along with them. guilty conscience? just a thought. Anyway on a lighter note, other than piracy, pillage and plunder anyone know any valuable contribution to human civilization made by the Portuguese? No? me neither, none that immediately spring to mind, guess we'll have to do a google search then. Loot, now that's a Hindi word used by Indians to describe what the Europeans did, funny how it ended up in the English language.
Sarvesh Dev bhai ye satya bol ra hi...main difference in their and ours is we worship human form,we worship ahimsa ..bhai ek bat janlo..krishna ho chaliya bola gya hi..I mean he is playing with all religion faith,even with every atom,...agar wo indra swarg k raja ko respect karte hi then..unne daityaraj bali ko bhi...amar hone ka vardan diya hi...so he respect everyone...so he say in geeta na mera koi apna hi na koi paraya he is not fix with any specific religion but ...when his ...land of leela means bharat get destroyed
..then he takes avtar
sir devi kali Satan hai Kyuki
This dambo just trying to change the history of India. He is telling the mythology like he was there when so called jusus deciple came to india.
2000 pahel kaise? Syrian orthodox Cristian 5 vi sadi baad aaye hoge iska koi paka sabut nahi, pahel Jesus khud aaye thain North Tibet Buddhism Sikh ne unka ek kaber gha bhi North jis abhi kashmir kahte Russian author ki kitab unknown life Jesus crist padlo
Christian is fearing religion.. just business religion
02:08 Haa ye kalpanik kahani hi hai.
Ye to humare Nawaz bhai bhi kar lete hai 'Maut ke tak se chhukar vapas aa sakta hu' haaaaaa
kanyakumari two sister bhagwati ,vilakani bath sea Fishman nut chahiye to come forum vila veni really history not reported why secularism
Wrong information sir,
Need to read the Bible and understand
yes, Muslim only belive that Jesus is not son of god, he was a messenger, and also that prophet Mohammad is the last prophet, and its also mentioned in BIBLE, A MUSLIM MUST LOVE JESUS (ISA) IN ORDER TO BE A MUSLIM....
These are all false things said to Hindus... devdutt is destroying Hindu Dharma and sanatan dharma Sanatan Dharma was the oldest religion that is all over bharat.....which was way before chritanity and Islam
पूर्ण मुडंन सिर्फ बुद्दीस्ट में होता हे
sab "shiv" ka hai ... sab shiv hai... kan kan main dhiv hai... sab nasht ho jayega ... bs shiv hi rahege ...
devdut ji bhagwan or ishwar frak hai, bhagwan ek form hai jaise pahelwan hota Jo insaan karishma kar ta bhagwan kah te hai ishwar infinite hai woh brhamad har ek atom hai ishwar koi swar ya akar hai bhi or nahi bhi is koi samjha nahi sakta