I AM SO THANKFUL to you on P Gurus (to know of you) and now I am right here and subscribed & saw few of your amazing, inseighful, fact based and detailed analysis... THANK YOU SIR. SALUTE TO YOU AND OUR BIGGEST RESPECT TO ALL ARMED FORCES PERSONNEL.
Proxy war is not even a thing in India's thinking but sadly India had also abandoned intelligence sources by terminating all RAW operations in Pakistan, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Bangla Desh, and Burma (now Myanmar). This was done by a "genius" Indian PM named I. K. Gujral. He implemented a doctrine called "Bhai Chara". He said we do not want to upset our brothers by doing these things, and we should earn their goodwill. Intelligence community had protested this. This naive action came to be known as "Gujral Doctrine". Gujral was no other than a long time Congress minister, mostly in I&B ministry. This tells everything about him that he was from Congress. Only a Congressman can do it. The result of his stupid doctrine was immediately stated showing up in revolt instigated by China against the king of Nepal who was a friend of India. Likewise, Pakistan became active in Kashmir, China stated spreading its wings in Sri Lanka, and Bangla Desh signed a 25-year security protection treaty with China, never mind that India got them the freedom from Pakistan. Unfortunately, no PM after Gujral has reversed this disastrous Gujral Doctrine till today. As a result, India has lost the precious intelligence network of sources built over several years of hard work in all these countries forever.
Three external examples of India using proxies. Mukthi Bahini, LTTE & Northern alliance in the 90s. Remember Ahmed Shah Masood. Internal examples there are many with the various insurgencies. Salwa Judum comes to mind in the naxal context. All you do is write cheques and out spend the other side.
Was the king of Nepal a friend of India? Why he allowed road to China in the 60s then. Relations have always been challenging with the king of Nepal or any other leader simply because we can't protect them from China. After 62 this thinking began
I would not be too sure about losing anything forever. People need to eat and we have the resources. Methods change. What worked in the 80s does not work today. Just remember since independence every govt regardless of party has put India's interest first. You have to understand the context in which the decisions are made. Don't see them in isolation. If you want to blame the govt then you blame the people too because one is a reflection of the other. As a people we don't like tension. Any govt that does not work to control tension will lose office
It was thrilling to hear Lt Gen Shankar
I AM SO THANKFUL to you on P Gurus (to know of you) and now I am right here and subscribed & saw few of your amazing, inseighful, fact based and detailed analysis... THANK YOU SIR. SALUTE TO YOU AND OUR BIGGEST RESPECT TO ALL ARMED FORCES PERSONNEL.
"Pakistan will fight till the last Kashmiri and not till the last Pakistani" this statement 📈📈📈
Good talk to the young India by the General.
Such an amazing deliberation
Darshan you nailed it.
Such an interactive session
Very insightful
Quite interesting talk🙏🙌
Knowledge bombs
Darshan bhai just wow❤️.. And thank you very much Lt Gen Shankar sir🙏❤️... Yhis session is🔥
Excellent Session... Selection of Questions 👌👌👌
PR Shankar sir’s energy in the interview
Thrilled to hear from Lt Gen Shankar! 💥
Amazing interview, great work by you Darshan👏
Amazing interview ❤️
Happy to see you here .proud of you 🎊
Amazing interview 💯
Amazing interview brother 🔥🔥🔥
Excellent interview
हरहर महादेव
Very interesting perspective
Thank you so much buddy..✨✨❣️
Hope you conduct many more session like this one for us in near future..😁
Please provide link to general sahabs channel.
Gunners shot. You can also find earlier clips on def talks with aadi
Proxy war is not even a thing in India's thinking but sadly India had also abandoned intelligence sources by terminating all RAW operations in Pakistan, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Bangla Desh, and Burma (now Myanmar). This was done by a "genius" Indian PM named I. K. Gujral. He implemented a doctrine called "Bhai Chara". He said we do not want to upset our brothers by doing these things, and we should earn their goodwill. Intelligence community had protested this. This naive action came to be known as "Gujral Doctrine". Gujral was no other than a long time Congress minister, mostly in I&B ministry. This tells everything about him that he was from Congress. Only a Congressman can do it. The result of his stupid doctrine was immediately stated showing up in revolt instigated by China against the king of Nepal who was a friend of India. Likewise, Pakistan became active in Kashmir, China stated spreading its wings in Sri Lanka, and Bangla Desh signed a 25-year security protection treaty with China, never mind that India got them the freedom from Pakistan. Unfortunately, no PM after Gujral has reversed this disastrous Gujral Doctrine till today. As a result, India has lost the precious intelligence network of sources built over several years of hard work in all these countries forever.
Three external examples of India using proxies. Mukthi Bahini, LTTE & Northern alliance in the 90s. Remember Ahmed Shah Masood. Internal examples there are many with the various insurgencies. Salwa Judum comes to mind in the naxal context. All you do is write cheques and out spend the other side.
As for only a Congress man can do it, I've heard Chidambaram restarted support to the Balloch in upa second term. It was stopped by Modi
Was the king of Nepal a friend of India? Why he allowed road to China in the 60s then. Relations have always been challenging with the king of Nepal or any other leader simply because we can't protect them from China. After 62 this thinking began
I would not be too sure about losing anything forever. People need to eat and we have the resources. Methods change. What worked in the 80s does not work today. Just remember since independence every govt regardless of party has put India's interest first. You have to understand the context in which the decisions are made. Don't see them in isolation. If you want to blame the govt then you blame the people too because one is a reflection of the other. As a people we don't like tension. Any govt that does not work to control tension will lose office
Its going to be fuunn 😁
Hindi.kab