You haven't seen this test! Milwaukee VS Makita VS DeWALT VS Bosch VS Metabo

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 23 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 1,3 тыс.

  • @ToolTest
    @ToolTest  2 года назад +26

    NEW TEST VERSION: ruclips.net/video/Al18xzeWwVU/видео.htmlsi=jZhtf2MyUgF2PrPZ
    Check this 12V VERSION TEST as well: ruclips.net/video/KDeBi9_p8oU/видео.html

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +3

      Why would I pre drill on a video test? How do we can see the strength and behavior of a drill if I pre drill? You have written a comment that has absolutely nothing to do with the subject of the video

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +2

      @@sasquatchrosefarts No, I understand your point, but what does it have to do with what appears in the video? Did I start building something, or did I start testing some drills? How would you test some drills, do you pre-drill? When you want to test the power, behavior, ergonomics, capacity, reliability of a tool, you subject it to brute force. I think the goal was to see what strength the drills have, where their limit is, how they each behave in situations where extra power is needed, etc. And you teach me lessons on how to build? Of course, in normal life you don't use them like that, but that's not the point.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +2

      @@stephaneferracci818 I'm not selling anything, be careful with the language.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +3

      @@stephaneferracci818 How do I know what your impressions are? You get the impressions you want, without any objectivity. That's your problem, guys. I show how 5 models of drills behave in the same working situation, this is the purpose of this video, I thought it was obvious. Do you think I'm interested in promoting a particular brand? If that was the intention, I would have promoted it in a separate video.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +3

      @@stephaneferracci818 I want people to express their opinion, without insults, is it possible?

  • @tinker3962
    @tinker3962 2 года назад +182

    It is not how fast it is, but how long they last. Endurance under repeated load is key for value longevity. Use em everyday and see which ones last for 2 years!
    I have had many brands, and as a tradie have experienced that Makita is more plain-jane but lasts best in the trades and gives the best durability value.

    • @hanslund308
      @hanslund308 Год назад +9

      I have an old 12volt dewalt drill from the 90s, it has been used regularly and it just drives. That is the thing in my exp, dewalt does drills and tools for the average person very good. But if you want something for heavy jobs or just bigger tools, makita does that better and they will last longer. I might be wrong, but that is just my exp.

    • @hellmatehellmate
      @hellmatehellmate Год назад +3

      Thank goodness I chose Makita over others, its 2.5 times as costly compared to bosch for same power

    • @paavobergmann4920
      @paavobergmann4920 10 месяцев назад +2

      Jupp. Makita is the tool you buy once. Period.

    • @bongobob7079
      @bongobob7079 10 месяцев назад

      @@paavobergmann4920 I was talking to some trades people today and they said the tool is good but the battery packs are terrible?

    • @NP-ux9xg
      @NP-ux9xg 7 месяцев назад

      @@paavobergmann4920 great tools. As a guy who has to use these to make a living though, nothing will top my Hilti stuff.

  • @dimitrisgoktsis5702
    @dimitrisgoktsis5702 2 года назад +469

    No-one talk about for duration in the years!Speed itself saying nothing to me!The thing is how it last!

    • @maxvaly7747
      @maxvaly7747 2 года назад +96

      I have all Makita tools: drill, impact, etc. no issues after 5 years...all batteries still work well

    • @dimitrisgoktsis5702
      @dimitrisgoktsis5702 2 года назад +29

      @@maxvaly7747 well done then my friend! This is the most important thing 😊

    • @benmacrae4784
      @benmacrae4784 2 года назад +97

      As a metal roofer we use drills all day everyday, some of the boys use Milwaukie.. drills last about 2 years if that … I use Bosch .. 7 years still the same drill

    • @seanwiddowson5008
      @seanwiddowson5008 2 года назад +11

      @@maxvaly7747 yep the best for price performance and test of time . Droped from scaffolding at top few times. Still no damage to battery or drill .

    • @keithclark486
      @keithclark486 2 года назад +9

      Well if it has more speed, you get the job done faster. So if you get a 2 year job finished in a year ' You need to take in consideration profit vs the cost of the tool.

  • @Guitube99
    @Guitube99 2 года назад +41

    Very well made comparison video ! No waste of time, just pure data. Very useful thanks.

  • @cyberdogg5
    @cyberdogg5 2 года назад +110

    The Metabo is a an old brushed model, you should have used their brushless LTX-BL for a fair comparison.

    • @bergsgeten1
      @bergsgeten1 2 года назад +2

      Fair comment. Still a loss tho!

    • @firebladex8586
      @firebladex8586 2 года назад +17

      Unless your job is to pointlessly drive lag bolts into wood all day, these comparisons are meaningless anyway.

    • @elijahvalencia5825
      @elijahvalencia5825 2 года назад +2

      also the flexvolt 60v dewalt too

    • @PatricSjoeoe
      @PatricSjoeoe Месяц назад

      Yeah, and when he used the others, it was raining and wind blowing.

    • @molnrire
      @molnrire 28 дней назад

      And with a smaller accu capacity.

  • @WilliamVG
    @WilliamVG 2 года назад +39

    Dewalt is solid all around but Makita really impressed me here.

    • @kizgintosbaga
      @kizgintosbaga 5 месяцев назад +2

      makita impresses me too. its price is also very impressive.

  • @Grodd70
    @Grodd70 Год назад +49

    Cool video. I am a Milwaukee guy, but have family that are invested with Dewalt and a friend uses Mikita. It really depends on a particular tool, one might have an edge in say a drill the other makes a better saw. I think if you stick with the BIG 3 you'll be well served.

  • @adamcoe
    @adamcoe 2 года назад +88

    I'd be interested to see a chart at the end of all the speeds together and stuff, and maybe an overall ranking. That being said, out of Makita, DeWalt and Milwaukee, they all seemed incredibly decent with maybe a slight edge to the Makita.

    • @SuperChipperson
      @SuperChipperson Год назад

      True, every brand more than likely has a different 'low' speed. I got Makita 18v stuff and it is awesome

    • @e.lan.s
      @e.lan.s 5 месяцев назад

      i myself used some makitas installing solar energy.
      5000mAh batteries lasted a whole shift putting self tappers on 3mm thick metal trusses.
      Pretty unbelievable to have these things choochin all day no hesitation.

  • @eemeliuusitalo3638
    @eemeliuusitalo3638 2 года назад +24

    I'm not sure if the models from other brands are old models, but DDF481 from Makita is succeeded by DDF486. The 481 has definitely aged well and it's still comparable to other brands, i have had mine for eight (8) years and i couldn't be happier. The drill has seen about a year and a half worth of professional electrical installation use and the rest of the use has been general use around the house.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +7

      They are all the same generation. Bosch 18V-110C was succeeded by 18V-150C, Dewalt DCD996 by 998 and 999, Metabo as well.

  • @craigwilson6049
    @craigwilson6049 2 года назад +87

    Makita is the best for me. I'm a tradie with nearly 40 years experience and I've had a big range of tools to play with. If you're serious and have the $ then makita is the best by a long shot. Ive had some of the 3amp batteries for 6 years and theyre still going good.

    • @keithhoward4069
      @keithhoward4069 2 года назад +9

      Yes. I am a professional locksmith. I do many hotels and condos, military bases. Makita may not be the most powerfully horsepowered gun, but it is reliable and has the finness needed. It also isn't too heavy to be used continuosly all day as I do lock after lock after lock on these big Hotels. Long lasting batteries that charge quickly also.If you want the best heavy horsepower gun. Milwaukee is for you.

    • @vinceruland9236
      @vinceruland9236 2 года назад +4

      I agree. Makita has suited me very well for years.

    • @nbco55
      @nbco55 2 года назад

      I'm just now killing some of my 3ah, 8yrs old through -20*f to 100*f!

    • @josephpa05
      @josephpa05 2 года назад +3

      Makita is the past Milwaukee is the future

    • @keithhoward4069
      @keithhoward4069 2 года назад +4

      @@josephpa05 depends on what you need. Milwaukee is too heavy and overpowered for detail work such as I do. I install electronic locks, digital key locks, mag locks electric strike with readers. Makita fits my requirements better.

  • @anonymoususerhere
    @anonymoususerhere Год назад +6

    I refurbish/build furniture and I purchased an entire DeWalt set on sale and it's been just over 5yrs. No issues so far. I'm thankful for the sale and for its durability over the years 🤘

  • @Lasky202
    @Lasky202 2 года назад +32

    I like the DeWalt. I have a impact and drill I paid 550 for but have never been let down. Makita makes the best skill saw and matabo makes the best grinders. But that's just my opinion. That's just my experience ,I'm not biased toward any of them.

    • @seanwiddowson5008
      @seanwiddowson5008 2 года назад +1

      At 550 I think you would expect that . Have makita set of drill and impact at half the price at 200 which peforms just as good if not better and on top of that the S.D.S drill all within that budget of 500 👌

    • @Wkyliving
      @Wkyliving 2 года назад +1

      All my cordless tools are dewalt and that's what I stick with other then my corded skill saw I went with makita too and definitely don't regret it.

  • @garrydhintz8017
    @garrydhintz8017 2 года назад +72

    Most impressed with Makita here. The biggest let down was probably Bosch and Metabo. DeWalt and Milwaukee looked strong as well.

    • @doitbeforeyoudieful
      @doitbeforeyoudieful 2 года назад +1

      Ye, i have Metabo LT, its a solid build but I would say weaker.

    • @william_gran-sorensen
      @william_gran-sorensen 2 года назад +7

      Bosch got a way more powerfull one that is easily strenger than all the others

    • @lecoureurdesbois86
      @lecoureurdesbois86 Год назад +4

      @@william_gran-sorensen And the others don't?

    • @dolmarf411
      @dolmarf411 Год назад

      no, this was the strongest makita..........@@lecoureurdesbois86

    • @Ivangomezescultor
      @Ivangomezescultor 20 дней назад +2

      Hilti gana a todas ellas 😅

  • @karabela1043
    @karabela1043 Год назад +6

    Hello, I'm an air conditioner installer, Makita is the best for heavy duty and for a long time, 8-9 hours a day. I've used it for 10 years. It doesn't break for 8 hours a day. Makita gives confidence

  • @mikehenthorn1778
    @mikehenthorn1778 2 года назад +15

    Really at the price point we are looking at how it feels in the hand for all day work is more important than a .5 second of speed or 50 ft lb of torque.
    I use Bosch because they fit me best. As a lefty the safety placement on some items is a solid sell for me.

  • @creative_expressionproductions
    @creative_expressionproductions 2 года назад +25

    For me the speed is pointless. All of these tools do the job better than my hands. What I am interested in is how many times can the tools repeat the job before giving up or running out of batt? I don't work on a site and drive on 9"lag bolt a day...

    • @tommygun5038
      @tommygun5038 2 года назад +4

      It is nice to see a side by side comparison though. A lot of companies fudge their specs.

    • @creative_expressionproductions
      @creative_expressionproductions 2 года назад +2

      @@tommygun5038 true. For me it was a toss up between Makita and Milwaukee...for DIY stuff it's a colour preference at the end of the day😅

  • @kenturner3268
    @kenturner3268 Год назад +3

    I purchased the GSB18V-1330 hammer drill. A BOSCH GCM18V-10SDN PROFACTOR miter saw. Two GXS18V-16N14 battery and charger kits and two spare 8ah core batteries. I am impressed except for the fact that the batteries fit in the drill so loose you can feel them move when using it. The drill has never even been on a job and it won't be going to one because of the battery fit issue. All of the other contractors that have used my miter saw were blown away by the capacity and performance at just 40 pounds. That has prompted me to order the 7 1/4 miter saw. The drill will be going back for a makita XGT. I can't believe bosch would release substandard crap like this for the contractor crowd to purchase, These are not home owner drills so why the suzy homemaker quality control. I own 3 impactor/drill combos from bosch from 2008 that still have better battery fitment than this new 1330. DON'T BUY IT.

  • @divinerandc7243
    @divinerandc7243 2 года назад +7

    Everyone has their favorite… i use Milwaukee and have all of them… they havent failed me at all

  • @alimuratvarsl3069
    @alimuratvarsl3069 2 года назад +33

    I always say, these cordless drills are the invention of the century.

    • @PurpleHurrple
      @PurpleHurrple 2 года назад +6

      For real when I'm at the construction site I sometimes think to myself how absolutely revolutionary power-tools must have been to the industry.

    • @gameseeker6307
      @gameseeker6307 2 года назад

      They really are

    • @timjohnson1199
      @timjohnson1199 2 года назад +1

      I can't imagine being without them. On the rare occasions when I use a corded drill I'm acutely aware of the difference.

    • @TheEchelon
      @TheEchelon 2 года назад +1

      No, computers are. You know, the thing that you're watching this video on (yes smartphones too) and that was used to engineer these cordless drills.

  • @lateralol
    @lateralol Год назад +13

    To those that write about the longevity of the tools, think of this: if the tool struggles with the task and you repeatedly use it, will it last very long? The fastest to deal with the task at hand will serve longer. It really is that simple.

    • @sombatone
      @sombatone Год назад

      That being said, Makita everyday, today was a good day

    • @antipatriarchy
      @antipatriarchy Год назад +2

      thats just plain pathetic. so you think a sprinter can last as long as a marathon runner, calling things simple, is also an overestimation of yourself solely as your comment is already full of lies.

    • @lateralol
      @lateralol Год назад

      @@antipatriarchy if you are so inclined to "bash" on my statement, at least give an "apples to apples" comparison. So far you didn't give any clue as to why my statement doesn't work out.

    • @vaakdemandante8772
      @vaakdemandante8772 Год назад +1

      @@lateralol if the tool is a slower performer but a consistent one and does not choke on the screws, than it is most likely going to last longer than a faster tool. It really depends is the tool only slower or is actually struggling to finish the job. The one struggling, be it fast or slow is the first one to go. The the fast one because of wear and tear, and then the slower one. Assuming they have the same power output.

  • @mrbigberd
    @mrbigberd 2 года назад +18

    Bosch has released their 150 model with 1330 in/lb up from the 973 in/lb of the 110 seen here. It would be great to see that in the mix as it has 30% more torque.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +3

      The 150C model is part of the new generation. It should be compared with 486 from Makita, 999 from DeWalt, etc

    • @mrbigberd
      @mrbigberd 2 года назад +2

      @@ToolTest Your terms are acceptable.

    • @HabudaKimdur61
      @HabudaKimdur61 Год назад

      Hat mich nur geld gekostet und ist kaputt

  • @vangelisevangelou4545
    @vangelisevangelou4545 2 года назад +19

    Metabo you have the 4 amp battery and the old one..sorry but is not fair

  • @sweetkiller9696
    @sweetkiller9696 2 года назад +4

    Power is important but in my opinion reliability and a long life are also very important

  • @gattiroberto8415
    @gattiroberto8415 2 года назад +5

    With bosch you have to use the procore bateries at min 8ah to use the max power with secure battery's life AND with the Dewalt price you can get a 150C in bosch and its a lot better performance prices/power comparison.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад

      No, it would have been at an advantage for Bosch compared to the rest of the drills tested, because apart from Metabo, they all use the same generation of batteries, with the same capacity. If I had put ProCore at the Bosch, then I should have also put PowerStack on DeWalt, etc. In any case, the clip is old and many drills in the clip are from the previous generation.

    • @gattiroberto8415
      @gattiroberto8415 2 года назад +1

      @@ToolTestwell, as comparison Bosch with procore is other tool to benchmark, maybe the same tool with powerstack does not took advantage with older tools despite compatibility.

    • @TheDwightMamba
      @TheDwightMamba 3 месяца назад

      Bosch literally says their new drill won't reach its full potential until an 8 or 12 Amp ProCore clicks in.

  • @mutatedAi
    @mutatedAi 2 года назад +8

    Unless they crack the tools open to see build quality inside I find these tests limited. 😞

  • @aaronpops4108
    @aaronpops4108 2 года назад +43

    I am really impressed with my Bosch drill. It's a beast.
    I'm surprised it didn't do better in these tests.

    • @christiaanbarnard2451
      @christiaanbarnard2451 2 года назад +24

      Same here. Our company mostly uses Bosch and they perform a lot better than in this video.

    • @ak4.
      @ak4. 2 года назад +6

      New bosch not as good as old ones i got one from 2007 and its a total beast

    • @svenblumenthal4626
      @svenblumenthal4626 2 года назад +22

      He uses the old batteries, procore are much stronger

    • @veridico84
      @veridico84 2 года назад +2

      I have the older Bosch lithium 18v and a new one, I also have a Makita and Milwaukee, and the Bosch are rubbish compared. They are good enough to use, but worse than the other top brands.

    • @probotaktor320
      @probotaktor320 2 года назад +4

      The blue Bosch is the profimachine! Not the green!

  • @totolilititi4694
    @totolilititi4694 2 года назад +6

    I got a Panasonic since 2016 i work with it everyday and it still very performant

  • @YiZuSc
    @YiZuSc 2 года назад +14

    Awesome video, thank you. I would suggest putting a summary chart with all the timings.

    • @FotoCreatives
      @FotoCreatives 2 года назад

      Makita is really worthless....have had several and all have a lot of play on the shaft (especially during fine drilling in metal). Just like DeWalt...also such a bad brand...interior is all made in China. Festool is really so much better! These kind of stupid movies tell absolutely nothing about the quality...play, etc.

    • @truthserum9157
      @truthserum9157 2 года назад +1

      @@FotoCreatives - your English and choice of words tells me your a foreigner, probably Germany, this is why you chose Festool, I’ve seen Festool drills in a test fall miserably, I love their tracksaw and there sanders and dust collection but not their drills.

  • @cloric1
    @cloric1 2 года назад +16

    Looks like Milwaukee was the all round hero,
    Dewalt excelled at almost everything but struggled on one or two.
    Makita did ok.
    I think it be fair to list them
    1. Dewalt
    2. Milwaukee, didn’t struggle on any.
    3. Makita.
    Im already stuck on Milwaukee with a fairly big range ive bought,
    I can’t fault them, I’ve abused them, the warranty policy is faultless, ive broke a few and either had them fixed or a new replacement sent within 4 days every time via courier.

  • @sweetkiller9696
    @sweetkiller9696 2 года назад +3

    I work as a car mechanic in Germany at mercedes and we all use mostly makita e-tools

  • @servisboschiltihiltimakita7960
    @servisboschiltihiltimakita7960 2 года назад +13

    can we trust you on how much the batteries are charged? and what is the speed/torque rate for each tool because as i can see some have 3 gear levels others 2 and different tools have different applications having different speed/torque rates.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +5

      From my point of view, you have two options. Trust me or not. :) You can see the speed setting for each one on the top right. The drills were set to either the highest or the lowest speed, no matter how many speed levels each has. (Only DeWalt had 3 speed levels)

    • @6atlantis
      @6atlantis 2 года назад +2

      @@ToolTest i’m not nitpicking and I appreciate your video and I know every battery can’t be the same size you have to use what’s available, but you should’ve at least used Boschs’ newer core 21700 cell batteries

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +1

      @@6atlantis It would not have been fair to use the new batteries at Bosch, and at the others to use the old ones. The main idea of this was to see the behavior of each tools, fed (more or less) by the same power. All tested tools were powered by (approximately) the same batteries (except for Metabo where I did not have a battery of the same capacity).

    • @6atlantis
      @6atlantis 2 года назад

      @@ToolTest I disagree, I read some other comments after I commented and saw your view on things. If you were testing a Ryobi HP tool would you not use an HP battery because it has an extra connector? I can probably come up with a better analogy than that but using the battery that the tool was designed for is how you should test it as long as it’s still 18v/20v and the closets amp hour batteries you can find.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +2

      @@6atlantis "using the battery that the tool was designed for". Exactly, when this model appeared, (the Bosch GSR /GSB 18V-110C), I don't think the new 21700 cell batteries were launched. So I used the classic GBA batteries, the ones with 18650 cells. For better performance with the new ProCore batteries and others in the new ranges, they launched 18v-150C. When you do such tests, you usually want to see two things. First, see how the tools behaves when receive the same power, and second, test the most powerful models available on the market, of course with the best batteries they have in that range. In this video, I wanted to see the first thing.

  • @santos54
    @santos54 2 года назад +19

    These tests should be monitored by an independent body and recognized, in that way only can it be recognized with the authenticity of the tests performed

    • @brucemiller1696
      @brucemiller1696 2 года назад +2

      These tests are just a basic overview. Wood density changes throughout the boards and the person holding the drill has different pressures on it, so a true test is nearly impossible.

    • @santos54
      @santos54 2 года назад +8

      @@brucemiller1696 Lol .. the test was a "rubbish" test, that's all

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +11

      Why, maybe because your favorite brand didn't behave as you hoped? 😀

    • @sonnyoldenburger51
      @sonnyoldenburger51 2 года назад +5

      I agree Santos ......... this is just fake as hell .... using half batteries on some on purpose and multiple times he let the trigger go on purpose but he think nobody seen that 🙄

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +4

      @@sonnyoldenburger51 I don't normally respond to stupid comments, but this clip has become quite popular and I wouldn't want other users to form a wrong opinion. Can you prove that the batteries were half charged? I think you're confusing me, I'm not a fanatic, and the tests I show you are as objective as possible.

  • @sickofitall8486
    @sickofitall8486 2 года назад +9

    One of the best ways to see which tools are well built, is to go visit a tool rental place.
    They aren’t going to rent out cheap crap that breaks down easily.
    Sure enough, you see lots of Makita tools in the rental section.

  • @TheSundanceKid71
    @TheSundanceKid71 2 года назад +6

    As a contractor I use Makita now because I have a good deal on them, and I'm satisfied. But I have to say I miss my old Dewalt.

  • @embohmaskud7464
    @embohmaskud7464 2 года назад +2

    there is no need to actually fight, because the hardness of the wood at each point is not the same, also wood waste sometimes blocks the drill bits with unequal amounts

  • @thepawchoe2749
    @thepawchoe2749 2 года назад +4

    I've never seen any other brand besides makita consistently compete with Milwaukee. I don't own Milwaukee but I sure as hell am glad I bought makita.

  • @OpinionFromGenX
    @OpinionFromGenX Месяц назад

    As a contractor I own sets from the big 3 and in my experience, using a 5amh battery and quick chargers for each brand Milwaukee produces the most power in general, Dewalts are the most common making it easier to borrow a battery in a pinch or a tool and use your own battery if necessary. Makita batteries charge the fasted. I find myself grabbing the Makitas because power consumption is fairly close between the 3 but makita gets me back in the game the quickest when the juice fades.

  • @gilgameshxxx6896
    @gilgameshxxx6896 2 года назад +36

    Muchos de los enganchones en la madera puede ser debido a nudos o cambios de densidad. La madera fue algo vivo y por lo tanto no es constante. Tal vez debieran de probarse en algún material sintético. La prueba no me parece válida.

  • @redraiderrider3289
    @redraiderrider3289 2 года назад +4

    Pretty impressed by the Dewalt and makita tbh. Weren't my first choice but I'm also not a fan boy if Milwaukee tools. I'm actually looking to get a combo kit and I know it won't be Milwaukee

    • @user-gb2gq8lb3s
      @user-gb2gq8lb3s Год назад

      What did you get eventually? You can’t blindly trust any of these brands.. for example, here in the UK, I started on Makita and within 6 months the drill and the planer were a toast and I have been on Milwaukee for over 2 years of heavy abuse - no problems so far. My partner is on festool - one tool or the other always in the service centre for repairs. There is no one size fits all solution..

    • @adammeyer3129
      @adammeyer3129 Год назад

      Saying your not a fanboy already shows a massive bias.

  • @bobspread
    @bobspread 2 года назад +4

    Not Bosch's flagship. It would be fairer to see their best drill compete. For future ref, pop a timer up on the screen, user error was at fault for a couple of the times above.... also covered metabos final time with next video clip.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +1

      This video is older, meanwhile other more powerful models have appeared in each range

    • @_Rudi_666
      @_Rudi_666 2 года назад +1

      Same with Metabo. This isnt the brushless version. The BL has much more power. I use it at home and drilled four 12mm holes 150mm deep in a row in heavily reinforced concrete without pre-drilling. Had absolutly no issues with that. The BL version is another league as the regular version. This test is unvalid cause different classes of drills are compared.
      Despite this video is older, Metabo produces brushless versions for many years. Mine for example is 6 years old I think, cant remember exactly.

    • @bobspread
      @bobspread 2 года назад +1

      @@_Rudi_666 love Metabo.
      Their stuff is bullet proof.
      The best in my opinion!
      I have their impacts and combis and mixer drills and grinders.
      The best.

    • @_Rudi_666
      @_Rudi_666 2 года назад +1

      @@bobspread Yeah, Metabo is great when it comes to cordless tools. One of the best (affordable) brands. Sure, there is better stuff but this is made for professionals which use it daily in the workshop or construction site. This is reflected in the price, which is two or three time as high as for machines made for costumers. But I disgress.
      I own a cordless drill, angelgrinder and saber saw from Metabo. Everyone of them is an awsome tool. More then enough power for private and semi-professional use. Even for professionals they are a good option. And the most important thing, they are very reliable. Never had one single issue over the years with these machines.

  • @t-rex4211
    @t-rex4211 Год назад +2

    Looks like as long as you steer clear of Bosch and Metabo then you’re golden 👍

    • @LiamBoyle-mb6ms
      @LiamBoyle-mb6ms Год назад

      Metabo combi in this was an outdated drill with an old battery as well.

  • @jegr3398
    @jegr3398 2 года назад +43

    Makita has always made the best drills in my experience

    • @stepanikmichal
      @stepanikmichal 2 года назад +10

      Makita is trash...its not depend on speed but how long drills can work. Makita after year is broken, but Dewalt could you 5 years

    • @danivplus8530
      @danivplus8530 2 года назад +15

      Makita and Drills are Made for eachother , best Drills out there , used my grandpa Makita 12v 17 years

    • @jonathangarzon2798
      @jonathangarzon2798 2 года назад +11

      @@stepanikmichal not in metalworking, maybe in soft wood dewalts king but when it's only hard metals you're drilling in day after day, Makita been the most reliable and batteries last longer

    • @przemysawrz.4918
      @przemysawrz.4918 2 года назад +8

      Yes, Makita is Pro. For me only Makita.

    • @evictioncarpentry2628
      @evictioncarpentry2628 2 года назад +9

      @@stepanikmichal do you sniff glue? Makita is 1000x better then dewalt. Makita makes their own electric motors. That's what they started out as.
      Makita impacts and drills are far superior to dewalt and milwaukee.
      Thats not even makitas newest model either. I have the new one and it's even more powerful then the one he's using here.

  • @Muv-Luv
    @Muv-Luv 2 года назад +4

    The moral: you can buy anything if it's DW, Makita or Milwaukee.

  • @ufukoozaltin487
    @ufukoozaltin487 2 года назад +6

    You can't do a tool test without Hilti..... They are all crab against the no. 1 in professional tools.

  • @sondre.linonus.berglund
    @sondre.linonus.berglund Год назад +1

    The Dewalt is rated at 95nm? And the milwaukee at 135nm? How come that milwaukee and dewalt are so close? And the makita is at 125nm, and both bosch and metabo is at 110nm🤔 there has to be more to it than torque. And my experience with owning a ton of bosch is that it doesn't like water at all. Can we get a water test?

  • @paulrash8861
    @paulrash8861 2 года назад +7

    Makita has always been a solid unit, I'm talking bout from the late 80s till now 👍

  • @sloppyjalopys1739
    @sloppyjalopys1739 10 месяцев назад

    Truly depends on why you have it. If its to look pretty in your garage obviously dewalt is the "designer" brand. As a carpenter ive used Dewalt, Ryobi, Makita, Rigid, and Milwaukee any drill that the boss found on sale my preference was Rigid i ran that thing 8-10 hours a day for over 5 years.

  • @MarceloSilva-ht7rx
    @MarceloSilva-ht7rx 2 года назад +8

    Pra min qualquer uma dessas aí eu já ficaria muito feliz em ter

  • @producoescriativaseengenha1682
    @producoescriativaseengenha1682 2 года назад +2

    Interesting. However for a fair comparison it would be helpfull to know the power of each one of these machines. Power=Torque x angular speed. It seems that deWalt has more power than the others....

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +1

      You have links to each of them in the description

  • @abnerlopez2274
    @abnerlopez2274 Год назад +8

    I think I have the best. DeWalt.

  • @rodnabors7364
    @rodnabors7364 Год назад +1

    Thanks, nice test. I got a set of new 20V Dewalt tools last year, to replace some 18v units that had seen serious duty. The new DeWalts were NOTICABLY cheaper made and less durable. I'm looking at maybe Milwaukee or Makita now.

    • @SuperChipperson
      @SuperChipperson Год назад

      never been a fan of dewalt maybe because everyone else seems to have them or my boss back in-the day having old piece of sh1t dewalt drill putting up rain gutters 🤬

  • @januszR
    @januszR 2 года назад +9

    Thanks for the interesting video. Unfortunately you used the older Bosch (new: gsr 18v-150 c) and older Makita (new: ddf486).

    • @captaron
      @captaron 2 года назад +1

      It still held up pretty well for an older model and even the Bosch I would be happy with.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад

      I know, the video is older

    • @julienfislage
      @julienfislage 2 года назад +3

      Bosch with an old battery isnt a fair test. Most power with an procore battery.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +3

      Precisely because I used older batteries, it's a fair test. Because the batteries from Makita, DeWalt and Metabo are also old.

    • @julienfislage
      @julienfislage 2 года назад

      @@ToolTest half the power because of an old battery is fair?

  • @takis-t2g
    @takis-t2g 19 дней назад

    in my old working days Metabo was above all other drills ( not hummer drills Hilti Was) Beautiful to use so well balance so true running n its speed control was something else now Bosch have taken them over how good are they?

  • @kamalasanan7
    @kamalasanan7 2 года назад +34

    Makita is the best one

    • @tudordruta5555
      @tudordruta5555 2 года назад

      Best one is Hilti and Makita 40v💪🏻

    • @kizzjd9578
      @kizzjd9578 2 года назад +1

      Dhp486 is even better

  • @roger55es
    @roger55es 3 месяца назад

    The real test of durability is 1 Battery life , 2 when its stops due to overheating ,
    The life span ,Whats the upsides & downsides.
    Price .
    Life span
    Battery replacement cost.
    Replacement parts & costs .
    If you cannot buy replacement parts then its a short term o hobbyist type of tool

  • @njmikeche5575
    @njmikeche5575 2 года назад +23

    Various tool test reviews can be fun to watch, but realistically there isn't usually enough daylight between the comparable units in each brand to justify getting into multiple battery platforms. It is also not just about speed and power, Makita came out with a 40V system and the smaller hand held tools (e.g., impact driver, hammer drill) have almost exactly the same performance as their 18V counterparts. This suggests that Makita engineers thought these tools were already powerful enough. Making them over-powered might cause vibration or ergonomics issues. I doubt that the Milwaukee actually enables you to build a deck faster. By the way is that the Hitachi-Metabo or the actual German Metabo-Metabo? Or is Metabo HPT still called "Hikoki" outside the US?

    • @tommygun5038
      @tommygun5038 2 года назад +3

      Most are already at the limits of the fasteners strength. They'll just snap. If they weren't most people would just buy an M12 impact wrench at 250ft lbs.

    • @jani0077
      @jani0077 Год назад +2

      this is the German Metabo, and the Metabo HPT is still called Hikoki, at least in Europe (was in a Home Depot style shop yesterday). Btw, the German Metabo sold in Europe has more options than those sold in the US.

  • @pskumthekar
    @pskumthekar 10 месяцев назад

    Sir thanks for excellent demonstration. Add a result of comparison chart.

  • @TheJensss
    @TheJensss 2 года назад +7

    Bosch with the new procore batteries are also a good combo. I think Bosch would have performed a lot better with an 8ah procore battery.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +3

      Sure, but then it wouldn't have been a fair test for the others

    • @TheJensss
      @TheJensss 2 года назад +2

      @@ToolTest That's true, but I think the tools tested in the video is limited by the battery. So if you do a follow up video where each brand has the new type of battery, and compare the tools then, and the results to the old results. That could be a really interesting video.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +3

      "the tools tested in the video is limited by the battery", yes, they are.

  • @PhillipRodriguez-bp1tu
    @PhillipRodriguez-bp1tu Год назад

    Danke für die Bewertung, jetzt weiß ich genau was ich kaufen soll🤤

  • @irmaosthiagoedeivaladario-1088
    @irmaosthiagoedeivaladario-1088 2 года назад +5

    Um dos melhores teste que eu vi parabéns pela produção de vídeo

  • @skytyme7721
    @skytyme7721 Год назад +1

    The best drills are not listed, such as Hilty, and Festool

  • @ecosse543
    @ecosse543 2 года назад +34

    Dewalts don't age well. Makita's seem to be able to take a bit more punishment before they start to look and feel tired. Definitely more durable if your using and abusing them day in day out. Makita is top with Dewalt next. Wouldn't even bother with Bosch because you need arms like the Hulk to lift their cordless drills.

    • @paulwhat322
      @paulwhat322 2 года назад +2

      I guess Dewalt is a lot cheaper than Makita.

    • @ajs96350
      @ajs96350 2 года назад +3

      As the owner of many Makita cordless tools, you are correct.
      Daily use for years and they're still good.
      I get about 4 years out of the batteries.

    • @simonrano8072
      @simonrano8072 2 года назад +7

      My deWalt drill took seven stories fall on compact soil, not a single scratch.

    • @vsahankrat7176
      @vsahankrat7176 2 года назад

      I mean you have a 3 year warranty

    • @WATCHING-247
      @WATCHING-247 2 года назад +6

      The Bosch is heavier due to the build quality you take them apart you can see the difference and honestly its very disappointing opening Dewalt and Makita also Milwaukee isn't too impressive.
      If you think Bosch is a too heavy you need to sort those wimpy arms out bud or maybe you'd be better at McDonalds.

  • @giovannijuniordimartino232
    @giovannijuniordimartino232 2 года назад +1

    Why for bosh are use normal battery instead the pro ?
    This model of drill is made for this kind of battery. Anyway good video .

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +3

      I used old type batteries in all the tools tested, precisely so as not to favor any of them. In any case, the model in the video is 18V-110C, not 18V-150C, the latter of which was built to perform with ProCore batteries, etc.

  • @SaturnineXTS
    @SaturnineXTS 2 года назад +6

    Darn, Metabo definitely didn't do as well as I was hoping. Good thing they've got the torque x3 attachment, which does cost money but ensures all kinds of work like this are guaranteed to succeed

    • @hairyrice5407
      @hairyrice5407 2 года назад +5

      On metabo he is using 4AH battery...
      Big diference... Not fair at all

    • @hownowbrowncow9704
      @hownowbrowncow9704 2 года назад

      @@hairyrice5407 that's just the capacity of the battery. Milwaukee actually makes high output batteries which i believe he was using the regular xc batteries.

    • @hairyrice5407
      @hairyrice5407 2 года назад +4

      @@hownowbrowncow9704
      It is not just capacity... It is power as well... 4 amp baterry can not deliver as much power as 5.5... I have both and it is a big difference expecialy with angle grinder...

    • @hownowbrowncow9704
      @hownowbrowncow9704 2 года назад +2

      @@hairyrice5407 there's a small difference as amp hours usually just relates to how many cells there are for storage so more cells distributes the load easier, but does not change the actual out put or the c rating which is how fast it can discharge. 1.5 vs 5 ah sure there a difference there but 4ah and 5 ah would be nearly impossible to tell apart. Lithium batteries are really confusing how they all work but I worked at a hobby store where I quickly became the go to person for rc trucks, and the main thing I would have to explain was lithium batteries. Although these drill batteries are different the same principles still apply.

    • @hairyrice5407
      @hairyrice5407 2 года назад

      @@hownowbrowncow9704
      Well im sure you are well educated about it but im just saying what i have try and put on the test for myself... Every one who tests those power tools measure with time and the difference is seconds... Or 0.3 seconds which is almost no difference...
      If ju have strong power tool you need big battery... Angle ginder with 4amp is no go my friend... So is those drill machines they are making in very strong nowdays...
      And for those bolts it is better to screw them with impact tool😃

  • @mortezagolmakani484
    @mortezagolmakani484 Год назад

    The best video tools ever no extra words and wasting people time.
    Thank you

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  Год назад

      Thank you for the view 👍

  • @nezaustavljiv1
    @nezaustavljiv1 2 года назад +12

    Hilti!Number one proffesional tools!

  • @vidright
    @vidright Год назад +1

    I use power tools only for private use. All my tools are Makita and I have been using them for about 20 years. I have never had any issues with Makita tools and not a single failure.

  • @cal5566
    @cal5566 2 года назад +7

    That DeWalt is really surprising, I think the Makita has the power in the motor but the over loads kick in too fast, unlike the Milwaukee that just keeps calling for more current.

    • @jamesadams7131
      @jamesadams7131 2 года назад +2

      The Makita overload protection will give longevity to the tool which is what you want. These were not the right tool for those bigger bits if you are driving more than a few at a time, or in a pinch. In my opinion, if you're using the right tool for the application, all these modern tools are decent, it's the longevity of tool and power pack that you want.

  • @benkohout6495
    @benkohout6495 11 месяцев назад

    Bosch is known for batteries (battery life), dewalt is American, makita Japanese, we all know Japanese cars and electronics will outlast American. They’ll all drill. Just depends on the job site. Are you drilling into concrete? Do you need an 18v, 12v? Is it for around the house or for decking?

  • @ALEXSARR20
    @ALEXSARR20 2 года назад +4

    If you try a hilti, you win by far. HILTI is the best ever. second place Milwaukee, third place Makita.

    • @geodias8627
      @geodias8627 2 года назад

      That’s the correct order if we are speaking about professional tools.

    • @lambert1875
      @lambert1875 2 года назад

      Beg to differ. I work for a company that uses Hilti drills and we are replacing them with Milwaukee. We find milwaukee power tools better and cheaper. Don't know how Hilti can charge what they can.

    • @anthrazite
      @anthrazite 2 года назад +1

      Milwaukee ain't gonna last for shit though

    • @lambert1875
      @lambert1875 2 года назад

      @@anthrazite 3 years warrenty says other wise . Hilti are good but there repair costs dont justify the cost of a new tool £180 to look at a drill before its even been touched .. No thanks

    • @anthrazite
      @anthrazite 2 года назад

      @@lambert1875 3 years warranty is nothing special, and Milwaukee tools age horribly so that ain't gonna help ya anyway

  • @kalijasin
    @kalijasin Год назад +1

    The Makita got the job done but it was really struggling.

  • @florinradu7838
    @florinradu7838 2 года назад +8

    I take the dewalt for me, thanks 😊

    • @montanatony5838
      @montanatony5838 2 года назад

      Milwaukee all the way...
      I've had better luck with Milwaukee with longevity and performance, Dewalts got that Purdy yellow though

  • @matthewella8280
    @matthewella8280 Месяц назад

    i think everyone has there own preference ive had nearly almost every tool u can think of apart from dewalt bosch professional have lasted me around 5 years still now and still going makita tools are really good also but ones ive had fall to bits after around 3 or 4 years and ive just started on milwaukee fuel atm really good drills they are on the heavy side also but hence heavy duty i use the M12 and M18 angle grinder awesome kits

  • @davidkelly2
    @davidkelly2 2 года назад +4

    Now you need to run these tests with Bosch gloves, Makita gloves, Milw--

  • @interman7715
    @interman7715 2 года назад +1

    Can't go wrong with yellow, teal blue or red ,imo.

  • @АрчиПо
    @АрчиПо 2 года назад +6

    Makita 18v... Xgt top

  • @ducka0f
    @ducka0f 2 года назад +1

    Can you do an actual test where it's fair for all drills? Like applying the same pressure to the drills.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад

      The tests you saw were as accurate as possible. At least I tried my best. If you have the impression that I have applied more pressure on some models, in order to cheat, I can do 1000 tests, you will remain with your fixation. Both, the screws and especially the drills I used, they pull themselves into the wood, you don't have to apply pressure. The only reason you have to apply a little pressure is when you want to keep the bit as fixed as possible in the head of the screw, but this does not affect the screwing speed at all. So, if you have the impression that I have tried to put certain models in a better light, you can do the tests yourself at any time, and see how each model behaves. Thanks for the view.

  • @wojciechrachwal8373
    @wojciechrachwal8373 2 года назад +6

    Only Hilti

  • @Palpac
    @Palpac Год назад

    You are using the DeWalt 996 was the most powerful at it's time for wood and concrete, but 2 other Dewalts have come out since then that produce more power.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  Год назад

      I used drill drivers of the same generation. In the meantime, much more powerful models have come out at Makita and Bosch and Metabo, etc. Those will have to be tested in another video.

  • @christiansprojects-cgmanuf1426
    @christiansprojects-cgmanuf1426 2 года назад +14

    Interesting test. It would be interesting to see, how the most powerful models from each brand perform. For example, there's the SB 18 LTX BL I from Metabo which has 20Nm more than the one you tested.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +6

      I hope to make another video soon, with the new top models from each brand

  • @robertshoemaker6204
    @robertshoemaker6204 13 дней назад

    Have Makita and Milwaukee....Dewalt had some but didn't hold up as well.

  • @IMPACT-NATION
    @IMPACT-NATION 2 года назад +8

    Awesome video man. Great job on the testing! So glad I came across your channel. I just started my own channel couple months ago and I love comparing impact drivers. You just gained a new subscriber my friend. Looking forward to catching up on your videos

  • @mogbaba
    @mogbaba 6 месяцев назад

    I am a causal hobbyist and have found Metabo a good brand. Good quality and reasonable price.

  • @Shpongful
    @Shpongful 2 года назад +14

    Makita hands down.. this is not even competition.

    • @edwardmatthews5899
      @edwardmatthews5899 2 года назад

      Yeah me too that and hitachi are my go tos the extra price of dewalts and Milwaukee here in nz don’t validate the trade off for what you get.

  • @nikoGR86
    @nikoGR86 2 года назад +2

    LOL Bosch 18v-150 without ProCore?

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +1

      The model in the video is 18V-110C, not 18V-150C

  • @xokemon
    @xokemon 2 года назад +3

    Metabo LTX BL Qi is better then the LTX

  • @kato_dsrdr
    @kato_dsrdr 10 месяцев назад

    If I'll buy power tools, I'll buy makita because the makita angle grinders on my welding school are like 10 years old and still works perfectly.

  • @21powertools
    @21powertools 2 года назад +3

    Good review and test👍👍👍

  • @joejoejoe3387
    @joejoejoe3387 2 года назад +2

    U have top models only Metabo is old model with brush motor.

  • @baggerbaggerbaggerst.5458
    @baggerbaggerbaggerst.5458 2 года назад +10

    RUclips ned Metabo 18v ltx bl Q1 and than is it fair!

  • @RealeaD
    @RealeaD Год назад

    After reading a lot of comments here it seems Makita is all around best in terms of longevity and also battery life. I don't think Makita fans gathered here. It seems analogues to Japanese cars :) Some people in USA and Europe only concerned about power and features, so they call Toyota crap, but they don't know Toyota don't break compared to European and American cars. I am going to buy Makita.

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  Год назад

      They are intended for home, hobby area

  • @kirovfactory
    @kirovfactory 2 года назад +9

    Dewalt DCD999 flexvolt advantage would make some kills here

    • @KallenSC
      @KallenSC 2 года назад +1

      Milwaukke would kill that advantage with high output battery not with higher voltage!

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +3

      The same would be done with the new 486 from Makita or 150C from Bosch, but the clip is about the old top of the range

    • @mattek519
      @mattek519 2 года назад

      @@KallenSC no it wouldn't. Even in this video, something isnt right. That is the dewalt dcd996 which is also a flexvolt advantage drill.
      It's also the second most powerful drill available of any brand only falling short slightly to the dcd 999.
      Every tool vs channel has proven this so its weird how this channel is the only channel to show milwaukee beating the dewalt.
      Lol

    • @ToolTest
      @ToolTest  2 года назад +1

      Clearly, I'm not the only channel testing DeWalt and Milwaukee, with Milwaukee doing better. I have no interest in rigging a test, I am deeply objective, what is seen in the filming (and on all my videos), that is the reality. You guys always ask the same questions and I always come back with the same answer. When doing such a versus, you must try not to clearly put in an advantage situation one of the models in detriment of the other. You would have liked me to use Flexvolt batteries, others have asked me why I have not used ProCore batteries, etc., but what do we do with Makita? So for such a test, you should use as much as possible, the same type of battery for all.

    • @mattek519
      @mattek519 2 года назад +2

      @@ToolTest what channel has a milwaukee doing anything better than a dcd 99x?
      Ill wait.

  • @onlylove1992
    @onlylove1992 2 года назад

    Thanks. I am looking for some tools to buy for my diy job. Pretty useful video

  • @fl3694
    @fl3694 2 года назад +3

    It's very powerful compared to what it looks like

  • @rickylralte308
    @rickylralte308 2 года назад

    i haven't seen this test... i like it, i know which is the best drill from u. thanks a lot... im from India, Mizoram

  • @terryshove5926
    @terryshove5926 2 года назад +9

    For me Dewalt wins every time regardless of your tests

  • @jonsmith9708
    @jonsmith9708 2 года назад +1

    Panasonic and hilti should be tested as well

  • @user-Hsh4885
    @user-Hsh4885 2 года назад +3

    Manly men are Milwaukee 👍👍🇰🇷

    • @mick666
      @mick666 7 месяцев назад

      Leave Red in the Shed. Milwakee is for boys. Dewalt for men.

  • @antoniodavidgilmour4704
    @antoniodavidgilmour4704 2 года назад +1

    In conclusione , non ho capito quale sia il migliore perché le prestazioni variano a seconda di quello che devi fare. Mi aspettavo una classifica finale.

  • @albertinidivago7003
    @albertinidivago7003 2 года назад +4

    Milwaukee my favorite for quality and use

    • @adalberaht
      @adalberaht 2 года назад

      no, i have Milwaukee and all have problems with battery holder after 1 yr battery starts to fall out