47:12 “throw in a little Black Mirror” No no no, good sir, you are forgetting that Community did it first! App Development and Condiments came out in 2014 while Nosedive (the Black Mirror episode that also has apps that rate people and ratings determine social status) came out in 2016!
Yeah I noticed that as well. It's one of the few times where people mistake a typical community parody when in reality they likely inspired the Black Mirror episode.
i don’t think he’s saying that they’re parodying black mirror, i think he just meant that the episode had a familiar feeling or concept to what you’d see in black mirror, unintentionally
I've wondered sometimes what the show might have been like if Elroy (Keith David) had been there from the start, instead of Pierce (Chevy Chase)... But then that would have thrown off the dynamics and all that...
4:19 You missed the whole point. Jeff by the end of the episode still doesn't believe in the fake illness. But Jeff dropped everything against him because he related to Chang on wanting to have a fresh restart in life.
I also think he made a mistake placing this as the worst episode, it has a bunch of funny moments and is way better than economic of marine biology or basic story.
36:58 Fun Fact: This episode is actually written by Jim Rash which I think is the reason it's so much better than the rest of season four and part of the reason it's so loved by the fandom. I mean the man is an Oscar winner for goodness sake.
@@ayushbajaj4708The jokes in general in season 4 are lazy and not clever. But, there are definitely some pretty good episoded regardless. I actually really like the puppet episode. The songs are beautiful and really catchy, and Jeff helping Shirley feel okay was heartwarming
I have a theory that (due to Dan Harmon discussing S4 concepts in episode commentaries) that Dan Harmon wrote the skeletal structure for Season 4 just before the fired him
Nah, they just pulled from a big idea board they had in the writer’s room. I don’t think he was planning much for the season, he doesn’t write big arcs in advance usually. You can hear him discuss episode concepts sometimes in early Harmontown
ulled from a big idea board they had in the writer’s room. I don’t think he was planning much for the season, he doesn’t write big arcs in advance usually. You can hear him discuss episode concepts sometimes in early Harmontown
@@teej7244 the ending of Season 3 seemed to foreshadow a lot that Season 4 would pick up on (Chang scheming w City College, Jeff's dad,), so there must have been some long-term concepts set up
Starburn's death came out of nowhere because they were still playing off the Law & Order schtick.... Law and Order would always have some wrench thrown in at the very end after everything was tied up in a nice little bow. I thought even that aspect of the episode was perfectly on brand
It came about because the actor was also a writer and producer on the show and didn’t want to act any more so that he could focus on his behind the scenes work.
The glee club Christmas episode has become my fav non paintball episode. It's even my fav Christmas thing to watch every year. Also what makes remedial chaos theory so good is that it shows you how the group is effected by not having one person present. When Jeff leaves everyone is happier. When Troy leaves the world ends. Good stuff.
Pillows and Blankets is probably #2 for me (since nothing can beat RCT). I have never seen any parody of anything that was more accurate and hilarious as this episode parodied Civil War documentaries.
A lot of people put Modern Warfare at the top and I get it, it's amazing but nothing, and I mean NOTHING tops RCT. And like you, I think I might put Pillows and Blankets in the 2 spot.
About geothermal escapism. I really liked the subtle nod to an earlier episode where troy said Come Sail away by Stix always makes him cry and then it was the song played when he left.
Man, I remember watching remedial chaos theory for the first time. Once I finished, I immediately called my friend and told my wife at the time that we all had to watch it together cause it was the best episode I had ever seen. Absolute perfection.
My roommate sat the rest of us down for Remedial Chaos Theory and then we proceeded to marathon the whole thing as a family (except we watched the first episode of season 4 then skipped the gas leak year and came back to it out of a sense of duty when we had Community Hangover and needed some hair of the dog)
Something you missed in #103 (ep. 509) was the fact that the "cowboy" on the VHS Abed and Annie were watching is Vince Giligan, the creator of Breaking Bad, so yeah that was definitely intentional.
The 10/10 S tier episodes for me are: Comparative Religion, Modern Warfare, Epidemiology, Cooperative Calligraphy, Conspiracy Theories and Interior Design, Mixology Certification, Advanced Dungeons and Dragons, Intermediate Documentary Filmmaking, Paradigms of Human Memory, A Fist Full of Paintballs/For a Few Paintballs More, Competitive Ecology, Remedial Chaos Theory, Documentary Filmmaking: Redux, Regional Holiday Music, Basic Lupine Urology, and Digital Estate Planning. It's hard to pick a favorite, but it might actually be Competitive Ecology.
Glad you appreciate GI Jeff. There’s some other guy on RUclips who calls it a terrible episode, and it just shows the depth and darkness is completely lost on him.
Glad to see you think Intro to Recycled Cinema is underrated. I can tell you that applies to the real world because the hand puppet prop from that episode was one of the cheapest props that got auctioned once the show ended. Citation: I own it.
Watching Modern Warfare for the first time absolutely blew my mind and it’s stayed as my favorite episode of the series. Also couldn’t agree more that season one Chang is absolutely the funniest character
The end of this video made me emotional 😭 Great list, I respect the time and effort that went into making this. You really did an awesome job of explaining your thoughts. Brb, gonna go re-watch the entire series again
Oh also when I first watched this and went to check who made this, I was expecting a 10-100k youtube artist based on the editing quality alone, I’m really suprised to see you’re not even over 1,000 subs. I’m excited to see how this channel grows
This video made me realize that Netflix doesn't have the episode "Advanced Dungeons and Dragons" for whatever reason. It was pretty funny because I had no idea that episode existed before you mentioned it as "a well-known episode". This definitely explains some jokes in later seasons about Fat Neil now, so thanks I guess.
Funnily enough, I think Repilot is in my top 20, maybe top 10 episodes. Idk, maybe I'm a fan of the parallels to the first ever episode, and maybe I just love seeing how far Jeff Winger has come as a character. It just really hits with me.
same, i think for me it’s that it is a masterclass in how to not just un-fuck a story or show, which would only revert it back to before it was fucked, but also shape it into something that reestablishes it’s greatness while advancing and building on it. the story is equal parts entertaining, shocking, believable, funny, sad, and injects hope into a story and a production which seemed to have lost it. most shows who had a “season 4” can’t recover from it, but this repilot says “get ready, we’re back, and soaring past your expectations.” plus all the actors do wonderfully, especially Joel, and the added comedy of the Shirley-spin-off-show is a fantastic way of explaining an actor’s sudden departure. overall it’s just a super tightly written episode with emotional heart that feels both plausible and brimming with potential for the season to come.
Fun fact: the reason I started watching this show was because my dad had a box set of the first 3 seasons. I didn’t pick it up until I started watching glee and my dad told me that there was a glee parody in it. So in a weird way my favorite bad show helped me find my favorite good show
6x12 "Wedding Videography" is truly peak comedy of Community If you wanna know "How truly chaotic this group was" 6x12 the best episode to describe how actually chaotic this group was
I knew it that remedial chaos theory is No.1! The episode shows how such small change can have a different outcome, and all characters in the episode is highlighted in each different universe. The best episode.. No, its the best comedy episode of all time!
Also I disagree with advanced advanced DnD having better pacing. As someone with a fairly unhealthy obsession with DnD and someone who can relate to both fat Neil and Pierce in that episode I can say that that episode is far more faithful to how playing DnD and especially older versions feels like. It also deals with heavy topics like bullying and suicidal thoughts pretty well showing how bullying can often be accidental, the impact of loneliness, and honestly how much someone else making an effort to simply play a game with you can be (hell I’d kill for that)
Community is by far My favorite show of all time. And this was a great list, enjoyed the analysis and the appreciation for this gem of a show! Of course can’t top Remedial Chaos Theory. And I agree that the first paintball episode took the show from exceptional to legendary.
I'm glad that someone else gave season 4 some love. The episodes are more so watered down but are still half decent. I myself am fond of: The Convention episode, The German episode, The Thanksgiving episode, The Puppet episode and The body swap episode. The issues are that most of the episodes don't expand on the concepts. So you have a paintball episode where the darkest timeline invades but it feels lacking because of the lack of exchanges between the study group and their evil selves.
You know? Honestly? Having just rewatched the series, this is a fantastic list. I couldn't agree more with your points on Remedial Chaos Theory, and I think I'm gonna rewatch it right now.
fun fact: when abed talks about crapping his pants on the set of cougar town he is actually in episode 21 of season 2 of cougar town. he is seen as a background extra who for seemingly no reason at all stands up and just sprints out of frame.
While I liked Pillows and Blankets, I thought it resolved Troy and Abed's fight in kind of a rushed way. The conflict was built up for several episodes and resolved in a minute without actually addressing the reason they were fighting in the first place. It was an opportunity for some character growth for Abed, to realize that he can hurt his friends' feelings when he doesn't account for them. Instead, "friendship hats" fixes their relationship. I also hate that the silver paintball plot point gets dropped in Modern Espionage. It's too clumsily abandoned to be considered a proper red herring, and the stinger should've been used to hint at if not outright reveal the silver paintball gunner's identity.
May I just applaud you on the music choice at the end. Not only does the instrumental "we think we know you" work so well with the vibe and editing of the final montage of the video, Bo Burnham himself is the only person I've seen have as subversive, meta and rewatchable comedy as community. There's a reason I have all of Bo Burnham's specials and a few episodes of community downloaded on netflix for long train rides.
I’ve watched this whole show more times than I can count. I stopped keeping track after 4. I think ima go through and do this too. What was your organization method?
Used an episode tier list I found online and wrote the entire script on google docs. I was rewatching the whole show with my dad who had never seen it before, and after each episode, I wrote a little review and ranked it on the tier list. I had multiple recurring tabs that I kept open bc this project took me 7 months.
The Christmas episode in season 4 didn't feel like a Christmas episode because it was a reference to die hard. Abed references die hard like 5 times, which if you don't know is an arguably Christmas movie despite not feeling very christmasy. It was a very clever homage honestly and even though the episode itself was shit, I liked how they did this.
i too love shirley and jeff! i think they had so much character potential together and i would have loved to see that fleshed out more. the moments they do have are great though and always make me smile ((:
The whole point of Chang being in dark elf face was not unlike RDJ in Tropic Thunder, making fun of cosplayers that go a little too far in their costumes, so it’s not so much being tasteless as much as it is making fun of tasteless people
This is offically one of my favorite genres of youtube, COMMUNITY CRACK! Like Community is such a comforting show for me, it's so nice for me, and Chang is literally one of my fav characters
I was surprised how good this video ended up being. I love how with every ranking video, the narrator becomes more passionate the higher on the list we get, and this video hits that right on the spot. That montage when you got to number one was amazing, and your explanation on Modern Warfare is something I couldn't have done better. You can be proud of yourself.
One thing that always amazed me about community was that it could do some many tv/movie homages while still being funny and unique. My biggest regret for the series was that we never got a full season with betty white teaching anthropology
the accuracy of this video is insane and i respect the dedication in the rewatch and rating. thanks for making this for me to watch instead of studying- so worth it
Fabulous video. I really appreciate how much work must have gone into this. I have so many disagreements about rankings, but to me that is precisely the point.
Loved this video. I am currently struggling getting through season 4 and it is reassuring knowing that some of the best episodes are still ahead! Thanks!
Hugely impressive work, man. Great video. I kept disagreeing with placements and then realised just how many fucking amazing episodes Community has, so even hilarious shit could be low on the ranking. What a show.
I think the problem with the inspector space time episode isn't that it isn't funny the pierce stuff is hilarious I think its because to get there the characters have to act way out of character
neglected to mention that vince gilligan was the guy in the vcr game Pile of Bullets, further tying into possible breaking bad parody that they didnt do for that episode
I decided to watch this specifically because of the age difference to see how you viewed the show.. and I must say very well crafted and while you may have missed some points of certain episodes, I’m sure with time and more experience when rewatching, you’ll see it differently. Great video bruh 👌🏾
I only recently started Community. Watched the pilot, part of season 1, and about 10 of the “best” episodes. Somehow, I’ve watched your video twice all the way through. Well done. Love the show.
This show just gets better and better every time u watch it and I don’t even think there’s a single episode that I absolutely dislike, truly streets ahead… anyways my top 10: 10. Cooperative Polygraphy 9. App Development and Condiments (this episode > Nosedive) 8. Mixology Certification 7. Pillows and Blankets 6. Wedding Videography (one of the most underrated episodes imo, absolutely love it) 5. Emotional Consequences of Broadcast Television (this title is perfect) 4. A Fistful of Paintballs & For a Few Paintballs More 3. Contemporary American Poultry 2. Modern Warfare 1. Remedial Chaos Theory (obviously) Honourable mentions: Debate 109, Basic Intergluteal Numismatics, Advanced Dungeons and Dragons, Epidemiology and Conspiracy Theories and Interior Design
I've seen every episode of this show at least 6 times and I gotta say... this list is really great. You explained a lot of my exact thoughts about things (for example, Communication Studies being the best "normal episode") and even the things I didn't agree on, your explanations were valid. I do think the puppet episode is as bad as people say because it feels like some shitty show trying to copy Community's formula. I also think Intro to Knots, the pilot and Studies in Modern Movement deserved to be higher and there were a few I'd personally move down, but that's just my opinion. Also I gotta appreciate the dunkey reference AND the love for Elroy, big W on that scene. Also also, DAMN you got some anime ass hair man, that's sick.
I just used a ranking Engine to rank the series since I've been watching it on repeat on Netflix for months. I removed the first Dungeons and Dragons episode because it's not on Netflix and I haven't seen it as many times as all the others and I don't remember it well enough to rank it against the others. 1 Remedial Chaos Theory 2 Epidemiology 3 A Fistful of Paintballs 4 Basic Intergluteal Numismatics 5 Conspiracy Theories and Interior Design 6 Intro to Felt Surrogacy 7 The First Chang Dynasty 8 Cooperative Calligraphy 9 Regional Holiday Music 10 Horror Fiction in Seven Spooky Steps 11 Basic Lupine Urology 12 Applied Anthropology and Culinary Arts 13 Digital Estate Planning 14 Basic Rocket Science 15 App Development and Condiments 16 Advanced Introduction to Finality 17 Investigative Journalism 18 Course Listing Unavailable 19 Curriculum Unavailable 20 Abed's Uncontrollable Christmas 21 Contemporary American Poultry 22 Advanced Gay 23 Intro to Recycled Cinema 24 Wedding Videography 25 Messianic Myths and Ancient Peoples 26 Celebrity Pharmacology 27 Romantic Expressionism 28 Aerodynamics of Gender 29 Advanced Safety Features 30 Competitive Ecology 31 Studies in Modern Movement 32 Paradigms of Human Memory 33 Asian Population Studies 34 Basic Genealogy 35 Basic Human Anatomy 36 Foosball and Nocturnal Vigilantism 37 Pascal's Triangle Revisited 38 The Politics of Human Sexuality 39 For a Few Paintballs More 40 Accounting for Lawyers 41 Modern Warfare 42 Documentary Filmmaking: Redux 43 Urban Matrimony and the Sandwich Arts 44 Mixology Certification 45 Advanced Criminal Law 46 Anthropology 101 47 Contemporary Impressionists 48 Interpretive Dance 49 Custody Law and Eastern European Diplomacy 50 Intro to Political Science 51 Beginner Pottery 52 Digital Exploration of Interior Design 53 Geothermal Escapism 54 Laws of Robotics and Party Rights 55 Virtual Systems Analysis 56 Intro to Knots 57 Geography of Global Conflict 58 Introduction to Finality 59 Herstory of Dance 60 Cooperative Polygraphy 61 Home Economics 62 Comparative Religion 63 Competitive Wine Tasting 64 Origins of Vampire Mythology 65 History 101 66 Introduction to Statistics 67 Introduction to Teaching 68 Paranormal Parentage 69 Pillows and Blankets 70 Grifting 101 71 The Psychology of Letting Go 72 Basic Email Security 73 The Art of Discourse 74 Critical Film Studies 75 Advanced Documentary Filmmaking 76 Bondage and Beta Male Sexuality 77 Communication Studies 78 Debate 109 79 Cooperative Escapism in Familial Relations 80 Basic Sandwich 81 English as a Second Language 82 Football, Feminism and You 83 Basic Crisis Room Decorum 84 Biology 101 85 Alternative History of the German Invasion 86 Early 21st Century Romanticism 87 The Science of Illusion 88 Pilot 89 Advanced Advanced Dungeons & Dragons 90 Modern Espionage 91 Physical Education 92 Intermediate Documentary Filmmaking 93 Introduction to Film 94 Basic Story 95 Economics of Marine Biology 96 Conventions of Space and Time 97 Lawnmower Maintenance and Postnatal Care 98 Emotional Consequences of Broadcast Television 99 Environmental Science 100 Spanish 101 101 Analysis of Cork-Based Networking 102 Basic RV Repair and Palmistry 103 Ladders 104 Repilot 105 Social Psychology 106 VCR Maintenance and Educational Publishing 107 Queer Studies and Advanced Waxing 108 Heroic Origins 109 G.I. Jeff
@@thelaggingcactus5488 Do people like GI Jeff? I didn't realize it was popular I feel like a lot of people don't like that one either? I watch the series all the way through a few times and I really didn't know that people didn't like season 4 that much. Felt surrogacy was one of my favorites on all of my re-watches I know it's not the deepest episode but I just love the puppets and the music. Then after seeing online opinions I realized that it was one of the fans least favorite episodes. But I thought I would be lying if I pretended it wasn't one of my favorites. I do understand people's arguments against it though.
@@Jessfrogger88 I agree about both G.I Jeff and Felt Surrogacy. The cartoon is more important to Jeff's arc than Felt is for anyone, but I don't look forward to seeing it again.
Loved this list! Only thing that I had a problem with is that the “parody” episodes aren’t actually parodies, they are homages and Harmon is very particular about them not being parodies.
Environmental science is one of my favorite episodes. I feel like it's the one that really sucks you in for good and starts to find it's footing. The end where they sing to Fievel while chang is dancing with his wife and pierce helps Shirley is when I really realized I was watching something special
Great list and great video by far. Community is one of those shows that, no matter how low on the list the episode is, it's still a great to watch. The same can be said about the "Dinner Party" and "Scott's Tots" episodes of The Office. I think, for me, the best thing about this show is how relatable each male character is for me personally. I can be socially awkward like Abed, I like retaining my non-adult tendencies like Troy, I can be snarky, jaded, and sarcastic like Jeff, and like Pierce, I want to able to fit in with a group of my peers regardless of age. I'm 57 BTW. Also, my wife thinks I can be flamboyant like the Dean, and I'm kinda crazy like Chang.
I think it’s interesting to see how when people watched the show impacts which episodes they like. I started watching late in the series run and I don’t like seasons 4-6 as much as those who first watched it during the pandemic but I also like them more than most of the og fans who watched from the very beginning.
You don't mention why people hate the puppet episode - character assassination. Felt Surrogacy's big problem is that it tries to be one of the "secrets revealed" episodes and (in stark contrast to the impactful revelations of Cooperative Calligraphy, Cooperative Polygraphy, and to a lesser extent Basic Email Security), the secrets are mostly either way out of character or weightless and pointless. Annie (who has always been completely against any kind of academic fraud as in Conspiracy Theories) was allegedly struggling in history and let Cornwallis rub her feet in order to cheat on a test? No way. Shirley forgot her kids "all night in the grocery store"? Nope. Britta's never voted in an election but has voted for The Voice (SONG BROUGHT TO YOU BY ADAM LEVINE OF NBC'S THE VOICE)? Why would Britta be embarrassed by that, given her radical background, defending Julian Assange, raging against the machine, etc.? Troy started a fire when he was young? OK, whatever, but what impact does that have on his character? Jeff ghosting a woman he had started to date and her son? Could be interesting, but goes nowhere, and it doesn't make him "exactly like my dad." Pierce having lied about Eartha Kitt I don't actively hate, but it's meh.
I believe it's the first episode I ever saw, at a friend's house. I remember liking it enough to think I should keep watching, but being too lazy. A year or two later, I was at my parents' house flicking channels at like 1AM and saw the show was on. I remembered how fun Science of Illusion was, so I started the episode over (it was Debate 109) and literally became a fan on the spot
Excellent list, my dude! Very, very solid. I've been saying for years that Intro to Recycled Cinema is underrated! Good to know I'm not the only one that thinks that.
Basic genealogy should be higher simply for the fact that Jeff and amber walking in on Britta getting smacked is probably the funniest moment of the show
You recognised Intro to Recycled Cinema as the quality episode it is, I don't care where you ranked anything else, that alone gave you more credibility than most other people that do this kind of thing. Nice job!
Conventions of space and time predicted the trajectory of Dr. Who FAR too well for it to be comfortable and me and my family who were huge whovians (before Chibnal and his hack writers who if you were to tell me that they’ve likely never even seen an episode of Dr. Who I’d tell you you are correct because that is exactly what happened for a good majority of his episodes with a good portion of the writers on top of that never writing a sci-fi let alone a tv show in some cases and it shows)
Nice video man! Glad to have inspired you! 👍
W interaction
Yet he is a mere boy ….respect
I love creators supporting other creators. So wholesome ❤
Yeah definitely streets ahead!
"Overall, the worst paintball episode. 9.2/10" is a pretty good way to sum up the quality of Community imo
The quality of PEAK Community
Lol yeah community is just great and that proves it
Ikr every paintball episode is just gold
Now this is a man who knows how to rank community episodes
And secretly marry his cousin
And serve meatballs
He starts the ratings at 7.3? Even for the gas leak year! Not the best way to rank it IMHO.
This guy is truly streets ahead
@@gmanrowe streets behind on the gasleak year...
47:12 “throw in a little Black Mirror”
No no no, good sir, you are forgetting that Community did it first!
App Development and Condiments came out in 2014 while Nosedive (the Black Mirror episode that also has apps that rate people and ratings determine social status) came out in 2016!
Yeah I noticed that as well. It's one of the few times where people mistake a typical community parody when in reality they likely inspired the Black Mirror episode.
That is still the only episode of Black mirror I've ever watched lol
i don’t think he’s saying that they’re parodying black mirror, i think he just meant that the episode had a familiar feeling or concept to what you’d see in black mirror, unintentionally
Now this is a man who knows how good Elroy is!
yessirrr
I frequently watch Ken Burns' The War, and just NOWWWW realized it was Keith David narrating. Holy Crap!
now this is a man who knows how to marry his own cousin 😭 this show is a once in a lifetime experience i stg
I've wondered sometimes what the show might have been like if Elroy (Keith David) had been there from the start, instead of Pierce (Chevy Chase)... But then that would have thrown off the dynamics and all that...
4:19 You missed the whole point. Jeff by the end of the episode still doesn't believe in the fake illness. But Jeff dropped everything against him because he related to Chang on wanting to have a fresh restart in life.
I guess I can see that, but I still don't like it bc of the messy structure.
Why no one asked why Chang was in the vents bothers me
@@realjoshb You learn not to question the things Chang does. If you start you’ll never stop.
@@thelaggingcactus5488 yeah the kissing changs ex wife left a terrible taste in my mouth, I had to skip that part when I rewatched
I also think he made a mistake placing this as the worst episode, it has a bunch of funny moments and is way better than economic of marine biology or basic story.
36:58 Fun Fact: This episode is actually written by Jim Rash which I think is the reason it's so much better than the rest of season four and part of the reason it's so loved by the fandom. I mean the man is an Oscar winner for goodness sake.
He's a national treasure
Season 4 has plenty of other episodes that are on a similiar level
@@ayushbajaj4708The jokes in general in season 4 are lazy and not clever. But, there are definitely some pretty good episoded regardless. I actually really like the puppet episode. The songs are beautiful and really catchy, and Jeff helping Shirley feel okay was heartwarming
I have a theory that (due to Dan Harmon discussing S4 concepts in episode commentaries) that Dan Harmon wrote the skeletal structure for Season 4 just before the fired him
Wrong theory, not correct.
WE GOT ROBBED.
Nah, they just pulled from a big idea board they had in the writer’s room. I don’t think he was planning much for the season, he doesn’t write big arcs in advance usually. You can hear him discuss episode concepts sometimes in early Harmontown
ulled from a big idea board they had in the writer’s room. I don’t think he was planning much for the season, he doesn’t write big arcs in advance usually. You can hear him discuss episode concepts sometimes in early Harmontown
@@teej7244 the ending of Season 3 seemed to foreshadow a lot that Season 4 would pick up on (Chang scheming w City College, Jeff's dad,), so there must have been some long-term concepts set up
Starburn's death came out of nowhere because they were still playing off the Law & Order schtick.... Law and Order would always have some wrench thrown in at the very end after everything was tied up in a nice little bow. I thought even that aspect of the episode was perfectly on brand
It came about because the actor was also a writer and producer on the show and didn’t want to act any more so that he could focus on his behind the scenes work.
The glee club Christmas episode has become my fav non paintball episode. It's even my fav Christmas thing to watch every year. Also what makes remedial chaos theory so good is that it shows you how the group is effected by not having one person present. When Jeff leaves everyone is happier. When Troy leaves the world ends. Good stuff.
Glee Club Christmas is S tier, not even up for debate.
Same
@@cjmckay309Boopy doopy doop boop sex
It's not a parody of a sitcom...
It's an homage
Yes! Community is a love letter to media!
@@soy4600 Just kind of stumbled on this, but no, it's "an". The "h" in homage is silent. I apologize, I just had to.
@@liambaron6229 huh
Pillows and Blankets is probably #2 for me (since nothing can beat RCT). I have never seen any parody of anything that was more accurate and hilarious as this episode parodied Civil War documentaries.
A lot of people put Modern Warfare at the top and I get it, it's amazing but nothing, and I mean NOTHING tops RCT. And like you, I think I might put Pillows and Blankets in the 2 spot.
About geothermal escapism. I really liked the subtle nod to an earlier episode where troy said Come Sail away by Stix always makes him cry and then it was the song played when he left.
Man, I remember watching remedial chaos theory for the first time. Once I finished, I immediately called my friend and told my wife at the time that we all had to watch it together cause it was the best episode I had ever seen. Absolute perfection.
My roommate sat the rest of us down for Remedial Chaos Theory and then we proceeded to marathon the whole thing as a family (except we watched the first episode of season 4 then skipped the gas leak year and came back to it out of a sense of duty when we had Community Hangover and needed some hair of the dog)
Dan Harmon's best work
I'm glad to see Garret's wedding so high up here. Chang's speech at the end is one of my favorite moments in the series
Something you missed in #103 (ep. 509) was the fact that the "cowboy" on the VHS Abed and Annie were watching is Vince Giligan, the creator of Breaking Bad, so yeah that was definitely intentional.
the way you timed talking about remedial chaos theory was art in itself! such a good video
Facts
YES i got emotional when the vocals started 😭
The 10/10 S tier episodes for me are: Comparative Religion, Modern Warfare, Epidemiology, Cooperative Calligraphy, Conspiracy Theories and Interior Design, Mixology Certification, Advanced Dungeons and Dragons, Intermediate Documentary Filmmaking, Paradigms of Human Memory, A Fist Full of Paintballs/For a Few Paintballs More, Competitive Ecology, Remedial Chaos Theory, Documentary Filmmaking: Redux, Regional Holiday Music, Basic Lupine Urology, and Digital Estate Planning.
It's hard to pick a favorite, but it might actually be Competitive Ecology.
Glad you appreciate GI Jeff. There’s some other guy on RUclips who calls it a terrible episode, and it just shows the depth and darkness is completely lost on him.
So many of the A tiers felt like S tiers, but that just shows how amazing community is.
Glad to see you think Intro to Recycled Cinema is underrated. I can tell you that applies to the real world because the hand puppet prop from that episode was one of the cheapest props that got auctioned once the show ended. Citation: I own it.
“Starburns death came out of nowhere” yeah death does that
Love seeing Mixology Certification so high, it's such an underrated episode but one of my all time favourites
Watching Modern Warfare for the first time absolutely blew my mind and it’s stayed as my favorite episode of the series. Also couldn’t agree more that season one Chang is absolutely the funniest character
Modern warfare is crazy good!!! Now whenever I think of paintball I think of community. And yes season one Chang is amazing
The end of this video made me emotional 😭 Great list, I respect the time and effort that went into making this. You really did an awesome job of explaining your thoughts. Brb, gonna go re-watch the entire series again
I can’t get over Pierce being held at gunpoint by drug runners in 2x21. Funniest shit ever.
Same 😂😂😂
Oh also when I first watched this and went to check who made this, I was expecting a 10-100k youtube artist based on the editing quality alone, I’m really suprised to see you’re not even over 1,000 subs. I’m excited to see how this channel grows
This video made me realize that Netflix doesn't have the episode "Advanced Dungeons and Dragons" for whatever reason. It was pretty funny because I had no idea that episode existed before you mentioned it as "a well-known episode". This definitely explains some jokes in later seasons about Fat Neil now, so thanks I guess.
yeah, it's on amazon prime now so you can see it there. It's a fantastic episode but a shame that they took it off Netflix.
It was because Chang dressed as an elf that happens to be black. Somehow that's racist
Funnily enough, I think Repilot is in my top 20, maybe top 10 episodes. Idk, maybe I'm a fan of the parallels to the first ever episode, and maybe I just love seeing how far Jeff Winger has come as a character. It just really hits with me.
same, i think for me it’s that it is a masterclass in how to not just un-fuck a story or show, which would only revert it back to before it was fucked, but also shape it into something that reestablishes it’s greatness while advancing and building on it. the story is equal parts entertaining, shocking, believable, funny, sad, and injects hope into a story and a production which seemed to have lost it. most shows who had a “season 4” can’t recover from it, but this repilot says “get ready, we’re back, and soaring past your expectations.” plus all the actors do wonderfully, especially Joel, and the added comedy of the Shirley-spin-off-show is a fantastic way of explaining an actor’s sudden departure. overall it’s just a super tightly written episode with emotional heart that feels both plausible and brimming with potential for the season to come.
Also Jeff beating his asshole partner with his own tie is one of my favorite moments in the show
Fun fact: the reason I started watching this show was because my dad had a box set of the first 3 seasons. I didn’t pick it up until I started watching glee and my dad told me that there was a glee parody in it. So in a weird way my favorite bad show helped me find my favorite good show
Your dad was streets ahead
6x12 "Wedding Videography" is truly peak comedy of Community
If you wanna know "How truly chaotic this group was" 6x12 the best episode to describe how actually chaotic this group was
Now this is a man who knows how to pick a community episode!!!
The parental parentage episode has been one of my favourites simply because of the “secret dogs!” Joke lol
The whole episode is great, tight dialog, good pacing. Definitely A tier
I knew it that remedial chaos theory is No.1! The episode shows how such small change can have a different outcome, and all characters in the episode is highlighted in each different universe. The best episode.. No, its the best comedy episode of all time!
Also I disagree with advanced advanced DnD having better pacing. As someone with a fairly unhealthy obsession with DnD and someone who can relate to both fat Neil and Pierce in that episode I can say that that episode is far more faithful to how playing DnD and especially older versions feels like. It also deals with heavy topics like bullying and suicidal thoughts pretty well showing how bullying can often be accidental, the impact of loneliness, and honestly how much someone else making an effort to simply play a game with you can be (hell I’d kill for that)
i like the way u ranked them bc like community at C tier was a high 7 and that’s literally crazy for any sitcom
Community is by far My favorite show of all time. And this was a great list, enjoyed the analysis and the appreciation for this gem of a show! Of course can’t top Remedial Chaos Theory. And I agree that the first paintball episode took the show from exceptional to legendary.
I'm glad that someone else gave season 4 some love. The episodes are more so watered down but are still half decent. I myself am fond of: The Convention episode, The German episode, The Thanksgiving episode, The Puppet episode and The body swap episode.
The issues are that most of the episodes don't expand on the concepts. So you have a paintball episode where the darkest timeline invades but it feels lacking because of the lack of exchanges between the study group and their evil selves.
You know? Honestly? Having just rewatched the series, this is a fantastic list. I couldn't agree more with your points on Remedial Chaos Theory, and I think I'm gonna rewatch it right now.
fun fact: when abed talks about crapping his pants on the set of cougar town he is actually in episode 21 of season 2 of cougar town. he is seen as a background extra who for seemingly no reason at all stands up and just sprints out of frame.
While I liked Pillows and Blankets, I thought it resolved Troy and Abed's fight in kind of a rushed way. The conflict was built up for several episodes and resolved in a minute without actually addressing the reason they were fighting in the first place. It was an opportunity for some character growth for Abed, to realize that he can hurt his friends' feelings when he doesn't account for them.
Instead, "friendship hats" fixes their relationship.
I also hate that the silver paintball plot point gets dropped in Modern Espionage. It's too clumsily abandoned to be considered a proper red herring, and the stinger should've been used to hint at if not outright reveal the silver paintball gunner's identity.
May I just applaud you on the music choice at the end. Not only does the instrumental "we think we know you" work so well with the vibe and editing of the final montage of the video, Bo Burnham himself is the only person I've seen have as subversive, meta and rewatchable comedy as community. There's a reason I have all of Bo Burnham's specials and a few episodes of community downloaded on netflix for long train rides.
I’ve watched this whole show more times than I can count. I stopped keeping track after 4. I think ima go through and do this too. What was your organization method?
Used an episode tier list I found online and wrote the entire script on google docs. I was rewatching the whole show with my dad who had never seen it before, and after each episode, I wrote a little review and ranked it on the tier list. I had multiple recurring tabs that I kept open bc this project took me 7 months.
The Christmas episode in season 4 didn't feel like a Christmas episode because it was a reference to die hard. Abed references die hard like 5 times, which if you don't know is an arguably Christmas movie despite not feeling very christmasy. It was a very clever homage honestly and even though the episode itself was shit, I liked how they did this.
i too love shirley and jeff! i think they had so much character potential together and i would have loved to see that fleshed out more. the moments they do have are great though and always make me smile ((:
Absolutely beautiful tribute to the show. Makes me want to watch the whole thing again!
IM SO GLAD SOMEONE ELSE AGREES ON THE WORST EPISODE JEFF WOULD NEVER DO THAT
I wasn't expecting We Think We Know You during the outro and it was a pleasant surprise
The whole point of Chang being in dark elf face was not unlike RDJ in Tropic Thunder, making fun of cosplayers that go a little too far in their costumes, so it’s not so much being tasteless as much as it is making fun of tasteless people
Yep but unfortunately parody and satire are lost on most people. There is very little room in the modern world for subtlety and nuance.
This is offically one of my favorite genres of youtube, COMMUNITY CRACK! Like Community is such a comforting show for me, it's so nice for me, and Chang is literally one of my fav characters
I was surprised how good this video ended up being. I love how with every ranking video, the narrator becomes more passionate the higher on the list we get, and this video hits that right on the spot. That montage when you got to number one was amazing, and your explanation on Modern Warfare is something I couldn't have done better. You can be proud of yourself.
One thing that always amazed me about community was that it could do some many tv/movie homages while still being funny and unique.
My biggest regret for the series was that we never got a full season with betty white teaching anthropology
why doesn't this vid have more views!? its so well made, great job dude
the accuracy of this video is insane and i respect the dedication in the rewatch and rating. thanks for making this for me to watch instead of studying- so worth it
Fabulous video. I really appreciate how much work must have gone into this.
I have so many disagreements about rankings, but to me that is precisely the point.
You can only imagine the insane level of joy I felt when my favorite episode was put in the number one spot.
Loved this video. I am currently struggling getting through season 4 and it is reassuring knowing that some of the best episodes are still ahead! Thanks!
Hugely impressive work, man. Great video. I kept disagreeing with placements and then realised just how many fucking amazing episodes Community has, so even hilarious shit could be low on the ranking. What a show.
I think the problem with the inspector space time episode isn't that it isn't funny the pierce stuff is hilarious I think its because to get there the characters have to act way out of character
It's the same for the whole season, because, say what you will about it, season 4 had almost as many laughs as other seasons for me.
neglected to mention that vince gilligan was the guy in the vcr game Pile of Bullets, further tying into possible breaking bad parody that they didnt do for that episode
3 x 20 - digital estate planning - is easily in top 10 for me . i just love that episode so much. cant believe, you did that to it.
Excellent work! 99% agree with your rankings, and love how much you love this perfect show.
Having the greatest sitcom episode of all time at 26 is bold i'll give you that
Really awesome video! Felt like I was chilling with a friend discussing the show; very cool, love it
I decided to watch this specifically because of the age difference to see how you viewed the show.. and I must say very well crafted and while you may have missed some points of certain episodes, I’m sure with time and more experience when rewatching, you’ll see it differently. Great video bruh 👌🏾
thank you sm
What a wonderful tribute to an amazing show
I only recently started Community. Watched the pilot, part of season 1, and about 10 of the “best” episodes. Somehow, I’ve watched your video twice all the way through. Well done. Love the show.
this is such a high quality video wtf? deserves more views!
This show just gets better and better every time u watch it and I don’t even think there’s a single episode that I absolutely dislike, truly streets ahead… anyways my top 10:
10. Cooperative Polygraphy
9. App Development and Condiments (this episode > Nosedive)
8. Mixology Certification
7. Pillows and Blankets
6. Wedding Videography (one of the most underrated episodes imo, absolutely love it)
5. Emotional Consequences of Broadcast Television (this title is perfect)
4. A Fistful of Paintballs & For a Few Paintballs More
3. Contemporary American Poultry
2. Modern Warfare
1. Remedial Chaos Theory (obviously)
Honourable mentions: Debate 109, Basic Intergluteal Numismatics, Advanced Dungeons and Dragons, Epidemiology and Conspiracy Theories and Interior Design
Mini the cosmonaut, jokes aside, great video man. Top notch quality!
I've seen every episode of this show at least 6 times and I gotta say... this list is really great. You explained a lot of my exact thoughts about things (for example, Communication Studies being the best "normal episode") and even the things I didn't agree on, your explanations were valid. I do think the puppet episode is as bad as people say because it feels like some shitty show trying to copy Community's formula. I also think Intro to Knots, the pilot and Studies in Modern Movement deserved to be higher and there were a few I'd personally move down, but that's just my opinion.
Also I gotta appreciate the dunkey reference AND the love for Elroy, big W on that scene. Also also, DAMN you got some anime ass hair man, that's sick.
I just used a ranking Engine to rank the series since I've been watching it on repeat on Netflix for months. I removed the first Dungeons and Dragons episode because it's not on Netflix and I haven't seen it as many times as all the others and I don't remember it well enough to rank it against the others.
1 Remedial Chaos Theory
2 Epidemiology
3 A Fistful of Paintballs
4 Basic Intergluteal Numismatics
5 Conspiracy Theories and Interior Design
6 Intro to Felt Surrogacy
7 The First Chang Dynasty
8 Cooperative Calligraphy
9 Regional Holiday Music
10 Horror Fiction in Seven Spooky Steps
11 Basic Lupine Urology
12 Applied Anthropology and Culinary Arts
13 Digital Estate Planning
14 Basic Rocket Science
15 App Development and Condiments
16 Advanced Introduction to Finality
17 Investigative Journalism
18 Course Listing Unavailable
19 Curriculum Unavailable
20 Abed's Uncontrollable Christmas
21 Contemporary American Poultry
22 Advanced Gay
23 Intro to Recycled Cinema
24 Wedding Videography
25 Messianic Myths and Ancient Peoples
26 Celebrity Pharmacology
27 Romantic Expressionism
28 Aerodynamics of Gender
29 Advanced Safety Features
30 Competitive Ecology
31 Studies in Modern Movement
32 Paradigms of Human Memory
33 Asian Population Studies
34 Basic Genealogy
35 Basic Human Anatomy
36 Foosball and Nocturnal Vigilantism
37 Pascal's Triangle Revisited
38 The Politics of Human Sexuality
39 For a Few Paintballs More
40 Accounting for Lawyers
41 Modern Warfare
42 Documentary Filmmaking: Redux
43 Urban Matrimony and the Sandwich Arts
44 Mixology Certification
45 Advanced Criminal Law
46 Anthropology 101
47 Contemporary Impressionists
48 Interpretive Dance
49 Custody Law and Eastern European Diplomacy
50 Intro to Political Science
51 Beginner Pottery
52 Digital Exploration of Interior Design
53 Geothermal Escapism
54 Laws of Robotics and Party Rights
55 Virtual Systems Analysis
56 Intro to Knots
57 Geography of Global Conflict
58 Introduction to Finality
59 Herstory of Dance
60 Cooperative Polygraphy
61 Home Economics
62 Comparative Religion
63 Competitive Wine Tasting
64 Origins of Vampire Mythology
65 History 101
66 Introduction to Statistics
67 Introduction to Teaching
68 Paranormal Parentage
69 Pillows and Blankets
70 Grifting 101
71 The Psychology of Letting Go
72 Basic Email Security
73 The Art of Discourse
74 Critical Film Studies
75 Advanced Documentary Filmmaking
76 Bondage and Beta Male Sexuality
77 Communication Studies
78 Debate 109
79 Cooperative Escapism in Familial Relations
80 Basic Sandwich
81 English as a Second Language
82 Football, Feminism and You
83 Basic Crisis Room Decorum
84 Biology 101
85 Alternative History of the German Invasion
86 Early 21st Century Romanticism
87 The Science of Illusion
88 Pilot
89 Advanced Advanced Dungeons & Dragons
90 Modern Espionage
91 Physical Education
92 Intermediate Documentary Filmmaking
93 Introduction to Film
94 Basic Story
95 Economics of Marine Biology
96 Conventions of Space and Time
97 Lawnmower Maintenance and Postnatal Care
98 Emotional Consequences of Broadcast Television
99 Environmental Science
100 Spanish 101
101 Analysis of Cork-Based Networking
102 Basic RV Repair and Palmistry
103 Ladders
104 Repilot
105 Social Psychology
106 VCR Maintenance and Educational Publishing
107 Queer Studies and Advanced Waxing
108 Heroic Origins
109 G.I. Jeff
Bold choices putting G.I. Jeff last and putting Felt Surogecy in the top 10. I envy your bravery.
@@thelaggingcactus5488 Do people like GI Jeff? I didn't realize it was popular I feel like a lot of people don't like that one either? I watch the series all the way through a few times and I really didn't know that people didn't like season 4 that much. Felt surrogacy was one of my favorites on all of my re-watches I know it's not the deepest episode but I just love the puppets and the music. Then after seeing online opinions I realized that it was one of the fans least favorite episodes. But I thought I would be lying if I pretended it wasn't one of my favorites. I do understand people's arguments against it though.
@@Jessfrogger88 I agree about both G.I Jeff and Felt Surrogacy. The cartoon is more important to Jeff's arc than Felt is for anyone, but I don't look forward to seeing it again.
Damn dude, great video! You can really see the time and effort you put into this. Great job :)
Loved this list! Only thing that I had a problem with is that the “parody” episodes aren’t actually parodies, they are homages and Harmon is very particular about them not being parodies.
Environmental science is one of my favorite episodes. I feel like it's the one that really sucks you in for good and starts to find it's footing. The end where they sing to Fievel while chang is dancing with his wife and pierce helps Shirley is when I really realized I was watching something special
Great list and great video by far. Community is one of those shows that, no matter how low on the list the episode is, it's still a great to watch. The same can be said about the "Dinner Party" and "Scott's Tots" episodes of The Office.
I think, for me, the best thing about this show is how relatable each male character is for me personally. I can be socially awkward like Abed, I like retaining my non-adult tendencies like Troy, I can be snarky, jaded, and sarcastic like Jeff, and like Pierce, I want to able to fit in with a group of my peers regardless of age. I'm 57 BTW. Also, my wife thinks I can be flamboyant like the Dean, and I'm kinda crazy like Chang.
Could you PLEASE make an episode going over the behind the scenes drama that impacted episodes and why
Amazing video, thank you for making it. It brought many good memories
I think it’s interesting to see how when people watched the show impacts which episodes they like. I started watching late in the series run and I don’t like seasons 4-6 as much as those who first watched it during the pandemic but I also like them more than most of the og fans who watched from the very beginning.
this show is my favorite show ever for a reason i couldn’t put in words, but the opening of this video perfectly explains how i feel. great job man.
You don't mention why people hate the puppet episode - character assassination. Felt Surrogacy's big problem is that it tries to be one of the "secrets revealed" episodes and (in stark contrast to the impactful revelations of Cooperative Calligraphy, Cooperative Polygraphy, and to a lesser extent Basic Email Security), the secrets are mostly either way out of character or weightless and pointless. Annie (who has always been completely against any kind of academic fraud as in Conspiracy Theories) was allegedly struggling in history and let Cornwallis rub her feet in order to cheat on a test? No way. Shirley forgot her kids "all night in the grocery store"? Nope. Britta's never voted in an election but has voted for The Voice (SONG BROUGHT TO YOU BY ADAM LEVINE OF NBC'S THE VOICE)? Why would Britta be embarrassed by that, given her radical background, defending Julian Assange, raging against the machine, etc.? Troy started a fire when he was young? OK, whatever, but what impact does that have on his character? Jeff ghosting a woman he had started to date and her son? Could be interesting, but goes nowhere, and it doesn't make him "exactly like my dad." Pierce having lied about Eartha Kitt I don't actively hate, but it's meh.
I seriously thought this video was from a more established youtuber.. so suprirsed you haven't got more followers.. incredible video and great editing
I love the "half in the bag" theme in the intro
I really enjoyed this video! I can tell a LOT of time was put into it. I gotta go back and watch Community again now. Keep up the great work!
I'm here. It took me all of August but I'm finally here and it was worth it.
Remedial chaos theory is Community's Ozymandias
I love this video. I was working on my own rank list video so I wanted to see if anybody else did it and yours is wonderful
So glad you put Science of Illusion so high. That’s my favorite season 1 episode but no one talks about.
I believe it's the first episode I ever saw, at a friend's house. I remember liking it enough to think I should keep watching, but being too lazy. A year or two later, I was at my parents' house flicking channels at like 1AM and saw the show was on. I remembered how fun Science of Illusion was, so I started the episode over (it was Debate 109) and literally became a fan on the spot
I dont think jeff actually ever thinks chang is kevin. He realizes that chang wants to abandon his old life, like jeff did at the start of the show
I also agree that curriculum unavailable is better than paradigms of human memory.....loved the rankings agree with you on many of them !!
Was waiting to see where my opinion differed and it happened so early! Competitive ecology is one of my personal favs! Can't explain it.
the joke about the titles is that they're classes you could take at greendale
The editing of this video is sublime, the ending with Roxanne kicking in is masterfully done.
Awesome video. Also loved the bo burnham song for the conclusion
Not me watching an hour long episode about every episode of a show I have seen a thousand times.
real
Excellent list, my dude! Very, very solid. I've been saying for years that Intro to Recycled Cinema is underrated! Good to know I'm not the only one that thinks that.
Now THAT is dedication 👏👏👏. I find it hard to do stuff like this but i know for me the 8 bit episode and the SVU episode are the best ❤
Basic genealogy should be higher simply for the fact that Jeff and amber walking in on Britta getting smacked is probably the funniest moment of the show
You recognised Intro to Recycled Cinema as the quality episode it is, I don't care where you ranked anything else, that alone gave you more credibility than most other people that do this kind of thing. Nice job!
Conventions of space and time predicted the trajectory of Dr. Who FAR too well for it to be comfortable and me and my family who were huge whovians (before Chibnal and his hack writers who if you were to tell me that they’ve likely never even seen an episode of Dr. Who I’d tell you you are correct because that is exactly what happened for a good majority of his episodes with a good portion of the writers on top of that never writing a sci-fi let alone a tv show in some cases and it shows)
Great justifications and format for the video. Love how well this was made, akin to some of the best tv analysis youtubers.