Milwaukee vs Metabo hpt….it didn’t end well

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 дек 2024

Комментарии • 110

  • @ozcampnhuntdan7858
    @ozcampnhuntdan7858 4 дня назад +1

    When my m12 driver starts overheating the brake seems to not work also.

  • @DiligentDave1966
    @DiligentDave1966 7 месяцев назад +6

    I have the 36v triple hammer. It's not the Bolt, but I really like it for what it is. I got it on clearance for $70 with 2 batteries and a charger.

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  7 месяцев назад +1

      Damn good deal

    • @DiligentDave1966
      @DiligentDave1966 7 месяцев назад +3

      @@Kaleb_RoSs It's a smooth impact driver. I have to agree with another commentor, though, about the selector on the drill.
      I returned the 620 inch pound Metabo HPT drill because the selector felt like it could be bumped out of position way too easy.

    • @baseballdude8491
      @baseballdude8491 Месяц назад +1

      The triple Hammer has much better control and ergonomics than the over overpowered More leaked
      If we are.doing lags a good hammer drill or impact works much better and faster and quieter
      Triple hammers have stood the test of time for what impact drivers are supposed to excell at

    • @DiligentDave1966
      @DiligentDave1966 Месяц назад

      @@baseballdude8491 My old Dewalt DCF787 has been my go to ever since I got it, but I have definitely been using the triple hammer more and more when I need more power.

  • @JacobQualls-bo7zx
    @JacobQualls-bo7zx 7 месяцев назад +4

    I have some Metabo HPT tools. I love the triple hammer and nailers. Was not a fan of the 18v Recip and Circ saws. But hey they have great sales. If you can get Metabo HPT at the same price as Kobalt, Ridgid, or Craftsman it is almost always a win and the HPT line generally among the best value in power tools.

    • @Therealphantomzero
      @Therealphantomzero 4 месяца назад +2

      You want the 36 recip. Don't get why not on the circular saw power and weight ratio is great

    • @baseballdude8491
      @baseballdude8491 Месяц назад +1

      The 36V rear handle recip.is our go to on jobsite.as.well as the triple hammers
      Other MHPT winners are the 2" plunge router, portable band saw, grinders, and the awesome SDS plus and Max rotaries which are great for the AC adapter
      Table saws and mitre saws also have been too notch
      Much of my red and teal has been replaced over the last 5/6 yrs
      Better pricing , durability and warranty(which have only had to use on a battery or two-no tools yet)

    • @justCarner
      @justCarner 29 дней назад

      @@baseballdude8491yep, agree. With all of it.

  • @HashV17
    @HashV17 7 месяцев назад +9

    Metabo HPT: Ergonomics, balanced power (and i personally love the color a lot)
    Milwaukee: Power, Power, Power even if i break and die. 😂 (Absolutely different class though 💯)

    • @tyreselovell
      @tyreselovell 3 месяца назад +1

      Impacts aren’t meant for power

    • @DrKeef
      @DrKeef Месяц назад +1

      @@tyreselovell what are they meant for, if not power?

  • @justCarner
    @justCarner 29 дней назад +1

    Use the non triple hammer cheaper option from metaboHPT. It excels at this type stuff over the triple hammer. Triple is just a much more finesse and frankly special drill than being a powerhouse. Side note: The new BOLTs power is better than original TH, but I feel like the auto mode is much more usable than the BOLTs. Or maybe I’m just not used to the BOLT yet.

  • @SouthFLTools
    @SouthFLTools 7 месяцев назад +2

    If the Milwaukee had to start impacting at the beginning of driving the 12 inch GRK, then it was pretty apparent the Metabo HPT was going to struggle with that test overall. Nice comparison and great video!

  • @onikwa
    @onikwa 7 месяцев назад +4

    Interesting with the flex battery lol. I love my triple hammer I have the 36v Bolt but im thinking of swapping to the new 18v Bolt, apparently it performs exactly the same but you can run the smaller 18v batteries which is good because I like to carry light. It's a different tool than the stuff Milwaukee is putting out though for sure, it has less power and speed but gains much more finesse especially with the slower modes actually being slow but not hopelessly weak. Good for delicate screws, small screws and finer work. They actually have a brand new model in Japan with a CRAZY slow mode that actually starts impacting even with no load, which makes it super consistent and predictable for REALLY fine work. Cool stuff, nice to see some R&D put into things other than max power and speed

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  7 месяцев назад +1

      Sounds like I gotta have it

    • @trippleHelixV2
      @trippleHelixV2 7 месяцев назад +3

      What is that new “Japanese” one… I love their stuff. I have the makita tdz173 and the precision and refinement it has is unbelievable. Would love a metabo hpt/hikoki to compare to!! Plus I now have plenty jdm bits

    • @kutapio
      @kutapio 7 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@trippleHelixV2WH36DD.

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  7 месяцев назад +2

      Just found it on Amazon Japan, should be here in a few weeks. Thing looks awesome.

    • @user-ii8dz4vu7n
      @user-ii8dz4vu7n 7 месяцев назад +2

      Subscribing just to see you review it. It's supposed to be REALLY nice and I'm thinking about importing it

  • @tanibroshka9029
    @tanibroshka9029 4 месяца назад +1

    How did you fit Flex battery on a Hikoki? Can you fit hikoki battery on Flex?

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  4 месяца назад

      @@tanibroshka9029 3D printed battery adapter

  • @georgedavall9449
    @georgedavall9449 7 месяцев назад +2

    My only beef with Metabo HPT is why they cant seem to put a decent FWD/ REV switch in the drills, like what is in the impacts? It is strange. It works, but is very ‘mushy,’ even on my 36 Volt drill? It is not a positive click as you go between locking off the trigger into Fwd or Rev. My Triple Hammer has a very. Nice switch.

    • @DiligentDave1966
      @DiligentDave1966 7 месяцев назад +2

      I ended up returning the 620 inch pound drill for that very reason. It's a shame, too, because it was on clearance.

    • @georgedavall9449
      @georgedavall9449 7 месяцев назад +2

      @@DiligentDave1966 Yeah Dave, that is how I scored most of my Metabo stuff. Sorry it didn’t work out for you.
      Can you believe I picked up two of the 36 MultiVolt drill kits, with nice hard side cases, at my local Lowe’s, for a total of 230 dollars or so after taxes! Then I used that receipt to get two ‘free’ 36 volt batteries on their Rebate program, awhile back. Take care

    • @DiligentDave1966
      @DiligentDave1966 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@georgedavall9449 I wish the drill would have had a better selector because I’ve heard it’s a great little drill. The store had a few left when I returned it, so I tried another one and it was the same so I just got a refund.
      I do have the 36v triple hammer impact driver, though, and it’s pretty sweet. It’s not the Bolt, but it works great. I got it on clearance for $70 and it came with 2 batteries and a charger.
      I don’t need to be on just one platform, so I can always pair it with a drill from a different brand. As long as the tools come with batteries and a charger, I’m good with whatever does the job.

  • @VacMaster1991
    @VacMaster1991 7 месяцев назад +2

    I have had pretty poor reliability with Milwaukee. I have had 4 m12 & m18 batteries die on me, all less than 2 yearsold. Then my m12 polisher stopped working one day. Finally my m18 fuel hammer drills chuck broke and would no longer hold bits without them falling out. I was denied warranty on all of them because the store no longer had my receipt. I ended up going back to Dewalt. I have multiple yellow tools & batteries from 5 years ago that work great. I will soon be selling the rest of my Milwaukee tools

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  7 месяцев назад +1

      Yea I haven’t had great luck with Milwaukee either. Plenty of broken batteries, broken m12 driver broken gen 4 hammer drill on the first use and a broken 2767 impact wrench within 9 months. Maybe just bad luck for me.

    • @VacMaster1991
      @VacMaster1991 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@Kaleb_RoSs or it's that they focus so much on power and performance they forget that tools are supposed to last a while too.

    • @VacMaster1991
      @VacMaster1991 7 месяцев назад +1

      @Kaleb_RoSs which batteries have you had more issues with. M12 or M18?
      I have actually had 3 m12 and two m18 batteries quit charging. They show like 5 volts, and the charger won't even recognize them. I have heard you can jump-start them, but I am a little wary of doing that, considering they are lithium batteries.

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  7 месяцев назад

      @@VacMaster1991 more m18 batteries have literally just fallen apart for me. M12 batteries I’ve had maybe 3 just stop working.

    • @VacMaster1991
      @VacMaster1991 7 месяцев назад +1

      @Kaleb_RoSs I haven't had any physically break. But they had constant charging issues. It seems they have no protection from being discharged too much. I have dewalt batteries from 2018 that get used constantly and work fine. Only Milwaukee has given me such trouble.

  • @unclefester4626
    @unclefester4626 29 дней назад +1

    That gen 4 impacter failed quite badly on the torque test channel. 3 or 4 of them broke right in a row.
    I have one but have never run it in top speed....just speed 2.
    Supposedly gen 3 was a better impacter than gen 4 is.

  • @TheTemplarnight
    @TheTemplarnight 7 месяцев назад +3

    it's been funny watching these videos and i don't mean any shade by this but, i basically "grew up" on Milwaukee impacts and i never actually realized how underpowered most other brands impacts where comparatively till i used a DeWalt one on a jobsite few years back cause i forgot to throw my driver box in the truck, It's actually surprising. Not sure if it's just cause it's what i both learned on and got used too but i never found my gen 2, 3, 3.5 or 4 M18 to be "not smooth" even after trying some Makita, Metabo & Festool Impacts i just was never impressed by other brands outside of the ring light setup some brands have, but idk just me i suppose. (also before anyone wonders why i've had every gen outside of gen 1, it's simple often times where i live they throw deals that making buying a quick charger, batteries and impact cheaper than just buying the battery by itself and it never hurts to have backup impacts around just incase although i've never had one break yet outside of the Gen 3s bad collet retention for spade bits)

    • @HashV17
      @HashV17 7 месяцев назад +1

      Milwaukee is the current benchmark of cordless power tools. Can't argue about that it's a fact. Red is all about power.

    • @TheTemplarnight
      @TheTemplarnight 7 месяцев назад +2

      @@HashV17 yeah I also just appreciate the reliability of them from my experience I've seen dozens of DeWalt, Makita and Bosch tools replaced meanwhile I've only had to warranty fix my gen 3 collet once for retention issues and my M18 sander once for over spinning but that's it in almost 8 years

    • @HashV17
      @HashV17 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@TheTemplarnight Yes. Performance, reliability, durability and longevity, that's Milwaukee for you. Those are factors that justify the price especially when it's for industrial use.

    • @Jihadbearzwithgunz
      @Jihadbearzwithgunz 7 месяцев назад +1

      They are built for power but lack longevity.. and more often then not can't be repaired when they brake in america it's worth it cause you get a 5 year warranty outside of America you get a 1 year ... watch power tool repair videos to do the repairs on most Milwaukee tools it cost as much as buying a new tool or more which makes the repair not worth doing . Dewalt is the same the issue with Milwaukee (tti) and dewalt (SBD) is the armature switch control board and battery connection is sold as one piece making it cost as much as the tool.. good tools for mechanics for anything else it doesn't really make sense .

    • @TheTemplarnight
      @TheTemplarnight 7 месяцев назад +2

      @@Jihadbearzwithgunz I would strongly disagree but maybe my experiences are different than yours since I'm Canadian my 2 repairs 1 free 1 was $25 and they gave me a whole new unit so not gonna complain

  • @chrxx4327
    @chrxx4327 2 месяца назад +1

    This is testing the latest and greatest Milwaukee fuel impact gen3 vs metabo hpt's older gen bolt model. Not exactly apples to apples, of course a new generation gap tool is going to dunk on the older gen. You could run the same test with the newest 18v Bolt vs the old gen bolt which is the model featured here and it would dunk on it as well.

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  2 месяца назад

      @@chrxx4327 this is the gen 4 m18 not the gen 3 and this is the first gen tripple hammer. All the tripple hammers perform very similar though. The bolt isn’t the newest one, I have a video comparing this first gen tripple hammer vs the hikoki wh36dd which is the newest tripple hammer (not available in the states yet) and they perform very similar.

    • @chrxx4327
      @chrxx4327 2 месяца назад +1

      @@Kaleb_RoSs metabo hpt sells the latest 36v triple hammer WH36dc and the 18v wh18dc in the US. The 18v is actually faster in most scenarios due to higher rip 'ems. I can't keep up with the amount of generations a tool has. Sorry if I got the Milwaukee Gen wrong. The Point is, this is the newest Milwaukee vs an older model of the metabo hpt triple hammer. This is the click bait youtube manipulation that people are sick of. Just based on your comments it sounds like you areaware the model is older, yet you didn't disclose that fact... its almost like you were running an advertisement or something for team Milwaukee....

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  2 месяца назад

      @@chrxx4327 I am very aware of the generation of each of these tools lol. I never said this was apples to apples. It isn’t clickbait…I didn’t say Milwaukees latest vs Metabo hpts latest. I’m not saying to buy one or the other, I actually stated I prefer the Metabo hpt over Milwaukee. When I uploaded this video I had less than 1000 subs, a company like Milwaukee is not going to sponsor me lol. I completely understand the skepticism though. I buy all of these tools myself and these videos are usually just for fun.

  • @kutapio
    @kutapio 7 месяцев назад +1

    Started buying milwuakee tools due to the sales at home depot. So far I have an m12 hammer drill die within three minutes of just trigger pressing and playing with clutch and forward and reverse buttons
    an m18 hammer that has a clacking sound when reducing speed from full in speed 2. I know there is a brake which it might be but my ridgid high torque is smoother and does not have that. Power is there but quality? Not so much.

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  7 месяцев назад

      Agreed

    • @DiligentDave1966
      @DiligentDave1966 7 месяцев назад +1

      Ridgid for the win!

    • @kutapio
      @kutapio 7 месяцев назад +2

      ​@@DiligentDave1966waiting for a deal on the 4 speed impact driver. The combo kit is currently $276 but Picked up the high torque drill for $67 on clearance in January.😊

    • @DiligentDave1966
      @DiligentDave1966 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@kutapio Nice! I actually got the high torque drill combo during the Black Friday sale. The combo ended up only costing me $180 with the “free tool” hack.
      I tested the drill against the Flex, the Milwaukee and the Dewalt 999. I was sort of trying to prove that the Ridgid is inferior, but I ended up loving it.

  • @THEBEARDEDTOOLGUY
    @THEBEARDEDTOOLGUY 7 месяцев назад +2

    You just won't be able to buy the BOLT wont run for more FLEX BATTERY for more Then 1 second but the Lights stay on

  • @trippleHelixV2
    @trippleHelixV2 7 месяцев назад +1

    I would think that adapter doesn’t nearly optimize the flex battery nor the metabo hpt tool.

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  7 месяцев назад +1

      It doesn’t but I have done tests showing it makes the Metabo faster than using a regular Metabo 18v

    • @trippleHelixV2
      @trippleHelixV2 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@Kaleb_RoSs I was honestly curious, not trying to be an ass!!! Sorry brother!!

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  7 месяцев назад +1

      @@trippleHelixV2 no reason to be sorry and you weren’t being an ass😂 you can say whatever over here lol appreciate you watching!

  • @wallacenaaz5132
    @wallacenaaz5132 7 месяцев назад +3

    “Why didnt you test the newer metabo hpt bolt version” is what im assuming most people going to say.

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  7 месяцев назад +1

      lol I would love to. Going to have to wait until I actually get it though

    • @wallacenaaz5132
      @wallacenaaz5132 7 месяцев назад +3

      Forsure, I just got the 36v version and I love their tools. Smooth compared to my 850. I have few other metabo stuff and they are so good.

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  7 месяцев назад +3

      @@wallacenaaz5132 I’ve been considering moving my main line that I actually use to all Metabo hpt they’re great tools.

    • @wallacenaaz5132
      @wallacenaaz5132 7 месяцев назад +2

      @@Kaleb_RoSs esp with the ac battery corded option! How sweet to be able to use that with the table saw or chop saw.

  • @El_Diablo_LI
    @El_Diablo_LI 7 месяцев назад +2

    Try putting that Flex battery on the Milwaukee. Now that is the ultimate in speed and power for an impact.
    I know SoAlz shits on them all the time, but I like Makita for delicate intricate work where speed and power isn't a requirement. When it is, I go with my Milwaukee. To me, the Makita just feels better in my hand than the Metabo HPT.

    • @mtasubwaymartasubway
      @mtasubwaymartasubway 7 месяцев назад

      soAlZ doesn't know anything, soAlZ is a Big mouth loudmouth Bozo.

  • @Leeroy2586
    @Leeroy2586 7 месяцев назад +2

    I love the tripple hammer. And most HPT tools for that matter

  • @nervousbreakdown1108
    @nervousbreakdown1108 3 месяца назад +1

    that stubborn bolt at 2:05 is being driven straight into a knot

  • @dannychairez9925
    @dannychairez9925 6 месяцев назад +2

    I have both of them and I mainly use the metabo it’s a lot lighter and feels more comfortable when in using it
    You get a better grip with the metabo as well

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  6 месяцев назад +2

      I agree, I got the newest metabo(Hikoki) the wh36DD and it immediately became my favorite impact driver to use.

  • @rickyperkins232
    @rickyperkins232 7 месяцев назад +1

    So I don't get the triple hammer. If its performance falls off, why manufacture it?. Why make a V12 engine, yet most top turbo 4 cylinders will crush it every time.

    • @durantplayz7111
      @durantplayz7111 7 месяцев назад +2

      I own dc850 gen 4 milwaukee gen 3 m12 and triple hammer, I'd pick the triple hammer for stuff a impact driver is for

    • @rickyperkins232
      @rickyperkins232 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@durantplayz7111 explain to me why? Isn't the triple hammer a down grade from the Milwaukee and Dewalt you have? As a matter of fact the M12 is just as good or better than the triple hammer? If I am completely wrong let me know.

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  7 месяцев назад +2

      The triple hammer is just extremely ergonomic and basically a pleasure to use lol. Just doesn’t have the balls that a lot of the others do.

    • @johnsxterra9020
      @johnsxterra9020 7 месяцев назад +1

      A turbo 4-cylinder sounds like a piece of crap and it's not very reliable but a V12 is very smooth revving and it's the world's best sounding engine

    • @rickyperkins232
      @rickyperkins232 7 месяцев назад +1

      @johnsxterra9020 bro, it was only a contrasting analogy. The triple hammer is supposed to be like a V12, but the lesser 2 hammer Milwaukee, DeWalt, Nikita, FLEX, etc. crush it every time.

  • @x_istance7265
    @x_istance7265 3 месяца назад +1

    Metabo so far is only better in angle grinders blew my Milwaukee out of the water but I love my Milwaukee impacts

  • @dustinkrebs8229
    @dustinkrebs8229 7 месяцев назад +2

    Lets go Metabo! 👏👏👏👏👏

  • @realJohnJohn
    @realJohnJohn 4 месяца назад +1

    my issue with Metabo that is own KKR …

  • @Sheepleton
    @Sheepleton 7 месяцев назад +1

    That Milwaukee throws down...but I'll still never buy one. Just too expensive. I have a cheap plug in for stuff around the house.

    • @gregorsamsa1364
      @gregorsamsa1364 7 месяцев назад +2

      Can find em highly discounted on sale fairly often if you keep an eye out

  • @ssergei
    @ssergei 7 месяцев назад +2

    Tactics, you, garage ma'am, you guys started to love metabo synchronously😁
    that wood round tests my fav👍🏻

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  7 месяцев назад +1

      Haha I’ve been loving Metabo a while back since my initial review I did like a few months ago

  • @tuffytoys9707
    @tuffytoys9707 7 месяцев назад +2

    ! The Milwaukee and others are Plagued by the lack of parts quality manufacturing since the Covid-19 shutdown. You Should Retest the impacts with the Milwaukee Gen 3 or Gen 3.5 with the double ball bearing in the collet to hold on to the Bits.

  • @Donald-w7o
    @Donald-w7o Месяц назад +1

    use metabo hpt battery and its a night and day difference, nice try on being a Milwaukee sponsor with your home depot wardrobe

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  Месяц назад

      @@Donald-w7o lmao I wish I was sponsored, Metabo Hpt/hikoki is my favorite brand though, especially the tripple hammers. They just aren’t as strong

  • @anibaltv845
    @anibaltv845 5 месяцев назад +1

    Metabo hpt is dogshit... now METABO is the second best for professional use after Hilti and that's up for debate, METABO is made in Germany, Metabo hpt is Chinese crap

    • @Kaleb_RoSs
      @Kaleb_RoSs  5 месяцев назад +2

      @@anibaltv845 they might not be that powerful but they’re quite smooth and feel premium honestly. I see even some of the German Metabo is actually made in china as well though, not all but a lot of it.

    • @baseballdude8491
      @baseballdude8491 Месяц назад +1

      You obviously haven't used the tools
      I was a Milwaukee fan boy with some teal mixed.in but Metabo HPT/Hitachi has always had the best nailers/fasteners 25+yrs running and the triple.hammer is by far the most ergonomic and smooth driver
      The 36V recipe, grinders, portable band saw and SDS plus and Max rotaries run circle around my Milwaukee's and the Table saw is such a better and larger capacity than all others as well as the 12" , 10" and 7 1/4 mitre saws
      And the 1/2" plunge router absolutely beats down red and yellow and has been out for yrs ahead
      And all can utilize the AC adapter for those king run times allowing for battery life saving(which ends up being $ saving as well)