It'a so lovely that the mother still covers the boy with blanket even tho she was crying earlier that day from her son exchanging the cow for a bean. Now that's truly love. ❤️
I always wondered why they never took the beans off the beanstalk and sold them. Like. It's a BEANstalk. It has BEANS. GIANT MAGIC BEANS. That's worth something right?? Right???
I had only heard the Giant version with the harp, this one is just as lovely, although I always wondered why the kid payed the wife's kindness by stealing her husband, that's not so nice.
The image of the dragon in Hungarian folk tales is not exactly the same as the reptilian monster of European legends, but rather a humanoid figure with one or more heads, endowed with human characteristics. Each dragon's head symbolizes a soul.
@@DannyConeHeadOnceLer As is the story in "Hungarian Folk Tales: The Giant Tree" (in native language The Tree That Reaches The Sky) wich is the same story as this from a different angle, and the beanstalk is a tree.
This one reminds me of that one adventure of Thor and Tyr, to obtain a cauldron from Tyr's giant father, just with the added beanstalk and with less fighting.
Elaine Canby is right. This tale comes directly from the legend of Jack and the beanstalk, which is from Cornwall, England. This tale originated with real events in early English history, taking place at a place called St. Michaels, a popular tourist site today. The Hungarian tale comes from the original, with it's "Fe Fi Fo Fum, I smell the blood of an Englishman". It's not just some silly children's story. And it's not from Hungary.
@@PixieDust18 Le Petit Poucet also stole the magic object of the ogre. His seven league boots. But this is the only thing alike in both those stories. Except for the ogre’s wife who is kind
Cows where never eaten back then, it was a treasure that gave milk everyday. I don’t even know why he went to sell the cow for the money. They would earn it would but it would be soon all spent
That would be a waste of a cow! The cow gives milk which can be drank, plus the cow can be bred to have calves that can be sold. Bad use of a cow to eat it, then they’d have nothing to sell anymore
Grimms tale is different because there is a giant and has a golden harp which plays when he orders it to. And it reminds me of the Disney version. Somehow
So this kid took accepted only 1/5 the price the English 'Jack' got for his cow (most English versions specify 5 beans or say 'a handful') and only got the chicken, not the harp or the sacks of money. But at least his mum still loved him enough to offer him dinner and tuck him in.
I like this virsion of jack and the beanstock more, also 50% of comments: oh poor dragon's wife, her husband was killed other 50% of comments: Hazah for the dragon's wife, for she is now free of her abusive husband
Tenth one with the title right, 10 out of 12. This one is basically "Jack and the Beanstalk", but instead of a giant it's a hydra (who looks more like a lizard man than a dragon). P.S. The magic man who exchanges the bean for the cow has a similar design to the shepherd from "Only Donkeys Don't Eat the Spoon".
Elaine Canby I think the dragon is depicted as someone with a human-like form, because in ancient Hungarian legends dragons possessed many human-like qualities (they were more like spirits of the underworld). Also, he had 3 heads, as in Hungary dragons always have multiple heads (either 3, 7, 9 or 12, as those are symbolic/ magical numbers). We used to have a very cute Puppet Show called "Dummy the Dragon" (Süsü a Sárkány) which was about a humble, but slightly mentally challenged dragon who had only one head, so he was constantly ridiculed and bullied by the other dragons, but he always saved the day in the end.
In Brazilian version of the tale the villain is Aunyaina, a ogre with boar's head and tusks but also likes to eat human flesh like any other fairy tale giant.
Its so weird how att the end of every Hungarian folk tale the narrator said "And if you don't believe my story..." or "If my story wasnt true..." etc and then followed by the most useless "proof" ever.
I wonder why that there isn't much adaptations like this A dragon 3-headed or not that was in the giant's place instead still the same story and characters
evey time i come back to watch these i have so many questions, some examples could be; what did that guy who magically appered do with the cow and how did the wife and the dragon end up together i would love to hear that story why didnt jack think ooh i should pass down som beans down to sell them ofr make food, is the moon not reaol in that world but a hole that showcases a brighter world i could go on but in need to finish the story first oh and one more can the golden eggs hatch and if they do coulg you make and infinite black chicken glitch, but as im reading this i realize that wont work cause you need bothe ra cockrel and a hen so never mind that last one intead caun we think about how that man aqquired the beans anf was he like a fairy of sorts and .......
It'a so lovely that the mother still covers the boy with blanket even tho she was crying earlier that day from her son exchanging the cow for a bean.
Now that's truly love. ❤️
local boy robs dragon husband. Wife shook
Thou isth shookith
Shoz Chel *shooketh
I always wondered why they never took the beans off the beanstalk and sold them. Like. It's a BEANstalk. It has BEANS. GIANT MAGIC BEANS. That's worth something right?? Right???
lol ikr
True true true
That includes the other stories
Priceless
Hahaahahaha
I ain't gonna lie, that bed looks kinda comfy
True
You're not wrong.
So the wife is kind to the boy and he steals from her house and kills her husband i know hes cruel and all but who will fend for her now
well usually the dragon has stolen the maiden, so maybe he just liberated her
First off he's poor and she probably was kidnapped
@@pangaeus exactly
She even warned him and offered him food
Hid him from her EVIL hushband
Her own hushband is so abusive and scary ..
I don't know how the wife put up with her three headed dragon of a husband.
Really, you don't know? The heads !!!
All six of them.
@@morgantorium What do you mean six of them.
@@madisonwebster6490 I'm suggesting he had six heads, which could explain why she stayed with him.
@@morgantorium Don't worry - I got it :-D
I had only heard the Giant version with the harp, this one is just as lovely, although I always wondered why the kid payed the wife's kindness by stealing her husband, that's not so nice.
Look, kid, you can steal magic poultry all you want. But NO ONE messes with a Hurdy-Gurdy.
I like how they represent a dragon with an exaggerated humanoid!
They do that in just about all of the stories with dragons. Maybe that's how dragons are viewed in Hungary. But I'm not really sure.
That’s why, because the story of jack and the beanstalk has a dragon with three heads and three eyes
The image of the dragon in Hungarian folk tales is not exactly the same as the reptilian monster of European legends, but rather a humanoid figure with one or more heads, endowed with human characteristics. Each dragon's head symbolizes a soul.
Now the dragons wife is all alone 😢
and broke / poor too.
It is not known how she tought about her dragon-husband - this tale is from an era when arranged marriages were the norm.
At least that she doesn't have to deal with this monster for a hushband especially since he's very agressive and cruel
@@La-my8asd or was kidnapped
@@DannyConeHeadOnceLer As is the story in "Hungarian Folk Tales: The Giant Tree" (in native language The Tree That Reaches The Sky) wich is the same story as this from a different angle, and the beanstalk is a tree.
A twist to Jack and the Beanstalk!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Exactly !!
@@DannyConeHeadOnceLer or is vJack and the beanstalk a twist to this?!
the original history
...not really. The overall arc of the story is precisely the same. No meaningful changes have been made.
Basically the Hungarian version of Jack and the Beanstalk.
wife= maiden that was never rescued...
So the guy selling the magic beans apparently when to both Hungary and England! 😂
This one reminds me of that one adventure of Thor and Tyr, to obtain a cauldron from Tyr's giant father, just with the added beanstalk and with less fighting.
Elaine Canby is right. This tale comes directly from the legend of Jack and the beanstalk, which is from Cornwall, England. This tale originated with real events in early English history, taking place at a place called St. Michaels, a popular tourist site today. The Hungarian tale comes from the original, with it's "Fe Fi Fo Fum, I smell the blood of an Englishman". It's not just some silly children's story. And it's not from Hungary.
There is a French version of this tale. It is called “Little Thumb”. It is also the type of AT 328 - The Boy steals the treasures of the Giant
What does AT mean?
@@bcjmythical9576 Aarne Thompson classification of folk tales
You are confusing " le petit poucet " and " jack et le haricot magique"
@@PixieDust18 Le Petit Poucet also stole the magic object of the ogre. His seven league boots. But this is the only thing alike in both those stories. Except for the ogre’s wife who is kind
the title: the giant *bean* stalk
the thumbnail: **proceeds to show chili and a flower**
Not a chili, that's a bean pod (think peas)
So basically the boy robs the giant, murders him and becomes rich. Wow. Just wow.
I mean, to be fair, the giant/dragon was going to kill him... that sill leaves his wife's fate up in the air, though...
The woman marrying a dragon is far more realistic than why the boy and her mom didn't just slaughter and eat the cow if they were so poor.
Cows where never eaten back then, it was a treasure that gave milk everyday. I don’t even know why he went to sell the cow for the money. They would earn it would but it would be soon all spent
That would be a waste of a cow! The cow gives milk which can be drank, plus the cow can be bred to have calves that can be sold. Bad use of a cow to eat it, then they’d have nothing to sell anymore
Any possibility that the boy name is ‘Jack’?
Grimms tale is different because there is a giant and has a golden harp which plays when he orders it to. And it reminds me of the Disney version. Somehow
I thought the boy couldn’t eat supper because there was nothing to eat. Not because he was excited for his magic bean
So this kid took accepted only 1/5 the price the English 'Jack' got for his cow (most English versions specify 5 beans or say 'a handful') and only got the chicken, not the harp or the sacks of money. But at least his mum still loved him enough to offer him dinner and tuck him in.
That hen still lays golden eggs. Hungarian Jack is still set.
The dragon looked more like a giant to me.
True
I mean this was the 70s is some Soviet country. They didn't have the talent or budget for a real dragon so they had to make due with a man in a suit.
@@CrossBorderNerds Hungary
Did anyone notice jack is wearing high heels?
No
In the past, men wore high heels. It helped them stay on the horse
JACK AND THE BEANSTALK
I like this virsion of jack and the beanstock more, also
50% of comments: oh poor dragon's wife, her husband was killed
other 50% of comments: Hazah for the dragon's wife, for she is now free of her abusive husband
How would a nice woman like that ended up with a three faced monster?
Probably kidnapped
It could also be that golden egg laying chicken
I thought a hurdy gurdy was some kind of undergarment
This one seems normal enough...
"My Husband is a three headed dragon who plays the hurdy gurdy"
Ah.. there it is =]
Haha
I need a chicken like that!🤑
Tenth one with the title right, 10 out of 12. This one is basically "Jack and the Beanstalk", but instead of a giant it's a hydra (who looks more like a lizard man than a dragon). P.S. The magic man who exchanges the bean for the cow has a similar design to the shepherd from "Only Donkeys Don't Eat the Spoon".
Elaine Canby I think the dragon is depicted as someone with a human-like form, because in ancient Hungarian legends dragons possessed many human-like qualities (they were more like spirits of the underworld). Also, he had 3 heads, as in Hungary dragons always have multiple heads (either 3, 7, 9 or 12, as those are symbolic/ magical numbers). We used to have a very cute Puppet Show called "Dummy the Dragon" (Süsü a Sárkány) which was about a humble, but slightly mentally challenged dragon who had only one head, so he was constantly ridiculed and bullied by the other dragons, but he always saved the day in the end.
@@elodmarton9588 How very interesting! I would like to learn Hungarian. Would you recommend anything to help me learn?
In Brazilian version of the tale the villain is Aunyaina, a ogre with boar's head and tusks but also likes to eat human flesh like any other fairy tale giant.
i mean jack and the beanstalk
where is that place exactly?
Its so weird how att the end of every Hungarian folk tale the narrator said "And if you don't believe my story..." or "If my story wasnt true..." etc and then followed by the most useless "proof" ever.
As many peoples, as many types of tales, as many stories, as many storytellers, as many endings.
I wonder why that there isn't much adaptations like this
A dragon 3-headed or not that was in the giant's place instead still the same story and characters
Based in the fairy tale, Jack and the beanstalk
I know that story its jack in the beanstalk
The house moving to the hilltop 😂
I prefer this version of Jack and the beanstalk.
Old stories make absolutely no sense, but It's fun to listen to them anyway.
So... you're saying the wife is single now?
Yeah or free roaming around with a better hushband on her side
Gonna drop some beans and pay her a visit?
The og jack and the beanstalk
Hey. The boy's name is Jack! Right?
So that’s all he said? Plant the bean and see what happens. That’s all?
To think almost everyone who heard jack and the bean stalk thinks it's a giant
A 3 headed Ganondorf?
@6:00 "And if you don't believe my story, you can go..." **** yourself =P
Now the question is... who ripped off who?
I like the princess storys
Very gracious.
different version, but the same story. the Magyar story tellers seem to like three-headed giant men/monsters. 🐲
I was the thousandth's like on this video :D
Is the boy's name Jack by any chance?
beautiful
so what happened to the Dragon's Kind wife?
This is where jack and the bean stolk originated from? Wow
army be everywhere jungkookiex no, the original story is from england,1734 💜
Many of these folk tales are similar to ones told in other cultures. They circulate around.
As others have said, there is no definitive "original" version of these stories.
So this is like jack and the beanstalk
The cows name was milky white
5:55 - beautiful music? I beg to differ.
Hey ! I know this dragon !
Giant had a baddie for a wife….why would broski threaten to hurt his own wife
Preach 🙌 she is stacked
It's like jack the giant Slayer
But what about the dragon's kindly wife...?
I think she still loves their or she escaped
Where is the place? Drop me an address
Jack and the beanstalk anyone?
evey time i come back to watch these i have so many questions, some examples could be; what did that guy who magically appered do with the cow and how did the wife and the dragon end up together i would love to hear that story why didnt jack think ooh i should pass down som beans down to sell them ofr make food, is the moon not reaol in that world but a hole that showcases a brighter world i could go on but in need to finish the story first oh and one more can the golden eggs hatch and if they do coulg you make and infinite black chicken glitch, but as im reading this i realize that wont work cause you need bothe ra cockrel and a hen so never mind that last one intead caun we think about how that man aqquired the beans anf was he like a fairy of sorts and .......
Fee Fi Fo Fum
3:01 Huh.
3:03 WHAT 😂😂
Interesting
Wait... is this original to Jack and the Beanstalk?
The English version is the original.
These are folk tales, nobody truly knows where the originals are from. Most of them still existed at the ancient Egyptian era in some forms.
Jack?
The giantess may be kind but she's no MILF
Um WRONG