Incredible job you have done sir. This much of clarity and substantial information even our so called professional tv channels have not provided. Thanks again for good work 👍. I am watching your all videos. All are marvellous.
Look at the railway line China has built upto its borders. With the present pace, India cannot come close even after 50 years. We need to expedite Rishikesh-Karnaprayag line, bhanupali-bilaspur-manali-Leh line and extend them till our borders on war footing basis.
Indian Government should accelerate in war footing mode all necessary infrastructure including all weather roads to match or even superior to that of China so that India can monitor Chinese activities 24/7 and take offensive measures even with the slighest indication of mischief by the Chinese . This whole thing is scary and totally unacceptable to Indias interests. No wonder that Chinese are jittery and protesting the construction of border roads and the construction of the road leading to Lipulekh which allows the Indian army quick access to the very door steps of China and Chinese controlled areas.
Thanks for the reconnaissance - I found it very entertaining. Indians are very good at doing serious things in funny ways and taking funny things seriously, both often ending up with hilarious results ;-)
The road trough Aksai Chin (China National Highways 219) goes from Sichuan to Xinjiang! From Aksai Chin its only few hundred road kilometers to Kargilik, which has an railway connection (Kashgar-Hotan-Railway).
Not each other the f congress nehru who were all Muslims Nd Indra now a ltalian lady who were too busy looting Nd supporting China Nd Pakistan 🇵🇰 Only now a true indian has taken over if we had started atkeast 40 years ago there would be no Pakistan
Truly hope that both countries can reduce military conflicts in the boarder, sit down, and do business together. Fighter over land is a zero sum game, while cooperating and competing in economy can be win-win game. Worry less about how to divide the cake, but more on how to make the cake larger together.
Now each and every movement of both armies are under watch of respective countries and as such it is not possible for any side to start sudden action on large scale. However Indian main land is much close and smooth which will get a sure advantage over the adversary.
I respect your quality analysis work on the security issues . it's always amezing to see the depth of your analyital work . thanks for creating and sharing with us .
What if during a war the main highway connecting Tibet and aksai chin was bombed by India at several places? Is that highway close to the border a disadvantage for the Chinese?
the chinese were building roads, air port, tunnels, rails all over tibet up to india since 1950.. But all this while the indians were debating whether to build or not border roads.. And when it was decided to build, the chinese protest
@@dcp15121980 Aksai chin has never belonged to India，except in Indian dreams or map. Neither your Brritish papa nor India has control Aksai chin in the history. Wake up,don't live in your dreams,it's not funny,just like a clown!
@@user-bk5zb6sn9w so arunachal sikkim is also urs? Cos there also you tried to make roads. You have boder problems with Taiwan, Butan, Japan, Vietnam, india, honkong. Here all china claim it's China's land. Guess china lives in dreams
@@dcp15121980 ALL land border problems between China and other countries have been settled，except India. Why is India so special？ BTW，Taiwan is not a country，It's a region，and Taiwan is a part of china. this is a fact recongnized by the United Nations and most countries in the world including India.
@@khokan1951 And you were the eunuch who held the torch while Nehru was fornicating to know about these matters. Nehru was potent man unlike the other PMs who were/are bachelors or sent their wives away because of lack of potency.
china govt also fools chinese by showing arunachal pradesh with china but it is with us and they can't do shit about it..........they also proposed they want to exchange tawang for whole aksai chin india would have gained territory but we rejected as tawang is 2 biggest buddhist city . they want monopoly on buddhism really ........buddha was born in lumbini nepal
Sir ,highly admire your work.can you please make a video and elaborate on the chinese presence in Trans-Karakoram Tract. Especially the Shaksgam valley.How strongly do they hold it.Where are the supply lines.I only c a dirt road starting from the highway(G219) running along the Yarkant river and then Kel qinghe, leading to a end point that is exactly on the supposed border.After that in the indian side (rest of the valley) i can not see any roads or military infrastructure in or anywhere near the Shaksgam Valley.Why is it a no Mans land .Why is it not controlled by india when its our territory.Thx, Dhruv.
In 1962, India pursued a progressive policy that constantly encroached on Tibet and China was forced to fight back. In fact, China had always wanted to negotiate with India to maintain peace and friendship. But Nehru refused to say that all of them were Indian territory. Then war broke out. We don't want war. We built the Great Wall more than two thousand years ago. We hope that we can solve the border problem peacefully in the future. China will not fight for Pakistan. But in Pakistan there is China's oil lifeline.
@@samlin3884 So, was India or Nehru involved in "encroaching'" on Tibet in the Qing era, as you allege?? You were talking about the 1960s AD and not of the Qing era 1765 AD, right?? In the 1950s, Tibet was NOT a part of China, since the Qing era had long ceased to be. China had annexed it forcibly; had Tibet been part of China, China would not have to send troops to occupy Tibet. Tibetans, meanwhile, had gained autonomy later on with the creation of successive Tibetan kingdoms independent of Chinese rule. Kingdom of Tibet (1912-51) OK you can Wikipedia OK. Tibet not part of PRC at that point of time OK you can Wikipedia OK. It was a de facto independent (even though unrecognized) state and even de jure it was part of the Republic of China (Kuomintang) that now exists in Taiwan (which the Chinese do not recognize) and NOT the PRC run by the Communist Chinese OK you can Wikipedia OK. So, who did interfere in Tibet; India or Communist China???
Tibet was administered in the Qing Dynasty, and the Dalai Lama was established by the Chinese Emperor. After 1912, the central government of the Republic of China sent commissioners to supervise the selection of the Dalai Lama and the Panchen Lama, and then held ceremonies. At that time, there was the Mongolian Tibet Committee of the Republic of China. In 1945, the Kuomintang retreated to Taiwan and there was still the whole China in law, but the Chinese people did not. Do you understand that the Republic of China inherited everything from the Republic of China? Tibet was managed by the Government of the Republic of China from 1912 to 1945, while the People's Republic of China inherited the Government of the Republic of China. The whole world recognizes that Taiwan is part of China, including your country OK!
My research suggests, not more than 5000 troops of China are in the region at any given point of time. There are no facilities to host more than that. Also in the entire aksai chin area does not even have a civilian population of 2500. Mostly Buddhist Tibetans, ready to cross over to India where they are free to practice their religion and way of life!
The 5,000 troops serve as a tripwire. If India just sent 1 soldier across Tibetan border, China will mobilize and send 500,000 troops into Tibet to defend it. Tibet is one of the most important strategic region of China.
Now that most of the papers pertaining to the period have been declassified, could you provide a reference which supports this date of 1951? Some books have been published which have reference to this road. What I have read is that the first suspicion that the road existed came in 1957 (or '55?). It was reported by our ambassador in China. And it took us 2years before we could send a patrol to verify it. And that is what the Chinese threw back at us. We forgot the dictum, "Possession is nine points of the law".
@HoiNam Superior Southern Chinese you fuckin Communist ass hole... People of Arunachal Pradesh are largely Hindus and others also are linked to Indian Culture and speak Hindi language and no one there would like to merge with you Communist Red Dogs
@@adv.anandpande3547 Too sad the beautiful Sikkim ，Ladakh and Northeastern state people has to be with a filthy and poor country like India where is full of rapists and poverty!! It would have become another rich place like Singapore or Switzerland if it was an independent Kingdom. They are clearly a different race with the dark skin Indians. Sikkim，Ladakh and Northeastern state people deserve a better future for themselves. Free Sikkim,Northeastern state, Ladakh the blessing from the China Sino-Tibetan brothers! 2
@@adv.anandpande3547 Please start your stupidity, Sikkim, Ladakh and Bhutan, and Northeastern Tibet. From the race, the culture is East Asian, not South Asian black.
Very interesting. I was exploring Google Earth and this area piqued my interest because it has no labels on the map, no points of interest, barely any names on the map for mountains, rivers, lakes, etc. If you select a location within Aksai Chin, the map does not show any information other than Lat/Long and does not show any country name, neither India nor China. Very weird, I would love to visit one day.
Because Tibet is a strategic state, so strength, speed and intelligence will be the deciding factor in determining who will control Tibet. Historical data on ownership, morals and legality will play no part on who will own Tibet. After the China Civil War (1945-1949) ended in 1949, Mao Zedong wasted little time, and took over Tibet in 1950, before India realize what has happened. India had window of opportunity from 1945 to 1949 when China was engaged in a civil war. It coud have invade and taken Tibet with ease. But India is dim-witted and slow, and did nothing. Nowadays India keep on complaining and whining about China's control of Tibet. Too bad, they are too slow, dim-witted and lack strategic foresight. Well, at least India have control of Sikkim, Northeastern states and Arunachal Pradesh(South Tibet) even though it has no strategic value, it's better than nothing.
@आर्य रौद्र , Tibet is the source of the major rivers of Asia. In India's case, that includes the Indus and Brahmaputra. For China, it's the Yangtze and Yellow. For South East Asia, it's the Mekong. All those rivers support the livelihood of millions of people. The one who control Tibet, controls the source of those rivers. That's why China will never ever give up control of Tibet. At the same time China don't really care about Arunachal Pradesh, Sikkim and Northeastern states. They have no strategic values. In 2003, India recognize Tibet as an integral part of China in exchange for China recognized Sikkim as an integral part of India. China does have historical precedent in claiming Tibet, and India doesn't for Sikkim. But it doesn't matter, China only care about Tibet, and not Sikkim. As for the original natives of Tibet and Sikkim, hopefully their overlords would treat them humanely.
@आर्य रौद्र , the Indian government already made up it's mind and stated Tibet is an integral part of China in 2003. If you disagree you can be a rogue and take up the issue with your own government. Furthermore the Dalai Lama had reversed his position and will not seek independence for Tibet. He even asked China to provide more development for Tibet, which China has been doing all along irregardless.. All the talking, discussion and useless blabbering of freeing Tibet is over.
@Shiva Badruswamy , If India unrecognized Tibet, then China can unrecognized Sikkim and Arunachal Pradesh. Besides the Dalai Lama has reversed his position on Tibet independence and wishes Tibet remain a part of China. And now some Indians want to kick him out of India.
that means china has also violated UN resolution on J&K because UN resolution is applicable for J&K as a whole. Pakistan has violated the resolution by giving away a large chunk of land to china in part of J&K which they call northern areas.
They must evacuate this place....jai Hind .... they r hoarding our legal possessions..... out out out..... from our motherland if trying to intrude..... straight n simple ! Very nice video
After the WWII India regained its land from British Raj but it mistakenly thought it also inherited the territory boundary ( which includes Tibet) desired by the British realm. Arunachal Pradesh and Aksai Chin borders were areas drawn by the the British. What is the English name of McMahon line doing in that area? The British had been skillful in laying time bombs in these areas and in Hong Kong. Now we witness the explosion.
And confirmed in writing by Grandson Papu Rahul and his mother Antonio Maino Sonia in the Party to Party MOU signed by Papu and his mother Antinoio Maino Sonia.
It was Nehru who gave directions to include Aksai Chin in Kashmir while drawing maps. India was never in possession of Aksai Chin. According to Macarteny- McDonald line , Chinese Chinese got the suzerainty.
@Hulk India was not in possession of Aksai Chin. Anyway, who decides the legality? What we have today is the legacy left behind our colonial dads, the British. It is only speculations that if we had done this or that, China would have been defeated. What provoked the Chinese was the fact that Nehru asked the cartographers to include Aksai Chin in India. After the defeat of the Sikhs in 1846, Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh came in the possession of British who then installed Gulab Singh as Maharaja under British suzerainty. The British fixed the southern end of the boundary at Pangong Lake, BUT REGARDED AREA NORTH OF IT (Aksai Chin) AS TERRA INCOGNITA, , that is unknown territory. Pangong Lake lies at the southern end of Aksai Chin. William Johnson, a civil servant with the Survey of India proposed the "Johnson Line" in 1865, which put Aksai Chin in Kashmir. This line was never presented to the Chinese. In 1878 the Chinese had re-conquered Xinjiang. By 1892, China had erected boundary markers at Karakoram Pass. In 1899, Britain proposed a revised boundary suggested by McCartney. THIS BOUNDARY PLACED THE LINGZI TANG PLAINS, WHICH ARE SOUTH OF THE LAKTSANG RANGE, IN INDIA, AND AKSAI CHIN PROPER, WHICH IS NORTH OF THE LAKTSANG RANGE, IN CHINA. This border, along the Karakoram Mountains, was proposed and supported by British officials for a number of reasons. The Karakoram Mountains formed a natural boundary, which would set the British borders up to the Indus River watershed while leaving the Tarim River watershed in Chinese control, and Chinese control of this tract would present a further obstacle to Russian advance in Central Asia. The British presented this line, known as the Macartney-MacDonald Line, to the Chinese in 1899 in a note by Sir Claude MacDonald. The Qing government did not respond to the note. According to some commentators, China believed that this had been the accepted boundary. THESE BOUNDARY LINES REMAINED UN-DEMARCATED AT INDIA'S INDEPENDENCE. Upon independence in 1947, the government of India used the Johnson Line as the basis for its official boundary in the west, which included the Aksai Chin. Up to this point, the boundary in the Aksai Chin sector, based on the Johnson Line, had been described as "un-demarcated." The Indian position, as stated by Prime Minister Nehru, was that the Aksai Chin was "part of the Ladakh region of India for centuries" and that this northern border was a "firm and definite one which was not open to discussion with anybody.” The Chinese minister Zhou Enlai argued that the western border had never been delimited, that the Macartney-MacDonald Line, which left the Aksai Chin within Chinese borders was the only line ever proposed to a Chinese government, and that the Aksai Chin was already under Chinese jurisdiction, and that negotiations should take into account the status quo. In situation like this, it is always the might is right.
If the problem of Jammu and Kashmir isn't solved for next few years it will definitely lead us to 3rd world war .milltary budget of India ,China and Pakistan are up in trillions now . Instead of spending the huge chuk of money on such projects all the 3 countries should come forward and try to solve this problem once for all. Spend this money on upliftment of people, education, health and research sector.
Thank you sir please share this so everyone will k ow past history how congress till today we’re not doing anything in the indi china boader till Modiji came to power
This is all happened after illegally occupied of TIBET ,before 1959 there is no issue on border security, now problem is facing on border. I think the only solution is to support Tibet independent than eventually border tension will resolve .. Jai Tibet Jai Bharat 👍
Even if a blade not grow there it's of strategic importance. China can never be our friend. George Fernandez rightly said CHINA IS OUR MAIN ENEMY. India is the only competition for China. China recognized this in the early 1950s. If India wants to be a force to reckon with, we should have a thriving and vibrant defence industry. Its of strategic importance and geo political influencer.
My dear friend ur vedio is very nice but while explaining you made an allegation of 1962 which has to be studied in detail which would have made ur vedio more accurate and dear friend Before talking 1962 situation make a vedio of social and economic life of india in 1962. I hope you are a highly knowledgeable person but don't be prejudiced. Sorry if it annoys you.
This video made 3yrs ago is highly relevant in current situation. Wonderfully detailed & explained. Ofcourse now China apparently has built more bases & posts. One thing is it hurts to know how they sneakily took away our land while a pacifism was romantic. Our troops should have preemptively captured all these posts even befoee they tried. One day that will be done. PS: China don't bother scaring us. Nobody is afraid of you. You've almost lost Taiwan. USA is arming it to the teeth.
@henry white no i mean india will be occupied by china And india will become slave nation of china for ever Because they dont know how to run the country
@Paralle. Colonials were treacherous terrorists, Colonialism remains the biggest act of terrorism worldwide. Strangely, India has been at the receiving end of all but Genghiz, they had smashed the Huns a long time ago though. India now need a swift neutralizing of Chinese occupying their territory, take all vantage positions in Tibet and some of Xinjiag, cut off CPEC. If China tries something, screw them in the Indian Ocean, sabotage Gwadar too. India needs to really get into Tibet and Xinjiang now.
Deepak Gupta we never thought India as enemy, but India thought all British India belongs to India now. Be a nice neighbor, u already failed in 1962🤣 don’t why u guys have such confidence, Mumbai is the 1st city, WOW🤣 please face the truth.
@HoiNam Superior Southern Chinese Arunachal Pradesh is part of india.. You don't even know the spelling of Kashmir 😂😂.. Also Free Hong Kong🇭🇰, Free Macau🇲🇴, Free Tibet
![China's New Armored Brigades [Explained]](/img/1.gif)
Incredible job you have done sir. This much of clarity and substantial information even our so called professional tv channels have not provided. Thanks again for good work 👍. I am watching your all videos. All are marvellous.
Thanks I was looking for some material on Aksai Chin. OUTSTANDING
You have created most informative and wonderful videos.It is really a great job. Our salutes to you Sir ..!
It is really a great good job, I thank you and statutes to you Ji, please give me some information about SIKKIM. It’s people Indus Ji?
Thank you gentleman, you made me know about whole kashmir .
Excellent explanations. Thank You...
Look at the railway line China has built upto its borders.
With the present pace, India cannot come close even after 50 years. We need to expedite Rishikesh-Karnaprayag line, bhanupali-bilaspur-manali-Leh line and extend them till our borders on war footing basis.
Indian Government should accelerate in war footing mode all necessary infrastructure including all weather roads to match or even superior to that of China so that India can monitor Chinese activities 24/7 and take offensive measures even with the slighest indication of mischief by the Chinese . This whole thing is scary and totally unacceptable to Indias interests. No wonder that Chinese are jittery and protesting the construction of border roads and the construction of the road leading to Lipulekh which allows the Indian army quick access to the very door steps of China and Chinese controlled areas.
Thanks for the reconnaissance - I found it very entertaining. Indians are very good at doing serious things in funny ways and taking funny things seriously, both often ending up with hilarious results ;-)
Excellent video covering the detail relief of easternmost border of ladakh. Love to see about karakorum highway and pass
The road trough Aksai Chin (China National Highways 219) goes from Sichuan to Xinjiang! From Aksai Chin its only few hundred road kilometers to Kargilik, which has an railway connection (Kashgar-Hotan-Railway).
China built road , meanwhile INDIANS are busy in fighting each other 😂
Not each other the f congress nehru who were all Muslims Nd Indra now a ltalian lady who were too busy looting Nd supporting China Nd Pakistan 🇵🇰
Only now a true indian has taken over if we had started atkeast 40 years ago there would be no Pakistan
you have provided information here which is otherwise impossible for the layman to gather. you have really good knowledge about this area. cheers
Well researched, informative. Pls bring more strategic info and policy advise about Pak and Chinese held Indian territories.
Truly hope that both countries can reduce military conflicts in the boarder, sit down, and do business together. Fighter over land is a zero sum game, while cooperating and competing in economy can be win-win game. Worry less about how to divide the cake, but more on how to make the cake larger together.
We'll capture one of your state and then well sit and talk okk my frnd
@आर्य रौद्र So u mean Indian army in Kashmir is playing cards or ludo with Kashmiri civilians ? World know pallet guns or bullet guns ?
No we will attack china one day and occupy whole china
Because we like china
Its just a ready modern country for indians to enjoy
@@RajeshKumar-gd5gl , Are you one of those illegal Indian immigrants trying to infiltrate Hong Kong seeking a job and better life?
@@asadkhan-zz4ph If pakistan stop funding them to do the stone pelting, the army will not fire pellet guns.. we also want peace bro.
India is a superpower of the world, India is No.1
Feng wan 大忽悠
yes. number one in pooping on streets.
@paul Wesley no. on the streets of Randia.
@@nomiak6150Chinese number one in eating bat sh*t and spreading viruses
This is impressive. Thanks for the research
3 saal pahlay ki gai ap ki batain sach sabat huien,you are great sir
Now each and every movement of both armies are under watch of respective countries and as such it is not possible for any side to start sudden action on large scale. However Indian main land is much close and smooth which will get a sure advantage over the adversary.
A comprihensive v good video presented by inteligent prodeucer
thank you sir....
Sir can you please make a second video covering , G-219,G-314 , kunjerab pass and karakoram highway w.r.t Siachin Glacier.
Ultimate efforts to making this video 👌👌👌
thanks cybersurg for sharing this...
I respect your quality analysis work on the security issues . it's always amezing to see the depth of your analyital work . thanks for creating and sharing with us .
India should let China keep Aksai Chin and sign a peace agreement or something. It'll be good for us to have Chinese support.
Bc zakaat ya bheekh batt rahi hai kya jo yuhi rakhne de?
@@xyglrox5869 You are an idiot! If we gave them uninhabitable aksai chin as a token of peace then they will support India in obtaining PoK. Good Day!
too late. status quo benefits china's long-term interest.
@@AbhilashBharadwaj China will support Pakistan if India attacks PoK. I'm chinese.
@@nomiak6150 Just because you're Chinese doesn't mean you can predict what your government will do
What if during a war the main highway connecting Tibet and aksai chin was bombed by India at several places?
Is that highway close to the border a disadvantage for the Chinese?
Great vdo!!
Great Work Sir,
Will be very happy if get latest positions of Chinese military bases at Aksai Chin.
thanks for the information.contention costs.both loose. peace is gain. so maintain it.
Thank u for the video
Very informative sir ..
Nice video
Aksaichin is a Turkic language meaning Baishitan in China.
China is a Hindi word meaning small
Very well explained very good
Good information thanq sir
Nice video bro
Make more videos on pengong lake militrization
Very good information provided
Great info with video....
Can you make a video on the current changes in position of china on ground?
what a beautiful explanation!
Wonderful information sir...
This is NOT Google Map. Which map do you use for ?
Great picturisation.
the chinese were building roads, air port, tunnels, rails all over tibet up to india since 1950..
But all this while the indians were debating whether to build or not border roads.. And when it was decided to build, the chinese protest
China built road for help local economy and tourist industry
@@Ggyygc Why you build roads in our land.
@@dcp15121980 Aksai chin has never belonged to India，except in Indian dreams or map.
Neither your Brritish papa nor India has control Aksai chin in the history.
Wake up,don't live in your dreams,it's not funny,just like a clown!
@@user-bk5zb6sn9w so arunachal sikkim is also urs? Cos there also you tried to make roads. You have boder problems with Taiwan, Butan, Japan, Vietnam, india, honkong. Here all china claim it's China's land. Guess china lives in dreams
@@dcp15121980 ALL land border problems between China and other countries have been settled，except India.
Why is India so special？
BTW，Taiwan is not a country，It's a region，and Taiwan is a part of china. this is a fact recongnized by the United Nations and most countries in the world including India.
You build your coust and returns until no more friendship
Thanks.
That is sad News for all concerned.
Yes. We need to take back aksai chin region also..
Nehru did not pay much if not any attention to Indias interests because he was romancing most of the time.
I suppose you were shooting the scenes. So what is Modi doing now?
Nehru was busy fornicating & earn underhand money.
@@khokan1951 And you were the eunuch who held the torch while Nehru was fornicating to know about these matters. Nehru was potent man unlike the other PMs who were/are bachelors or sent their wives away because of lack of potency.
How endian media and govt making fools by showing wrong map to Indians in reality Kashmir territory divided in 3 countries.
china govt also fools chinese by showing arunachal pradesh with china
but it is with us and they can't do shit about it..........they also proposed they want to exchange tawang for whole aksai chin
india would have gained territory but we rejected as tawang is 2 biggest buddhist city .
they want monopoly on buddhism really ........buddha was born in lumbini nepal
hello Chinese government cell member
@HoiNam Superior Southern Chinese free Taiwan free Hong Kong free tiibat
@@soumendrajena9108 keep crying while we keep getting stronger.
@@neverfallinlove.5801 indian tears are very tasty. dont worry we already freed aksai chin and u cowards couldnt do anything about it.
Very apt and precise presention
An update on the video is now needed
Sir ,highly admire your work.can you please make a video and elaborate on the chinese presence in Trans-Karakoram Tract. Especially the Shaksgam valley.How strongly do they hold it.Where are the supply lines.I only c a dirt road starting from the highway(G219) running along the Yarkant river and then Kel qinghe, leading to a end point that is exactly on the supposed border.After that in the indian side (rest of the valley) i can not see any roads or military infrastructure in or anywhere near the Shaksgam Valley.Why is it a no Mans land .Why is it not controlled by india when its our territory.Thx, Dhruv.
In 1962, India pursued a progressive policy that constantly encroached on Tibet and China was forced to fight back. In fact, China had always wanted to negotiate with India to maintain peace and friendship. But Nehru refused to say that all of them were Indian territory. Then war broke out. We don't want war. We built the Great Wall more than two thousand years ago. We hope that we can solve the border problem peacefully in the future. China will not fight for Pakistan. But in Pakistan there is China's oil lifeline.
References ??? BTW, wasn't it China, not India, that forcibly annexed Tibet by brute force????
Gaurang Karmakar Qing dynasty OK you can Wikipedia OK
@@samlin3884 So, was India or Nehru involved in "encroaching'" on Tibet in the Qing era, as you allege?? You were talking about the 1960s AD and not of the Qing era 1765 AD, right?? In the 1950s, Tibet was NOT a part of China, since the Qing era had long ceased to be. China had annexed it forcibly; had Tibet been part of China, China would not have to send troops to occupy Tibet.
Tibetans, meanwhile, had gained autonomy later on with the creation of successive Tibetan kingdoms independent of Chinese rule.
Kingdom of Tibet (1912-51) OK you can Wikipedia OK. Tibet not part of PRC at that point of time OK you can Wikipedia OK. It was a de facto independent (even though unrecognized) state and even de jure it was part of the Republic of China (Kuomintang) that now exists in Taiwan (which the Chinese do not recognize) and NOT the PRC run by the Communist Chinese OK you can Wikipedia OK.
So, who did interfere in Tibet; India or Communist China???
Tibet was administered in the Qing Dynasty, and the Dalai Lama was established by the Chinese Emperor. After 1912, the central government of the Republic of China sent commissioners to supervise the selection of the Dalai Lama and the Panchen Lama, and then held ceremonies. At that time, there was the Mongolian Tibet Committee of the Republic of China. In 1945, the Kuomintang retreated to Taiwan and there was still the whole China in law, but the Chinese people did not. Do you understand that the Republic of China inherited everything from the Republic of China? Tibet was managed by the Government of the Republic of China from 1912 to 1945, while the People's Republic of China inherited the Government of the Republic of China. The whole world recognizes that Taiwan is part of China, including your country OK!
@@samlin3884 My question is simple: Who invaded Tibet or encroached on Tibet, India or China in the 1950s?????
Our political leaders were sleeping since 1947...
indian leaders had been busy protecting cows and building Temple.
@@nasimhossain7683pakistan leaders has been busy building madrasas and mosque even now that y they lost east pakistan 🤣🤣🤣
Please cover Galwan Valley
Good amount of information.Keep researching .Expacting more videos.
Need Similar video on PoK please
it's not PoK. It's called "Azad Kashmir". Because it is Azad.
watching in actual stand off
Good work
But very nicely showed. I like it
My research suggests, not more than 5000 troops of China are in the region at any given point of time. There are no facilities to host more than that. Also in the entire aksai chin area does not even have a civilian population of 2500. Mostly Buddhist Tibetans, ready to cross over to India where they are free to practice their religion and way of life!
The 5,000 troops serve as a tripwire. If India just sent 1 soldier across Tibetan border, China will mobilize and send 500,000 troops into Tibet to defend it. Tibet is one of the most important strategic region of China.
Interesting, how the hell do you know all these?
Now that most of the papers pertaining to the period have been declassified, could you provide a reference which supports this date of 1951?
Some books have been published which have reference to this road. What I have read is that the first suspicion that the road existed came in 1957 (or '55?). It was reported by our ambassador in China. And it took us 2years before we could send a patrol to verify it. And that is what the Chinese threw back at us.
We forgot the dictum, "Possession is nine points of the law".
It's said that only the west 1/3 part of the lake is salt, no?
Free Tibet and Hong Kong
@HoiNam Superior Southern Chinese you fuckin Communist ass hole... People of Arunachal Pradesh are largely Hindus and others also are linked to Indian Culture and speak Hindi language and no one there would like to merge with you Communist Red Dogs
@@adv.anandpande3547
Too sad the beautiful Sikkim ，Ladakh and Northeastern state people has to be with a filthy and poor country like India where is full of rapists and poverty!! It would have become another rich place like Singapore or Switzerland if it was an independent Kingdom. They are clearly a different race with the dark skin Indians. Sikkim，Ladakh and Northeastern state people deserve a better future for themselves. Free Sikkim,Northeastern state, Ladakh the blessing from the China Sino-Tibetan brothers!
2
@@ChineseHOME1 yes... Start the charity from home... Please free Tibet so that it becomes another Singapore of South Asia
@@adv.anandpande3547 Please start your stupidity, Sikkim, Ladakh and Bhutan, and Northeastern Tibet. From the race, the culture is East Asian, not South Asian black.
@@adv.anandpande3547 dont blame Communists, I,m a Communist and hate China... Chinease are fake coommunists
Very interesting. I was exploring Google Earth and this area piqued my interest because it has no labels on the map, no points of interest, barely any names on the map for mountains, rivers, lakes, etc. If you select a location within Aksai Chin, the map does not show any information other than Lat/Long and does not show any country name, neither India nor China. Very weird, I would love to visit one day.
China can move the Type-15 tanks and SH-15 155mm howitzer with magnetic plasma coating and one million troops rapidly using the Tibetan railway
Because Tibet is a strategic state, so strength, speed and intelligence will be the deciding factor in determining who will control Tibet. Historical data on ownership, morals and legality will play no part on who will own Tibet.
After the China Civil War (1945-1949) ended in 1949, Mao Zedong wasted little time, and took over Tibet in 1950, before India realize what has happened. India had window of opportunity from 1945 to 1949 when China was engaged in a civil war. It coud have invade and taken Tibet with ease. But India is dim-witted and slow, and did nothing. Nowadays India keep on complaining and whining about China's control of Tibet. Too bad, they are too slow, dim-witted and lack strategic foresight. Well, at least India have control of Sikkim, Northeastern states and Arunachal Pradesh(South Tibet) even though it has no strategic value, it's better than nothing.
@आर्य रौद्र , Tibet is the source of the major rivers of Asia. In India's case, that includes the Indus and Brahmaputra. For China, it's the Yangtze and Yellow. For South East Asia, it's the Mekong. All those rivers support the livelihood of millions of people. The one who control Tibet, controls the source of those rivers. That's why China will never ever give up control of Tibet. At the same time China don't really care about Arunachal Pradesh, Sikkim and Northeastern states. They have no strategic values.
In 2003, India recognize Tibet as an integral part of China in exchange for China recognized Sikkim as an integral part of India. China does have historical precedent in claiming Tibet, and India doesn't for Sikkim. But it doesn't matter, China only care about Tibet, and not Sikkim. As for the original natives of Tibet and Sikkim, hopefully their overlords would treat them humanely.
@आर्य रौद्र , the Indian government already made up it's mind and stated Tibet is an integral part of China in 2003. If you disagree you can be a rogue and take up the issue with your own government. Furthermore the Dalai Lama had reversed his position and will not seek independence for Tibet. He even asked China to provide more development for Tibet, which China has been doing all along irregardless.. All the talking, discussion and useless blabbering of freeing Tibet is over.
@Shiva Badruswamy , the Indian government recognize Tibet as an integral part of China in 2003. Game over.
@Shiva Badruswamy , If India unrecognized Tibet, then China can unrecognized Sikkim and Arunachal Pradesh. Besides the Dalai Lama has reversed his position on Tibet independence and wishes Tibet remain a part of China. And now some Indians want to kick him out of India.
Peace to both India & China, the two most populous countries. Keep the peaceful border area for the local people!
that means china has also violated UN resolution on J&K because UN resolution is applicable for J&K as a whole. Pakistan has violated the resolution by giving away a large chunk of land to china in part of J&K which they call northern areas.
Bro.. Please use BHUVAN BY ISRO.. SUPPORT OWN..
They must evacuate this place....jai Hind .... they r hoarding our legal possessions..... out out out..... from our motherland if trying to intrude..... straight n simple ! Very nice video
After the WWII India regained its land from British Raj but it mistakenly thought it also inherited the territory boundary ( which includes Tibet) desired by the British realm. Arunachal Pradesh and Aksai Chin borders were areas drawn by the the British. What is the English name of McMahon line doing in that area? The British had been skillful in laying time bombs in these areas and in Hong Kong. Now we witness the explosion.
You only see what is above but not what's underground and in caves .
The Chinese have also started deep drilling for mineral and geological investigations where Chinese are sitting.
With Nehru's tacit blessings
And confirmed in writing by Grandson Papu Rahul and his mother Antonio Maino Sonia in the Party to Party MOU signed by Papu and his mother Antinoio Maino Sonia.
It was Nehru who gave directions to include Aksai Chin in Kashmir while drawing maps. India was never in possession of Aksai Chin. According to Macarteny- McDonald line , Chinese Chinese got the suzerainty.
@Hulk India was not in possession of Aksai Chin. Anyway, who decides the legality? What we have today is the legacy left behind our colonial dads, the British. It is only speculations that if we had done this or that, China would have been defeated. What provoked the Chinese was the fact that Nehru asked the cartographers to include Aksai Chin in India.
After the defeat of the Sikhs in 1846, Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh came in the possession of British who then installed Gulab Singh as Maharaja under British suzerainty. The British fixed the southern end of the boundary at Pangong Lake, BUT REGARDED AREA NORTH OF IT (Aksai Chin) AS TERRA INCOGNITA, , that is unknown territory. Pangong Lake lies at the southern end of Aksai Chin. William Johnson, a civil servant with the Survey of India proposed the "Johnson Line" in 1865, which put Aksai Chin in Kashmir. This line was never presented to the Chinese. In 1878 the Chinese had re-conquered Xinjiang. By 1892, China had erected boundary markers at Karakoram Pass.
In 1899, Britain proposed a revised boundary suggested by McCartney. THIS BOUNDARY PLACED THE LINGZI TANG PLAINS, WHICH ARE SOUTH OF THE LAKTSANG RANGE, IN INDIA, AND AKSAI CHIN PROPER, WHICH IS NORTH OF THE LAKTSANG RANGE, IN CHINA.
This border, along the Karakoram Mountains, was proposed and supported by British officials for a number of reasons. The Karakoram Mountains formed a natural boundary, which would set the British borders up to the Indus River watershed while leaving the Tarim River watershed in Chinese control, and Chinese control of this tract would present a further obstacle to Russian advance in Central Asia. The British presented this line, known as the Macartney-MacDonald Line, to the Chinese in 1899 in a note by Sir Claude MacDonald. The Qing government did not respond to the note. According to some commentators, China believed that this had been the accepted boundary.
THESE BOUNDARY LINES REMAINED UN-DEMARCATED AT INDIA'S INDEPENDENCE.
Upon independence in 1947, the government of India used the Johnson Line as the basis for its official boundary in the west, which included the Aksai Chin. Up to this point, the boundary in the Aksai Chin sector, based on the Johnson Line, had been described as "un-demarcated."
The Indian position, as stated by Prime Minister Nehru, was that the Aksai Chin was "part of the Ladakh region of India for centuries" and that this northern border was a "firm and definite one which was not open to discussion with anybody.”
The Chinese minister Zhou Enlai argued that the western border had never been delimited, that the Macartney-MacDonald Line, which left the Aksai Chin within Chinese borders was the only line ever proposed to a Chinese government, and that the Aksai Chin was already under Chinese jurisdiction, and that negotiations should take into account the status quo.
In situation like this, it is always the might is right.
@Hulk Views are always views. Everybody knows how to save the ship after it has sunk.
@Hulk Okay, go ahead recognize Tibet. ICJ is packed with European judges and are biased against non-Europeans.
Just try 1 pls
If the problem of Jammu and Kashmir isn't solved for next few years it will definitely lead us to 3rd world war .milltary budget of India ,China and Pakistan are up in trillions now . Instead of spending the huge chuk of money on such projects all the 3 countries should come forward and try to solve this problem once for all. Spend this money on upliftment of people, education, health and research sector.
really sad that China is having so strong presence in pangong area Indian army should do something about China Dadagiri ,
Thank you sir please share this so everyone will k ow past history how congress till today we’re not doing anything in the indi china boader till Modiji came to power
Video consists of much knowledge
india must tak back all of aksai chin
All 3 country land dispute is due to British's landmine on those land.
That all land belongs to us even though it's barren. 😠😠😠
This is all happened after illegally occupied of TIBET ,before 1959 there is no issue on border security, now problem is facing on border. I think the only solution is to support Tibet independent than eventually border tension will resolve .. Jai Tibet Jai Bharat 👍
Akai come Near India. Good well time India.
Even if a blade not grow there it's of strategic importance. China can never be our friend. George Fernandez rightly said CHINA IS OUR MAIN ENEMY. India is the only competition for China. China recognized this in the early 1950s. If India wants to be a force to reckon with, we should have a thriving and vibrant defence industry. Its of strategic importance and geo political influencer.
Please make video presentation comparing china and india border military preparation for public comment.
WE SHOULD INVEST HEAVILY ON DAULAT BEG OLDI FOR TRADE IN CENTRAL ASIA IF WE WANT TO BE SUPER POWER UP TO 2047
My dear friend ur vedio is very nice but while explaining you made an allegation of 1962 which has to be studied in detail which would have made ur vedio more accurate and dear friend Before talking 1962 situation make a vedio of social and economic life of india in 1962. I hope you are a highly knowledgeable person but don't be prejudiced. Sorry if it annoys you.
This video made 3yrs ago is highly relevant in current situation.
Wonderfully detailed & explained.
Ofcourse now China apparently has built more bases & posts.
One thing is it hurts to know how they sneakily took away our land while a pacifism was romantic.
Our troops should have preemptively captured all these posts even befoee they tried.
One day that will be done.
PS: China don't bother scaring us. Nobody is afraid of you.
You've almost lost Taiwan. USA is arming it to the teeth.
I get triggered when i see actual map of kashmir
@Paralle dude stop your bullshit. Aksai Chin was,will and forever be part of India. Amen.
@Kiran Koti China soon will take whole India
That will be very good then in India we will use our own products called indochinese products
@henry white no i mean india will be occupied by china
And india will become slave nation of china for ever
Because they dont know how to run the country
@Paralle. Colonials were treacherous terrorists, Colonialism remains the biggest act of terrorism worldwide. Strangely, India has been at the receiving end of all but Genghiz, they had smashed the Huns a long time ago though. India now need a swift neutralizing of Chinese occupying their territory, take all vantage positions in Tibet and some of Xinjiag, cut off CPEC. If China tries something, screw them in the Indian Ocean, sabotage Gwadar too. India needs to really get into Tibet and Xinjiang now.
@@gulabsinghsingh7248 ha ha ha
thankyou so muh for your research
One thing is for sure,Modiji has put brakes on China's ambitions of becoming a super power.
Deepak Gupta ant thinks it can crash elephant🤣 in fact, we dont even care about such india
@@yintzhaha the ant may not be able to crush an elephant,but it just needs to enter it's ears to bring it down.
Deepak Gupta we never thought India as enemy, but India thought all British India belongs to India now. Be a nice neighbor, u already failed in 1962🤣 don’t why u guys have such confidence, Mumbai is the 1st city, WOW🤣 please face the truth.
Deepak... Modi helped to make China a super power faster than they thought. You just don't know that. Lol
@@yintzhaha1962 was back stabbing the thing Chinese are good at coward army why doesn't China try again now?
what about chines access from pak to India in case of war
Very good news
When an india cok possession and now suitable time
Askai Chin is the part of India.
Jai Hind Vande Matram🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@HoiNam Superior Southern Chinese Arunachal Pradesh is part of india.. You don't even know the spelling of Kashmir 😂😂.. Also Free Hong Kong🇭🇰, Free Macau🇲🇴, Free Tibet
make them play if they play around India
Result of sleeping Indian governments from 60s to today and even in future... Only big words but no action...
Please give Road and long bridges built by China, so that Indians can target them