The ball was touched TWICE in controversial call! | AFL 360 | Fox Footy
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 апр 2024
- Gerard and Robbo break down the ending of the Carlton Fremantle clash including the controversial call, a new review system, and the dissent penalty.
Subscribe and 🔔 to Fox Footy RUclips 👉 bit.ly/39CUfB1
Stream Fox Footy 👉 kayosports.app.link/y5QWBPZac7
FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL
Facebook: / foxfooty
Twitter: / foxfooty
Instagram: / foxfooty 
Спорт
Adelaide Oval. The home of questionable umpiring decisions.
and it never happens to victorian teams
@@tangiers365 🤣😅😂
The umps come with nails & crosses
Where's dissent been for every other game, it's been missing until the last 20 secs , disgraceful
Is Robbo just there for comic value?
he seems to ramble without substance quite often
Robo is unhinged. Whately sanctimonious. 360 is not worth watching.
@@SkySurferG I like Gerard, ok, he does go on a bit but he's a good commentator
@@dylanbanks3656 He should e drug tested, and WTF is that thing under his bottom lip?
If so, he's doing well because that's why I watch haha. Nah I like his passion, and yes I think he's a bit too close to losing his head much of the time.
This is not dissent it is a complete overreach and a continuation of the umpires hijacking the game and the AFL promoting the whole thing what happened to a good game being when you don't notice the umpire they have now become an overreach and are out of control
We all come and watch for the Umps... or so they all think! 🙃
Got all the hallmarks of corruption
Will be interested to see Robo’s take on things when this happens to a VFL team. Somehow I don’t think “let’s just move on” will be his words then…
Yeah lol, I’m not one for screaming vicbias or calling conspiracy.
But 100% if this happened to Robbo’s darling Bombers he’d be up in arms demanding AFL accountability and a review system or captains call to be implemented.
He’s only be in uproar if it happened to Essendon.
VFL team?, thats the seconds mate. No one cares much about that anymore.
@@iankearns774 Pretty sure it was a crack at the vics ian.
@@iankearns774 he meant any team not in Melbourne, Any team in the AFL who isn't in Melbourne is called an interstate team, which is extremely weird for a national competion don't you think?
Absolute rubbish that umpires can influence the game by "gifting" a goal to a particular team. The dissent occurs during the pause in play and the ball was on its way back to the centre, did not infringe on Carlton at all so why should they benefit? Just send the bloke a fine during the week for abusing the ump and ball it up.
The other I'd like to see gone is the umps choosing when a team gets paid advantage after a free kick. What a joke that they can pay "no advantage" to a team and call the ball back or on the flip side, pay it when it's not there...
Yeah should be a fine. Or it should just be a free to the ruckman in the center.
What are you talking about, umpires influence games every week by gifting goals. We should know, 5 Richmond goals out of their first 7 against us were gifts, & kept them in the game.
Get back to us when you finally learn something about footy, princess. Umpires have been f**king decisions up for over 100 years. Get used to it.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
But 6 of freos 9 goals came from free kicks,...that is the game😳 Also, a freo player kicked the ball out on the full in Carlton forward 50 and should of been a kick at goal, but that one was missed🙄 Carlton also had 23 scoring shots to freos 19😜
When Adelaide missed out on finals last season Gerard was taking aim at the AFL, labelling it an insult, and said they needed to sort it out. He even invoked the NHL system of reviewing everything in the last 2 minutes to make sure that "what truly happened would have been there."
score review different to introducing an on field review. and they did improve the goalline camera
One was a genuine mistake from the umpires, the other was an umpire being completely wrong and not using the technology that should've always been used in that scenario
Slobbo needs to be at his AA meeting get him off the air it’s embarrassing.
It's also been revealed in audio that the umpire didn't hear anything. He says to Alex Pierce, I didn't hear anything so umpire Whetton made it up..... So he admitted on the field that he didn't hear anything. He didn't hear what was said he's paid the Centre kick because he's heard a swear word but the swear word he didn't know it was directed at him. He didn't even hear what was said so you've never got umpires just making stuff up.... It is the worst decision in the history of the game that I've seen. The ball was touched twice, actually three times you got four umpires out there that could not see that and then you've got an empire making up a dissent call that he didn't hear. why do I come to the conclusion that this game was rigged? Why do I suddenly come to that conclusion?
Possible you say ,how about 100% rigged bro.😊
If it was rigged, why wasn't the deliberate oob on the full paid to Carlton in its forward line? Why wasn't Curnow paid a free kick in marking contests as he was scragged on most occasions. Why did Freo get 6 goals from free kicks, most dead in front? If the ball was called touched then Cottrell could have handballed to another Carlton player running towards the goal. It was undisciplined play from Freo, the ruckman instead of dropping the ball to his feet and forcing another ball up, hits it to Hewitt. Then, when there was still 40 seconds on the clock, swearing at the umpire, gives up a free dead in front. Poor play, Fremantle only have themselves to blame.
@@blueycarlton De Koning was the designated ruck, but Cripps went up instead, probably just got confused
@@gwilkes5325That was the reason they did it and look it worked as they got a shot on goal and won the game😜
@@azzajames7661 Pretty sure that’s a free kick tho right?
Your a clown Robbo, it would not have happened if they played touch ball
who saw it touched the slow slomo camera
@@aussieintexas61 touched twice teams don't normally continue to tackle someone if they've caught the ball knowing it was touched
how the maggots can make themselves the centre of attention is beyond me, why he AFL say the umpires missed the touch ball but the dissent was correct, ever consider if they got the 1st call right, the dissent would not have come into play? maybe 5 umpires are required now. Great composure Longmuire, you have much more tolerance than many other coaches.
It’s putrid hey.
There were howlers all night, the Umps had a bad game. At least 5 Freo goals came from dodgy free kicks that could have been called play on. At the end of the day the side trying to win won and the side trying to maintain their meager lead playing safe lost. It is what it is.
5 umpires might be a shout, but also, I think they need to stop being scared to say something, apparently one of the umpires saw it was touched but they didn’t say anything to overrule it.
@@iankearns774Umps have been terrible for every match I've seen this year.
@@gwilkes5325so wait an umpire saw it was touched and the other one paid dissent despite not hearing what the player said. That's absolutely insane it has to be corruption.
And according to Gerard the game is at its best that is ever been! PLEASE!!! Stop insulting people's intelligence. If you want to talk about bums on seats we can agree but everything else it's a bloody joke.
Games in the dump. I’ve genuinely lost so much interest in the game.
I used to watch every match I can only handle 1-2 games a week now.
Freo a bit stiff. I wonder how the Victorian commentators would have adjudicated the umps performance if it had gone the other way and gifted Freo the win?
Most Victorians would have been happy to see Carlton lose. Get over your victim complex.
@@seedy80it's the media bias trying to throw it under the carpet.
But 6 of freos 9 goals came from free kicks,...that is the game😳 Also, a freo player kicked the ball out on the full in Carlton forward 50 and should of been a kick at goal, but that one was missed🙄 Carlton also had 23 scoring shots to freos 19😜
Carlton were pushing forward and overwhelming freo and so freo panicked and it cost them the game. Carlton did the same thing two years ago and now they are not panicking, but are holding their nerve and winning these games. Freo will learn and next time won't make the same mistakes again😜
@@azzajames7661 umpires won them the game still. Carlton scored 70 points directly from umpires vs north Melbourne it's not a valid argument.
Freo just have use this as incentive and go harder.
hats off to the editor putting in the ending of Spiderman across the spider verse sound track in this. 10/10
Fr, thought it might’ve been some random RUclips channel and had to triple check 😂
Robbo has lost it now. By blaming Jackson on this and saying “he shouldn’t have tapped it to the center of the defensive 50” is saying the equivalent of “Adelaide wouldn’t have had the scoring problem in round 22 last year if Ben Keays hadn’t kicked for goal.”
Absolute rubbish thing to say.
How can you blame this on the ruck he has borderline nothing to do with the situation robbo is just sitting there talking out his ass
There’s probably 50 other touched balls over the weekend that were called a mark too lmfao
well mate, this one costed the game, and a chance for the dockers to sit on top of the ladder.
@bencampbell07 If you were one of the umpires, what would you have done in the heat of the moment?
@@bencampbell07 All line-ball decisions can be said to cost a game. It's just that everyone focuses on the last 5 minutes. And that's a problem, especially during the finals, as umpires are too fearful to apply the rules. They won't go out on a limb, and make decisions as if they're half-blind.
@@phillipmarnik You wouldn't believe it, but I do in fact umpire, Claremont district junior football umpires association, in this situation I most likely would've payed the mark, but you never know, there could've been a ball up or maybe another umpire saw the deflection and stepped involve. It's a game were many mistakes take place.
@@phillipmarnik Don’t know, but if it’s a 50/50 touched or a mark, I’m calling the touch, a stoppage is always better than an incorrect call. Carlton could’ve been robbed, but so could’ve Freo, either way, a stoppage is neutral ground, a mark isn’t.
basically proves why either a captain's review, or a player review is needed, where umpires have gotten it wrong so badly, that has potentially altered the outcome of a game, for a professional league, it is nowhere near good enough, we have seen it with the Sydney/Adelaide game last year, the two Adelaide/Collingwood games last season where a players call would have provided the only correct call, a goal for Adelaide, a free to Collingwood in the first game, and the free kick to Adelaide in the second game at the MCG. and how many more have there been that were probably more egregious than those three examples.
the dissent penalty rule is complete nonsense, and should be abolished, as it really isn't worth the ink it was written with.
Problem is the umpires make half a dozen atrocious calls every match and you know the review room will find the worst camera angle and go by that or even 'accidentally' look at the wrong incident which they have done in the score reviews.
Conspiracy to favour Carlton.??!! Maybe.. Happened last year when inconclusive footage of a touched ball to beat melbourne..
That’s right mate dees didn’t kick 9.17, Freo didn’t dominate for 120 minutes and only score 63 points. Did you just jump on the hate train and watch two moments in either game? I’m sorry but both clubs had ample chance to put the game away. The blues had 7 frees to freos 14 at ones point 6 of freos resulting in direct goals - the frees were there but it’s not like the umps were intentionally rigging it against Freo. Dees hit the post 3 times in the semi which would have ended the game. You and all those other conspiracy people are the saddest and biggest soooks I’ve ever seen. Grown men crying because the team they hate is winning 😂 it’s embarrassing
Explain to me how both Freo and Melbourne choke in commanding positions with many chances to put a game away were robbed? If the blues dominated game and scored 63 I’d say we didn’t deserve to win. No accountability.
@@loufyyy And Carlton Kicked 14:14...Hats off to Adelaide.. As Always close games can come back to bite you.🤣
Rubbish that vision was available within a couple of minutes.
Yeh not sure where that bs came from
@@ScreenScoutReviews
Yeah clearly someone had it, so why the hell don't the AFL get access to it? If that's true then it's a little embarrassing for them that they don't even run the games.
So what, on field decisions or non decisions aren’t reviewed. Completely irrelevant when it’s available.
@@user-jk6ho7qu3h don't be a moron the issue isn't if it's relevant hero it's that they claim the vision was not available for three days when the TV coverage played it within 2 minutes. You need to unfog your brain.
Umpires having a shocking year, how many Out of bounds but called play on so far this year? The third game ruined.
by the umpires so far this season
Has been quite a few, the boundary umps are no longer sp[onsored by SpecSavers.
*Greg* - Quote -- _'Umpires having a shocking year'_ -- Give it a rest --
@@Pax.Alotin Greg is spot on
@@Jesse-py6hi Like I keep saying - What are you going to do about it ? Everyone is a critic. Everyone thinks they could do a better job. OK - put you hands up - but none of you will. Why ? Because you're all gutless snipes who haven't got the intelligence - let alone the back-bone to do the job. I don't agree with every umpire call - but I'll defend them for keeping you knuckleheads in place.
@@Pax.Alotin 100% they are, need to simplify the game as there are too many grey areas that leads to interpretation.
What the problem here is the umpires caught Jordan Clark’s touch of the ball, because the umpire also called play on while the other umpire called a mark. If umpires are in conflict for a decision, why don’t they just convene over that call, and if they can’t agree, ball it up!?
yes jackson screwed up with his hitout so you ask where freo can improve from their mistakes but where are the umps going to improve from this? are they working on a solution so the same issue doesnt happen again
from the comments im presuming the umpires sat down at 3 q time and concocted this win for the blues. at least they did it spectacularly.
You’re right mate Freo weren’t actually playing for the other 120 minutes they were just disguised umps! The boys in purple had zero bearing on the outcome of this game!
could you imagine if it were the other way round, completely different
Would love to see Robbo’s comments if it was the other way around. Bet you move on wouldn’t be his reaction 😂
Come on contest marks happen a lot. 40k fans screaming and look where the umpires were on the other side and was blocked seeing the ball touching the shoulder nor could he have heard the noise.
Do not turn our game into a technology game and review every captains call. Players and umpires are human and we have to factor in errors
Hell of a lot of human error i'd prefer a game with very minimal amount of mistakes that was the worst officated game i've ever watched, marks have been overturned before so why didn't they in this moment
Its clear the afl wants carlton to make the grandfinal this year. They continually get goals from contentious free kicks every week..
That intro was cinema
Can you imagine the decent rule being applied in the 80's or 90's
Why can´t they show the behind the goals view, to show that it´s not clear. (because it would have been clear, an angle from the ground on the other side showed the ball taking an unnatural curve).
Have a look at the umpire in the background he still jumping about even though the Mark has been taken he knew it was touched he didn't stop so when the kick has been marked, he doesn't stop he knows that it's been touched
Rigged.
Of course it is, they literally had an ex saints player umpiring st kilda game the other week. It’s corrupt as.
That’s why Freo lead the league in goals from frees! Thats why Freo only scored 3 goals that weren’t from direct free kicks! Another professional victim.
But 6 of freos 9 goals came from free kicks,...that is the game😳 Also, a freo player kicked the ball out on the full in Carlton forward 50 and should of been a kick at goal, but that one was missed🙄 Carlton also had 23 scoring shots to freos 19😜
If the Fremantle player had gotten just 5cm closer with his punch it probably would have had enough force to push it forward. It's a game of inches as they say.
Fox Footy, This is perfect! I subscribed right away!
Mistakes will always be there and tend to even up.
Might as well be an amateur competition, no pro sports league settles on ‘mistakes’
In cricket they can go upstairs for the howlers, ball tracking and all the other tech stuff fixes those issues up. Need something similar in AFL.
@@J_Rex25 Give it a rest.
0:13 ABSOLUTELY A CANNON EVENT 😱😱😱😱😱
Speaking as a Freo fan from Day 1 I was pissed off at the time,but over it by Saturday night. No point going on complaining about something that isn't going to change,ridiculous that people are still complaining on Monday. Sirengate was completely different,very easy to prove that the game had finished and common sense prevailed and we got the 4 points,this one was the umpire missing a touched ball. As for the dissent,I had thought that there hadn't really been many this year,but the rule is still there.
Everything in our game has improved markedly and continues to get better and better except for one aspect - the umpiring. Why on Earth we need four of the fools all trying to out do each other and trying to make a name for themselves defies logic. It's not all that long ago that we only had one and the umpiring was a damn sight better then. The current crop give new meaning to the word "incompetent." If they find it difficult to keep up with the play then let's have two working together in their pretty yellow outfits, but any more is ridiculous.
Good morning!!!! Gerard here😂😂😂😂😂😂
Whining about losing a game footy while kicking 9.9. I understand Fremantle supporters been annoyed but they also need to understand I am annoyed at other decisions during the game such as Fremantle out of bounds on the full in Carlton forward pocket and the free payed against Mitch McGovern as 2 examples. In such a low scoring contest where goals were hard to come by every decision has an impact.
Victorian teams always get the advantage.
Remember Freo vs. Roos last year, umpires also got that wrong
It can't be dissent if the ump didn't even hear clark.
Let,s move on ,,Robbo,s last words,,BS
conspiracy ? when did the afl , the umpires and other vic teams suddenly like carlton and want to see them succeed. hahaha
as a mad AFL fan that is disgraceful because he says the descent is still there well no it isn't because if the ump called it right there would be no descent plus the ball was touched 3 times by fyfe aish then clark
Umpires face the most abuse out of any one and everyone is wondering why they make mistakes.
Robbo ,,please stop with the bias,if carlton was robbed you,d have a different opinion
What would his opinion be?
He hates Carlton but nice try. You clearly haven’t watched a single clip of his talking about Carlton. Freo only scored 3 goals not from direct frees and they apparently ‘dominated’. 63 points their lowest score of the year 36 points coming from direct frees but they did everything they could to get blues up! Sook.
Wow 🙄
Not Vic -centric my ass.
Professional victim here watch out guys
So if calls go differently are these guys still talking about Blues being in the flag mix?
There's an element of autocracy with umpires enabled by the AFL and I understand the reason for respect and avoiding discouragement of umpiring. But there is a King Henry viii complex umpires have developed, where it matters little to understand human emotions and significance of the moment with umpires and more important to enforce, "you can't talk to me that way" authority.
If this was Collingwood v Carlton be play on. Feel sorry for freo here - AFL continues to favour teams based on their revenue. Worst run competition in the world, they choose finance over a fair competition
Yeah mate that’s why GWS and Melbourne are on top! Two massive revenue clubs there! Go watch another sport I stand for 99% of afl fans saying we don’t need professional sore loser victims like you. Either watch the sport and enjoy it or piss off because it’s a conspiracy. Carlton have one good start to a year in 30 years and it’s rigged. Embarrassing.
The problem here is the dissent rule, it's garbage and needs to be scrapped, Nothing else needs changing and I'm a freo fan.
Let the red mist settle - eventually you'll see how you're over-reacting.😉
@Pax.Alotin how am I over reacting? It's a stupid rule that should have never been introduced, it's the first time it's been used all season it's not necessary, if a player shows dissent towards an umpire and he dont like let the AFL suspend the player.
@@Humanityiscomedy How are you over reacting ? Every way.
yeah cos theres nothing we want to see more in junior and lower league games are umpires getting abused on a saturday because freos clark can abused them in them afl.....
@@Pax.Alotinso you couldn't give an example
Note to self for moving forward in the new era , never say you were touched by a rainbow in reach around round 😉
I’ve never understood why they use the shittest cameras that blur from frame to frame for the reviews and then in this video they have vision from the front on angle in clear slow motion blur free. The afl clearly has better cameras around the ground so why not start using them for the review arc
Carlton are gonna hate if freo get them finals time as they will use it and take it personally come finals time
Freo not making finals 🤣🤣
Bring it on, five of our best 22 didn't play . So bring it on.😂😂😂😂😂
@@terrysowter4798And we played a second gamer on Charlie Curnow what’s your point? If we had our key backs. Carlton don’t get anywhere near us.
Watch the whole game and it was Free Kick Freo, especially in vicinity of the goals. I agree that it was touched and dont agree with the dissent free being paid but look at the whole game as it was poorly umpired all day. Carlton could have been 3 goals ahead if not for dodgy frees to Freo. Then we wouldn't be worrying about this in the slightest.
Every Blues supporter loves to run with this narrative because they know damn well they shouldn’t have won that game. You don’t mention that 3-4 of them were obvious holding/dropping the ball calls. I agree there were some absolutely awful calls both ways but does that mean Freo deserved to have the game stripped away from them No! if the shoe was on the other foot you’d be spitting the dummy too. It’s quite ironic that so many of you bring up our free kicks but don’t realise the Blues lead the free kick differential ladder atm. Been gifted in majority of ya games this season and you always get on the other end of some controversy against the dockers. I hope that luck comes to an end in a final so you can see just how it feels.
@@lj3998 Give it a rest. Your bias is showing.
@@Pax.AlotinWhy because I mentioned the context of those calls which blues fans fail to add but still love to run with the 6 goals from freekick garbage. 🤦♂️🤣
@@lj3998 A tackle is not a bump mate, two shots at goal were for bumps where the ball spilled out. Should have been play on. McGovern did every thing right in that spoiling contest but again it was Free kick Freo. You had the rub of the green all day and couldn't put us away, we were 2 pts down and coming hard when Cottrell marked the ball and yeah it was touched but all the momentum was going our way.The fact you are blaming the ump is ludicrous when you won the free kick count 16-12.
@@lj3998Wait so us leading the free kick ladder is us being gifted games but you winning the count 12-16 and getting 6 direct goals from frees is just good officiating? Do you hear yourself speak? You just accepted you think free count is being gifted a game but Freo only scored 3 goals without umps 😂 I will be the first to accept most of the frees were there but you are claiming our free count has led to wins. It’s either Charlie and Harry get gifted frees and that’s why we win or the other team gets all the frees and they somehow still found a way for us to win. You scored 63 points against a badly out of form Carlton - your lowest score of the year. You were wasteful in the forward 50 all day and scored your majority off iffy ump calls. Take some accountability mate. Stop being a professional victim. The dissent call sucked but the touch was completely understandable and any true footy fan knows it. I’m starting to think Freo fans enjoy crying.
blues!!! 4-0 baby .. i could watch this ALL day over and over again
Robbo is too biased to be taken seriously.. if it doesn't affect him he's all about "moving on".. Let the same thing happen to his team, he'll be leading the charge in protest
why is it always the number 19 out of the umpires that is always involved in most terrible calls?
You just cannot have umpires deciding the outcome of the game.
Carlton were pushing forward and overwhelming freo and so freo panicked and it cost them the game. Carlton did the same thing two years ago and now they are not panicking, but are holding their nerve and winning these games. Freo will learn and next time won't make the same mistakes again😜
Best umpires that money can buy !!!
Says the slob sitting in his Barge-Arse chair --- 😅
Anyone noticed that they still call any team outside of Melbourne, interstate teams, which is weird in a national competition, aren't Melbourne teams interstate to the other teams too?
both freo and carlton were playing interstate teams, haha they reside in different states. what is the point of your words.....
@@aussieintexas61 That is my point, when was the last time you heard Carlton be called an Interstate team? Seriously, think before speak my friend.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@runnynose8341😢😢😢😢😢
As a West Australian I'm embarrassed by the reaction of 'our' media.
I'm glad I don't consume or pay for any of their stuff
I get the contreversy b it can we just move on already?
kobi freo robbed
Jordan Clarke also makes high contact with Cottrell's shoulder . Correct call
Freo got robbed big time.
@@dancowza6092 If McGoverns was chopping then that was over the shoulder. Good point made there.
This is giving me deja vu twice now freo have been screwed against carlton whens it going to change
And when you don’t get screwed by the umps Carlton do it for them, bogey team if there ever was such a thing
At the ground deaf freddy could hear the ball was touched. Disgraceful umpiring. The umpires should NEVER determine the outcome of any game. And I’m not a dockers supporter.
So what's your point? That's one player I noticed you haven't mentioned both Ryan and Pearce hanging of Curnow all game. In fact if Clarke had shut his mouth the shockers might have had a chance from the centre. So it's obviously a lack of discipline or the captain doesn't have control of his players. Take your pick, but either way we got the four points and a 4&0 record.
Typical Carlton fan
A lot of Carlton players would of known it was touched, but I guess it is not cricket where the batsman would of been called back for wrongful dismissal.
So you're a mind reader are you ? 🙄🤨😑😏
your funny
When was a batsman last recalled in a Test Match?
@@blueycarlton New Zealand veteran Daniel Vettori was given the ICC Spirit of Cricket award in 2012 for this gesture in a hard-fought tie against Zimbabwe. Vettori accidentally collided with non-striker Malcolm Waller during his follow-through that stopped Waller from taking a single but by that time the batsman at crease Regis Chakabva had come too far down the track to get back. Kiwi wicket keeper Reece Young, whipped the bails but Vettori immediately withdrew the dismissal, saying that it was his collision which had caused the confusion in the middle.
@@stevep2430 12 years ago against test minows how many tests played since? Would it happen against Australia, India or England, I doubt it. Vetorri is a nice bloke, but would he call back a batsmen who was incorrectly given out after he "nicked" it and the batting team had used up its referrals?
We are constantly reminded about how sport helps to develop good character yet players who were obviously aware the umpire made a mistake, chose not to inform him.They elected to cheat.
There should be a captains chalenge 1 per quarter or per match 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Well i seen this game and Carlton got robbed through the game freo got robbed at the end simple Carlton win.
Carlton won hahahahahahahahhahahahs
Captain obvious over here😂
Carrrrrrrnnnnnnnn
You just have to watch the Fremantle players reaction after the dissent call. The go straight to Clark to tell him shut up and don’t turn on the umpire like they did with the touched ball.
We need to do a full inquiry into the umpires. They are the worst they jave ever been so a full review into thier systems and training is necessary. They have zero accountability and every year its looking more corrupt.
Should of been 50m penalty with Cottrel kick. Freo players walked over the mark. Missed that one umps
Carlton left them in the game had 5 more scoring shouts and Harry in the goal square get over it there would have been a hundred more decisions in the game
official afl position after incident of umpire corruption: "yes, we concede there were umpiring mistakes that cost freo the game, but let's move on... put this behind us. we're sure this sort of thing won't happen again. in the fullness of time as voss, cripps & our beloved melbourne establishment club carlton hold that cup aloft, who will remember these little discrete leg-ups along the way? let's move on! let's not feel cheated or robbed. it's just the afl way!"
Umpires are better at feeding there dead plant then actually umpiring the bloody game. Hate the afl this year, never heard of a ump get a fine for doing something wrong but players get a fine for eating with there mouth open
What's the justification for dissent to cause the free to be given where it happened? Why wasn't it just a free to the ruckman in the center? It wasn't an infraction against the opposition, it was abuse to an umpire.
Yes, I think the dissent rule applied the other day was too harsh. The penalty should not be a near- certainty of a goal, especially as the uproar was over a very dubious decision in a finely balanced game.
When you interfere with the umpire - or bring the game into disrepute -- you'll get smacked.
I will be waiting to see if the AFL presses charges against some of the remonstrating players.
@@Pax.Alotin Umpiring decisions have always lacked consistency. In past decades, umps would make their calls quickly to establish their authority over line-ball decisions (whether they were right or wrong). But with the advent of video reviews, that 'get out of jail card' no longer works.
And heavy-handed dissent rulings won't solve the problem that is facing the AFL. The rule book is unsuited for video reviews and concerns over concussion. But no one wants the character of the game changed. It's a dilemma. Pressing charges against Freo won't solve any of it.
did he give a free in the center, then the player kept whining so they moved it to the square ???
@@electronwave4551 Umpiring is done by humans. Only one eyed supporters - get every decision right.😅
Yea but the dissent wouldn’t of happened if the mark wasn’t paid. Freo absolutely robbed of a huge win
Not sure the free cost Freo. Freo should have been a long way in front. Carlton had kicked badly, and Freo had dominated the game all game. Carlton should never have been that close as a result.
@@davidselby-smith5982 If Carlton kicked straight we are 3 goals in front, if those two stupid holding the balls for non tackle bumps werent paid it would have been 5 goals up. You have to tackle the player in order to enact holding the ball. The ball is clearly out on the full in the pocket and a free to Crippa and they say they dont know whether it was out or not so ball it up. I nearly put my foot through the TV half a dozen times. The umps had a shocking night.
@@iankearns774YEP👍 blues would've won anyway blues did win anyway.
And the mark wouldn't be paid if Luke Jackson wasn't such a poor decision maker
@@davidselby-smith5982 Their forward line was ordinary and so was ours. Free kicks at goal kept them in the game, but I agree around the ground they seemed a bit quicker and cleaner. Backlines on both sides did pretty well. Blues really miss Walsh's pace in the middle, Carroll is still learning so not yet ready. Cerra wasn't his usual self in the guts, I think his ex teammates and coach knew his game too well.
What a disgrace, it reminds me of the 1999 grand final. When silvangi reckons he touched the ball. And North marked the ball in front of goal.No Mark. I am glad the Kangas flogged them that day. Admit to your stupidity
Put 8 umpires on the ground. 4 umpires each side of play. The game has to correct this stuff too much money involved with sponsorship of each club. Disgrace
If this took place in say the 2nd quarter Freo players would not have uttered a word ,
It could also be said that if your aunty had balls, she'd be your uncle.
Well...naturally! Big difference between the frantic end of a very close match and the early stages of a match. You don't think Carlton (or any other teams') players would say anything??!!
The umps crucified the Dockers
Yet another game decided by terrible umpiring.
AFL media hysteria? Too many replays now. Allows the type of behaviour now like players pointing to the big screens at games?
I used to watch nearly EVERY FOOTY GAME every week.. Now I have completely lost interest.. To top it off, we have this BS comments from Robbo, who couldn't care less cause it's Freo "Move on, move on already" and Gerrard who HARDLY EVER has a strong opinions on anything and always walking the fine line..
I'm finding myself losing interest in my favourite sport in this world and it bloody SUCKS!!
WTF? 6:24
Umpiring has been questionable all season. There are 4 of them on field, yet mistakes continue to be made each game, and one team suffers. The ARC should be used in these situations when inside 50? Freo players or any defender wouldn’t argue if there was nothing in it. The AFL needs a video umpire for the entire game, it won’t slow the game it will ensure consistency. How many cameras does ch7 have over 20+ yet this wasn’t available for the ARC…unbelievable! Shut up Robbo……you pick and choose what to support, subjective analyst / typist ….. move on!
Umpires stuff up another good game . Why do wee need 10 goal reviews a game now cause umpires cannot remember what they saw ? Very annoying and makes the game unwatchable . lots of balls going out on the full too ! being paid as a mark ??
Never challenge an umpire. No good ever comes of it. Freo leaders need to talk to Jordan Clark about discipline.
Easier said than done
30 seconds left that mark puts them up and it was a miss call i'd be fuming to
Carlton won fair and square. 😁
FreeKickCarlton2024
Well said Robbo get over it .
How can you blame freo for this "do better??" jacksons just doing his job and he really got pulled into it
Carlton always gets the calls from the umps, it's crazy. They're just an average team, let's see how they do when they play a real contender like the Giants without the help of the umpires.
It's still early in the season, but their fans are acting like they've already won the flag😂😂😂 It'll be interesting to see where they are at the halfway point, but I'd be surprised if they make it deep into September.
Get over it fox footy
Nah - they're milking it for the ratings.
Nothing more than a storm in a teacup - but worth $$$$$$ in revenue.
Hold all the post mortems you like. Fact is the record and the ladder will show. Carlton four wins and no loses. I find it interesting no one is talking about the seven goals from contentious free kicks in front of goals for Freo. And for the cherry on top the same umpire who paid cottrells mark, Alex Whetton (19) is the same clown who gifted Freo the seven goals.
they had 2 good tackles resulted in goals. mcgoverns free against could have gone either way. so they still got a few frees no one is talking about. im sure there were marks paid and not paid all day, that were touched all weekend all season.
Our goals from frees came from good defensive pressure and holding the ball decisions. Which ones weren´t there? The McGovern arm chop where he gets none of the ball?
Don´t forget you got a pretty cheap one for holding against Draper, in what was a pretty nothing entry..